Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 675171475.mp4

Downloads

Content

Full uncut reaction to Attack on Titan Season 4 Episodes 27 and 28

Files

Comments

JT

Publicly Available Info Episode 27 Enemies and Allies When Titans were the greatest threat, Titans were the enemy. When countries were the greatest threat, countries were the enemy. For as long as people hold firm to different beliefs, there will always be an enemy. Episode 28 The World Beyond the Walls, there is a sea. On the other side of the vast, blue sea is a continent. That continent has cities, bustling markets, and all sorts of people living there, just like on the island. But in the outside world, Subjects of Ymir are despised more than anything.

Sparks

Oh boy I have a lot to say about episode 27 so incoming. First off this episode introduces one of my favorite OSTs in the series being "Traitor" by Kohta Yamamoto. it begins to play right as the train explodes and sets the tone for the rest of the episode. Khota was the primary composer for season 4 specifically and Sawano took a more supportive role reusing quality music from previous seasons or making specific tracks in which a lot were used in episodes 20 and 21. Season 4 is very dark and morally gray and Khota's music is supposed to fit that. times have changed for the characters and the story so gone are the primary uses of the heroic anthems by Sawano from seasons 1-3 in favor of these more tense and dark songs like "Traitor" and "ashes on the fire". In terms of characters this is where I went from despising Floch to understanding why i despise Floch and that it was his goal as a character. As Hange and Armin symbolize what the scouts used to be and what they hope to return to Floch symbolizes what the Eldian empire's military has become in order to survive. Hate him or not he was unfortunately shaped this way by Eren's change of heart and his first mission as a recruit in the retaking of Shiganshina and without the context of our main character's relation to Eren and the possibility at stopping him Floch's speech to the yeagerists is correct. Given what we have seen in human nature and how episode 28 goes as well as this entire season has shown us if Eren is killed that is the reality they face. I love how Falco draws so many similarities to early season 1 Eren with the struggling to transform and the passion to help any way he can even if he is out of his element in some ways.

JT

14:34 The moment when Floch floched in and started having main character energy for a minute

JT

Well, the end of this journey is nigh. This bout to be one of the loudest finales this place has ever seen in every possible way, I can feel it.

Chris Collier

Mikasa really blew up those two yeagerists just for the aura. Like Ken said, she did that blood rain on purpose lol

Chris Collier

New Titan! Falco’s first transformation is a cool one. Middle of a live or death battle, y’know. Fun times

Chris Collier

RIP Magath and Shadis. Both stubborn old men who may have been abrasive and unsociable at times, wanted what’s best for “their kids” and were willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for them.

Jennywocky

E27: It was really great (and unexpected) to see McGath and Shadis come together like this, versus dying alone -- I think it meant something to both men to have this last bit of contact with another person (even a stranger) as they prepared for the end. To add to the good stuff said about McGath, I think it’s telling how in early S4 he’s typically relying on his rank to dominate the room, but we’ve seen him become aware of his own heart as the season progresses and realizes deep down he actually wanted a better life for all the kids he trained – a life he foolishly didn’t give them. At the end, he doesn’t refer to himself by title – he’s just a man named Theo McGath, spending his life in hopes that it somehow helps his kids. Keith Shadis also has a great mini-arc. Midway through the series we discovered that he was once the Scout commander and imagined himself special … then realized he wasn’t a hero after all, lost faith in himself, and handed the reins to Erwin Smith (who accomplished spectacular things) and became a teacher. The irony is that, by being moved by the kids he trained, he’s able to do something absolutely heroic: He makes sure the reinforcements can’t kill them and then he covers their escape with McGath. In the end, he does become a hero and makes a difference, just not in the way he originally conceived. Keith did actually matter. It’s kind of amazing to see characters who were enemies for season after season having each other’s back like they were never foes – it reinforces how people might be compatible if the circumstances had just been different. Annie’s got nothing left – out of all of them, she’s always up for a fight, but we’ve never seen her like this. It kind of makes you realize a lot of her callous aggression was in part to bolster her resolve for a war she wanted to leave before they even originally got inside the walls. Mikasa has become a demon of blood in some sense, she just cut through the Yeagerists like butter -- once she makes a decision, she's all-in. Because of Ackerman resiliency, I don’t think people realize how badly Levi was hurt by Zeke’s thunderspear; he’s not in action because he’s still recuperating. (You know if Levi could fight, he would.)

