Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 454266892.mp4

Downloads

Content

The “Addendum” is significantly longer than the actual video, but oh well. People have asked me for my personal opinions on this case, and I think after listening to this you’ll get why I didn’t think I could just rattle them off in real time during the upcoming Creator Commentary on the vid. This Addendum contains those opinions and just about everything I’d want to outline in defending them.

It could be a good idea for some to rewatch my JonBenet vid before taking this in if you’re scratchy on the 101s, as this mainly assumes prior knowledge. I’ll be really interested to see what you all make of it. Obviously there are some very strong opinions in all sorts of directions about this case. Maybe I won’t convince you on what I see as the most likely explanation, and that’s OK, but I hope there’s at least certain angles discussed in here that get you thinking a bit.

Feel free to ask any questions and I’ll do my best to clarify where I can, though there will always be areas where I just have to concede I don’t know for sure what the answers are. 

UPDATE:

I don’t even know the topic for the next main release as I’ve been focusing only on putting this together! However, I will get the Commentary JBR vid up (or are you sick of the topic now!?) in a few weeks and provide a proper update then :)

NOTES:

Calling Cyril Wecht’s theory “barmy” might have been too harsh, but it is a bit out of left field to say the least…He thinks John accidentally strangled her during a sex game. I think a lot of his observations are interesting, but he lost the plot a bit when putting it all together. Here’s a vid of him discussing his views in more depth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ererA-5uiEQ

LINKS:

DocGs Blog: https://solvingjonbenet.blogspot.com/

Ruled In, DocGs book: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00HNWYIEM

More on the MS Word theory: https://solvingjonbenet.blogspot.com/2012/08/ruled-out-part-3-courier-new.html

RDI Reddit thread on DNA: https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetRamsey/comments/l0ev4y/dna_evidence_in_the_ramsey_case_faqs_and_common/

IDI Reddit thread on DNA: https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenet/comments/18sb5tw/the_facts_about_dna_in_the_jonbenet_case/

Files

Comments

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I’m not ready to take it back or anything, but I would say my outside ground disturbance talking point is among my shakier ones.

Ben Harrington

Great stuff as per usual! Probably been asked before, but are there any plans to take on more non-murderous/societal topics like Weiner again? Absolutely love those videos

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I can’t 100 percent promise, but the tentative idea is to make the next subject an outside the box one in some way. I’m getting fatigued with crime myself atm!

Skippy From That Podcast

Any chance of this being released on any video platform that isn't the godawful Patreon player that won't even play from a background tab when viewed on a phone? Or even just as an mp3?

PityTheHateful

20:36 - I had the same dolly thought. I also don't understand why they wouldn't mark the exact spot on the mock up skull that needed to be struck. That seems incredibly important to replicate the fractures. Also, they asked him to hit as hard as he could. Which is an assumption. Not only one, that as you discussed, is difficult to achieve on a moving target, but there's no way to know what force would have been applied. I also can't remember, is the skull at the right height distance to the mock Burke? Because the point in the swing that contact is made matters. Basically, I have issues with this as a valid experiment on top of the many you included. The lack of a full reveal is catapulted to the top though.

Dzmien Nzimad

This won't play for me in the Android patreon app :-( Edit: nevermind, I had to restart my device in order to get it to play.

Positivelypolarized69

I really appreciate that you included the skull fracture image as gross as it looks, because it's a pretty strong bludgeoning that's implied there because to any layperson blunt force trauma is blunt force trauma and just hearing that someone has that blunt force trauma makes it easy to say 'hey accidentally pushing the kid onto a bathtub ledge and willfully bludgeoning her would be indistinguishable in appearance'.

