Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey, all!

We've got a couple of very meaty, substantive bonus episodes coming up for you, but given the state of the world (and requests from you all!), we figure we owe you some fun ones, too. So, in the spirit of our previous bonus episode about the Bachelor and in the spirit of driving Mike up the wall, we're gonna do a fun reality TV epsiode, and we'd love your help!

What reality shows should we force Mike to watch, and which episode(s) in particular? ("Force" is his word choice.) We're not going to do anything that could make an on-topic episode for the show--so nothing on diets, wellness or weight loss. Just some good old fashioned reality TV--a genre that Aubrey enjoys, but Mike cannot abide.

Bonus points for naming specific episodes/seasons, and for picking things that Mike specifically will dislike. (Again, his request.)

Drop your nominations in the comments! We'll record a bonus episode about one of your nominations it in the months ahead. And stay tuned next week for our April bonus episode.

Thanks, as always, for your support! See you soon!

M&A

Files

Comments

Bailey

Vanderpump rules Seasons 5-7

Erica Buist

Married at First Sight Australia

Emma Martin

Secret lives of Mormon wives PLS

Deanna

Bridalplasty. The only season that exists because it's insane.

Alex

Love is Blind

CLC

Dance Moms lol.

Jane

Love is blind

Molly Riddick (they/she)

If we really want to trigger Mike’s “mean hot people” complex then Vanderpump rules S1-3 is required

Cisco Frost

Love after lockup. Any of the seasons are good, it's all insane and awful

Kate

Alicia

Real Housewives of Beverly Hills!

Seaver

Most recent season of rhoslc

Faye

RHOSLC jen shah fbi episode

Sydney Whiteford

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives or Chimp Crazy

kb

Vanderpump Rules! The gender and sexual politics on that show are fascinating.

Anna Wegener

On topic: Celebrity fit club Off topic: married at first sight

Gabrielle Thompson

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City - every single season

kayc1128

Married at First Sight

Mary

Love is Blind. One of the more recent seasons

M

I have such love for Gordon Ramseys Kitchen Nightmares that I cannot justify but would love to inflict on more people

Anna

Jo’s season of the Bachelorette featuring Chad!!

E

MILF manor!

Ben Ramsdale

Ramsey’s Kitchen Nightmares

Gaby Berkman

Season One of selling sunset.

Georgia Peach

Jersey Shore when they go to Italy

Samantha Chapman

Kitchen Nightmares if you never want to be able to go to a restaurant again

Dee B

Bad Girls Club

Tim Summers

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. The worst people in the world.

Blake Martin

Season 10 and/or Season 19 of top chef (Seattle and Portland, respectively)

Momo

Intervention because I watched it in my human growth and development class in high school

alex

the queer season of are you the one!!

Salwa Saeed

The trashiest of all reality tv: Temptation Island

Cassidy

Listennnnn Mountain Monsters. Rednecks running around chasing Bigfoot with obviously fake shit happening. GOLD. Seasons one and two are best. After that it’s kinda gets complicated.

chloe

i would like to hear mikes reaction to the housewives… particularly early RHOBH or any RHOSLC

Deirdre Ryan

Season 1 of Jersey Shore. 🏋️☀️🧺 (please)

Tilly Jean

100% yes “so Whitney and I did ketamine therapy”

Amy Friedman

Love is blind!! Specifically the “Megan Fox” season! He’ll die! It’s amazing! Shot: love is blind Chaser: queer ultimatum

Em Castro

Love is Blind, especially the Minneapolis and Charlotte seasons

Chris Savesspiders

I think Hoarders might send him over the edge. I think it would be kinder to give him Hell’s Kitchen.

Kai

💎 Milf Manor 💎 please I'm begging you

Sarah Rockwood

The Bachelor! We're getting new seasons of Paradise and Golden this summer.

Amanda Buchanan

Hoarders Season 6, Episode 4. I feel cruel even suggesting this but he will CRINGE

Carson Tompkins

The cheating episode of VPR but AFTER someone explains the dating/fucking chart with all the cast members to him

Kait East

Survivor! Specifically the season where a guy got med-evaced for eating too much meat and getting constipated (I can’t remember the season off the top of my head)

William Selig

knowing nothing about it but that gay guy todd's show

Erin

It doesn’t matter which one as long as he’s watching it for the Right Reasons

Madeline Cohen

A love island episode where they return from casa amor. The BEST drama.

jade breen

Hells Kitchen or Hoarders. I think he’d be so freaked out by the messes

Alex

MAFS or Love is Blind. The straights are absolutely not ok.

Hailey

Flavor of Love or Rock of Love!

Marie Hicks

I do think he would genuinely enjoy traitors

Jae

No idea what it was called but there’s a tattoo cover up contest show that’s wild. They reenact the instances that led people to get bad tattoos and everything.

Sandra Zapata

I just started The Valley and boy do I love-hate it 😅

Alex Miller

Hotel Hell or Kitchen Nightmares

Case

The Great Pottery Throwdown. Ever seen a grown man cry over a well made jug? It's... Gosh it's just wonderful.

Rachel Augustine

Sister Wives. Love is Blind. Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.

Sarah

Vanderpump rules PLEASE

Bb.bbby

Secret lives of Mormon Wives cos it is a 🚩🚩🚩🚩 haven and insane example of compulsory heterosexuality

Chloe Hays

Milf manor!!! Or housewives (OG RHONY would be amazing, or the Carlton season of RHOBH)

Stacy Owens

Sister Wives!!!! Muahhahaha

Katelyn Isaacson

The Traitors!!! The most recent US season especially!!

Aliya Webermann

Vanderpump or real housewives of SLC 100%

Mary

seconding this!! He should watch the opening episode at least, but the whole season is pretty quick to get through.

Blair

My brother introduced me to The Ultimatum and I think Mike would have a field day with either season

Lauren

Love is blind

April Chaney

Please GOD 90 Day Fiancé: The Last Resort (season 2).

Emily Wilson

I'd love to hear Mike's take on the Browns, Sister Wives. I've only watched it in the last two years, and it's actually fascinating

Jennifer Macdonald

Love is Blind UK, episode where Nicole meets person she first says yes to.

Yaz

Love island 🙏🏽

Dylan Stephens

The Circle, on Netflix, seasons 1-3!

Dylan Tanner

Oh my god the golden bachelor

Leo

I second love is blind (also thank you for making an episode that's lighter)

Leigh Forsyth

CLEAR CHOICE would be love island US season 6! but rupaul’s drag race season 6 or the traitors season 2 or 3 would be choices too!

Sammy Gibbons

The Ultimatum: Queer Love (bad and chaotic) or Survivor: Cook Islands (tbh a good season once you get past the first couple (problematic) episodes)

Tawnee

RHONY scary island episode Vanderpump rules any of the reunions.

Sylvie Freedman

early americas next top model think 2005 era

Kai Dorothy

Traitors US!! And Traitors AU season 1 - one of the best reality seasons of tv ever imo! Also the bisexual season of Are You the One? Assume he’s seen that - he is gay 💅

Veronica

The traitors, UK season 2!

Bela Garces

i am begging Mike to watch Are You The One season 8. Need to hear his takes on chaotic gay 20 somethings

kitkatkara666

90 day fiancé, before the 90 days, season 7! Episode 1 would be perfect!!!

Laura Clowder

Ooh... Bar Rescue or Restaurant Impossible both have a lot of good stuff...

Julia Seaver

Milf Manor or…love is blind. might be too on topic though

Lauren Garrec

Below deck... Sailing yacht is my favourite!

Corey Eagan

Yes! Came here to suggest this exact ep due to the BAMU content!

Emily Saunders

Do NOT do the Kardashians if you want it to remain a silly bonus episode. That being said The Ultimatum is my fav messy reality TV show.

Erin Alackson

Selling sunset!! Or 90 day fiance!

Cole McKussic

I don't hate Mike, so The Challenge.

Jules Nestler

Vanderpump specifically the story arc of Stassi and Kristen and Jax and Tom

Leorio

Hoarders because I think Mike would hate it and it would be funny AND I think you both would have valuable insight and social commentary on how exploitative shows like that can be and how they protray fat people and mental illness.

Kirstine

THE CIRCLE SEASON 2

Stephanie Marinelli

The most recent season of Love is Blind was especially cringe. Especially cringey men. There was a guy WHO LIVES IN MINNEAPOLIS WHO SAID HE HADNT THOUGHT ABOUT BLACK LIVES MATTER. There were a lot of times watching where I was like “oh. This is how Donald trump was elected”

zebussy

I Love a Mama's Boy. Grad student in psych & this is my favorite what-the-fuck show 💚 S1 Ep 5 is off the rails

Sam

I love this idea! I don’t actually watch a lot of reality TV, but I’m looking forward to hearing Mike’s rant about whatever he ends up having to watch.

Bev Rogers

The Australian one is apparently the wildest

Ray Levy

LOVE IS BLIND!!!!! Specifically Season 1!!

Lady Stoneheart

Naked Attraction. I've never watched it, but I know what happens and Mike will not get through an episode!

Fahema Rahman

How about a happy British one like Yorkshire Vet? Or the awful Dance Moms.

Catherine

Ooo the we were rooting for you episode

Annie McClanahan

90 Day Fiance The Other Way, any season, because it is legit excellent

Maria Garcia

Could have been love!!! On YouTube!!

JS

Traitors - Alan Cumming being the most camp while the players are invested in a game

Beck Exists

The Fox Reality show Solitary is fucking wild... It's one of those ones where it almost boggles the mind that it was ever made, but there's like six seasons of it.

Ann Stapel-Kalat

Deal or no Deal Island!! Watch those people lose their minds to heat stroke in real time, plus anyone who likes to look at a fine man will enjoy gratuitous Joe Mangionello in resort-wear content

Anna Jahns

Secret lives of Mormon wives. Selling sunset/the OC/Tampa/The City The ultimatum

Laura Clowder

Alternatively, Hoarders has *so many poop-related episodes*...

Eternis

Second season of Next Level Chef It's actually good lmao I also want to hear his reaction to cooking in the basement kitchen...

madi

too hot to handle!

Ari

Love is blind or ultimatum!!!!

Jen Mackessack

The traitors Australia season 2 - painful watching throughout for a very satisfying final 7 minutes

Alexa Bastelica

90 Day Fiancé — I bailed on that years ago but all the trash reality tv tropes are on full display.

Sara

Ugh, no relationship shows. They're boring. Do Drag Race! Or something fun like that

Victoria Tang

Real Housewives of Sydney, season 1 specifically. Or - Fuckboy Island?

Devon Meyer

I watch none of these, but I’ve heard Selling Sunset, Below Deck, and Love is Blind are the big ones my friends watch because they’re terrible.

Chelsea Robin

A long shot but Mob Wives from VH1 was spectacular

Rachel S.

The Traitors is fun, but if you're open to older shows I feel like Project Runway, ANTM, or RHONY (early seasons) would be interesting to hear from both of you!

Joey Simpson

Kitchen Nightmares - Amys Baking Company- Season 6, Episode 16. Absolute mind blowing stupidity

Amy

Love is Blind, which is painful. The Circle - starting with season 1, then go in order, this is a silly but actually good show, the seasons kind of build on each other.

frankie

i think the floor is firmly from another universe and would love to get Mike's opinion on that

JJ Grindstaff

Any episode of Dirty Jobs, but especially one that may deal with BAMU stuff. 😂 Hoarders is a close second suggestion.

Liz

Whatever that love island show is??? Sorry, I am not versed in the reality show culture:)

Elizabeth Goldberg

Love Island. Preferably seasons that require subtitles because the UK accents are unintelligible.

momo

90 day fiance or marrying millions

Alexis Logsdon

Traitors! The camp factor of AC’s wardrobe is reason enough, but it’s also got bi-conic players, Gabby and (British Royal) Ivar! And you can sprinkle in some trivia from a million other reality shows (scandoval, anyone?)

Veronica

Married at first sight Australia, you’ve never seen more toxic men (and most of the women) yelling at them through the TV is actual therapy

Aurora Surber

I would love to see Mike's reaction to Flavor of Love, esp season 1!!!

Suz

Season 4 Pride episode! I feel like that one is a rich text.

momo

below deck!!

Leah N

Honestly the queer Ultimatum is SO TOXIC, highly recommend

Lauren Garrec

Oh, you're right. Selling sunset is a great call.

Emily

Vanderpump Rules Season 2 (legit one of the if not THE greatest seasons of reality TV ever) with the Scandoval season as a close second

kayla

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City!! Jen Shah arrest or Lisa Barlow hot mic or “her husbanddd” mayhaps

Hannah Campbell

This is also my answer! I feel like The Circle is the promise of reality TV distilled into its best and worst and I'm completely obsessed.

Alexander Chenery-Howes

Scream Queens on VH1, a show about casting actresses for the Saw franchise that no one knows but it's so iconic

Kate Workman

I think Hoarders or Intervention might make for more interesting episodes, but not as lighthearted - for more fun shows, I think Survivor (one of the older OG seasons) or Queer Eye (something from the first season of the reboot.)

MollyD

Too Hot to Handle

Rachel Heart

Girls Next Door! An oldie, from the early days of reality tv

Emmett DeRome

Omg I would looove hearing Mike talk shit about Temptation Island. He only has to watch the first episode, I promise it’s the dumbest concept for a TV show and he will absolutely hate it

Lucile Pons

Married at 1st sight Australia, any of the last 3 seasons!

Tory Sparks

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City, Season 1!

Laura Winton

Love is blind and/or the bachelor.

Sev Nev

Seconded! I think Mike and Aubrey would have really interesting insight to this show that goes beyond “eww look gross”

momo

seeking sister wives!

Jam Drago

I actually think if you can get your hands on the MTV reality genre of Parental Control / Next / room raiders

Lisa Rosett

Couple to Throuple or Farmer wants a wife-Australian version!🤣

Amit

Please make him watch Milf Manor season 2 because I noped out halfway through but I'm curious what happens next

Annie Fuhrman

I am not up on new reality TV, and I think this could actually be diet/wellness related — SO I'd vote any early seasons of America's Next Top Model.

Brittney Mills

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives or Real House Wives of SLC!

Alyx Olney

The ultimatum is peak straight nonsense. Also I love a classic America's next top model

Erin Mather

I was going to say the Amy's Baking Company episode of Kitchen Nightmares but y'all's ideas are better!

savannah

omg temptation island literally just episode 1 it is so bananas id die to hear mikes reaction😅

Paula

Ultimatum Queer Love is especially awful

Merry Blackbird Postcard Society

1. The survivor season where they separate everyone by race, which is both *absurd* and a BANGER season with HOT people 2. Are You The One, the season where everyone is bisexual (6??? I think????)

Jessica Coons

Season 8!!!! It should be on paramount plus

Clara

Selling Sunset!!

Emma Stevens

I think Mike would absolutely hate The Ultimatum (which many of us would deeply enjoy)

Megan Wilson

Secret lives of Mormon wives - get some of the fun of housewives, but only one season so you can see it all! Housewives of salt lake as a close second

Marisa

Milf manor season 1 is the only correct answer

Sarah S. Dawson

Ohhh I think Traitors With Alan Cumming! The Outfits are amazing.

Meggy Parsec

Naked and Afraid, cuz nakey is just overwhelming.

Melani Robison

I have absolutely no suggestions, as I don't watch reality TV. But I need to let you know that this is exactly what I didnt know I needed until this moment. Oh please. Thank you for your service, Mike!

Marcus

Farmer Wants a Wife

Lea K

Yes, especially Australia or New Zealand or UK ones.

Sefa

the sexually fluid season of "are you the one?" on MTV is messy as hell and really fun! (season 8)

Phoebe Webb

Oooooh listen to the recent episode of Ologies about reality TV! I'm not super familiar with US reality TV but Undercover Boss and Kitchen Nightmares are fun. No good if you need an ongoing series though.

Allison Katz

The Bachelorette season 15, fantasy suites episode - the absolutely WILD one where Hannah is an absolute inspiration for knowing her worth and setting boundaries and taking ZERO bullshit

Amber Englebert

The most obvious answer is season 3 of Traitors, because it made a social media splash. AND Alan Cumming is delightful.

Dylan Tanner

If you want a wholesome palette cleanser

Jam Drago

Jersey Shore or Dance Moms great options

mads

love island UK is my choice for sure. like it gets so unhinged, i feel like everyone needs to watch at least one season of love island UK, season one is pure gold just because it’s from so long ago but a lot of the seasons are pretty good

Jaclyn Schuenzel

Secret lives of Mormon Wives- it's only one season, eight episodes. Highlights include laughing gas and dirty sodas

Kathryn Hester

Vanderpump Rules, the Scandavol season.

Coty Montag

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 4 specifically

Lindsey H

KIDNATION ON YOUTUBE A VERY SKETCHY SHOW WHERE THEY ABANDON CHILDREN/TEENS TO BUILD THEIR OWN SOCIETY AND I CANT BELIEVE THERE WASNT A LAWSUIT

Scarlett Hummingbird

The recent season of Temptation Island on Netflix. Most of those men are VILE and I want to hear both of your unfiltered thoughts 😌

Candice Kaup Scioscia

Okay, clearly we are torturing Michael BUT can I put in a plea for a Great British Bake Off episode as a chaser? It's just so damn charming (older eps).

Mary Bertrand

Survivor season 20: heroes vs villains

Judith

The Ultimatum: Queer Love

Erin Moody

Vanderpump rules all the way

Faras

MILF Island. Such a ridiculous premise, and they have to turn it up a notch with S2.

Bastilledeb

The Traitors (UK)! Naked Attraction might be a step too far

Mike Stewart

I don’t have specific episodes in mind but Michael Hobbes needs to be subject to both MILF Manor and Couple to Throuple

Jessica Coons

Ok but great pottery throwdown is way too earnest and wholesome. Maybe Aubrey should watch it and just also cry about it for a bonus episode?

Jessica Mc

Kid Nation! Oldie but a goodie and there was a recent podcast that dove into all the specifics of how it was made that was super good

Alicia Penney

There's an old one I watched on YouTube called dating in the dark. They would actually go on dates in pitch blackness 🤣 Occasionally the men would try to feel the women's bodies to see if they were thin enough. Then they would stand up and they'd turn the light on and see each other (but no touching). Then one of them would go on a balcony and the other person would either come out on the balcony, or they would see them rolling their suitcase out to a car and drive away 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Isabel

Selling Sunset pretty please The music especially is horrible

Sophia

Selling sunset or queer ultimatum!!!

Willa Yonkman

Real housewives of Salt Lake City seasons 2 and/or 4

Dan

I think any straight dating show in order to discuss the performativity of straightness

Sophie Poppie

I have to advocate for VPR-specifically the Scandoval episodes (inlcuding reunion). I'm not a reality TV girl but I watch that ALL the time. The other option would be Bachelorette, specifically Hannah Brown's season when she kicks Luke to the curb

Rachel I

Kid Nation PLSSS

Elizabeth Kite

Yes, this! It's a remarkable distillation of the state of misogyny in the early aughts. I know you said no wellness angle required but there's a multi episode arc in Cycle 3 that's a real all-timer: -Judge/former supermodel Janice Dickinson tells a very skinny teenager that they "look 2 months pregnant" in a photo - Said contestant is revealed to be actively/unapologetically bulemic - Tyra gets to do a bunch of hand-wringing about how she wants to help, tried to help, why oh why won't this girl accept help!?!

Dorothy

Fuckboy Island!!!!

Amy Bourque

Season 10 reunions of Vanderpump Rules. Would be great to see his takes without knowing the decade of history behind all of their entanglements.

Pocket & Locket

Vanderpump Rules!! Season 6, the best season of reality tv of all time. And yet somehow the worst!!

Cori Drysdale

Asked my mom who actually watches reality TV and also was the one who introduced me to MP - Love is Blind. I know that’s the one reality TV show that makes me leave the room.

smarshtastic

Vanderpump Rules season 11 specifically for the Scandoval drama

Christina McPants

Ooh, the episode where Aussie and Mildred fight with the ironing.

Aurora Surber

new york pollard is reality tv gold so i rec seasons 1 or 2 of flavor of love OR season 1 of i love ny

Chris

Cops

Kyle harper

Yes! This season of love is blind. It was so weird and the TikTok drama is ridiculous!

Maia

Temptation Island on Netflix— the most diabolical show of all time

Hallie Steiner

Love Is Blinddd! It is elite and so much more fun to watch than The Bachelor. I’d say season 6 is the messiest. Also The Ultimatum is pretty unhinged.

Julia

The gay/queer season of Are You The One!! Messiest show i've ever seen and seemed so statistically impossible for the contestants to actually win, they were doing such a terrible job that the show had to just straight up spoil the audience on one of the perfect matches before the contestants figured it out so that we would stay somewhat invested

Maia

Totally agree

Asher Kuhl

RH of SLC specifically the episode where Jen Shah gets apprehended by FBI officers, or the episode where they go to the Trixie Motel lol

Nikki VanRy

Queer Ultimatum or Love Is Blind!

Emma Sims

The Queer Ultimatum, the final episode. The sister wives s1e1. The Real L word, any episode. America’s Next top model. Secret lives if Mormon wives. Outdaughtered- first episode, more recent episode.

Meg Lucas

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Bev Rogers

Ink Master - the stakes are high and the contestants are awful. Every single episode someone will complain that their human canvas isn't a piece of printer paper

Briley Lewis

Naked attraction, the British dating show where people literally judge naked people!

NonMonogaMommy

I wish we weren’t limited to reality TV. I’d suggest Gilmore Girls. 😈

Jodi Kreshover

the season of top chef with Marcel particularly the restaurant wars episode

annabananaramagram

I feel like he'll just say "this is just grindr" and be unimpressed lol

Lindsay

Idk if it's available anywhere but I'd kill for Mike to have to watch the episode of Sorority Life (MTV, early 2000s) where one of the women gets a tattoo that is supposed to say "Jewelz" but the tattooer misspells it as "Jewlez". It's lived rent-free in my brain for over 2 decades.

Claire Cullen-Delsol

You are what you eat, British show with "Doctor" Gillian McKeith who designed meal plans for people based on thorough root through their stool sample.

Hanna Zepeda

Love After Lockup, or Before the 90 Days

Julia

Kid Nation is an iconic problematic older option. The Ultimatum Queer Love season specifically.

Tracey Hickey

I think The Ultimatum is a great pick for someone who wants Bachelor/ette style drama but cannot tell anyone on the Bachelor/ette apart. They did a great job casting a bunch of very conventionally attractive people who nevertheless do look different from each other.

Alex Mitchell

Would esp like a UK season for all Mike’s insights into the British psyche. This feels mean tho as every season is 36h long! I enjoyed it and still feel queasy about how much of my wild and precious life I spent on it.

Megan Rector

Twinning. It was so bad there was only one season.

Aurora Surber

a very different vibe idea would be something like welcome to plathville or similar reality tv show about fundie evangelical lives bc it's a crazy whole other world

Molly

Dance Moms, Golden Bachelor(ette), Bar Rescue

Melanie Cundiff

16 and Pregnant, Teen Mom and Teen Mom 2!! Both on Paramount+ and are batshit.

Cattlin

Early season of ANTM for the particularly nasty Y2K brainrot. S1 is a classic but s2 gives us shandi in the hot tub and s3 is just full of bangers.

Jill

Farmer Wants a Wife!!

Suz

Vanderpump Rules Season 4, Episode 6 - PRIDE. The hottest of messes, and a bunch of straight people taking up all the space at Pride.

Diane

I'm gonna go for Cutthroat Kitchen or Queer Eye. I love silly shows

Renae S.

Hoarders, s9 e6

Pacers fan

Love is Blind! I would love to hear him go off on every element of this insane concept

Laura Koivisto

Love is blind!!! Literally any season.

Jess Crane

Junior British Baking Show!

Sara Kuhs

Summer House season 8! Also Traitors season 2.

Jennifer

Make! Him! Watch! Hoarders!

Aleesha Hallahan

Married at First sight Australia, season 12, any episode really

Ryan

selling sunset is kinda an obsession of mine. s3e8 has a ridiculously over the top straight person™ wedding

Eleanor Rose Dirt Apple

The Boston Rob extended universe. Do 1 season each from Survivor, Amazing Race, and The Traitors

Adam Royer

The original The Mole! Such a classic, plus it's hosted by pre-out Anderson Cooper!

KDC

Hoarders is one that always makes me desperate to clean my house. Like, if I need to clean, I watch one Hoarders while drinking a huge iced coffee and I am off to the races. Commenters are saying Love is Blind, which I watch and kinda like, but the seasons are soooo long. Naked and Afraid and Alone are great and I let my kids watch those because... survival skills!

Sarah

I agree with others who said Vanderpump Rules!!! But you have to watch all 11 seasons, so it might be a while! 😜

Emma Coghlan

married at first sight. i’m begging

Amber

Anything from the 90 Day Fiancé franchise

Kaitlyn Wallace

PLEASE do Temptation Island🤣🤣🤣 or the Ultimatum queer edition

Willa Yonkman

Real housewives of New York City scary island episodes

Case

Yeah. I have such a dislike for most Reality TV that I overcorrected and went wholesome. I just wanna make sure someone out there knows about that show because it fills me with the warm fuzzies. Probably not great content for making someone watch it admittedly

Shelby Van Vliet

This is probably too close to on usual theme but a mega mix of reality food tv could be fun, both the bad and the good? Maybe a random Kitchen Nightmares, the Kwanza ep of Semi Homemade, any Barefoot Contessa episode where she’s having her gaggle of gay friends over for cocktails, and close with The infamous “Baked Alaska” British Bake Off episode?

Parys ⚡️

I'm BEGGING for y'all to watch the Amy's Baking Co episode of Kitchen Nightmares (Kitchen Nightmares: Season 6, Episode 16). It is top 5 reality TV of all time in my book!

Celia Duffy

Gogglebox (UK) worth pulling episodes from YouTube. The concept sounds nuts but it’s so great.

Ali

Please make Mike watch Will blunderfields content on the benefits of male genital scent exchange

Carly C

Season 5 finale of real housewives of salt lake city

Faras

Whoops, it's MILF Manor. Got it confused with a 30 Rock bit

Archie

I think it would be neat to watch a little bit of Survivor, and then watch a little bit of a Survivor: [Country] spinoff. I know that the entirety of Survivor: New Zealand is just up online (I think Vimeo?) cause my Human Communication teacher made us watch it for class.

Daniel Wallace

I put in my vote for Milf Manor. 1st season, no specific episode

Emma Sims

Alone- the Alaska one.

Xpensive Cardboard

Don't watch reality TV, but wasn't there one where guys who date older women were stuck on and island with their moms who also date younger guys? I remember seeing a commercial for it and thinking "huh, so this is the bottom of society"

Rachel D Luke

Below deck! Will look for a specific episode / season. But seasons worth Kate as chief stew are great!

Ronan

anything with Gordon Ramsey lmaooo

Mikhail

1 episode of 90 day fiance might kill him but it's worth finding out for science

Dex E Anderosn

For some reason, MasterChef Junior comes to mind.

Drew Reilly

Love Island UK! New season is around the corner

Tiffany

If we're going for "most unhinged," Love Is Blind, no contest.

Joey

Vanderpump Rules is the reality show to end reality shows

J A

Vanderpump Villa!! I can hear Michael in my head already.

Jean

Love is Blind - PLEASE! Season 8 in Minneapolis. Or Season 4 in Seattle.

Wynter Park

Omgosh I’d LOVE for Mike to see Chrisley Knows Best 😂

Arielle Brousse.

The Trixie Motel arc is the entry point I give to friends who want to get into RHOSLC

Clara Sherley-Appel

MILF Manor Season 1. Don't let him watch the trailer or read anything about it ahead of time. PLEASE

E Ling

Um, the Vanderpump Rules!!

Samantha

The first few seasons of Dance Moms or 90 Day Fiance

Joan and Sarah are Welly Hammfans

One Mike might like: Traitors, especially the US version. One that I think you would both have a lot to say about: Alone. The Arctic Circle season especially

Aurora Surber

for dance moms must recommend season 2 personally

robbie

Love Island USA S6

Rebecca Chalmé

Vanderpump Rules S6E5 “Sex, Lies, and Audiotape” — I need to hear Mike’s reaction to Brittany telling Jax to “ROT IN HAYL”

Cooper Joslin

Naked Attraction! Not sure if it counts but if so, that's my vote

Naomi Kidder

pleeease real housewives of ny, specifically crazy island. please. please. the people need this.

Spider Perry

Yes! Ink Master. I either love the contestants or hate them. The season where there was nearly a fistfight is the one to force Mike to watch. There are so many horrible humans.

Kai

Mole Season 1 + 2 are peak reality TV, although like any reality TV of that time the blatant racism is tough

taybee92

This is the one!!!!

Kaitlyn Wallace

I genuinely don’t know where they found these men😭😭

4rm4d1ll0s

The lesbian ultimatum, 2023 seasons of selling sunset for sure.

Sarah H

Absolutely The Utimatum: queer love!

Alexandra Curd

Kitchen Nightmares- bonus points for it being the Amy's Baking Co. Episode!

Patti Jardine

The Queer Ultimatum that was completely unhinged or the new season of Love Is Blind that had everyone complaining about how boring it was and all the dudes were identical

Jen

Omg, Kid Nation! I thought I dreamt this show.

