Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 428862449.mp4

Downloads

Content

Another commentary to tie you over!

Discord: https://discord.gg/UXccftmd

The dissent comment I liked:

"Great video, but I think you place too much burden on the defense to provide an alternative theory of the case and alternate suspect. That isn't their job. They don't have the investigative resources or legal authority to investigate the crime and interrogate alternate suspects. What the defense did do is successfully show that the prosecution's case wasn't strong enough to overcome reasonable doubts. Such as how he killed his father in such a bloody way but had only minute specks of blood on his jacket, none on his body or the rest of his clothing (as far as can be seen on the surveillance camera) and none in his car. What was the murder weapon, where is it? The ear-witness testimony may have cleared him, if you believe their initial statements, and the one with the more specific timeline. No single element is dispositive but together they do raise a lot of doubtable scenarios. All the prosecution really had was the logical starting point of Dennis being the last known person to see his father that night, and the fact the phone was probably, although not provably, somewhere it wasn't supposed to be. Dennis isn't accountable for where his father's phone is, unless you can prove that he stole it, which they had no evidence of. That really isn't enough to convict. I'm not saying he's innocent; he seems like a very good suspect. There might have been a lot more evidence the police could have collected to prove he was guilty, but they failed to do that. A court can't rubber stamp a failed police investigation just because we think the guy might have done it." 

I also made a compilation of Wexler being cute for friends and family, so here's an extra bonus for you Wex enthusiasts. Includes the same clip from last time. He's well settled in now :) : https://youtu.be/5hs2-JyYCDA

Files

Comments

Alan Holding

Thanks for update! Did you consider reaching out to Samsonite for an integrated ad read for the Sarah Boone video? Jokes aside, I'm looking forward to your take on it. I did have a few queries about the WM3 because I went and watched all the Paradise Lost videos and I'm still a bit confused, but I suppose it's like the JBR case, we'll never definitively know... speaking of which, did you see the Netflix documentary? Okay that's enough rambling, give Wexler a chin rub from me, he's a very good boy.

Rob

Man I haven't watched this one in a long time. Instang classic

Rob

"The Night Of" is amazing. Shame Gandolfini died.

SimplySnaps

As for the "Interest only mortgage" question you posed around 17:50, Dennis had good reason to be pissed about that. Interest only loans/mortgages mean for a span of time, all you pay on the mortgage is interest. If what Dennis says in the interview is to be believed, that means he was paying interest to his father in the ballpark of 4-figures a month. Interest only periods don't contribute at all to your actual amount OWED, meaning Dennis was spending what little money he had to his father who didn't need it, and he wasn't even paying off his actual debt. Essentially, it's a smaller monthly payment for a span of time before your actual monthly payments begin, whether that's in a span of months or years. Richard was a very wealthy man. Having interest on a loan to his son is already greedy enough, but collecting monthly interest that didn't actually contribute to Dennis's total amount owed is ghoulish in my opinion. Absolutely zero fatherly love there. Richard stood to profit from this bailout. In his eyes, the lower monthly payments were probably meant for Dennis to land on his feet and start making enough money to handle the principal amount. None of this is meant to lean one way or the other on Dennis's guilt or innocence. It's simply pointing to an extremely screwed up financial situation Richard put his son in, and apparently expected him to be grateful. I think there are two ways to view Dennis's softer opinion of his father. As the prime suspect, I think it's fair to say Dennis would want to avoid publicly trashing his father for any reason regardless of his guilt. Anything negative he said about Richard could and would be used against him by the state, even if he didn't kill the man. With that in mind, the "He wasn't perfect, but he was my dad" approach is respectable and has no real bearing on his innocence or guilt either way. It's the only possible stance he could take regardless.

