Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • ASL2 [94 Option 1].txt

Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

-- CHAPTER 94: Option One --

****

-- SUNDAY, JULY 5, 2009 --

“Ohhh… fuuuuck… meeee… Masterrrr…” Summer crooned, pinned to the blankets with her right leg hooked over Ben’s shoulder.

He straddled her left leg, a position that I knew from personal experience would let him get extremely deep as he repeatedly pounded her pussy. His right hand also had easy access to her perfect breasts, and he presently tweaked the barbell in her nipple before palming a round globe and giving it a firm squeeze.

“I’m cumming! I’m cumming! Ohhhwwwaaauuuggghhh!!!” Summer howled as he reached down to rapidly wriggle his fingers against her clit, strumming her like a guitar. And a moment later he slammed forward one final time and filled her up.

Meanwhile, Adrienne and I were right beside them: naked and sixty-nining. I was on top with an excellent vantage point to take long licks at the busty blonde bombshell’s succulent snatch while watching my One True Love absolutely annihilate my BFF. Perhaps Sasha’s compersion was rubbing off on me, because THEIR pleasure gave ME pleasure. And mere seconds after Ben nutted his load into Summer, both Adrienne and I started screaming simultaneous orgasms into each other’s pussies.

That was soooo gooood…

Nestmate foursomes are always good. Don’t get me wrong: I enjoyed both Adrienne’s fishnet orgy at the Garden of Eden and her assless chaps orgy in the barn, but there’s something special about having just the four of us here together like this. Just my soulmate Ben and his three girlfriends.

Two girlfriends. You’re not an official girlfriend, remember?

Even better. I’m a wife.

A wife ‘in spirit’, remember? You don’t want THAT official title either.

Tomayto, tomahto. I’m not getting into semantics about it. I’m enjoying the moment, and I’m enjoying THIS particular moment a little more for the nostalgia factor.

Feeling giddy and flush with pleasure endorphins, I giggled and rolled off of Adrienne. I reached out to tap the sexy supermodel’s shoulder and said, “You remember the first time we did that?”

Adrienne giggled and nodded. “That was exactly what I was just thinking of. Oh, you shoulda been there, Tiger. It was SPECTACULAR.”

“Oh, for fuck’s sake,” Ben groaned, having already pulled out of Summer as he rested on his back and stared up at the sky. Rubbing his forehead, he complained, “How many years have you two been rubbing that one in my face?”

That question prompted Summer to ask about my first time having sex with Adrienne. We reminisced for a little bit about the angst Adrienne and I had gone through on account of Ben being her boyfriend at the time and me feeling on the outside looking in: a soulmate without a partner. We patched things up with each other a bit, more of a “the enemy of my enemy is my friend” sort of thing when Felicia tried to seduce Ben. Adrienne had a good analogy about me being more like a sister-in-law she had no choice but to accept if she wanted to be part of Ben’s family. She explained how she’d been jealous of me and my elevated importance in Ben’s life.

But then Ben reminded all of us that he’d specifically chosen Adrienne over me, giving her a promise ring and declaring his intention to eventually marry her and raise a family together.

As in: with her.

Not me.

Never me.

Because you’re still not good enough for him to be ‘official’. You’ve enjoyed yourself for the past few days. Good for you. But never forget that you’ll never be more than ‘wife in spirit’ to him, because you don’t honestly deserve the real crown, and you never will.

We’re not having this conversation anymore. I’m happy with my place in Ben’s life. The cards on the table conversation really established how much we all love each other, how the girls and I can share him successfully.

Well, at least for a little while until one of them or Ben (probably Ben) gets the itch to move their title beyond “girlfriend” and realize - once again - that he’d feel empty if he never got to marry one of you girls for real.

That’s not a conversation we need to have right now. Cards on the Table wasn’t even three full days ago. For now, this is all I need.

For now.

Maybe forever.

Pssht. Yeah, right. When has ‘this is all I need’ EVER lasted more than a few days for you? Huh? Okay, you’re Ben’s ‘wife in spirit’ for now. Good for you. But someday you’re gonna wake up, look down at your hand, and realize that the only ring you ever wear on your fourth finger is a cheap, fake wedding band worn solely to help deflect guys from hitting on you.

I don’t NEED a wedding band. I don’t NEED a government piece of paper to validate my love for Ben. My love is PURE and requires no external symbols to represent the true love I feel in my heart.

Then why are you rubbing your wrist right now?

I’m not rubbing my… Oh.

I glanced down, and sure enough, I found my left hand fiddling with my right wrist. It was the same spot where that special unbroken circle of cheap mall-kiosk stainless steel used to reside, now long gone beneath the current of the big river at Morris Camp.

I still remembered the way it had instantly disappeared below the surface like those pebbles I’d been tossing into the creek with Summer. The bracelet hadn’t skipped or sat on the surface for a moment like The One Ring from that Frodo-movie. It had simply gone [plunk] and vanished out of sight.

‘You don’t need the bracelet to feel the sentiment in your heart,’ Summer’s voice intoned in my mind.

I felt the truth in her words, and yet they didn’t reassure me in the slightest. It wasn’t that I doubted my love for Ben: I was absolute in my certainty of that. Rather, I found myself keying on the first five words: ‘You don’t need the bracelet.’

You kinda do need the bracelet.

No, I don’t. I don’t. We’ve been over this already. My love is pure. It stands on its own.

Then why are you rubbing your wrist? You still haven’t answered that question, and you don’t need do. Because the truth is that you’re lying out of your ass about your love being pure enough to stand on its own. At the end of the day, you want the bracelet. You want the ring. You want the crown.

I don’t need the crown. The crown is just like ‘Perfect Dawn’. All I truly need is to be a part of Ben’s life, and I have that now. “One of those ‘aim for a hundred percent but be willing to settle for ninety-two’ kind of things. Still an ‘A’, right?” I stated aloud.

Still with my soulmate.

I’ll agree that’s still an ‘A’, but it’s not an ‘A-plus’ and you know it. It’s almost the fulfillment of your dream, but it’s not and you know it. Face it, girlie: Option Four isn’t working.

It IS working. Me, Summer, Adrienne, and Ben: we’re a quad. The FOUR of us make this work.

Go on. Keep telling yourself that.

****

That afternoon, we went on a big family horseback ride. George, the stable lead, was at the front of our “half” of the family, followed by Kim, Sasha, Adrienne, Ben, Summer, and then me. Summer held her reins a little too tightly, trying to steer despite my repeated reassurances that her gentle mare, an old favorite of mine named Honeydew, was not a suicidal horse and would know exactly where to go whether she was being ridden or not.

Meanwhile, I was gently stroking Aurora on the neck for her comfort and my own as we made our way through the well-worn trail. George had been reluctant to let me take the young mare, fresh from being saddle broken this past winter and spring and in her first season carrying campers. I wasn’t inexperienced on a horse, but I wasn’t particularly accomplished either. But he remembered me from my days as a brunette ranch hand and saw from the size of our party that we had a lazy ride ahead of us and acquiesced. But while I’d thought this would be a good opportunity to enjoy the pleasant sunshine and cool breeze while surrounded by nature and my friends and family - as well as to reconnect with Aurora - instead I found myself with perhaps too much time to think and allow my weariness to fester.

This isn’t working.

Shut up, you.

Today should’ve been glorious, as glorious as the trip to The Garden of Eden. You went to bed last night nestled between your Nestmates: naked, satiated, and pleasantly exhausted after the barn orgy. It’s only been three days since you took Summer’s advice, committed to Option Four, and said your marital vows aloud for your friends to hear. Since then, the group dynamics have been nothing but orgytastic.

You’re right. Things are glorious.

Then why were you feeling hollow this morning after an perfectly orgytastic session with The Quad? Why are we having this conversation right now?

We’re not. We’re not having this conversation. You’re gonna shut up now.

Good luck with that. You can’t bury your head in the sand to avoid me. You can’t call me a Stupid Fucking Moron and expect me to go away. This isn’t working, and there’s nothing you can say to prove otherwise.

It IS working. Me, Summer, Adrienne, and Ben: we’re a quad. The FOUR of us make this work.

Go on. Keep telling yourself that.

I just did.

I know you did. You repeated yourself verbatim. You keep telling yourself this should be working. All the pieces are here, you all want this to work, you all love each other, and you know you each love Ben. And yet you keep asking yourself, ‘Why isn’t this working?’”

I’m NOT asking myself that.

Um, you just did. And if this is how you truly feel, you’re supposed to tell Ben, Adrienne, and Summer about it. Honesty, remember? Does the phrase ‘Open Communication’ ring a bell?

Shut up. Shut up. Shut up! Focus, girl, focus! Horseback riding. Horseback riding. I can do this.

But despite being on a slow-paced excursion that should’ve been a relaxing horseback ride for an experienced ranch hand like me, my anxiety only built the longer we continued. George took us through the second river crossing, and I found myself desperately wanting to lean forward and hug Aurora around the neck. But I had a river to cross and a new mount that needed stability and evenhandedness, not a crazy lady she barely remembered from when she was a baby shifting her weight in the saddle.

I shouldn’t have taken Aurora out. She needed a surer pair of hands than mine and a rider who wasn’t looking to her for comfort. Less crazy in her life and a chance to learn how to handle unexpected bumps in the road. Maybe next year, once she’d gotten settled, I could take her out again.

There’s a metaphor in there. Girl who isn’t quite ready to make the leap. Maybe next time. Maybe next year. This isn’t working, and you know what to do.

It IS working. Me, Summer, Adrienne, and Ben: we’re a quad. The FOUR of us make this work.

And you’re repeating yourself again. Fine. It’s working. For now. We already know it won’t last forever. The status quo never remains the same. The three of you have agreed to not chase the crown… for now. This four-way Nestmates relationship seems great on paper, but put it into action, and somebody’s gonna get left out. And that someone is you.

Ben would never leave me out.

Summer: official girlfriend. Adrienne: official girlfriend. Dawn: just friends? I know you hate that idea. You hate the idea of the other two being official when you’re not.

I’m a ‘wife’. That title outranks the girlfriends.

You’re a wife ‘in spirit’. And if I had that worthless title plus a nickel, I’d have a grand total of five cents. I can tell you’re not completely satisfied with the ‘in spirit’ qualifier because I AM you, so you can’t lie to me. This isn’t working and you know it.

It IS working.

It IS working.

It IS working.

If you have to repeat yourself that many times, that’s kinda proof in itself that it’s not.

I’m gonna keep repeating it until you get it through your thick skull that Option Four is the solution. I CAN do this.

I don’t actually have a skull. And you need to get through your thick skull this is the peak of your relationship with Ben. It’s all downhill from here. Face it, girlie: Summer had a nice idea. Option Four sounded great on paper. But the reality of your situation hasn’t changed: you want him, but you know you don’t deserve him, and you never will.

I can still make this work.

Sure, keep telling yourself that.

I can still make this work!

Option Four didn’t work. There’s only one solution now. You know what you need to do.

I don’t WANT to do that.

It’s all you’ve got left. Further, it was Ben’s idea in the first place. He knew it was the right call.

I don’t know if I can do it.

It’s your only shot at making this work.

I dunno. Maybe we could try Option One instead? We could still get married.

Yeaaahhh. Sure. Try that. Just don’t blame me when you crack under the pressure, make an unforgivable mistake, and ruin your relationship beyond any possible repair… AGAIN.

You don’t KNOW that would happen.

I DO know that you and the other two girls promised each other barely two days ago that none of you would chase the crown. Are you really gonna be ‘that bitch’ who goes behind her best friends’ backs and betrays them like that? Think of what THAT would do to your image.

You’re right, you’re right.

You know what to do.

****

-- MONDAY, JULY 6, 2009 (SILICON VALLEY) --

“Hey Mom, I’m home!” I called loudly as I walked into the house, set my purse onto the table by the door, and dropped my car keys next to it. It had been a long day and I was pretty tired after the long drive back from Morris Camp, but also emotionally tired after having one last dinner at home with my Nestmates and then leaving them to come here before returning to work tomorrow morning.

“Heyyy,” she called in reply. “Welcome back.”

In the background I heard what sounded like baseball coming from the family room and figured Dad was watching one of the games. I headed into the hallway half-bath to wash my hands and was just finishing up when Mom’s reflection appeared in the mirror, standing in the doorway behind me.