Jennywocky

That was just crazy when she sets off the guy's thunderspears. Geez. But hey there's not much left in the series, it's time for an aura farm.

Jennywocky

Yamamoto's music is great in both the original elements and/or how it translates Sawano's earlier compositions. (They kinda did the same thing in Eighty-Six as well.)

Jennywocky

Hey, it's not the battle for heaven and earth for nuthin' lol

JT

Oh, I'm not just talking about the show itself lol

Chris Collier

Dawn of Humanity is a really good episode. You get to see the flashback of them going to Marley for the first time with usual country bumpkin antics. You get to see Mikasa and Eren’s conversation about what he means to her, and her contemplation on whether or not a different answer could’ve affected Eren. And of course the port scene of all the battleships.

Chris Collier

I really like that you guys were able to see through the fog of Eren saying those things to Mikasa. AOT was HUGE while it was airing, and as a manga reader it was fun going through twitter when this episode dropped. Lots of pondering to do I think you’re right in that Eren is being childish and selfish, and deciding that pushing them away is what’s best for them without taking into account their wants or feelings. It sounds noble, but only if you look at it specifically from Eren’s emotional standpoint.

Andrew Zhang

I'm glad y'all are more perceptive than I was on my first read through. Ken is completely on point when he says that Eren's motivated by his shorter life span. Bethany also correctly pointed out how the Titan shifters, without a future to live for, can easily give in to hopelessness. This is why Eren is ultimately just childish and selfish in his conviction: a world where his friends are happy and alive means nothing to him unless he's there to see it or, in this case, guarantee it. I think this is something I only realized a month ago. Also, let's not forget that Eren's able to see future events. That gave me chills today to hear him tell Mikasa "Nothing yet." It really lets the viewer know that Eren's cynicism is beginning to hit a boiling point.

Sean Carroll

I think youre both severely underestimating Eren as a character in this season and this episode. 1. He has suffered for 4 years with all these constant future memories. Earlier in the season we see flashbacks to 2 and 3 years ago where he was desperate to come up with a plan that didnt involve the rumbling at all. Whenever everything would have happened during those 4 years that must have caused a terrifying dread and confirmation that what he has seen is real and that he cant change it. 2. The further that the 4 years went you can see the depressed look on his face get worse to the point where he looks like a dead shell of himself. Knowing that the devastation of the rumbling is coming closer and closer would have been so demoralising that no matter what he tries he will fail. 3. Yes when he asked Mikasa what she viewed him as that was definitely one last desperate moment of trying to change the future. If she had said she loved him that would have gone against everyhintg he had seen and maybe he would get the spark to find a different solution. 4. I also think you dont realise how desperate the situation was. After Willy Tyburs speech the entire world was preparing to launch a full scale attack on the island. With very little time left in his life and a desperation to save his loved ones from total annihilation Eren realised that he had no other choice and that the prior 4 years had brought him no other potential options to save everyone. 5. Eren certainly does have a very childish view on freedom and things in general. We have seen that multiple times throughout the show. He viewed freedom as a desire for the first time when he read Armins book and held onto that forever. The irony and tragedy of Erens character is that no matter how desperate he is for his version of freedom he was forever trapped in a time cycle that he couldnt escape from.