Captain Panda (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-07 07:00 Wait, the West Memphis Three is one you would say is MORE likely they were guilty than Dennis Oland? Please tell me I misheard that. If I didn't, can you expound upon that? Because when I look at the West Memphis Three I don't even think they are more probably than not to have done it, I think it's outright EXTREMELY unlikely. What evidence do you have that I'm missing on that one??
2025-02-28 15:28

Jan Piet

I know you were just saying a number but 92% is not nearly enough to be beyond a reasonable doubt in my opinion. That would mean 8/100 convicted murders are wrongfully imprisoned for decades of their life if not dying in prison. Beyond a reasonable doubt for me would be closer to a 1 in a 1000 chance they didn't do it. Still think Denis Oland isn't too far off that though given how many coincidences need to align for it to look this bad for him while being innocent... I could've gone either way as a jury member on this one.

Jan Piet

Yeah, exactly. 99% is more reasonable but even then still a bit on the weak side imo. I get that at some point you've gotta start convicting some people and absolutes don't exist, but when the punishment is completely life-ruining you better get those percentages up...

Gekkotor

Tbh yeah the father had a lot of money but half a million is still a decent chunk of 37 million, especially if it’s not a give and take relationship, my family is not at the poverty line but no where near 37 million, and me and my parents still alternate payment responsibilities on take always, I just think if i was just taking and taking and taking, ied expect my dad to want some money back at least, also the father here probably had money if different places not just sitting in the bank so ied say he probably drew that money from somewhere, I can’t really blame him from wanting it back

Jonathan Gill

I was surprised by that as well. Off the top of my head, I'd guess it's because of how accurate the one guy's description was of the broken bottle. But I didn't come away thinking that was a clear-cut case by any stretch.

