Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm posting another of Daksian's Drive-By Reviews to help tide you all over until Chapter 96 drops. For this and other DBRs, check them out on Discord!

https://discord.com/channels/807281178456490014/858585795551690762

----

You have selected Option Two.

If you wish for Ben to marry Adrienne, please use your keypad to enter ‘Tigress’, followed by the hash key.

If you wish for Ben to marry Summer, please use your keypad to enter ‘Sunshine’, followed by the hash key.

If you wish for Ben to move to Utah and marry all of them, please hang up and read another story. It’s not happening.

**3296**

You have entered an invalid code. Please try aga—*

**—phone disconnected**


‘Invalid code’ my ass—oh hey folks! Sorry, didn’t see you there through the ~~bitter~~ happy tears in my eyes! I know why you’re here, just one moment.

https://tenor.com/view/broken-phone-ron-swanson-parks-and-rec-angry-gif-5145523

There we go! Okay, it’s clearly time to phone in another EPIC Drive-By Review! Oh…wait…

Remember, this is an epic drive-by: I’ve had this percolating in my brain for longer than you and this is the first opportunity I’ve had to sit down and really *think* about it, but these are still my impressions and thoughts. As usual, I speak only for myself even when the text says otherwise. I make no promises of logic, consistency, and I embrace my own hypocrisy. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. 😉

So, after reliving ASL2 from Bora Bora (and even earlier) to now through Dawn’s eyes we finally find out *what happens next* after Ben’s explosion of hatred toward her. Let’s recap, shall we?

> **“I HATE YOU!!!”** I howled, trying to scream so loud she could fucking HEAR me in her car forty miles away.

>

> **“I HATE YOU, BITCH!!!”** I howled again.

>

> “Tiger, Ben, seriously…” Adrienne soothed, trying to calm me down.

<snip>

> Eventually, I found my voice. “Forever and Always mine, my Tigress,” I said with a sigh, reaching out to caress Adrienne’s cheek.

>

> She flinched just a little, understandably unnerved by my recent outburst, and I started to pull my hand away. But then she quickly grabbed my hand and pressed it to her cheek. “Forever and Always, Tiger. I’ll love you for the rest of my life. I am **yours**. One hundred and a million percent _yours_. NOTHING could ever make me leave you.”

>

> “Exactly.” I nodded, my tone mournfully bitter. “Unlike Dawn.”

Right. Good times. :rolling_eyes:

---

So many questions to be answered: Does Ben keep ranting? How many chapters do we have to go through of more Ben and Dawn angst before they resolve their problems? And what’s Adrienne going to do with a broken Ben? Enquiring minds want to know!

Well, it turns out the last question answers the rest. Adrienne, the heroine of the last chapter, continues her good form:

> Taking my hand down from her cheek and then squeezing it between both of hers, Adrienne shook her head. “That’s not true. Dawn **loves** you and will ALWAYS love you. What did she say this morning? That she’s loved you for twenty-five years - her entire life - and has never stopped for even a single day.”

What we’re seeing here is Adrienne following through on what she said she’d do: she’ll do *anything* to ensure Ben’s Happily Ever After, and she’s identified that he needs Dawn for that, and here she is making sure that he knows – that he *remembers* - this fundamental truth about Dawn. And she says the magic words that opens the door to everything else, words which Ben focuses on to immediately:

> I blinked in surprise and frowned. “Wait, did you just say ‘this morning’?”

Yep, she did, Ben. Your newest girlfriend was on a mission – a mission to bring your soulmate back for good…

> But we at least already came to a decision this morning: Dawn’s gonna be your official girlfriend again.”

Making *her* your newest girlfriend. :heart_eyes: :AD: :Dawn:

---

Ben needs some answers though:

> I blinked and furrowed my eyebrows, not yet daring to believe. “Define ‘coming back for good’.”

>

> “‘For good’ for good. Back on the team. Back in The Quad.”

YAY!

Oh, I’m not cheering about Dawn coming back for good (hey, I was already happy about that last chapter). I’m happy about this:

```You may be the only man in your current… uhhh… quaple? Quad? What you call a four-person relationship?”```

- ASL2: Chapter 86: Kung Fu Panda

```According to the authority that is Wikipedia:

A relationship among three people is often called a triad, threesome, or throuple; among four people a quad or foursome. Sometimes all groupings of three or more are called moresomes.

Quad it is.```

- DBR 86: Kung Fu Panda

```We were supposed to be a team, remember - a team of four. But there were just three of us now. What was supposed to be a quad (quaple?) was back to a triple.

Because Dawn was gone.```

-ASL2: Chapter 88: Normal

```Dude, it’s ‘quad’. Wikipedia says so.```

- DBR 88: Normal

Called it. **Literally**.

Peanut Gallery: “Uhhh, Daksian? *Technically* it was *Wikipedia* that called it…”

**DON’T RUIN THIS FOR ME!!!** :sob:

---

Ok, back to less important matters. Where were we? Oh yes, Ben trying to learn exactly how awesome Adrienne was today:

> “How the hell did you pull off THAT?”

>

> “Bottom line: I told her… _we_ told her that we’re not letting her walk away from this relationship or break up with us anymore. She’s gotta stop running away to try and deal with things on her own. We told her that the **one** thing you’ve wanted more than anything else is for her to stay by your side and try to work things out together. I asked Iris for calendar availability on the weekends for the next month or so until Dawn moves back to Berkeley for the school year, and she was willing to set up an 8am appointment tomorrow. It’s a little early in the morning for a Saturday and not even a regular timeslot, but she’s doing me a favor. Summer booked the three of you for a Krav Maga class at 11am. And we pushed back the ‘birthday party’ stuff to Saturday night so the four of us in The Quad can talk tonight.”

Yeah, she was *THAT* awesome. And this isn’t the first time she’s come through for Ben and Dawn:

```I exhaled slowly and nodded. “You’ve already done so much. That alcoholic analogy? The car crash trauma? That’s… that’s stuff she’s never told me before. I didn’t realize that’s how she really felt. Those are _breakthroughs_ in my understanding, and probably hers. You’ve accomplished more with her in the last twenty-four hours than I did in the past three years.”```

- ASL2: Chapter 52: Alcoholic.

```Yes.  YES.  FUCKING YES.  At last...AT LAST: progress.  For ALL of us, Ben and readers alike.  The entire problem has been properly reframed.  It's not resolved, not by any stretch....but dammit we're here.  We know what it is.  I adore Adrienne.```

- Daksian’s Review: Chapter 52, sent to -b.d.- Dec 13, 2021.

So what have we learned today? When things look bad for Ben and Dawn, light up the Tigress Signal, and the Catwalk Crusader will save the day.

---

Something else caught my eye though:

> I asked Iris for calendar availability on the weekends for the next month or so until Dawn moves back to Berkeley for the school year, and she was willing to set up an 8am appointment tomorrow. It’s a little early in the morning for a Saturday and not even a regular timeslot, but she’s doing me a favor.

So…when Iris was interrogating Ben about Dawn, she was operating under the knowledge she’d be seeing Dawn the *very next day*. You might recall that I was a bit peeved how she handled Ben’s therapy session:

```I just want to make an observation about the last scene with Iris: I’m really curious what she was thinking. She’s not a fool, and since she’s aware of Jack’s joke she’s aware Dawn is coming over tonight. And she riles Ben up, both emotionally about Dawn, and sexually. Now, there’s no doubt - absolutely no fucking doubt - that Ben is interpreting her observations through the prism of his anger and not how she meant it – the whole ‘two-faced’ bit comes to mind – but surely as a therapist she would recognise he is agitated. And to add some sexual frustration to his already aggressive mindset?

Seriously Iris, what the absolute fuck were you thinking?```

- DBR 89: Hate.

So…there was clearly *some* level of *intent* here by Iris. But I’m still curious what she was thinking in stoking a possible confrontation where she couldn’t know how the participants would behave.

Yeah, I *still* want to know what the *absolute fuck* Iris was thinking. There are many reasons I want another Dawn POV (I can just imagine the collective groan from many of you), but I seriously would love to see her therapy sessions with Iris.

---

> My eyes widened in surprise. “Dawn’s gonna… You went… I can’t believe…” My mouth flapped and I couldn’t get out any more words than that, basically stunned speechless.

>

> Adrienne grinned. “Quite honestly, I’m still trying to talk her into being your official wife.”

:face_exhaling: If wishing made it so… Sadly, I think Adrienne’s powers only extend so far.

``` When will I ever learn to stop underestimating Adrienne Fucking Dennis?```

- DBR 84: Cards on the Table.

Good point. But I think I have a pretty solid reason to doubt after reading this chapter…

Adrienne gives credit to Summer and Sasha, but modesty aside, the Tiger’s share of credit rightly belongs to her (though Summer was clearly a significant influence as well, and Sasha provided a more balanced view overall). But Ben’s still not convinced, worried that he and Dawn might not be able to fix things between them. But again Adrienne helps put things in perspective for him:

> “But now you’ll at least have the opportunity to try. I know you’ve felt like she abandoned you all week. I know how helpless you felt last night, sitting alone in your room, unable to DO anything to fix the problem. Well you’re gonna get the chance to sit down and work things out together. **I will wake up at the crack of… umm… well I’ll wake up early on Saturday morning** and drag her by the hair to Iris’s office if I need to.

That seems *very* familiar…

```Adrienne is up at the crack of…nevermind…giving Ben his morning BJ```

- DBR 89: Hate

:rofl: AD is channelling **me**. Oh, Adrienne…*Tigress*…you can do *so* much better. :wink:

---

And Adrienne ends up doing just that without actually *meaning* to:

> So then a professional can tell her she’s being an idiom, and _maybe_ she’ll actually listen.”

>

> “Did you just say Dawn’s being an ‘idiom’?”

>

> “Did I what?”

Out of the mouths of babes. :wink:

Be careful Adrienne: if you think BJ had no patience with Ben calling June’s friend Nay-Turr that, imagine what he’ll do if he hears you calling Auntie Dawn that. He’ll probably ask you to explain why you can’t get a baby from a BJ. :rofl:

…is it wrong that I want -b.d.- to write that actual scene now? :smiling_imp:

---

This sets Ben off, and he has a bout of slightly unhinged laughter mixed with tears of relief. And it *is* a relief. Another idiom comes to mind: “tears cleanse the soul,” but I remember reading an addendum to that once: “and create space.” That latter sentiment reminds us by purging the negative feelings we create space for positive ones. And that’s just what Adrienne does for Ben. She holds him while he laughs and weeps until his body, mind and heart settle a bit.

> Once I’d finally calmed, Adrienne and I both sat up straight and I wiped the moisture off my eyes. She gazed at me with infinite compassion, took my hand in hers, and gave it another squeeze.

>

> “I was going to surprise you with the good news when I picked you up after work,” she explained. “But then you called me right after your session with Iris, came into the apartment, and immediately said, ‘I hate Dawn.’ And then your emotions got a _little_ out of hand there for a minute.”

Just a *little*. :laughing:

> “I’m so sorry.” I squeezed my Tigress’s hand. “I scared you there for a second, didn’t I? I’m sorry about that. My anger wasn’t directed at you.”

>

> “Your anger wasn’t really directed at Dawn either, I think.”

>

> “I’m angry at myself,” I sighed. “I’m upset that I’ve been too passive about this whole thing. I let Dawn talk me into taking a break by citing that it was my idea in the first place. I let her deflect away conversations too many times instead of pushing her to communicate with me.”

So, a big sigh of relief from me. I had faith in the fact that Ben didn’t *really* hate Dawn, but he was legitimately upset at her, and at himself.