“So what’s this I hear about you and Ben taking a break?” she began without preamble.

I sighed and shook my head. “We’re not having this conversation.”

“I’m a little confused. See, last I was told, you, Ben, and the girls had come to an agreement that Ben wouldn’t choose any one of you to marry and instead planned to keep all three of you, Adrienne, and Summer in a sort of quad four-way relationship. Everybody seemed onboard with that decision, and even if none of us parentals expected that status quo to last forever all the way Happily Ever After, I’m pretty sure we expected it to last until the end of camp at least. So imagine my surprise when Beth called me a few hours ago to say you two had broken up.”

I shrugged, shut off the water, and shook the excess water off my hands before reaching for the hand towel. “You seem to have all the important details.”

“What I don’t have is ‘the why’.” Mom waited until I dried my hands and turned around to face her before finishing, “What happened?”

“Option Three didn’t work. Neither did Option Four.”

Mom blinked. “That statement didn’t make things clearer.”

I hung my head. “I really don’t want to have this conversation, Mom.”

Rather than reply verbally, she stepped into the bathroom and wrapped me up in a warm hug. At first I simply raised my arms to hug her back with a minimum amount of pressure, intent on simply enduring her grip for however long it lasted. But as she squeezed me tighter, I felt a little of the old maternal comfort I remembered from being a little girl in a household with two parents who loved me very much. As the warmth of her embrace slowly seeped through my defenses, I found myself hugging her back harder and harder as the weight of my situation crushed down on me. And before I realized what was going on, I was clutching my mother like she was a life preserver in the ocean as I cried and cried and cried.

What the fuck is going on? Where the hell did THIS come from?

I don’t know!

Why are you crying on Mom’s shoulder right now?

I don’t know!

Do you WANT to be crying on Mom’s shoulder right now?

No! Absolutely not!

The tears were still streaming down my face when I abruptly jerked myself out of her grasp and briskly walked out of the bathroom. I turned the corner and made a beeline for the stairs, rapidly ascending them two at a time. And I didn’t stop hustling until I’d made it safely into my bedroom with the door shut and locked behind me.

Running away again? Even from your mom’s hug?

Shut UP.

I took a deep breath and let out a long exhalation, desperate for calm as I absentmindedly rubbed my hands together.

You’re not rubbing your hands together.

I’m not-- Shit.

I glanced down, and sure enough, I found my left hand fiddling with my right wrist beneath my sleeve: that spot where my Ben Forever bracelet used to be. I stopped rubbing my empty wrist and even put my left hand into my pocket just to make sure I didn’t start again.

Just then, I heard the sounds of an emergency pin-key snicking into the door lock behind me, and my bedroom door opened behind me.

“Mom, seriously,” I groaned as she came into my room. “Does a locked door really mean nothing to you? Talk about an invasion of privacy.”

She shrugged and made one sweep of her hand with two fingers extended, explaining matter-of-factly, “It’s my house.”

I rolled my eyes, sighed, and walked over to sit down on my bed.

“Tell me what’s going on.”

“We’re not having this conversation.”

“We ARE having this conversation,” she insisted.

“If I’d broken up with some other random guy, you wouldn’t be pestering me about this.”

“That is an absolutely correct statement. But Ben isn’t ‘some random guy’. You wouldn’t have broken down crying in my arms downstairs over ‘some random guy’,” she stated while moving over to sit down beside me on the foot of the bed.

“Can you please just leave me alone?”

“I’ve left you alone for your entire life, and yet here we are. So maybe it’s time I stopped leaving you alone and instead said, ‘I’m sitting here and I’m not leaving until you’ve told me what’s going on.’ And you need to stop rubbing your wrist like that or you’re gonna break the skin.”

“What? I…”

Yes, you’re rubbing your empty wrist again.

Uggghhh…

I quickly pulled my left hand off and shoved it back into my pocket.

Mom sighed and looked at me with evident concern. “You used to play with your bracelet when you were stressed out. The one you got in high school and had engraved with ‘Ben Forever’ on it.”

“Thanks for the reminder, Mom,” I drawled sarcastically. “I never would’ve remembered what you were talking about.”

“I haven’t seen it since you came back from your ranch hand year. Whatever happened to it?”

“Don’t want to talk about it.”

“Newsflash.” Mom leaned in and patted my knee. “Your lack of interest in talking about it doesn’t really have an impact on my resolve to sit here and occupy space in your bedroom for as long as I feel it’s necessary. It’s my house, and I’ll sleep in this bed if I have to.”

“Then I’ll move over to DJ’s room.”

“I can follow you there as well.”

“Dayna’s room.”

“I can go to that room as well. It’s my house.”

“Then maybe I should sleep in your room.”

“With Dad? Sure, go right ahead.”

“What? Eww. I’m not Dayna.”

Mom chuckled lightly and shook her head.

“I can leave the house entirely,” I insisted. “Go back to Berkeley and commute to work every day if I have to.”

“I’d be happy for you to do that. Maybe then you would sit down with Ben and sort things out rather than running away to hide here.”

“I’m not running away to hide. I have an internship in the morning. Even if Ben and I weren’t taking a break, I’d still be here right now.”

“Ah, but if you and Ben weren’t taking a break, -I- wouldn’t be here right now.” Mom patted the mattress for emphasis.

I planted both hands over my face and groaned.

“What happened to the bracelet, Dawn?” she asked seriously.

“I threw it away,” I muttered while dropping my hands back into my lap.

“Today?”

“A long time ago. While I was a ranch hand.” I sighed and shook my head before staring out at the far wall. “Right after I found out DJ was pregnant. Chucked it into the river, never to be seen again.”

“Oh. Huh.”

“I don’t need it anyways.”

“The way you were just rubbing your wrist seemed to indicate that you do.”

“I’m rubbing my wrist because I’m having trouble letting go of the dream. The bracelet said ‘Ben Forever’ on it. For so many years, it was the goal, my planned end destination, my purpose in life.”

“But not anymore?”

I shook my head sadly. “Not anymore.”

“But… why? I thought you loved him.” Mom frowned and gave me an almost plaintive wince. “I thought you were gonna give me grandchildren with Ben.”

I gave her a sad look. “I can’t have kids with Ben just for your sake.”

“I know that.”

“I’m not sure that you do.”

Mom took a deep breath and half-turned to face me. She reached out and took my hands into hers, squeezing them gently. She started to speak, but then caught herself and pursed her lips. Her sky-blue eyes tightened in concentration as she tried to work out the words in her head, and I patiently waited her out.

Eventually, she found her voice and tried again, starting, “I am proud of you, Dawn. I think you know that. You were the smart one, the mature one, the responsible one. You were an easy daughter to raise: so self-sufficient, hard-working, and never causing trouble. As parents, we’re always told never to play favorites, but I think you noticed that you were mine. Dayna has always been a handful, and the fights we had when she was a teenager were…”

“Epic,” I finished for her. “Classic know-it-all teenage girl, convinced she didn’t need any parental supervision. I still remember her howling, ‘I’m sixteen years old! I’m not a child anymore! I can make my own decisions!’”

Mom rubbed her forehead and chuckled wryly. “Oh, good lord that girl. She wants to live her life the way she wants to live her life. She’s twenty-seven now and she can make up her own damn mind. As for DJ, she was always Daddy’s Little Girl.”

“In part because you were so mean to her,” I chided.

“I wasn’t mean to her,” Mom said defensively.

“Yes you were,” I stated with a shrug. “Does ‘Why can’t you be more like Dawn?’ ring a bell?”

“I never said that,” Mom stated flatly. “Not once.”

“But you meant it. We all knew it.”

Mom sighed wearily. “Let’s not go off on a tangent about DJ. We were talking about you.”

“About me being your favorite daughter. How much of that was because I was paired up with Ben and therefore gave you the best chance of having shared grandchildren with your best friend?”

“None at all. I love you for you, and I told you I’m proud of you. You are intelligent, not just pretty. You are modest, thoughtful, and kind. You’ve always wanted to succeed through hard-work and dedication instead of coasting by on your good looks. You’re the complete package.”

“Can’t still be the complete package if I don’t end up giving you the kids with Ben you always wanted.”

Mom pursed her lips. “My love for you is not dependent on something like that, nor is my pride. I can be especially proud of you standing up for what you believe is the right path and not doing something solely to please me. And having kids with Ben for MY sake would definitely be doing so for the wrong reasons.”

“I agree.”

“But I still want to understand what’s going on. I thought you were happy. The group of you had that big conversation. Everything was sunshine and rainbows for a few days. I got to start dreaming about you and Ben having babies. And then out of nowhere Beth calls me and tells me you two broke up.”

“We’re not breaking up. We’re taking a break. It’s like a…”

“It’s like a trial separation is what it sounds like.”

“Kinda.”

“Which is just a euphemism for ‘We’re getting divorced’ but haven’t filed the paperwork yet.”

“We’re just taking a break. It doesn’t mean we don’t still love each other.”

“And THAT is what people tell their friends and children when they’re getting divorced.”

“Can’t get divorced if we were never married.”

“But weren’t you?” Mom squeezed my hands and leaned forward to look into my eyes. “Weren’t you? How many times had you called him ‘husband’? How many times had he called you ‘wife’? Yeah, I heard you two a few times. ‘Wife in spirit’, I think was the phrase?”

I sighed. “That was Option Four. Summer’s idea, really. To accept that Ben loves me as a wife and that I love him as a husband, and that we didn’t need government paperwork or wedding bands or anything else to prove it.”

“But you couldn’t accept it?”

I sighed. “I tried. I really did try. We all got together, put our cards on the table, and both Summer and Adrienne declared their undying love for him along with me. We agreed to the quad four-way relationship, and everything was sunshine and rainbows for a few days.”

“But only a few days.”

I chuckled and shook my head. “Ben and I are alike in so many ways. Valentine’s Day morning, he woke up feeling ‘empty’. He wanted to believe that having all of his loved ones together would bring him happiness, with no need for a wedding ceremony, a government certificate, or any of that. But he was wrong. He still wanted the titled wife and the government certificate. And after two days of sunshine and rainbows, I sat there in my special clearing on Sunday morning and realized that I do too.”

“That you want to be a titled wife and have a government certificate?”

I nodded slowly, pulled my left hand free of hers, and started rubbing my right wrist again. “I do.”

“Then grab him and go get a fucking certificate!”

I shook my head. “I can’t.”

“Why NOT?”

“Because he doesn’t want to marry me.”

“Of course he does.”

I shook my head. “No he doesn’t. Ben hasn’t seriously wanted to marry me in more than a year. Tell the truth, Ben hasn’t seriously wanted to marry me since we were juniors at Cal. That was my big chance, and I blew it. I destroyed our relationship, compounded the problem by running away from him for a year, and it left us at a point where he can never fully trust me ever again.”

“Sure he can. You’ve spent almost two years repairing his trust, haven’t you?”

“Two years, five years, fifty years: it doesn’t matter. It took me twenty years to build up that kind of trust with Ben. It only took a few seconds to break. And it’ll take a lifetime to repair.”

“Then spend a lifetime repairing it.”

“I will. I fully intend to spend the rest of my life repairing his trust in me. But as a friend, not as a wife. Either Adrienne or Summer would be far better choices in that role.”

“He wants you.”

“He wants all of us.”

“Which by definition includes you.”

I shook my head. “Ben’s the one who declared Option Three: that we both had to accept that our relationship is better off as best friends without the angst of potential marriage or the pressure that would come with being married getting in the way. He made abundantly clear to me that if I ever asked him to marry me again, he’d say ‘no’. Actually, he DID say ‘no’. We hiked out to our special clearing Thursday morning to make love, I started floating on a cloud of joy, lost my head, and asked him to marry me. He got pretty mad at me.”

“Mad?”

I sighed. “He got confused. I’ve spent the past year insisting that we were better off as best friends. And after that Valentine’s Day morning when he woke up feeling empty, he told me he wanted the government certificate with me.”

“And you turned him down.”

“I called him a Stupid Fucking Moron and stomped away.” I sighed. “So you’ll understand he was getting fed up with the mixed messages.”

“You should’ve said ‘yes’.”