Jonathan Gill

Hearing about the witnesses who observed Oland at the wharf has me curious: I doubt there's enough details to speculate about what was in the bag he had. Assuming he's guilty, there'd be the phone. Maybe the murder weapon? and a poncho or whatever blood-soaked clothes he had? It's not clear to me why he'd want to remove the phone anyways (again on the presumption of guilt). Also: surprised you didn't say much about the twist ending, which I thought was a really effective card to hide until the last few seconds: Dennis later faced a bizarrely violent allegation of domestic abuse. Of course that has no evidentiary weight on his innocence regarding the father's death, but it sure does flag him as someone capable of the sort of violence this murder necessitated.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Well there's not much to say beyond that really, is there! But I'm glad you liked the little twist at the end. I too thought the play of withholding that tidbit til the very end was an effective play :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Putting a number on it isn't really a perfect way of talking about the standard - it'll do in a pinch, but at the end of the day it comes down to grappling with what "reasonable" means. You can't just assign a number to that question. When you start saying it should be beyond 99 percent, because after all, anything south of that would mean a statistically visible chance of a wrongful conviction...are you truly being "reasonable" or veering off into "scintilla of theoretical doubt" territory? Just sticking with speaking of it in percentage terms for the time being - If you were to go with my prescription of having to be at least say 92 percent sure, I don't actually think using that standard would result in 8% of criminal trials yielding a wrongful conviction. In cases where a defendant seems guilty to a 92% degree of certainty, I'd wager they are indeed guilty 99.99% of the time or so. It's certainly possible for an innocent person to be on the wrong end of an unfortunate coincidence or two, but when such circumstances just keep piling up...I think people very rarely get that unlucky outside the realm of fiction. You've also got to remember the other side of the coin. Yes we all hate the idea of sending an innocent person to prison for a serious crime like murder. What if it were us? But what if someone you loved were horribly murdered, and the state had enough evidence to demonstrate who did it to a point that should satisfy anyone with common sense: Solid motive, his car was parked nearby, there's DNA markers (though not perfect 1 in a gazillion type ones), he was captured on film disposing of unidentifiable "garbage" at a really unnatural hour that night...But we don't quite have him absolutely dead to rights. Never could confirm it was the murder weapon he was throwing away, the DNA does match like 5% of the population, another person COULD have gotten in the room in which your loved one was killed... Should the person who (almost certainty) killed someone you love get to walk off into the sunset just because we didn't quite get him committing the crime on camera and he's able to demonstrate a theoretical possibility it wasn't him? When you start thinking about the human tragedies that would result in really applying a 99.9% standard of proof, I think it's every bit as troublesome as the idea of wrongful convictions.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I probably shouldn't make one to one comparisons between the WM3 and Oland cases because I frankly haven't spent anywhere near as much time contemplating Oland and today I'm more scratchy on the details of it than I was back when I wrapped it. But you didn't mishear me! I am personally satisfied on the guilt of the three to what I'd put at a 98% degree of certainty. And the remaining 2% isn't actually based on anything I see as exculpatory. It's just that ultimately it was all done out of sight in the woods, and the crime scene is literally very muddied, so without one absolute be all, end all silver bullet, I have to leave SOME room. Explaining my position here is tough..So, I intended on making (and still intend on making) an addendum that outlines my opinion and why I hold it, and I wanted to be extremely thorough with it so I'd never have to speak on the matter again. I even started writing it...but then I saw how much it was going to balloon and turn into a whole project in and of itself and so I've just had to bench it while i work on other main projects. Then whenever i go to explain myself in a thread like this, I realize I'm gearing up to write the fucking addendum. One thing leads to another with that one. So the first thing I'll say is if you want to get read up on why you should be a non, Gary Meece's "The Case Against The West Memphis Three" is something I would basically co-sign roughly 90 percent of. I might disagree with an opinion or argument here and there, but just pedantic stuff. A good free resource would be a blog called WM3 Revelations. A good start would be this article: https://thewm3revelations.wordpress.com/2013/03/24/understanding-the-crime/ And in terms of just stating as succinctly as possible why I'm convinced without accidentally writing a book: I believe the logistics of the day - who was known to be where and when - pretty much boxes out any alternate suspect that's actually been named. John Mark Byers and Terry Hobbs that is. Remember that Terry was seen driving through the neighborhood calm and clean (with his 4-yeard old daughter in the car mind you) around the time the boys were first being noticed as missing. How he was reasonably supposed to shake little Amanda and brutally murder, bind, and conceal three children before or after this time with everyone being none the wiser is a question I rarely even see approached by those who favor him as a suspect. As to the actual guilt of the three - I really, really could go on all day, but if I had to reduce it down to one thing, I find Jessie Misskelley's confessions to be credible *in the main.* That very importantly includes the first one. Yes there are some leading questions that piss me off as much as anyone - but he does at several points seem to offer special knowledge of the crime. And yes there are problems in some of what he says in that confession, and indeed in his future confessions - but I think those problems are quite easily explainable, and indeed he has explained some of them. The problems in his confession(s) and how they're often blown up also highlights an overriding problem I have with WM3 Supporters. A sort of attitude that if a piece of evidence is not perfect, It is therefor useless. Conversely, if a very flawed piece of evidence points away from the three, all that sort of nit picking immediately stops.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I did see the JBR Netflix thing. It was basically just a PR piece for John Ramsey, but oh well.  Same guy who made the Paradise Lost docos, mind you! I don't actually hold them in high regard, especially 2 and 3. A brief explainer on why I believe the three to be guilty in comments below.

Alan Holding

I definitely agree on the PR puff piece assessment, it reminded me of that weird Casey Anthony documentary from a while back in which she talks to the camera in an overly earnest attempt to appear innocent, making her look mental.

Jan Piet

Maybe you are right about a 99,9% chance of guilt feeling like a 92% to jury members. But in that case they need to include some math lessons with the Jury instructions. Cause personally I don't feel like it is even that hard to reach 99% if the state really has a better case than the defence. Let's take the example you used. the DNA matches 5% of the population. Let's say its 50% based on the the whereabouts of his car (it was there for the time the murder took place and isn't there all that often otherwise) and another 75% for the throwing out garbage in the middle of the night (don't really know how to put a number on this one but probably about reasonable). If all these circumstances happen at the same time, and for the sake of argument now assuming that these 3 are the only factors of the case, the chance he didn't do it would be 1/2x1/4x1/20=1/160. In other words you are very much past the 99% in my opinion. And yeah 1 in a 1000 was maybe a bit too much but if I was on a jury i would never convict unless I was clearly past that 99%