```It’s said the line between love and hate is very thin indeed, and for the moment, Ben has crossed that line. For the moment.

<snip>

But like any storm, this one too will pass. Ben and Dawn will heal, will recover, and will be together again.```

- DBR 89: Hate.

Called it.

---

And despite all she’s already done, Adrienne pledges to do *more*:

> “You did your best. She told me about the times you followed her rather than let her walk away, reminded her how much you loved her, and that you would wait as long as necessary. As for getting that extra push to force her to communicate…” Adrienne flashed me a megawatt grin. “That’s where **-I-** come in. Trust me, Tiger. **I’ll** get her to talk.”

I believe she will. She is my heroine, after all.

Ben then asks if the reverse is true, if Dawn’s allowed to push Adrienne whenever she doesn’t want to communicate. And Adrienne’s response is pretty impressive:

> Adrienne took a deep breath and regarded me seriously. “I’m gonna make you a promise - a promise I’m asking you to make sure that I keep. I’ve seen how much it hurts you every time Dawn turns turtle and bottles up her thoughts and feelings instead of being honest with you. It’s not that I’m trying to vilify what she’s done, but I want to learn from her example of what NOT to do. So here’s my promise: For the rest of our lives, I WILL communicate with you. **Demand** that I communicate with you. <snip> Dawn told me that Honesty was one of the four core qualities of being in a relationship with you, and admitted it’s something she’s failed at time and again. That won’t be me. Please don’t ever **let** it be me.”