Naomi Kidder

ohhh this is a very good suggestion

Krystal

I feel like Michael is versed in the Housewifery already, so why not Vanderpump Rules? Or Season 10 of Big Brother US.

Madeleine Wright

Too Hot to Handle. Only watched the first season but it’s WILD. I would also love to hear y’all talk about The Ultimatum: Queer Love.

Lesley Schmidt

Secret Lives of Mormon Housewives - there is so much to unpackage there with sex and gender and religion and influencer culture and read wives (see Adrian and Moira’s IBWTR episode). And a new season is upon us!

Squid Pro Quo

i see many people have suggested VPR already, so i’ll throw in specifically Season 6 Episode 5 “Sex, Lies and Audiotape” — though i’m a pump-head so maybe others can chime in if this would be too dark of an first episode for newbie to watch

Emily

Too Hot To Handle or Love Is Blind🙏🙏

Kfisch

I don't consume much reality TV anymore but would love his commentary regarding Queer eye when is was rebooted on Netflix.

Kat Ruane

MILF Manor… Or F-Boy Island… Or Farmer Wants a Wife

Emily Kuper

Secret lives of Mormon wives or the traitors!!

hannah lamberty

Shot at Love w/Tila Tequila, Kid Nation, Flavor of Love, ANTM, MasterChef Jr, 90 Day Fiancee, Jersey Shore (original)

Angela Maki

The Ultimatum Queer edition!!!

Mia Freiberg

WHERE IS IT I HAVENT BEEN ABLE TO FIND IT

Beth Faller

I feel like you can't go wrong with the RHONJ season 1 finale with the table flip. RHOBH "dinner party from hell" season 1 episode 9, is also very uncomfortable. Plus, there's a psychic!

C Harrison

too hot to handle—i’ve only seen season 1 but it had me yelling about heteronormativity and our weird cultural hang ups around sex for a month

Jessica Coons

Couple to Throuple on peacock is everything anyone ever needs from trashy reality. Episode 5 is messy and hot, but the whole series is gold.

taybee92

Kitchen Nightmares S6 E16. Amy’s Baking Co is the restaurant featured. Peak reality TV.

Kai

Milf Manor crew let's get it done!!!!

Hannah Norris

RHOBH. Specifically the whole Erika Jayne mess.

Yael

Real Housewives!

RJ

The Traitors (I prefer UK season 1) but Us will do just fine because of Alan Cumming

Arielle Brousse.

I’m a reality TV junkie and even I cringe hard enough to leave the room at Naked Attraction.

Kate

I’ll toss out Great British bake off!

Chelsea Dreyer

Flavor of Love - Season 2 - Episode 1 “Sumthin’s Stinkin’ in the House of Flav” there’s “bamu” in this one, Mike will hate it 😂 90 Day Fiancé is also good or any early 2000’s VH1 celebrity dating reality shows OR MTV Room Raiders or NEXT

Simon Clifford

The Traitors, Season 3 Episode 4. Bob the Drag Queen vs survivor alum Boston Rob! (Also “Love Off the Grid”, any season)

Jen Bowers

Too Hot to Handle, start with episode 1 of any of seasons 1-3

Blair Carpenter

I don't know if you could even find this, but I would LOVE for Mike to watch Flavor of Love season 1, specifically the episode where Pumpkin and New York get into a fight Runner-up nominees include: - The episode of RHSLC when the other ladies put together Jen's crimes ("Highway to Vail") - Literally any episode of Bad Girl's Club, Jerseylicious, or Mob Wives

Amy Jones

I vote for early Project Runway, especially Season 2 with Santiago.

Emily Crebbin

Traitors US season 1 or Australia season 1

Stephanie Rice

S1E9 of Before the 90 Days. There's a chase scene that involves a machete mugging.

Cassidy

Milf Manor!!!!

Carly Byron

As a world traveler, he should watch 90 Day Fiance: the Other Way when Americans go to live in other countries! He will hate it.

Elizabeth Wynn

still the only full season of reality TV I've ever watched and when I tell you the reunion made me feel ILL

Bethany Wuerch

All of me wants to say something like Milf Manor, but my soul really wants Kitchen Nightmares. It’s older but MY GOD. It really ruins restaurants for ya and I imagine his reaction would be a delight. 😂

NYB

Naked & Afraid! <3

Heather

I never watched it but I feel like it would be torture for Mike... Catching Kelce... Straight love and football... Mike will love it

Erin Brillhart

Traitors US season 3 the doll episode lol

Lizzie

Love island USA season 6!! Specifically when they return from casa amour and Serena going off 😂 It's the ultimate unserious silly reality dating show

Genevieve Aldi

I also support MILF Manor, season 1.

Maddie Ulevich

Real Housewives of SLC and the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!

Julia

i'm seeing other commenters saying its on paramount plus now, i watched it on mtv way back when it was airing tho :/

eberga

RHONY Season 3, Scary Island episodes

vohak

Survivor Season 8 (all stars)! Or an early season of Are You The One (use statistics and see if yuu can figure out the matches before the contestants do)

Kate McDonald

The second season of America's Next Top Model was the last one before it went so hard off the rails that it was irredeemable.

Smart Bitches Trashy Books

The Real Housewives of Dubai, season 1. On one level: truly shocking (ice in the swimming pool) levels of wealth, privilege, and opulence, set in Dubai, aka We Do Human Trafficking and Labor Abuse Really Good. But on another level: Black women talking about raising their children outside of the US, wealth disparity among the very wealthy, Muslim families visiting one another, surprise appearance by Phaedra, and some petty petty behavior.

Kristin Connifey

Southern Charmed- the early seasons with T-Rav and Catherine drama. Or Big Brother the Dr. Will/Mike Boogie season or Evil Dick season

Lea K

He would probably hate Lol Last One Laughing Australia. It's so awkward.

Ljós

The Ultimatum. Queer Love for sure, I never really got that into reality TV but that shit is heroin!

Mary_ellen76

TheSurreal Life- the season with Tammy Fay and Ron Jeremy. The OG seasons

Vanessa

Love Island Australia season 1 or Fuck Boy Island

ACM

I want this to lead to a bonus episode where Mike teaches Aubrey how to play Balatro.

Jean O'Hara

Milf Manor, Temptation Island, or Farmer Wants A Wife

Lady Stoneheart

Oh that woman is awful! My brother and I used to call it How Clean is Your Poo (as it was the same era as How Clean is Your House). I would love Mike and Aubrey's take but feel this show needs an extra special debunking.

Mia Freiberg

lmao sounds like the netflix one where they get professional monster/creature make up for their dates so it’s impossible to tell if their face is hot or not hahahah

Sara Ravid

For the love of god, vanderpump rules. early seasons or scandoval

Emily Seiger

Love Island USA, Season 6 or The Ultimatum: Queer Love

Bethany Wuerch

YES! Came looking for Kitchen Nightmares. I don’t remember this specific episode, but I’m gonna ruin my life and watch it tonight. Thaaaaanks!

Kai

Flavor of Love Season 1 is insane. But I think Season 2 has the raw chicken in the microwave which is iconic

Ryan The Artist

Traitors, definitely. I recommend the American season 1!

SoundForest

Seconding Vanderpump Rules / Too Hot To Handle is like a master class in heteronormativity / any of the insane episodes of Cutthroat Kitchen where they force the contestants into restraints / the Ultimatum?

Jen

Was this the show with the petite blonde host who would first shame the overweight person by showing them the equivalent of all the food they ate for the week on a big white tableclothed table?

Sheree Speaks

Polyfamily on TLC. I went to High School with one of the wives!

Becky

SURVIVOR!!! We can tell him which ones specifically to watch, because there are literally 48 lol. Definitely earlier seasons!

Maya

Love is Blind or RHSLC! Or, to be kind, The Great British Baking Show.

Brian Monk

MILF Manor would be too funny to hear him react to. Season 2 is so great and uncomfortable

Megan Parker

Beauty and the Geek will particularly piss him off!

Valerie M

The Ultimatum: Queer Love pleeeease

Khaya Buhler

A vote here for Love is Blind. I only watched half a season once but that shit is a mess.

Elizabeth Klekman

Love is blind Sweden with a particular focus on Ola, the insane health nut with cult leader vibes.

Sandy Beach

Seconding!! Specifically Scary Island or Morocco trip

Chloe Holmes

Need his take on OG Love Island UK

$5FeetPics

Please please watch season 5 of Love is Blind. It takes place in Houston and it's the first season of LiB I ever watched. I show it to all my friends if we have time but no plans. It's a master class in manipulation and a perfect encapsulation of why these people can't keep a partner in the real world. My husband and I stayed up til 4am the first time we watched it because we were so hooked.

Marissa

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!

Parys ⚡️

You are in for so much more life ruining than you can even imagine! Enjooyyy!

Kira

I can’t believe nobody has suggested Couple to Throuple!!! Must watch

KMB24

Below deck! Drama + actually trying to accomplish a job!

Veronica Jamison

Traitors (U.S.), season 2 or 3. I'd love to see how Mike reacts to the logic of reality celebs. 😄

carms

the highlights of shayne from love is blind

katie adams

early seasons with the most unhinged version of Kristen is a MUST

Jess

A shot of love with tila tequila or flavor of love. Or both

Kristen

Go old school with America's Next Top Model S04.E07 The Girl Who Pushes Tyra Over The Edge

Helen Johnson

If you can find it, any episode of Mob Wives will do. The drama is so over the top

Alexander Wikstrom

Maybe a more obscure pick, but I recently saw a British reality show called “Olivia Attwood’s Bad Boyfriends” that features some truly awful men

Noor Ali-Hasan

Selling Sunset please! Good follow-up to Erehwon!

bailey sperling

TWIN LOVE!!! weird social experiment dating show where they split 10 sets of identical twins into 2 houses and see if the twins pick the other twins to date. it’s awesome and so ridiculous. or couple to throuple

Hannah Groves

What about love on the spectrum or later daters? They’re so wholesome!

Laura

UK is so much better! Claudia Winkleman is the best.

rancorousFilth

Kid Nation from 2007, a vaguely interesting premise with a toothless execution that surely the execs knew couldn't last long

Anna Jones

Traitors! Specifically the most recent season!

Debra Davidson

Toddlers and Tiaras Season 6 Episode Georgia's Most Beautiful Girls

Lauren Joyner

RHOBH or RHOSLC - if you go with BH, please make him watch the dinner party at Camille's house.

Lisa Frueh

It 10000% has to be milf manor season 1. I can’t believe this was tv that actually got made

Tal

Naked and Afraid is my vote

katie adams

The people crave Mike's take on Kristen Doute, seasons 1, 2 or 3 of VPR

bailey sperling

or are you the one season 8, the queer season- best season of reality dating tv of all time, these gay people are messyyyyyyy

MacKenzie Dunlap

Obviously real housewives of Beverly Hills season 5 episode 16!!!!

Alexandria

Below Deck! It’s on hulu! So many options!

Elizabeth Harper

absolutely without a doubt, season 2 of Bad Girl’s Club which is the most unhinged thing I’ve ever seen.

Jessica Coons

Justice for Tom Sandoval - the only person to take the challenge SERIOUSLY!!!

Patrick N

BIG BROTHER PLEASE PLEASE PUH PUH PWEASE!

MystifyTrick

Like the Amy's baking company one?

Gina Stella dell'Assunta

I want *nothing more in the world* than to hear you both yell about the Lamborghini Funeral episode of Dubai Bling. 😆💓

Kelly Fischbein

Oh, Queer Eye Season 1 Ep 3, "Dega Don't" where they make over a cop. Horrifying l.

Erica Nadine

Are you the one or older seasons of the challenge

Karen Koy

There is an episode of Hoarders where a lady basically eats her own poo. The lady's name is Shanna, it's season 6, episode 4. She also collects poo in bottles. Love ya, Michael!

Caroline Moore

The Bachelorette, Hannah Brown’s season

Lemon G

Milf manor and queer ultimatum lol

Candy Knockout

OMG A Shot at Love! I was obsessed back in the day! 😂

Sam &amp; Matt

To “force” - Traitors For heart feels - great British baking show Jr

Nick Batley

As a Brit, I have to 'recommend' Snog Marry Avoid

Abigail

Temptation Islands latest season on Netflix is great, truly unhinged.

Publiq Quaker Friend

LOVE ON THE SPECTRUM+++ please please please, i hate it SO MUCH i want to hear u talk about it!

Liza Lou

Queer Ultimatum

Oscar Shipley

Gordon Ramsay’s Hotel Hell season 3 episode 3. The diarrhoea episode

Mollie Mae

Naked Attraction on Max. The first episode alone had my husband and I addicted. It's AMAZING.

Jessica Otway

Married at First Sight/ Love is Blind!

Emily Ahrens

Real Housewives of New York. For episodes, either Scary Island or December: Berkshires County

Sunni Mullenix

real housewives of salt lake season 3🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Sarah Sparkles

The new season of Temptation Island on Netflix. OMG. Mike is going to STRUGGLE.

Camille Lussier

If you want actually good, well produced and super interesting reality TV then Survivor. If you want trashy reality TV to make fun of, Too Hot to Handle

Helen Jenne

Adding another nomination for the ultimatum queer love and LIB Seattle

Hannah Leatherbarrow

SOUTHERN CHARM! Season 3 Episode 11 "Words of Wisdom." Coked up disgraced politician invites his friends over for a dinner party. He promptly begins to hilariously, colorfully berate them ("climb on my back, you will crawl off bleeding"), chases them out of his home. They flee by golf cart and almost collide with oncoming traffic. Mt Rushmore reality tv moment.

Wendy Baron

Traitors US, Below Deck (any of the iterations but Sailing Yacht has the most idiocy thanks to Gary)

Maya

milf manor!!!!!!! Freud would love it absolutely crazy shit

Helen Woods

secret lives of mormon wives PLEASEEEE i want to see him get so stressed over these 24 year old women

Jenna M.

I love New York! The reality dating show from the early aughts with Tiffany pollard. Specifically, season 2, "The Mangent." Omg. Please please please.

Shanda Wells

Secret lives of Mormon wives season 1 episode 1. I NEED to hear you guys talk about Connor's character

Kristine Feleppa

Vanderpump Rules! Season 8, episode 18 when Scheana does the cringey music video; season 6 when Scheana is dating Rob; season 5 Katie and Schwartz wedding lead up

Mollie Mae

Oh I watched this recently on like Peacock or Paramount+! I can't remember which

Lady Stoneheart

Oh I remember this! There was a couple who got on super well in the dark, then he showed up and she walked away because he had ginger hair!

Jen

I think any of the "of Love" shows would be good, but I'm here to toss my "Daisy of Love" hat into the ring

Faranak Keshmiri

Queer eye, Project runway or the great British bake off! Especially one of the insane ones where they butcher other cultures like "Mexican week" where the do crimes to an avocado

Rachel Mohr

The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 2 episode 10- the one with the FBI raid!

Claire Dawson

Feels like definitely Queer Eye.

Ryn 🖤

Omg, I still think about this episode. How they thought that was okay to do to Karamo is beyond me.

Zombie Sockmonkey

Kid Nation, a show that left children to fend for themselves in an Old West town and govern themselves. After season 1, the state made everything they did to produce the show illegal so it couldn't be done again.

Ve Green

Real house wives of Atlanta or Potomac 😂

Kat

Oh, I'm a connoisseur of crappy reality dating shows. Too Hot To Handle would probably be the best/worst. I'd recommend season 6 episode 6. Another great contender would be Temptation Island (2025) episode 5. Other greats: The lesbian season of The Ultimatum, the bi season of Are You The One, Love is Blind season 1, and Perfect Match Season 1.

Nicole Chain

The Ultimatum! (The queer season rocks)

Corey Graff

My favorite reality show not enough people ever watched was called “Kid Nation”. Wild, problematic, and only lasted one season but I will always remember it for being a rollercoaster ride

Cy

That season of are you the one where everyone is bi

Chrys Buckley

Bachelor/Bachelorette/BIP - bring it full circle! I haven't watched the last couple of seasons so can't say if any of those will be particularly tuned to Mike's dislikes. As for some previous seasons that might be good - I mean if it's findable Jake Pavelka's (sp) season is old but iconic esp the ATFR, and Matt James's season might have some of the worst cringe. Just please avoid Nick at all costs - not for Mike's sake but for the sake of my sanity.

Jen

Daisy of Love from VH1! The episode where the guys get skunked!!

Michelle McGraw Trela

The most recent season of Married at First Sight, episode 15, Cheat and Retreat. MAX drama!! It's not my fave reality show at all, but if he is just being "forced" to watch an episode, not a whole season, then that one is amazing!

Shelbey Deegan

PLEASE Temptation Island. Mike would be so uncomfortable 😂

Hannah

Survivor!!!

Jessica Coons

The Challenge: Fresh Meat II (season 19) - hot people doing sports in 2010 with the most incredible Bush era fashion. The golden age of reality TV where people acted with absolutely no filter because nobody’s Internet was fast enough to watch clips on repeat and influencer was not a career.

Lzzz

that episode of queer eye where they move the cowboy from a barn bedroom to a tiny house

Jules Walker

Queer Eye - We re in Japan. It's excruciating on several levels.

Robin Halma-Reed

Honestly, any of them, but I'd love a low-stakes breakdown of Gordon Ramsay, so Hells Kitchen or Kitchen Nightmares would be good starting points.

Mollie Mae

Oh that's thr season with a girl I called Patriot! Excellent suggestion!

turbanous

This show is called MILF Manor and was on TLC

Carly C

I second this

Kerri

Dance Moms

Nasim Suterwala

Not tv, but I honestly think it would be informative and interesting, and also hilarious, if you could watch a Mr Beast thing and comment on it

Rebecca Gerson

I was coming on here to comment the challenge!! I second that!

TR

Naked and Afraid (Because why?), Below Deck (starting with season 2), or Queer Eye (because I love it but also get some weird vibes about their friendship?)

Lara

Scream Queens, the 2008 reality show featuring a young James Gunn as a judge in a show where actresses compete for a part in SAW. It's the most campy goofy thing I've ever seen in my life and i love it.

Kirsten Barringer-Cook

I also vote hoarders, I just figured it might encroach on the [mental] wellness frontier.

Victoria

America's Next Top Model, if you want to go for something a little older

Ahelpfulpeach

If cooking shows are off topic enough, both Cutthroat Kitchen and Worst Cooks In America are very funny, tho maybe not something he'd hate.

Lzzz

the amy's baking company episodes (original, follow up hour, + follow up) of Kitchen Nightmares

Michelle McGraw Trela

Also, he might actually tolerate the 8th season of Are You the One? on MTV. It's the rare dating show where the whole cast is queer, and honestly, while it has plenty of drama, it's also surprisingly heartwarming. Easily my favorite season of any reality TV show ❤️

Jeanette Wall

I actually think I need y'all to do S10 of Vanderpump. Absolutely epic.

Mollie Mae

Oooooooooo really?! I thought that hadn't aired yet!!

Jules

Love is blind, the most recent season is a real disaster. Lots of wtfs

Melinda Nystrand

Oooooh The Ultimatum queer edition was WILD!

CJ

Millionaire Matchmaker is problematic on nearly every single level, and it's very fun.

ByDivya

It absolutely has to be the love island uk episode where they discuss brexit

Kellee

Are You the One but the queer season (season 8)

Emily LaMon

I love this so much. Definitely The Traitors

Printed Word & Poodle Enthusiast

Drive to Survive, the last few episodes of season 4, I feel like Michael will get sucked in against his will and we will get some Rachel-Hollis-episodes-level "I don't even care, but...!" content.

Danielle Rollins

Please make him watch Love is Blind. It will melt his brain.

Julie Spray

SURVIVOR but not because Mike will hate it. I actually think he might find it fascinating and it will be funny if he thinks he’s supposed to hate it but he can’t stop analysing it as a cultural product and a vehicle for studying human relationality and behaviour.

Julia S

Vanderpump Rules is peak reality TV - for old school eps, season 2 episode 14 (I lied) and if you want something more recent, the Scandoval episode (s10e15) Or ya know...real housewives of salt lake City finale when they confront Monica 😅. It's incredibly dramatic

bringle wingle

Love Is Blind (the US/original version). Season 7. The whole season is brutal and punishing to watch, so it should fit the bill for what Mike is looking for! BUT in the interest of time, I would recommend episodes 8 and 9. Enjoy! Or not!

Alyssa Todd

Ok any episode of “flavor of love” or “rock of love” please.

Dr. Chunk

Oh my god I have the perfect one - Kid Nation. It's Survivor, but instead of adults on an island, kids are left to run a ghost town with minimal supervision. I think it was canceled because someone drank bleach. There's also that one Jenny Nicholson covered about teams from the "past" and "future" competing to see which era is better. It tries to be scientific in a way that might get under his skin.

Liz Grimaldi

Oh absolutely Queer Eye, Kitchen Nightmares, or some type of baking/cake show (Amazing Wedding Cakes? Cake Boss?).

Aria Velz

RHOSLC Season 4, last episode before the reunion. Receipts! Proof! Timeline! Screenshots!

@pipsuxx

the bisexual season of are you the one, please god

Lillian

The first season of the reboot of The Mole on Netflix. It's batshit insane and just so so silly. My wife and I still say 'Mole-ish behavior!' to each other whenever one of us is being weird.

Hannah Miller

Married at First Sight, especially this most recent Chicago season. You might wanna find some highlight reels or something though because the episodes can drag.

Clare Maxwell

I want Mike and Aubrey watching Drag Race! Not because I think it will be pure Mike torture, but because it's like...80% genuinely awesome people being Hella talented and 20% total reality TV madness! Curious to see what the reaction is

Musse

I'm not really big on reality TV, but I was PULLED the fuck IN by Culinary Class Wars - a South Korean cooking competition. The intrigue was totally different from US shows but definitely there. For some reason I was glued to the screen, no phone, no craft project, just pure simmering drama and genuine rooting for different competitors. I'm afraid you'd need to watch maybe the entire first half of the season to know what I mean though.

Darian Selander

There’s an old show from 2003 called ‘Playing it Straight’ that is absolutely BONKERS and could never be aired today, but it’s a fun nostalgic ride into the homophonic early 00’s? I think you’d both find it hilarious and troubling!

Sophia B

Queer ultimatum or are you the one come one come all

Ali Waterhouse

Mob Wives! But I will be upset if Mike has anything bad to say about Big Ang

Erin Maaskant

The Traitors!! For maximum annoyance, the US seasons hit cos they're reality TV stars trying to stay famous. UK seasons are regular UK peeps so different vibes.

Blair Carpenter

That is probably the most unhinged episode, but unfortunately it does not include New York and I NEED to know Michael's reaction to her!!!

Jessica Edmonds

MILF Manor. Tbh the whole show is so beyond insane any episode would be fun, season 1 specifically

Ilona

Love is blind - if you want some body and diet content then watch love is blind Brazil. There was this really disturbing reveal where the man was obviously “disgusted” by the woman’s body because she was not thin/was fat. she had appearances in later episodes and she was just thriving and having a good time (and looking stunning). If you just want bonkers then the Texas season - a lot of religion, troubling politics and manipulation.

K J

I would love you guys to watch Love is blind! It takes my roommate and I approximately 4 months to get through a season because we stop every 3 minutes to dissect how ridiculous these people are

Gra

Geordie shore

Sarah Bee

True Life, season 4, episode 21. Calf Implant Guy is an elder millennial legend.

Alexandra

Hannah browns season of the bachelorette or love is blind (Seattle season)

Michelle McGraw Trela

YESSSSS. My gf and I are huge watchers of dating/relationship reality shows, and this is my fave season of all time. A close 2nd is the most recent season of Love is Blind Sweden.

Natalia Johnson

Love island US season 6 and the ultimatum queer love season

Rachael

Omg... I wanna say Hoarders because it so traumatic and therefore incredible podcast material. But really I want all the opinions on Queer Ultimatum.

Ros

Yesss I love survivor

Emmalee

Another vote for Milf Manor! Temptation Island would be wild to watch too. Mike would absolutely hate it 😂

Madison Patton

Temptation Island is particularly abominable and still pretty new!

Kristine Feleppa

Also, Special Forces on Fox, or throw it way back to Rock of Love with Brett Michaels or Flavor of Love

Emily Ahrens

Vanderpump Rules Season 1, Episode 4: Jax crashes Stassi's birthday wearing a chunky sweater and tries to fight Frank in a strip mall parking lot.

Lenka Koudelkova

PLEASE Love is Blind, Season 5 or 7, but I think the whole season is kinda necessary, not just an episode

Brandi Hassouna

The Great Pottery Throwdown. Every time Keith Rymer Jones cries while judging is something I both relate to and is so very cringeworthy. They also make folks build toilets. Artistic toilets.

Natalia Johnson

Also Naked and Afraid (any season or episodes )

Anna Katz

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives plz

Becca

love is blind season 1 absolutely

TS Tout

Kitchen Nightmare’s Season 6 Episode 16: Amy’s Baking Company, an iconic part of the 2010s

Rachel Becker

My Big Fat Fabulous life. Really I want to hear what Aubrey thinks of this series in general. As for FORCE I would recommend season 5 episode 9.

Shelb

Trading Spaces! Unfortunately a lot of it is pretty much lost media, but there's a few full episodes on youtube, including one from Evertt, WA that features a downstairs dining room being transformed into a *taupe and magenta circus tent*

Rachel Pearson

Omg the Love is Blind episode where the guy puts eye drops in his eyes during a talking head to fake that he was crying and the production leaves it in (S3, E3)

Pamela Krier

Love is Blind, Amazing Race, Traitors, The Challenge

Lynna Petkovich

I'm begging for a Traitors recap, please!

Hannah Foulger

Love is Blind?! Even just the wedding episode for the editing.

annabananaramagram

Or Monty Don's garden shows! No I just couldn't take it if he didn't like Monty

Haylie S.

Seeing a lot of bids for Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, which totally makes sense! BUT I felt like you guys got some things wrong about the church in your Brian Johnson segment (source: I'm an Ex-Mormon from a very LDS family, but not from Utah), and I know shows about Mormons set in Utah depict one highly specific cultural thread of the church that certainly doesn't represent my (again, VERY MORMON experience), so all I'm saying is: please proceed with caution?

Haley Hampstead

RHOSLC Season 2 episodes 9-10 (Jen Shah's arrest) RHOBH Season 11 episode 17 (Erika Jayne's infamous monologue) RHONY S8 EP 20 (It's about Tom) or S3 EP 12 (Scary Island) RHOP S3 EP 13 (Mime moment) VPR S3 Ep 7 (Kristin's revenge dress); S6 Ep 7 🍝

Megan

In a list from would make Mike the least upset to the most upset: 1. Great British Bake Off - Series 11 ep. 1 - "Cake Week" 2. Tidying Up with Marie Kondo - any episode they are very similar 3. My Cat From Hell - Season 2 ep 2. - "Mad Max" 4. Hoarders - Any episode 5. Love is Blind - Season 6 ep. 8 & 9 6. Fboy Island - Season 1 ep. 3 7. Jersey Shore - Season 3 ep. 3 "Where's the beach?"

Tania Kliphuis

Farmer Wants a Wife: Australia. Unless you’re really wanting to challenge yourself, in which case, Boer Soek ‘n Vrou (South African Afrikaans culture at its best).

Rachel Morgan

Three words - SUR 👏VI👏VOR👏

Musse

Ok sorry I need to come back and say, like, I was sitting on the edge of my seat, cheering when someone did good, covering my face when someone did bad, it was sooo intense

Michelle McGraw Trela

Oh yeah, Couple to Throuple was some great trash! Never heard of Twin Love though....sounds insane lol

Donny K

Make Mike watch the Amy's Baking company episode of Kitchen Nightmares, I am begging on my knees

Becky E

You Are What You Eat, a UK show where a pretend doctor inspects fat people's poo. Mike will be wretched at every single bit of it.

Nicole Reilly

The Traitors!! This show is obsessive and Alan’s outfits are amazing!!

Amber R-C

Anything that’s got “poop” or digestive stuff in it 😆 failing that - any of the Love is Blind seasons

Sheree Speaks

I don't think it has but when it does Mike should watch it.

Erin Maaskant

The Summit - very unknown, a group of completely inexperienced Americans hike up a legit snow capped mountain in New Zealand. I still don't quite understood how most of them made it up as far as they did.

Nick

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!

al russo

The Real Housewives but specifically of Salt Lake City. My partner and I devour it like candy. Jen Shah is a force to be reckoned with.

Siri Johnson

Super sized vs Super skinny. It's a British dieting show that at one point was avalible on youtube

N. Bowles

Omg anything 90 Day Fiancé 🤪

NaNoWrecked

Oh my God but TWIST- show him the Baked Alaska episode

halley ann

Not a full show but the random episodes of MTVs Next that you can find they are like 10 minutes of gold but especially any of the gay episodes, sooooo good everytime life is bad I rewatch and I laugh so hard everything else seems fine

Caitlin

Married at First Sight UK - the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever watched

Geshem420

Season four of Are You the One is PEAK straight people toxicity. It’s so good. There was a contestant who secretly had a boyfriend and just went on the show to cause drama and get famous, and multiple of the men went truly bonkers over her. That show in general is just genre defining and!!! Groundbreaking in having queer seasons!!!! But yeah Julia is an icon.