Jennywocky

E28: Yeah, this was the Scouts’ ‘recon mission’ to Marley, which ended up reaffirming the world despises Paradis in a way they don’t even despise the OTHER Eldians outside the island. It seems like such an impossible sentiment to overcome. Remarkable how much Gabi looks like Sasha – what an arc, where her penance for blindly killing someone is to be changed enough to physically and spiritually become like her. The ice cream moment was great, and it felt like an AD&D session when Levi picks up the kid and shouts "RUN" to resolve a social situation gone bad, lol. I don’t disagree with the things you said about Eren, but the big picture is still not entirely spelled out even if we can extrapolate some of it from the pieces -- there’s even more to him and to his decisions than what was attributed. We’ve seen hints of it (like him crying when Mikasa finds him) but we’ll get more in the movie(s). Bethany is right about how Eren HAS been looking for reasons not to go scorched earth, and Mikasa’s response was simply an element to his decisions. (I do appreciate when Zeke tells Eren there’s a simple reason Mikasa would do anything to protect him – it’s simply because she loves him.) Despite everything he is doing, I feel bad for Eren on some level – with everything he knows and everything he sees, and the burden of power in his grasp, can you imagine how LONELY that must be? The only people he could even afford to depend on was a condescending half-brother he was lying to (because Zeke wanted to exterminate all Eldians) and that asshole Floch, who Eren doesn’t care for either but who he also needed to use. He can’t even tell people he loves without needing to block their memories after. The kid is 19, no one’s in a position to advise him, and he’s truly alone. Side Note: Historia wouldn’t be “controlled by the King” unless she ate Eren. If she just ate the Beast Titan, she’d be a titan and could replace Zeke in triggering a Rumbling, but without the King’s influence on her mind. I loved the party with the refugees and how it was the last happy moment they had together, with Eren lying there asleep with his best friend and the woman who loves him on either side, along with his other friends. It has been captured in that one image, yet “you can’t take a picture of this, it’s already gone,” sigh – Six Feet Under. The power of the Rumbling is just horrifying and mind-blowing as we see them plow right through the world’s armada. Wait until the film. They showed “The Last Attack” in May in theaters, and on the big screen it was just crazy.

Sparks

Yeah its really good. I need to watch eighty six

Jennywocky

S4 Top Five: It’s so hard to not talk about the movie(s) when we talk about character arcs because so much is just perfectly resolved as this story wraps up. I never thought much of Jean and Connie until this season, then they both really shine – Jean for the reasons B&K suggested, Connie because even if he needs longer to grasp his own motivations and perceptions than others (and sometimes almost does the wrong things for the right reasons), he typically ends up at the right place in the end. They are both “everyman” characters who show us what actual heroism in a regular person looks like. And yes, Gabi. One of the best arcs of the season and even show – esp after she commits the unpardonable sin of killing our angelic potato girl. I am getting annoyed defending her online (because I don’t necessarily even like Gabi a ton), I just keep seeing her in polls of “most evil anime” characters along with Shou Tucker and Griffith – someone just argued with me this week that she never actually changed. (Did you watch S4??) Gabi teaches us about redemption and the potential for human growth. Hange shows such leadership this season. She had a far harder job (or at least a very DIFFERENT job) than Erwin did, as Scouts leader, and she somehow manages to thread the needle and pull together the slimmest of hopes to keep the Scouts’ spirit alive. She might be crazy, but she’s crazy like a fox. Armin has had one long arc throughout this ENTIRE series, each season building off the last, exploring his resilience (“I never run”) undermined by his own self-loathing, and the movie(s) will take this to their inevitable conclusion. Annie and Reiner both deserve kudos too, now that we understand them better. I love Annie for cutting right to the chase, reminding everyone of where this is going, and are they in or out? Falco is a beacon of goodness and light. He must be protected at all costs! Floch went from whiny bitch to formidable adversary. They needed a Floch in this story, and so here we are. I think Zeke was a pretty rich character. I disagree with him too, but I “get” him… and even his story is not yet done.

