Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

During the course of writing the latest video, I had a fair amount of correspondence with Tiddy Smith, the author of Death by Talons. Quite early in that correspondence, we had an extended real time conversation to help me get my head around his theories on the case - beyond what’s even postulated in his book. 

We spend the first halfish of the conversation fleshing out the details of what Tiddy terms the “Unified Owl Theory.” The basic premise explained in the video where Kathleen was somehow attacked by an owl while alone outside, leading one way or another to the ultimate crime scene.

After that we move on to some newer, more outside the box ideas - namely that an entirely different bird of prey may have somehow been introduced to the Peterson residence through circumstances unknown, and in the presence of additional company undisclosed, some point after which all hell broke loose and a vast two-way cover-up ensued. 

Who would have had such a bird and why? Where are the feathers? Was the raptor still in the house, wrapped up in a bunch of towels beneath Kathleen’s head when responders arrived? We explore all these questions and more!

Warning: I used illustrative imagery including the actual photo of Kathleen’s scalp, as well as the most graphic portions of the crime scene walk through as they became relevant to certain theories. There are on screen warnings before they’re shown, but they are completely uncensored. It’s all already in the public domain and only used insofar as it’s relevant, so no gore-exploitation here, but it’s definitely worth readying yourself for. 

Tiddy’s Book: https://www.amazon.com.au/Death-Talons-Murder-Kathleen-Peterson-ebook/dp/B0C9R4NBBX

Gallery: https://wildbluepress.com/death-by-talons-gallery/Ursula Franco’s Bare Hands Theory: https://malkecrimenotes.wordpress.com/2015/03/18/the-murder-of-kathleen-hunt-atwater-peterson-at-the-hands-of-michael-peterson/

Files

Or Maybe It Was A Red-Tailed Hawk: A Conversation w/ Tiddy Smith

Comments

Geraldine Kelly

Thanks again Matt, you really are spoiling us this year. Big hugs for a Scottish Hogmany when it comes. Xxxxxx🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

Geraldine Kelly

Still waiting on you doing an interview with the Penguin Theory dudes😆😆😆😆😆

Evilbrother425

The bare hands theory makes so much sense. I can't believe it wasn't pursued in court or in the documentary.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

If you revisit the clip in my video of Jim Hardin's opening statement, he does actually name check the steps as a weapon, but he asserts it couldn't have been that alone. Personally, I agree with him - as a layman.

Monica

I can appreciate that there are some facts in this case that don’t point to a bludgeoning. I can’t get behind a large conspiracy to hide a bird attack though. Especially when Mike has a history of another woman’s death in his past.

Sylvia

I’ll be real, the bird stuff doesn’t pass the sniff test for me. Without going on too long, it’s a lot of theorizing that hinges largely on her head wounds, and I’m far more willing to believe she was murdered by her husband and her wounds are unique because being murdered with the trimming of a staircase is unique. Edit: Like okay let me just go over some evidence and my opinion of each: small feathers: contamination Large feather photos: big if true? Unique Head injuries: aforementioned unique trimming as weapon Hair in various locations: Michael pulled her backwards down the stairs by her hair Throat injury: choking to slam her head Blood patterns: as simply as possible, looks like someone attacked her more than any other possibility imo. Natural, double fall: I like it more than bird theory 🦅 Weird husband: definitely

James Higgins

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year Matt. I hope you have a prosperous and successful 2025. I'm holding Chch down, don't worry. Thanks for all your hard work; I continue to highly value my monthly investment in your work. Thank you. Much love

Alan Holding

This was fascinating, thanks for sharing.

PaintinByNathan

Knowing you’re a slow reader is pretty inspirational to me. I’ve wanted to create a YouTube channel in a similar vein that would require me to do a lot of reading but I’ve always held back because of how slow of a reader I am, so knowing you consider yourself one is giving me a good kick in the pants to get going with it. Love your channel!

TinTicket

So, during Todd's wild xmas party his secret pet hawk goes crazy and kills his mom, and everyone (including the state) is cool with ignoring all the evidence. Mostly impressed with how well Matt interviews Tiddy, well done and clear, good balance of respecting him and giving him the chance to speak but some good challenge. Although, and this is my major issue with the interview - why are we never shown Tiddy's new puppy?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

He showed up during a bathroom break but I had to cut it for flow! Annoying huh, I knew people would like a cameo. Miniature Schnauzer named Hades :)

Jonathan Gill

Tiddy is a very engaging speaker, so this is a great interview. But he lost me particularly when he theorizes that the whole thing is a coverup for a Christmas party where Todd unknowingly unleashed a falconry accident. I have doubts about whether that many people could coordinate a covery story and keep it consistent. I have even stronger doubts about money buying off all the investigators that came to the crime scene. And there are supposedly hundreds of feathers on the footage? At some point, the coverup theory becomes more implausible than the oddities it's designed to explain. And there certainly are oddities in this case. But I don't find it too hard to imagine an attack leaving odd-shaped head wounds, or investigators somehow misplacing the evidence presumed to be from a murder weapon--even if I don't have strong explanations for either.