Alyx

Below deck or too hot too handle!!! Both are so bad they're funny. Like very enjoyable to watch because they're so fuckin' absurd

alana scott

All my coworkers watch Love is Blind and the only way I would think about joining them is if Mike has to watch it too.

Rebecca Welzenbach

Love is Blind Season 2: it is unequivocally the best season, fantastic heros and villains, the gimmick of the show is at its height (we all get it now....but it's not so overplayed it's not working anymore as in every season that comes after). Some of the best characters in the entire series, some of the most hilarious moments in the entire series, takes place in Chicago, best bachelor party of the entire series. AND a season 2 alum is (now, years later) leading the charge to organize reality tv labor!!!

Elli

Watch the ultimatum queer love

Haylie S.

FWIW my pitch is Love is Blind because Nick and Vanessa Lachey position themselves as so wholesome but they are sooooo toxic

nowfailingoutofschool

SEASON 8 OF ARE YOU THE ONE - their "all bi" season but they didn't want to say bi so instead every time the narrator has to say "sexually fluid community" and it's just hot messy twentysomethings and a man my friends and I were convinced was a plant from accounting sent in to help them make sense of the very complicated math standing between a bunch of queer sluts (affectionate) and $100,000

Michelle McGraw Trela

OMG, he was so nutty/creepy. But so much of the rest of the season is so sweet! (Although my heart also broke for Alicia.)

Wild Girl Wellness

Episode 2, Season 2 of The Valley. It is AWFUL and also it would be funny to hear him try to make sense of it without any of the lore (which barely makes sense anyway...)

Deanna Riese

Came here to say exactly this lol

Catherine Hallam

Traitors UK. I think about the banishment in season 1, episode 1 constantly.

Susan Corcoran

Great Pottery Throwdown (UK) or Traitors!

Alyx

Second this!!!!

Claire Cullen-Delsol

Oh yes! I forgot that particular horror!! And once showed a paramedic dad what his daughter would look like as a cadaver made from chicken nuggets? The Tupperware full of poop wasn't actually the worst bit...

ReganChristeen

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Traitors! - most reason season, the bachelor - episode where Hannah moves the rose stand and says she had sex

Alyx

Second this!!

Sam Thomas

Dog the bounty hunter! Honestly any episode. He's the most quotable reality tv character of the early 2000s.

Emily

Naked Attraction

turbanous

Season 1 Episode 8 for the ridiculous pregnancy reveal

Amy Ellingson

Ex on the Beach - Peak of Love (season 4), which is inexplicably on a snowy mountain instead of a beach

Claire Robinson

Traitors US both seasons but especially the second season

Shelley Rees

Love Is Blind is the most insipid nonsense and I would love an episode on it

Kyla M Winchester

Couple to Throuple was trash but would likely make for a hilarious episode.

Sarah Carton-Wirth

Amazing Race! The first seasons are especially filled with violently ugly American attitudes towards people in the countries they're racing through, plus couples who need to not be together AT ALL.

DINKing with a vengeance

Or that one season of bachelor in paradise where the one girl Sam had a “poop baby” and had to leave the show aka most recent season

Ariel Burgess

Temptation Island. Literally any episode. It's just crazy, and Mike would definitely hate it.

Emma Mendelson

-RHONY season 3 ep 12 (scary island!!) -the bisexual season of are you the one -from couple to thruple

Rachel Anderson Tucker

This is fan service and I’m here for it. In the spirit of flipping table, throwing drinks, and examining hetero dating norms, Love Island UK (Hulu) Season 5, episodes 44 & 45. They are such long episodes, so you only really need to watch the last ten minutes of episode 44 and the first 15min of episode 45. Also, we know Michael loves to dunk on the UK given the opportunity. They’re only like 5% better than us.

Linda Glantz

Love Is Blind! Please make him watch. Every season is equally terrible!!

Viljatuuli

This may be too close to health because it's sports, but me and my partner have been obsessed with Physical: 100, it's this terrible and super unfair sports reality, it's amazing.

Tez

Yessss! This episode is classic!

Erica Baron

Just want to put in a nomination for How to Build a Sex Room on Netflix. It's like every other home makeover show except they make bespoke sex rooms. It's quite something!

Liz Fo

VH1’s Rock of Love

Mary Maxwell

Will also put a co-sign on for the Hannah season of the bachelor, particularly the Fantasy Suites episode where she finally comes out of her delusion and realizes how much Luke sucks.

Claire Cullen-Delsol

That's what my brother called it too! Well, how clean is your stool. They were on the same channel around the same time I think?

Caroline McLean

TV peaked with the queer season of Are You the One

Joelle Killian

Drag Race was my intro to reality TV! But maybe not as horrifying as you're looking for :D

Rebecca Wilson

My cat from hell! Judging clueless pet owners is my favorite!

Hope Moser

I don't have episode suggestions but am obsessed with Married at First Sight!

Sarah Wolf

Bad Influence, a 3 part documentary on Netflix about child influencers . It’ll scratch that YouTube drama itch, and inspire much discussion.

Kirsten P

Real Housewives of Beverly Hills ep. Amster-damn! I'm just assuming that's one of Mike's favourite RH fights that he loves to watch.

Becky Patouhas

What about the documentary Spellbound, about the Scripps Spelling Bee? It's basically the length of a long episode, not health-related, but lots to talk about, and the kids are grown now so hearing about that would be interesting

Emma Mendelson

Yes watch season 2 ep 10 when she gets arrested!!

LawyerGAL

Amazing Race season 5 episode 11 aka the “My Ox Is Broken” episode. Survivor season 39 episode 8 aka “the reason many women stopped watching survivor” (Google Kellee Kim)

Seaburner Lio

Milf Manor!! The first episode of season 1 is enough, but the longer he can make it, the better

Nora Cobo

The memory of that circus tent is burned in my brain

Hope Moser

Also Are You The One - something from the queer season ideally

Stacy Wilkes

The ultimatum queer edition!

Serena

Mike would be absolutely baffled that Say Yes To The Dress has as many seasons as it does. 😍

Katie Pier

Kitchen nightmares Amy's Baking Company

Christina Schultz

16 and pregnant/teen mom! The 16 and pregnant episodes you get the full story in one episode whereas teen mom is ongoing. The parents of the teens on 16&P are INSANE That or America’s next top model! There’s enough controversy to go around but season 4 episode 5 they do a “race swap” photo shoot 😬

Kristin

Omg, PLEASE show him RHOSLC. I believe the very first episode involves a feud that is ignited because Mary Cosby (an alleged cult leader who is married to her step-grandfather) tells Jen Shah (who is now in federal prison with Elizabeth Holmes for scamming elderly people) that she “smells like hospital.” ICONIC. Plus, Mormonism.

Kirsten Barringer-Cook

He might actually enjoy pit bulls and parolees, but Mike surprises me. I expect him to nit pick the formula.

NoJo

Go old school! Jersey Shore or Rock of Love (both dark ass hetero gender studies)! Or go back to one of the OG reality TV shows like the original Temptation Island from 2001. Or Megan Wants a Millionaire (particularly dark back story on that one 😬)

Lynn Wiser

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Jessamyn Larsen-Kast

I'd love for him to watch I didnt know I was pregnant. Any episode

Rebecca B-B

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City

h. p.

I think the lawless 00s era of reality television has some gems we can't let fade into history. Literally just the introductory episode of Playing it Straight has sent my friends and I into hysterics. Kid Nation is also completely bonkers in a way that's endearing in an introductory dose. It's more of a full season affair to watch it melt but I watched Finding Prince Charming as a teenager and I think it really inoculated me against specific aspects of gay dating culture. It's such a beautiful and horrible microcosm. Finally, I am obsessed with two Netflix originals from Australia. S1E4 of Instant Hotel is a total fever dream and deep enough into the season that you're aware the voting system of the show makes no sense. Zumbo's Just Desserts is like if British Bake-Off was evil and hated you. It's awesome.

Elin Berg

I beg of you to watch Secret lives of Mormon wives!!!!

Carol Palmer

Does Mike need to clean/organize his house? Then I suggest "Hoarders"

Christy McGillivray

Daisy of Love (the Rock of Love spinoff) - the episode where a skunk gets in the house.

Alexa Chunis

Are we sure we'll be able to find something where Mike will be able to resist being Mike? I'm just imaging picking an episode of Hell's Kitchen, for example, and Mike starts up with "Well I got curious Aubrey, so I spoke to some experts and here is what the science says about calling your subordinate a complete donkey after making them cook a 7 course meal in 15 minutes"

Katie Pier

Bridezillas or go full meta and do The Joe Schmo Show

Rachel Greene

Real Housewives of New York - ep scary island

Jamie Karnes

Survivor Pearl Islands, Ep 11. Iconic episode with Johnny FairPlay and one of the first really despicable moments on survivor. Also the final tribal in season 1 just for the Sue Hawk speech

Kate L

Putting in a vote for The Ultimatum: Queer Love, and then any episode of The Great Pottery Throw Down as a palate cleanser. (My wife and I used to refer to the genre of reality dating shows as "...Are Straight People OK?" so TUQL absolutely wrecked us.)

Matt Owen

I Love New York with Tiffany Pollard. Please and thank you ❤️

Loren Burlingame

Is 90 day fiance still around? One of the Angela episodes. Thinking of one where she accuses her fiance of trying to "swindle me with cake"

Nadia Dam Hansen

Love is blind or the secret life of mormon wives!!

Alejandro wants a Seattle live show

Tiger King Season 1, Episode 3: The Secret You get misogyny, insane true crime, animal abuse, and it's all wrapped up in the time we were confined to quarters during the pandemic.

Hope Mowery

Long shot, but I'd love to see y'all cover one of the VH1 "... of Love" shows from the 2000s (Rock of love, flavor of love)

Mary Riehle

Secret lives of Mormon wives!!!

Fred Maxon

If you watch Hoarders, Michael might want to avoid Season 6, Episode 4 -- Shanna is known as "The Poop lady"

Ali Barthwell

RHONY - The Tequila Mexico trip for drunken madness. RHOA - The Bachelorette party with Bolo RHOSLC - Jen getting arrested or Reality von Tease reveal The Bachelor finale where Arie changes his mind Vanderpump Rules - if you wanna go big, obviously scandoval but literally any episode is a masterpiece. Personal rec - Top Chef - the Chicago season Restaurant wars and the Pop Up Restaurant Wars and Dim Sum episodes from all-stars.

Rose Young

Australian Married at First Sight. Absolute squealing trash, any season, every episode

Kathleen C Harding

Beauty and the Geek. I think Mike would have some amazing things to say about heterosexual culture 🤣

Diana Rodin

Ok, unrelated but are others getting deluged with social media content pushing mouth taping?

Amy

As an Australian, I have to recommend "farmer wants a wife". Also MAFS, it made me question my bisexuality because the women all seem like nice enough people, but the dudes suck. There are also only 2 genders in MAFSland

Christina Bugna

America's Sweethearts, bonus points for the og CMT Making the Team. It's horrifying.

Ella Tootell

Below Deck!! I only recently started watching and it’s terrible and wonderful

Sylvia Hunter

Iron Chef would be fun. Or if you want something wholesome and kind, The Great Canadian Baking Show and/or GBBO. Battle of the Blades (hockey players learn ice dancing with figure skater partners) is very fun.

Faith

Kitchen Nightmares or Hoarders

catthem

Tabatha Takes Over! Any episode but maybe the Finance bro one?

Katie Thomas

Are You the One Season 8, where all the contestants were bisexual.

Phoebe Webb

Okay yes this is the one.

Lizz

Do competition ones count? I'm a huge fan of the Traitors show on NBC/Peacock! But also Love Is Blind has PLENTY of great reality TV moments, especially the reunions 🫣

Abigail Mumma

Please watch I Wanna Marry Harry! It was so unethical they had to cancel it after 4 episodes and truly is one of the most insane pieces of television I’ve ever watched.

Kali

Joining in to also say The Traitors UK, but one I haven't seen anyone mention is Love After Lockup - my girlfriend and I got into this recently and it's WILD. I'd make him watch season 2 because there are multiple absolutely unhinged love triangles that start off in that season

Phoebe Webb

That's one for a main feed episode, it was CRAZY

Elli

Labor of Love!!!

Jamie Karnes

Also a vote for Extreme Cheapskates, a show that feels like if My Strange Addiction or True Life but just about people who go to extremes not to spend money. Season 3 episode 3 (all wrapped up) is particularly good because the things this man does are insane but you also see the more emotional side as his ex wife deals with his extreme habits ruining their relationship

Taylor Clark

Love is blind, secret lives of mormon wives, or even some Say yes to the Dress episodes

Danielle Fritz

Catfish!! There are some great episodes that are just “this isn’t a catfish, these people are just bad at communication/pathological liars.” The Katie Perry episode is especially bonkers, and timely!!

Sara P

Are you the one- season 8 (“the gay season”) Dating show where the cast has met with matchmakers and are trying to figure out who in the house is their match + They get $$ if they all figure out their matches

Annie Bananie

Hoarders…I think he would absolutely hate it

Matthew Farah

Couple to Throuple or F-boy Island

Isabelle Hasman

Below Deck! The heteros are insufferable and the rich people are terrible. Any of the down under seasons are good!

Charlotte Ginder

“Scary Island” RHONY season 3 episode 12, should be studied for sure.

Deirdre

How far back can we go? I think America’s Next Top Model - perhaps cycle 4 or 6

Phoebe Webb

We need a full episode on this one. I can't blame this show for my eating disorder buuuuut it sure was influential as a pre teen.

Lorelei

Season 18 Survivor with Mike White

Jasmine Shirley

Temptation Island season 1 :) also book rec The Doctor’s Kitchen (seems quite good)

Natalie Morehouse

I am obsessed with this. My suggestion is Survivor— specifically season 32. Any episode— but specifically episode 2 is pretty gross. But also just a great reality TV season!

Rebeccuh

I want to say Hoarders but those just wind up making you feel sad so how about an old Bridezillas? Those were nuts in a fun (?) way.

Annalisa Castaldo

I have no idea which episode would be best, but I'd love to hear Mike deal with the mess in any Hoarders episode.

Grace H

RHOSLC season 2, episode 10. Jen is arrested for her fraudulent telemarketing biz that steals from elderly people. Then the rest of the ladies go to Vail. Meredith is in a bubble bath for at least 15 minutes of the episode

Mckay Grundstein-Helvey

Jersey shore, first season, all of it. Rock of love with Brett Michaels … really really bad.

Phoebe Webb

I retract my last comment, Naked Attraction is the only option.

Angela Smith

Intervention season 2 episode 18. Cristy in all her dancing naked on the back of her couch, diagramming the steps between her and God, asking strangers at the gas station if they're allowed to buy alcohol glory.

Julia

PLEASE have him watch The Traitors, I think he would get so into the psychological aspect of it

Danielle Fritz

The old school Trading Spaces has some bananas episodes. Hay glued to walls, faux turf in living rooms, etc.

Mary

Married at First Sight Australia or Love After Lockup

Anna

Vanderpump Rules!! Elite reality tv and also straight hell!

Cassandra Lewis

A Hannah B bachelor episode could be awesome. Or maybe the finale where Ari breaks up with becca 🤔 I’ll be obsessed no matter what you pick 🥰

Victoria Borges

Seconding the vote for Great Pottery Throw Down as a palate cleanser! My favorite season was the one with AJ

Moon Unit

Trading Spouses, God warrior episode (Marguerite Perrin) part 1 and part 2. I don't know the season but I think the whole episode is on youtube

Abby Hassler

Singles Inferno! Really, really interesting approach to food and eating in a dating show. First or latest seasons.

Rebecca Gordon

Either season 3 or 11 of VPR. So messy, so much weird organic and performative conflict, so much Lisa Vanderpump having the world’s strangest definition of what’s sexy. Although maybe this is just me wanting to listen to you all yell about it rather than something Mike should be subjected to.

Kelly Kenneally

Selfishly I want you to watch The Secret Lives of Morman wives (there's only one season and it's all sooooo good) because I want to hear your takes on it! Because Mike is squemish I think you should do Kitchen Nightmares, get him really grossed out.

Sarah LeNoir

DANCE MOMS Season 3,episode 12. It's a double length titled "the apple of her eye" and it includes insane behavior and the phrase "it's 2013 now, racism is gone"

Phoebe Webb

I was about to go off before I saw you said you hated it.

Sara W

I'm throwing my hat in the ring for either survivor or naked and afraid. Maybe the first episode of this last season of survivor with pod save bro Jon Lovett? Nice crossover lol

Phoebe Webb

Oooooh yeah the original seasons with the woman from Atomic Kitten.

Taru Kortelainen

Are You The One season 8, aka the all bisexuals season. It’s messy and fun with a ridiculous premise. Minus points for me because I don’t think Mike will hate it. He might die of second hand embarrasment though 😊

Kayla Leader

I think it has to be hoarders because often the cleaners are dealing with poop, and we know Mike can't handle that. 🤣

Elizabeth Lewis

The bachelor presents Listen To Your Heart

Sarah LeNoir

Also consider "couple to throuple" - it's easy to breeze through the whole thing and it's chaotic af

Quinn

90 day fiance!

Katie

Seconded!!!

Jacqui

Omg please do survivor, specifically the series where they thought it was a good idea to divide contestants by race (!!!).

Mckay Grundstein-Helvey

Not a reality show but I really want Mike to to an episode on “The Way Down: god, greed, and the cult of Gwen Shamblin” and other such religious weight loss cults.

Laura Patterson

Any episode of hoarders where the subjects have what my partner refers to as a “poop nest”

Hayley

Love island UK, married at first sight Australia, or 90 day fiance

Krista

Survivor for sure, the episode where Jeff Varner outs Zeke as trans at tribal council as part of his strategy to avoid being voted off is epic. Season 33 episode 4.

Laura L

90 Day Fiance, specifically Danielle and Mohammed's storyline in season 2. It continues the first season of two of the spinoff, Happily Ever After, as well.

Sarah Erdman

Real Housewives of NJ season 1 finale. There is so much animal print, so much hairspray, an actual table flip and a scream of "Prostitution Whore!" Hurled at one of the women

Becky E

Excellent point, and I just realised it doesn't work with the "no diet/wellness/weight loss" brief. But dear lord, it would be cathartic. Ps hope you're doing ok now x

Publiq Quaker Friend

i don't even watch it, i just know there was a BEFORE and an AFTER of how i get treated bc of THAT show 🙄

Adia Paulete

“She was a showgirl” Queer Eye. Or really any of them. Or Fuckboy island. It’s entertaining as hell. And dumb.

DW

Okay so there are not so much hate watches as...some extremely hateable behaviours, some actual emotional growth, high drama but high payoff: Are you the one season 8 (all contestants are bi/pan/queer/fluid so it tests out what happens if anyone there can date anyone else); the ultimatum queer love season 1; the ultimatum (hetero love?) season 1.

Megggggggzy

Episodes 1-4 of Traitors Season 3

Elise Roche

Perfect Match!!!! It's classic reality trash with a more old school MTV spin- BUT keeps interest of non-reality lovers because their is a challenge/riddle element that you are trying to solve as the viewer as they go and Mike loves a challenge/finding an answer! there are like 20 people and "psychologists" have determined 10 "perfect matches" and they have a few weeks in a house to figure them all out, and get docked money each week they mess up the pairs. In terms of seasons idk they did ONE lgbtq one but it made the show way harder on the math side lol

Samson Harman

THE SECRET LIVES OF MORMON WIVES. I don't mean to yell but it's a reality tv show about "MomTok" - a group of Mormon ladies in Utah. It really exposes how messy and hypocritical these influencer Moms are to a satisfying degree.

Moon Unit

The Anna-Nicole Show. Any episode with Bobby Trendy.

Sam Zuckfinkwitz

Love 👏 is 👏 blind 👏 (season 3, the episode where Bartise gives his thoughts on abortion specifically haunts my dreams)

Emily Van

90 Day Fiancé any season but just go Season 1!

Lydia Gerike

Ultimatum! Either the first season or the queer love one

Emily Piff

perfect match queer love!!

Victoria Borges

If it's not too upsetting at this point, might I suggest the first season of The Apprentice? America's Next Top Model would also be great!

Robin Adams

Love is Blind or Mormon Wives!

JAJankity

Season 10 of Vanderpump Rules!

Colleen Yeakle

Oh, this is so a job for Southern Charm!! Season 1 is a riveting rollercoaster of appalling behavior. Fancy people; foolish conduct. (though there are some deeply troubling moments of threats and physical aggression).

Sarah Erdman

Oh that's PEAK trash TV. I loved it.

Jennifer Williamson

I've been meaning to watch Alone Australia because my fellow reality tv watching friend described it as a series about smug men losing.

Victoria Eden

It might be too close to a show topic, but early America's Next Top Model. Tyra screaming at Tiffany. Shandi cheating on her boyfriend. High drama.

Lily Nellans

ANTM cycle 4, the worst of the show is really on display. Includes the posing in graves episode (and the contestant whose bestie just died freaking out), a posing with dangerous animals episode, a switching races challenge, and mistreatment of contestants throughout. Truly Tyra at her most unhinged.

Shannon Godwin

They’ve done this one! October 2021

Laura Alix

Millionaire Matchmaker. The Nick & Omar episode.

Rebecca

I want him to watch one episode of Kitchen Nightmares (maybe the insane ABC Bakery one, just because it's so notorious, and I don't think that kitchen had anything in it that might make Mike vomit), one episode of Hell's Kitchen, one episode of Master Chef Junior, and one episode of something from Gordon Ramsay's British ouerve, just for the full gamut of Gordon Ramsay.

Sarah Erdman

There have been a LOT of votes for that

Marianne

the traitors, but specifically the uk version!! claudia winkleman is so camp and the fact that it’s not celebrities makes for better gameplay imho, and is maybe more mike-friendly

Brienne Rosman

Vanderpump Rules. From the beginning. You wouldn’t want to miss Jax fighting his way out of a chunky knit sweater in a bar parking lot.

Robyn Harvey

If it wasn't for the no weight loss shows caveat I would have said You Are What You Eat, fronted by "Dr" (not a doctor) Gillian McKeith; only because the sheer level of BM talk would drive Mike insane.

Gwen Kingston

Out of affection for Mike I will go slightly off brief and recommend a wonderful show: Love on the Spectrum Season 1 💕

Sarah Erdman

And Stassi! Were they calling themselves the witches of weho by then?

Joy

Love island so he can make fun of the British

Leah Dooley

The Seattle season of Love is Blind!!

Sarah Wolf

This show makes my cold black heart grow 3 sizes larger. So heartfelt, and the judge who cries about teacups etc is such a sweetheart.

Katie

Southern Charm!!

Hannah Smith

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Jo Hewitt

You must get him to watch Celebrity Big Brother UK series 4 (2006), day 8.

T Shaaban

Drag race season 9 episode 9 (the one where valentina goes home) !!!!

orange fox

FARMER WANTS A WIFE plzzzz it's so funny and weird. 4 farmers each get 5 women to go LIVE at their farms and see if they can hack it as farm wives and they get engaged to one at the end. The farmers say things like "she's as cute as a sick pup sleepin under the shade of a wagon wheel"

bear

Rock of Love or 90 day fiance

Jessica Piper

Season 3 or 5 of Love Island UK - by far the best ones

Grace H

The AUDACITY of Arie. Sooo boring and such an asshole.

Sarah Erdman

I just suggested the season 1 finale. Unironic table flip? Yes please

Sarah Erdman

Do you listen to Everything Iconic? Danny plays that audio CONSTANTLY

August Enger

Love Island (uk) was enough to make my partner hide in a corner with his head in his hands! I think we were watching season 5 (2019)

Mj

Do love is blind season 2 and the reunion or you can. I want Mike to see the Love is Blurry guy!!

Nisha Riley

The gay season (season 8) of Are You the One? Genuinely the best season of gay reality TV imo!

Keeley

Seconding all those saying ANTM but really, if older shows are on the table, any of those old VH1 dating reality shows would be so fun. Flavor of Love, I Love New York, Rock of Love are so fun and unhinged

Alexa Burke

Love Island USA season 6!!!

Katie

America’s Next Top Model? Whew, that show does NOT hold up on re-watch. Can’t remember the episode (it may be the first one) but in Season 5, Kim is told to basically not act so gay (and Tyra compares it to her not having to make being Black a huge part of her identity which also felt weird). In season 6 they go to Thailand and ride elephants and having lived in Thailand, I know that with even a cursory amount of research, even back then, it’s well-known that elephants used in these kinds of tourist activities are pretty gruesomely abused. Also in season 6, they basically force a girl to get dental surgery to reduce the gap between her teeth (which she actually loves as a part of how she looks). Very hard to watch. And probably the most well-known photo shoots from the show involve having contestants styled and made up as different race (complete with full on blackface) in seasons 4 and 13. I don’t know if you can even find those episodes anymore. But basically any season, any episode you pick, there’s gonna be some major cringe.

Helen Walmsley

Toddlers and Tiaras, My Big Fat G*psy Wedding and Naked Attraction are classics, Come Dine with Me if you want to see the height of middle class British politeness pushed to extremes

Tonya Ricks Sterr

Love is blind, Seattle season. For extra annoyance. 😂

Katrina Connor

I was thinking about this one WHAT a wild time in reality tv this was

Claire Dederer

Wholesome and genuinely wonderful (I know, not actually what you are looking for): Portrait Artist of the Year

Amiee Flynn-Curran

90 Day FIance is my weakness, most drama in an episode: No Turning Back" '90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After?' (Season 3, Episode 8)

frozenpuddy

Forged in Fire: Knife or Death

Laura Reineke

the first two seasons of Vanderpump Rules are like, god-tier good, and they go down easy, esp. if u watch them on 1.5x (which may appeal to mike)

Chloe Briggs

Love on the spectrum season 3 episode 7 (I think he would try to hate it and would kind of love it) or love is blind Seattle season but permission to fast forward through alllll the boring parts/scripted dates

Mwikali

Please I am begging you to watch The Trust! It’s a sleeper hit and a sociological expedition. There is SO much to talk to about in it cause the cast of character are really diverse

Brendan Murphy

This may not count (more of a game show/panel show), but we should make Mike watch Taskmaster. It's actually good!

mish the fish

paris hilton's show where she was looking for a new best friend

Lady Goggles

gotta be kitchen nightmares or - if you want to be slightly old school - bridezillas. i’d LOVE to hear your reactions to either of those!

Saramir

I would love Survivor as well. I thought any episode where they have to do a food challenge that turns out to be bugs!

Katie

I said these same cycles! So much yuck in cycle 6. I do not think Mike would enjoy watching someone be forced to have an extremely long and intense dental surgery in order to be more commercial looking.

Shannon Allen

Hoarders will probably make Michael itch. There is also a horrifying poop episode. Season 6, episode 4 with Shanna

The Wizard Snoop

would love to hear two queer folks really engage with straight culture

(evil)amy

Squid Game Challenge, Celebrity Bear Hunt, Kitchen Nightmares, Traitors Australia season 2, Alone, Rock of Love (omg, sorry Mike!)

Wathgwen

Series 5 of the Great Pottery Throw Down

Nancy

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!

king

An oldie and definitely probably absolutely cringe and horribly problematic today: any episode from MTVs True Life

Becky B

Iron chef would be amazing. Prefer the original Japanese version.

Rebecca Chalmé

Hahaha no I don’t but it is absolutely an iconic line and it is BONKERS to me that you could go on to marry the person you said that to

Natalie Wood

MILF Manor is so cringe-inducing I think Mike would die

Danielle Chastaine

Season 13 of Big Brother from 2011 with Rachel and Brenden. I hated her in 2011 when I was 19 but now I kinda love her? It was classic 2010s drama.

Mich Reynaud

Below Deck Sailing Yacht S2 or Love is Blind S1 or S6. Incredible television

Danielle Chastaine

Also any of the OG episodes of Teen Mom 2 with Janelle and them. Sooo good.

K

For the Love of DILFS (Stormy Daniels is the host)

H e ll a m a l a i s e

Old Dance Moms Episodes! Just totally out of the realm of something he'd ever have exposure to.

Molly Tavella

Secret lives of Mormon Wives is a relatively short one but a really rich text!

Emily

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Alexa Ringer

90 day fiance. any season. any episode.

K

Couple to Throuple was unexpectedly enthralling

Kit K

It's vintage, it's British. Specifically the UK 2005 variant of Playing It Straight, set in 'the hacienda' with a mariachi band doing exposition

king

I second this. The Amy's Baking company episode was iconic.

Samantha Anthony

Physical 100! It's a Korean show about finding the perfect physical form through a series of challenges. It's insane but I love it.

Emily

I didn’t know this existed! What is it called?