ArcaneAnomaly

"I'll kill them all, every last one!" - Eren in Season 1 Episode 2, talking about his enemies. "I'll kill them all, every last one!" - Eren in Season 4 Episode 28, talking about his enemies. "Since the day I was born, this is who I've been." - Eren in Season 4 Episode 20. I really do like the underlining of that. Who Eren saw as his enemies has changed, but his reaction hasn't.

Grimmxlaw

IMO, for season 4: 1. Reiner 2. Gabi 3. Jean 4. Falco 5. Connie Reiner by faarrrrr is my favorite. The other characters are good, but I like him more than any other AoT character by a lot.

deron

I like that scene at the conference where they originally last saw Eren, cause it was probably right then when he was fully resigned to his plan. He saw that there WAS some people out there that sided with Eldians, however even they hated the ones within the walls in Paradis. That must've been the tipping point for him.

user00

Well said

xAcEx Lee

He knows he wont be there to see them be alive and happy after four years, so he will do whatever it takes to guarantee their safety, so they could live long lives. Who knows if they'd be happy, but they'd live long lives without having to worry about others calling them island devils and wanting to exterminate them.

Zeno

I just think Ken doesn’t like eren at all even from the beginning so thats why there really underestimating him like the comment “he’s doing this because she didn’t tell him she loved him “ like im glad she called him out on that like no that was one of the last desperate moments eren had and there was many attempts to not start the rumbling

mantis toboggan

for "so long as there are differences there will be fighting" i interpret it as it as a harsh reality rather than saying proposing no differences is a solution. Cynical and depressing maybe but i think there's a strong argument that some of the dark parts of human nature can never be fixed. Oof.

deron

From what I understand, Reiner's name is German and the way the show pronounces it is technically the correct way.

mantis toboggan

i love this episode. it's so sad that eren convinced himself this was the only way and spent so much of his limited lifespan in abject misery. And even though Eren is obviously wrong, I think it's such cool imagery to see the little boy who lost his mom become a god and fight the entire world because of it. What a cool expansion of the lore and mythos from ep 1 to now.

Mosh Mia

Damn these 2 episodes are brutal! The brutal fight scenes in the first one and you get some insight as to what Eren was feeling during his time 'across the sea'. Essentially he had already seen some future events occur hence his general mood and sadness, your right to an extent in that he was looking and hoping for had been a different outcome to the one he was getting. Alas everything pretty much played out as he expected it to, though he made a half hearted attempt IMO to get Mikasa to open up her feelings to him and perharps change course, it was for naught and i doubt he thought it would succeed.

Reed James

The movie is part of the Final Season. They're called the Final Season: The Final Episodes.

John

can you guys watch the 18 minute AOT live orchestra vid after this? it's a live orchestra performance of aot's greatest OSTs, most people who react to aot also watch it. it's on youtube titled "Hiroyuki Sawano / Project【emU】 “Attack on Titan” suite"

Mosh Mia

My top 5 were Armin, Gabi, Zeke, Eren and Hange.

Val

Yeah, you're not really supposed to be on Eren's side at this point lol your frustration is valid but you also gotta understand that he's SEEN a lot of the future. Him asking Mikasa that question was his final attempt to see if the future can change. Bro was praying for a different answer 😭 also, the entire world was going to come crashing down on Paradis. In Eren's mind, he had no choice but to destroy the world. And in regards to Eren saying those hateful things to Mikasa, sure we know it was real shitty of him but that's the point. Eren is about to bring the world to hell. He absolutely does not want his friends to be involved with his genocidal plan so he kinda has to push them all away. Something that is also easy to forget is that Eren is only 19! 19 with the power of a "God"

Andrew Zhang

Agreed on the DND energy in the last episode! On the topic of the Rumbling, I find it amazing how much death and destruction this anime showcases, only for us to realize that Titans, despite their grand imagery, are actually not even the most threatening calamity by modern technological standards. I think seeing the Rumbling for the first time was what finally drove home the fear of nuclear armageddon. Also the pure existential horror Eren would've had to live through, knowing for years that he would be the one to push the big red button to destroy the world.