“No, I shouldn’t have.” I shook my head. “Ben’s right. We are NOT a good fit for each other as a married couple. Actually, DJ was right: starting down a path toward marriage put me right back into my obsessive-compulsive Perfect Dawn behaviors that got me into so much trouble in the first place. If Summer was around, she’d buzz me with a metaphorical shock collar for saying this, but--”

“Waitaminute. Metaphorical shock collar?”

“Nevermind.” I took a deep breath, held my hands out while collecting myself, and then fixed Mom with a steady look. “Ben and I just aren’t compatible that way, alright? I realize that’s hard for you to believe after all your dreams of me and him uniting our two families together and all that, but it’s the truth. Yang and Yang, not Yin and Yang: we’re too alike. We really ARE better as best friends. We’re the same as Dayna and Brandi, DJ and Brooke, or even Eden and Emma, and you’re not expecting any of them to marry each other, are you?”

“So that’s it? You’ve given up on ever being Ben’s wife?”

I sighed and rubbed my right wrist again. “Not yet. But I need to. And that’s the whole point of this break: for the two of us to take a pause, not be around each other so much, not be so dependent on each other’s presence, and find our balance again. It’s not forever and we’re still going to keep in touch. I’m going back on Friday night to celebrate my birthday. But other than that, I’m going to stay here until the end of my internship, which is only forty-five days away. I’m not ignoring him. I’m not running off to be a ranch hand for a year. It’ll be cool. We’ll be fine.”

“So fine that you broke down crying in the bathroom and you’re rubbing your wrist raw again right now.”

I sighed and didn’t reply right away, although I did try and stuff my left hand back into my pocket.

Maybe you need Summer’s Shibari ropes to bind your forearm against your lower back.

Maybe.

“I want to be married. I want a house with a picket fence and 2.5 kids. I want a husband who will love and cherish me and not have niggling doubts in the back of his head wondering about my faithfulness. And I want that husband to be Ben. I do. I still think about marrying him fifteen times a day. But…” My lower lip quivered and I felt moisture in my eyes as the weight of my situation crushed down on me again. And my voice started cracking as I managed to choke out, “But he doesn’t want to marry me. I asked. He said ‘no’. And… And I have to live with that.”

I shuddered, and Mom leaned forward to start hugging me again. The warmth of her embrace started to slowly seep into me once more, and the dam burst: I found myself clutching my mother like she was a life preserver in the ocean… again… as I cried and cried and cried.

She didn’t try to say anything. She simply held me.

The voice in my head didn’t even bother me. I was despondent enough without it needing to castigate me any further.

I simply cried.

I had dreamed a dream.

And now that dream was gone from me.

But I knew that somehow… someway… I would have to find a way to move on.

****

-- TUESDAY, JULY 7, 2009 --

The morning air was cold against my right cheek, the pillow reassuringly warm against my left. I snuggled deeper into the covers and their cocooning heat while hugging an extra pillow to my chest - a poor substitute for the feeling of Ben’s arm against my midsection with my bare breast in his palm.

I was used to waking up alone in bed. I didn’t prefer it, of course. One of the nicest things about having so many Nestmates was that there was always somebody to cuddle with, even if it wasn’t Ben. But this wasn’t The Nest and I wasn’t about to go snuggling with my parents or anything like that. It was a weekday morning and we were no longer on vacation. Waking up alone was standard operating procedure while attending my internship.

Still, I couldn’t shake that extra sense of feeling alone this morning, and I already knew exactly why. I couldn’t help but feel a deep sense of loss at what I was giving up: long-term comfort and companionship, not only with Ben but with Summer and Adrienne, too. They were both inextricably part of Ben’s life now. For months, my Nestmates and I had been a team - a team of four. But not anymore. Now, the three of them were still together.

And I was alone.

Not “alone until Friday when I’d go back to spend the weekend with my lovers.”

No, I was “alone until school started in August so Ben and I could take a break and reset the parameters of our best friends relationship, and perhaps continuing to be alone indefinitely until we found a balance again that didn’t tempt either of us into falling back into our wistfully pining habits of wanting to marry each other again”.

And my reality was that “alone until whenever” might very well turn out to be “alone forever”. And you’ll forgive me for not jumping out of bed for joy at that prospect.

It’s not forever.

Right, right. My birthday is on Thursday and even though we’re not gonna do anything more than a Skype call for that, we’ve already got plans to celebrate together with friends and family on Friday. I’m gonna see him in-person on Friday.

But you’re just gonna see him. You’re gonna talk to him. But he’s not gonna be able to give you a birthday orgasm with his gorgeous dick. And whether or not you wanna argue about labels, Imma gonna go ahead and label ‘not being able to give Dawn a birthday fuck’ as Exhibit A that this is a ‘breakup’. Wasn’t ‘Ben Keeps Fucking Dawn’ the single underlying principle that guided all of your decision-making?

Not anymore. I have a new single underlying principle that guides all of my decision-making.

Which is what, exactly?

Ben Forever.

Somehow, someway, I managed to imagine the disembodied voice in my head blinking in surprise, as if disembodied voices had eyelids to blink (or eyes, for that matter).

I’m confused. Wasn’t that your OLD principle?

A very old principle. A principle created from the first time I could cognitively comprehend the abstract concept of ‘forever’. We were childhood friends, and we pledged back then to be together forever. ‘Ben Forever’ means being in each other’s lives, never truly separated. He’s my constant. He’s my soulmate. He’s my partner. Much like Dayna and Brandi, DJ and Brooke, and Eden and Emma, my relationship with Ben shouldn’t be dependent on sex.

No sex with Ben? Now I KNOW you’re crazy.

Sex is nice, yes. It’s a great bonus. But if push came to shove and they had to stop having sex with each other, they could do it. Brandi actually DID give up Dayna for a little while in the early days of her relationship with Jared. Because the partnership matters more than the sex. The partnership came BEFORE the sex. For the first sixteen years of our lives, Ben and I didn’t have sex, and we were as happy together as ever. If need be, we could do it again.

You already HAVE gone through several periods during which you and Ben couldn’t - or more accurately “wouldn’t” - have sex with each other.

You’re proving my point.

Each and every time was an unmitigated disaster. The first time while you were dating Ryan, being together but not able to intimately touch each other was a constant source of stress and undermined your relationship with your boyfriend. The Dawnpocalypse and your year away as a ranch hand was so lonely that you ended up trying - and failing - to find solace in Nick.

Nick and Deedee really did provide me solace for a while.

But only for a while. And even when you came back to Berkeley, being close to Ben and having sex with the other girls but having to remain hands off with Ben absolutely crushed you inside.

Look, I’m not happy about the situation, and I’m still hopeful it won’t come to holding myself abstinent from him.

It can’t. Physical intimacy and emotional intimacy go hand-in-hand. There IS no ‘best friends’ without you two making love, and the stress of NOT being able to make love would undermine everything. When Harry Met Sally was totally right: the sex part always gets in the way. You and Ben canNOT go back to being platonic.

If we have to, we have to. I’ll make it work. I swore to myself I would do EVERYTHING in my power to ensure that he and I NEVER got separated again. If taking sex off the table is what it takes to find our balance as best friends, then so be it.

Yeah, good luck with that. I’m gonna conference call the voices in Ben and Kim’s heads and start taking bets on how long it’ll take you to crack. I’m thinking to put the over/under at about a week, and that’s only because you’re at your parents’ house five nights at a time. If you were in Berkeley, I’d be betting in terms of hours.

Good. Fine. Go do your conference call and leave me alone. I’m gonna get up and get ready for work. Just like every other random Tuesday during this internship period. This is fine. I’m doing fine.

Annnd now you’re using the f-word.

I’m alright. Today is just another ordinary Tuesday. This is a momentary blip and I’m not gonna turn into a freaked-out, insecure, neurotic, emotional idiot about this.

You kinda already are.

I thought you were gonna leave me alone.

Pssht. Since when have I ever actually left you alone?

Whatever. Shut up. I’m gonna stop stressing myself out having a mental argument with the disembodied voice in my head.

Maybe if you’d talk to a real-life human being about this stuff, we wouldn’t be having so many mental arguments.

I miss Yvaine…

I meant a licensed therapist, the way Adrienne and Ben keep suggesting.

Yeah-yeah-yeah, whatever. Go away.

I did get up and get ready for work. It was still early - too early, really - but I knew if I stayed in bed I’d simply keep having mental arguments with the disembodied voice in my head. I went through my morning routine, put on my makeup, finished getting dressed, and headed downstairs to make breakfast. Today was an egg white/spinach omelet tortilla wrap and green tea. But once I finished eating, I found myself seated alone at the dining table without any further distractions. And I found myself wondering what Ben, Summer, and Adrienne were doing right now.

Probably fucking each other’s brains out. I mean, it’s still pretty early, so I suppose the three of them could be stacked together like spoons, Summer snuggled in his arms with his palm on her bare breast and his morning wood hot-dogging her buns while Adrienne hugs them both from behind. But THEN he’ll wake up, push himself into Summer from behind in that absolutely delicious way he likes to wake a girl up, and still end up fucking each other’s brains out. It’s so hot to watch them going at it. Almost as good as getting fucked yourself. Almost. But to see your Sex God Soulmate in action, sinewy muscles rippling, rock-hard abs flexing, just fuckin’ pounding the girls one after the other.

Fuck, you’re making me so wet.

Is this internship really so important? Why the fuck did you ever agree to live away from him in the first place? And now your brilliant idea is to spend even MORE time away from him on this break?

I need to get him out of my system. The only way this works is if we decompress, stop getting used to fucking each other’s brains out all-day/every-day, and get back to a point where we’ll appreciate our intimacy again.

But did you really have to quit cold turkey just like that? Couldn’t you ease into the abstinence part you know? Can’t we at least fantasize about burying his big dick inside your tight holes for a little bit?

Well… maybe for a little bit.

Ooh, now we’re talking. I mean, we can at least masturbate, right?

Sure, sure, I’m good with that.

Indeed I was good with that, and I was already rubbing my thighs together in anticipation. But before I could actually unbutton my jeans, my phone rang.

It’s him.

That’s my ringtone for Summer.

I still know it’s him. Because he loves you and misses you and he’s thinking about you right now. I talk to the voice in his head, remember? How ELSE do you think this link works? Seriously, he misses you SOOO much right now.

“Hey, babe. I miss you too,” I said immediately upon answering the phone.

“I love you,” he replied to me simply, and my heart ached and the longing in his voice.

Stop this charade right now, girlie. You love him. He loves you. Go HOME to him.

We need to get off the hamster wheel. This sucks. I know it. But I swore up and down I would do EVERYTHING in my power to keep us together, even if it means short-term pain for long-term success.

“We all love you and miss you,” Summer chimed in.

“All of us,” Adrienne added.

I smiled to hear the warmth in their voices. Less than forty-eight hours ago, we’d all been making love in our special clearing and talking about how the four of us were a team. I wanted to be part of that team again. I did.

“Wish I was there,” I said with a sigh. “I mean, I know I’d have been here at my parents’ place anyway, but I still wish I was there.”

But what had to be done had to be done.

So I finished by saying, “This is for the best, though. We all know it.”

Ben replied in weary resignation, “We do.”

All four of us went quiet for a few seconds. It wasn’t an awkward silence, more of a… heavy… silence. None of us wanted things to be this way, and yet we all understood the necessity.

Ben finally broke the silence and said quietly, “It made me feel a lot better to hear your voice.”

“You too,” I replied in the same tone before taking another deep breath. “I’ll see you all in-person on Friday.”

“Can’t wait.”

“You’ll have to. But that’s okay.” I took a deep breath to drum up all my confidence. “We’ll get through this, stronger than ever.”

“I know we will,” he agreed. “Love you.”

“Love you too. Bye guys.”

“Bye,” he replied, and then Summer and Adrienne also chimed in with their goodbyes.

I hung up before I broke down, my lower lip quivering and my eyes getting a little moist. Leaning back in my chair, I let my head loll back so I could stare up at the ceiling, just taking deep, calming breaths.

He loves you. No matter what. No matter where you go. No matter what the state of your relationship, he will always love you. As a friend. As a lover. As a sister. He’s your Ben. Forever. Believe that. Know that. FEEL that.

I do.

We’ll get through this.

We’ll get through this.

Stronger than ever.

Stronger than ever.