I’m reminded of something I said before:

```Dawn must keep a card with the letters: ‘WWADD’ and then choose to NOT do that.```

- DBR 91: Constant

That was in relation to Dawn not giving into a selfish impulse. Clearly, Adrienne is drafting her own WWDD card. :joy:

---

The scene ends with expression of mutual gratitude and love between Ben and Adrienne, and it should be noted that Adrienne uses ‘Benjamin’ instead of ‘Tiger’ when professing her love. They kiss, and their kissing deepens, but before it can turn to something more, Ben pulls away. It’s not the time.

That – and they – will come later.

They leave the Love Nest and make their way to JKE to pick up June before heading home. Adrienne insists on driving, and Ben doesn’t argue – he’s not in any state to drive.  In fact, he’s so out of it he doesn’t actually notice June is in the car until they’re already home. Instead, his focus during the car ride is inward…on what he wants to say to Dawn.

It starts with ‘Happy Birthday’ and ends with ‘**I do**’, but the in-between is just *fantastic* writing. It’s a stream-of-consciousness of Ben’s honest feelings about and for Dawn, all wrapped up in a love letter.

I only wish Dawn heard them through her Link. Maybe she did. Just another thing to want another Dawn POV for.

Oh shut up Peanut Gallery. You know it’s coming…later. Just like Ben and Adrienne. :sweat_drops:

---

Seriously though, some things really in this bit are really significant. It’s all important stuff – all of it, even stuff we’ve seen before like expressions of love and need for Dawn – but these are what I think are the most important moments:

> I need you to _communicate_ with me, alright? No more running away.

The biggest, and most important expectation Ben has for Dawn. And he’s right to expect this from her. :1000:%

> I should’ve made clearer _before_ you left how much I needed you to stay with me.

>

> But then, maybe I needed you to leave me.

>

> Maybe I needed to lose you again to remind myself how much I want you in my life.

>

> Maybe I needed you to call my bluff about ‘taking a break’.

As painful as it was, they *did* need this. There was *never* going to be a ‘going back to how things were a year ago’. And the truth is, they weren’t *really* happy a year ago. Ben was lying to himself and Dawn was lying to everyone *but* herself about how they felt. They had travelled the road since then *together*, rebuilding the depth of the romantic feelings they had for each other. Only a true Dawnpocalypse or Bentastrophe could undo that, and this break wasn’t that.

Their separation hurt them both, but it was a lesson learned, not a fatal mistake.

---

> I want you to be mine.

>

> I’m a hypocrite that wants to claim you for my own.

The word ‘hypocrite’ gets bandied about like it’s a massive sin of personality. Clearly this is something Ben believes. But *everyone* is a hypocrite about *something*. It’s really fucking unlikely for a person to be perfectly fair in mind and deed. There’s a reason politics and religion are banned in this forum because discussions about them turn into ‘whataboutism’, and the truth is we all set expectations on others that we ourselves often fall short on. Hypocrisy is part of the human *condition*

And while it’s not something to be championed, hypocrisy is only a problem if the one upon whom you’ve set expectations you yourself can’t meet is unhappy about it. And Dawn *isn’t*:

> You spent months trying to tell me you WANTED me to claim you as my own, to accept your Oath of Ben-ogamy and say, ‘You’re MY fish, and ain’t no other man fucking MY fish.’

>

> I heard your words, but I wasn’t really _listening_.

And THAT is Ben’s sin: when Dawn actually *was* trying to talk, Ben wasn’t listening, he was imposing his own standards upon her, his own biases, rather than truly accept her setting her own standards, even if they aligned with his own desires that he thought was selfish or unfair.

> I tried to be the better man, tried to be ‘Perfect Ben’.

I was blown away by this statement from Chapter 89, and I still am. It’s an *incredible* revelation. And it really gives perspective to the greatest challenge to Ben and Dawn’s love.

> The truth is: I’m jealous of you.

>

> You’re **my** cow.

>

> And I don’t ever want you to become someone else’s cow.

>

> Just mine.

This is important. Ben is abandoning the failed ‘fair is fair’ doctrine, *embracing* his hypocrisy on this issue…just as Dawn *wants* him to.

---

> Will you please marry me?

>

> Well, I want to marry Adrienne too.

>

> And Summer.

Considering what comes later, I have to admit this bit messes with my head a little bit. He wants to marry them *all*; little wonder he’s a bit sarcastic when they do their little ‘hot potato’ act. But more than that…well, I’ll get to it later.

> Fuck, why is the legal system set up so that I can’t marry all three of you?

Well, there wouldn’t be much dramatic tension in the plot of ASL2 if you could. But again, if wishing made it so…

> One problem at a time: Please stay with me. Married or not, _please_ stay with me.

>

> Don’t ever leave me again.

>

> I won’t _let_ you ever leave me again.

Please for the love of all that is holy and unholy YES. I cannot overstate how much I want this issue to be **done** and **over with**. I’m genuinely **sick** of it. I don’t even want it *tested*, where Dawn leaves again and Ben goes after her and they resolve whatever sends her running. And I don’t want to see a role reversal either, where Ben runs from Dawn instead.

> For the rest of our lives.

>

> Forever and Always.

>

> For all eternity.

>

> **I do.**

Marriage vows. Whether or not Dawn hears all of this through their Link, the message is loud and clear: legal or not, Ben is pledging himself as Dawn’s husband. Frankly, I think that’s a more important mindset to be in than thinking of Dawn as his wife.

Or cow. :cow:

---

Ben comes out of these deep thoughts about halfway home, and again he needs to let Adrienne know how grateful he is:

> “Thank you, Adrienne,” I said quietly.

>

> “Hmm, Tiger?” She glanced over at me from the driver’s seat before returning her attention to the road. We were on the Bay Bridge already, halfway home. I hadn’t even noticed when we’d picked up June, now sitting in the back seat.

>

> I gave her a wan smile, and held it until she glanced over at me again and smiled back. “Thank you,” I repeated. “Thank you for bringing her back to me.”

>

> “Of course, Tiger. I got your back.”

>

> _Just keep being awesome, Adrienne._

>

> Agreed.

Agreed. :1000: :AD:

---

Emma and Dawn arrived at the Nest 10 minutes before Ben, Adrienne and June, but when Ben hurriedly enters Dawn’s not in the living room with everyone else. Emma explains that she’d gone upstairs to lie down after having an intense headache and even blacking out for a moment ~~from psychic feedback~~. Ben rushes upstairs and finds her in her bedroom, with Summer there watching over her.

> Apparently asleep, Dawn was beautiful in repose, looking peaceful and serene. She lay flat on her back atop the covers, her hands crossed atop her chest like Sleeping Beauty. That notion put an idea in my head, and I sat down on the side of the bed, slowly bent forward, and gave her a gentle kiss.

>

> My touch was featherlight, and I pulled back after only a moment, just like in the movie. My Dawn’s eyelids parted open and then flapped like butterfly wings, up and down and then up and down, repeating several times. Recognition… well… _dawned_ on her… and she gave me a tranquil smile that slowly warmed with each passing second.

Ok, that is *absolutely beautiful*. I mean, I *know* it’s a description of the scene from the movie, but it’s @BlueDragonAuthor#1353 ‘s description, and it’s…well, it’s **perfect**. You can’t read a moment like that and think ‘this is just a sex story’.

Well, I suppose you *can*, but if so it’s kinda weird that you’re fapping to it. :rolling_eyes:

---

With Dawn awake, Ben kisses her again, this time more deeply, and she kisses him back.

> There had been very few words between us since my arrival. We hadn’t seen each other face-to-face in almost a week, and I was still less than an hour removed from spewing emotional fireballs of vicious hate in her general direction while screaming at the top of my lungs.

>

> But none of that mattered right now.

>

> Right now, the only thing that mattered was that I had my Dawn back in my arms.

>

> My Dawn.

>

> **My** Dawn.

As I had said before, there’s a thin line between love and hate, and Ben only stepped over that line for a moment. It was a moment of catharsis. And this is a moment of realisation: Dawn is **his**, and that’s *okay*. It’s better than okay, actually, it’s **right**.

> Because Adrienne had brought her back to me.

>

> _Thank you,_ I mentally whispered back to my Tigress, and in my heart of hearts I felt like she could hear me.

I feel that way too. Yay Link! :smiling_face_with_3_hearts:

---

Speaking of…

> I stared down at My Dawn with a smile of contentment. There were no words between us. None were needed. Not yet. We’d have to talk, of course. Two people don’t simply go from being ‘broken up’ to ‘back together’ without _some_ discussion of the matter. So we would take the time to talk.

>

> Later.

>

> To be perfectly honest, I felt like I’d already said most of what I needed to say to her in the car. Between my therapy session with Iris and my explosion of hate with Adrienne, **I’d already word-vomited up a metric ton** of emotional angst tonight, and I really didn’t want to _talk_ anymore.

I know what you mean Ben. I get that feeling *all* the time. Back me up here @Benjamin Davidson#2027 :wink:

> And apparently Dawn didn’t feel the need to talk either, because she started to strip herself naked just then.

>

> Well, she did _sorta_ talk.

>

> _I haven’t felt your big dick deep inside me since camp, and we need to fix that ASAP,_ her voice silently spoke straight into my mind.

>

> Good talk.

Ok, **NOW** it’s a sex story. Fap away. :smiling_imp:

---

We get a nice description of what Dawn is wearing (for the moment), but it’s really to illustrate just how out of it she was when she and Emma got home:

> Spray paint-tight jeans hugged her legs, and also told me just how wiped out she must’ve been to have come right upstairs and take a nap. Dawn would typically be fussy about “outside” clothing she’d worn to work contaminating clean bedsheets, so perhaps that explained why she’d laid down atop the comforter.

Oh. My. Gawd. I bet she didn’t even *wash her hands*. The horror! :scream:

> Meanwhile, I was unbuttoning my own shirt, although I fumbled with the last two buttons, distracted as I was when Dawn slipped the hooks on her bra and bared her beautiful breasts to my hungry gaze.

>

> _You’ve seen these puppies naked a million times by now,_ she said without saying, a sparkle in her sky-blue eyes.

>

> ‘And I’m delighted to see them a million and one.’

You know how things always sound better in your head before you say them, or you think of better ways to say something after you’ve said them? I have *never in my life* been as smooth in my own head as Ben was right there. Well, he *is* a Sex God and they say the brain is the most important sex organ of all… :rofl:

---

As things continue to get more passionate (and more naked), Summer quietly gets up to leave.

> I arched an eyebrow at her with a look that silently said, ‘You’re welcome to join us.’

>

> I’m not about to claim that Summer and I had developed any mystical link or anything; not in such a short period of time, at least. But she seemed to get my drift and shook her head, replying aloud, “This moment is for the two of you. I’ll see you guys later.”

>

> Dawn beamed at her BFF, saying, “Thanks, Sunshine.”

Well Ben, *you* might not think so, but I’m happy to state here definitively: Yay Link!

With her mind full of images of Sleeping Beauty to gush happily to the other girls downstairs, Summer blows Ben and Dawn kisses before she leaves the room. Dawn, meanwhile, just wants to blow:

> My soulmate lover slid down to the floor and squatted before me, unzipping my slacks and then dragging my pants down to my ankles. My big dick sprung out right in her face, and only a second later she crammed half of it into her mouth.

>

> ‘So glad you’re back,’ I told her silently, gazing down at her beautiful face and caressing her cheek.

>

> _I never should’ve left,_ she replied with a mouthful of meat, a twinkle in her eyes. _And I’ll **never** leave again._

I’m holding you to that, -b.d.-. **Never** again.

---

So, in this sex story we once again get just the beginning and the end of the sex scene – which is why this is predominantly *men’s* erotica, let’s be honest. Yeah, I went there. Unlike most men though, Ben the Sex God is able to hold his orgasm at bay, and he does so for a very good reason:

> But it just felt so damn _good_ to be inside my girlfriend’s pussy that I didn’t want it to end.

>

> My girlfriend.

>

> Officially.

>

> _Finally._

>

> And I wanted to make *my girlfriend* cum ONE more time.

I don’t think there’s enough emphasis on the word ‘finally’.

***FINALLY***.

Yes, that’s better. NOW Dawn can cum.

> Grunting and groaning, my girlfriend came _again_. Her inner walls spasmed around my shaft, milking me for my steaming spunk. Her sky-blue eyes glittered as she gazed up at me with infinite adoration, recognizing the strain on my face. I still didn’t want our fun to end, but she clutched my shoulders and crooned into my ear, “Cum, babe, cum…”

And *that*, gentlemen, is why it’s great to learn control. For that moment when she croons in your ear. It’s fucking HOT.

> So I slammed forward one final time and came, grunting my orgasm into my girlfriend’s ear as a quart of spunk flowed out of me and into her sucking pussy. She clutched my heavy body with all four limbs, embracing me with her entire being as my liquid love filled her to the brim. And I twitched and shuddered and sighed and muttered as wave after wave of semen flooded her womb to overflowing.

‘Twitched and shuddered and sighed and muttered’? It’s like -b.d.- has abandoned alliteration in favour of Dr. Seuss. I may never read ‘Green Eggs and Ham’ the same way again! :zany_face:

---

> What felt like hours later, Dawn hummed and patted my shoulder. “That was a good one, babe.”

No kidding. After what Adrienne said this morning, it’s pretty clear Ben was seriously backed up. I’m surprised it didn’t start shooting from Dawn’s nose.

Anyway, in the aftermath, Ben and Dawn have a bit of a talk:

> I felt her turn to look at me, a soft smile on her face. “I love you,” she intoned quietly, sincerely.

>

> I smiled and made my dick twitch inside her again. “I love you, too.”

>

> “Wholeheartedly. No more hiding from the truth,” she stated quietly. “I love you. I want to be your girlfriend again. I’ve _always_ wanted to be your girlfriend again, but I’ve been terrified - and continue to be terrified - of screwing it up again. I’m sorry.”

The best part of this? The *honesty*. Every word here is *true*.

> “That’s okay. Your heart has always been in the right place, and that’s enough for me. I love you, I’ll always love you, I’ll _happily_ be your boyfriend again, and I can’t believe it took so long for us to finally get back here again after what… four years?”

>

> Dawn sighed. “Four of the hardest years of my life.”

Pfft. Four years. That’s *nothing*. For some fans (thankfully not me, ignorance was bliss), it’s been 11 years, 2 months and 6 days. There’s a reason Dawn fans are called ‘Dawniacs’; ~~we’ve~~ they’ve been driven out of their minds with antici—

*Say it -b.d., say it!*

—pation. :wink:

(If you didn’t get the reference, I genuinely feel bad for you)

---

Dawn blames herself for the long wait, but Ben is rightly having none of it:

> “Can we NOT get into an argument about which of us is more at fault for what happened?” I chuckled and pecked her nose. “The past is past. Let’s move forward, alright? Be honest with me. Tell me the truth about how you feel. Have faith in **ME** that I’ll do whatever it takes for us to work things out and keep us together. Please?”

This. A thousand times THIS. :This:

> She gave me a tentative smile. “I’m not perfect.”

No kidding. Perhaps the biggest understatement in the entirety of OSL. :rolling_eyes:

> “So I can’t promise with a hundred percent certainty that I won’t screw something up again or find myself hiding something I shouldn’t try to hide. But I CAN promise that I’m going to try.”

>

> “That’s all I ever wanted from you. Let’s try… together.”

>

> “Together,” she repeated with a smile. “As a team. A quad. Ben and his _three_ committed girlfriends.”

>

> I grinned. “That’s my Happily Ever After right there, more or less just like we talked about when we put our cards on the table at camp. We had a little speed bump for a week coming off the end of it, but I’m glad the four of us seem to be on the same page again.”

Yes. Yes *please*. I for one would love to get off the roller coaster and ride the Ferris wheel instead. It has it’s ups and downs too, and also stays in the same place, but you get time to enjoy the view and not so much of the sensation of your heart in your throat.

> Dawn took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. “Not _quite_…”

>

> I frowned, not understanding. “Not quite?”

>

> Dawn nodded. “The four of us need to talk.”

Gawddammit Dawn. Ok, one more ride on the roller coaster, but that’s *it* young lady.

> “Rrrggghhh,” I groaned, rubbing my forehead.

>

> _Haha. I’m imagining BJ rubbing his forehead just like you right now._

>

> Dude, shut UP.

Seriously. I’m sure BJ is going to have his own roller coaster rides. :wink:

---

After having a quick shower and shower sex, Ben and Dawn head downstairs to join the others. Emma notes that Dawn is looking healthier, which reminds Ben that Dawn had a headache. Emma and Dawn briefly describe the end of Chapter 94, and Adrienne is the first to put it together:

> “I was fine, I was fine,” Dawn insisted, giving me a reassuring look in response to my concerned expression. “I did black out for a second, but then when I came to, it was all over. I felt fine.”

>

> “Around what time was this?” Adrienne asked curiously.

>

> “Time? Uhhh…” Dawn fished into her pocket with her other hand and pulled out her phone. “It was right after I texted Ben to ask if everything was alright. So… 5:18.”

>

> Adrienne glanced back at me. “Seems like she COULD hear you howling, ‘I hate you, bitch!’ Not that I’m actually surprised.”

Uh, yay Link? :grimacing:

Well, Ben wanted greater honesty in his relationship with Dawn. No time like the pres—

> I sighed and rubbed my forehead. “The absolute LAST thing I want to do right now is talk about this. Hey, little man…”

—ent. That’s a deflection that would do Dawn proud. :rolling_eyes:

> “Rrrggghhh,” BJ groaned, rubbing his forehead to mime me.

>

> _Hahahaha!_

LOL. The words your looking for, Inner Voice, are ‘*Called it.*’. :wink:

---

Anyway, Dawn’s not happy with getting a dose of her own medicine and asks about the ‘I hate you, bitch’ line (which, I have to say, is not NEARLY as dramatic as it is in CAPS), but Ben begs off, promising to talk about it later, and Summer backs him up by pointing out that it’s dinner time.

> I sat at the head of the dining table looking around at nine of the closest people in the world to me. Clockwise starting at my left were BJ, Kim, June, Sasha, Adrienne, Eden, Emma, Summer, and Dawn.

Yes folks, it’s another episode of seating arrangement analysis!

Ten people, with Ben at the head. Adrienne being at the other end…well, no need to analyse *that*. BJ to Ben’s left and Kim on the other side makes sense, as does June on the other side of Kim. And Sasha at Adrienne’s right hand, where her BFF should be. To Ben’s right we have Dawn, and on her right side is her own BFF.

Nothing there is surprising, and symbolically it all makes perfect sense. It’s the placement of the twins that is a little surprising. It’s probably nothing (like seriously, I really doubt it), but I suppose it’s possible that Eden’s placed where she is because she’s similar to Adrienne in that the only man she will ever be romantically interested in is Ben. As for Emma…well, I suppose that’s as close as the next baby mama *can* be without being too obvious… :wink:

---

Ben also thinks of those who aren’t there: the extended Family in Bert, Lynne and ~~Celine~~ their unborn child, Brandi and Dayna, Brooke and DJ, his parents, the Evanses. The might-have-beens and the conquests: Penny and Mila from work, Professor Ice, Paige, Kady, Noelle, Amber, Peyton, Moon, Rania and the Tri-Delts. High school sweethearts Megan, Cassidy, Allie, Candy and Heather also get a mention.

Poor Andie. :sob:

That’s the problem with listing names -b.d.-: someone’s always fails to make the cut. She just gets lumped in as another Tri-Delt. :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

And some can no longer be there: Elyse. Cameron. Yvaine.

> Dawn reached across the table and squeezed my right hand. There was moisture in her eyes, and as she looked at me, I could tell she was thinking of Yvaine in that moment as well.

In terms of seating arrangements, Dawn is right where she and Ben need her to be.

But in thinking of Yvaine in particular, the question is, who will be next? :grimacing: :cry:

Ben’s thoughts go in a similar direction to mine:

> I remembered my own words as I’d toasted my extended family after Commencement, about how life was precious and that we could never know whether or not we’d ever all be together around this table again. Yvaine had been there for that gathering, and her absence now proved my statement’s truth.

Translation: no time like the present. It’s time to talk.

---

Ben is exhausted. He’s been talking all day in some form or another, but this cannot be delayed. Even so…

> I was SICK TO DEATH of these endless conversations, and part of me wanted to cry out, ‘Just put me out of my misery already!’.

‘Just put me out of my misery already!’ A more apt chapter title than ‘Option Two’, to be sure. Especially for anti-ADers (and more than a few Dawn fans).

I’m sure some people will be feasting on tears in Discord, first on beta, then on VIP, then Patron. It’s the gift that’ll keep on giving. :wink:

Not mine though. -b.d.- already got mine. :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

Ben debates the notion of having a talk with his Inner Voice, who makes a very salient point:

> _You know the “status quo” of having three girlfriends who all deep-down want to be your wife will NEVER remain status quo so long as you remain unmarried. The agreement for none of them to chase the crown is utter bullshit. Look at what happened to Dawn. And yes, she’s back now and agreeing to be your girlfriend again. But you know she still thinks of you as her husband in spirit and will ALWAYS want the crown._

>

> I know.

>

> _Adrienne wants the crown too, you know._

>

> I know.

>

> _And Summer would love to be your lawfully wedded wife as well._

>

> I know.

Honestly, I can easily imagine this conversation in -b.d.-‘s head reading the comments from the shippers for each girl on Discord.

@Daksian#5143 *says he’s okay with anyone but you know he really wants Dawn as wife.* I know.”

@Berithon#4060 *says he’s okay with anyone as long as it makes sense and isn’t Dawn but he really wants Adrienne as wife.* I know.”

@Thaddius1000#9540 *says he’s he really wants Summer, but will accept AD, but won’t accept Dawn.* I know.”

C’mon -b.d.-, put us out of our misery already…

---

> “But you can’t marry all of us, not legally at least,” Dawn stated aloud.

>

> “I know,” I sighed and then looked up and out across the horizon.

The scene shifts – quite literally – to the plaza at Lawrence Hall of Science. On my first and second read-through of this I kept missing the fact that Ben establishes he and his Nestmates went there after dinner, and I kept thinking this looked like another coma dream.

Reading comprehension for the win. :rofl:

Anyway, the Quad are all seated around a fountain in the plaza, in a serene environment with a bit of needed privacy. Ben’s facing the city, not the girls, and thinking deeply about what he wants to say, but also avoiding the choice he has to make.

> It was as if me turning around and facing any one of the girls would be like choosing one of them over the others, and I couldn’t bring myself to do that. I wanted to keep all of them in my life. I wished I could marry all three of them and tie them to me Forever and Always, For All Eternity, ‘Til Death Do Us Part (and even that parting might only be temporary, if my dreams of Yvaine could be believed).

Aww, that last bit is a nice touch. :wink: :smiling_face_with_3_hearts:

> I had a love for the other girls in my life as well, but everyone knew these three were my endgame.

>

> “Well, the two of _them_ are your endgame,” Summer stated seriously.

Ok, that’s twice now. Ben didn’t say a word and he’s not facing them. He might have dismissed the moment in Dawn’s bedroom earlier, but I’m calling it here:

YAY LINK!!! :SummerRedhead: :partying_face:

---

Sorry Summer, I was geeking out. You were saying?

> “As long as I can feel safe and reassured that there’s a place for me in all your lives, I don’t need the so-called ‘crown’. Dawn’s been your soulmate since the beginning of time, and Adrienne’s your Tigress Forever and Always. I’m just the glue girl. If we’re seriously going to have a discussion about which one of us is gonna marry him any time within the next three years, the finalists are down to two.”

Will someone *please* tell Summer she’s actually the Best Girl?

> Still facing away from them, I picked my head up and sighed. “First of all, you’re not ‘just’ the glue girl. You’re my Sunshine. With all the emotional hoops these two have been putting me through, you’ve been the brightest light in my life.”

>

> Summer blushed and gave me one of those radiant smiles that always gave me joy.

Even better. Thank you, Ben.

> “Second of all,” I continued, “this isn’t _The Bachelor_. I’m not handing out roses and there aren’t any finalists. This is real life, and the simple fact that there’s _any_ ambiguity about the identity of my potential bride is reason in and of itself of why I **shouldn’t** be getting married anytime soon.”

>

> _*Is* it so ambiguous? Or was what you told Iris this afternoon a lie?_

>

> It wasn’t a lie, but now’s not the time.

Wait, WHAT?!? :exploding_head:

---

Okay, if you’re reading this chapter review, you know how this chapter ends. (If you don’t, WTF…read the chapter first!)

With Ben’s words to Summer about the emotional hoops in dealing with Dawn and Adrienne and Summer herself being the brightest light, coupled with his Inner Voice’s comment, honestly made me think “Wait, does that mean Ben’s chosen Summer?” But it doesn’t end up being that way, does it?

I’ve gone over this very, *very* carefully, because it confused the hell out of me. And I realise that Ben’s statement to the girls is misleading:

> This is real life, and the simple fact that there’s _any_ ambiguity about the identity of my potential bride is reason in and of itself of why I **shouldn’t** be getting married anytime soon.”

As another Ben might say: “what I said was true, from a certain point of view.”

Specifically, Ben’s pointing out that any ambiguity in this means that he shouldn’t be getting married anytime soon, and it implies that there still IS ambiguity…but in point of fact, to Ben there *isn’t*.

So it’s clever. But seriously Ben, it’s kind of a dick move. And not kind the girls enjoy.

---

What follows is a long discussion, and for the most part, until he stands up at the start of the next scene, Ben’s contribution is primarily to mock the girls and their ‘hot potato routine’ (‘You take him.’ ‘No, you take him!’ etc.). And I’m seriously tempted to follow Ben’s example, since their arguments do fundamentally end up there. But my name is Daksian and I have a problem with rabbit holes so, yeah…I’m just gonna dive in. :zany_face:

The one thing the girls seem to be in agreement is that a decision on who Ben chooses to legally marry must be made as soon as possible, if for no other reason than to end the torment, especially to Dawn. Dawn herself also points out that it’s not just tormenting her, it’s tormenting Ben:

> A minute ago, you had that look on your face pleading ‘Just put me out of my misery already!’”

>

> _She’s right._

She IS right. The problem is *who*?

Adrienne and Summer think it should be Dawn. Dawn thinks it should be Adrienne, or Summer if Adrienne opts out (Adrienne reciprocates, saying it should be Summer if Dawn opts out).

> “Annnd we’re back to hot potato,” I muttered, finally picking up my feet and turning around. Miming one at a time at all three of them, I mocked, “‘You take him.’ ‘No, you take him!’ ‘No, YOU take him!’”

He’s not wrong.

I’m gonna do this out of order, because while the conversation flows naturally throughout the scene, it’s all over the place in forming coherent arguments as the girls bicker back and forth. In many ways, these arguments have already been made in prior chapters in some form or another, but it’s useful to have them all set forth here and now.

---

**SUMMER AS THE LEGAL WIFE/OPTION TWO (S)**

To be honest, the strongest argument for Summer as the wife was made by Ben himself:

> You’re my Sunshine. With all the emotional hoops these two have been putting me through, you’ve been the brightest light in my life.”

It really is saying something when the girl who recently lost her mother, who’s a diagnosed with a mental condition, who’s happiest when she’s trussed up and subjected to pain…she’s the one who *isn’t* putting Ben through emotional hoops. Yeah, let THAT sink in for a moment.

Summer is also the clear Plan B of each of the other two women. As Dawn says:

> But if [Adrienne] genuinely can’t handle it, I would welcome Summer as his titled wife.”

And Adrienne concurs:

> “I agree,” Adrienne stated firmly and then turned her attention to Summer instead. “I think you’d make an _excellent_ wife.”

And when Summer acknowledges her bond with Ben is strong and has potential if not for Dawn and Adrienne, Adrienne presses the matter further:

> I’m devoted and he’s affectionate, and if it weren’t for the two of you or the half-dozen other girls in his life, I’d like to think he and I could build the kind of lifelong relationship together that millions of people around the world create every day.”

>

> “You could,” Adrienne stated confidently. “You really could, and I think you deserve that chance.”

What *isn’t* said but is definitely a factor is the fact that as wife, Summer is no threat to either Dawn or Adrienne and their place in Ben’s life. Her accommodating nature actually *precludes* that risk. It doesn’t mean Ben will regard or love Summer any *less* than he does Dawn or Adrienne, but she definitely won’t eclipse them in his heart. And more to the point, Summer will work hard as ‘glue girl’ to keep the Quad together and happy, and as wife she’d have a higher ‘authority’ in this regard. Indeed, one could argue (and I would) that Summer becoming the wife is what she needs to elevate her to Dawn and Adrienne’s level.

---

**THE ARGUMENT AGAINST SUMMER**

As with each of the women, the biggest detractor of Summer as the wife is Summer herself. And right from the outset, Summer is keen to take herself out of the running:

> “As long as I can feel safe and reassured that there’s a place for me in all your lives, I don’t need the so-called ‘crown’. Dawn’s been your soulmate since the beginning of time, and Adrienne’s your Tigress Forever and Always. I’m just the glue girl. If we’re seriously going to have a discussion about which one of us is gonna marry him any time within the next three years, the finalists are down to two.”

She doubles down on her argument when Dawn and Adrienne both declare her as their Plan B:

> The purple-haired girl blushed but shook her head. “Thank you both for the vote of confidence, but my emotional bond with Ben is still in its infancy. We still haven’t hit our three _month_ anniversary yet. I can’t read his mind or sense his thoughts and moods the way you two can. I’m not familiar enough with his routines, wants, and needs the way you’ve learned by now. I’m devoted and he’s affectionate, and if it weren’t for the two of you or the half-dozen other girls in his life, I’d like to think he and I could build the kind of lifelong relationship together that millions of people around the world create every day.”

<snip>

> “I’m happy being his girlfriend and I’m _thrilled_ that he’s my boyfriend. But if we’re having a serious discussion about one of us marrying Ben sooner than later, I don’t really qualify just yet.