TinTicket

Tiddy is a great speaker, he was likeable. What I find interesting about him is he is on the cusp of awareness - where he goes "I don't know, this insane, why would this happen this way?!?!". So close to going "oh wait..." I think he wants answers, he's not "crazy", he wants to try and make sense of an event that probably looked like a Final Destination film scene.

Samuel Stewart

Great discussion. Tiddy had some really great ideas. Sort of lost me at the double conspiracy aspect. As for the "party trick gone wrong" theory - why couldn't the Petersons have removed the bird by tearing it off Kathleen before the paramedics arrived? That seems more likely in my mind than paying off first responders or using Michaels political connections. I seem to remember the doc mentions he was at odds with the local political establishment over some articles he wrote so not sure how much influence or goodwill he would have but it's been a long time since I've gone back so that may not be accurate. As you pointed out, it also doesn't make much sense that Michael would risk life in prison for Todd over negligent homicide and poaching fines. Great stuff as always!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It's that exact point I remember getting stuck on in the interview - I might have even cut a bit of talking in circles around it because I remember it being a little annoying to watch back. We were speaking past each other a bit because I couldn't click with the logic of it - and still can't. If it were a situation like that, and they've come to settle on the plan of concealing the bird, why in god's name would you allow responders to arrive on scene before getting the bird off her head?? Even if you have to rip it through the scalp - which is exactly what Tiddy thinks ultimately happened. If so, surely it was done before the responders arrived. You want to hide something that badly, and Plan A is to just hope the people who arrive to find a dead raptor latched on the back of a dead woman's fucking head will just go along with being bribed and hopping aboard this bizarre scheme?? Which is exactly what they do and they totally pull it off and get everyone else on board too??? No - does not not compute. If we were to go down the road of a full on conspiracy, the only way I could find myself to sort of make it work would be if it were a one way conspiracy where Michael and co successfully hid enough bird evidence and the police just drew the most common sense conclusions they could from what was left. Not saying I endorse that by any means, but it's the best narrative I can create with the most fundamental assertions in Tiddy's thesis.

Claire

Matt, I'm just now watching The Staircase and can't believe you passed up the chance to include the scene of Mike singing Do Re Mi from The Sound of Music in preparation for his court testimony 🤯😂

Dan Kelly

Matt Orchard is the man. I don't have a point other than subscriber activity possibly helping the channel. I guess I do have a point - more - I want more.

David McKinnon

Re finding feathers, could an innocent explanation be from a pillow(s). Our pillows leak feathers every now and then, it’s not uncommon to find one half poking out of a pillow or already out on the sofa/ground etc. In my view, I can’t get passed the 911 call. Michael said my wife fell down the stairs. Zero qualification, as if he had seen it. I think when ppl speak about things they haven’t seen they add qualifiers, “she must have fallen down the stairs”, “maybe she fell down the stairs” etc. that’s to say nothing of the fact it’s 3am or 4am, and to Michael, a supposedly uninformed viewer, the probability of her having fallen down the stairs was no greater than the probability of a break in and assault, which would increase the requirement for a qualifier when describing what he thought had happened.

AR

I was sort of on board the bare hands theory until I got to the part where she says Peterson looks like Popeye and implies that this gives weight to the idea that he used his arms. Why can't a single sane person attach themselves to this case

Jonathan Gill

The writer is obviously not using that as an actual point of the argument. It's brought up at the very end to thematically link to the Popeye epigraph. They're merely couching their argument in a loose "theme", which is something Matt does in many of his videos.

Joris Oosterbeek

This guy is straigth up nuts. Michael paid off the police to make up a fake story and persecute him to cover up that his son killed his mother with a bird? He bribed the cops to get himself convicted? absolute gobbledygook.

Chad McRod

Birds aside, I really appreciate the way you conduct your interviews where you challenge Smith’s logic and the evidence head on instead of letting, for lack of a better term, politeness rule the conversation. I can tell you’ve got a good head on your shoulders for critical thinking, you would’ve made an excellent English major!