Ross Bonander

Lacking sexual dimorphism, kids look androgynous and plenty of unattractive children get assaulted too. To think the man had no pedophile in him until a pretty one arrived seems way off the mark. This man goes from zero to sadistic sociopathic evil genius molester overnight in that argument, and makes no sense, incompatible with all we know about that type no? This addendum really was great, thanks!

nebulazer

I think Det. Arndt’s “loopy” vibe is to do with the blue-eyed stare effect more than anything. If you listen without looking at her, she seems pretty normal imo. Great video! I just finally signed up for the Patreon last night because I was starving for more MOCAS content, and I woke up to a 2hr drop to chew on. I’d never seen the autopsy photo of that skull fracture, and I was in immediate agreement that it didn’t pass as accidental in any way, let alone inflicted by a child. This is more vibes-based, but my siblings and I whacked each other a lot growing up, and I can’t imagine any of us picking up one of those maglite flashlights, of which we had a couple - it’s just too heavy, and you know intuitively, especially by the age of 10, that it’s going to do far too much damage. BDI is just silly to me. Thank you for treating this case in particular with such sensitivity. This poor little girl deserved so much better, and it’s horrible how often her murder seems to eclipse her humanity in most coverage. I hope that Patsy and JonBenét are somehow, some way, reunited and at peace.

Jennifer Ann

This is a great video! As someone who's also done a deep deep dive into this case and also leans JDI I think you covered everything very well and I've also studied DocG's posts and agree with a lot of their evidence. There is one other (very dark) element to the case I want to bring up because I think it's something of a missing puzzle piece that explains what happened even better and also explains a lot of the evidence that leads people to believe in BDI that you didn't go into. I used to lean BDI so I’m very aware of all the arguments/evidence BDI supporters use to support their theory. Burke allegedly had behavioral issues that are the subject of a lot of discourse that leads many to suspect him. He was also very deliberately kept away from law enforcement by his parents in the early stages of the investigation and a somewhat implausible story was presented that he basically slept through *everything*, didn’t hear anything, and wasn’t woken up or questioned by his parents after they found the note. Both JonBenet and Burke had issues with toilet training that were more typical in much younger children. These issues are also extremely common among children who are being sexually abused. From a purely behavioral perspective there is as much or more evidence for Burke having been abused as JonBenet. I also would agree with the premise that if the general JDI narrative you've presented was true, it would be somewhat expected that John might have a history of similar behavior with other children in the family. I think such a history does exist, and the victim wasn’t his older daughters but Burke. If you look at true crime stories involving incest, it's unfortunately very common for pedophiles to abuse both male and female children in the same age range. It's also disturbingly common for such pedophiles to groom one of their victims into participating in their abuse of another victim. 
 
I’m not sure the murder was premeditated (beyond maybe a few hours or so before it happened) but I do agree the upcoming Christmas trip was the impetus. I think John believed JonBenet might let something slip to someone in the extended family that he wouldn’t be able to explain away. Patsy’s illness and the medications she was on may have impaired her ability to see what was happening to her children, but John may have had reason to believe others in the family would be more perceptive. Burke had likely been groomed over a period of years to such an extent that John wasn’t worried he would talk, but JonBenet was by many accounts a more talkative and social child than her brother. 
 
Even if John wasn’t worried about Burke talking unprovoked, Burke’s involvement would create an added concern that if JonBenet did talk, Burke might back up what she was saying if directly confronted about it. It would be hard to get a conviction based purely on the word of a six-year-old, but far easier if an older child backed up what she was saying and made similar allegations of his own. This is also why Burke was taken out of the house so quickly on the morning of the murder: I suspect that was John’s idea that he manipulated Patsy into going along with by convincing her that they were sparing Burke additional trauma. It’s also why it took so long to get Burke into an interview with police, and why his demeanor was so unusual in the taped interview that is so often used by BDI proponents to suggest his involvement. I think Burke *did* know more than he was saying and had been coached by his father ahead of time. 

 I don’t think he had direct knowledge of the murder, but he knew that both himself and JonBenet had been abused and that this was a big secret he was not allowed to tell. I also suspect he eventually did come to suspect his father’s involvement in the murder as an adult but has chosen to keep silent because his father has largely been financially supporting him. 