Now smile for him. Send him a selfie of your beautiful face with a big, beaming smile. Let that be the last image he has in his head before he gets out of bed this morning.

I quickly fished out my phone and held it above myself at an angle to make sure I had some cleavage in the shot as well.

He’ll love that.

Of course he will.

I hit the magic wand to do minor cleanup on the photo and then sent it off. On impulse, I puckered up for a kiss and took another selfie to send.

Less than a minute later, Summer sent a landscape selfie of the three of them in bed, all blowing kisses to the camera. I instantly felt my heart warm at the sight of them, at the sight of the obvious love on ALL of their faces.

My Nestmates.

My Team.

We’ll get through this.

We’ll get through this.

Stronger than ever.

Stronger than ever.

And NOW they’re gonna fuck each other’s brains out. Without you.

Actually, I don’t think they will. Ben’s weird like that. He’s gonna feel guilty about me being left out. That’s probably why they DIDN’T start fucking each other’s brains out before they called. No sweaty bangs or flushed faces. It was obvious on all their faces that they hadn’t had sex yet. I know Ben. He woke up this morning feeling the same sense of loss by my absence and wasn’t in the mood.

But I know how to fix that.

I had my phone back in hand, and I started typing while getting up to return to my bedroom: Send me a pic with his dick in your mouth. I’ve got time to jill off before work.

A minute later, I was back in bed with my jeans off and my panties down around one ankle.

Yeah… we were gonna get through this.

****

“Heyyy, rugrats,” I greeted warmly while opening both arms. It was late evening, almost 10:30pm. And while I’d been surprised to get Emma’s text asking if she and Eden could stop by, I wasn’t about to decline or anything.

Both twins stepped in to hug me at the same time, one on each side, and when we pulled apart I turned to Eden, saying, “I’m surprised you came all the way down here this late at night.”

“We need to talk,” my baby half-sister stated seriously before looking back into the house. “But Em and I should probably say hi to your parents first.”

“They actually went to bed already.”

“Ooh!” Emma said, perking up. “Hot tub time?”

“Hot tub?” Eden queried. “We didn’t bring suits.”

“Who ever said anything about suits?” Emma drawled with a grin before catching my eye. “You still owe me from the way our last hot tub visit ended.”

“Has hot tub skinny-dipping been a regular thing for you two?” Eden probed.

“Once a week? Maybe twice?” I explained. “There’s a toy box stashed out there as well.”

“Ooh, nice!” Eden perked up. “Adrienne definitely has a big hot tub on her list for the new Nest compound she’s planning. I should’ve been coming down here to visit more often!”

“Yes, you should’ve,” Emma chided, while grabbing her twin’s elbow and starting back through the house. She then leaned over to stage-whisper, “Just don’t tell Dawn my suspicions that her mom makes active use of the Ben Juniors out there.”

“So wrong…” I groaned while following right behind them.

“Makes you wonder if Mom has ever used them,” Emma added.

“Aaack! Brain bleach! Where’s the brain bleach?!” Eden squawked.

The girls both laughed, and the three of us went straight towards the privacy provided by the gazebo. We each tied up our hair in buns to keep it dry, stripped naked save for our jewelry and the cute chokers the twins both wore, set our folded clothes onto the shelves, and then slipped into the warm, bubbling water.

“So what happened during your last hot tub visit?” Eden asked, glancing at both me and her sister once we’d settled in. “You made it sound like something bad.”

“The usual,” Emma drawled, the back of her head supported by a folded towel for comfort while she reclined back and semi-floated. Every so often one of her perky nipples broke the surface amidst the foamy bubbles.

“The usual meaning… Ben issues?” Eden queried.

“The usual,” Emma confirmed. “We usually fuck each other in here for stress-relief mid-week while away from you, but her heart wasn’t in it that day and we pretty much ended up talking.”

“I still got you off in the end,” I insisted.

Emma smirked. “-I- got you off in the end to help you get over your anxiety attack. And speaking of anxiety attacks…”

Eden made a face and sighed as Emma turned to look at her. I didn’t yet know why the twins had wanted to come over. It certainly hadn’t been a planned trip out to the hot tub. I sat up a little straighter and studied the elder-by-minutes twin, asking, “What happened? How’s Ben?”

“He’s a mess. It’s only been one day and he’s already a mess,” Eden explained with an apologetic expression. “Things were alright when he first got home. BJ was being adorable - you guys should ask him about idioms the next time you go back - the girls were all doing their best to make him feel loved and supported. But he would space out every now and again; you could tell he was thinking of you. Lynne and Bert came over, we started playing Settlers, and I don’t know if it was just because the game wasn’t going well for him, but he got really testy.”

I arched an eyebrow. “Getting testy during a Settlers game isn’t the end of the world.”

“It wasn’t just Settlers. If it was just Settlers, I wouldn’t have come all the way down here.”

“Aww, not even for me?” Emma mock-pouted.

Eden immediately pushed a wave of water at her twin. But then she sighed and gave us both a sad look. “I’m serious. He’s pretty messed up. Like, he went upstairs to take a shower with Adrienne, and when they came back down she had that walk we all have after he’s stretched our assholes to the breaking point, y’know? So we knew he’d gotten some stress-relief. But even so, he wound up just parked in a corner staring out at nothing, and none of us could really get through to him. He’s saying all the right things, putting up a brave front and acknowledging that this was a mutual decision and his idea in the first place. But he’s miserable without you, Dawn. Straight up.”

“I know he is. I can feel it in my heart. I’m pretty miserable without him, too.” I took a deep breath and sighed. “Ben, Adrienne, Summer, and I all talked this out Sunday night. We went through all the options, talked out all the issues, and we knew Ben and I were going to go through withdrawal pangs. He and I are addicted to each other - straight up. We knew this part was gonna suck donkey balls, but it’s for the greater good.”

“Define ‘greater good’,” Eden muttered skeptically.

“Staying best friends. Remaining part of each other’s life. Accepting who we are and what we mean to each other instead of getting frustrated with who we cannot be.”

“What does THAT mean?”

“Option Three.”

Eden and Emma exchanged a look. “Back to this again?” Eden sighed.

“Ben and I were stuck on ‘the usual’, and you know I lost my head a bit and asked him to marry me after making love in our clearing.”

“And he turned you down flat,” Eden muttered with an apologetic wince. “But it all worked out alright with Summer’s cards on the table talk, right?”

“Well, worked out for like two days,” Emma drawled.

“Ben came up with three options to solve the impasse - to finally remove the uncertainty of me and him ever getting married. Option One: just get married to each other and have it over with.”

“Also known as: The Right Answer,” Eden drawled, and Emma elbowed her.

“Option Two,” I continued, “Ben settles down and marries someone else; but neither Summer nor Adrienne is ready for that. Or Option Three: make me understand that his answer is now and forever will be, ‘No, we’re never getting married.’”

“And you’re trying to say Option Three is the solution? That’s bullshit,” Eden muttered.

I sighed. “Summer actually came up with an Option Four: to understand and accept in my heart that I was already his wife in spirit and that we’d love each other ‘til death do us part.”

“I like Option Four,” Eden proclaimed. “I’m gonna steal that.”

“Eed…” Emma drawled.

I shook my head. “Option Four didn’t work for me.”

“Because you’re not actually satisfied with only being his wife in spirit,” Emma stated in understanding. “Unlike my hopelessly insane twin sister here, you’re not related to him. And so long as he remains unmarried on paper, you’ll always crave - always covet - that piece of paper.”

My shoulders sank. “Simple enough, right?”

Eden exclaimed merrily, “Option One it is. Team Dawn all the way! Half-sister for the win!” She raised her hand out to me, and I chuckled as I reached out and high-fived it.

“Thanks for the vote of support,” I began, “but you both know there’s no way I’m gonna try and supplant Summer OR Adrienne. Besides, it takes two people to want to get married. Ben’s made clear to me he doesn’t think our relationship works as a romance. Option Three was HIS idea.”

“He seemed pretty happy with Option Four,” Eden stated. “And more to the point, he is absolutely MISERABLE right now without you. From where I’m sitting, it seems to me that you unilaterally decided on this break-up, and even if he agreed to do it for your sake, he’s definitely got buyer’s remorse and wants to take it back.”

I sighed. “We can’t go back. We just can’t.”

“Why NOT? I mean seriously, what IS the hang-up with you two?” Eden shook her head. “Why are you really doing this? Everything seemed so perfect at Morris Camp.”

“Morris Camp is like that sometimes,” I stated with a shrug. “It’s easy to get lost in the magic and feel like everything’s going great. But everyone eventually has to come back to reality.”

“What was wrong with The Quad?” Eden asked. “After we all put our cards on the table and everything, I thought things were finally working out. Next thing I know, we’re back home at The Nest, you and Ben start telling us you’ve mutually decided to ‘take a break’, and then you’re driving down here.”

“We all talked about this yesterday, didn’t we?” I asked with a shrug.

“You informed us of your decision yesterday,” Emma corrected. “But it was clear that neither of you wanted to go into details, so you and I packed up and drove down here.”

Eden piped up, “And you didn’t interrogate her on the drive down?”

Emma shrugged. “Like I said: it was clear that neither of them wanted to go into details.”

“Are you willing to go into details now?” Eden asked, turning her attention back to me.

I reclined back, raised my elbows onto the deck, and sighed. “Emma was right,” I stated as if that answered everything.

“I was?” Emma queried, looking confused for a moment before she got it. “Ohhh… seriously?!?”

“Does someone wanna fill me in on the big secret?” Eden complained.

“I’ve been saying for weeks that maybe Dawn and Ben are destined to be best friends and lovers the way our parents are. Always together. Intimately close. But ultimately married to other people,” Emma explained before turning to me. “But I was just hypothesizing. Is that seriously what you believe now?”

I took a deep breath and exhaled slowly before nodding. “It’s all I’ve got left. As much as I loved being part of The Quad - as much as I loved being part of the team - I realized that I wasn’t really happy with the way things worked out.”

Emma arched an eyebrow. “With you NOT on top as Ben’s titled wife?”

I blushed and sighed. “I thought I’d be alright with it. I thought I’d be okay with being his ‘wife in spirit’. But in the end--”

“Wait-wait-wait,” Eden interjected. “You just agreed a minute ago that you coveted the government piece of paper, thus implying you still WANT to be legally married to Ben. Now you’re saying you want to marry somebody else?!? That doesn’t compute.”

“I’m not saying I WANT to marry somebody else. There aren’t any other male candidates in my life, for one thing. But I am honestly wondering if that’s the best long-term solution for me - for us. Something’s gotta change, clearly. Ben and I have been stuck on this hamster wheel for too long already. Round and round in circles without going anywhere.” I sighed and closed my eyes. “I love him. I’ll always love him. But I think that it’s long past time that I considered the possibility that--”

“NO. Just… NO,” Eden cut me off. “You CANNOT be seriously thinking that--”

“That maybe there’s some other compatible soul out there for Dawn?” Emma interrupted. “Yes, I think it’s time she started to think that. I think it’s time she considered the possibility that she and Ben just don’t function well as a romantic pairing and really do in fact belong together as best friends and partners like Brandi and Dayna, and Brooke and DJ, or even you and me. At the end of the day, they’ll find their own husbands (or maybe a wife for you) but stay closely interconnected with each other.”

“No-no-no-no-no. That’s not how this works,” Eden protested. “You and Ben BELONG together. Full stop. Period. End of story. Happily Ever After.”

“We do belong together. I agree,” I stated firmly before taking a deep breath and sighing as I finished, “but just as best friends.”

“But WHY?!?” Eden exclaimed. “Option One IS the right answer. You LOVE him: I know it. Do you have any idea what I would give to be in your position right now? Ben is heartbroken by your absence. THIS is your opportunity to go back there and tell him you made a mistake! Tell him that Option Four wasn’t good enough, that you really DO want the government piece of paper, and that whatever hang-ups he’s got about you right now, that you’ll work with him to overcome them.”

“These aren’t hang-ups we can overcome.”

“What are these hang-ups? And why CAN’T you overcome them? And please don’t give me anymore bullshit about how your love is purer without needing external validation or anymore mumbo-jumbo.”