Over and over again, Summer is reiterating that she and her relationship with Ben just doesn’t measure up to the other two women’s relationships. It’s a relevant point, though I’m not keen on the implied devaluation. I’m also not convinced by some of her arguments; while theirs is certainly a far younger relationship, they have shared experiences both good and bad that aren’t shared by the other two (though Adrienne does have a similar dark experience with Adam’s attack). And of course, this very night there’s evidence of *some* kind of deeper, mystical connection.

Nevertheless, I’m left to wonder if her arguments didn’t end up influencing Ben after all, especially if she was who Ben had originally chosen.

---

**DAWN AS THE LEGAL WIFE/OPTION ONE**

Of all of them, Dawn has the strongest NEED of the title, and her taking it really WOULD end the drama, both on a personal AND a meta level. As Adrienne herself says:

> “YOU and Ben get married, solves all our problems, and everybody comes away happy.”

<snip>

> You’re the one he’s wanted his whole life, Dawnie. Your absence is what drove him mad this week.”

<snip>

> Option One is the solution: you can have him. You’ve _always_ wanted to be his wife… so **be his wife**. Marry him. Stop waking up feeling empty. Have the crown on your head so you no longer **have** to claim the crown. Put ALL of us out of our misery already and just MARRY him!”

<snip>

> Of the three of us, I think you’re the only one who actually NEEDS the title. Summer wants a place to belong, and she always will. I’m a celebrity who never **actually** has to get married. It’s perfectly normal to remain unmarried but still have a ‘partner’.

She’s not wrong. Dawn has a desire, a need to be the titled wife that not even Adrienne herself can match. And her being the wife is perfectly acceptable to both Adrienne and Summer, who are happy for her to have it, who even believe that it really *should* be Dawn.

---

Summer agrees:

> Dawn’s his Destiny. Always has been. Always will be.”

And Adrienne again piles on, pointing out if she’s not the wife it may break her again:

> “He’s **your** soulmate,” Adrienne countered. “I believe Summer when she says she’d willingly step aside for you or me, that all she ever wanted was a place to belong. But I’m NOT convinced that you’ll honestly be alright living the rest of your life NOT married to your One True Love. You tried accepting ‘wife in spirit’ for like three days, realized you couldn’t handle it, and tried to break up with him.”

And more to the point, based on Dawn’s history of ‘freaking the fuck out’ when Adrienne and DJ were in ascendency in Ben’s heart, Adrienne’s not certain it wouldn’t cause another Dawnpocalypse if she and Ben got married.

As negative as some of these reasons are, they’re not *wrong*.

Except, it turns out that they ARE wrong.

---

**THE ARGUMENT AGAINST DAWN**

Dawn’s the one who argues against her being the titled wife, and her arguments are far more…~~airti~~ *persuasive* than the arguments against the other girls.

Right off the bat, Dawn states that she’s the *problem*, not the solution:

> “We can’t keep doing this,” Dawn continued. “**-I-** can’t keep doing this.

<snip>

> “We already talked the subject to death this morning with just us girls,” Dawn stated wearily. “There can only be one, and for a million and one reasons it can’t be me.

It’s not *quite* a million and one reasons, but this book alone is over a million words getting to this point, so it’s not *too* much of an exaggeration.

Dawn trots out the same ‘best friends’ argument that she has all throughout ASL2.

> “Best friends. We work better as best friends,” Dawn insisted to me. “Romantic best friends, if I need to qualify that, and official girlfriend again. I know you like to think we go together like Yin and Yang, but we’re fundamentally actually Yin and Yin. We’re too alike.

That’s Dawn’s truth, but I’m gonna say it’s the weakest of her arguments. Being alike is not an actual problem in a working romantic partnership – in fact, the ‘opposites attract’ rule of romance isn’t a *real* rule. Common goals, common interests, common morals…I think there’s often a lot more ‘alike’ in most marriages than not. Dawn qualifies her argument by saying she and Ben are ‘too’ alike, that they’re ‘Yin and Yin’, but the only thing that they’re ‘too’ alike in that is a genuine barrier to marriage is their respective chases of their ‘perfect selves’, and that’s a problem no matter what their relationship is with each other or anyone else. Dawn’s argument here amounts to a *very* subjective opinion. However, the opinion is *Dawn’s*, so it still carries weight. But I think that weight isn’t as heavy as she thinks it is.

---

Her next argument is also a weak argument, in my opinion. In trying to argue for Dawn to be the wife, Adrienne points out that Dawn herself can’t seem to accept any other alternative:

> But I’m NOT convinced that you’ll honestly be alright living the rest of your life NOT married to your One True Love. You tried accepting ‘wife in spirit’ for like three days, realized you couldn’t handle it, and tried to break up with him.”

>

> “I did, and once again you’re proving my point of why I can’t be his wife.” Dawn sighed and sat back. “I don’t deserve him.”

Ah, this old chestnut. You know who gets to decide who *deserves* to be Ben’s wife? **BEN**. And Ben already **has** decided:

> Will you please marry me?

Ben’s own deepest thoughts earlier this evening in the car, when he was raw, vulnerable and exposed, and could be nothing *but* honest about how he felt. That question was directed at Dawn, and he followed it up admitting he wanted to marry Adrienne and Summer too. In Ben’s heart, they are ALL deserving to be his wife.

It’s not Dawn’s call whether or not she deserves Ben. That’s her guilt and shame talking, and those aren’t the things she should be listening to when facing *any* serious decision about her happiness, the same as anyone else.

So yeah, this argument can be dismissed pretty easily. Unfortunately, the next argument cannot be dismissed *at all*.

---

What it boils down to is the simple fact that Dawn isn’t in a place where she is ready to be Mrs. Ben. This isn’t about trying to be ‘Perfect Dawn’, this is about Dawn struggling with her inner ~~Voice~~ demons, a struggle she has been having since high school:

> Dawn sighed. “I’m a work-in-progress, still in the midst of an identity crisis, and in no emotional shape to marry anyone. I’m a neurotic control-freak, really, with a track record of reacting very poorly to situations where I didn’t get my way. Back in high school, I wanted to flirt with Ryan to get the attention of a handsome man but always believe I could claim back my long-distance boyfriend Ben whenever I wanted, but then I freaked the fuck out when Ben told me on the phone that he’d chosen you instead first.”

She’s 100% right here. She genuinely struggles with not controlling her fate, demonstrating here how she struggled when Ben chose Adrienne. She follows it up her example, describing her reaction to Ben and Adrienne in their first year in college and her reaction to Ben and DJ after the Dawnpocalypse:

> “When the two of you came to Cal as a boyfriend/girlfriend couple,” Dawn continued. “I always believed he’d automatically return to me when - not if - you two broke up, and I freaked the fuck out when he gave you the promise ring.”

<snip>

> “And even when I went on my sabbatical to Morris Camp,” Dawn continued, shaking her head, “I always believed Ben would be waiting for me, and we all saw how I reacted when he proposed to DJ instead. It wasn’t pretty.”

Dawn freaks the fuck out. When she is not in control, she is absolutely out-of-control. There is no middle ground. That’s not good. Now imagine her being like that as Mrs. Ben.

Yeah, that’s *even worse*.

---

And Dawn *knows* it:

> “These are the examples of my mistakes, and of the changes I need to make in myself. Even when Ben told me Option Three was the way to go, I refused to let him break up with me, only to make the same decision myself three days later and *tell* him - not ask him - that we were taking a break. I always had to control the outcome.”

I’m *still* laughing at the outrage over Dawn ‘losing her agency’ or whatever it was. That has *never* been a problem for Dawn. As she herself says here, it’s usually the other way around – and THAT is the problem. She can’t give up or even *share* control; until now, control could only ever be held or taken from her.

> Dawn sighed. “In the past I always tried to control the outcome so that I’d end up being Number One. Ben recognized in the clearing that I’ll never be able to let go of Perfect Dawn until Option One gets completely taken off the table. That was the whole point of having Option Two and Option Three. I said it wasn’t about me and my issues, but you know what? It really IS about me and my issues.

Yep, it really is. See Crack of Dawn, Break of Dawn, Constant, Caspian, Option Four and Option One for details. :wink:

Seriously though, it’s hard to argue that control isn’t a problem for Dawn, and it would be an even bigger problem if she didn’t learn how to *share* control with her husband. To be honest, titled wife or not, she needs to do that *anyway* just as a *girlfriend*. But she definitely needs to sort it out for herself before she can accept Ben’s ring.

---

Here’s what Dawn thinks *will* happen if ‘Perfect Dawn’ claims the crown:

> Dawn pointed first at Adrienne and then Summer. “I have every bit of faith that you two could remain official girlfriends in The Quad and play nice with each other. I believe you two _wouldn’t_ compete with each other, or with me, to try and be his favorite. But **-I-** would. I’m the one who decided I felt empty being nothing more than his ‘wife in spirit’ and felt the urge to try and claim the crown. That’s why I left: because I didn’t want to hurt either of you. And I don’t want to hurt either of you now. Marriage to Ben is a carriage on a stick that I will forever chase until--”

Yeah. THAT. The ‘rankings’. Number One, Plan A, all that shit. In fact, Adrienne herself said it best:

“We ALL take him,” Adrienne insisted, pointedly looking at both of the other girls. “That was the original agreement. No rankings. No Number Ones. No Plans A, B, or C. Ben needs all three of us in his life, and all three of us need him. We’re a team. We’re The Quad. That’s why it was so important for us to go down there and get *YOU* back.”

Right now, if Dawn took the crown, she couldn’t do that. She couldn’t *be* that person. And for everyone, Ben included, to have their Happily Ever After, they *need* to be equal. If Dawn can’t do that, she shouldn’t be the wife. None of them should.

I know I say I’m a Nestmates fan who prefers Dawn as the wife. And that’s absolutely true, but regardless of my preferences I’m a **Nestmates** fan. If Dawn became the wife and pushed out Adrienne and Summer, I would be *bitterly* disappointed. I’ll be *bitterly* disappointed if Adrienne gives into her ego problems and claims primacy over the other girls too, for the same reason. They are ‘The Quad’, and the other two girls must be equal, and not ‘side pieces.’ Each of them shoulders ¼ of the responsibilities of the collective, and that gets undermined if Mr and Mrs Ben are ‘more equal’ than others.

Don’t disappoint me Adrienne.

---

Back to Dawn. As compelling as the ego issue is, it’s not the killer blow the next problem is: her own self-hatred.

> “I love you, Ben. I’ll always love you. But I don’t like myself right now. I downright HATE myself right now, and it’s not healthy.”

No, it’s not. And hating yourself in a marriage is even more unhealthy.

> “I HAVE to break free of Perfect Dawn. I have to. And marrying you is a HUGE part of being Perfect Dawn: getting the title of ‘Ben’s Wife’, claiming first prize, wearing the crown that announces to the whole world, ‘I won!’” She shook her head sadly.

Definitely not a good thing. Even beyond the ego issue, this is feeding the beast within her. Dawn then summarises her POV chapters in a way I never could, outlining her struggles and her failures before leading up to their moment in the clearing at Morris Camp:

> When we got to the clearing and had such an incredible moment of passionate love that I couldn’t help but blurt out, ‘Will you marry me?’, you turned me down flat. You said our relationship had gone to shit, and you were right. We’d gone from a period where you could ask me anything, to a period where I **constantly** hid my true thoughts and feelings from you. All because I was chasing Perfect Dawn.”

And it’s true. She was hiding her thoughts and feelings – that brick wall, remember? How many times in her inner thoughts did we read her trying to be perfect? Oh, she’d couch it in other language sometimes, but at the end of the day she couldn’t stop herself. And yes, part of it is the entity of the Inner Voice, alternatingly egging her bad behaviour on and condemning her good behaviour (Miss Hyde) or trying to pull her back from the brink (Dr Jekyll). And for some reason I still don’t understand, Dawn kept trying to placate Miss Hyde while ignoring Dr Jekyll.

Here's hoping Iris can sort that one out.

---

But even THAT isn’t the worst part about ‘Perfect Dawn’:

> Dawn took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. “I’m still stuck in an identity crisis of sorts. I look back at who I was for most of my life and realize I didn’t like the person I was: consumed with my image, catty, and false. I was cruel to DJ growing up and rubbed it in her face that I was superior to her in every way. I smiled to your face a hundred times, Adrienne, while simultaneously entertaining thoughts about backstabbing you. When you first showed an interest in Ben, Summer, I initially thought so little of your meek, deferential nature that I figured you’d be a convenient placeholder to keep Ben occupied until I got myself perfect enough and claimed him back. I wanted everyone to see me as the All-American Girl Next Door: a blonde blue-eyed beauty, pretty but modest, sensual but not slutty, intelligent but not arrogant. I wanted to marry Ben, pop out 2.5 kids, and have the white picket-fenced house he always talked about. I’d be on the PTA, host get-togethers in our carefully manicured back yard, and revel in the jealous stares of all the other school moms who wished they could be me.”

Forgive the use of an old internet expression, but: Quoted For Truth.

Dawn is being brutally honest, opening herself up to condemnation for her thoughts beyond that which she already condemns herself. And you know what? It makes for ugly reading. It’s vanity and selfishness run amok. And the Thought Police would lock her up for it and throw away the key. But although Dawn is being completely honest here, it doesn’t make her self-condemnation wholly correct. And I’m not the only one who thinks so:

> Adrienne, Summer, and I remained quiet after Dawn went silent for a bit. She was futzing with her bubblegum pink hair, and I glanced at the other two to gauge how they were reacting to the revelations that Dawn considered backstabbing Adrienne and thought of Summer as a convenient placeholder. But Summer merely looked at her BFF with an expression of obvious concern, and Adrienne looked at her Nestmate with an expression of sympathetic pity.

Obvious concern and sympathetic pity. Yes, unlike the vast numbers of anti-Dawners, these two characters actually *get* Dawn Marie Evans.

---

Adrienne and Summer are not condemning Dawn. You know why? Because they get it, they *understand*. This isn’t an exclusively *female* thing, but self-condemnation is something that many, and I would argue even **most** women struggle with. Sometimes it’s justified, but oftentimes it’s not. It’s tied to self-esteem issues, and in Dawn it manifests as the Miss Hyde version of her Inner Voice.

Imagine the Inner Voice of Adrienne. Imagine it as a child, neglected by her parents, raped by her brother, competing for validation with other girls. Imagine it as an adult, where her every public move is scrutinised, where her entire professional life revolves around her image, and where she is genuinely confused about her feelings and even her sexuality. Imagine keeping her own Miss Hyde under control without the benefit of a therapist, or the love and affection of the No Name family.