Jan Piet

Asking the money back is completely reasonable of course, but you could at least give him a break on the interest, no?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think from that we're probably more or less on the same page, just not thinking of certain terms in the same way. When I say 92(ish) percent, I'm not actually thinking of applying a model of statistical probability to a given case. I'm just thinking of a certain scale of convincingness where past that point I'd feel unreasonable if I didn't vote "guilty." I don't believe jury instructions on this ever speak in percentage terms in the US, probably because it could give jurors the wrong idea - whatever number you chose. The Boone case has this one which I think is pretty common, and pretty good: "Whenever the words "reasonable doubt" are used, you must consider the following: Proof beyond a reasonable doubt does not mean proof beyond all doubt. A reasonable doubt is not a mere possible doubt, a speculative, imaginary, or forced doubt. Such a doubt must not influence you to return a verdict of not guilty if you have an abiding conviction of guilt. On the other hand, if, after carefully considering, comparing, and weighing all the evidence, there is not an abiding conviction of guilt, or, if, having a conviction, it is one which is not stable but one which wavers and vacillates, then the charge is not proved beyond every reasonable doubt, and you must find the defendant not guilty because the doubt is reasonable. It is to the evidence introduced in this trial, and to it alone, that you are to look for that proof. A reasonable doubt as to the guilt of the defendant may arise from the evidence, conflict in the evidence, or the lack of evidence. If you have a reasonable doubt, you should find the defendant not guilty. If you have no reasonable doubt, you should find the defendant guilty."

Janissa Rose

My family is more like yours, we help each other and let it go as much as we are financially able. I will say I am happy not to be paying a family member rent anymore, because towards the end I found out that, although they were charging less than market rent, they were charging more than the mortgage note, but never setting aside for repairs, leading us to living in a house with a leaking roof (BADLY leaking) and termites, and lead paint lol. So idk I still feel like it was kind of shitty. I got a "good deal" but if we weren't related all of that would have been grounds for legal action... Edit: also, I expected the Sarah Boone case would be delayed lol. There's a lot of body cam and court footage AND letters...

TinTicket

It is interesting how you critique your voice over. As someone who likes long videos on so I can settle down and do crochet, or gaming, or looking at things I can't afford online, the voice is one of the most important things on a video. Your delivery, use of your tone, etc is (to me) excellent. Though maybe unfairly, it takes me about 10 seconds to decide whether to nope out on a voice or not.

TinTicket

On the debt and divorce stuff. Assuming all of us have enough money to outright buy the house without it impacting daily outgoings: I wouldn't expect anything from family - I'm an adult, I made my bed now I can lie in it, and I wouldn't expect them to ask for my help. If I had kids, it would depend on how often this happens. First time do it, second time you are paying me back (at least something), third time nope. Though for me with my parents it would still be grating to know they could have helped and made the problems go away but didn't. So while I wouldn't expect the help I would be hurt if it wasn't offered. What's interesting to me about the mortgage on the house, it is supposedly a house the family has had for years, and has sentimental value to the entire family. Which would suggest Dennis has been taking out new loans on it and is bad with money, so dad is going to be pissed. So I see this situation as you have made bad choices, I am punishing you, there are consequences for your actions. From what Dennis and others have said about Richard's character he would probably have made it clear that this was a punishment (if it was). Would be interesting to know what the history of bailing out Dennis, Richard had. Of course, what you're worth and what you have to hand is different, if all Richard's money is in the business and his quality of life is going suffer by helping Dennis then asking for it being paid back is fair.

TinTicket

OMG dude, yes, I'm more "what is this shirt" than hate it but it is a thing.

TinTicket

Suruthi on the Redhanded podcast says this well: alone each piece of evidence might be weak but when you look at the totally then you get a brick wall. I think that applies to Dennis really well, put everything together his family context, the cctv and going in and out, the phone, no proof of life after Dennis left, no else is there, the lies, alone they don't give enough to say Dennis did it, but together...