“No mumbo-jumbo.” I pointed at Emma. “You were the one saying that maybe Ben and I just aren’t compatible. I know Ben loves me, but I also know he’s jealous of me. As a best friend, he accepts me as I am: a sexual creature with a varied appetite. He can handle me… partaking… from time to time. Even if I never actually ‘partake’, he can handle me having flashes. But he would never accept that from his wife. A woman bonded to him in holy matrimony would need to be able to uphold undying fidelity - her sacred temple reserved exclusively for him - and he gets that from Adrienne and Summer both.”

“AND you,” Eden insisted. “Wasn’t that the whole point of your Ben-ogamy?”

“Ben wants his wife to never even desire another man but him. To see him as ‘All I need’.”

“Isn’t he all you need?” Eden wondered. “How many times have you asked me and Emma to plug you up to help you satisfy these cravings without needing another man. You were satisfied, weren’t you?”

“I was satisfied. I AM satisfied. I don’t ACTUALLY need to have sex with other men, but I still feel the desire. I still get flashes. There’s nothing remotely emotional or romantic about it. There are no specific men with whom I actually want to have sex with. It’s simply a sexual high I’ve felt before and keep chasing, and while I’ve tried to force myself not to have the thoughts cross my mind, they still do. Ben sees the light in my eyes when they do, and I can see him forcing himself to swallow the bile in the back of his throat. I can see him reminding himself to have faith in me. The reality is: the Dawnpocalypse traumatized us both. We both still carry the scars today. I truly believe in the deepest part of his heart he has done his best to forgive me. But as long as we remain in a romantic relationship of any kind, he will always feel this jealousy. He will always be reminded of his pain.”

“Time together will heal that wound,” Eden insisted. “Faith and trust can be re-earned. You say you never want to take another man into your sacred temple reserved exclusively for him, right? Did you mean that?”

I nodded slowly. “I did.”

“Then DO it. Maybe after another ten years you’ll stop feeling flashes. Maybe after ten years go by without you ever breaking your Ben-ogamy, he’ll stop swallowing bile because he’ll know that even if you get a flash, you’ll never actually ACT on it. We’re defined by our actions, not our thoughts, right? We’re all ALLOWED to have thoughts.”

“Are you listening to yourself?” Emma interjected. “Ten years?”

“Whatever it takes, right?” Eden challenged.

“You can’t expect Ben and Dawn to put their lives in stasis for ten years,” Emma stated flatly to Eden before turning to me. “And YOU need to get over this idea that having thoughts of other men is some defective part of your core psyche that needs to be excised for all eternity. Husbands are allowed to leer at bikini-clad babes on the beach and briefly think about bending them over the nearest bench. Housewives are allowed to have illicit thoughts about the shirtless gardener. And you know what? If that housewife’s husband gives her the green light to fuck the shirtless gardener, then that’s allowed too! Defining what is acceptable in a relationship is entirely between the two people involved and nobody else!”

“I’m not disagreeing with you,” I stated evenly.

“Do you know how many times I fantasized about other men while I was dating Marcus?” Emma continued.

“I’m guessing at least a few times.”

“A LOT.”

“Okay…”

“A LOT a lot. Exhibit A: I fantasized about my big brother constantly. I FUCKED my big brother… constantly. And I fantasized about some of Marcus’s football buddies too!”

“Okay…”

“And I FUCKED two of them, too!”

“Wait, what?” I whipped my head around to Eden, who shrugged and gave me a look that plainly said, ‘Yeah, I knew.’

“I realize that everyone in our big extended family sees me as the youngest baby sister of baby sisters. But newsflash: I’m NOT that innocent. I know big brother Ben always wanted to maintain some willful ignorance of his baby sister’s sexual activity - and maybe you did too - but I’m a gorgeous college coed and I know it.”

I found myself stunned speechless.

“It took a while for this baby bird to leave the nest,” Emma continued. “I saw the bile in the back of Ben’s throat whenever he thought of me being with another man. He was jealous of me. Fine, that was normal. But I knew deep down in his heart that he wanted me to live my very best life.”

Just like he wants YOU to live your very best life.

“My big brother would never want his baby sister to be tied down to him - either of his baby sisters - so I moved forward. I moved on,” Emma continued. “I started a relationship with Marcus. I had sex with my boyfriend. I met two other guys I was attracted to. And I took advantage of the opportunities I had… WITH my boyfriend. ALL with his knowledge and presence. I NEVER did anything behind my boyfriend’s back, and we had some fun threesomes and even moresomes on occasion. I totally get your fascination with getting DP’d by multiple dicks; it’s amazing. Much as I like girls with Ben Juniors, it’s not quite the same as the real thing; I get that. Getting spit-roasted and going down on cute cheerleaders while my boyfriend banged me from behind weren’t all-the-time-every-time encounters or anything like that, but they happened and I enjoyed them. We’re in college, right? Marcus and I were always in total agreement. We communicated. We agreed on what was happening. And as long as my boyfriend and I were on the same page about what was going on, why NOT ‘partake’? And when I found myself lying in bed, sweaty and oozing sperm from both of my sodden holes, I never felt any shame, only satisfaction. Enjoying myself didn’t make me a slut - didn’t make me sinful - because Marcus and I were the only ones who could define what was or wasn’t acceptable.”

“Just like Ben and I are the ones who define what is or isn’t acceptable,” I stated firmly. “YOU may be fine with me having flashes, but HE isn’t.”

“Did HE say that?”

“He didn’t have to. I can feel it…” I tapped the side of my head. “… in here.”

“That mystical link you two are so proud of isn’t infallible,” Emma grumbled. “You see the bile in the back of his throat and feel the twinge of pain in his heart. But I’ve been there when he’s insisted to you out loud that you’re allowed to have these thoughts - that he still loves you and accepts you exactly as you are, flashes and all. Those flashes don’t make you a bad person. Your actions define you, not your base impulses.”

“My base impulses… and his knowledge that I have them… WILL poison our relationship from the inside,” I insisted. “They’re already poisoning our relationship from the inside. Don’t you get it? This is a fucked up Gift of the Magi story.”

“A gift of the what now?” Eden asked, looking confused.

Emma pondered for just a moment before explaining, “That Christmas story about the husband who bought his wife a fancy comb for her long hair by selling his prized watch.”

“But she sold her hair to get the money to buy him a platinum chain for his watch,” Eden continued. “I remember now. In the end, she had no hair to use the comb, and he had no watch to use the chain.”

“Right, that one,” I confirmed.

Eden shrugged with a rueful smile. “It’s the thought that counts, I suppose? Even though they bought gifts the other couldn’t use anymore, it demonstrated just how much they loved each other and how far they were willing to go for their love.”

“It demonstrated how futile it is to make incompatible sacrifices for each other,” I sighed mournfully. “He tried to do something for her, but she tried to do something for him, and in the end they only ended up worse off than when they started: her with a buzzcut and him without a prized watch anymore.”

“You BOTH are missing the REAL point of the story: Communication,” Emma stated firmly. “If the husband had simply TOLD his wife what he was doing, she never would’ve cut her hair, and vice versa. Lack of communication is what ultimately screwed them both over.”

“Which is why Ben and I ARE communicating about this, alright?” I insisted. “He’s not trying to swallow his bile for my sake, and I’ve got to stop stressing myself out trying to chase perfection I don’t deserve. It’s always about expectations, and Option Three IS the answer. Option Four sounded nice on paper - the whole bit about being husband and wife in spirit - but it would leave us BOTH yearning to make things official and make us BOTH feel like we were settling for an incomplete romance. We really DO function better as best friends, and after taking a short break to detox, we WILL come back stronger than ever.”

“Stronger than ever,” Emma agreed.

Both of us looked over at Eden, but rather than add her approval, the elder-by-minutes twin shook her head and gave me a caustic look. “I still think you’re a Stupid Fucking Moron.”

“I think you’re just bitter,” Emma drawled to her sister, “because you think Dawn’s in the same position as you, only NOT related to Ben, and she’s rejecting the outcome you want for yourself.”

“You’re not wrong,” Eden sighed.

“You’re not quite right, either,” I stated seriously. “I AM in the same position as Eden, actually, faced with only two choices: pursue the man of my dreams despite an impossible-to-overcome obstacle which will inevitably tear us apart, or have the strength to accept what I can’t change and make the choice that will keep me in his life for all eternity.”

Eden and Emma glanced at each other and then returned back to me.

“I’m choosing the latter,” I insisted, and then took a deep breath before finishing, “because I WILL stay in his life… whatever it takes.”

****

-- FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 --

The morning air was cold against my right cheek, the pillow reassuringly warm against my left. I was spooned up behind my lover’s back, her dark brown hair sweetly fragrant only inches in front of my face. The fingers of my right hand reflexively squeezed the firm breast I was currently palming. My left arm snaked beneath her pillow and the hand dangled off the end of the bed.

Emma had been a semi-frequent overnight companion while we were both in the Silicon Valley area for our internships, and she’d gone out of her way to keep me company last night for my birthday. Given that Ben and my Nestmates were all back in Berkeley, having Ben’s Sex Goddess baby sister blasting my holes with a strap-on Ben Junior was, quite honestly, the next best thing.

Ordinarily, I would’ve hummed happily and snuggled a little closer to my cuddle partner.

Ordinarily, I might’ve slipped my fingertips into my slumbering companion’s tight teen twat, coated my digit in her sweet moisture, and then transferred that natural lubrication to her budding clit to patiently titillate her senses and make her ultimately wake up to a screaming orgasm while shoving three fingers into her spasming snatch at the same time.

But not today.

Some days I woke up feeling absolutely incredible. All was right in my world, metaphorical birds sang, and my room was filled with the warm glow of sunlight even though all the curtains were shut. Waking up to find someone’s slippery tongue slithering into my succulent snatch certainly helped me feel that way often enough. So did waking up to find myself spooned around a cute coed holding her bare breast in my palm.

But this wasn’t one of those days. I mean obviously, I had the bare boob in my hand and all that, and yet I couldn’t help but feel… unsettled. There were no particular warning alarms going off in the back of my head. As my sluggish brain booted up, I couldn’t think of any specific issues that needed to be addressed. I simply felt… off.

Disconcerted.

Ill at ease.

And I wasn’t in the mood for sex.

At first, I tried to snuggle back up to Emma’s back and exhaled slowly to try and force myself to relax. I had another twenty minutes before my alarm clock would go off, and didn’t really want to get out of bed yet. But some niggling thing in the back of my head bothered me, and I found myself wondering what Ben was doing right now.

Feel The Force. Let it flow through you.

Alec Guinness’s deep voice echoed in my mind as I closed my eyes and stretched out with my senses. There was no rational logic that explained why I might have any ability to feel my soulmate’s thoughts. And yet, there was no mistaking the number of times I’d simply felt… something… and then later found that feeling to correlate to some negative event in Ben’s life. It didn’t happen every time. There had certainly been incidents in his life that had taken place without me ever feeling a thing. And there had been times I’d thought I felt something, only to reach out to him and discover that nothing was amiss.

Also, there was a definite disparity between his sensitivity and mine. Ben felt these ‘somethings’ far more rarely than me. Perhaps he found himself in highly-charged emotional situations a lot more often than me. One could speculate that as a male, he was clueless more often than not, and that as a female I had a more natural affinity for such a thing. Or maybe I was just more emotionally closed-off than he was, always keeping my true feelings bottled up inside, and that it made sense he couldn’t sense my senses the same way I sensed his.

I suppose consistency shouldn’t be expected when it comes to quasi-mystical psychic links, but I had learned to trust my instincts in such things.

And at the moment, I trusted my instinct that he wasn’t in trouble, wasn’t in danger, and didn’t need my immediate assistance.

Still, I felt… off.

Disconcerted.

Ill at ease.

It was still early, too early to wake up Emma to go to work. Rather than disturb her slumber, I slipped out of bed, put on some pajamas, and padded out of the room. I’d get a pot of coffee started before returning to get fully dressed.

Five minutes later, I reclined in the living room armchair, surfing Facebook on my phone while waiting for the coffee to perk. I was scrolling idly when Ben’s text message came in: a selfie photo of my handsome best friend giving me a beaming smile.

I love you, he wrote immediately after the photo came in. Never forget that.

I smiled and wrote back: For all eternity.

****

Ben’s selfie and reminder that he loved me improved my mood far more than the coffee did, but my feeling of unease continued into the morning. I was distracted at work - uncommonly so, since I was known to be a studious hard-worker and typically quite focused.