```“I get that you’re feeling pretty shitty right now,” Adrienne continued with an expression of genuine sympathy. “I’ve been there, believe me. I’ve doubted myself - considered myself unworthy of being truly loved. I shudder to think of where I might’ve ended up had I not fallen in with Ben and his family. I look at what happened to Elyse and it all hits a little too close to home. It makes me think, ‘That could’ve happened to me.’ But it didn’t because I had a family that quite literally wouldn’t LET me go. Just like _we’re_ not letting you go.”```

- ASL2: Chapter 94: Option One.

It's painful, and I hated reading it, but read OSL: Elyse if you want to know what life would have been like for Adrienne without therapy and the support of the No Names.

There is no way…*no way*…Adrienne is gonna condemn Dawn for entertaining thoughts of backstabbing her. She gets it. She *understands*.

---

Imagine the Inner Voice of Summer. Imagine being a daughter of a mother chasing perfection, and following in those footsteps. Imagine the lack of attention of the male members of her family, and not having a positive influence of that gender as part of her development, and instead seeking it in trashy romance novels and celebrity gossip. Imagine getting cosmetic surgery as a teenager. Imagine having relationship after relationship where she is only getting used and abused, and that she gets off on it even if at the same time it’s not giving her what she *really* needs. Imagine being with someone like Toby. Imagine keeping her own Miss Hyde under control without the benefit of a therapist, or the love and support of her mother, BFF and boyfriend.

```“I’m as happy for where I am as for where I’m *not*. I’m not huddled cold and shivering on the floor at the foot of my boyfriend’s bed all night as punishment for burning dinner. I’m not standing in front of the bathroom mirror after waking up an hour early before work to cover my bruises with extra makeup. I’m not sitting in my car in the garage because I’m only allowed to cry in places where he can’t see or hear me.”

“Summer…”

Her chin dropped. “I’m not tied down to a filthy motel double-bed while a man who claimed to love me stands at the door collecting a hundred bucks from every guy who wants a piece of me.”```

- ASL2: Chapter 66: 24 Hours of Summer

There is no way…*no way*…Summer is gonna condemn Dawn for entertaining thoughts of using her as a placeholder. She gets it. She *understands*.

The only person who *doesn’t* get it, who *doesn’t* understand, is Dawn. But she *wants* to get there, and that’s a start. She actually *doesn’t* need to marry Ben. She *needs* therapy.

---

And for a while, she had it, or something like it:

> Eventually, Dawn took another deep breath, held it, and then slowly exhaled. “Yvaine talked a lot about chasing suburban housewife perfection and how unfulfilled she felt in the end. ‘Image **isn’t** everything,’ she said. I mean _obviously_ right? It’s not that I didn’t **know** that, but I didn’t _live_ that. Without true love, friendship, and family, a cookie-cutter house and all the trappings of success left her as fulfilled and as satisfied as a kale salad.”

Kale salads are *disgusting*. Sorry A.D. :wink:

Seriously, Dawn’s point about *knowing* something versus *living* it is well made.

> “Option One wouldn’t SAVE me from Perfect Dawn; it would TRAP me into Perfect Dawn. I’d feel obligated to _be_ Perfect Dawn for the rest of my fucking life, and that’s not who I want to be. That’s NOT the real ‘me’. I’m still trying to find the real ‘me’. Different hair colors. A willingness to embrace my sexuality. Being open and honest instead of deflecting questions I think might make me look bad. Recognizing that I can’t do it all on my own and sharing my issues with my support network.” She turned to Summer. “I have _missed_ your mom, Sunshine. I didn’t want to show it. I lost a confidante, but you lost your **mom**, and didn’t want to make it seem like I was being insensitive to your loss. Maybe sharing more with you and with Adrienne is the answer.”

That is incredibly insightful. And as much as **-I-** would prefer Ben marry Dawn, I understand she needs to get past or at least learn to deal with and control the ‘Perfect Dawn’ impulses first. And she is not anywhere *near* that right now.

---

Adrienne, on the other hand, still has hope for Dawn:

> “I still think you can get there. What better motivation to improve?”

>

> “It’s the _worst_ motivation for me to improve. I can’t marry him. Marrying Ben was _Perfect Dawn’s_ dream. DJ was right all along: for me to even consider the possibility of being Ben’s wife is to put me right back into my obsessive-compulsive behaviors in chasing Perfect Dawn. But that’s not who I want to be anymore. Please… Help me discover who I can be when I’m no longer chasing perfection. I _hate_ Perfect Dawn.

Dawn is asking…no *begging* for help. I spoke of the Dawn POV chapters as character development, and they *were* character development. @Berithon#4060 disagreed with me, but cited character progression, not development. This is what I was talking about. Right here, in this chapter? *THIS* is character *progression*. Development in a literary sense is the establishing of a character so that the reader truly knows and understands everything relevant about that character, developing personality and motivation. The Dawn POV chapters achieved that. But any time a character *grows* beyond what the reader already knows? *THAT* is character progression.

I’ll be honest, this genuinely *pains* me to say this, because I *love* this character, but right now? Dawn *cannot* marry Ben. She is literally not ready, and I don’t mean that in the Perfect Dawn sense. She needs to rid herself of that albatross. Ben, Adrienne and Summer will help her get there, but not because the goal is to make her Mrs Ben. It’s because she needs to get there to truly have her own Happily Ever After. If she becomes Mrs Ben along the way? Well yeah, I’ll be happy. But as long as she’s Mrs Ben in her heart and Ben’s, as long as the titled wife really is just a title and not a ranking, then it *truly* doesn’t matter.

But if I’m being honest, I’m kinda tired of the Taylors and Ambers getting the crown.

---

**ADRIENNE AS THE LEGAL WIFE/OPTION TWO (A)**

While Adrienne doesn’t *need* the title like ~~Perfect~~ Dawn does, she certainly wants it. But she’s not gonna claim it if Dawn or Summer want it. But Dawn ends up being her greatest advocate:

> Option Two is the way to go: you and Adrienne get married. Solves all our problems and everybody comes away happy.”

Welllll…I think we’ll have to wait and see if you’ll actually be happy with this result Dawn.

Fortunately, Dawn doesn’t have to rely on her own happiness to help sell the idea of Adrienne becoming Mrs Ben:

> We’re too alike. Adrienne, on the other hand, **you** complete him. You’ve built the relationship with him since high school, you have the resources to support him and a family, and there’s logic in solidifying your public image with getting married.”

Ok, there’s problems with these arguments too: Adrienne alone completes Ben? Debatable. I’d argue that ALL of the Nestmates complete him. ‘Solidifying her public image’? *Really?* Yeah, I don’t have to tear down this argument, Adrienne herself does it nicely:

> “You’re talking logic and public image instead of love,” Adrienne sighed. “And being the husband of a world-famous supermodel would put a spotlight on a man we ALL know would prefer to remain OUT of the spotlight.

Yeah, so let’s dispense with that one.

But the building of the relationship? Yeah, that’s a Rock solid argument. :wink: They’ve had highs and lows, and both have made terrible mistakes, but the overall trajectory has been upward. The foundation IS solid because they’ve worked on taking out the stuff that *doesn’t* work. It’s still a work in progress, but since high school there has been steady construction, with only a single period of extended delay in the project.

---

In her argument to advocate for Dawn, Adrienne points out that Dawn’s absence drove Ben mad. Dawn returns the serve:

> “If you’d left, **your** absence would’ve driven him mad,” Dawn insisted.

Yeah, she’s not wrong there. Playing devil’s advocate though – if Summer left, would it have driven Ben mad?

…yeah, let’s not go there.

> Adrienne shook her head. “I’m never leaving him again.”

>

> “You’re only proving my point.” Dawn smirked. “What was it you said this morning? ‘I’ll do ANYTHING I have to for the man I love more than any other human being in the world’, right? Well this is what he needs from you. This is what both Summer and **-I-** need from you as well. You want to do everything humanly possible to make this team work together? Marry him, Adrienne. Is that really such a hard thing to do?”

This is a very good point, at least in terms of Adrienne’s comparative ‘worthiness’, though I hesitate to be too happy about it. It *can* be interpreted as Adrienne marrying Ben to make *him* happy, to provide that balance and steadiness in his life that right now Dawn and Summer can’t or aren’t ready to do. And if Adrienne is marrying Ben primarily for that reason, that’s a *bad* thing. It can be a part of her reason, but it cannot be the *main* reason.

But taken in the positive sense intended, yeah, this is very strong argument. A spouse should prioritise their spouse above all…but honestly, this is true whether they have the title or not. Still, it’s a point in A.D.’s favour.

---

Dawn then builds on her previous point:

> I need you to marry him, Adrienne. Option Two: I need you to take him off the table… for ME.”

Dawn is trying to get rid of Adrienne’s hesitation to marry Ben because Dawn is his soulmate, by framing it as…well…an intervention on her behalf. Dawn was wrong to try to separate herself from Ben, but she still needs to separate herself from Perfect Dawn. If Adrienne marries Ben, then Perfect Dawn loses and Dawn has a better chance at killing her mental nemesis.

It's a good argument, but there is a double edge to this one too (I’m sensing a pattern here). It’s again promoting the idea that Adrienne marries Ben for the good of the collective, which is okay to a point. I mean, if the Nestmates are and remain equal then yes, it’s a good thing and Adrienne gets what she wants. But again, the balance and steadiness in the Quad shouldn’t be a primary motivator.

In fact, Dawn’s advocacy of Adrienne really IS about Adrienne getting Dawn off the hook. It doesn’t make the wrong choice, but it’s a choice where it should be made in *spite* of Dawn’s struggles, not *because* of them.

Really, what ARE the reasons why Adrienne should marry Ben over Summer that aren’t related to helping Dawn and/or maintaining the Quad? (I won’t argue over Dawn, as her bid is well and truly sunk). She’s built the relationship and she is arguably ‘the best of them’ (as Dawn says)…but I’m finding myself ambivalent here. I may have to get back to that.

---

**THE ARGUMENT AGAINST ADRIENNE**

Just like I’m struggling to form a coherent argument FOR Adrienne, there’s not much AGAINST her either, though as it has been for the other girls, it’s Adrienne herself who makes this argument.

As mentioned above, Adrienne herself points out to a problem with Ben becoming Mr Adrienne:

> Adrienne sighed. “And being the husband of a world-famous supermodel would put a spotlight on a man we ALL know would prefer to remain OUT of the spotlight.

There are legitimate concerns with Ben having a higher public profile. The harem thing can be shrugged off as a modern-day (and much better person than) Hugh Hefner. But the incest thing? That could ruin him, and everyone else in the Family. It runs the risk even as the unmarried ‘partner’, but there IS higher scrutiny on legal spouses.

The other issue, also as mentioned above, is Dawn herself:

> I’m NOT convinced that you’ll honestly be alright living the rest of your life NOT married to your One True Love.

<snip>

> “You’re not reassuring me you won’t freak the fuck out if Ben and I ever do get married,” Adrienne muttered.

<snip>

> “Now I’m **definitely** not reassured.”

Yeah, if Dawn’s rehabilitation goes sideways, or doesn’t happen at all, it has all the potential to be a nightmare. Adrienne shouldn’t live or make her choices based on fear of what Dawn might do, but it has to be acknowledged as a risk.

---

The other argument that Adrienne makes is that she genuinely doesn’t *need* the crown. Yeah, she wants it, but she admits she can be perfectly happy without it:

> I’m a celebrity who never **actually** has to get married. It’s perfectly normal to remain unmarried but still have a ‘partner’. Oprah and Stedman. Anna Kournikova and Enrique Iglesias. Kurt Russell and Goldie Hawn. As long as Ben and I are in each other’s lives for the rest of our lives, I’m perfectly happy to bear his children and never formally tie the knot.”

There’s a weak counterargument about her not getting his last name, but Adrienne easily swats that aside (besides the simple fact that she can change it any time as the adopted daughter of Beth and Michael):

> Adrienne sighed. “My brand manager at ICON told me I should never change my last name, even IF I were to get married.”

Awww, does that mean she’s not gonna be Mrs Ben? :pleading_face:

“You could still _legally_ change your last name but not change your brand name,” Summer volunteered. “Adrienne-fucking-Dennis definitely rolls better than Adrienne-fucking--”

Kenobi. I’m going with ‘Kenobi’ until -b.d.- confirms otherwise. There’s been enough Star Wars references in this story I’m confident in my guess. :smiling_imp:

---

But back to Adrienne pointing out she’s happy to remain Ms Dennis instead of Mrs Kenobi:

> “All I really want is reassurance that my Tiger’s head will be on the pillow beside mine when I’m gray and old and my tits have sagged to my navel. I want to put his name on my emergency contact forms. And I want to find out what our baby is gonna look like. And I can do all that _without_ the government piece of paper. I really _can_ live with being his ‘wife in spirit’. He’s already my husband in my heart. He’s the only man I’ll ever want, ever need, or ever have. And I **really** don’t need a title to prove it.”

I believe her. And Dawn is envious of her:

> Dawn sighed. “Then you’re everything I _wish_ I could be but am not. You’re the best of us, Adrienne. And that’s why you should be his wife.”

Yeah, debatable and subjective. She’s certainly in the best ‘position’ of any of the Nestmates, but I’m uncomfortable with this train of thought…it’s straying from the notion of equality between the Nestmates if someone is ‘better’ than the other. Also, not needing the crown is not much of an argument of being more worthy of it.

But, it certainly isn’t an argument against it, either.

---

Really, there isn’t much to argue against Adrienne being the wife that’s covered here, other than her own position that she doesn’t need it and would be just as happy without it (which is also Summer’s argument). But there IS an argument against it that isn’t raised here, but has been raised numerous times in the past: Adrienne’s ego.