Rebecca Daley

Any of the Real Housewives of New York (original cast) - maybe season 3 featuring Scary Island (Season 3, Ep 12). PS my partner and I have listened to the Bachelorette ep like 3 times and regularly say we'd listen to an entire podcast of just you making Mike watch reality TV so we are beyond hyped 😍

Drew Hardin

Dance moms, secret lives of Mormon wives, love island

Janice Davis

90 Day Fiancé Season 4. Or any season really.

Caroline S

JERSEY SHORE!!!! Season 1, episode 8 where Pauly gets into a fight with his gf over the duck phone. Too iconic

Ally

“Are you the one?” Season 8, the “sexually fluid” season. It’s a show that usually features 10 men/10 women trying to find their perfect match, but they opened this season up to 16 bi/pan/omni folks and it’s the MESSIEST reality tv I have EVER seen 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️

EJ Mears

This. Any and all episodes with Gaggy Windey

Morgan Osborne

Glad to see many of us here are voting secret lives of Mormon wives 😂 I am also not a reality tv person but boy did I dive into that rabbit hole

mish the fish

paris hilton's my new bff (had to look it up). i watched the first season as a tween because i loved the premise that this was how she was finding a friend. funnily, there was a second season

H Foster

controversial but, Rick Steves 🤣

Sara T

How dare you name all of those shows and leave out A Shot At Love with Tila Tequila!

Rachel Wolff

Can we go super old school and do MTV reality shows? I'm thinking My Super Sweet Sixteen and Next would be amazing

Lady Goggles

*definitely* the japanese version. the american one is fine enough, i suppose, but the original is where it’s at

Erica Buist

YES. “Hi Bronson, can we get rid of your eyebrow ring please?”

Suzanne Hart

Absolutely the Bachelor. Bonus if you also make him listen to Game of Roses.

Eayrin

You are what you eat (2004-2006), Gillian Mckeith examining people's BM's!

Amiee Flynn-Curran

Please watch the PBS "reality show" Frontier House (2002). All episodes are on YouTube. It was part of a series but definitely became more 'reality show' format in 2002. Survivor debuted in 2000, so you can feel PBS trying to jump on the reality tv bandwagon with this one - drama, "challenges" and relationship dynamics but with historians popping up each episode to brief us on frontier facts. I watched every episode in 2002 the last year I was still living at home with my 'no tv except PBS' parents, then downloaded it a decade later so my non-US husband could see it because basically Frontier House is my Roman Empire and I never stopped talking about it. I need someone else to see it and comment on it.

Ellen

Oh. Oh no 😂 I can still hear that bloody band

Hannah Loss

Hoarders S6e4 (Shanna/ Lynda) has some serious BAMU triggers...

Bethany

Pretty Wild! I need Mike to see The Secret as part of LA homeschool curriculum.

Hannah Lee

Too Hot to Handle - Season 6, Episodes 8,9,10! 9 is especially cringey :)

cash

RHOSLC - S4E16 has amazing interpersonal drama, S2E10 has an arrest, S5E1 is just pure stupid fun

Ellen

Also, Tool academy....

Angela

Something from HGTV please! Maybe an episode of Fixer Upper?

Sylvia Hunter

Haha I didn’t know there was an American version!

J’Amy

Love Island! It’s so wild.

Rachel Young

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City, Season 2, Episodes 9 and 10.

Aries Jo

“Are You the One” season 8- THE GAY SEASON!!! While I love this season (especially the notorious party drama episode) because it’s gay and I’m gay and it’s great to see gay representation in a reality dating show… it’s also still SO MESSY! And cringy! And train wreck you can’t look away from-y! It’s all the things you want from a reality dating show, but with the queers. There are also awesome sweet moments and characters you love to hate. It’s a MUST WATCH!!! 💜🌈

Maggie Schedl

Aaaaaaanything Gordon Ramsey!!! Old seasons of Kitchen Nightmares are golden but the new one is good too!!

cash

S2Ep 13 please!!! so good

Gina Spiotta Davis

Indian Matchmaking, Top Chef, Queer Eye, Project Runway (original Bravo edition)

Allison Rozich

Baggage with Jerry Springer. Or MILF Manor

Jacqueline K

Too hot to handle s1, the Ari/Becca split on bachelor or baked Alaska drama of GBB S5 E4

Jo Hewitt

Some UK shows which would be good are Tattoo Fixers, Taskmaster, Come Dine with Me (s.10 ep. 29 is particularly good), Embarrassing Bodies, The Supervet, First Dates, The Dog House, 24 hours in A&E Bizarre ER, Gogglebox

Maddie

Next or Room Raiders if we want to make him extra uncomfortable. Early aughts MTV was unhinged.

RJ

Love is blind. Mike is gonna hate it.

Ellen

Traitors Austalia season two is truly cursed 😂

Rose Hanuy

please make him watch F-boy island, hosted by nikki glazer. season 1. i feel the show takes the complexities of straight people dating to new levels that only Mike can interpret for the rest of us.

Casey Connor

I know it's old, but Bad Girls Club remains a classic.

cash

omg the phantom of the opera episode is so good

Amy Summers

The Ultimatum Oops All Lesbians season, 90 Day Fiancé, or Married at First Sight!

Cate Kneale

There was an extremely cringe UK one called Too Posh to Wash but that might be too bad. The same women made How Clean is Your House before that which is more of a cult classic. All episodes are basically the same and involve extreme grunge, cat poo, and dead mice and cleaning tips with feathered marigolds. Kim Woodburn is now fully focused on celebrity feuds instead. Apparently there's also a US version but I'm a purist.

Charlotte Coulombe

If you wanna lean more towards enrage Mike, I recommend Wife Swap

Hadley

Temptation Island. The first 3 episodes. These couples need therapy! The straights are not okay!

Brandy VanLoo

Too Hot To Handle! The show is about as mindless as reality TV can get.

Ann Parker

Bad Girls Club!! Or Jersey Shore

Cate Kneale

All of Pottery Throw Down is lovely though and I don't think that Mike will hate it.

Brandy VanLoo

I'm assuming GBB is Great British Bake-off? If so, then I'd also recommend the Signature challenge from S11 E4 where they all fantastically fail at making brownies

Ave

Wife swap PLEASE!! Everyone is suggesting dating shows but this would be so good to review

Megs

Naked attraction (any series, any episode 🤣)

Moe

This isn't quite what you want I know, but the Great British Pottery Throwdown is so sweet (or whatever the proper title is). One of the hosts, a man, is consistently brought to tears by the beauty of the pottery and I just think it could be a nice pallet cleanser for Mike 🙂

Elizabeth Kite

Awwww, I love Frontier House! Gentle reality show, PBS style, though you still get the drama of that one couple's marriage disintegrating in real time. They did later versions (Manor House, some UK-based WW2 home front house) but none had the same charm. I did enjoy the WW2 contestants getting driven insane by the constantly shifting ration requirements.

Alyssa Cartee

Pretty Wild (the pilot mostly)...homeschooling based on The Secret would make Mike explode

K Beth

90 day fiancé season 6 any episode or any episode from any season.

Haley Miller

The Queer Love season of The Ultimatum - it's a bunch of lesbians couples who switch partners and do trial marriages before getting back together with their original partner and deciding whether to marry their original partner, stay with their new gf or just break up.

Christine LaFleur

Anything from the 90-day universe, especially Jasmine and Gino or Sister Wives!

Jo Hewitt

Try Ice Road Truckers or Deadliest Catch for rugged people doing rugged things. Or Storage Wars or Is it Cake? For something really silly.

Zack

MILF Manor! It is on MAX and it is wild! 2 seasons, first season the sons date each others moms (and have to sleep in the same room as their mom) and the second season it is MILFs dating Dad+Son combos *chefs kiss reality TV*

Rose Hanuy

this show is such a millennial time capsule. Oddly enough, I don't remember the episode where they made a girl reduce the gap in her teeth, but I do remember the episode where they made a girl WIDEN the gap in her teeth! yikes!

Larissa Parson

Seconding Ultimatum queer season! SO GOOD.

Monica Lopez

America’s most smartest model! It’s only one season but made an impression on teen me. Second on the Rock of Love suggestion too!

Cate Kneale

Gipsy Weddings was both fantastic (the dresses!) and horrifically classist and offensive. Definitely peak British telly.

Emily Reeder

Classi bachelor. Do the unhinged season with Becca and Ari.

Nico Peruzzi

Flavor of Love is a favorite of mine. It’s the Bachelor but with the twist that the Bachelor is always Flavor Flav. I think at least season 1 is available on YouTube for free.

Allie Jane Bruce

#Scandoval (vanderpump rules, season 10, episode 15)

Taru Kortelainen

Oh and if you do end up watching Are You the One season 8, the first+second episode (it’s a double episode) is already a banger, the contestants waste ZERO time. Episodes 3 and 4 are also great, I think there are several fights and make ups there. Early season Jenna/Kai relationship is just so high drama, we love to see it.

Masha

Love is Blind - so unhinged!!

Jenna Levy

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City

Rose

Married at first sight Australia, get him dissecting those couch sessions with the experts 😆

cash

Dance Moms S3 Ep 7 or S4 Ep 7 both have good mom fights

Jerri Lynn Knight

Oh thank god, I'm not the only one who remembers this unhinged show.

Hannah Kroese

Ooh, this is an oldie and it probably didn’t age well—Tila Tequila’s A Shot at Love. Another cringey British one is My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding. And I think this one is hilarious, but Mike might hate it because the humor can be super awkward—Taskmaster, the season with Lisa Tarbuck, especially the episode with a cake.

Maggie

Netflix has had some particularly wild shows in the last few years- either Too Hot To Handle or Love Is Blind would be good!

Zack

S16 - Fans vs Favorites, though IDK if Mike could do a full season, which is necessary for Survivor

Michelle

GameChanger: The Bachelor (season 5, episodes 7 and 8)

Meg Ford

What about the episode of Naked and Afraid where one contestant washes her ass in their water supply and then gets sick from it. Much Bamoo.

Elizabeth Sorrell

Traitors so he can get a taste of multiple realty universes.

Aimee

Below deck! Because it’s got interesting commentary on class and I stg he will physically not be able to stop watching.

Emma Cowley

Yasssss SURVIVOR! My husband got me into this show and now it’s my favourite reality TV. Hate drama and back stabbing IRL but I’ll happily watch other people doing it on TV. I’ll suggest a couple of recent seasons so they seem more ‘relevant’, there’s some absolute classics in the early seasons but they may feel dated. Season 44: couple of very memorable characters and an unexpected, cunning underdog as the winner. Season 46: so many meme-able moments, just utter chaos, great fun. Votes at Final Tribal Council (to decide the winner) was DRAMA. Season 47: laugh out loud moments, some innovative strategic gameplay and a very satisfying, worthy winner.

Allie

Traitors USA Season 3! Would love to hear y'all talk about the outfits, drama, and Tom Sandoval. My personal favorite is Season 3, Episode 8 where we get to hear Tom's "musical talents"

Jorie Slodki

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Season 1. It's only eight episodes, but if you have to narrow it down watch Episode 3, "The Book of Sinners & Saints" (the one with the "fruity cereal" prank) and Episode 6, "The First Book of Sin," (the moms go to Las Vegas and Zac freaks out over the idea of Jen going to a Chippendales show).

Summer T

One of the Bachelorette episodes with Hannah Brown, the home towns one solely for lukes staged ass church scene. (and then the episode after fantasy suites for a palate cleanser)

Alexis Wallace

Queer Eye S09 E01 "She Was A Showgirl"

Meg

Taskmaster isn’t reality TV. But I would also add Naked Attraction to the list.

Becca Simon

RHOSLC was my first thought, but all these Secret Lives of Mormon Wives votes made me question it. This comment just made it so clear to me. How could I ever discard RHOSLC?!

Annika

I would love Mike's take on My Big Fat Gypsy wedding.

Kara Youngs

Hoarders! One with many cats.

Luigi Liccioni

Please, do the Real Housewives, I think hearing you commenting this would permanently fix me. RHOSLC season 2 episode 10, the arrest. Or RHOBH some early season with LVP Or Some good old RHONY

Julie

Watch Marrying Millions. It's about "regular" people getting with millionaires (part of the fun is guessing which couples are real and which ones are fake). Focus on the Desiry and Rodney storyline: I stg all of Rodney's friends and family were hinting that they think he's in the closet

Rubaiya Shahrin

OK final suggestion: the Anthony Bourdain food travel show (i forget the name)

Aimee

Right!?!

Emma Trevor

Smothered or Extreme Sisters <3 the cringe! the laughs!

Elif

Any bachelor/bachelorette!!!

Janine

I vote for Hoarders. I don’t watch reality shows, so that’s all I got. 🤣

Stephanie S

Salt lake ! Receipts! Proof! Timelines!

Sarah Hewitt

Yes, this is the right answer. It is one of the most beloved seasons and has lots of people to root for and against! Even if Mike wasn’t from Seattle, this would be the right LIB season to watch!

Cindy Webber

Or S13 E4 "Mexican Week" where they get everything wrong about Mexican food and Paul Hollywood defends bad opinions and says 'taco' super weird.

Fayelle

Survivor season 4 with Boston Rob or season 7 with Jonny Fairplay. I would pay extra money to witness Mike's reaction to Jonny Fairplay.

Aimee

Damn. I don’t want to endorse an option that is not my pick (Below Deck), but Mike would HATE this. And the finale payoff would be cathartic. Second this.

Amy Savage

Love is Blind! The British one :)

thestateofBri

the Bachelorette episode where Hannah Brown moves the podium after she eliminates the born again virgin and he wont take no for an answer or the episode before when she says I had sex in a windmill four times and Jesus still loves me!

Emma

The Circle!! Season 1 (US) is incredible but honestly all of them are bananas and fun.

ZH

Love is blind, specially the seattle season, or “are you the one” season 8, a dating show in which every contestant is bi (just for that one season) and the showrunners were maybe not prepared for the number of orgies that broke out as a result

lizziebee

the traitors! preferably the uk one lol

Braonán

Paranormal Home Inspectors, any episode.

Kitchen Sink

Not reality TV but you guys should watch s7e3 of King of Queens, “Furious George.” Doug joins a support group for abusive relationships while Carrie thinks he is there for over-eaters support group……RICH FUCKING TEXT.

Lauren Joyner

Specifically the choir auditions - between Whitney and Angie H in their costumes and Lisa's terrible Away in the Manger, it's the most cringeworthy TV ever

RJ

The original Below Deck season 7 has to be one of the most toxic and season 6 the most entertaining. Don't know how far you've gotten. I hate myself for saying this but I also love Below Deck Sailing Yacht LOL

thestateofBri

the traitors episode when they get married during the challenge and they are all wearing red. its very gay

Kayla Hower

Mama June from Not to Hot!

Aimee

Yessssss!

Daphné Yogi

The OG Love is Blind. Season 1.

Leslie

F Boy Island

Linda

Several of my friends love this show, I would love to hear Aubrey and Mike talk about it! (I found myself so concerned for the women, and also unable to differentiate between some of them, so I didn't stick with the show, but I think the commentary would be great on this one!)

Rachel H.

Season 249 of "America" is absolutely bonkers and has everyone climbing the walls. The producers and editors have totally lost the plot. Cannot wait to hear his reaction. 🍿

Fenstar

I second this. Episode 5 is the one I would watch! But all of them are cringe and train wreck and compulsive viewing.

ARI

Naked Attraction! British ‘dating’ show where people see the genitals before the face

Leah Leiner

Below Deck Season 7 in Thailand— it’s literally bananas

Lindsay

The hoarders episode with the poop eating lady. So horrible and so incredibly sad.

Ivy Cross

Millionaire Matchmaker

Melissa O

Vanderpump Rules is the pinnacle! Season 1.

Staige E. Davis

Any British “comfort” shows! With Mike’s background in global human rights, I would love to hear his takes on why we (I) love “gentle” TV from the world’s #1 colonizer. GBBO, Task Master, and The Great Pottery Showdown come to mind.

Christine

Love is blind because I want his head to explode at how often they describe it as “an experiment”

Lindsay

Wife swap (or trading spouses, can’t remember) with the pirate wife is a good one, or the medieval family

Sarah

Below Deck season 3.

Josie T

90 day fiancé!

Jerri Lynn Knight

A group of friends and I watched a season of this together online during covid quarantine, at my request. They started out just humoring me, but by the end everyone was so invested (but also so full of secondhand embarrassment)!

Lindsay

If you can find Crowned, that is my all time favorite

Freda

If you want something genuinely enjoyable you should watch some game changer or taskmaster because y'all deserve that in your lives If you want some NONSENSE I think about the first season of love is blind at least once a week for being absolutely bananas

Madeleine Burkholder

Catfish would I think Mike lose his mind, and Rod and Ebony from season 1 is particularly wild. (As a trans woman I’m allowed to endorse that episode). Kya and Alyx from the same season might be a cute chaser

Sarah Bauer

I would love to make Mike watch Too Hot To Handle 😂

Emily C

Hoarders bc there will undoubtedly be poop stuff

Elizabeth Doherty

Not for this, because it was a shame-you-about-what-you-eat show, but I remember an absolutely what-the-fuck show from BBC America with a horrible woman who made people poop in a box so she could shame them for the quality/consistency of their poop... It was absolutely bugfuck.

Sylvan Tomlin

I would say milf manor season 1, but honestly i had to leave the room when I was forced to watch it because it is a streaming human rights violation.

AE

Below Deck Sailing Yacht, Season 2. A perfect blend of all types of reality drama, plus Michael can hate both the crew and the guests.

Carleigh

90 day fiancé season 2 episode (8-11) season 4 ANY episode or 90 day fiancé happily ever after season 3 episode 8 where River and Pedro get into a huge fight at dinner

Allie V

Love is Blind Season 1, including alllll the follow up episodes!

Sarah Akers

I don’t watch a lot of reality TV, but I do have at least one guilty pleasure that should be sheer torture for poor Mike: Hoarders. Especially if you chance on an episode that has “bamu stuff”. Now, for comic relief, how about The Traitors? The premise is utterly ridiculous, but it’s worth it for host Alan Cumming’s fabulous outfits!

Eric Schobel

Forged in Fire is a competition show where four amateur bladesmiths forge a knife in three hours. Then the hosts chop up pig carcasses and ice blocks to see which knife is the toughest. It’s the most insanely masculine coded show on TV and I think Mikes head will explode.

KWV

Yesssss

KWV

Naked Attraction!!

Alan Daly

Selling sunset for sure will ruin Mike 😂

Elizabeth Doherty

I'm going to suggest the episode of either Trading Spaces or Changing Rooms where the interior decorator insisted on painting the brick fireplace and the homeowner absolutely lost it

Meredith Ruff

Love Island or Too Hot to Handle!!! Or the Queer Ultimatum. Please 🥹🥹🥹

Emily Hood

Love Island! Any season, they’re all crazy.

Michaela Stewart Van Uden

Ha for just the brash experience of being thrown into British Saturday high street nights across the land experience... Geordie shore...do make sure you give him a kebab and some aftershock shots for atmosphere

KWV

Has anyone suggested Selling Sunset yet? It’s my guilty pleasure. The houses! The outfits!

Alexis

Dating Around if you want cringe. One person goes on multiple blind dates each episode. It's been a while since I watched but the episode that I remember most is S2 E2! Say I Do is more of a cute/emotional comfort show where they do surprise weddings. It only has one season

Jonathan

Married At First Sight

Jorie Slodki

It's got everything. Mormons! Bizarre fashions! Incomprehensible fights over TikTok clout! Catty moms who weren't even alive when 9/11 happened!

Emma

literally any episode of 4 weddings, first episode of vanderpump rules, first episode of RHOBH

Jazmin Evers

Please watch Sexy Beasts on Netflix! Any or all episodes.

Sarah Hartzell

Vanderpump rules, probably season 1 episode 4 or the scandoval episode, season 10 episode 15

Rachel

This is a good one, there are a couple other Trading Spaces disasters - whole room painted brown when the homeowner said "anything but brown" and a bathroom where they glued fake flowers to the walls.

Subadubdub42069

Love is Blind Season 1 - they call it an experiment the whole time and there is nothing scientific happening!

Leah Leiner

Or if you want something truly horrifying, America’s next top model cycle 4. They do blackface, they bury a girl whose friend just died, several cameos of a shirt that says “don’t feed the models”, make a girl who “gained weight” pose as an elephant. Just completely unhinged.

Dory Peacock

Love is Blind! Its the worst one!

Leigh K Schroeder

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. I know it's not a classic, but what a hook!

Brita Dorfman

I would love to see mikes reaction to fboy island

Elizabeth Doherty

Or (same show) one of the ones where the designer glued hay to the walls of a room or (same designer!) decided that an interior room really needed to be a sandbox: just dumped wheelbarrows full of sand all over the floor

Alexandra Furey

I'm just wrapping up Season 12 of Married at First Sight AU and it is ABSOLUTELY UNHINGED. 10/10 recommend if you're into garbage television. This is the best MAFS season I've ever had the pleasure of watching.

Alyssa Haley

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 3 episode 12 “White Lies and Black Eyes”

Alexandra Furey

I'm just wrapping up S12 of AU and it's UNHINGED

Jo Loui Borup

The first season of Love is blind when Giannina runs away after her fiance says no, one of my fave reality tv moments

Cathy Walsh

Is Christley Knows Best still on? Or Wife Swap? For current shows DEFINITELY Selling Sunset!

Harriet Burt

I feel like The Ultamatum is an appropriately unhinged premise that it's basically absurd comedy

Rachel Helmick

Alone! Season 6 Episode 5 features killing a moose with a bow and arrow. And then all the fun that comes after that.

Jennifer S

It has to be The Ultimatum franchise. The whole thing just weaponizes New Relationship Energy in wild ways. Swap the most recent season, which was a let down, for Ultimatum France! IMO, it’s the best of the bunch.

Elizabeth Doherty

I used to watch that show with my flatmate before I got married, and I've been married for more than 20 years now. The fact that I can call up specific episodes in my memory like this? (I remember the brown room, too!) I feel like the entertainment value would be high!!

Katie

Secret lives of Mormon wives! Former Mormon here, it’s absolute bananas and would love to hear Mike interpret 🤩

Emily

Survivor!!!!! There's so much to choose from, but I recommend going old school. Seasons 1, 2, 7, 13, 18, and 20 are great ones to pick from. New school is also fun (I watch current seasons!), but you want that good reality nonsense? Go old school.

Jessica C

Four Weddings on TLC!!!

Jo Loui Borup

Or when the guy fakes crying with eyedrops. A classic

KWV

For a real bummer, any episode of Supersize Vs Superskinny (UK). My goodness it was a diet culture nightmare for all involved and watching.

Laura Cantrell

WWE Total Divas, probably season 3, episode 3 - plenty of made up story lines & lunches. Bryan Danielson rises above the nonsense in most episodes. Spawned many internet hate-watch recaps.

Tegan Hannah

Love is Blind! My teenager made me watch it and it is the absolute worst (best?). I’ve just seen season 2 but I’m sure they’re all equally terrible so you really can’t go wrong!

Isobel Goddard

I feel like love is blind would be so good for us and so baffling for Mike!

Emily Smouse

The worst ones I can think of have to be Supersize vs Superskinny, The Swan, and Milf Manor (S1)

Marta

Alone season 6 episode 6 where one contestant makes a finger puppet out of a rabbit skin and records the puppet show for her young children

Isobel Goddard

Or maybe temptation island, that one threw even me, haha

Laura

The ultimatum!!

Pip Elder

‘Ladette to Lady’- the British show about making girls behave instead of being themselves. With a lot of alcohol and class systems…

Pip Elder

The Swan. Anything that has plastic surgery as a requirement is awful

Mia

Temptation Island, the only season on Netflix pleeeease! He will lose his mind and we will all comedically benefit from his insanity.

sevenyearsrain

I want to know Mike's strategy for surviving The Circle and suggest S2 E2 (or E3 when Lance Bass enters 😂)

SierraTango

only if it's a Christine season

hey_boo

Everything I know and learned about America I learned from watching WIFE SWAP. It is a relic of early reality TV (up there with The Simple Life) and a fascinating insight into group think, religion, domestic abuse, child abuse and gender roles through the lens of 2005 with editors who gave ZERO shits about making people look bad. It belongs in a time capsule. After watching Wife Swap, I'm not surprised America is in the situation it's in. 10/10

Jennifer Mateer

Love is blind where the guy does the fake cry with eye drops?! Or a below deck episode where the woman jumps in the way drunk? Or the women who has new dietary restrictions out of nowhere? 90 day fiance the other way?

Olivia

Oooh please do the Queer Ultimatum

Jessica

Is that Mike white’s season?! So good!

hey_boo

S3 E16 Haigwood/Hess-Webb ---- one family only eats raw meat, they don't drink water because they think hydration is bad for you, and they brush their teeth with butter.

Emma

The last episode or two of the 2024 Uk Traitors for how ordinary people can be so wrong in how they assess each other and a victory can leave a hollow feeling. And Claudia Winkelman presenting with high Goth ridiculousness.

Daniel

Parts Unknown?

Pip Elder

All of these are British (I love British tv… just not these!) Secret Eaters. Snog Marry Avoid. Supersize vs Superskinny. How to look good naked.

Eleanor Howell

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City! Just watched the whole show while dealing with a very stressful thing, it’s been getting me through 😂🫠

Kaitlin Kelly

I cannot think of a more Maintenance Phase show that the one season unhinged as hell show Bridalplasty. The triggering nature of women competing for plastic surgery is offset by one of the most compelling hero/villain arcs of all time. So much to unpack.

Katherine Blackburn

Sweethearts on Amazon prime about seniors in high school deciding whether to stay together for college or break up but maybe you really need to watch the whole season… any episode of too hot to handle that includes a “workshop” 😂

Ellen Walter

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City, season 2 episode 10 (there's a fugitive) OR season 3 episode 12 (is there a fugitive?). Both absolutely captivating, I-can't-believe-this-isn't-scripted shitshows.

Emily

i’m imagining mike having a mental breakdown at the assignment of nicknames alone

Cosette Weaver

If you want a wild fucking time in the real housewives universe, real housewives of Orange County, seasons 9 and 10 deal with some bonkers medical stuff.

LAURA D

MILF Manor, especially Season 1. Extreme cringe because the moms and the sons are on the show together.

Rachelle

Temptation island

Jude Armstrong

90 day the other way any season, really, but the second season really has a lot of the lore in it.

Katherine Minns

Live island! Specifically the Australian one

Alicia Shapard

My Kitchen Rules, Season 10 - the Romel episodes. We just love an Australian reality show and Romel was just the *worst* contestant.

Genevieve Starke

House Hunters, Love is Blind, or Dance Moms!

Krystal

Also Below Deck (original), Season 3. Rocky Dakota!

Courtney Mills

Real housewives of Atlanta season 3 episode 5 “hot mamas day.” It features a hilarious maternity photo shoot and discussions of how long a pregnancy lasts that have to be seen to be believed. One of the greatest episode of reality tv.

Ashley Lackey

Vanderpump rules or the valley !!! You could do vpr season 6 paired with the valley now

Laura McLachlan

Married at first sight - Australian version. Everyone is terrible, it’s the best

Courtney Mills

Also first 3 seasons of vanderpump rules are amazing as is season 1 of the valley.

Kelsey James

There are some really standout episodes of My Strange Addiction. I will never forget the one about the woman who was addicted to eating her dead husband’s ashes.

Ellen Marten

I am old so I want it to be America’s Next Top Model. An early seasons episode. I’ll say cycle 4, episode 3: “The girl who pushes Tyra over the edge” because it’s iconic and a meme. What happened in the entire rest of that episode? Who knows? I’d love you to remind me. “I was rooting for you! We were all rooting for you!”

Mitchell

Too hot to handle - all the weird bullshit around abstenciance = purity = morality?! 😂

Leann G

Love me some 90 day fiancé!

Elizabeth Archer

YES this one would be the worst for him to watch and the funniest to hear his perspective on

Liz

Real housewives of Salt Lake City specifically season 2, at least the episode where Jen gets arrested

Jennifer S

The Supersizers Go…. It’s 8 episodes of Sue, Perkins and Giles Coren living and eating as if they were in the Regency era, the 1970s, during the second world war, etc. It’s amazing. Highly recommended.

Carly Ann Braun

1. Cirie Fields education: make him watch all the seasons of survivor she has been on, then traitors. 2. Queer Are You The One 3. Queer Ultimatum

L

The episode of the Kardashians with Bryan Johnson in it 😵‍💫

Maevelbee

I have a special place in my heart for The Circle - Mike would probably hate it but maybe not too bad? 😆 You gotta go Season 1

Marta

Frontier House (single season), the PBS take on reality television, where families must live as though they are on the frontier. They give up modern amenities, wear prairie dresses, build log cabins, etc. Spectacular failures abound and divorces ensue.

Rachel

Housewives all the way

Leah

Ultimatum- Queer Love

chalmecatecuhtli

90 Day Fiance! Specifically the earlier seasons with Ed/Rose, Jorge and Anfisa, Danielle and Mohammed.

Liliana

If you want something genuinely bizzare and brilliant, you should watch I Kissed a Girl - it's an all lesbian dating show that just gets so messy, and Dani Minogue is... also there! The first episode will give you plenty, but there's also one where they have a thirst trap party. Enough said.

Ashlen Bellin

Queer season of are you the one PLEASE

Tori

The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City !

Thais

Seconding The Traitors! I'm fascinated by the social dynamics of this show and how much it says about how we overestimate our ability to suss out lies and how just a little manipulation can convince an entire room of people so quickly.