 I just also want to mention that it’s been alleged there was forensic evidence JonBenet had been sexually abused prior to her murder and I think even if the killer wasn’t John, the killer and the molester were the same person and the paintbrush evidence (which I agree you were 100% right not to go into in too much detail) was designed as staging to explain away possible injuries related to the prior abuse. I think this is entirely compatible with John being the killer/abuser even if he was not intending for her body to be found in the house because he may have intended for it to be found elsewhere or at least knew that was a possibility. And if the purpose of the murder was to cover up the abuse the last thing he would want is the autopsy exposing said abuse and causing the police to start investigating who was responsible for it. Much better for it to look like the work of the deranged intruder/kidnapper/murderer which I believe is still the angle the Ramseys cling to. I also just want to bring up one more point l that I thought you were going to make when you mentioned at the beginning that one of the only things we could be sure of was that JonBenet was found murdered in the house on the day after Christmas. While the body being found in the house is a major thing pointing to RDI rather than someone outside the family, imho the significance of that particular date is also something that points away from IDI. That part of Colorado is largely Christian and almost everyone there celebrates Christmas. A lot of neighborhood sickos who looked like possible suspects were easily ruled out because they had a solid alibi for Christmas night. Christmas night in general would be a very unusual time for someone to decide to commit a crime like that, and if we're to assume the purpose of the break-in was always to kidnap or kill JonBenet the hypothetical intruder would have to either know the Ramseys enough to know they would be in town that particular night or have been stalking them for some time. This is ultimately a minor issue that doesn't really prove/disprove anything but coupled with all of the other things you mentioned that make is unlikely for an intruder to have been in the house that night, we also have to consider that it was someone who didn't have other plans Christmas night and knew exactly where the Ramseys would be. I'm sorry, this comment has gone on for way too long, but I just couldn't help myself having spent a lot of time going down this rabbit hole myself during the last few years. I also agree with everything you've said about how uncomfortable it can be exploring these theories both because of the sensitivity of the issues and the fact that you are accusing someone who might be the innocent father of a murdered child or some very disgusting and serious crimes. Great work, again! I absolutely adore all your videos!

Evan Monroe

Excellent video Matt, I'd really been looking forward to this one. I will say, your slight addendum about David Bain essentially changed my mind and made me see the case differently. Not sure you've done the same here, but you did lay out and focus primarily on the facts. I haven’t read into the case all too much myself, and I will definitely check out some of the books you recommended. But in the reading I did do, there was one detail that stood out to me. Someone who gave an opinion was John Douglas, the FBI agent who wrote “Mindhunter”. In that book he explains his process of observing details in cases and profiling criminals. Regardless of if you think it's pseudoscience, he did make some pretty compelling profiles which matched specific details he laid out with suspects later caught. He was firmly in the IDI camp and supported Lou Smit’s arguments largely. But more importantly, he personally met and talked to John Ramsey and dismissed him as a suspect. It’s interesting to me that a man who profiled hundreds of criminals and worked with the FBI for decades spoke with John the night after his daughter was killed, yet Douglas didn’t square him as a killer. It goes to the whole utter monster aspect of the facts of the case you mention. With an intruder the picture in your mind has to be someone who’s a complete perverted lunatic. Obviously some really sick people can put on a face. But just looking at him you don’t get that same guttural Scott Peterson vibe. I am definitely of the camp that it wasn’t an accident staged to look like a murder/kidnapping. But I just can’t accept an intruder for two key reasons: They would have been playing with fire and burning time being in the house to stage the kidnapping. And as you said in the video, people who are that sick are usually repeat offenders. DNA is how they caught the Green River killer who proved elusive for years. The idea that whoever did that to JonBenét either never left DNA somewhere else and or didn’t kill again just seems too implausible to me. What’s so tricky about this case is that every suspect you have to square with the facts. There are a lot of facts that we unfortunately don’t have. But almost none of the puzzle pieces square with any one person or even combination of persons. However, considering how disorganized and downright mystery novel some of the details are, a plan gone awry definitely seems like the most plausible macro explanation of the crime scene rather than an accident or intruder.