Akka

Man, I loved the ending sequence of ep 28. Everything about it was perfect, seeing all of those battleships together gave you a sense of hope that they could actually do something and lessen the rumbling at the very least. The music really added to tension, and I loved how music stopped. Then when we see that the battleships' guns could actually damage and even kill the titans gave you more hope that they could do something, then we see that there are a lot more. The ships get destroyed, and then they make landfall. The music really sells the utter despair and helplessness of the situation. Then we see Eren's titan form, which was horrifying enough. The world called them island devils, so they sent one back in return. I loved the depiction of the rumbling as a biblical event because in a sense, it is. Fun fact, Eren destroying the world was hinted in season 1 a few times. The first one was when our trio was cornered, and Eren was saying that he would kill them all. Then we see it again when he's about to eat Annie when he says "Die, all of you, everything!" Interestingly, in the orignial Japanese dub, he says directly "I will destroy the whole world!" giving us even more of a hint of what was eventually to come. I'm somewhat dreading what comes next, but also can't wait. There was a nearly two year gap between this finale and the next film, which was one hell of a cliffhanger to leave a season finale at.

Sean Carroll

I agree, Ken has a strange problem with characters that show weakness and pain which was evident when Eren was struggling in season 3 and armin doubting himself earlier in the show. It seems since then he hasn’t liked him so much. Glad Bethany corrected him because sometimes he reduces something to a much smaller degree than it actually is which is why I left the comment. I personally just found the eren commentary from them this episode was really short sighted

Alfreddd

its not a fantasy its a flashback

Alfreddd

thank you for being normal people. cant stand reaction channels that do mental gymnastics to justify siding with Eren

Jennywocky

Yeah we will get a much better perspective on Eren in the final film. MAPPA and the manga purposefully left him rather enigmatic during much of this season.

Jennywocky

I can't believe this view is almost over. I kinda don't want it to end. But hey.... then it's time to watch it all again lol.

Jennywocky

I was kind of avoiding discussing it much until we get that clearer window into Eren's thoughts in the finale and everything is on the table. We are talking about world genocide, so people have different levels of emotional response to that. Eren's situation is more complicated (and multi-faceted) than what some viewers might guess from what he's doing overall...and face it, his behavior has been pretty consistent in the large sense... his view of who his opponents are has simply changed. But this is still the Eren who admitted to Reiner "we're the same" -- he's not oblivious. I think this is also a situation where the options people are considering might not be realistic and would generate extensive discussion. For example, would a limited Rumbling actually be beneficial long-term or is this a simple Trolley problem, where either all Eldians or else the outside world realistically are getting run over to end this particular war? And even if it's the latter, should the limited option still have been taken anyway, ethically? I do think some viewers overlook Eren's (limited) prescience. How much of Eren's choice derives from the reality he's aware of at least some future events and doesn't see any viable alternatives that would spare people? He knows things we do not. Also another important question is whether Eren is "truly free," as the show posits that we are all slaves to something, and if the future model is deterministic, even if Eren makes choices, can he actually alter anything? I think the finale digs into these questions, so maybe the discussion will change a bit once everyone sees it.

Jennywocky

I remember growing up in the last decade or two before the USSR collapsed and the fear of nuclear armageddon. It was pretty palpable, and watching AoT I couldn't help but think of Nagasaki and Hiroshima... basically a limited Rumbling that targeted cities of some military significance but also targeted a lot of civilians. Weirdly the firebombing of Tokyo probably killed more, but it's the mushroom cloud that sticks in one's mind just as the Titans are the more memorable image. Eren's been thinking more about his role in this more than it seems and it's agonizing.