Madison Kitchen

America’s Next Top Model - cycle 4, which includes be quiet Tiffany, a race switching episode, and the episode where they convince everyone that girl has a flesh eating disease. Also, MILF Manor or SexBox, just because they’re bananas.

Ellen Marten

I definitely immediately thought of the jars of raw meat when you reminded me of this show.

Rachel Rakov

Next Level Chef, as it’s the most contrived cooking show ever.

Alicia

Kitchen Nightmares: Season 6, Episode 16 with Amy's Baking Company!

Sarah Hartzell

Don’t we all? That’s half the fun of watching

Alison

A truly horrifying option is Naked Attraction. UK dating show where people pick a date by looking at them piece by piece… naked. From the feet up. It’s bananas.

Janel Hammar-Erickson

Couple to Throuple on Peacock, it’s got drama and queers and feels like the people in charge had no real plan and the therapist leading therapy…. So problematic. Seems like it would be fun to dunk on without punching down.

Meredith S

The Traitors Season 3 (all of it) but more specifically episode 4 because Bob Harper of Biggest Loser fame cries during exercise on national TV and it’s SO CATHARTIC

Dusty

I would request Married at First Sight, the Boston or New Orleans seasons.

Jessitalisa

Flavor Flav’s ‘Flavor of Love’ - the episode where a contestant poops on the floor, because we all know how much Mike loves talking about bamu.

Mellsy Ann

Hoarders or Dr. Pimple Popper- both will gross him out cuz Hoarders has lots of BAMU stuff and Dr. Pimple Popper, well that speaks for itself

Cat Gemkow

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!

Dusty

That show was so, so good.

jman117

90 day fiancé is perfect. It’s so toxic, so trashy, and so much. Fits perfectly as a follow up to the bachelor.

Beazlebub

Deal or No Deal Island season 2. Or the Real Housewives of SLC Season 3 or 4, both have solid drama.

Jorie Slodki

I remember there was one where the son from the strict family went on to murder his parents, but I'm sure that episode has been scrubbed from the internet.

Anisa Joseph

The vanderpump rules episode where Jax reveals that he did indeed sleep with Kristin. Or receipts, proof, timeline rhoslc.

Jessica

Any episode of kitchen nightmares? I’m just a fan of Gordon Ramsay yelling “I’ve eaten here!” while looking disgusted.

Jessitalisa

Oh oh what about the first season where there is absolute chaos in the house after a contestant cheats on her long term boyfriend? I feel like that was the birth of reality TV we know today.

Dusty

I’ve been rewatching RHOA and those early seasons are so epic.

Mikayla Holland

I feel like Too Hot to Handle would yield some great “are the straights okay???” moments. He might actually enjoy Olivia Attwood: Getting Filthy Rich which is all about selling sexual content online. Idk why both of mine are horny. Well, actually I guess I do know why.

Kristin Slonski

Are You the One? Mike will love/hate it because some basic math and a logic chart would solve the whole puzzle. But the contestants can’t seem to wrap their heads around it. Especially fun is season 2 episode 19 where one half of a couple that is confirmed to be not a match flips out when the other person tries to find her match.

F

Hoarders and Kitchen Nightmares for sure!!!

Stacey Colliver

Love Is Blind FOR SURE. Any of the seasons will be infuriating for him

Ximena Garcia Arceo

The first season of Chrisley Knows Best, before the highly publicized legal troubles and opportunistic right wing political stuff. They lived so lavishly the IRS knew something was up

G Connolly

Flavor of Love is my all time favorite, I think the episode where they have to cook chickens for Flavor Flavs mother is a highlight

Abbie Shew

it has to be love is blind! I feel like y’all would have an absolute field day taking about how they frame it as an “experiment”

jess

secret lives of mormon wives!!!

Lindsey

any ep of RHOSLC

Katey

Love after lockup

Jacqueline K

I had briefly forgotten the eyedrops 😂 iconic

Blairella

I think Mike should watch Temptation Island - the show has three iterations on three different "networks" but, has always had the same host (although his teeth upgraded between runs 2 and 3). I would recommend specifically Seasons 1 and 2 of the USA run of Temptation Island - they're streaming on Peacock. It's such a crazy premise - couple goes to island to date singles and determine if they want to get married. WHAT. COULD. GO. WRONG? I don't like the Netflix iteration (run 3 ) very much - they gave it a Love is Blind wash. I also haven't found the original episodes from FOX (run 1) in the early aughts. I would LOVE to hear Mike's thoughts on the show. Honestly I would watch a live stream of Mike watching the show, MST-3000 style.

Mary R.

TRAITORS SEASON 3 BOB HARPER ARC (and Bob the Drag Queen arc though less topical), but also love island UK season 3, or temptation island season 1, or Vanderpump rules season 2… I think I would pay for a seperate “Mike and Aubrey review reality tv” Patreon? Take my money PLEASE????

Melanie Schultz

Gabby’s season of the bachelor! Then watch and adore her recent tiktoks

sarah hansen-granger

Another vote for Love is Blind - it’s the show you love to hate!

Elizabeth Sobol

“Alone” S10 E4. It’s got everything: sleeping on the ground, eating weird food, and sticky ba-moo situations.

Jorie Slodki

Man, the "live like it's a historical period" reality show has not made a comeback. The British ones were good. I think 1940's House might be the only reality show where the participants actually became better people by the end. There was also an Australian one called "Outback House" where the contestants lived at a sheep station as if it was 1861.

Erica Windwer

Real Housewives of New Jersey, Season 3, Episode 1 - In the Name of the Father. It is a masterclass.

Kat

Hell’s Kitchen. That way your British listeners stand a chance of knowing what’s going on 😆 I also think he should watch some episodes of the British show Naked Attraction, purely because it’s nuts.

Emily Eisenman

Sister Wives, or Seeking Sister Wife

Sarah Karpovich

vanderpump rules. something before season 6 or so. any episode.

Simone Meltesen

Please force Mike to watch Queer Eye, any Queer Eye!

KaioKenneth

Big Brother, bonus points if it’s the season of the Cookout alliance

Sara Hoffman

pleaaaase make him watch vanderpump rules please please

Maria K

I Wanna Marry Harry

Tharon

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives! Can MomTom survive Mike watching it?

Daria

love island UK season 2 or the ultimatum queer season

Alexandra George

VANDERPUMP RULES !! Maybe S10 E10 when Scandoval is revealed. I imagine Mike didn’t even know Scandoval happened. It’s all just a masterpiece of reality television with the way it’s edited. It’s called “Divorce Party Crashers.”

Naomi Strand

Omg TRAITORS!! It is completely over the top and who doesn’t love Alan Cumming?

Nat and Jane

Love is Blind - it's my anthropological look into the world of heterosexuals

DrearyTina

It might be too on topic, but Supersize vs Superskinny was pretty wild and could be interesting to talk about. There's full episodes on youtube.

Matthew Nelson

As Mike is my fantasy husband, I do not wish him to be exposed to any of these horrible shows. He is a delicate soul who needs to be protected!☺️ That being said, don’t do anything g with body functions or human feelings. These things hurt my darling man.🥰

Kristina

Hoarders! Esp. an episode with bugs or poop!

Kristina Twiner

Lots of silly straight romance shows suggested by others which is its own kind of torture but what about something like Storage Wars or Dog the Bounty Hunter that are just super AMERICAN and MANLY in vibes. Stamped onto a steel tread plate by the wheel of a giant 'pickup truck': Reality TV *FOR M E N*.

Lynn McCullough

Love is Blind, Season 6....just horrifying examples of heterosexuals

Mabel Cudmore

The Australian version of MAFS is amazing(ly terrible)

hey_boo

Jacob Stockdale. The parents kept all the boys isolated in rural Ohio and made them play Bluegrass. The episode is still up (Stockdale/Tonkovic) but I often skip it during a rewatch because it's upsetting. One of the WORST ones is Long/Stephens-Fowler family--- the HORRID father of the "upscale" family spends the entire episode degrading the other mother to the point where they can't continue the swap. He's an absolute Ghoul (But then got fired afterwards --- here's an article about it https://www.noevalleyvoice.com/2011/March/Fowl.htm

Pengwenpenguin

Too Hot to Handle is a special kind of reality garbage…. the horny straight men and women will absolutely rot mike’s brain cells 😭

CAM

Vanderpump Rules, season 1! Or Secret Lives of Mormon Wives season 1 ahead of season 2 coming out soon!

Leah Totsubo

90 day fiance pleaseeeeee OR Amsterdam episode of RHOBH OR the ultimate queer love OR are you the one (queer season) OR maybe the finale of RHOSLC where Monica gets exposed???? 🥰🥰🥰🥰

Melissa Radomski

love is blind!! it's crazy, and it's delightful garbage

Emma Hotchkiss

Welcome to Plathville. Jon and Kate Plus 8.

Autumn Crary

I Love a Mama’s Boy… I’d suggest season 3. It’s the only one I watched because my niece is in it!

hey_boo

I'm a writer, so I get a lot of character ideas from reality TV, but I consider myself to be a scholar of Wife Swap 😂

Mollie K

Joining the masses to say 1+ for Vanderpump Rules. Scandoval season is wlld, but honestly the early seasons are pretty good too, season two or three.

Cat

The past season of Love Island USA please

Lisa B

The Kardashians, Secret lives of Mormon wives or F-Boy Island (Australia season 2)

Bel

WIFE SWAP! He would HATE this! The anti-fat bias, the misogyny, the violation of children's rights...it has everything. S5E18 with "King Curtis" is a great one

GayActivity

queer ultimatum or anything from the Real Housewives cinematic universe

Maria E.

America’s Next Top Model has NOT aged well and would be an amazing watch. The cattiness- THE CATTINESS OF IT ALL! Related: early seasons of Project Runway.

Hannah Hultman

The “it’s my 25th birthday” episode in Vegas where Jax and whoever Stassi was with at the time ended up shirtless in the parking lot is a vibe

sdesi

queer ultimatummmmm

Sacha Maniar

90 Day Fiancée - The Other Way - ideally the season with Kimbalee and Soulja boy

Becca Tarbox

He would well and truly loathe Married at First Sight (especially the second Boston season). It’s AWFUL and I love it!

diana

Oh my god where they gaslit those women that that guy was prince harry... Didn't they literally have a fake psichologist telling them their doubts are unfounded?

Elly Woods

Kings of Tupelo on Netflix. It’s technically a documentary…but that’s reality right? It’s an absolutely bonkers miniseries

H Bradman

Hoarders is my guilty pleasure reality show. There is pooping in bags and yards so Mike will hate it! And my partner has just suggested "the one with all the rats" (s3e20 Glen/Lisa).

Maria K

Yes! Evil and wild!

Carly

Sister wives!!! He would have to watch the forst season, then the last season... so much juice.

Mary

Queer ultimatum pls

Erin S

I second this one - after the first season when it was half 'civilians', it's all folks from these other bonkers shows mixed together!

B Fitzgerald

I, too, hate the idea of making him watch something horrible. I have to vote for the most heartwarming reality TV: Love On the Spectrum. The latest season is the best one yet. But if I had to be mean, go watch any season of Love is Blind. (Like many have said before me lol)

Sabrina

VANDERPUMP RULES

Kiana Fekette

MILF Manor. My husband and his friends got into watching it together - it’s so trashy, so messy, so wild. It’s perfect for Mike 😅

Megan Powell

Love is Blind or Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!!! If you want him to hate it, LIB, if you want him to secretly LOVE it, Secret Lives of Mormon Wives 😍

Historia

love is blind Japan

liv

real housewives of salt lake city -- maybe the episode where Jen Shah gets arrested for elder abuse as the girls are in a party bus about to leave for Vale?

Laura

Married at First Sight - I would really like to hear Michael react to the "experts" constantly saying stuff like, "Well, these couples are in a difficult situation, since they've married someone they had never met before," as if they hadn't created that situation. Love Is Blind and Queer Ultimatum are also great choices.

Ezra Dobson

I would love Mike to experience the bewildered horror that I experienced when watching "Love is Blind UK". As someone British, I promise it is not cultural. What it turns out to be is straight people a) behaving like lesbians (but clumsily-- don't say "I love you" after two dates like THAT) and b) pretending that they do not care about physical appearance WHILE being on camera the whole time and desperately performing Western attractiveness and heteronormativity. It makes me wonder if the straights are okay and then rapidly come to the conclusion that they are not. That said, there is some serious schadenfreude in watching them struggle and then go back to their deliberately gendered quarters and attempt to perform gender all over again to their peers. Bless these people, they are being vulnerable(?) while also making probably a lot of money and attempting to show solidarity and openness while being sometimes in direct competition for a partner. The sheer capitalist dog-eat-dog mentality meeting this idea of non-judgemental human connection all through the prism of TV is honestly WILD.

Elle

Singles Inferno season 2!

Aimee Blanchette

The Traitors! If I had to suggest an episode I would suggest the first episode of Peppermint's season because I would love to hear both of your takes on it. And your thoughts on Alan's outfits, of course.

Amy Ainslie

Early days/seasons of TLC's Trading Spaces!

Arielle

“Scary Island” ep of RHONY or Welcome to Plathville

Kaitlin McManus

I feel like might would hate the entire concept of Kitchen Nightmares.

hey_boo

I remember THE poop episode to end of poop episodes

Laura

I want this but also I am scared of Queer Eye being ruined for me!

Lauren Karcher

Married at First Sight, America's Next Top Model, Tough Love

Sacha B

In the spirit of "picking things that Mike specifically will dislike" I suggest Hoarders, because of the potential of animal shit.

Gail

Canada's Worst Driver, which is a surprisingly good show, and is earnestly trying to help terrible drivers be a bit better.

womenslasers

QUEER ULTIMATUM!! QUEER ULTIMATUM!! QUEER ULTIMATUM!!

Madeleine Hill

Vanderpump Rules season 2 episode 13 (“Bitch Slap”). It contains a huge revelation/scandal but you need minimal background to understand the drama. It’s peak old school VPR.

Maggie Smith

THE ULTIMATUM: QUEER LOVE 💯💯💯

Sam

Below Decks Sailing Yacht or some vintage episodes of How Clean is Your House?

Ella Dawson

Throwing a curve ball in here: Shark Tank. I would love to see y'all rage over Mr. Wonderful and the lionization of capitalism

cryptic doe

i feel like it would be really funny to hear micheal react to 1) I wanna Marry Harry or 2) Queer Eye or 3) MILF Manor

L

The episode in season 2 of big brother where they learn that 9/11 happened The episode of early survivor where the guy (johnny fairplay) fakes his grandmas death The episode of love is blind where jessica lets her dog drink out of her wine glass

Jon

Lol. I would love to see another reaction to Solitary. It was on Fox's ill-fated reality tv show channel. The host is basically a glados voice. The contestants never meet each other, isolated in their own separate areas. They are only referred to by numbers. The prize for the winner was not enough and I'm sure all of them are still in therapy.

Emilia Calma

Shark tank or The challenge!

Nico

Top chef for any food/ health claims debunking

Nicole

Hells Kitchen

L

Marriage or mortgage, one of the episodes where they decide to have a wedding but then it gets cancelled because of covid and they get nothing.

Nancy Rexford

The queer eye episode with the Vietnamese chef. I love watching that show and even I was like, oh hell no, why??

RadicalZack

My strange addiction is that weird thing like hoarders of staring at a traffic accident and also just little exploitative. Mike would not be able to live with himself watching it.

Wicky

I hate to admit it, but I really like "Alone" I would love to hear Mike talk about it.

Phoebe Lile

Queer ultimatum. Some of the best reality TV I have seen in a long time

Megan

love is blind season 2 or 3

L

Omg out of the ARCHIVE I wanna see him watch an episode of beauty and the geek. Specifically the episode where a guy asks a girl "would you say you are a red state or a blue state" and she said "I'm from california so I would say I'm a golden state"

Jessica Leslie

Southern Charm - I need Mikes commentary on TRav

Naomi

The Ultimatum, especially the Queer Love version! Maybe the first or last episode - they feature plenty of the host, who seemed baffled by the contestants and the premise of the show

Chriscy Kwan

America’s Next Top Model! Or 90 Day Fiancé. 😁

Kate Bolin

I asked my favourite Reality TV junkie: Real Housewives of Salt Lake: Season 2 Episode 10 Real Housewives of New York: Season 3 Episode 12 90 day fiance the other way: Season 1 Episode 9 The Bachelorette: Season 11 Episode 1

Bethany Fuller

Vanderpump Rules, Below Deck, Jersey Shore, Welcome to Plathville, Real Housewives of Salt Lake City!!! Oh and Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Jessica

I have never once posted a comment here, which shows how much I mean this: 90 Day Fiancé! Not the early seasons, where people are actually trying to make some stuff work. I’m talking Danielle and Mohammed, Nicole and Azan. Trash! It might just end up sad, but it might end up hilarious and I am willing to take that risk.

Frida

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. Jen’s arrest + Mary Cosby church drama 🤌. And he has to create his own RH-esque tagline .

Colette Lambert

Any heart rate challenge from love island uk

Anna Donahoo

I was obsessed with a reality show in the early aughts called Beauty & the Geek that paired a bunch of archetypal nerds with beauty queens. The nerds were supposed to help the beauties with brain challenges, and the beauties helping the nerds with social challenges. I just know it would be a crazy rich text of early 2000s ideas about beauty, gender, intellect, etc. I would love to revisit it myself and would kill to hear the Mike and Aubrey take!

Kiki

Yummy mommies - an Australian reality show about wealthy new moms

L

Oh also any episode of "the challenge" from mtv

Faye B.

Wife Swap

Micaela Egan

I'm not connoisseur of reality TV but Secret Lives of Morman wives was a silly good time

Jacquelyn Benoit

Too hot to handle—specifically season 1 or 2!!

Bailey DeVetter

Is it even a question?? 90. 👏 Day. 👏 Fiancé. 👏

Meri B

US Traitors season 2 or 3!

Glory Turnbull

Let me sell Too Hot to Handle: The premise is that a bunch of hot people try to win money by "fixing their approach to romantic relationships" by not having sex with each other and doing extremely grating, trite, hacky self help workshops. If the contestants touch each other sexually, prize money is deducted. Some of the plastic surgery on the show also enters uncanny valley which is a fun bonus for judgemental bitches like myself. Enjoy!

Melissa Belasco

Traitors US! Season 3 was such a trainwreck!

Jo Hewitt

Just started watching a new UK reality TV show, Love My Face, it's really heartwarming

Miranda Field-Martin

just watched the newest season of temptation island on Netflix. maybe some of the most psychopathic television ever made. bafflingly heterosexual, deeply insane. would love your take

Eeeeeeep

Below Decks is a must. It’s so insane. S4E9 involves floor pizza and a panini press fire, so that seems like it could be great.

Bb.bbby

Wife Swap UK series 1 is WILD Also Queer Ultimatum

Keeley

OMG I cannot believe I was thinking about this cohort of shows and managed to forget TILA TEQUILA of all?? Could you IMAGINE 💀 this is my actual vote I can’t imagine anything funnier than Aubrey and Mike reacting to tila tequila

Jojo Ruta

the queer season of Are You The One !!!

Maria

Love is Blind: season one juxtaposed with season 6! Season one: Love and the best reasons (Lauren and Cameron) against the drama! Barnett and Amber, plus poor Jessica creating a love triangle, the absolutely unhinged lines from the girl from south America (sorry, can't be bothered to Google!) as she berates her fiance for unhinged things. And the set up of it all to create and then destroy couples! The party in Mexico during the "honeymoon" etc. Honorable mention to Season 3 for the fake tears (Andrew), best hot mic scene ever caught on camera in LIB. Everyone talking about "the experiment" as if it's a peer reviewed study instead of horrifically engineered and plotted drama would absolutely drive Mike up the wall! Season 6 would hit this on the head beautifully with that two faced Janus: JERAMY. Omg. In one of the first pod episodes, he emphasizes over and over again how he loves the experiment because the people are "psychologically vetted" and his arc becomes that that was him telling on himself!!! The fake apartment (he showed his fiance an airbnb and claimed it was his place), the tracking of his location by his fiance when she knew he was lying and caught him epically, his fake liberal politics to make Laura (?) fall in love with him and then him blaming her and saying he "shares more values" with that other girl he cheated on her with and she caught him!, "go kick rocks with open toed shoes!", followed by Laura crying as Jeramy whips around on a jet ski in the background with that other girl. Or, for that, you can also watch the Trixie and Katya "I like to watch" react to season 6. It is glorious! Season 6 is almost a complete deconstruction of "the experiment" imo. Season 6 also has the whole "Megan Fox" lookalike storyline, which I would love to hear his take on. The "when you see what you missed out on, you will f---ing choke" line. It is a very very rich text when watched alongside season 1. If I weren't having daily anxiety attacks about impending war and food shortages, I would finally write my incomplete thesis and probably integrate the notion of fame as a text: what it is and how we, as a society, are being driven into the ground because Narcissus personified (except for the good looking part) can look at himself in a phone camera instead of a lake. Instead, I am currently building one of those camp washing machine things we used at girl scout camp with a bucket and broom handle "in case of an emergency", while telling myself that my great grandma did not vote in every election she could since women won the right to vote in her twenties until her death at 104 years old but also made her own soap and washed her laundry outside in the yard until she was 89 only for the world to explode because of an unhinged some how elected narcissistic madman determined to drive the world into war so that he can be rich and for me to end up washing my own laundry in the yard! Jesus!) Thank you thank you thank you for encouraging us all to keep digging, stay critical, and find humor in the absurdity!

Carrie Magee

If it's going to be traitors, it has to be Traitors Australia season 2 - trainwreck doesn't even begin to describe it, it was so diabolical they cancelled the whole show

Lynsey Hanratty

MAFS Australia is epic this year! Too Hot to Handle is mental as well. The Ultimatum is ridiculous too. I would need to see Mike’s face watching these trashy shows though!! 🤣🤣🤣

Bb.bbby

Queer Eye series 1 or 2

Olivia Harden

Last season of Love Island USA was PURE CINEMA!! It consumed me

Olivia Harden

Specifically the casa episodes and post casa

Jamie Fritz

The worst chefs season where they had reality tv stars. That’s like a 2 for 1.

Carrie Magee

I would also love to hear Michael and Aubrey get into the queer season of Are You The One (season 8, I believe?). Honestly some of the best reality TV I've ever watched in my life. Such chaos, so many gays, the two non binary folks in there representing completely opposite energies. It has EVERYTHING

All Hail Peanuth Butra

There has got to be a good “Naked and Afraid” poop episode somewhere.

Jenteal Sielaff

Temptation Island! Mostly because I love the host Mark. Mark is daddy

Maria

Idk, Trixie and Katya already took this one OUT! I also find it to be so incredibly boring I cannot sit through even five minutes. They are like a hive mind and I cannot understand how none of them has a single hobby! Like, get a hobby! Volunteer somewhere! Idk, that show drives me crazy. Well, maybe it is actually perfect for him 😅

Allison Zibelli

It MUST BE HOARDERS. Mike is so squeamish that this would make for a hilarious episode.

Elise Keston-Smith

Fuck boy island is literally the best reality dating show because it is completely self aware and the editing is insane

Becca

Season 4 finale of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City

Kirsten

New Zealand Celebrity Treasure Island 2021! It was the first after the pandemic, and largely regarded as the one of the best ever seasons (lots of comedians that year!) Episode 9 is great if you just want one ep but really you could get into the whole thing. Plus one of the contestants was the NZ Bachelor who owns a paleo store and controversially hosted Pete Evans on his podcast. It can be watched for free on tvnz.co.nz (hopefully for Americans too)

Jenteal Sielaff

Also, F boy island, Are you the one queer season, and Queer Eye are all great choices

Rem

Love is blind! Truly deranged. Would love an analysis of the ‘experiment’ about whether physical attraction matters but all the contestants are conventionally attractive and in smaller bodies

Kristal Greenlea

MAFS I would absolutely LOVE to hear how he “tolerates” the experiment.

Rachel Cumbee

Later seasons of Sister Wives. Any episode will do. Season 19 is particularly good for showing how unhinged Kody gets. It's got ✨everything✨ Mormonism, terrible parenting, a fear of spices, the whitest people you could ever imagine... It's perfect. Its really a show that will make him ask "Are the straights okay?"

Cush

F boy island pleaseeee

Wendolyn Vermeer

Real Housewives of Miami S2 Ep8. It's unhinged in the best of ways.

Jessitalisa

Omg yes Johnny FairPlay… he was ahead of time on reality tv!

Rachel Cumbee

Just took a scroll. I feel like y'all are sleeping on sister wives. It is an insane show about insane people and I LOVE it.

Talya

Too hot to handle!

Naomi

Alone!!! Lots of opportunities to talk about physical and mental health and to laugh at cis het mens ridiculousness

Naomi

And for Mike to react to people eating worms and rats 🤢

Shelby Van Vliet

I would happily accept a full hour of nothing but dragging Trishelle

Just Helen, but also, Indecision

Don't tell the Bride! Peerless British reality show about how all men are useless slobs and all women are helpless wannabe pink princesses - seriously it's a fascinating watch, and the way it's put together by the producers is genuinely devious. The premise is just "make the groom plan the wedding with no input from the bride" - but they also make the bride go through everything she'd want (including trying on dresses) so she's really, really primed to be devastated when she sees what her future husband has wasted their money on. S6E9 is memorably unhinged

Kat

Naked and Afraid

Jennifer Claxton

Traitors Australia season 2. An absolute masterclass in stupidity. They figure out one of the traitors pretty early but he just yells at them until they vote for someone else?! And this happens EVERY EPISODE. I love it but it also depresses me as these people vote in elections and we wonder why the world is on fire 🫠

Alyssa Bones

Every time I think about that season I get so mad. Producers should have done *something* to make it more interesting.

Maria

How to Marry a Millionaire! The host is an incredibly vile woman with bizarre personal style that she projects on to her "clients". She hates curly hair, red hair, (straighten or dye it she screams at women!!!), anyone who is POC she calls "exotic", she is obsessed with fake tans, she is a horrible boss and berates her employees on camera, she has the worst mixers imaginable, she says everything on her mind--EVERYTHING, completely uncensored, and the fat shaming and other types of shaming and tokenism are UNREAL. She has a seemingly made up boyfriend/fiancé, is in her fifties and constantly tells people they have "too much work done" and gets more and more and more work done. The episodes where she tries to match her "first female millionaire" are absolutely horrendous.

Alyssa Bones

Oh man yes! I’m trying to decide on a season. Maybe the couples one?

K J

Million dollar secret on Netflix. One of the tamest reality shows out there. They mainly appear to be having hundreds of meals a day where they sit down and chat with each other.

Nurelle H

yes, cause it's just like youtube drama. But also may that is why he shouldn't watch it. I vote for Alone and Afraid. We are supposed to be torturing him

Lydia R

Queer Eye! Any episode! Also I'd love to get a more serious episode about makeup culture . It's interesting how the language has shifted to be more about "skincare" but it's still the same beauty industry.

fox

Queer Ultimatum, it’s pretty short so reasonable to watch the whole season. Inexplicable choice to use a random C list straight host who seems lost and confused whenever she appears. Bananas reunion.

Shelby Van Vliet

Great suggestions, and I’d add the one burned in my brain which is where they found clearly private boudoir photos of the homeowner and decided to blow one up to painting size and hang it above the mantle

Thea Cooper

The Circle, but I think he'd like it too much 😂

TalkTalk

Hoarders, Hoarders, Hoarders. There's poop in every episode, his psyche will not escape unscarred.

Sarah LeNoir

I'm telling you it's gotta "apple of her eye" from DANCE MOMS

Julie Cox

Traitors Season 3! Imagine Mike yelling at the screen….

Merg

F Boy Island seasons one and two, and or a straight episode of the ultimatum, followed by the ultimatum queer love

Amelia Rosch

The Jen Shah arrest episode of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City; Vanderpump Rules s1-2 because I think he would be so bemused/confused by the existence of Jax Taylor.

The Little Inkery

Queer Ultimatum! Episode 4 or 5! Also The Bachelorette Australia, Season 5, episode 2, in which Tim dresses up as a terrifying lobster and Angie kicks out a skeezy politician with a great feminist speech (I think) Also I started watching Taskmaster because of Aubrey's recommendation on another podcast, so I'd love a bonus episode in which you guys come up with silly tasks for each other please ❤️

Bridget

Oh my I am titillated!

Rohan McLaughlin

Make him suffer through the episode of Vanderpump Rules that launched Summer House. I think it’s called Summer House Rules!

Eleanor Streit

that episode of ANTM where they make everyone switch races

Amelia Rosch

Oh or the Scandoval episode of VPR (although that one does have a lot of associated lore).

Naomi

Yes!! But honestly they are all deranged and would be hilarious to hear Mike and Aubrey reaction to

Julie Seippel

The Circle is an interesting watch.

Joanna

ANTM!

Isobel

F Boy island! (Are the straights okay!?)

Vanessa Rivera

MILF Manor would send him into a coma I swear

Cousin Newt

Kitchen Nightmares, specifically the Amy’s Baking Company episodes ; also putting in a vote for My Strange Addiction

szeráf

the ultimatum: queer pride 😭😭😭😭

Cardner Babakitis

Bridalplasty!!! Horrible premise, compelling character arcs

Jennifer

The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 2, episodes 9 & 10 or season 4 episode 16 or season 5 episode 12

Rebecca

The first season of the Mole with Kathy Griffin!