MG

Such a good video! I really enjoyed it up until the end. When you ended with that image of JonBenet that everyone looked at so disdainfully, oh man - that was me! Big reality check, thank you!

Evan Monroe

Seriously, the fact that John Douglas talked to John personally really has me skeptical of his guilt. Say what you will about Douglas' criminal profiling, there's some pretty compelling profiles he made on people who were later caught. But that guy worked in law enforcement for decades. Rule number one is the detective never rules out the guy who hired them as a suspect. Considering Douglas didn't support him as a suspect based on evidence, I think it counts for something.

Michal Tomashov

thank you so much for this. your thoughts and analysis are always very illuminating.

Vincent

All the contingencies and hair-splitting flies in the face of Occam’s razor. Looking at similar cases (i.e., child victim slain in their own home while the rest of the family remains undisturbed), common sense leads us to accepting the claim that one of the parents did it.

KatieASMR

ur brilliant, i wish you lived in america - sincerely, a harmless 36 y/o shameless SIMP

Merglo Mclaughlin

Even though the footprint point is not the strongest, the "there were no footprints at all " point pushed by the netflix doc is also not strong. Your inclusion of that discussion for me works more to show how docs like the netflix doc can be disingenuous, making weak evidence look monumentally important. Besides that I loved this addendum!! I like the more casual tone, and appreciate hearing your personal opinion on this case. I've personally avoided thinking too hard about this case because i think we'll never truly know. But i agree with much of what you say in this vid.

gillygull

If he did do it, I wonder if it wasn’t her “attractiveness” but how child beauty pageants (in my humble opinion) normalize the sexualization of children. Maybe John was fighting those urges until JonBenet got involved in that world and his mindset started to change and he started to rationalize abuse. I do hate child beauty pageants though and could just feel that way because of my bias.

Ann Silberman

Matt, very well done. I’ve been in the IDI camp. I won’t rehash all the reasons why but I understand that psychopaths will stay in a house for many hours without fear of capture, there really isn’t proof about entry/exit, this has happened in their area before, etc. However, your clean, well-reasoned and ultimately horrifying idea about John has given me pause. I had also been swayed by John’s clean a record as far as being a pedo, however, it didn’t occur to me that this type might just be sexually attracted to one child. I still find it hard to imagine he’d kill her because he thought she might tell-lots of these men believe nobody will believe a child over them, plus they often think the feelings they have are mutual. (Stephan Sterns, for example: the theory is he only killed Maddie when he thought she was moving on.) Anyway, I will purchase the book from Amazon and I hope you get a percentage. :).

Jaws

I really appreciate the amount of effort you go into trying to give respect to both sides of the argument. That being said, I’m an unwavering IDI that can’t put my bias aside for even a second lol

Michael Russon

Great video. From the original I’d kind of suspect that you leaned RDI of some variety. I didn’t know a lot about the case before the original video but reading about it since I came to a lot of the same conclusions as you. I hadn’t really considered the exit point as so much of an issue as you’ve pointed out, possibly just an oversight as my front door opens with a latch and locks behind you when you close it so I may have just assumed it was something like that. I think for IDI the attack would need to be targeted, quite possibly by someone who knew the Ramsey’s plans for Christmas Day which I think goes a bit further in straining credulity for various reasons. Overall I’d agree that JDI or IDI are the most likely but when comparing two events that both seem incredibly unlikely for different reasons I’m struggling to really weigh the likelihood of one against the other. I’ll definitely pick up the JDI book and have a read through.