Justin Fornof

You think the child with an IQ of 72 who was interrogated for 12 hours and then was only capable of producing a story concocted from news reports and leading questions to be credible?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Interesting question! I actually live in Sydney Australia as of a couple years ago. But yes, I do have to do my own taxes. Though I use an accountant because I'm terrible with that stuff.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

On the 12 hours thing - this is a great example of falsehoods that have become ingrained in the case. My video never makes the claim, because it is verifiably, factually and flatly false. It appears in the first PL movie, but it's an abject lie. Jessie arrived at the station at 10 AM. He confessed at 2:20 PM, and the recording began about 20 mins later. You can see the official time-logs here: http://callahan.mysite.com/wm3/img/jmtimelog.html Jessie is a slow guy, there's no two ways about that. But an IQ of 72 is likely a pretty heavy low-ball that Dan Stidham's to thank for. Just watch his interviews in the PL movies. Slow, sure, but not the intelligence of a small child. He knows what's going on around him, and what he's saying. There are problems in that interview such as leading questions, I freely admit. But the leading questions and prior news reports don't account for everything he said. He got genuine hits. And that's before you get into his relentless efforts to come clean that followed. He gave another confession in private with Stidham just a couple months later. No police presence at all.

Critical Wranker

Just to put my two cents in, I would say Richard Oland's treatment of his son regarding his financial situation really does depend. Problem is, being a parent isn't just about giving them the best chance you can, it's also about preparing your children for the big bad world. As an example, I have three children, the oldest of which is 18. He works, and while we are in a very comfortable financial position (no where near Richards wealth), we still charge him rent. This is done so he can learn to balance his account , and not just waste his money. My wife and I aren't actually spending this money, we are putting it in a savings account for him when he moves out to give him a start on a mortgage or rent. Although I will say, if I was worth £20m, and one of my kids got themselves in that situation, I would just fix it for them. I suppose the question is, how many times had Richard bailed Dennis out? Sometimes, the best way to help your kids, is not to always come to their rescue.

PityTheHateful

Found the section on Canadian versus American right to an attorney interesting. Left me with a question though. The American Supreme Court ruled that it has to be a definite invoking of the right. Things like, I probably should get a lawyer, any equivocating terms aren't enough to stop questions. You need a concrete, I want a lawyer etc for it to count. What's this like elsewhere?

Gigi

You’re reasoning on not putting ads in the middle of a video is spot on. I stopped watching a creator because the entire vibe of their narration was ruined by the ad interruption. It was like watching a movie and having the star of the film stop and look at the camera and try to sell you something.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah exactly. It would be fine if it was a different sort of format...but it's not, so it's not. I need to work on a secondary medium so I can start making some of that sweet, sweet sponsor money lol.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I'm pretty sure it's similar to Canada in most "western" countries. You don't have to speak to police without a lawyer (or with one for that matter), and the prosecution can't hold that against you in court...but the police can keep speaking to you as much as they like...within reason, I mean there will be laws around sleep deprivation and so on. So it's quite similar, but the big difference is the interrogation doesn't have to actually end. You have rights over your mouth, but nothing else.

Gigi

If you could do those hilarious voiceovers in ads like you do for your Patreon. The Fargo intro is my favorite.🤩

Amy Culham

I don’t think it matters so much whether we think it’s reasonable that Dennis Oland would feel resentful towards his father for holding that debt over him. Considering the relationship it seems they had, it seems likely that it would have provoked Oland’s anger as another way his father held power over him.

Obsolete Man

It is reasonable that the elder Oland wouldn't just bail out his son. He didn't amass his wealth by being generous. And his son was probably a POS. I can say this because he very likely killed his father, and that's, generally, a POS thing to do. Also, love the shout out to Casa Bonita! It was my childhood Disneyland. Went last summer with my nephews and Matt and Trey really did an amazing job. Go if you can!

Virginia

Also definitely beat his wife! Probably a POS.