Gretchen Laverty

Wife Swap: Season 5, episode 20. This was a generally WILD era for reality t.v.!

Alex

There’s an early episode of KUWTK where the girls talk about how their dad used to drive them down to “skid row” to go look at the unhoused folks to remind them how lucky they are, or something. (It’s to show us how humble and grateful they are.) Then they find this guy Shorty who hangs out in front of their clothing store and give him a makeover, and veneers maybe? THEN they reunite with him in an episode of the new Kardashians series which feels even more tone deaf than the first time they put him on TV. Anyway, that whole subplot is absolute Michael Hobbs rage bait from start to finish, please show him 😅

Sharon

THIS

Kate Parks

Intervention- season 3, episode 8 with Laney

Amelia Rosch

I believe Mike has mentioned watching compilations of fights from Real Housewives. If I am correct, then it should be RHOBH season 5 ep 16 or RHOM season 2 ep 7 and 8.

Calla Martyn

Indian matchmaking season episode 2. Any of the queer eye episodes with really crummy men who make it clear they don't want to be there (season 6 episode 3 for example)

Riley

Dual survival on max!

Petro

I want to say “Shot at Love with Tia Tequila.” While the mix of angry running commentary interspersed with “no…” would be insightful and funny. But, oy, that would be a *massively* problematic “where are they now” portion of the podcast.

Ashley Hicks

please turn mike into a housewives gay. salt lake city is so funny and i think mike would especially hate s5 e16 when they read their meanest texts about each other out loud in order to….help them forgive and move on or….something?

Rita Shah

First season of Too Hot to Handle. The latest season of Love is Blind. Ultimatum Queer Love. F Boy Island Season 1

Alexandra Grigsby

Gotta watch Farmer Wants a Wife USA. It’s an insane set up for a television show and I cannot believe that there are three seasons.

Liz Martin

The Traitors, and more specifically, the first season of The Traitors New Zealand. If Mike knows anything about party games beloved by theatre nerds, he will recognize the murder mystery party set-up of this show. Mike will be charmed by how bringing together 2 dozen New Zealand "strangers" to deceive and manipulate each other actually turns out to be a love-fest of people who are pretty much just 1 degree of separation from each other (since basically no one in New Zealand is a stranger).

Becca Dair

The Incredible Dr Pol. So many animal abscess-drainings and livestock births. I imagine he’d hate it 😂

AS

These are all really unhinged and I’m not big on reality tv (except baking and cooking competitions lol). But I’d say anything 2000s MTV or even Girl Next Door (that’s the gross playboy one right?)… date my mom Room raiders Next My Super Sweet Sixteen I did like and watch life of Ryan lol Parental control Laguna beach whichever one Kristen always says STEPHEN (maybe that’s every episode) The Simple Life Flavor of Love Run D MC had a good one

Holly Kruse

Hoarders, for sure. I'm a non-reality TV person, except for Hoarders.

Mary DeVore

Season 14 of Married at First Sight. You really only need to watch the first handful of episodes and focus on Alyssa. OR Love is Blind. Personally, watching this show as a gay person blows me away. Either one I think will have Mike cringing for days.

Tayla Martin

I second this immensely also anything with Big Ed in it

Greta

Too hot to handle, season 4 episode 8!

Julette Jones

Married at first sight OZ!!!! Anything from 2022 onwards!!!!

Alyssa

The Ultimatum: Queer Love!!!

juliet

Please God the UK Traitors!!

Jessica Calme

Naked and Afraid is my favorite, lots of fun to watch and marvel at the things people will do.

Katie

Literally watching the final episode of UK traitors Season 2 right now! Would love the Hobbs treatment for this.

JimKit Pendleton

Which on has the most pooping references? Pick that one!

Sarah Threlkeld

Amazing Race, season 17, episode 1. Watermelon 😏

Eva

Milf Manor (a criminally under appreciated show where a bunch of 18-20something ish y/o guys date each other's moms! It's very creepy!). Every episode is a train wreck, but S1 is better.

Sarah Threlkeld

The Circle! Every season is great, but I’d say watch season 5.

Heather Dunagan

“90 Day Fiancé, “Sister Wives,” “Real Housewives of Salt Lake City,” “Welcome to Plathville,” “The Ultimatum Queer Love,” or the Seattle season of “Love Is Blind.”

Esperanza Vencebi-Bacilio

Amazing Race because I think he'd actually enjoy it. The older seasons before they started having influencers on.

Mary Wilson

Amazing Race, season 7, ep 10. But also, really old, cringey reality TV from the dawn of the genre, though most of it is lost to time: Love Cruise, Temptation Island, Love Hotel. I'm embarrassed to say that I devoured those in the early 2000s.

Mason Schrader

Love & Translation (TLC) Tulay’s death dagger eyes. ‘Nuff said.

lumpyprol

Kid Nation: Episode 5: Viva La Revolucion!

Joy

Survivor! I dare it!

MagicMiscellany

Mr. Personality (the dating show hosted by Monica Lewinsky)

Ainsley Austin

I’m a lover of Love is Blind! My friend and I just started watching a beyond unhinged Peacock original called Couple to Throuple as well (monogamous couples try adding a third. It’s terrible)

Possum

Survivor Season 34 Episode 6, the tribal council focused on Zeke’s gender. Eight years later i still think of it often - never expected to be so devastated and moved by an episode of Survivor! Also any episode of Below Deck if you truly want to upset Mike…

Claire Herr

Temptation Island season 3

Anya Clarkson

YES!! I was waiting for someone to suggest this...without fail the most chaotic thing I have ever been witness to! My friends and I watched it on holiday and instead of going out on the last night we stayed in to watch the last ep and did all the maths on who the right couples could be to win the money. We still quote 'nobody knew anything until 5 minutes ago Jonathan' to each other to this day 🙌

Kaity

Seconded!

Tessa Lee Gloede

Apparently the Australian version is completely unhinged!

Eleni

Flinch(Netflix) and Celebrity Bear Hunt(also Netflix)

Jennifer Konikowski

Seconding Welcome To Plathville (season 4, when it’s all really going to shit) and I’m gonna vote Farmer Wants A Wife (any season, American version) because that show is the most painfully heterosexual thing I’ve seen and I need Mike’s take. I want to give every woman on that show a copy of the tragedy of heterosexuality and wish them the best.

Emma Janicki

Next Level Chef, 90 Day Fiancé, or Survivor Season 1

Julie

Vanderpump Rules or Real Housewives of Salt Lake City

hanna

real housewives of salt lake city!!!!!

Julia Nouse

One episode each of “I kissed a boy” and “I kissed a girl” honestly the finales of both (not the reunions lol) have some pretty wholesome moments of families accepting their queer loved ones. Maybe you don’t have to hate what you watch?? I mean it’s really funny when you do of course. But maybe you’re allowed to enjoy things a little once in a while. (Both shows have their problematic faults as well of course)

Julia O'Neill

Vanderpump Rules! Any 90 Day Fiance!

addie

Oh god, love is blind and the ultimatum … they follow the jessica simpson episode of you’re wrong about… like how is nick lachey hosting two new reality tv shows where everyone else is cringe and he’s a love expert?

Julia Nouse

Hate watch option: I love a mama’s boy on TLC/Max

Rose Sandberg

Wife Swap 😂 Villalpondo Price

MRos

Ok there are already 1500+ comments so I know this will get buried...but I would've loved to hear both your thoughts on the old S3 episode of Love Island (UK) where the actually lovely & smart Camilla tries to teach a fuckboi what feminism is and then he rants and raves all over the villa for days about it.

Nicole Cochran

Secret lives of Mormon wives on Hulu

Vin Pasciuto

specifically the queer season(s?) of The Ultimatum!

Brian Lane

Love Island UK Season 4

Ellen

TAMPA BAES: a single-season show about a lesbian friend group in Tampa. Please!!!

rbt

Tattoo Fixers Extreme UK (streaming on Hulu and Disney+)

Emily Phillimore

For a truly unhinged experience, Playing It Straight. A show from 2004 where some poor girl thought she was signing up for the bachelorette. It turns out half the guys are gay, and pretending to be straight. It then runs exactly like the bachelorette, but at the end if she accidentally picks a gay guy he wins a 100 thousand dollars (if she picks a straight guy, she and him share the money and also get to be in love). It's set on a ranch with a full country music theme-song, and all the episodes are on youtube in 240p. There is no acknowledgement of the concept of bisexuality.

Kate K.

Southern Charm any of the first 5 season. Its an early 2000s dumpster fire.

Alissa Mooney

Back with the Ex. It's an Australian reality show and it's absolutely amazing.

SC

I'm not into reality TV but there's a show in Australia I can't stand the ads for - "Married at first sight"

Sophie

Americas next top model, any of the makeover episodes

fae-imposter

hoarders is grosser than bar rescue, but also sadder. i would recommend either one. if you're really feeling evil, doctor pimple popper, season 1, episode 3, the lipoma whisperer

Nikola

Hoarders, Season 6, Episode 4 – “Shanna”

Kristina Belyea

the queer season of Are You The One!!! So much chaos!!!! When they bring out the solo cups to do math!!!

Julia Tindell

NAKED AND AFRAID. I have converted many people into Naked and Afraid fans. Also consider a Part 2 where you watch Naked and Afraid of Love ✨

Rita

Temptation island season 2! Rick and his OOOWEEE and it’s so aggressively straight

E

Hoarders! My mom used to force me to watch it as a child because I was too messy

laura jordan

PLEASE watch Jersey Shore, here are the episodes I recommend: season 1 episode 1 if you want an overview on all the people, season 2 episode 5 for the note, season 2 episode 7 for jenni and angelina fighting, season 3 episode 3 is when Snooki gets arrested, season 4 episode 5 mike injures himself to get more pills (pretty dark and they don't address that on the show), season 4 episodes 8-9 snooki having terrible relationship issues (this whole season is pretty dark tbh)

Andrea Westby

100% need to make Mike watch Big Break - it’s reality TV about golf, and there’s drama plus sports.

laura jordan

literally any episode of wife swap one of the most entertaining reality shows ever

Mary

Vanderpump Rules - Scandoval Arc!

Felix O'Brien

100% Season 1 of VH1’s Scream Queens. It’s absolutely WILD. Hugely camp and very problematic. I adore it.

Sheryl

Vanderpump Rules but just the season leading up to scandoval because what the actual fuck? Like he literally helps get her engaged and then ????

Sabrina

Real housewives of New Jersey Teresa’s season back from prison

Kate DeVoe

Survivor, season 13 (Cook Islands) is probably the most problematic.

Sean

Please watch Back in the Groove on Hulu. It’s a Bachelor in Paradise style dating show hosted by Taye Diggs about younger men pursuing older women and it’s absolutely bonkers

Michaela

Love Island USA season 6 - specifically from episode 16 (before casa amor) to 27 (after casa amor). (No need to watch the after sun episode so it’s 10 episodes!!

Michaela

Or Married At first Sight Season 9!! (USA)

Meghan Matt

Love is Blind!!! The first season is best, you dealers choice which level of drama you want. The high the season # the more drama

Carrie Wellbaum

So this is such a soft show and probably wouldn’t make a great episode LOL! But I’m currently obsessed with The Great Pottery Throw Down (British, on Max). I rewatched every GBBO season so many times I finally got sick of them and then found this gem. Maybe this is just my way of suggesting “light” reality tv Mike might actually watch for fun 😂

Jacob King

I stand with Mike on this issue.

Lisa Martinusen

Couple to throuple! Pure trash. And traitors.

Meghan Matt

Also want to say, I'm totally scamming on this list for my next tune out and watch show!

Meghan Matt

So agree! What's with Nick Lachey as 'your dad's but also 'your hookup connector'? Perfect Match season 1 was soo problematic and also so good.

cass

Love Island USA season 6. excellent television!

sm

Real Housewives of Melbourne!!!

Sylvia Hunter

I’ve thought of another one but idk if you’d be able to find it. In the early aughts, when I had a new baby who nursed every hour on the hour for an hour, I began watching a FULLY UNHINGED renovation show called “While You Were Out” because it came on right after M*A*S*H. It was really amazingly terrible!

MarisaN

Love is blind, season 1

MarisaN

The golden bachelorette -- a good encore bc he knows how it works, but it feels so different with an older female lead. It made me cry from how wholesome it was at times

MarisaN

Secret Eaters might be too on the nose for this, but def a lot to talk about

Caitlin

Farmer Wants a Wife! 🤣 Traitors, Secret Wives of Mormon Wives

Asa X

Kitchen Nightmares, Season 6, Ep 16, "Amy's Baking Company"! A truly iconic episode

Julie K

Bachelor in Paradise to follow-up on Bachelor discussion. I think Mike would like how after Season 1 Marcus and Lacey got married and then come to find out it wasn’t a real wedding and she apparently ghosted him (vague recollection). I think he would enjoy the seasons with Ashley I pining over Jared, constantly crying.

Kara Barker

Oh my god please Survivor it's iconic

R

Married at First Sight to make him even more sorry for the straights. or the OG Big Brother not the celebrity one.

Laura

Intervention.

Fen

America's Next Top Model, specifically the episode in Hawaii where they make the models do blackface ☠️

Abijah Gattis

I think he’ll genuinely like 90 day fiancé. My favorite is before the 90 days

Kai

The most recent season of traitors or physical 100, it’s a Korean show about who’s the most buff and they all take it insanely seriously

Megan Young

Vanderpump Villa, obviously.

Trish Hoskins

I also tend to avoid reality TV (except Amazing Race, but I don't think that would provide the Mike torture you're looking for) but I am SOOOOO in for this and can't wait to see what y'all come up with!! maybe I will even have to watch the ep in question prior to listening, so please please please give us a head's up once the selection has been made. OR CAN WE SAY WATCHALONG??

Breanne Boyle

Oooh, it needs to be something that is just disgusting since he is so queasy about that stuff. I would say Hoarders, hands down. Find an episode with a cat person because those are extra special.

Erica Ward

I'll vote for Love is Blind, just because it's so silly and also current.

Sara Amorosi

*Australian* Married At First Sight, the absolute nightmare that continues to this very day!

Stephanie Stewart

I was starting to think I made this one up 🤣 no one seems to remember it

Ilana

I mean I live for the "wholesome" reality TV like GBBO, Repair Shop, and QueerEye.

Yelena Kart

Love is Blind would be good. Somewhat controversially… maybe project runway? Like, one of the episodes where their challenges are real people or plus size models, especially.

Tim

The answer is obviously the Amy's Baking Company episode of Kitchen Nightmares.

Ali Clawson

Love is Blind or Married at First Sight!

Amy VanderZanden

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City, I think it's season 3 when one of the cast gets arrested? (I also cannot abide reality tv but i DO love hearing people talk about it in my ear buds :)

Jenn

This one!! Plus, the drummer of Silverchair is married to one of the housewives…I feel like Mike and Aubrey both would appreciate the cameos? This show is delightful.

sm

Exactlyyyy plus it's sooooo unhinged

Marina

Definitely bridalplasty. It is a little known horror show with so much going on.

Victoria P

Temptation Island PRETTY PLEASE!!!

Amanda MC

Australian Married at First Sight! It is so so so bad and so chaotic and so so so bad

Joelle Charbonneau

Swedish Love is Blind! The former scandi living will give Mike appreciation for it's pleasant boringness. Great Pottery Throw Down (latest season) also very pleasant!

Smack McCoy

Omg please do Extracted! It's like survivor but insane

Lance Charisma

It might be a little on topic but I would love to hear both of you react to Bridalplasty. There was only one season. 12 brides-to-be compete to get their dream plastic surgeries before their wedding. When contestants are eliminated the host says "your wedding will still go on, it just won't be perfect."

TessaJ

Australian Survivor - Titans v Rebels

Hannah Bieler

Wife swap. The most unhinged reality tv show of the early 2000’s

TessaJ

Or RHONY S6 ep 20 when Aviva chucks a leg.

ES

Please NOT Hoarders. That is not a fun show. I have hoarding tendencies, and it’s MEAN. I have seen exactly one episode, and never seen another because it was so upsetting. Secondhand trauma from just watching how those people were treated.

ES

YES

Emily Goodell

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives or Temptation Island

ES

My Cat from Hell, but only if Mike promises to be nice about my favorite thing. The overproduced parts are funny, but Jackson Galaxy’s work for the welfare of cats is really important and moving.

Elisabeth Handler

Sister Wives season 1. Ep 6. I deeply need to see/ hear Mike’s reaction to Kody Brown.

ES

16 and pregnant / teen mom

Caitlin Hepps Keeney

Something gay for sure. Are You the One Season 8 (the queer season) is my top recommendation. Episode 1&2 are messy and fun but the peak drama is probably episode 8. The Queer season of the ultimatum is also messy and worthwhile

Paula Kiger

Whatever KUWTK episode he picks, he must obtain some Khloud Protein Popcorn (it's a thing). Fairytale wedding, Season 6, Ep 14 where Kim married Kris Humphries. 3 Vera Wang dresses for a 71-day marriage. The excess will make your head spin.

Jules

The Flavor of Love (specifically the episode where a girl poops on the floor) or in the same vein, Rock of Love with bret michaels

Catharine Smith

The first season of the queer Ultimatum was pure reality show gold. I loved it.

zebussy

Agreed, it's very exploitative!

Jessica Howard

This is dumb and no one should take it seriously, but there's a cartoon spoof of reality tv called Total Drama Island. It scratches your reality TV itch without making you lose all faith in humanity; 'cause they're cartoons.

Rose

Sisterwives!! A knife to the kidney!!

Karen Beaubien

One of the RHONYs with a Ramona pooping incident. Preferably Season 10 ep 17.

Catharine Smith

I also suggested the queer Ultimatum. I think it's waaaay better than the straight version because everyone had more recoupling options so they had more freedom exploring what a different partner would look like. Whereas in the straight version the ladies only had four guys to choose from and frankly a lot of straight men present the same issues in relationships.

Haley

90 day fiance, the 2 part reunion of season 9

Megan Beene

If you're looking for single episodes, RHOBH season 5 episode 16, the iconic Amster-damn episode is iconic for a reason. Also RHONY season 3's 'Scary Island' episode , (Sun, Sand, and Psychosis) holds up. Either of those could also be a full season watch too. I would also second the queer season of the ultimatum if you're doing a whole show/season. Good luck, Mike! Enjoy, Aubrey! Looking forward to this episode 👀

Laura Cantrell

Formula 1 : Drive to Survive season 1. Got the US excited about F1. Some of these guys don't like each other

Kylie

Yes!!!

Kylie

Vanderpump rules 🤪🤪 scandoval episode in season 10 is crazy but needs context

Laura Cantrell

Wheeler Dealers - nice British chaps fix up cars & sell them for a tiny profit. Lots of seasons to choose from, probably pick a UK based episodes with Ant as the mechanic. Bonus if they pause for tea.

Moss B.

Seconding Are You the One! The all-bi/queer season is one of the only reality shows I’ve managed to watch for a full season. Superbly messy.

Olivia

RHOSLC!! Especially season 2 episodes 10 and 11 where someone gets arrested and indicted on federal charges

Minna Reilly

love that season of AYTO - the only reality show for which i have multiple times created a spreadsheet for my notes (I love the gameplay aspect of this)

ぎん

The British reality TV show "Don't Tell the Bride" is very painful and entertaining to watch! Also "I Wanna Marry Harry" where they gaslight American women into thinking they're competing to marry Prince Harry.... it's insane and I would love to hear his reactions.

Moss B.

It really does! I love that there was “nonbinary fuckboy who never buttons up shirts, ever” representation. Our super messy archetypes should get to be on reality TV, too, not just cis archetypes.

ぎん

OH OR AMERICA'S NEXT TOP MODEL THAT WOULD BE SO FUNNY

Nick Mamach

Real housewives of Beverly Hills season 1 episode 9 “Dinner party from hell”

Emily Schlenker

I can't think of a more cringe reality TV series than MILF manor, especially season 1.

Lauren Nicholls

Any episode from What Not to Wear. The OG.

charlene swift

Agreed that it's sad and it feels really wrong to watch. I also feel like Mike could lose his mind with any situation where there's no working bathroom, for example. I mean, I understand if he wants a challenge, but that show goes way over the 'challenge' line.

Alex Blaisdell

Please watch Americas Next Top Model!!! Seasons 1-4 are the best

Mark Eyles

Four in a bed . It’s on Channel four in the UK. It’s where 4 different bed and breakfast owners stay in each others places and score them on a list of criteria (comfort, cleanliness, food etc). It starts nice and ends terribly as each owner sees the feedback before they stay in the next place. Season 5 has some great episodes

Purvi Kanal

Vanderpump Rules! Specifically the early seasons featuring episodes with shirtless fighting in a parking lot, 2010s fashion and many cheating scandal reveals. I have an episode watch guide spreadsheet if it’s helpful!

Kirstan Norris

Highway Through Hell - it's a reality show about Canadian Tow Truck drivers and the wrecks they work. Sounds dumb but is really engaging! It's on The Weather Channel of all places.

Sydney Satchwill

The Traitors US season 2 on NBC/Peacock. It’s just a genuinely fun show that even my reality opposed friends enjoy. Recommending this season in particular because of Phaedra Parks’ legendary takedown of Dan in episode 6. Plus one of the stars that season (Peter) is a a former Bachelor! Plus Alan Cumming is the host.

Eirwen Jalokivietsija

There's a competition show on Netflix that's about glassblowing and mostly avoids the bs editing that a lot of reality shows to. Also Mike could make jokes about glory holes.

Caitlin

Are You the One season 8. It has hookups, it has messy bisexuals, it has math. 11/10 would recommend. And then this is pretty unconventional because it's a youtube competition show but Jetlagged the Game Season 3 ("Playing a 72hr game of tag across Europe") episode 3.

Caitlin

I think ANTM might have too much anti-fat content for a lighthearted episode? IDK it's been a loooong time since I have watched.

Jennifer D.

The secret lives of Mormon wives! It's got everything: cults, slut shaming, weird body stuff, grifters, influencers, passive aggressive fighting, active aggressive fighting. 10/10

Caitlin

What about the season 4 Finale, do you think it would work without the context of the rest of the season?

Kennedy Curlz

This is the og of reality shows, second only to the swan

Madeline Adams

Just want to say first of all, I would listen the shit out of you two watching reality shows. - The TLC family of reality is its own best. My 600 pound life, the tree stump guy, what not to wear. Early/mid 2000s was a very “freak show” era for TLC - biggest loser - americas next top model (Tyra banks did not age well) - queer eye original

Avery

How about Drag Race? Season 5 or 6 is probably the best starter.

Geri Paul Dudley

Seventeen hundred comments hahahahahahahahahaha. I wanna say 90 Day Fiancée but I'd have to ask my wife which episode.

Christian Clarkson

There’s only one answer to this question and it’s the most unhinged television event of all time: 2010’s Bridalplasty. It only ran for one season because it flew WAY too close to the sun. In terms of episodes … probably the denoument

Adison

this is the real answer

Julia Latino

I vote for Survivor. I started watching last year and it's actually fabulous. Or Hoarders. But that might be too sad.

Sarah

The only thing more cringe was the 1 season wonder, Labor of Love, hosted by Kristin Davis. I was embarrassed that I watched the whole thing

J Savage

Ink Masters or Blown Away

marce

Absolutely!!

marce

The Challenge, probably season 21 battles of the exes

marce

craziest episode is #5 Crazy in Love

Angela

Deadliest Catch! Who thought fishing could be so exciting! 🎣

Angela

Good one!!

martymulder666

Agree with love is blind or the queer ultimatum. Love is blind is so straight/cis sometimes it hurts but also fascinating look at the straights. Queer ultimatum is more sane/wholesome but still a lot and only afab people

Maggie Sharpe

Survivor is the ONLY option! Season 7 or season 8

M. Sunflower

Survivor!!!!! New podcast (or livestreaming so no editing is required??), watching every ep from season 1 onwards LOLOLOLLLL! As a person who grew up hating watching sports, Survivor is my preferred sport :P A game that uses brain play, social awareness, diplomacy, puzzle solving, pattern recognition, research, so much so that even if you're bad at the physical sporty part you can still win the WHOLE THING! Episodes and seasons: Survivor: Pearl Islands, I think Rupert is one of the best people on the show of all time. Ep 1 would be a fine watch, you totally see the charm of him, AND the eventual winner in this brilliant ep :) also as a bonus, he's a BIG guy! Tall, and a lil thick. Strong AF and a sweetie at heart! Survivor: Cook Islands, in which players were segregated into tribes BY...RACE....(jfc ffs.) Ep 1 would work for that too. EDIT: Alsooooo Dr Pimple Popper lipoma removals are AMAZING. I went from a queasy person to doing exposure therapy by watching Dr Pimple Popper on youtube, and now I CANNOT GET ENOUGH. It's so incredible seeing a doctor who actually gives a crap. In some of the lipoma episodes I actually suspect LIPEDEMA...so perhaps that is a future episode you might do? So in that case, perhaps one of the YouTube compilations of "Best Dr Pimple Popper cases of all time". EDIT 2: Also, I'm a Hoarder and it's disheartening to see how many people see that show as just "gross" exploitation freak show. It's as harmful as the egregious "Biggest _____" show is to us fat people. The participants are traumatised hugely, their consent is frequently ignored, and the aftermath will be huge harm.

NotaManga

Hella Kitchen!!!

Jo Lum

Have you heard of sex box? It’s as terrible as it sounds. I could only watch 2 episodes and I love reality trash

Jo Lum

Or actually, what about naked attraction. That show is truly unhinged.

Jo Lum

This inquiry is really making me feel like I should have been paying attention to which shows feature weird ba-mu stuff. I’m coming up blank tho…

Alex Hausman

Need Michael’s take on secret lives of mormon wives

Anya Samiljan

This is an early 2000s throwback, and there is only one season and it goes fast: Bridalplasty. Brides to be competing to win different plastic surgeries in preparation for the big day. Trashiest thing I've ever seen. I loved it.

Jess Gtz

Ok I never watch reality TV but Survivor has me HOOKED in it’s ridiculousness and it’s ability to make me feel all of the things. Season 37 with Mike White was a great entry point for me because I’m a fan of his/White Lotus, and it’s really cool to see how he was influenced by survivor. It’s also just a wholesome season in my opinion. I’m now going back and watching season 18 which I think was 2009 and oh boy is it a different vibe, not in a good way. In my opinion viewing survivor through a sociological perspective is 1000% worth it, and highly entertaining.

M. Sunflower

Yeah I'm a Hoarder too, and it's awful that these shows exist.

M. Sunflower

I was gonna suggest this one too! The only thing is, I think you need to watch the whole season for context around the event too, cos previously I had been rooting for the person who became the "villain" and did the outing (before this egregious deed). The fact that they really thought they had something there was a SHOCK. But knowing the context makes it so much more...I guess nuanced? Or maybe that's not the word....not sure what word to use.

Maisy H.

Oh Jenn tran's season of the bachelorette week 6 or anything from jerry springers baggage

Doctor Starky

Tiny house hunters! Every episode is either a pair of hipsters looking to buy a yurt or Christian family of six it rules.

Caterina Misale

Surely the Australian Fboy Island. A rich text.

Mariah Kunz

The ultimatum (queer season), secret lives of Mormon wives

Erik West

I know it's old, but, Wife Swap.

M. Sunflower

I would have suggested Fairplay episode as well, but I feel like you need to have watched a lot of Survivor from the beginning of the show to understand fully just HOW groundbreaking and crazy that was. Also - you don't find out he faked it until later, if I remember correctly? But maybe I'm thinking of the players - cos they definitely don't find out until later. It takes watching previous series, AND that entire series to get the nuance of how much that play changed the entire game and genre moving forwards. It broke an ethical boundary that had previously existed.

M. Sunflower

Hehe oh this makes me remember how much I used to enjoy American Pickers!

Ruth Estrada

Real Housewives of Atlanta season 15, episode 15, they throw a sip and see. I’d never heard of this before. It’s a fabulous party where everyone gets dressed up, drinks and they see the baby who makes a really short appearance. I want to do this!

M. Sunflower

Oof...I haven't heard of this. It sounds...traumatic.

bee

Anything from season 1 of Dragula. Pleeeeeeease

Jill

Episode where Kristen gets fired stands on its own!

madeleine

PLEASE make him watch keeping up with the Kardashians. FREE KHLOE!

Emma Casey

married at first sight Australia, the dinner party where martha throws a glass of wine on cyrell

Brenna Frandsen

My vote would be How to Build a Sex Room, but it isn't quite reality TV, so I'll go with Queer Ultimatum.

Julia Smoot

Love is Blind! They spend the whole time in the pods trying to figure out what the other looks like

Nicole Suren

I agree with everyone saying the queer season of the ultimatum and love is blind! I’d also love to hear Mike try to understand the point of The Circle

Kelly Mace

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives was a good time. Altho my personal favorite is MTVs The Challenge. Any rivals or exes season will do. Especially with the CT and Diem storyline 💔

whatserface

Traitors UK Season 1 is genuinely one of the best, most interesting seasons of television I have seen in a while and I think Mike will be driven crazy by the theatrics.