Christian

great presentation, throughly enjoyed. three exculpatory points in John’s favour: he first tells the police the house was locked and only later tries to create uncertainty here (you covered this one already obv); he gives the police the notepad on which the ransom note was composed voluntarily, in response to a general request for handwriting samples of himself and his wife; after the body is discovered he insists to arndt that the killing must have been an “inside job.” None of these totally destroy DocG’a very elegant thesis, but there is kind of a pattern, according to which John seems to act without much knowledge of the crime in the earliest hours, while later on more overtly striving to make space for an intruder and also adjusting his story in one or two other minor but to my mind significant ways.

Dan

Wow. I’m blind, don’t know how you get to “that’s a fuckable 6 year old.” But I also don’t know how you get to “That’s a fuckable adult.” Visually. All the same I both was not prepared for that, and never properly grocked her appearance as a factor. So …thanks for just saying what you meant I guess.

Jane Brinkley

You raised everything I was going to. Especially John’s late in life child molesting. Also John knew they were getting up early for their flight - would he really keep his daughter up even later after the party (on Christmas Day, no less) in order to molest her when the family has to be up around 5am for a big travel day? And then, needing to stage the scene and get back into bed all before Patty’s early AM alarm goes off, he decides a good use of his limited time is to write the world’s longest ransom note? He’s a business executive, brevity is going to be a skill he has.

Jonathan Gill

These Addendums are amazing; they clearly take a lot of work to put together. I might comment in a few days, when I have time to respond, but I want to leave a question regarding the sequence of JonBenet's injuries. As I understand from James Kolar's book, the police's head trauma expert, Lucy Rorke, looked at the swelling the brain to estimate the length of time between the headblow and JonBenet's death. Rorke places that timeframe as 45 minutes to 2 hours. From what I've read, the strangulation is the actual cause of death. Now, point taken about lab coat expertise, and the details in this case can be tricky to wade through. But under the assumption that the headblow happens before strangulation, does that open up for you the possibility of another Ramsey doing it (specifically Patsy)?

CaptainJZH

it might be possible to combine the IDI/JDI theories into one if the "intruder" was someone John knew or was otherwise in kahoots with? Which would explain away the indirect evidence supporting IDI while also making sense of the very bizarre "coverup-esque" behavior by John afterwards

Jonathan Gill

The Ramseys hired John Douglas. He was paid by them, so he can't be said to have a neutral, disinterested opinion. But even if the money had no influence on him whatsoever, the fact that he has "star power" shouldn't sway you on the quality of the theory. Some IDI supporters talk about the star power of Lou Smit as well, but his theory has a number of issues.