Nathan Little

Regarding the gift vs loan issue, the most likely reason Richard provided his support via a loan instead of a gift is likely some combination of legal and tax considerations oppose to Richard debating if he should help his kid (granted Richard's main motive for the loan was likely keeping the family farm in the Oland name oppose to throwing his son a lifeline out of parental concern). While I am not well versed in New Brunswick/Canadian debt and tax law wrt to gifts to adult children, some readily apparent considerations on this point is that by supporting Dennis through a loan Richard had control over the use of the funds via the underlying credit/loan agreement that would have been entered into (i.e., the money would be spent for the farm and not Dennis' other debt, and if used for other purposes would be a breach), Richard could "perfect" his loan in relation to the farm which would have notable implications in the event of Dennis undergoing a bankruptcy or consumer proposal since Richard could have higher priority to those funds when compared to other creditors especially those that had unsecured interests (such an insolvency event not being an unreasonable concern given Dennis' other debts), etc. If Richard wanted to just gift the money to Dennis later, he could have forgiven the loan at any time (which is likely is what he intended to do at some point - if not until he died via his will). The "interest-only" part of the loan was almost certainly in place to make sure courts (or tax collectors) didn't later characterize the loan to be gift and effectively void the planning the Richard (or his business lawyers/accountants) put in place. That context doesn't really go to proving whether or not Dennis is more or less guilty. Even if Dennis understood the rationale of why the money was being giving to him via a loan, dealing with that loan in addition to other his debts would have been extremely burdensome and if he was under the impression that it would be forgiven via Richard's will - the thought of killing Richard could be tempting (especially when presented with circumstances similar to the night of Richard's murder). It also suggests that Richard only was supporting Dennis b/c of the farm rather than out of parental affection for his child, so additional funding was unlikely to be provided and speaks to the affection Richard had for Dennis. It also provides additional ways Richard could have berated his son (e.g., on the night of question Dennis asks for loan to be forgiven, at which point Richard berates him and insults for not understanding why the gift was made as a loan and how he should be grateful he is doing that).

SpergGurtDirt

Two things: Firstly, I’m very interested to hear your expanded thoughts on the west Memphis three whenever you get around to that commentary (or addendum like you did with jonbenet), because you keep saying you’re pretty sure they did it - really speaks to your persuasive abilities, because my girlfriend (who only ever heard about the west Memphis three from your video) came away from it thinking the three were innocent! Secondly, in regards to Oland (and others), whenever someone changes their story without a very good reason (I.e. something better than “oh I guess I forgot about that”), that drags me over the “reasonable doubt” line pretty much every time.

Kite 9d3

Re the monday morning podcast- you should definitely revisit it! I was never a regular listener but I heard some episodes and clips circa 2013 and I enjoyed it. Earlier this year I binged a bunch of newer episodes, and I love it. It’s still mostly just Bill talking, but you’re right that his kids have changed it, just indirectly. He’s MUCH less angry and judgmental, and more wise. And that’s not a knock on the old him, it’s just a fact that he often was quite angry and judgmental in the past. Now he is vastly less of that, but still just as hilarious and insightful. Highly recommend it. Also, Stephen King is phenomenal. Which novellas did you read? I think you mentioned the title of the collection but I missed it. My favorite full books of his are The Green Mile and Firestarter. Both very superior to the film versions. Especially Firestarter, that movie was an absolute travesty.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Full Dark, No Stars - and I especially am a big fan of Fair Extension, which is a shorter nasty one. Have since also read Different Seasons, Pet Sematary, The Institute, The Stand, You Like It Darker and Skeleton Crew so I’ve been on a bit of a kick! I’ll get to Fire Starter and Green Mile eventually. I just wish I wasn’t so familiar with the movie of the latter

Anastasia

Oh wow, I've been really looking forward to the WMT commentary, and now I am even more eager to hear it! It is probably going to be the first one I'll have to disagree with you on. But regardless, thanks for all the work you do!

Joe Best-Rotheray

Bro I would love an addendum and/or commentary on wm3. Personally the only thing that gave me pause was in Jesses confession he talked about the broken whisky bottle - but then maybe he did chuck the whisky bottle there but not related to the murder just be happened to walk through there

Queen of Hearts

I’ve given thought to the idea that Jesse made up his confessions as a way to throw the other two guys under the bus and get a reduction of his sentence. Matt has said that he’s gonna do a series of shorter WM3 Addendums interspersed between bigger videos