DrearyTina

It is. But it's unique because it's also pointing out the unhealthy habits of very skinny people. It's hook was putting all the food the person eats in a week in a big tube. And making the two people eat each others meals in front of each other to be like, "am I ok feeding this much/little food to someone else?"

whatserface

Pressed enter too soon! If the objective is primarily to annoy Mike, Traitors US Season 3 is peak reality TV messiness and would be a fun Avengers-style way to force Mike to experience stars from different franchises, everything from the Housewives to Survivor.

Nicole Kotov

Some might say I have been waiting my whole life to be faced with this question; I’ve researched a lot on the topic. I got a few suggestions so feel free to take or leave, all or any: My Big Fat AMERICAN Gypsy Wedding (season 1, episodes 4 and 7 are fascinating…. And then season 3, episode 3 is my where my favorite groom is featured) I hope it’s ok I used the language of the show title itself, I didn’t want to mislead anyone but also don’t want to be derogatory. Real housewives of New York is top tier! Highly recommend, season 7 ep 10-16 is a fun place to start If you want a FUN, competitive reality show, then there’s Dragula (all season on shudder) you won’t regret watching the hunt for the next drag super monster. It’s not one to dump on, just oozing reality tv core — and it’s a fast watch Last one Another light hearted reality tv show… pig royalty It’s like a chiller version of dance moms, but it’s Texas pig showing competitions. Nugget is killing the pig showing game!

Lily Roberts

It’s too wholesome but I’d love to know that Mike and/or Aubrey watch The Great Pottery Throw Down

Isabelle

Lizzo's "watch out for the big grrrls" was in my opinion phenomenal and criminally underrated.

Lauren Fairshter

Cosigning secret lives of Mormon wives! The ep where they go see Chippendales in Vegas!

Elise Brancheau

Specifically the God Warrior Dark-Sided Stuff episode

Elise Brancheau

Wait, that’s Trading Spouses, not Wife Swap, but my suggestion still stands

Tara Ann

Sister wives

Julia

Traitors UK season 1 - might actually get Mike hooked and not just cringe! Or Love is blind, specifically a European version - maybe the latest one from Sweden? So we get some bonus opinions about Denmark and gender roles and culture (in a fun way hopefully) as well!

Seymore Sinn

We should make him watch something tragically heteronormative.

Elise Brancheau

Honestly I can’t believe I’m not seeing RHONJ more in these comments. The table flipping scene? The christening?? Definition of iconic.

Bri

Secret Lives of Mormom Wives plssssss pls pls pls pls

Sergle

It's GOTTA be Married At First Sight, he will absolutely hate this show. For more funsies, Hotel Hell!

cam

chrisley knows best would be amazinggggg to hear his feedback on

NS

Love on the spectrum lol. Season 2 or 3!

NS

If you want something he will actually enjoy - the great pottery throw down. pleaseeeeee

Alex Lopez

Teresa Giudice (sp?) flipping the table!!! Prawstitushun whooahhr!!!

Alice Mouatt

Married at First Sight Australia season 6! Or any of the seasons from the last few years.

lesbian deanna troi

Stuff like this makes subbing to the patreon infinitely worth it. Please do Married At First Sight, it is so deranged.

Erin Dumont

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Queer Ultimatum, RHOSLC, Traitors, or if you really want to torture him, Bad Girls Club

Carrie Magee

Yes! Kai was so toxic and I loved it!

Mariel A

Flavor of Love, season 1, episode 8.

Mariel A

Real Housewives of New York, Season 6, Episode 20

Mackenzie Powell

Hoarders for sure, specifically the Spanaway episode. Shes the most quotable "this is my kitchen, i love to bake and cook" while standing on feet of compacted garbage in the most disgusting room imaginable. Absolutely the pinnicle of reality TV.

LaurieG

Survivor!

Mary Morson

Any mid season episode of the Masked Singer

Natalie H. Berg

Real Housewives of SLC PLEASE espc the episode of s2 where Jenn is arrested

Julia Kanapathippillai

He should watch married at first sight (MAFS) its australian. Its terrible. I think someone got arrested/investigated for DV in relation to the show this season. Its supposedly a “social experiment”. He will hate it

savagegeniusart

Seeing how easily he is repulsed by yucky stuff, I think Hoarders would be the most amusing.

Majella Ryan

Married at First Sight Australia. They’re about 30 odd episodes so there’s that 🤪. I would go for a thing from Season 9 onwards. This current season is particularly unhinged!

Drew Bernstein

I think Ink Master would make him delightfully extremely uncomfortable

Lee Davis-Thalbourne

Genuinely, I want to hear Mike go on a rant about Queer Eye. A rant about what? Not fussy! I want Mike to watch, be furious with at least one of the Queer Eye folks, and be unable to contain himself!

Iris H

The one where they restore cars. It will be educational!

Samita Darabkhani

I‘m gonna suggest Temptation Island, the Spanish one.

liesbeth

That's also my top pick, unhinged is an understatement lol

Brynn

MARRIED AT FIRST SIGHT AUSTRALIA I BEG YOU

Tora Sellevoll Hebnes

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Or the last episode of the last season of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. Or any Salt Lake reality show.

Chris Smith

Vintage UK reality show 'Playing it Straight'. Completely unhinged premise, so much fun to watch.

Lulu McConville

I want to see Mike experience Jacqui and Ryan

Maggie

DANCE MOMS SEASON 1 PLEASE

Tennelle Flowers

I think Love is Blind or Wife Swap is exactly the kind of garbage I'd love to hear BOTH of you rant about. Wife Swap could maybe be a bigger episode tho considering the content...

Julia Sero

I nominate Selling Sunset. Real Estate porn! Tacky but fabulous Outfits! Creepy bald Doublemint short kings! Co-parenting very small dogs! Drama! Maybe the one where the dog funeral is hijacked by personal conflicts. Or just ease in with the Burgers and Botox themed brokers' viewing party.

Ben Robinson

The last few episodes of the uk traitors season 1. One guys who's "you killed me mum im getting revenge", another who has so many red flags and a poor naive woman trapped in the middle. First time I watched reality tv in years, made me not want it again ever

Lynsey Murdoch

Tool academy- old but absolute madness. It's about getting men to behave better in their relationships

Lydia Rose

Married at first sight Australia! Exemplary 'are the straights okay' content!!

anarchopixie

MILF Manor, I am begging you

Maggie

Teen Mom 2 Season 3 Ep 4 when Jenelle tries to negotiate her jail time bc it interferes with her plans to see Kesha in concert 😭

Maggie

✨Wife Swap S3 Ep16 ✨ - the family that’s preparing for the apocalypse by not educating their children & EATING RAW MEAT

Maggie

oh my god i forgot about this one, this has to be the winner

Janina Matthewson

If it's available to watch in the US, the BBC's I Kissed A Boy

Oscar Shipley

Come Dine With Me. The Uk tv show

Ann Buckley

Noice! Love Island Australia 🐨 or the upcoming Season 15 Master Chef 👩‍🍳 Assuming you’re able to watch Aussie TV 🤣 love you guys ❤️❤️

Amy Smith

Vanderpump Rules

Madeline Adams

90 day fiancé is my all time favourite!

Aunt Levant

Say Yes to the Dress!! Fashion takes, interpersonal family dynamics, dramatic editing - this 👏🏼 show👏🏼 has 👏🏼 EVERYTHING

Summer Elliott

Love is blind! It's the only mess of a reality TV show I've ever watched, and I watch it on my own. I would love to listen to you two revel in the cringe of it all

Karena Barlow

90 Day Fiance: Before the 90 Days, Season 4!!! That’s the season with “Big Ed” and woof, it’s a doozy

Madison Lane

too hot to handle , season 2 or 3. lots of bizarre straight people action

E C

The bisexual season of Are You the One or the Ultimatum

E C

Or something really, really wholesome like the Pottery Throwdown or Grand Designs 😂

Hannah Bieler

Holy shit what about the Jersey shore?

Susan Williams

Either Come Dine With Me (UK TV show) or Married at First Sight please!

Jaq

Love Island UK or Australia! They're both terrible/delightful

Blooms & Barnacles

Come Dine With Me - very low stakes but very high drama. It's a UK show where participants have to plan and execute a dinner party for a groups of strangers. Socially awkward hijinks ensue.

Elle✨

Selling sunset, any Christine heavy episode

Blooms & Barnacles

If you're willing to go obscure, I would recommend the Irish show Faisean Paisean. The premise is that three men pick out outfits for a woman, and she decides who to go on a date with based on the outfits. Incredible. Also, it's broadcast in Irish Gaelic. Faisean Paisean got me through Covid lockdown, I'm not joking. You can stream it online here: https://www.tg4.ie/en/player/online-boxsets/play/?pid=6154603421001&title=Paisean%20Faisean&series=Paisean%20Faisean

Krietta

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City ssn 1! He needs to know about Mary Cosby and Jen Shah.

Alicia Ingiosi

Bad Girls Club — the episode where Tanisha pops off and starts banging pots and pans while singing “I didn’t get sleep cuz of y’all” I’ll try to find the season/episode but google Bad Girls Club Tanisha pop off and BOOM. ::chef’s kiss::

Ruth Oprysko

Thank you! Not a hoarder but have known a couple and this show was just cruel and 100% about getting the audience to both be titillated by the “gross factor” and act like they could NEVER find themselves in such a bad situation because they’re good normal people. It was awful!

Alicia Ingiosi

Season 2 — possibly episode 5. Honestly the whole season is amazing

Autumn

celebrity big brother uk the season w gemma and tiffany new york

Ruth Oprysko

Please don’t do any shows that exploit people’s bad life situations or mental illnesses. Which includes plastic surgery shows because the body dysmorphia is wild. There are so many shows that aren’t about looking at people like they’re freaks up for display! Kitchen Nightmares or Chopped or Cutthroat Kitchen or even Nailed It! (Love Nicole Byers). Or the Squid Game reality contest!

Jules

okay i would absolutely LOVE to hear you all discuss the queer season of Are You The One — Season 8!!!!!!!! it’s just gay chaos and you’d be so funny chatting about it! OR I feel like Mike would have a fit watching Below Deck — insufferable rich people, mega yachts, etc. Most recent season!

meacha

season 5 finale of real housewives of salt lake city!!! “I think we should take our phones, go through our text messages, find the worst thing we said about someone at this table and then we’re gonna hand the thing you said to the person you said it about. And they’re going to read it out loud to the group.” so good

Laura Cantrell

NKOTB's Jonathan Knight has Farmhouse Fixer & various spinoffs (Camp Revamp, new Rock the Block season6) sometimes his husband Harley or his brother Jordan help

Beth Rossano

Love is Blind. My adult kids and their partners are obsessed. I personally have only seen one episode, but when my kids describe it every time it seems more and more unhinged.

Nikki V

This is an old one but good: My Strange Addiction, guy has been dating and having sex with his car for years. Season 3, episode 1.

Tamara Marie

My vote is for Love is Blind - so painful to watch yet I’ve watched every season Temptation Island was pretty brutal too…

Ellyn Lambert

The Simple Life will make him pretty annoyed.

Your mom

Couple to throuple, any episode

Kate Randall

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 2, Episodes 4 and 5 - A divorced couple and their kids charter the yacht for a trip. One of the divorced parents is now dating his daughter's ex. And of course, drama within the crew.

Leela Corman

How Clean Is Your House! Mid-oughts show where two British ladies visit someone's house and show them how gross it is. Or, Embarrassing Bodies!

Harley

The Ultimatum: Queer Love. just an absolute mess, and I want to hear you both talk about it! tbh some reality tv is just psychological torture. I also just watched Temptation Island (also psychological torture) and recommend that one too hahaha

Frances Storey

Long Island Medium Season 1, Episode 3

Victoria Jost

Season 4 of America’s Next Top Model! (Too on the nose?)

Emily Graham

Definitely Love is Blind or The Ultimatum. Or Netflix's Million Dollar Secret if you want something that actually has pretty decent game mechanics

Sharon Ahwireng-Obeng

Please, please Come Dine with me, any of the earlier seasons are magic.

ML Corner

Any episode of Dance Moms would make Mike writhe in discomfort. Alternately, I feel like he would get sucked into the drama of Teen Mom and secretly enjoy himself? So maybe don't pick that one?

Ashley Clark

ROCK.OF.LOVE (with Brett Michaels)

Allison L

Episode 12 of Season 5 of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City is spectacular. Mary can't find the door to get into Meredith's bat mitzvah and Brittany is accused of having "high body count hair".

ML Corner

OOOOH. Season 1, Episode 1 of My Strange Addiction is PERFECTION for Mike. Lori can't stop sleeping with a hair dryer, and Kesha can't stop eating toilet paper! It's just enough "bah-moo" stuff to drive him under a chair!!

Etch McSmuttington

Ex on the beach is pretty ridiculous. The participants know which show they are on and basically say “oh I hope my ex doesn’t show up on this beach!” And then the ex does show up in a bikini and they do the pikachu shocked face about it every time.

Renata Sancken

OK this is a wildcare pick but I actually thought of MP/YWA watching season 2 of House of Villains, when in the first episode Wes introduces himself by saying that he has a really high IQ and he's going to be great at all the challenges, and my roommate and I turned to each other to be like "ok Wes, IQ is fake but go off" and then in a talking head later he's like "I have no idea what my IQ is, I just say stuff like that to intimidate other players" and we were like "......well played?" House of Villains is also a hilarious show because Joel McHale hosts it and he obviously has such contempt for all the contestants but also none of them know who he is (one of them thinks he's Carson Daly). Very uncomfortable for everyone involved! *chef's kiss*

Three Kobolds in a Trenchcoat

MILF Manor! Any episode really, but #3 has a double date and separately a reveal that one of the moms slept with her son's friend.

Becca M

Vanderpump rules!

Katie Pier

Oh I LOVE grand designs

Diane Crotty

The curse of Roanoke Island. The bad archaeology and dodgy history would do his head in. Also: possible research rabbit hole!

ES

@Ruth - oh I love this take! Yes!! Messiness and having “too much stuff” is absolutely moralized!!!! It’s not just that the audience is “normal,” but they’re hardworking and morally upright too!

Samantha Moats

Love is Blind or Too Hot to Handle please please please!!!

Shea Diaz

This season of Survivor- season 48! I feel like picking something good and timely might make for more interesting reactions

Laura Jewell

Season 1 of Traitors--the USA version that Alan Cumming hosts!

Eggy

90 Day Fiance

Lillian Zhou

Please make him watch the most recent season of Temptation Island. It has some really entertaining characters and dynamics that will further mystify Mike’s utter confusion about heterosexual dating

Vic

Real Housewives of Potomac season 1 or Real Housewives of Atlanta season 1

Allison L

Angie's text about Bronwyn's husband--that he has "one foot in the grave and the other on a banana peel" is amazing :-)

Allison L

I haven't watched this in ages, but the episode where the guy is somewhere in Latin America and claims to get robbed by someone with a machete??

Tiffany Bui

Biiiig ups to this one. It's VERY are the straights ok (the answer is no) and also the host Mark L. Walberg (not Wahlberg) plays a weird pseuo-therapist/host

Natasha

They rebooted toddlers and tiaras- I would love to hear Mike analyze this 🤣😆

Madeline Adams

I don’t remember this episode but sounds accurate lol

Leah Carey

Couple to Throuple or the recent season of Temptation Island 😍

Julia Marques

Season 3, Episode 7 of "90 Day Fiancé: Before The 90 Days" involves a cake being thrown in someone's face, which feels like something Michael will love

Nicole

The secret lives of Mormon wives.

Erica Block

Love is blind, season 6, especially episodes 3 thru 6

Amelia Ray

seconding this because i’ve watched a lot of reality tv and have never seen anything like kid nation

JessHomefries

Queer ultimatum!!! I can’t choose an episode I’m sorry

Carrie Poliksa

Love is blind for sure, season 1 for sure because I need to hear Mike scream about Messica like I need air.

Morgan Ruoss

Real housewives of Salt Lake City!!

Kitra Moeny

*chanting* Twin Love TWin LOVe TWIN LOVE it's very short, only one season, and so deeply strange my girlfriend and I watched the whole season in like 2 days and she usually absolutely cannot get through an episode of reality TV without falling asleep. This one is like Love Island but with weird identical twin dynamics and hosted by WWE stars

Miriam Elizabeth Brown

My partner wants to recommend Alone or any of the MTV shows form the 90's like Date my Mom or Rate my Room

Nicole

Seconded, I was just coming here to say this!!

Regina Randolph

Pass, thanks. Not a big fan of reality shows.

Miranda LaShell

The queer ultimatum, I kissed a girl, I kissed a boy (danii minoge is the host for both! ) or traitors

Heaven Keane

Is this the “receipts! Proof! Timeline! Screenshots!” episode? Because I’ve never watched the show but that clip lives rent-free in my head

sutherslat

Summer House season 5. All of it. The Covid season. Completely unhinged.

Saschi

mob wives

Robert W

I think Queer Eye might be fun. You both might have big opinions on everything. Food, beauty products, etc. Michael may love it, or absolutely loathe it. It’s also pretty low stakes because I don’t think either of you care if they mess up or fix a bunch of straight guys lives. If you need to give Hobbs homework, he could use context clues to estimate the straight guys salaries to see if they could easily afford their new lifestyle style. Season 5, Episode 1 was a gay pastor, if you really want to hint that Michael may need one of these make overs.

Leah Fishman

Vanderpump rules - any/all of it, especially early seasons

Amy

Yes, specifically the 4th episode where they play that game with the anonymous notes in the box, & it shockingly doesn't turn out well

PetiteFeatherZ

Cutthroat kitchen!!! It’s a hilarious twist on a cooking show with a surprising amount of spreader bars 😅

Sarah & Her Weird Looking Dog

I want to marry Harry, an E reality show where they trick American women that they are dating Prince Harry, when in fact it's just a red headed guy from the UK

beesher

Mr. Hobbes, thank you for your service. 📺🎖️🫡

Caitlin Bebb

My fav is mediterranean, Hannah seasons

Elizabeth Nearing

The Traitors, Real House Wives of Salt Lake City, or Vanderpump Rules

Nicole

Hahaha yes. I think he will get a kick out of the no drugs or alcohol but yes soda and botox

R Kisner

Perfect Match! It’s so trashy and hilarious.

Ella Smith

Traitors UK season 2, especially the first 8 episodes

E

I love any throwback such as flavor of love, rock of love, or daisy of love. It’s only 20 years ago but they really show how culture has changed. One of those would be a romp!

Meg Weckstein

Perfect match, early on in the all queer season!

Charles Fredricks

“I wanted to make this a chill episode but I ended up going down a multi-week deep research rabbit hole on TikTok”

Maisy

sister wives

Nicole

😂😂😂 he would have a FIELD day

LittleUggie

Four Weddings: season 1 episode 9

Camille

90 Day Fiancé. Hella options on spinoffs and seasons

Saschi

100%. also even tho they dont wanna discuss things related to MP, id be interested to hear their responses to Stassi, Lala, and Scheana's diets. I remember in Stassis book she was like 'when i want to lose weight I just take a bunch of adderall and dont eat." and j in general housewife (etc.) EDs are so common and under-discussed. Thank God for SUP!

EmBot

90 Day: The Last Resort S2E3: Save The Last Dance, specifically the clip ‘Natalie Starts A Fight With Everyone At The Bar’ 😂living!

EmBot

Next is so funny!

Saschi

omg u should read the book "Bachelor Nation," cuz imo way more reality tv than we want to admit is exploiting peoples bad situations and mental illness! (well, maybe not nailed it). like ppl often go on bc of economic precarity and get pushed by producers into creating 'good tv' (e.g. emotional outbursts, irritability, tears) . Like Kitchen Nightmares has them sequestered somewhere and pushed into emotional upset. Not saying this as a judgement I am a hypocritical bad feminist who rly enjoys reality tv, its j a super interesting topic to me.

EmBot

Yes, and The Last Resort!

EmBot

Yes, or Botched!

Jen Smith

Omg rock of love was sooooooo gross. The trashiest of trash tv. Just fabulous food for the most cynical humans.

Furbekah

Please not Hoarders. If Mike is forced to watch that show, it will not only be the end of this podcast but your friendship as well.

Lisa Hollingshead

This suggestion may not be in the spirit of what is being asked, but the Rehearsal is technically a reality show. I don't think it will provide the kind of reaction from Mike that we are looking for, but boy howdy, it's something to behold.

Kim

The Great British Baking Show!

Nick

TOO HOT TO HANDLE

Sarah Harsh

90 day fiancé! Watch the idea of the American Dream die in real time

Scout L

Traitors!!!!

Subha S.

live from the other side with tyler henry

Emily Knight

I always think Survivor is a good entry way, and then The Traitors!

Emiko Waight

I think you have to show the Bachelorette episode with Hannah Brown where she says, "I have had sex, and Jesus still loves me."

Lydia

Americas next top model!

Maxwell Winter

Kitchen Nightmares, I feel like watching Gordon Ramsey willingly put his hands into gross expired food would get such a reaction. Obvious episode is Amy's Baking Company because the AUDACITY of that couple is on a whole other level but honestly any episode where the synopsis mentions an owner is belligerent or refuses to make changes ends up being a helluva time.

VV

Oh my goodness, please consider marriage rescue

Kellyanna Foster

RHOSLC and thank you for your service, Michael !

Alyssa Boyle

Love is Blind, Season 3. 🍊🍊

Dede Jawde

Dance Moms!!! Season 1.

Alyssa Boyle

The most joyous of cooking shows!

Alyssa Boyle

But I kinda want to re-experience it through Mike’s eyes. It is so horrendous I need someone else to validate my extreme reaction to it.

Aleta de Tiburón

I'm not a big fan of reality shows either, but had fun watching Project Runway with the fam. It's not as catty as many of these shows. It's fun seeing what creations people come up with.

Alyssa Boyle

YES!!! I really miss that show.

Alyssa Boyle

Excellent suggestion. Botched kinda has it all, doesn’t it? I don’t watch it very often, but I’m still traumatized by the episode where the lady got the bargain basement butt implants that flipped! 😱

Joanna

The Ultimatum (the queer ones) + The Traitors (the British if possible, so much better than the American version)!!!

Camilla

Yes! Do the one where they “switch races” or any of the makeover episodes. Maybe cycle 6 because Jade is always good for a lol

Camilla

Hahaha I remember that!!!

Micah Long

MILF Manor. If we really want to make Mike squirm, this is the best of the worst.

sarah clark

Married At First Sight (Australia). It's a relationships 'experiment' - I'm not sure what the most popular episodes are but I had to give up on the last season because the men were bringing me dooooown. Unhinged behaviour!

maddy ferrito

Holy shit where do I find this 😂

SF

ANTM!!!! Any of the earlier seasons would be so fun

SF

Hoarders would be interesting. I’ve never seen the show, but I’m curious to see it through the lens of this podcast!

Áine Sheehan

The most recent season of the Traitors!

Lisa Gullickson

How about Australian Traitors, season 2!

Jon

I’m going off-theme. Mike should do Eurovision because it’s technically kind of a reality show and I really want the long-awaited Eurovision episode.

Ashley Valentine

Real Housewives of New York, Season 10 Episode 17 "Ship Happens" (They're all stuck on a boat during a storm while on vacation) and/or Season 6 Episode 20 "The Last Leg" (Aviva throws her prosthetic leg during a fight). I feel like I remember Mike mentioning on an episode that he has watched compilations of Housewives fights on Youtube, so he should be made to watch a full episode.

Carly Gove

season 1 of love is blind!!!!!

Carly Gove

omg, +1 on wlw ultimatum

Carly Gove

bonus points bc it’s hosted by nick lachey, former husband of jessica simpson, who says multiple times in this season “obviously i’m nick lachey”

Luke Williams

My recommendation would be Survivor, specifically the South Pacific season. Not to spoil too much about it, but it includes being weirdly mean to a neurotic dork, a protracted discussion about oral herpes, and a cult like alliance that ends up being a jumping off point for the editors making a big, season long thematic statement in a way they hadn’t before and probably won’t again.

Esther

I love that there's a casual 2000 comments on this post 😂

Jess Juice

90 DAY FIANCE 🙏🏻🙏🏻

Cora Bennett

Any of the Below Deck series would be good for a laugh or two

Stephanie Rosenblatt

Botched- the plastic surgery reality show. It a show that’s like a car wreck you can’t look away from!

Rez Watson

Can I vote against Hoarders? Mike doesn’t deserve that lol. And he will NOT feel good about the lack of treatment options and literally any info he could find

Jerry Gu

This, both seasons.

Kiera Gates

YES THE QUEER ULTIMATUMMMM. I don’t do RTV and I loooooved the first all-women season.

Erin Brosey

Love is Blind!!! The Ultimatum is a very cringy slice of interpersonal psychology that I think would also be perfect. Bar Rescue is also a great option…but it’s probably too formulaic to generate much feedback beyond the obvious first impressions.

Rachel

+1 Ultimatum

Lisa Dunlop-Clark

Married at First Sight, Australia. Season 12. The most unhinged television I have ever seen.

Julie Spero

RHOSLC. Season 2 or Season 4.

Breann

90 day fiance!! Any season/episode with Gino and Jasmine

Aimless AmyDel

I wish I knew why I liked the Circle so much. It kind of only works if he's going to watch a whole season. Season 4 is probably the way to go! Also, I can't believe I didn't get my shit together sooner to join Patreon until recently. Kinda glad I did wait b/c now I have so much content from y'all!

Korerat

Hoarders

Allie Devlin

Couple to Throuple or The Ultimatum would be the trashiest, but Love is Blind probably has the most use as being able to talk about with strangers at the hair salon while still being very trashy. Maybe the wedding + reunion of season 4?

Janneke de Jong

This. The episode where one of the guys is 100% serious when he says he hasn’t technically cheated because it was a threesome, which, for clarification, did NOT include his partner.

Anna Wilcox

the ultimatum: queer love. PLEASE

Felicia Reynolds

If he can't handle the poop stuff, Dr. pimple Popper will push him right over the edge

Lexi Fish

90. Day. fiancé. PLEAAAASEE

Kenzie Myer

Real Housewives of New Jersey!

Madison Hanson

Celebrity Bear Hunt, Traitors, Below Deck, Worst Cooks in America

Marie Diemand

DANCE MOMS DANCE MOMS DANCE MOMS DANCE MOMS

Jen

I agree! It was the first show that came to my mind but I quickly realized that I don’t think it’s fair to make Mike and Aubrey to watch a show that dunks on random people suffering from mental illnesses.

Jen

Not exactly a reality show, but With Love, Meghan would give Mike and Aubrey a lot to talk about!

Nicole Evelyn

Oh God the episodes where Abby goes to the cops

Violence Zack

90 Day Fiance or Milf Manor because they're the most cringe and if Mike watches them I won't have to 😅

EmBot

Oh. My. God.

Abby Krahling

Forged in Fire. A nice competition show and Mike can watch sweaty men hammer and sharpen steel for 30 minutes

Rebekah Barnes

RHONY SCARY ISLAND (season 3 episode 12?)

Fred

Omg please do "Are you the one?" Season 8 (the queer season where everyone is bi/pan so they could match with anyone and there is some seriously childish queer tea going on 😂)

Kristen

I personally vote for Love on the Spectrum (U.S.).. australias good too tho

Kristen

My Cat From Hell! The guy who carries cat toys around in his guitar case and visits homes to work with your cat and determine if it’s a “bush dweller” or “tree dweller.”

Tasha

Love is blind or too hot to handle!!!! They’re so dumb and I love them

Monica B.

Hell’s Kitchen pleeeease!!!

Monica B.

(Assuming I had to pick one from the pictures!)

Anna Hickey

Alone ppleeeeaaase!!! The first Australian season is fun

Meredith Mullins

Ah yes, my area of expertise. Love is Blind, the "Megan Fox" season. Couple to Throuple. Temptation Island. The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Real Housewives is a treasure trove of things Mike would hate, my favorite being old NYC (Aviva leg throw? Scary Island? The Harry Dubin years?) Potomac (the actual dragging of Candiace) or Atlanta (Bolo). God the possibilities are endless.

Stephanie Bee

Maybe 90 day? Season 2 or 4? That might be too mean. OR early Love is Blind, not the new seasons. ORRR Survivor season Caramoan with Dawn and Brenda.

Stephanie Bee

Wait!!!! I have a better rec. Definitely watch The Simple Life, hands down. It is something else. Paris and Nicole are hilarious. I wonder if Mike might actually end up not hating it.

funnyletter

I desperately want to listen to Mike bursting into flames at 90 Day Fiance but that show is such a hot mess express that I kinda feel mean just watching it...

Ray

Love is blind. I love when mike complains about conventionally hot people being out of touch with reality

Elijah Weiss

Please check out I kissed a boy AND it’s lesbian sequel I kissed a girl.

Nicole Michaelis

The pickup artist and the Paris Hilton best friend one

Tyya Dae Doss

Here Comes Honey Boo Boo - Season one finale ep 10 “It is what it is” Alana introduces her gay uncle, Poodle.