My boss commented on my distracted state, and I apologized, stating that I had “a bit of a birthday hangover.” She laughed and nodded. Ben had apparently called and told her July 9th was my birthday, and my co-workers had made a big deal out of it yesterday, so my excuse made perfect sense.

I tried to buckle down and refocus on my job, but that nagging sense of unease wouldn’t leave me. And it only got worse when Adrienne sent me a text:

Code Blue. Meet your house. Well be there by 12

I frowned as I stared at the screen, my eyebrows furrowed. I tapped on the message itself and then entered my passcode to unlock the phone. And a moment later, I typed back: What’s going on?

Adrienne: Need talk about Ben. He was really off last nite. Me sash summ coming down

I took a deep breath, my mind racing. What was going on? Adrienne could’ve simply called me. She could’ve texted me. Whatever it was, I knew Adrienne figured it was better for us to talk face-to-face, otherwise she and the others wouldn’t be going to the effort of driving down to my place. And while she wasn’t above overblowing a relatively minor thing into an overly melodramatic kerfuffle, the decision to drive in and of itself told me the gravity of the situation.

I checked the clock. It was only nine-thirty, and I didn’t really want to sit around and wonder what the hell was going on for the next two and a half hours.

So after a moment’s thought, I typed back: I can leave early. Can you be at my house in an hour?

Her response came back perhaps twenty seconds later: Yes. c u 1030

I replied back: See you then.

I spent the next thirty minutes unable to focus any better than I had all morning. Feeling useless, I went over to my boss’s office and knocked on her open door.

“Hey, I’m really not feeling well,” I told her, which was technically true. “I don’t think this is a simple hangover.”

“You should go home and get some rest,” she told me immediately. “Get that thoughtful, considerate husband of yours to give you a backrub or something.”

I smiled and absentmindedly rubbed the fake wedding band around my fourth finger. It hadn’t occurred to me she’d assume Ben was my husband. But I nodded my acceptance and told her I’d see her on Monday. And then I went back to my desk to collect my backpack and keys before heading back home.

I parked in the garage just before 10:15 and went to the fridge to get some apple juice, feeling like a brief burst of sugar as a temporary pick-me-up. I then went to chillax on the couch, leaning my head back and closing my eyes, trying to calm my brain and NOT let myself go down the rabbit hole of wondering what was so wrong with Ben to make Adrienne, Sasha, and Summer all drive down to meet me.

If the simple fact that the three girls were going to all this effort wasn’t concerning enough, the fact that my phone chirped with a text message reading “here” at 10:28 was positively terrifying. “Adrienne” and “on-time” were not two words that went well together in a sentence. Truly, I had figured on 50/50 odds whether or not they’d arrive before eleven.

I got up, checked the peephole, and then opened the front door while the three girls were just stepping onto the porch.

“Hey, Dawnie,” Adrienne greeted me and gave me a hug as she came in. Sasha was next, and then Summer trailing behind them.

They each hugged me, with Summer the last, and she held me close for a few extra beats, clearly not wanting to let go just yet. Meanwhile, Sasha went to close the door, and I pulled back just far enough to look into Summer’s eyes.

“You alright, Sunshine?” I asked in mild concern. The purple-haired girl’s eyes were quite moist and her expression was pained.

But she gave me a brave smile and said, “I just missed you.”

“Aww, I missed you too.” I leaned in and gave her a quick peck. Summer whimpered a little and clutched me close again. I let her hug me and stroked her spine, but rotated a bit so I could look over her shoulder into the living room where Adrienne had parked herself in the armchair and Sasha sat on the sofa.

“You need to come home,” Adrienne stated without preamble when our eyes met.

I relaxed my grip on Summer, and she finally released her grip as well. I kept my arm around her lower back while she turned to face the others, and we walked together into the living room to join them. “I was always coming home tonight. It’s Friday.”

Adrienne shook her head. “What’s more important to you: your internship or your relationship with Ben?”

“Hey, hey, let’s not get overly melodramatic right off the top,” Sasha advised gently.

But Adrienne looked defiant. She had that ‘ready to throw down’ look on her face that told me I was one wrong sentence away from getting a right cross fist to the face. “I let you and Ben both talk me into this ‘taking a break’ bullshit at Morris Camp a week ago, but it’s not working. Ben has been miserable all week.”

“We’ve both been miserable, alright?” I said defensively as Summer and I sat down on the sofa next to Sasha.

“It’s not a competition,” Summer soothed softly, stroking my leg.

“I didn’t mean…” I took a deep breath. “Ben and I both knew this would be a trying time for us. On the surface, it shouldn’t matter since I’ve been spending all week down here for my internship every week anyways, but--”

“But this is different,” Adrienne cut me off. “Every other week you were gone, Ben knew with absolute certainty that you loved him, cherished him, and wanted to be in his life forever.”

“I still love him, cherish him, and want to be in his life forever.”

“Do you? Do you really? I’m not so sure anymore.”

“Of course I do.”

“No don’t ‘of course’ me. Say ‘yes’, plainly and directly,” she growled.

I bristled at her tone, and the defiant part of my ego wanted to dismiss her out of hand rather than give her the satisfaction of my compliance. Adrienne was being rude, straight up, but at the same time I knew she was only being this emotional because she was worried about Ben.

So I took a deep breath, and as I exhaled I let go of that momentary annoyance. And I stated quite seriously, “Yes. I love him. I will ALWAYS love him. And I want to be a part of his life ‘til death do us part.”

Adrienne seemed to calm down a bit, and she glanced over at Sasha, something unspoken communicating between their eyes.

In the meantime, I had questions of my own. “So where’s Ben now?”

“At work. As usual,” Adrienne replied. “He’s got some Strawberry project deadline to wrap up before a 4pm session with Iris.”

“Is he alright?”

“Yeah, yeah, he’s fine. Well he’s NOT fine, clearly. But he’s not sick or injured or anything like that,” Adrienne muttered dismissively.

I didn’t feel like that answered anything, so I looked at Summer and raised both eyebrows.

Summer glanced at Adrienne first as if she needed permission to speak, but it was just a glance. “He’s physically healthy, but he’s definitely been out of sorts all week. You already know Eden drove down here on Tuesday because she was worried about him. Wednesday, the girls were able to distract him with the hip-hop class. Great idea Sasha, by the way, to invite A.D. That worked out really well.”

Sasha smiled and nodded.

“But then Thursday morning - your birthday - he…” Summer’s voice trailed off and she paused to collect her thoughts. “I mean, he--”

“He stopped to grab his phone and text you a happy birthday while he was buried inside me,” Adrienne muttered with an eyeroll, shaking her head. “And then after you hung up, he actually pulled out of me… ME… and rolled onto his back to just sort of stare up at the ceiling for a while. He started going soft, but then Summer went down on him and managed to get him back on track.”

“Oh… Uhhh… sorry?” I offered lamely.

“I do think you’re blowing this out of proportion a bit,” Sasha told Adrienne. “It’s expected for him to be a little out of it and… contemplative… during a transition time in their relationship.”

Adrienne shook her head. “He got contemplative during a Love Nest nooner with the three of us and Penny yesterday.”

“But he was at least still functional,” Sasha pointed out, “if a bit robotic and out of it.”

“Barely functional,” Adrienne scoffed. “And we didn’t even get THAT last night or this morning. Couldn’t get him an erection. ME. -I- couldn’t get him an erection.”

“Wait-wait-wait,” I interjected. “What happened?”

Adrienne rolled her eyes again, but Summer volunteered, “A.D.’s upset because Ben shut us out of his bedroom last night after the family Skype call for your birthday.”

“What?!” I exclaimed in surprise.

“Just for a little bit. I mean, you know he got up and left before the video chat ended,” Summer said.

I nodded, remembering how he hadn’t even said ‘goodbye’. He just sort of disappeared partway through.

“After the call, A.D. went up to go check on him. Thirty seconds later, we could all hear her banging on the door yelling for him to unlock it. I went up as well, Ben was telling her he just needed five minutes to think. So I talked A.D. into letting him have five minutes, and we gave him like… ten minutes… before going back. At first, it didn’t seem like he wanted to open up, but I told him I was worried and that I really needed his reassurance and to feel him holding me, and he came and unlocked the door.”

“Ah, you played the ‘need’ card,” I remarked with a chuckle.

Summer smiled. “So the three of us closed the door again and talked. He apologized and said he was just feeling out of sorts with it being your birthday and all. He loves you and misses you, and the uncertainty over the future of your relationship is driving him bonkers.”

“Bonkers enough that he didn’t want to have sex,” Adrienne grumbled, staring out the window with a foul expression on her face. “Ben. My Tiger. NOT wanting to have sex. With ME.”

“Taking it a little personally there, aren’t you?” Sasha said lightly. “He didn’t want to have sex with me, either. Or Summer or Eden or anyone else.”

“You’re only proving my point,” Adrienne muttered. “Ben’s penis is the easiest barometer of his emotional state. When he can’t get it up no matter what we try… all isn’t right in the state of Denmark.”

“‘Something is rotten in the state of Denmark,’” I corrected.

Adrienne rolled her eyes at me. “You really think I care?”

I stiffened again at her mocking tone, but exhaled again. Adrienne was just being Adrienne - wearing her emotions on her sleeve - and she wasn’t specifically directing anything at me.

“So Ben didn’t want to have sex last night or this morning, I assume,” I began speculatively, “so you therefore all believed the sky was falling and needed to pull me out of work and call an emergency Nestmates meeting. That about sum it up?”

Adrienne stared at me coldly. “How can you be so casually dismissive of this? Do you love him or don’t you?”

“Of course I love him.”

“And now you’re ‘of coursing’ me again.”

I took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. Adrienne was clearly frustrated, and okay maybe she WAS directing that frustration at me. I pursed my lips, collected my calm, and sat up straight. I sharpened my eyes and stared right back at the world-famous supermodel with equal determination and force of personality. And in a quiet but firm voice, I stated, “I have loved Ben for twenty-five years: my entire life. I’ve never stopped, not even for a single day. We’ve had our ups and downs. We’ve both made mistakes. Friends, lovers, family: our relationship has changed and morphed back and forth in ways that no single label can truly encapsulate. No matter where we are or who else we might be with, I will love him with every fiber of my being for all eternity. ‘Til death do us part. So when I say ‘of course I love him’, I mean of course I love him.”

Adrienne’s expression softened, she took a deep breath, and sat up straight in her chair as well. “Well alrighty then…” She smiled and nodded before leaning forward with her elbows on her knees and her hands clasped. “So with THAT cleared up, how do we all work together to fix this?”

“Fix… Ben?”

Adrienne nodded. “Fourth of July, before the barn orgy, Mom pulled me aside so she could have one of our mother/daughter chats. She wanted to make sure I understood that I wasn’t in a relationship with Ben alone: that he and I were only HALF of the involved parties to be considered in any decision-making, that we were in a four-person collection of equals and not three separate man/woman relationships with him at the center, and that it would be in Ben’s nature to feel overly responsible for maintaining harmony amongst the three of us. She knows it’s in MY nature to take charge and lead the way, but at the end of the day I only have a twenty-five percent vote and that I should take care to make sure you and Summer are on-board as well. So here we are - plus Sasha - and we need to figure this out together.”

I shook my head. “I’m not in The Quad anymore. That’s not to say I’m unwilling to help in any way I can, but you, Summer, and Ben are a triple now. I’m out.”

“No you’re not.”

I blinked. “What part of ‘Ben and I are taking a break’ didn’t you get on Sunday night?”

“That doesn’t mean you’re OUT. It means you’re… you’re on vacation.” Adrienne screwed up her face. “I realize I don’t have a corporate job, but the best analogy I’ve got is that you’re a long-term employee and you’re taking a few weeks off to go to Hawaii. Maybe you’ll delegate some of your daily tasks to the others still in the office, but your job will still be waiting for you when you get back.”

“This isn’t just a vacation. I’m out. I’m not his girlfriend. I never was.”

“Let’s not argue semantics right now, because I HATE arguing semantics,” Adrienne muttered, slumping against the back of her chair and hooking her right leg over the armrest. “Together/nottogether… Girlfriend/wife-in-spirit… it’s all the same. Friends, lovers, family and all that stuff about loving him in a way no single label can encapsulate that you said a minute ago still applies. I don’t care whether you call him your ‘best friend’ or your ‘constant’ or even your ‘husband’: it’s all the same to me. He’s your Ben. You’re his Dawn. ‘Til death do you part. You might feel like you’re ‘out’ but HE doesn’t feel like you’re ‘out’.”