MadeByMali

I’m late to watching this but I think we’re undervaluing Eren’s character quite a lot. Don’t get me wrong, at this stage in the story, Eren is the villain. He is wrong. But there is a LOT of nuance. Keep in mind that Eren does not only carry his experience. He is carrying 2000 years worth of memories and experiences. Not like how we can read a book and know history. He actually has those memories in his head. He has also seen the future. Knowing about slavery and actually carrying memories from a slave during their experience during slavery would have significantly different effects on you. That’s what Eren is dealing with. It’s not arrogance or condescension… he genuinely knows the past and future in a way nobody else on the planet does. Now with that said, his solution is ofc highly problematic and is more of a band aid solution. It’s fueled by anger and resentment. But Eren isn’t happy with his decision. He’s actively trying to find another way. He tried for years to change the future he saw but in the end he was unable to find a path that differed from the future he saw. It’s totally fair to be against Eren at this point and I’m pretty sure we are supposed to be but it’s not as simple as Eren is just being stupid and childish. His choices are wrong but dare I say valid. If anyone was constantly experiencing the oppression of their people over the span of 2k years and also knowing that oppression is doomed to continue in perpetuity unless something changes, and they had the power of basically a god, who’s to say many other people wouldn’t make the same choices.

Definitely Not Definitive

Love this analysis from Sean and Jenny, so important to learn from these additional perspectives and gain understanding of things we may have overlooked. And only good content will inspire these discussions!

Definitely Not Definitive

Love this analysis of Floch and the music. You are spot on too about Floch, we didn’t like him but his role was so important to the story and to understanding human nature in the face of conflict, genocide, prejudice, etc. If we didn’t have Floch the themes of the story would suffer hitting as hard as they did. We often try to simplify things because that helps us understanding and pick sides, but like the shades of grey you referenced, things aren’t always easily black and white and life is full of grey for us to navigate. That makes life interesting and hard and we won’t always show up at our best and make the choices we’re proud of, that’s human nature. Floch is easy to understand and while we’d like to believe we’d make a different choice, when you understand how scared Floch is and that fear drives his choice, in that world of them being under constant threat, how many of us would act that differently? We hope we would, but when fear drives a choice we rarely make the best one.

Definitely Not Definitive

I love that they did that. Because in life we don’t have a clear glimpse into the mind of people, we draw conclusions based on the evidence we have but it is never the full picture. So for Eren he takes us through such an emotional and cerebral journey of morality. I mean if it were easy to side with him all the time AOT wouldn’t be as incredible as it is. It is turning our hero into the villain and making us question our loyalty but then making us understand him and making us question our righteous condemnation. In life we can be so quick to do these things and this show really holds up that mirror and asks us if we like what we see.

Definitely Not Definitive

Love this analysis of McGath and Shadis, and they so totally earned it too that I’m thrilled someone kind of eulogized them here in the comments. Thanks, Jenny! 🙏

Definitely Not Definitive

The knowledge you’re going to push the red button and nothing can prevent that is a horror my mind can’t really wrap itself around. But it does instantly make you feel sorry for Eren. How someone lives with that feels impossible.

Sensei

Lol this is not an attack on the reactors but everyone I watch always tries to minimize or push to the side the point of.. the world already banded together and declared war on them… there was no other option Eren is not “forcing” his opinion of freedom.. he is surviving if he doesn’t kill them, they will kill them and as you saw early in this season the world can fight regular titans

Sensei

I always wanna know what the “other options” people say Eren has are I really couldn’t think of anything because of how much propaganda and fear the rest of the world has

Jennywocky

Later of course we find out that Eren did try alternatives but could never change the future he was witness to, so that's yet another wrinkle -- but it mostly to me comes down to whether one could morally sit back and just let Eren proceed or whether someone (e.g., Hange and a few of the remaining Scouts) just could not permit genocide no matter what the cost to themselves or the outcome for Paradis. Would a smaller scale Rumbling have been an effective deterrent? No one in Marley truly considered peace until it was clear they would be wiped out, and Paradis had been marked for extermination by Willy Tybur even before Eren attacked Liberio. Even Hange admitted she couldn't provide an alternative for Eren, she just firmly believed genocide to be wrong regardless.