Shay

Gotta be Any real housewives franchise

Lucy Newman

19 kids and counting please!! mike will hate it 💃

Lothlorien Lightfoot

the only REALLY bad reality TV shows I watch are Hoarders & Ghost Adventures (I watch a few of these ghost shows, but this one is particularly bad, because the main character/actor claims to believe in ghosts but is total fucking dickhead to them constantly). I don't have any specific episodes to recommend because I couldn't stand Zak Bagans long enough to watch many episodes. Honestly though, I'd be interested in torturing Mike with any ghost hunting show, all the ones I've seen are profoundly unconvincing, but Zak Bagans really is an infuriating asshole (or the version of himself he plays on his show is anyway).

Sonja

THE FARMER WANTS A WIFE (preferably the OG Australian version) It’s like the bachelor meets farmersonly .com

Cathy

Queer Eye, because I don't think it's that bad and I need Mike to show me how wrong I am

Jess Acton

PLEASE watch The Ultimatum: Queer Love!

Liani Baylis

Please make Mike watch Extreme Couponing 💕

Sara Ahlstedt

90 day fiancée: The other way. Any episode from season 2 from episode 4 forward.

Sara Ahlstedt

Or queer The Ultimatum, episode 2.

brennabean

Bridalplasty where brides to be competed in wedding themed challenges to win surgical procedures that they get while the show is going. Amazing villain and insane premise. Only one season

Jamie Hoel

A hoarders episode where the toilet is clogged and they have to defecate in plastic bags (hoarders is so problematic and I can’t stop watching send help)

Kensey Liebsch

Hi Baby Gorgeous! Make Mike watch Real Housewives of Salt Lake City! It’s community theater Housewives, but also the best franchise???? I love it. (in Lisa Barlow voice)

Aurora

In the spirit of Mike having lived in the UK, I'm A Celebrity, Get Me Out Of Here! could be a fun one for the gross-out factor (which is present in basically every episode). Bonus points for a season where there are politicians competing in an (failed) attempt to be relatable.

JS

Oh my god I would give anything if you could unearth the ~2008 US Farmer Wants a Wife that had a rapped theme song and featured a different farm-themed event as a kind of rose ceremony each week (fireworks at the county fair spell out the name of the rejected woman! A nice old lady embroiders the name of the rejected woman in real time! They STICK THEIR HANDS INTO COWS AND THE WOMAN WHOSE COW IS NOT PREGNANT GOES HOME!!!)

Nicole Evelyn

Acknowledging I'm probably too late for this suggestion but Season 1 episode 9 of Before the 90 Days where the American boyfriend confesses he has an arson charge after stalking his ex, runs into the Brazilian jungle, and then his Brazilian girlfriend gets mugged

Kathryn Steakley

Omg please do The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives! I would love to hear your guys’ thoughtful breakdown of the many things going on in that show.

mander

THE ULTIMATUM QUEER SEASON!!!

Molly

I cannot second this hard enough. Literal masterpiece from FBI arrests to secret masterminds. I think Mike would feel a kismet relationship with Mary Cosby who is television gold.

Chelsea

Hoarders!

PillowWithAButton

LOVE ISLAND PLEASEEEE i need to see him perplexed at straight relationship dynamics

Mary Bertrand

The surreal life season 1 (Tammy Faye Bakker is on it and that’s everything you need to know)

Lars Boss Lindholm

HOARDERS! I have so much guilt about all the clusters of things, that keeps growing in my house😳 Please make a nuanced take on it☺️

Alien@System

Somethingorother, NJ or Somethingorother, SD?

Theodora

I’ve got a couple of suggestions: -Ghost Adventures, Season 2 Episode 8 -Storage Wars, Season 2, Episode 5 -Project Runway, Season 4, Episode 10

Shannon Walton-Clark

Marriage Bootcamp: Families the season with Cory Feldman and Aaron Carter and his mom

Jenn

I love that you recommended a paranormal reality show. That little corner of reality television does not get the attention it deserves!

Theodora

A couple others to consider, sans specific episodes: -Cake Boss (have cake nearby while watching) -Little People, Big World (pretty wholesome as reality tv goes) -Trading Spaces (any ep with Hildi) -A Shot at Love with Tila Tequila (pure trash tv) -Miami Ink (art & melodrama) -Naked and Afraid (who would agree to this?!)

Theodora

Agreed. There’s a whole cottage industry of them! But Ghost Adventures and Zak Bagans take the cake.

Midbest Princess

Are You The One may be frustrating because on one hand it’s basically a big logic puzzle (which will draw you in against your will), and on the other hand they all sleep in one massive bed together 😂

Abby Longworth

There’s an atrocious old reality show called Playing it Straight - basically the Bachelorette, but it’s a bunch of gay men pretending to be straight and the (straight) woman has to guess which ones are actually straight. It’s so hilarious and so problematic

Cassandra

Coming late, but…OWNING MANHATTAN on Netflix. So much for Mike to love/hate: - A hot nightmare Danish guy! - Some truly wild outfits and makeup choices! (Jordan’s talking head producer must have HATED him to let him on TV with that visible beardline bronzer) - Unfettered capitalism verging strongly into self-parody/camp! Plus there’s only like 8 episodes.

Jackson

The guys on Golden Bachelorette freely talk about their bowels and aging bodies, which I really respect.

Aleisha B

Vanderpump Rules!

Aleisha B

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, please please please!

Jessica Gore

Married at First Sight or Love is Blind!

Crystaline

I’m voting for Physical 100 on Netflix. Or the most recent season of RHOBH.

Marika Lee

90 Day Fiancé and I fully agree with all the episodes that have been suggested but just added: Before the 90 Days: Season 1 Ep. 10 - Paul, Karine, and the machete Before the 90 Days: Season 3 Ep. 7 - Angela and the Cake Throw Before the 90 Days: Season 4 Ep. 10 - Ash’s Women’s Minds are Boxes Seminar

Sally Clarey

Love is Blind - for sure the most unhinged concept framed as deep and insightful

Morgan Clark

Something old school, like Survivor season 1.

Tyya Dae Doss

But fr Honey Boo Boo. The story has everything Mike loves to hate, well maybe except BahMoo.

Tyya Dae Doss

Honestly probably even has that somewhere too tbh. Season 1 episode 10, when gay Uncle “Poodle”enters the chat

Katie Marinello

Come ONNNN Housewives. Specifically any of Shannon's enema moments on RHOC.

Katie Marinello

Specific episode: When Jax is pooping on camera, or when they open the bathroom door while Tom Schwartz is pooping.

Naomi Wilde

Queer Ultimatum!!! Hands down the best season of all dating/love based reality shows

thread witch

Specifically the “queer season” because it totally messes with the probabilities. Also, the fivesome

Elise Loeb

Please please Queer Ultimatum it is an absolute wreck and you will emerge ruined

Isabella Martinez

Love is Blind!! Specifically Season 7 episode 4!

Sarah Sznajderman

I think Mike would love (hate) Real Housewives, it's a classic for a reason 🤣

JH

survivor!

Heather

Milf manor, s1e1

Cara Leopold

Yes to Naked and Afraid which I watch pretty much every Saturday night! 😂 I guess they’re running out of people because they keep bringing the same ones back!

Molly

Go old school, watch wife swap or average joe

Molly

Actually also: trading spaces (2000-2003)

Cora Leighton

The original British love island season 1!!

SC

don't know if this was just an Aussie thing but in the 90s there was a show called, "Man o man"

Helen Dennis

Hoarding is very misunderstood. It's awareness and humor where you guys operate, I think

Sarah Grieves

Naked Attraction! It definitely wins the award for the most uncomfortable reality show on UK TV.

cleofas

oooo please check out temptation island. it is Diabolical

Kailey

Temptation Island

Annie orloff

Summer house, southern charm or are you the one (old school mtv style reality)

Nina Richner

What's the show that's all about people abstaining from having sex? Too Hot to Handle I think is the title--on Netflix. It's whole premise is getting hot people on an island and telling them not to have sex, and I think there's a monetary prize involved.

B

Real housewives of Salt Lake City or secret lives of Mormon wives

Summer Holland

aubrey is right 90 day fiancé is gold

Ashley

Kid nation!

Cara H

Survivor season 32 - great season to start survivor and sure to make mike angry (but too angry) and entertained. Alternately Traitors (maybe American season 2 to start) - it’s ridiculous and so fun to laugh at

Rena Yvonne

New buzzworthy shows: Secret Lives of Mormon Wives season 1 episode 6 when they go to Vegas and see male strippers OR Life After Lockup Gypsy Rose season 1 episode 1 when she is released from prison and all she wants are hot McDonald's fries but her husband won't stop mauling her. Old School diet related: TODDLERS AND TIARAS season 6 episode 1 in all caps because I cannot emphasize how much I need Mike's reaction to this!!! Related: episode 1 of Here Comes Honey Boo Boo (Redneck games, Bobbing for pig's feet).

Rena Yvonne

"Everybody's a little gay." Honey Boo Boo ♥️

Lister

Are You the One? season 8 - it's all bisexuals and mathematics!

Claire Gunter

Amazing Race season 19 episode 8. They go to Denmark and I would love to hear Mike learn what the Amazing Race is and make annoying comments about how it is inaccurate because (insert Denmark knowledge here)

Ruth Britt

Portland/Seattle season of Love is Blind

Emilia Richman

Sister Wives - specifically season 16

Casi N

Palate cleanser: Queer Eye Germany, which is generally sweet and German

Guthrie Blechman

The Traitors, recent season, eps w/ Bob the Drag Queen!

Jennifer Swaim

Either the full first season of southern charm… or the Scandoval season of Vanderpump rules

Adriana Daly

Hotel Hell because he would find it very gross

SnakeGrl

I would love to hear Mike’s opinion on Horders

Helie Dharia

There was a show called Bridalplasty that I watched over a single weekend in 2015. Brides compete to get their dream wedding for free, plus a laundry list of plastic surgery procedures. It's WILD.

Troy

my absolute favorite is marriage or mortgage (rip) netflix did one season and then it died, i miss it dearly

Barry

Survivor! It is so messed up the way contestants are starved and expected to lose drastic amounts of weight over 40 days

Michelle Hertzberg

Oh my God there are so many wild ones. Temptation island is the first that comes to mind.

Mira Lamson Klein

I am begging for Shark Tank, because I think he will be so annoyed by the premise of the show and the whole capitalist/bootstrap narrative. Also people having terrible pitches is truly excellent

Annie

agree! summer house! there is some really funny stuff this season

Bonnie O'Halloran

Love Island USA s6e10&12 Pretty Wild - episode 1 and 6 (the iconic “Nancy Jo, this is Alexis Neiers calling” moment)

Grace

The Bachelor season 16 - ep 1 and ep 6

Abby Whitewell

MILF Manor! Guys who love dating older women enter a manor with an equal number of cougars to pair off and date... But the twist is that their mums are also part of the cast looking to date guys their age. It's messed up and hilarious

Kayla

90 DAY FIANCE is such a great dumpster fire! Truly awful, but you can’t say it’s not entertaining!

LC GANG

Sexy Beasts: dating show where contestants meet while wearing garish and extremely creepy animal prosthetics. It's w i l d

Kath

Definitely farmer wants a wife Australia .They have like six girls per farmer and he has to choose and it’s so awful it makes my little feminist heart rage 😂😂 . It will make Mike angry for sure

Laura Cantrell

Hildi purposely ruining people's homes. It got worse in later seasons!

Faith Benamy

The bisexual season of “Are you the one?”

Aubrey Robichaud

Marriage or Mortgage! The decision making process of some of the contestants is wild

Sarah Bannoff

The Traitors - original UK version! It is the reality tv show that converted me.

Lotte

Vanderpump rules!

Taylor

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City

Kathryn m

The episode of House Hunters International in which a British guy quits his factory job to move to Spain and become a nightclub singer but doesn't want to live in a neighborhood that has Spanish people in it!

Alexx

Technically Great British Bake-off is reality tv, so that's my vote

katie

Survivor, always!!

Emma B

HOARDERS i want yalls take on the portrayal of mental illness in that show

AC Hicks

It should be a classic cultural touchstone: America’s Next Top Model

Cari Elliott

Love is Blind is one of the most unhinged reality tv shows I have ever seen. Have him watch the newest season. The bar for acceptable male contestants is in HELL. OR!! Megan Wants a Millionaire was canceled in 2009 because the (unconfirmed, I believe) runner-up of the show ended up killing his ex-girlfriend and ran to Canada. He removed all identifying characteristics from her body, fingers, teeth, so he would have more time to run. She was identified by the serial number on her breast implants. (Too dark for a fun episode?? Sorry lol...)

Laura joubier

The kardashians because even though there is diet stuff, there’s also plain stupid stuff

Ari Shirv

HOUSE! WIVES! Fall in love with Andy Cohen!

Mikayla French

SECRET LIVES OF MORMON WIVES 🗣️

Annie

HUMAN VS. HAMSTER

Covo

Project Runway. Any episode ftom Season 2 or 10, but half way through the season will usually give you the best cattiness as everyone is exhausted by then.

Nicole Jenkinson

I think temptation island might actually kill Mike. If he survived he might go track down and murder grant which would be an interesting side quest for the pod

Nicole Jenkinson

If you do this you’d need to watch both episodes 4 and 5 so you could watch the full spectrum of grants self delusion. Bonus point is that he is not even attractive and looks like Nigel thornberry, which I assume will drive Mike insane.

Molly

This. I feel like this is the one.

Molly

If you go to their bonus episode where they discuss the Bachelor, they discuss this scene!

Molly

YESSS. The more time goes on, the better it gets.

Emily

Australian Married at First Sight - i would recommend any “wedding episodes” though it gets good during the “dinner party” episodes..

Kathy Milliner

He needs to watch hoarders season 6 episode 4, hint it involves lots of poop.

Sham Sha

In the spirit of being a contrarian, I'd recommend the reality show hosted by Kristin Davis where a single woman was dating multiple men for the purpose of making a baby so they had a bunch of baby making challenges. Or he could watch the Queer season of the Ultimatum

Sham Sha

Humans are fighting hamster?

Sham Sha

Love is Blind would break him. And to think Season 1 is sorta the best

Annie

no, humans are competing against hamsters in a race to finish an identical obstacle course adjusted for their relative size

Amelia

Survivor 💯

jordan

You should watch “Worlds Strictest Parents” pleeeeease. It is WILD. It’s from the early 2000s and they send “out of control” British kids to live with parents in other parts of the world. There’s one where they send a gay kid to go live with this military family in the South which was WILD and another one where they send the kids to live with two gay men in the northeast (which is actually really wholesome). Both are MWAH episodes.

jordan

this!!!

Dee

More serious answer is Are You the One? Season 8 (the “sexually fluid community” season). But I do love and think Mike would hate all ghost shows, especially Ghost Adventures season 4, episode 18, where Zak writes poetry and tries to hook up with a lady ghost 👻

Dyan

Awww love on the spectrum for the love Celebrity big brother?? Extracted ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Anything on Bravo in Lisa Vanderpump’s world (or branched from… Summer House?!??!)

Danielle

The secret of skinwalker ranch, season 1, episode 1. The show is pretty unwatchable but the first episode is hilarious, from a guy being called “Dragon” as nickname (seemingly against his will) to their half brained “science” experiments

Danielle

Teen mom, catfish, parental control, flavor of love

Gabriella Smith

Second Australian MAFS, truly horrific stuff. Mike will hate it

Kenna Jean

KID NATION! It’s so wild - a bunch of kids in George Bush’s America run a Wild West style town on their own without adults. Imagine a hundred kids running a mess hall, doing sanitation services, “bartending” rootbeer at the saloon and doing cowboy-related challenges. According to legend, there’s an un-seen episode that the network thought was too communist to air. 😂

Kenna Jean

Also: Traitors, Rock of Love, and Gigalos!

Emily

🤣 love hate it im sure!

Cara Leopold

I’ve just looked this up because I was struggling to believe it actually exists!

Cara Leopold

You Are What You Eat with Gillian McKeith?

Lena Stolz

The Scary Island Episodes from Real Housewives of New York City 🤣

Sam Bringman

Sexy beasts!! Redneck island!! The only two I’ve ever watched and enjoyed enough to continue watching

Mary Hall

Catfish, hoarders, Millionaire Matchmaker! (Especially the first episode where she works with gay men in season 1 … it’s wild)

Carri drake

The traitors season 3, the whole episode is great but I think he would really hate, I mean love Episode 7 and 8. Also RHOA current season, episode 1.

Kate Francis

Not for the squeamish, but Ink Master is my fave. The creativity is so good, and it’s a super body-positive show. Any show, any season, but the earlier seasons where hotter than hot Dave Navarro is a judge would be my rec. Season 8 had a bunch of super-talented women, always a plus in a male dominated industry.

AlliOop

Love is blind!

Emily L

Rock of love!

S P

farmer wants a wife - american version for the brainrot

sammmmm

Queer Ultimatum

Susan L

I love Hoarders. Some of the therapists are so good! “You’ve got to feel it to heal it!” I love Dorothy the Organizer! I love Matt Paxton, the clean up guy - “We are all five decisions away from pooping in a bucket!” BUT this is not a show for someone who can’t deal with feces, urine, or dead cats! Sorry, Mike.

Meghan Healy

Catfish! Reddit has a good list of the worst catfish.

Emi

s3 episode 6 of vanderpump rules where lisa vanderpump invites 50 gay mayors to the event at her bar- it’s such 2014 tv at its finest and i think mike would have many many questions

Steph

PLEASE, The Ultimatum: Queer Love season!! Although I've talked about it ad-nauseam within my friend group, I would LOVE to hear both of y'all's take on that whole situation. Is Vanessa the villain we make her out to be, or is she the drama we need-- or both? We can all agree Yoly sucks, right? Is Mel truly as hot and perfect as she seems, or is she managing her image for national television? Does it matter?

Steph

This may not exactly count, but Couple's Therapy might be kind of an interesting one to explore. Not as trashy, but some good people watching. Particularly the thruple from Season 4 and Mau and Annie from Season 1 are interestingly toxic.

Tilly Webb

My vote would be be either the queer season of Are You The One? (ALL BI/PAN PEOPLE ON A REALITY DATING SHOW THEY CAN ALL DATE EACH OTHER AND ITS VERY DRAMATIC) or more recent seasons of Married at First Sight Australia! On season 11 there’s a villain with some pretty gross things to say about bodies, but also the most delightful hippy you’ve ever met - any dinner party episode would be good watching (episode 17 and episode 28 are excellent watching)

Charlotte

Rock of love. Joe Millionare. Tool Academy.

zebussy

Oh yes! Vice has an excellent series exploring early reality TV and this was one of the episodes, I highly recommend as the behind the scene bullshit is intense!

Edd

Survivor !!

Amy Marie

Sister Wives! Especially this season where they skilfully edit in flashbacks whenever Kody and Robyn lie. Oh!!! Or 90 Day Fiance! An older season when it was less shouty and more just unhinged

Sheena Young

Ugliest House in America is fun and not too long (a few weekends, tops). Lots of absurdity plus some actually sweet moments. Not much for the screamy drama.

Sheena Young

Season 1, eps 2 and 5 feature some of the ugliest bathroom (and extremely questionable *everything*).

Katia Fenton

The Australian one is also really dumb, recommend it aswell!

Sorcha Nolan

Below deck - season 3, episode 10, a classic chaotic ep!

Heather Eggleston

Love is Blind. Specifically season 2, though all seasons of the show are generally unhinged.

Ray Levy

WIFE SWAP!!!!!!!!

Alena Klompus

MILF Manor season 2 episode 8 which features a segment wherein the MILFs must identify the man by squeezing their butts. Both seasons have some incredible moments but this one is great. Also the show is literally called MILF Manor

Ruth Oprysko

Didn’t know that about Kitchen Nightmares! I change my vote to nailed it. Like it’s wholesome and I think Mike deserves something fun

Travis Cole

For a second I got this confused with Milf Island, which I would love for Mike to watch, but unfortunately is not a real show

Ren Gresbach

seconded the secret lives of mormon wives, the entire first season is insane and my roommate and i Cannot stop saying "i just dont know how momtok is gonna survive this"

jude

Queer are you the one!!

Riley

Vanderpump Rules

Radha Lath

Bollywood Wives. I hate myself but can’t not watch. Also Dubai Bling. Ridiculous shows, but I’m always ready for a new season.

Susan

MILF Manor!!!! Full Stop.

Claire Mossman

Hoarders. He will hate it lol. There are some truly gross episodes that will make his skin crawl.

Maggie Verrall

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives—the drama is insane and even though my wife hates reality tv we watched the entire first season together and loved every second of it. Love is Blind—any seasons are good but season 7 will make Mike the most miserable because it is insane amounts of drama and every single couple is unlikeable :) incredible

Parnian Davoodi

Farmer Wants a Wife Seeking Brother Husband or Seeking Sister Wife (it’s like Sister Wives meets 90 day) Any of the 90 Day the Other Ways

Annie K

Vanderpump Rules! Season 1

Kaylan Godfrey

The newest season on Sister wife’s of fucking crazzzzyyyyyy!!!

SarahBH

Vanderpump rules season one !

Gia Betts

Chimp Crazy. You will be horrified.

LL

Bridalplasty. It is the very worst of the human condition. Worse than The Swan. For newer shows, MILF Manor. Unhinged as it gets.

LL

I forgot to add a nice suggestion: Tudor Monastery Farm! Anthropologists live like it is 1500s England. It is actually pretty soothing!

Grace Carver

Selling Sunset! It’s an HR nightmare

Plover

survivor!!!!

Rose Campbell

SURVIVOR!!! y’all should watch 13, the race war season

Alex

Please the Chopped episode where they put honey in the dessert basket and make a huge thing about whether the vegan chef will decide to use it 😭 (he does)

Rachael MacLean

Absolutely would love to hear him react to Survivor.

Alex

The Hoarders Coming Clean episode with Carol. There were *so* many unanswered questions there.

Alexanda

Vanderpump rules seasons 1-3

Katie Connor

owning Manhattan on Netflix is all the DRAMA and they actually show some of the dealmaking side of real estate !!

Megan

Love is Blind! The first season

Sara Lewis

Married At First Sight (Australia)

Claire Slesinski

Definitely married at first sight or love is blind

Risa

are you the one season 8: come one come all is the best season of reality tv ever made

Sara

"MILLIONAIRE MATCHMAKER"! My extremely problematic fave. Maybe season 3 episode 8, “Douglas and Nicole”? or "Are you the one?”, season 8, any episode! or: “Instant Hotel”, an airbnb reality competition show that is very poorly designed, with sassy Australians. Maybe season 1, ep 1 “Adam and Kathy” or season 1, ep 3 “Samantha and James”.

Brittany Welch

Mike reacting to The Mole would be pretty great.

Emily Bednarz

Does Taskmaster count as reality television? It doesn't really matter - I just want you guys to talk about Taskmaster ♥️

Paula Bishop

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Kel Snow

The Golden Bachelor

Amy Nippert

Because you all deserve to relax, I'd pick one of the later seasons of The Great Pottery Throw Down. So chill, very British. Or the Japanese show "Old Enough" where toddler run errands so that I can hear Mike talk about walkable infrastructure 😂

melody cornwell

The ultimatum: queer love!! If you into dating shows this one is absolutely bonkers

Jane

the traitors!! the most recent season was SO GOOD

molly

Millionaire Matchmaker. Please <3

catnapping

the ultimatum queer love — if you want just one episode the reunion (& ep before) are fucking nuts

Zanne

The Swan or MILF Manor

Maya

S2E6 of Vanderpump Rules is the pinnacle of reality television. The very straight staff of a bar in WeHo go to pride

Jenn D

Naked Attraction (on hbo max) ANY episode

Jenn D

Come dine with me (British) or 4 in a bed (also British)

Jess M

Secret Lives of Mormon Wives!!

Caleb

Finding Prince Charming!! i.e., the gay Bachelor knockoff

Anna Convery

this is the content i need in my life 😭😭

Dani

YESSSS either the very first season or the one with Mae Martin SPECIFICALLY.

Dani

90 Day Fiancé for one season and then 90 Days the Other Way

Molly

latest season of Real Housewives of Potomac!! I NEED to know his thoughts on Karen’s DUI (bad, but the body cam footage was pretty ridiculous) and Ashley’s drag show (good, but also pretty ridiculous, mostly the older straight women’s reactions)

Marion Eichholtz

Anything Jax Taylor related (VPR or the valley)

Liz W

Coming in 2,000+ comments late, so you have plenty good suggestions. But PSA for AUBREY: just in case you didn't know, there are many seasons of The Bachelor/Bachelorette/Paradise AUSTRALIA, all available free on YouTube. You get the same formulas + the Aussie charm!

Dr Beth

Naked and Afraid!

Morgan W

Please please please. I need Mike's take on the RHOSLC universe. NEED

Mar Rodriguez

Temptation Island!! There is so much to this one- almost a “real” reality show with the host basically therapizing these men into accountability

Holly

Married at First Sight Australia Season 12 episode 14 or episode 32

Abbey

Super late suggestion for The Traitors (s2 or 3), since it’s full of reality show people from so many different franchises and networks . 😂

Donna Shrout

Season 1 Love After Lockup - for the prison recipes!

Kayla Renfro

Secret lives of Mormon wives (season 2!)

Charlie Haldén

THIS! It would be such a joy. Season 7 is my favourite, otherwise seasons 9, 4 or 11 would be lovely.

Amanda R

Secret lives of Mormon wives PLEASE

Carrie Shevelson

I'm very late and thought I had nothing to offer then there it was: the Seattle season of love is blind. Just so Mike can go incandescent over that Kirkland gal who actually lives in Arizona or something.

Cassie Riel

I’m so late, but FOR THE LOVE OF GOD THE MIKE WHITE SEASON OF SURVIVOR. Whatever episode Reddit thinks is the best

Ana Andrade

Love after lock up so silly but entertaining lol

Sarah S. Dawson

The Traitors with Alan Cumming! The outfits are just too good to miss.

Lam

Also voting for Vanderpump or the valley!

jane deaux

Awww "Hoarders" is just sad and scary, don't watch it 😢 I vote Season 1 of "The Real World" lol

Meg Higdon

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City hands down. Maybe reboot of Real Housewives NYC because I’m in love with Jenna Lyons

Maddy Williams

Drag race PLEASE! Mike will HATE it. All stars season 9, episode 9, entitled: Rosemarie's Baby Shower - The Rusical. Pretty drag queens, a truly unhinged musical based on campy horror movies, with surprisingly good vocals, CRINGY vapid love-yourself messaging, puns galore. You'll both love and regret it🙏

Jill Holland

I LOVE NEW YORK. Meet the Plaths Sexy Beasts. NAKED ATTRACTION Traitors Undercover boss.

De Roche

Also with Mike's squickiness toward bamoo stuff, some of those bathrooms might do him in.

Joy

It’s temptation island isn’t it 👀 accidentally teased in IBCK today

red

my partner and I have been on a Project Runway kick, and we recently started S4 (iconically the season Christian Siriano won, sorry spoilers for 2007). In episode 5 (very unfortunately titled ‘What’s the Skinny?’), the contestants are given their ‘client challenge’. The episode starts with Heidi Klum introducing them to a group of women wearing clothes that are too big to fit them. She then reveals that “these women recently underwent a big life change, they’ve all lost a significant amount of weight.” She explains that the clothing they’re wearing were their “favorite outfits from before their transformation.” The way I audibly groaned. The challenge is revealed - they’re to remake these ladies’ favorite outfits to fit their ‘new bodies.’ The whole thing absolutely reeked of 2007 diet culture thinness =virtue baloney. Anyway, love the show so much thanks for everything you do!!

Elaina B

90 day fiancé

Scregify

NAKED AND AFRAID HAS SOOOO MANY BAMOOS

Lisa Starke

Survivor for sure. I would love to hear Mike react to the bug eating challenges.

Alexa

Love is blind. Seriously. Or ultimatum queer love

Kiley

I’m so sad no one requested Are You the One all bi season 😩 the best season of reality TV

Becc Hillyer

I second this vote. Reality show gold

KT

Netflixslop Love is Blind and the Ultimatum. Also the Queer Ultimatum, especially S1. For these, I think he needs to watch as many full seasons as possible, time permitting. TBH, I would also love his take on Milf Manor, the 30 Rock bit turned IRL show, and Couple to Throuple. Probably one or two episodes of these would get the point across! And Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, especially the episode where Taylor’s mom crashes that party in S2!!!

Haley

Traitors FTW

Dd

Not sure if you’re still taking nominations, but RHOBH S1E9 - “The Dinner Party from Hell.” Or for something truly Interdimensional Cable, try Flavor of Love (any episode really, but S2E6 - “Who Loves New York” is a classic episode)

alex was here

oh my god, finally bringing Mike into the catastrophe that is 90 Day Fiance would be iconic!! 💀

Eliza

For Light Hearted and Palate Cleanser reasons I would recommend Come Dine With Me. Or Four in a Bed for equally unhinged UK weirdness!

Aurora Surber

returning to this thread to humbly request, maybe as part of a bigger bonus episode, could u pleaseee watch the episode of nathan for you called "the movement"? i feel like the path jack takes is soo archetypal for these fitness book marketers