Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 625530996.mp4

Downloads

Content

Early ad-free access for Part 16 of our playthrough of Red Dead Redemption 2

Files

Comments

Khadels Nerdo

It's interesting now that TB has been confirmed for Arthur, you now have a choice to turn some rewards of cash, which before he would just take it own his own

Chris Collier

The deer you see is a symbol of Arthur’s karma. When good, he sees a deer. A friendly creature that seeks to mind its own. When Arthur is more evil, he sees a wolf. A violent creature that kills and devours with no regard. Intersecting choices

Chris Collier

I think this is where Dutch begins to show his cracks. For years, he was a legendary outlaw. He could play the bad boy, the tactician, and the law was weak and scarce enough out west that he could get away with it. He was the untouchable swindler. But now that society is encroaching, the walls are getting tighter. There’s no fast talking or swindler’s trick that will stop society.

Angel Guzman

I was kinda dreading this part of the game for you guys. As soon y’all had Arthur going into Saint Denis and he began coughing, I knew it was going to be a tough watch. No matter how many times I’ve played this story and countless other people, Arthur going this disease because of his past actions really become difficult to watch 😕

Chris Collier

Something to note, back when Arthur was doing debt collections, Mr downes was said to be very sick, and spit his blood in Arthur’s face. This is likely where he got TB, and only noticed it after it progressed during his time in the tropical and muggy Caribbean.

Chris Collier

The ride back to Shady Belle is always so nice, I’m glad you guys let the music play and didn’t rush to get back :)

Chris Collier

I haven’t heard Unshaken (the ride back to shady belle song) in a while, I’ll admit it got to me. Such a good track. Haven’t heard it since its creator passed away last year. Stand unshaken, D’Angelo ❤️

Definitely Not Definitive

We were wondering how he got infected and that makes a lot of sense. There is also a karmic element to it as I hated the debt collectors and despise predatory lenders who take advantage of people don on their luck, as Strauss was doing. So if this is how Arthur got infected, by doing Strauss’s dirty work, I appreciate the karma to it and how actions have consequences, although I didn’t want Arthur to die. But to be fair he waited a while to become the man he wanted to be, and didn’t seem to really lean into that until he got out from under Dutch’s thumb. Prior to that a life of crime which included robbing and killing people was okay. I believe he had a code of sorts but I also suspect he bent that for Dutch. Feels a bit like this ties into something Ken will say in an upcoming talk back, (I’m paraphrasing) “once you are in that life it is really hard to get out of it… has a way of catching up to you.” Ken is actually saying that in reference to another character but it works here too. Our actions have consequences and they catch up to us, if not immediately then eventually. That’s often why things like forgiveness are so precious and highly valued, because it is rare. Retribution is almost always the more immediate desire and it is easier to do than forgive.

Definitely Not Definitive

It is a gut punch, no question. There is a lot about Arthur’s story that appreciate in terms of the lack of sugar coating and not just providing a romanticized version of the life, but there is also a lack of satisfaction by some of the “unfairness” that makes this story more aligned with real life than a romanticized western fairytale. The latter is more comforting, the former is just better story telling even if not totally satisfying because it gives us so much more richness in our emotional journey.

Definitely Not Definitive

Now that we have finished it, and I won’t give away more than that, but I am so fascinated to know about Dutch and Arthur prior to the events of RD2. And who they were before we meet them here.