JB

Wow… I couldn’t have requested a better topic

Iron

Personally, I think John would have known his wife well enough to anticipate she'd instantly go to the police, but thats just me.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I'm already of the belief the head blow came first. I just have a firm belief it was struck with full lethal intent, very likely by a grown man. I was just saying IF the lab coats that contend the strangulation came first are right, that would help IDI just because it's so hard to imagine Patsy, or Burke, or even John for that matter, STARTING by strangling her with a garrote. Now if Patsy or Burke were to "wind up" and really deliver the strongest SMASH they were physically capable of to a static JonBenet's head, could they create the massive skull fracture under those conditions? Without any expertise, just going off what I've read/seen from various places and applying my own intuition, I'm sort of skeptical but maaaaaaybe. I'd certainly believe the outcome far more likely than if the head blow came about by some kind of accident (near impossible in my layman opinion). It's just that if you go with full lethal intent swing, much like with going with "strangulation first" you've got to come up with a scenario in which Patsy or Burke would do such a thing. Patsy I'm just at a loss. People sometimes like to point out Burke hit her with a golf club once, but her injuries from that incident were obviously minor, and I'm basically happy to take the families word it wasn't even intentional. I've just never really seen much reason to believe Burke would want to deliberately murder his sister other than he acted a little strange when talking about the pineapple and smiled at weird moments in his Dr Phil interview. Barring an Intruder, I think the most believable scenario is head blow first, with full lethal intent, from John because he wanted it to be a painless, one and done type deal. Strangulation was an improvised measure after JB failed to die instantly. The last part doesn't quite make perfect sense to me, but I can live with it.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I can’t find a solid answer on whether all the doors were/weren’t openable from the inside without a key - which is actually quite surprising. According to Grok: “While specific details about every door’s locking mechanism are not fully documented, it is highly likely that most exterior doors in the Ramsey house (e.g., the butler’s door, side doors, or front door) could be opened from the inside without a key, as this is standard for residential doors to allow easy egress for safety.” -- So even almighty AI has to default back to likelihood and presumptions. Seeing as it seems not 100% confirmed (weird after all this time and interest) let’s go with the assumption ALL doors required a key from both the inside and out. I still find the intruder not using a door to escape quite problematic if we’re going with my IDI proposition that he was in the house alone for hours while the Ramsey’s were out. Making presumptions based off how most people are again, but it’s very common for a set of keys, or multiple sets of keys, to be readily accessible and in plain sight within the house. I would have thought locating such a thing so you know where to get them later would be a top priority for the intruder. Maybe not on both counts though, in which case now we’re passed the “why not just use a door?” secondary problem and can get back to the primary problem of “no visible sign of exit”, which I have yet to see a convincing solution for. And that’s sort of a theme of IDI for me. It seems like to make it work you have to constantly navigate various problems of varying levels of severity, making one allowance after another just for the privilege of making it to yet another set of problems! Like, “great we’ve established it is at least possible (even if unlikely) none of the doors were openable from the inside without a key, so now we know why it could have been necessary for the intruder to go to an exit point that there is no sign of them passing through!”

JB

I really like the argument but my main point of contention is John’s motive. Idk, maybe I come from a really, REALLY bad place, culture, background, etc. But I think it’s very common and relatively easy for… an “arrangement” like _that_ to occur… for many years. Whether because JonBenet wouldn’t have said anything, or because no one would believe her, or because it would be swept under the rug as a “family secret,” I just doubt the looming fear of being found out led him to MURDER his own daughter, over other means of self-preservation. I also don’t think her “attractiveness” would play that much of a role. She was certainly more sexualized than the average girl her age due to the pageantry stuff—but I don’t think that level of perversion exists in a vacuum like that. From what I’ve read and researched, there’s always some sort of pattern—whether that would have been seen with his other daughters or on a hard drive somewhere. It’s incredibly rare and in my opinion, as much a stretch as the intruder being a 5’3” anorexic man, for John to suddenly be attracted to his own daughter and no other underage human ever before in his life. But most of the arguments for him being the culprit are sound and convincing. I credit this case with sealing the deal on me ever pursuing a criminal justice degree and working as a detective (once a potential dream job of mine). It’s just not fun trying to wrap your head around these sorts of things. But one of my favorite sayings is, “Truth is stranger than fiction.” And whatever happened that night is definitely stranger than anything anyone has ever concluded to this day. My answer is that we will never know for sure what happened that night. Edit: As much as I want to lean John, I can’t convince myself of it. Being separately lawyered up definitely makes it seem as if one of the Ramseys were complicit. But if that’s true, that makes them both guilty in some way IMO. So, I still lean RDI more than anything.