```“You talk about Summer being brighter than the sun, but I’d be the shadow that eclipsed her in your heart. I won’t do that to her. If Summer and I were both your girlfriend at the same time, we both know I’d wind up dominating her and becoming your ‘Number One Girlfriend’ or ‘Primary Girlfriend’ the way I was when we were engaged, however unintentionally. I already did it to Sasha, didn’t I? Maybe Summer and I would both cuddle with you every night in bed together, but I’d naturally take charge - take advantage of her submissive nature - and start bossing her around. Maybe she’d happily defer to me the way she always does. Fuck, we both know she’d voluntarily take a step back and be all, ‘You should marry him A.D. You’re the one he’s meant to be with.’ She even does it with me NOW!”```

- ASL2: Chapter 71: Covet – one month ago.

It comes up in chapter 77: Greenslade in a conversation three weeks ago between Ben and Kim, and again in chapter 84: Cards on the Table during the big conversation a week ago. Hell, Dawn herself adopts it as her own similar concern in chapter 87: Obligation and uses it to justify taking herself out of the running.

The relegation of Dawn or Summer as 2nd class wives…or ‘concubines’ if you prefer…yeah, THAT is a real argument against Adrienne.

But at this stage, I’m not convinced it will happen. For the same reason that she can be happy not being Mrs Ben except in spirit, then I’m reasonably confident she can put her ego aside. :fingers_crossed:

---

LOL. I well and truly went down the rabbit hole there, didn’t I? Well, that’s what I thought about the arguments, but what did Ben think?

> And I happen to know that Ben hates Perfect Dawn, too. Right?”

>

> All three girls stared at me, waiting expectantly.

>

> And when I didn’t respond right away, Dawn raised her eyebrows and leaned forward, repeating, “Right?”

Enquiring minds want to know, Ben.

> “I don’t hate you,” I muttered softly.

>

> “You did. For a while, you did. I felt it. I blacked out in the car.”

<snip>

> “But I don’t really hate you. I mean yes, I screamed that phrase at the top of my lungs, but I don’t really hate you. You know I love you.”

Yeah, we know it. I know some people aren’t happy with how quickly this resolved, but seriously folks, in the greater narrative Ben’s freak-out was a blip, an aberration, and an extreme reaction to stress…it wasn’t a sustained emotional state. But I digress.

---

> “I know you can both love me and hate me at the same time.”

>

> “I can hate the things you _do_, but I don’t hate _you_. I know deep in my heart you’ve never done anything intending to hurt me. Good intentions don’t always translate into good results, of course. But I know your heart. I know your soul. You do this shit because you’re scared: scared of looking like the bad girl, scared of telling me the truth because you think I won’t like the truth, scared of making the fatal mistake that makes me **truly** hate you. You’re still scared right now.”

>

> “I’m terrified.”

>

> “True statement. Thank you for that.

True statements from *both* of them. Ben has never been a *hateful* person in general, and to hate his soulmate?

https://tenor.com/view/princessbride-inconceivable-gif-5156858

(I do know what that word means, thank you very much)

---

> Maybe I need to give you a cookie after every true statement in order to Pavlovian-condition you into being more truthful with me.”

>

> “I’m not really a ‘cookie’ person.”

I don’t know who’s more disappointed about that: me or @jmarteen2012#3899

https://tenor.com/view/loki-loki-series-bit-of-both-loki-clip-tom-hiddleston-gif-21748514

(*¿por qué no los dos?*)

---

Ok, joking aside (including the joke about Dawn ‘getting her cookies’ instead), Ben actually has a serious point to make:

> I sighed and gave Dawn a mournful look. “The truth for ME is: I hate _myself_.”

>

> “Believe me,” Dawn intoned with a nod. “I _totally_ get what that feels like.”

>

> “I know you do. I think that’s why I could never really come down on you hard for trying to be perfect. **-I-** was trying to be perfect, and it would’ve been hypocritical of me to demand you be honest and truthful with me when… in fact… I wasn’t being honest or truthful with you.”

>

> Dawn frowned. “You mean your inability to admit that deep down, you don’t _actually_ want to share me with others?

So Ben reveals ‘Perfect Ben’ to Dawn, who isn’t surprised. And the discussion turns (again :face_exhaling: ) to Ben-ogamy, but this time takes a different turn:

> I wasn’t wrong about Fidelity being a core quality of being his wife - **male** fidelity specifically - and it’s just one more reason why it’s gotta be one of you two instead of me.”

>

> “Because you DO wanna have sex with other men?”

>

> “I don’t actually know yet. I just… I don’t know.

Incredibly, more honesty from Dawn. She clarifies that if she does it won’t be any time soon. In fact:

> The very thought right now makes me wanna vomit, actually.

I know *exactly* what you mean, Dawn. I’m betting I inspired that line. And as I write that, I genuinely don’t know if I’m making a joke here or not.

---

Dawn points out that she is genuinely happy that Ben is possessive of her like he is of Adrienne and Summer. And of course, Ben raises the ‘Fair is fair’ counterargument (again :face_exhaling: ):

> “It’s unfair to you.”

>

> “Fuck fair,” Dawn spat.

>

> “I actually do know of a girl named ‘Fair’,” Adrienne pointed out.

>

> “Really?” Summer chirped.

>

> “Not personally. Friend of a friend kind of thing. I also know of an Autumn and a Winter.” Adrienne grinned lasciviously.

That is *literally* the only time I enjoyed that conversation. Ok, Adrienne gets my nod to be wife solely on her ability to derail useless conversations. :rofl:

---

> “We’re getting off-topic,” Dawn cautioned. “The point is: I’m your cow. I **really** don’t want you worrying about somebody else stealing your cow, so with that in mind, after the girls left this morning, I went back to the mall and got this thing engraved.”

>

> Adrienne and Summer both gasped as Dawn reached into her pocket and pulled out a familiar gold band: the fake wedding ring she wore to work to keep guys from hitting on her. And she turned it so that I could see the engraving “Ben’s Cow” inside the band.

True story: @BlueDragonAuthor#1353 got me again. :rofl:

> I snorted. “‘Ben’s Cow’? Really?”

>

> Dawn grinned. “It’s to the point, isn’t it? Meaningful and special just for you and me.”

>

> I chuckled and shook my head. “I thought you said engraving it would be a hollow gesture to try and compensate for a lack of real love.”

And it turns out that the engraving isn’t for Dawn, it’s for Ben, to make *him* feel more secure in their relationship, not her. It’s a needed symbol of Ben’s ownership of her, and her acceptance and embracing of that ownership.

Yeah, that sounds bad, but if she’s a cow, then she’s gonna get tagged like a cow. :cow2: :smiling_imp:

---

What follows is not a joke though:

> I smiled, and Dawn smiled, but before either of us could say anything further, Summer stepped between us and smoothly took the ring from Dawn’s fingers. Summer then gently took hold of her BFF’s left hand, centered the gold band over Dawn’s fourth finger, and firmly slid the ring home.

>

> The two young women beamed at each other, and then Dawn turned back to face me with a smile as she held up her left hand and showed off the wedding band.

>

> _I do_, Dawn’s voice sang in my mind.

>

> ‘I do,’ I replied in kind, feeling a flush of warm happiness and contentment flow through me.

>

> My Dawn.

>

> *MY* cow.

>

> Fuck fair.

Yeah, this made me *all* kinds of happy. Ben and Dawn renew their vows from a week ago after a week of torment and angst. They reaffirm their love and their commitment. That Summer is a part of it makes it all the more beautiful. And the ‘my cow’ part? Even that’s not a joke, it’s a *symbol*, and it’s a symbol that belongs to Ben and Dawn and them alone. And just to put the final touch on this great moment, Ben embraces Dawn’s comment of “Fuck fair.” He lets go of the ‘Fair is fair’ argument, and all the angst therein.

> “You’re my husband in my heart, the only husband I’ll ever have, for the rest of my life. I know I said those words before, when we all put our cards on the table. I wasn’t lying then. The words themselves were true, and they’re equally true now.

Yeah, that’s good enough for me. For now. You two still have work to do.

---

But first…

> But last time, after a few days I found myself still craving… _coveting_… the crown. **This** time, however, we need to put all thoughts of that to rest.” Dawn turned her attention to Adrienne. “Option Two.”

Option Two.

> Adrienne’s wide eyes clicked back and forth between me and Dawn. “Are Ben and I supposed to get engaged right now or something?”

>

> “Yes, please,” Dawn confirmed. “It’s gotta be you.”

>

> Adrienne shook her head. “We can’t do that.”

>

> “Why not?”

>

> “Well for one thing, this is SUPER anti-climactic and the exact opposite of romantic.”

She’s not wrong, but notice that the nature of her argument has changed. Adrienne has truly accepted that Dawn cannot be the one to marry Ben. And Summer has *always* championed the other two women before her. So now Adrienne’s argument is against engagement by soulmate fiat, but not against marrying Ben.

Dawn makes a few romantic suggestions for the next day, and Adrienne’s response?

“That’s… not a bad idea…” Adrienne mused, waggling her head.