“Actually, I think he DOES feel like she’s ‘out’,” Sasha advised. “Which is exactly the problem. If this was just a Hawaiian vacation and Dawn would be back in the office next Monday, he wouldn’t be freaking out the way he is.”

Summer turned to me. “I told you the uncertain future of your relationship is what’s driving him bonkers. He wants certainty. He wants to make you an official girlfriend, you know. I know you’ve been against that from the beginning - all your talk about not having paperwork or bracelets or titles - but it’s what HE wants.”

“No he doesn’t. I asked to get back together and he turned me down.”

“That was more than a year ago, even before I came to Berkeley. This is now, and he wants you back. You, me, A.D.: he wants The Quad. That’s his Happily Ever After. He felt like he’d finally gotten it at Morris Camp. All of his loved ones nearby. He’s upset that he let you talk him into taking a break. He’s upset with himself for posing the idea in the first place. Plain and simple fact, he wants you living under the same roof as him, he wants you in his bed every night, and he wants you to be as official as me and A.D.”

“I can’t be his third girlfriend,” I stated with a sigh. “I can’t.”

“Why NOT?”

“Because…” I took a deep breath and sighed, shaking my hand.

Adrienne sat up again and leaned forward when it became clear that I wasn’t finishing my answer in a timely enough manner. “Because WHY?”

I shook my head. “What do you want me to say that I didn’t already say on Sunday?”

“I want you to admit the truth.”

“I DID admit the truth. I told you that I found myself dissatisfied with Option Four, at the idea of being his wife-in-spirit but never his real wife with the paperwork and all. I told you that despite our agreement for none of the three of us to chase the crown, I still kept thinking about marrying him for real fifteen times a day. And I told you I needed to step away for a bit - barely more than a month, really - to find some headspace and redefine my relationship with him as best friends. Ben’s got it right: I AM out. I’ve left the company. And when I return from that Hawaiian vacation, I’ll be a visiting contractor instead of an employee.”

“He doesn’t want you ‘out’,” Adrienne insisted. “He wants you ‘in’. He wants you official. He wishes he could go back in time and talk you out of ever taking a break in the first place. He is fucking traumatized from the Dawnpocalypse and feels like you’re abandoning him AGAIN.”

“I’m not abandoning him. I didn’t drive off to Morris Camp for a year. I’m not refusing his phone calls. We sent selfies to each other and said ‘I love you’ just this morning.”

“Sure, he put on a brave face for five seconds and sent you a text. I’m telling you: he feels abandoned,” Adrienne insisted. “He’s feeling miserable, he’s NOT having sex with me, and I’m going to do whatever it takes to fix him. From what I can tell, that means bringing you home.”

I held up my hands. “I was always coming home today. You guys have a belated birthday party planned for me, right?”

Adrienne shook her head. “I’m not talking physically. I’m talking about bringing you back into The Quad. Officially. I’m saying I’m going to do whatever I can to fix Ben’s Happily Ever After, and that means including you in it.”

“I can’t be Ben’s official girlfriend. We’ve been over this.”

“Because you’ll always want the crown, right? Done. It’s yours. Option One, right? Ben and Dawn get married? Summer, back me up here.”

Summer sat up straight at being put on the spot by Adrienne. She blinked in surprise but nodded almost immediately. “Ben and Dawn getting married? Yeah, totally. Option One.”

I shook my head. “We’ve been over this: Ben and I can’t get married.”

“Why NOT?” Adrienne groaned. “And don’t give me some bullshit about pushing out me and Summer as his official girlfriends. We’re the ones pushing you. Doesn’t mean we don’t love him as much as you, but at the same time, we understand it was always supposed to be you. It’s destiny. You two have belonged together since the beginning of time. We both know you’d let us be part of his life. We both know Ben has always dreamed of you two getting married. And we both know that YOU have always dreamed of marrying him.”

“I did… but that was just a little girl’s dream, and ‘it was always our dream’ isn’t a good reason for two incompatible people to get married. I’ve told you before a million times: Yang and Yang. I’ve betrayed him once already, and try as he might, he will never fully trust me. That needle in the back of his mind will forever poison--”

“BZZT!” Summer hissed while pinching my leg.

“Ow!” I glared at her. “Just because you don’t want to hear the reason again doesn’t mean it isn’t true.”

“The falsehood of what you’re saying means it isn’t true,” Summer insisted. “Ever since your little ‘I had sex with Bert’ test back in February, how many arguments have you gotten into with him about your Ben-ogamy?”

I shrugged but didn’t verbalize an answer.

“None. The answer is ‘none’,” Summer pointed out. “Because he really does have faith in you.”

“Faith that’ll go right out the window the very next time I meet a Dalton, or a Jaron, or even just have an orgy when Bert’s around and I get a split-second flash of desire in my eyes.”

“DID Ben’s faith go right out the window the last time Bert was around for an orgy?” Summer turned to look at Adrienne. “Did you see Ben get all knotted up at the Bingo 69 party?”

Adrienne shook her head firmly. “Nope.”

Summer returned her attention back to me. “We all know Ben’s preference is to keep the three of us all to himself. The three of us are his core Nestmates - no offense, Sasha.”

“None taken,” the brunette replied easily.

“Ben can accept Sasha having other lovers on her travels. He accepts his sisters finding romantic partners of their own. Kim and June have found friendship and companionship with Bert and Lynne. WE are his Special Ones, including you. And when it comes to his Special Ones, Ben really does expect… ohmigawd…” Summer blinked and stared straight at the far wall, her mouth gaping open with an overall shocked expression on her face. “I think I finally figured it out.”

I arched an eyebrow, and then glanced at both Adrienne and Sasha wondering if either of them had a clue what Summer was thinking. From the looks on their faces, neither of them did.

“Figured out what?” Adrienne pressed impatiently.

Summer turned to face me, her eyes still wide with shock. “Figured out why Ben was never happy with your Oath of Ben-ogamy. He doesn’t want your physical fidelity.”

I stared at her as if she’d grown a lime green and purple horn between her eyebrows. “Huh? Weren’t you just saying how he wants to keep all three of his Special Ones core Nestmates all to himself?”

Summer shook her head like I didn’t understand. “Your Oath of Ben-ogamy to him was exactly like being ‘wife in spirit’ to you: a disappointment. A letdown. A poor facsimile for the relationship you really wanted. You spent two days in The Quad as a ‘wife in spirit’ before realizing you could never be satisfied without the real government title. And swearing Ben-ogamy to him left him unsatisfied that you weren’t in a real, official relationship. He didn’t want just your physical fidelity; he wanted your commitment.”

I furrowed my eyebrows. “What?”

“Ben wanted you to be his girlfriend. Not his best friend. Not his constant. His girlfriend. The one and only thing he has ever wanted from you ever since the Dawnpocalypse was a chance to start again. He wanted to be the nice guy who didn’t pressure you into a romance you didn’t feel ready for, but he wanted it all the same. As far as he was concerned, he DID love you like a wife, and every time you told him he was the only husband you’d ever have only reinforced the thought in his mind that you belonged to him the way Adrienne tells him she belongs to him, the way -I- tell him I belong to him.”

Summer glanced around, and so did I, to find both Adrienne and Sasha nodding their agreement. The wheels were turning in MY head as well.

“Ben wanted… currently WANTS… to own you in the way a boyfriend owns a girlfriend. He WANTS to have the right to insist on your physical fidelity. As a boyfriend, Ben could demand that you be faithfully monogamous to him once and for all like a million other married couples where mono-dick fidelity is expected. It doesn’t mean wives stop thinking about other men, to use your shirtless gardener example, but they don’t ACT on those thoughts for the sake of their marriage. You can do that for the sake of YOUR marriage. Tell him the truth: that you get flashes and that you’ll always get flashes. But reassure him that despite all those flashes, you will now and forever be faithful to his penis and only his penis. Because as long as you remain single, uncommitted, and ‘we’re just friends’, then the possibility exists that you could one day decide, ‘Yeah, I wanna sleep with this hot Adonis with bulging pecs and washboard abs’, and Ben wouldn’t be able to do a fucking thing about it because he and you are ‘just friends’.”

“She makes a lot of sense,” Sasha stated approvingly.

“And you’re driving him INSANE right now,” Adrienne added. “A week ago you put your cards on the table and swore your undying devotion to him. The term ‘best friends’ and ‘wife’ were an interchangeable discussion of semantics. You even knew back then that if he didn’t claim you, he would fear some other man might make you ‘his cow’. Well… Sunday night you told him you were ‘taking a break’, and all of a sudden that fear has come roaring right back.”

“You want the needle gone from his head? Commitment was always the answer, not avoiding commitment,” Summer stated with obvious enthusiasm, as happy as if she’d solved a Rubik’s Cube for the very first time. She squeezed my knee and leaned in close. “This isn’t the same thing as my mom and Caspian. If anything, the one similarity you should take away from their situation is that life is fleeting and that you should take advantage of the time you have with him while you still can. Because I have to admit that my heart skips a beat every time one of you says ‘’Til death do us part’, because I’m terrified one of you is gonna suddenly die and leave the other one heartbroken forever with unresolved trauma.”

I shook my head. “We can’t live our lives fearing death around every corner.”

“And you can’t live your life fearing that Ben will never forgive you,” Summer stated sagely.

Wanna bet?

You have horrible timing.

I’m just saying: your so-called plan has always seemed to be to live your life fearing that Ben will never forgive you and doing EVERYTHING in your power to… well… avoid that. Classic Dawn.

Seriously… Shut. Up.

I took a deep, calming breath, trying my best to not lose control.

Adrienne leaned forward and glared at me with as much disgusted disapproval as Summer’s bright enthusiasm, and the supermodel grumbled, “What you’re doing right now? It’s not working. It hasn’t been working all year. Deflecting anyone from really discovering what’s inside your pretty little head. Trying to force yourself to NOT feel emotions or think thoughts you’ve declared to be incompatible with the ‘Perfect Dawn’ ideal in your head. You’re running away from your problems again. You try to convince yourself that this time it’s different. This isn’t another ranch hand sabbatical because you’re staying in contact with him, sending selfies, and texting ‘I love you’. But as far as he’s concerned, you’re running away again. Ben would never say this to you, but I can, so let me make this as plainly clear as I possibly can: YOU. ARE. FUCKING UP. AGAIN.”

“Little harsh, honey…” Sasha soothed.

“She’s a big girl. She can handle it,” Adrienne scoffed without ever removing her glare from my face. “This was NEVER about Ben-ogamy. He told you flat out after your ‘Bert Test’ that if he saw Jaron in the street, he’d shake the guy’s hand and tell him they were good. Does Ben want to keep all the toys to himself? Absolutely. But you having sex with another man - approved in advance and supervised by him - he’d gladly share that with you. Hiding your true self in a futile attempt to become Perfect Dawn? THAT was the true poison that would undermine your relationship. Running away instead of staying with him to work things out? THAT’S what upsets him the most. And you’re Doing. It. AGAIN.”

“Priority. Honesty. Fertility. Fidelity,” Summer recited like a mantra. “Those were the four things you said Ben needed from a wife. And you’re fucking up all four of them right now.”

Sasha blinked. “How, exactly, is she fucking up Fertility?”

“Well they haven’t been having sex this week, have they? Work with me on this…” Summer sighed.

“You’re NOT prioritizing him right now,” Adrienne stated flatly. “When faced with an uncertain situation as part of The Quad, rather than stay in the team and work things out together, you abandoned him. You ran away.”

Sasha started chuckling and she shook her head ruefully at me. “What you’ve been doing is the exact opposite of Open Communication. Do we really need to talk about your failures of Honesty?”

