Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 618272303.mp4

Downloads

Content

Full Uncut reaction to One Punch Man Season 3 Episodes 5 and 6

Files

Comments

JT

So, episode 5 actually omitted a character defining scene for Garou that was in the manga where he began eating some of the corpses of the monsters he killed while he was saving Tareo. Somebody on Reddit compiled the scene here. https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePunchMan/comments/1oso3xo/they_cut_the_scene_where_garou_eat_monster_flesh/ If ya couldn't tell, it's shit like this that also got people pretty unhappy with S3 on top of the poor animation. Since I stopped following the season, I've no clue if anything else was removed.

Brendan Wong

To you guys, Episode 6 might have been fine to watch at first glance, but if you actually look at the details, and this is a bit of a fun fact, it’s easily the worst and lowest-rated episode of the season. For example, Atomic Samurai’s head was literally cut off at the top during his conversation with Puri-Puri Prisoner? They just copied it straight out of the manga panel and forgot to draw the rest of his hair. Even crazier—if you pause during Captain Mizuki’s pole vault, she literally has six fingers on her right hand, which might've been a drawing mistake or possible use of Ai. Beyond that, the 'animation' was basically a slideshow. There’s a scene at the end that is just a 30-second still image with the camera slowly moving over it. That’s not an artistic choice; it’s a shortcut because they ran out of time. Even her outfit changes back and forth between shots because they couldn't stay consistent with the censorship. When you actually spot these mistakes, it’s hard to unsee them.

JT

16:29 The layers of irony behind this statement (and I don't mean that as a compliment for the writing).

JT

I'm trying to hold myself back and keep it together, but it's getting pretty difficult to sit through these episodes lol. Not ya'lls fault, of course.

Definitely Not Definitive

Yeah I imagine it would be hard to unsee them. And I’d be disappointed if they are using AI instead of animation artists. We may not be picking up on the details that you’ve pointed out and we aren’t yet as sophisticated with our animation knowledge and recognition as our community, but I’d be lying if I said I haven’t noticed a general feeling of cutting corners. I’m not savvy enough to put my finger on the specifics, but a general feeling of episodes being more like slide shows than full animated and compared to prior seasons has been felt by me. Don’t want to speak for Ken as he may be having a different experience. We’re still enjoying watching this because of the characters we’ve been hooked into though, so while I know there were many strong opinions about season 3 and it’s potential lower quality, we can see the legitimacy of those complaints and share some of that disappointment without hating our journey or throwing in the towel. We still want to know what’s going to happen next 🙂

Definitely Not Definitive

Oh wow, that does feel like a huge omition. And feels like if it was omitted simply because they weren’t up to the task of animating it rather than due to a broader plot plan then that would be a huge failure on their part. Not sure that is the case since we weren’t in the room where it happened when they chose to omit the scene to understand their reasons and we’re still on the journey so can’t speak to how this choice may be woven in with the plot, but it does feel like a pretty glaring issue and lack of consideration of the character and the fan base that is passionate about this story and the characters with a decent knowledge of it all from the manga.

Brendan Wong

Well, I still hope you have a fun yet interesting experience with watching One Punch Man Season 3. As I mentioned in another video, be sure to look forward to and keep an eye out for Episodes 8, 9, and 12. These episodes are the best of Season 3 and are the only ones that have produced good yet decent-quality animation. 👍🏻

Definitely Not Definitive

Honestly so grateful for what you and Brendan have shared. Since we only got into anime in the last couple of years we don’t have the same sophistication of animation pallet or attention to detail as you all have but I feel like I am getting smarter just reading this comments, like my awareness of animation and its styles is increasing and I’m sharing all this with Ken as well. Super grateful for this! 🙏

JT

Ofc np