Well, there’s a lot of people on Discord who disagree with you Adrienne. Some of them are your fans. :rofl: :AD:

---

Well, I AM a fan of AD (even if I favour Dawn more), and I’m perfectly content with this development. But as I understand it, people are seeing too many parallels with Ben and Adrienne’s previous engagement, and this continues right into the end of the chapter. It isn’t a spontaneous, super-romantic moment. It’s a group event, for crying out loud!

> “Okay, you’re being ridiculous.”

>

> “Our LIVES are ridiculous. And whoever said we have to do things the traditional way?” Dawn gestured at me with both hands. “Do you love him and want to be with him Forever and Always or not?”

Seriously. You’re part of a Quad in a larger, extended harem. In Western civilisation, I’d wager you’re practically unique. Even the relationships of *John Billionaire, Book of David* and *The Big Tits Club* haven’t evolved to this stage.

And besides, Adrienne does love him and does want to be with him Forever and Always.

---

To her credit, A.D. does make a last stab at asking Dawn and Summer, and they both waive her off. Dawn makes her position clear:

> “He’s still my One True Love, my ‘husband in spirit’,” Dawn cut her off. “I’ve been preaching that concept all along - and yes I admit it was a bit of a defense-mechanism to avoid getting rejected - but it’s a concept that I still believe in. He’s my Alpha and Omega, and eventually the father of my children, even if we never get government paperwork.”

Hey, she said ‘if’ we never get government paperwork…okay, I’ll stop. :wink:

> I blinked in surprise. “You still want me to be the father of your children?”

>

> Dawn leveled her eyes at me. “I’m gonna tuck my last box of birth control pills into my graduation gown and hand it to you right after I get my diploma.”

>

> I blinked again. “I’ll take that as a ‘yes’.

Yeah, I’m reading that as ASL3 epilogue material…

> Summer leaned in. “Me too?”

>

> “Wait-wait-wait-wait…” Adrienne waved both hands and shook her head.

>

> “Well, pending you knocking up your wife first, of course,” Summer hedged.

It does not escape me that Summer was cut off by Adrienne before Ben got a chance to answer. The mystery of Chekhov’s Womb continues… :wink:

---

Adrienne’s not talking about children, however, she’s objecting to getting railroaded in the marriage she wants.

> “We’re NOT getting married like this!” Adrienne screeched a little shrilly.

>

> “Of _course_ not,” Dawn stated with a grin. “A proper Adrienne-fucking-Dennis wedding will need time to plan, guests to invite, media to notify, etcetera, etcetera.”

>

> “What Adrienne _means_ to say,” I interjected roughly, “is that there is no way in hell we’re deciding collectively whether or not Adrienne and I are getting married at all. We’ve been over this already. That kind of decision will be entirely between her and me. Period.”

>

> “Exactly!” Adrienne confirmed.

That’s right Ben and Adrienne. You tell ‘em!

> “Solidarity,” Summer remarked approvingly. “An excellent quality in a marital partnership.”

Well, that worked well. :rolling_eyes: :joy:

> “Besides…” Dawn drawled. “Do you honestly think you’d actually make that kind of decision without asking the rest of us for our input?”

Hmmm…that seems *very* familiar…

```“Please…” Adrienne drawled. “Do you honestly think you’d actually make that kind of decision without asking the rest of us for our input?”```

- ASL2: Chapter 84: Cards on the Table.

Checkmate. :rofl:

---

Dawn and Summer are cracking jokes and laughing, and Ben and Adrienne are not as amused. Getting engaged is *serious business*. Except…not.

Daksian’s personal anecdote time! My wife is a true fanatic and lifelong member of her football club (Australian Rules Football) and when I was ready to propose to her, I decided to get them involved. I bought a football, wrote ‘Will you marry me?’ on it, and got the team to sign it. I set up a day to show up at their practice, and the captain was going to pass me the ball and I would get down on one knee. I helped set up where and when with the club, and they only wanted some pictures and an article in their club newsletter. It’s a feel-good story for the club, right?

So all of that happened. But it did NOT go according to plan. The day before, an ex-player suggested that a recently available player from another team – a player with a colourful past – should be picked up by the club. As a result, the news media was all *there* to get the story. When we arrived, there was no parking, so my girlfriend suggested ‘we come back another day’, and I replied ‘No. We WILL find a parking spot’. I take her to the spot for the planned proposal, and before practice ends, my girlfriend says ‘Hey, why don’t we go over to the other side of the field?’ I replied ‘No. I’m comfortable HERE.’ To say she was looking at me oddly was an understatement.

At last the moment arrives, and captain comes over with the ball and passes it to me. My girlfriend didn’t know what was going on until I got down on one knee. And as I do, my pants tear in the crotch. And all of this is happening while the media is recording the event (fortunately, the camera angle didn’t catch the mishap with my pants). She says yes, and then we get an actual media interview. My wife is a shy woman, and while she loved the proposal, she was mightily embarrassed to see it on the evening news.

Adrienne…consider yourself *lucky*. :joy:

---

Anyway, so Ben puts his foot down:

> “Okay, okay, okay, everybody just… **stop**.” I held my hands palms out to all of them. “Dawn, Summer: you both have made your positions quite clear. There’s nothing further either of you needs to say. So here’s what’s gonna happen: we’re all going home. Adrienne and I are gonna drop you two off back at The Nest, and then she and I are gonna drive out somewhere… **alone**. She and I will talk about this… **together**. Without any further interference. Got it?”

Jeez Ben, lighten up. It’s only the biggest night of your life. Up until now.

> Dawn and Summer smiled at each other. I think they knew they’d already won. Something passed between them, and they grinned at each other before turning back to face me.

>

> “Got it,” Dawn confirmed.

>

> Summer hugged Dawn from behind and nodded happily.

>

> I rolled my eyes, grabbed Adrienne’s hand, and started walking back towards the parking lot. The other two followed in our wake.

Ben, just roll with it. I’m pretty sure Dawn and Summer are just excited about throwing you and Adrienne an engagement party. They **ARE** girls, after all. :wink:

They get in the car and get back home. On arrival, Dawn and Summer get out of the car and give both Ben and Adrienne kisses before holding hands and giggling as they head into the house.

They **ARE** girls, after all.

---

And at long last, Ben and Adrienne are alone. Alone to have go off and have a serious discussion about a serious topic. Ben’s still exhausted, and the ‘put me out of my misery’ conversation only compounded that.

> I shifted the Porsche into reverse. Turning sideways, I held the back of Adrienne’s headrest with my right hand and looked out through the rear windshield, preparing to step off the brakes.

>

> “Yes,” Adrienne said quietly, before I actually moved my foot.

>

> I kept the brake pressed and turned my attention to her instead, not yet understanding.

>

> “The answer is ‘yes’. Yes, I will marry you.”

BWAHAHAHAHAHA!!! I thought *my* jokes were bad. -b.d.-, I bow to the master. :rofl:

> I felt my heart leap with joy, but at the same time, I couldn’t help but mutter, “I didn’t actually ask you… _again_.”

:man_facepalming: :popcorn:

> “Then hurry the fuck up and ask me, Tiger!” she whined.

>

> I smiled immediately at her eagerness.

>

> And I knew _exactly_ what I wanted to say.

>

> “Adrienne Felicity Dennis… my Tigress… my Forever and Always…” I took a deep breath and tried in vain to calm my racing heart. “Will you marry me?”

>

> “YES!” Adrienne exclaimed as she flung her arms around me, yanked me across the center console towards her, and seared my lips with a thermonuclear kiss.

:partying_face:

Got there in the end, dude. Well done. :right_fist: :left_fist:

---

Or not…

> My world got knocked off balance and I lost my sense of gravity. Waves and waves of my Tigress’s passion flooded through me, filling me up with glowing golden energy that overloaded my central nervous system.

>

> I felt like I was flying. No seriously: we were _moving_.

>

> _You are LITERALLY moving, dude. Your foot came off the brake and you’re about to roll into the street._

>

> Oh, shit!

>

> I stomped down on the brakes, arresting the Porsche’s backwards momentum. The rear two wheels had dropped down the driveway incline and hit the asphalt, but the back of the SUV only jutted a couple of feet into the street. I quickly shifted the Porsche back into drive and rolled us up into the driveway, and then I put it into park and switched off the ignition.

Very auspicious. :rofl:

> Drawing my **fiancée** back into my arms, I murmured, “Now where were we?”

>

> “Right here,” Adrienne intoned breathlessly, her gorgeous face only inches away and getting closer.

>

> And then we were flying once again.

Congratulations! I mean that sincerely. :smile: For what it’s worth, despite my own ultimately comical proposal, I recently celebrated my 10th wedding anniversary. I think laughter is an important part of marriage, and you two are off to a great start. :wink:

---

So…that’s it then, yeah? We’re all done? All the angst is past? Ben and Adrienne are gonna get married, Dawn’s gonna get therapy and she and Summer are gonna be spiritual wives to Ben, and the Quad will live happily ever after?

Nope. Not yet.

Oh, Adrienne is likely to be Mrs Ben, Dawn’s likely to get therapy, and they may end up as spiritual wives and live happily ever after as the Quad. But to say that we’re done and all the angst is past? No. Fucking. Way.

For one thing, we’re on chapter 95 of a book now confirmed to hit the triple digits, even if it’ll finish up in a few weeks. And this is book TWO of THREE.

I saw someone on Discord refer to Adrienne as the ‘wife’ instead of the ‘bride’ or ‘fiancée’ and my first thought was ‘you are REALLY tempting fate’. Hey, the wedding might go without a hitch…and if so, THAT would be the most unexpected thing -b.d.- could do, so I won’t discount it. But I wouldn’t bet on it.

After all, we’ve all noted the parallels between the circumstances of this engagement and the previous engagement between Ben and Adrienne. There’s a disquieting sense that past may be prologue here. It might.

One thing about people’s concern over this engagement that makes me laugh though – the idea that it needs to be rewritten. As if this *wasn’t* a deliberate choice by -b.d.-. C’mon guys, you may not like the implications, but honestly? Get the fuck over it. Fans of *all* stripes have had to deal with things not turning out as they hoped. Why on *earth* would you expect THIS to be any different?

As -b.d.- likes to point out in his Cars gif, this story is about the journey, not the destination. Chapter 95 is another step in the journey.

---

Speaking of journeys, this has been one for me as well. I won’t lie, even knowing it was coming (whether it was Summer or Adrienne), as a Dawn fan this was a bit hard on me. I love Adrienne, and I’m genuinely hopeful for her and Ben, but I always wanted Dawn to be Mrs Ben. And it’s not over yet, so maybe…but I really doubt it.

But part of my journey has been about seeing how the Happily Ever After can evolve in the Ben and Dawn romance. They are *together*. They have made *marriage vows* to one another, not once, but twice (not even counting the repeated ‘Til Death Do Us Part’ vows), renewing their vows from Cards on the Table after a week of trauma. Dawn is being honest and committing to taking steps to getting her head straight. Ben is being honest too, and committing to stop imposing his ‘fairness’ and genuinely embrace Dawn as ‘his cow’. This is *progress*, and I’m absolutely *thrilled* with it.

Yeah, I’m probably not getting the ending I want, but I’m pretty sure I’ll be getting an ending I’m happy with.

The only thing I *won’t* be happy with? If -b.d.- does change the title to ‘Hot Potato’. It’ll utterly *ruin* my Option Two phone gag at the beginning of this DBR. :sob:

Daksian

ANNNNNND DONE!!!

P.S. Unlike Dawn, while I can admit I have a problem, I’m not committing to doing anything about it. Just over 46 pages for a 29 page chapter.

Comments

No comments found for this post.