“And Fidelity,” Summer finished. “Emotional fidelity, not physical. Having sex with other men under controlled conditions to satisfy your urges is NOT cheating. Ben’s nuclear bomb panic has always been about a lack of communication. He said that if he ever turned a doorknob and walked in to find you unexpectedly riding some dude, that he’d walk away and never forgive you. I can believe that because of the unexpected nature of it, but if the two of you agreed on something beforehand? The compassionate boyfriend I know and fell in love with would totally do that for you. The only thing he’d ever ask for in return would be your commitment to love him for the rest of your lives - officially, in public, for the world to see and so Miss-Perfect-Dawn-who-doesn’t-want-to-look-like-the-bad-guy wouldn’t easily be able to back out and break up with him.”

“Ben needs you,” Adrienne stated seriously. “Now maybe the trigger word doesn’t work on you exactly the same way it does on him, but I’m hoping Yang and Yang function similarly enough to have the same effect. I want to believe you can feel it through your mystical link. I want to believe you’ll understand how miserable he is right now without you. Okay maybe I was out of line with the whole ‘What’s more important to you: your internship or Ben?’ question. I’m sure Ben would never actually want you to give up your internship just for his sake. But the sentiment remains: IS he as important to you as you’ve always claimed, or not? He needs you to come home. He needs you to give up this temporary vacation from your corporate job and return to work. Come back to him. Come back to us. We want you in The Quad again. And if it’s the crown you want, it’s the crown you can have.”

“Option One,” Summer confirmed. “It’s your Destiny.”

She looked so hopeful, smiling ear-to-ear with an expression of radiant sunshine. Sasha looked encouraging, reassuring, and warm. And Adrienne? Well, Adrienne was still scowling with an RBF (Resting Bitch Face) expression that suggested I’d get a right cross to the face if I didn’t cooperate.

And unfortunately, I wasn’t about to cooperate.

“You think that highlighting all the ways I’ve failed in living up to my own Four Core Qualities of Being Ben’s Wife will somehow encourage me to mend my ways and be better,” I stated rather bitterly, shaking my head. “Instead you’ve only reinforced how much of a failure I really am. There’s no way in hell I can marry Ben the way I am right now. I don’t deserve him, and thank you all just now for proving it beyond a doubt.”

****

“I’m tired,” I stated, getting up from the couch and walking over to the kitchen. It wasn’t yet 11am and yet I was exhausted. I felt weak and weary and wanted another glass of apple juice to get a quick sugar pick-me-up. And I called over my shoulder, “Anybody want something to drink?”

Nobody answered verbally, although Summer got up from the sofa and followed me into the kitchen. She trailed me over to the cabinet and purely by routine, I pulled out three tall glasses and set them down on the counter in front of her. We’d done this same sort of thing together dozens of times by now.

Summer went to the fridge with two of the glasses, got ice from the dispenser, and then crossed over to the water filter tap at the sink to fill them up. I brought over the other glass, added ice, and then went to the pantry to get a bottle of Perrier. Sasha had taken to drinking carbonated water instead of flat during her travels, as tap water often wasn’t all that clean in many of the countries she visited. And I also got my apple juice.

We returned to the living room, with Summer handing one of the ice waters to Adrienne and me providing the Perrier and glass of ice to Sasha. But rather than sit back down beside Summer, I dropped into the other armchair, took a sip of my juice, and then reclined against the backrest.

“I’m tired,” I repeated, “of doing the same thing over and over again. Ben’s right: our relationship went to shit since this same time last year. Part of me wishes we could just go back to the way things were. The other part of me realizes we really aren’t compatible as a romantic couple, and it’s better for me to at least figure that out now and move on with my life rather than continue to pine away for a dream that’ll never become reality.”

“The only one stopping your dream from becoming reality is you right now,” Adrienne stated wearily. “Summer and I both agree: Option One. You two belong together.”

“No we don’t, for all the reasons you’ve already listed out,” I disagreed. “I thought you’d be happy, actually. My absence clears the deck for you to take the crown, Miss Queen Bee.”

Adrienne shook her head. “You think I want to be Ben’s Plan B?”

I sighed. “You’re never gonna stop holding that against him, are you? For making you feel… even for a moment… like you were second-best to me? He explained that the letter order was all about probability, not preference, and had more to do with your public declarations of your homo-romantic nature than anything else. And yet you’ll never be able to forgive him, will you?”

“No… no… it’s not that,” she muttered before wincing. “I mean yes, I thought that for a moment. Just a flash. You should be familiar with having flashes. But I do know Ben loves me and doesn’t think of me as second-best at anything. Like I said: he wants all three of us. And that’s exactly why I’m here: to get you to come home.”

I shook my head. “Not happening. If there’s one thing I’ve realized during this conversation, it’s that this really SHOULD be a breakup and not just ‘taking a break’. I don’t deserve him.”

“BZZT!” Summer mimed thumbing a remote control, and I was glad I’d moved far enough away that she couldn’t pinch my leg. She shook her head and sighed, muttering, “In all seriousness, you really do need to stop claiming you don’t deserve him. None of us is perfect: none. Not even Ben. We are each perfectly imperfect, and that’s okay. I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again: we are NOT a pie chart cut into four perfectly even parts at ninety-degree angles. We each play a role in Ben’s life as well as in each other’s lives. We cover for each other’s weaknesses. We support each other with our strengths. And you know what I say to your feeble attempt to break up not only with Ben, but also break up with US? I say ‘No, we’re not letting you break up with us.’ Period.”

“Glue girl is right,” Adrienne stated emphatically. “We’re not letting you break up with us. At the very least, it’s a fucked-up move to break Ben’s heart and then put the onus on us to pick up the pieces.”

“Ignore Miss Meanie, here. The point is: you belong with the harem,” Sasha added with a warm, inviting smile. “You belong with Ben.”

“I get that you’re feeling pretty shitty right now,” Adrienne continued with an expression of genuine sympathy. “I’ve been there, believe me. I’ve doubted myself - considered myself unworthy of being truly loved. I shudder to think of where I might’ve ended up had I not fallen in with Ben and his family. I look at what happened to Elyse and it all hits a little too close to home. It makes me think, ‘That could’ve happened to me.’ But it didn’t because I had a family that quite literally wouldn’t LET me go. Just like we’re not letting you go.”

“To what end?” I asked. “This whole year is proof positive that Ben and I don’t function well together.”

Adrienne shook her head. “This whole year is proof positive that you REALLY need to talk to a therapist, so here’s what I’m gonna do. I’m going to either schedule you for weekend appointments with Iris or get referrals for professionals down here you can visit during the week. Then I’m gonna mercilessly hound you and pester you into actually attending these scheduled appointments until you realize it’s easier to just cave in and attend rather than put up with my nagging. And don’t think I won’t follow through with this kind of threat.”

“Oh, she’ll do it,” Sasha chimed in with a grin.

“I certainly will.” Adrienne’s smile was all teeth. “I don’t have a nine-to-five job. I’ve got a personal assistant right there I can instruct to call you every hour on the hour nagging you to go. You start avoiding our calls, there’s nothing stopping us from driving down here and pestering you at home. I’ll drive over to Apple, walk up to the front desk, and say, ‘I’m Adrienne-fucking-Dennis and you WILL excuse my friend for the next hour so I can escort her to her therapist’s office. I’ll bet your boss is some nice middle-aged man who will try very hard to be polite, respectful, and NOT ogle my big tits spilling out the top of my low-cut V-neck and will agree to anything I say just so he can stop sweating and run away.”

I laughed at the imagery before replying, “My boss is a sharp-as-a-tack woman in her early-30s and a hundred percent straight. She’s never tried to check me out even once.”

“Fair enough, but my point stands. Your mental health directly impacts My Tiger’s mental health. Believe me, I WILL do whatever it takes to get you to go.”

“I believe you,” I replied with a rueful grin. “It takes dedication to forge the kind of career you’ve had. And while you and I may not have always seen eye-to-eye, I’ve always respected your tenacity and drive to do whatever it takes to succeed.”

“Thank you for that. But at the same time, flattering me isn’t gonna get you off the hook. I’m serious. Therapy. Like… yesterday.”

I sighed and shook my head. “I don’t really have the--”

“Donnn’t give me any bullshit about not having time,” Adrienne cut me off. “Make the time, for HIS sake. Or I’ll make the time for you. Stop. Running. Away. Woman up, put your money where your mouth is and stop saying, ‘Yeah, yeah, I can’t do this on my own’ thirty seconds before walking away and trying to deal with this shit on your own.”

“I just don’t see how a total stranger is somehow gonna solve my problems for me.”

“Therapists don’t solve their patients’ problems,” Adrienne stated seriously. “They help you find your own solutions.”

“And WE’RE here to help you find your own solutions,” Summer added. “Not trying to say we’re trained professionals, but A.D. and I have been through a LOT of therapy ourselves. You’re running away from us right now as well. Come home. Talk to US. We came down here trying to get you to help us fix Ben, but maybe we were actually meant to rescue you.”

“Ben needs you,” Adrienne intoned softly, much more softly than she had spoken at any time since her arrival. “I value Ben’s ultimate happiness more than anything in the universe. More than my happiness. More than YOUR happiness.”

“Well that I can believe,” I drawled with a sigh.

“He really is miserable without you. You’re his soulmate. Always was. Always will be. Yeah, you’re a little broken right now, but we all know Ben loves broken girls, don’t we?” Adrienne gestured around at all of us. “So we’re gonna fix you up. We’re gonna sort out whatever demons you’re still dealing with - especially the ones you’re trying to hide even from yourself - and we’re gonna get through them. You think you don’t deserve to be Ben’s wife? Fine. We’re gonna work on that stuff too until you DO feel like you deserve the crown.”

“I don’t want the crown.”

“Bullshit. You specifically called for this break because you were his ‘wife in spirit’ but couldn’t help wanting the crown.” Adrienne shook her head. “You’re getting the crown, Dawnie. And just so we’re clear: I’m ‘telling’ you this is happening, not ‘asking’. I’m not ALLOWING you to break his heart. For Ben’s happiness, so help me I will knock you upside your pretty little head with a club, drag you into his fucking cave, and handcuff you to an altar if that’s what it takes to get you to marry him! For Ben. I’ll do ANYTHING I have to for the man I love more than any other human being in the world.”

I narrowed my eyes at her. “Do you really mean that?”

“With every fiber of my being.”

I nodded slowly and gestured straight at Adrienne with both hands. “And that’s exactly why YOU should be his wife.”

****

“So that’s it? Break’s over? You’re rejoining The Quad? Simple as that?” Emma asked from the driver’s seat of her Camry. We were on the freeway, halfway back to Berkeley after the workweek, and I’d just finished telling her about the girls coming to my house and refusing to let me break up with them.

“I wouldn’t call anything about this situation ‘simple’.” I felt a bit of a headache and rubbed my right temple. It’d been a long, LONG day, and I was thoroughly exhausted. “But basically, yes. As far as I know I’m back in The Quad, assuming Ben will take me, of course.”

“‘Of course’ is correct. Of course.” Emma chuckled. “Have you finally figured out that Ben will always forgive you for anything?”

“Forgive yes. Forget? Maybe not. There’s no magic cure-all, and we’ve still got a lot of stuff to sort out. Ughhh…” My headache pinched, and I had to clench my eyes shut and rub both temples now.

“You alright?”

“Just been a really long, emotionally taxing day. Ugh!” I bowed my head forward and planted both palms over my face, rubbing them in circles over my eyes. “Actually, maybe this isn’t a simple headache. Maybe… Ben?”

Emma glanced at me briefly before returning her attention to the road. “What is it?”

Feel The Force. Let it flow through you.

Alec Guinness’s deep voice echoed in my mind as I closed both eyes and stretched out with my senses. I didn’t get the feeling that Ben was in any trouble or any danger. And yet I couldn’t help but feel a wall of… pain. Anguish. I knew something was wrong, and despite my throbbing migraine headache, I fiddled with my purse to fish out my phone. And within seconds I had typed out: Everything alright?

[I HATE YOU]

A lightning bolt of agony slammed into my brain, hard enough and fast enough to completely overwhelm me. Blinding white stars flashed over my vision even though my eyes were closed.

Followed by darkness.

And then I blacked out.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For anyone who can’t wait, VIP tier has an 7-chapter lead: https://www.patreon.com/posts/68579834

Remember that all authors thrive on feedback, so let me know how you're enjoying the story! Leave a comment here or come chat with us on Discord! And be sure to connect your Discord account here on the Patreon website to get access to the Patron-Only channels! https://discord.gg/fg3m6MdfN9

Comments

No comments found for this post.