JB

I hate to say it but that was a pretty damn bad self sabotaging moment …

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

On John Douglas - I don’t actually hold him in especially high esteem. I love the show Mindhunter, and the whole idea of criminal profiling is a lot of fun, most probably has some validity to it, but…this idea of the master profiler who strolls through a crime scene and begins to ascertain what the perp does for a living and eats for breakfast (exaggerating, but you know the kind of thing I’m talking about) is very Hollywood. Douglas may indeed have an impressive resume, but I would never treat him as infallible, and I think, like Jim Clemente, he talks himself up an awful lot. I’m not in a position to do a full auditing of Douglas’ career, but I can tell you right now he does not have a perfect record and was instrumental in the wrongful conviction of a Canadian named Guy Paul Morin. And we’re not talking about a simple error here. It appears he did a full reverse engineering of his profile, provided direct assistance in trying the man through the media (where have we heard such practices bemoaned?) and dodged all accountability for his actions once the facts of the case revealed his theory had always been flat wrong. You can read more about that episode here: http://netk.net.au/Canada/Morin30.asp I don’t hate every inch of Douglas’ thoughts on this case. I haven’t read his books, but I do recall reading a portion from his chapter on the JBR case in Cases That Haunt Us where he refutes the Burke theory using pretty much the same logic I did in my addendum - you really think these people would respond like THAT to an ACCIDENT? Still though, let’s speak to your point about what John’s willingness to work with a famed FBI profiler says about John’s apparent forthrightness and therefore probable lack of guilt. Hmm…I can’t be a fly on John’s wall and know precisely how their collaboration came about. Why should I take it as a given zero explicit or implicit assurances were made? Just the word of the two Johns? From what I’ve observed John R is fairly selective with who he cooperates with, and I’m slow to believe this was any different. It might not have been as crass as a money under the table arrangement, though it’s openly acknowledged that John Ramsey did in fact pay John Douglas for his work, which I think you have to take on board somewhat! Anyway, it may not have been as straightforward as “I pay you, you clear me”, it may simply be that John didn’t see the famed FBI profiler as any more infallible than I do and (maybe correctly) fancied him a mark. Now maybe I am underrating Douglas’ capabilities, but that still doesn’t mean he can’t get it wrong. I’d say Lou Smit did indeed have a really impressive career, but that doesn’t inhibit me from strongly suspecting he got his last case wrong, and lost objectivity where you wouldn’t have thought he would based on that impressive career. Because it seems his theories - particularly on point of entry and exit just don’t realistically stand up. So my big question is: What is John Douglas’ theory on how the intruder most likely got in and out? His credentials don’t release him from having to answer the same fundamental questions everyone else does. And if his answers aren’t any more convincing than Smit’s, I don’t really care that much about his profiling work on the case. Intruder’s Exit: So you’re proposing they may indeed have found a deadbolted door that auto-locks when shut (or grabbed a key, and turned it to a locking position before closing the door, how did the key get back on the counter?) and headed out that way, walking across a clean, concrete pathway that wouldn’t clearly capture footwear impressions? Hmmm, I haven’t heard that one before, and like I said in the previous reply, I struggled to find concrete information on the nature of the house locks. It’s pushing my intuition hard, because surely, surely, surely, Lou Smit would have floated such a possibility if it were ever on the table, and I certainly can’t remember ever hearing such a theory from him or his colleagues. I guess I’ll have to table it as a maybe for the time being though until I can say categorically if it’s possible or not. Let me see what I can find. John as a late blooming child molester: well like you say, we can’t know if he’d never ever gotten up to some kind of nastiness, through some kind of avenue (i.e. not necessarily his other daughters), before JonBenet came along. If he had, would it be totally fanciful for him to have gotten away with it? I wouldn’t say so, child molesters don’t always get caught. And as for the notion that perhaps he had pedophilic feelings over his years, but had never actually acted out before JonBenet. Again, probably atypical, but the idea doesn’t seem inherently bonkers to me. This isn’t an area a lot of people like to think deeply about, myself included, but child molestation and incest are things that come about and develop in all sorts of ways. You start developing feelings, one night you try something a bit over the line, it doesn’t go all that badly, she still seems happy the next day, things develop, before you know it your past the point of no return. Horrible to think about, but is it batty? Unfortunately I don’t think so.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Now hold on, every detail is important here! I didn’t say John was sadistic. My conception involves him taking no pleasure in what he “had to” do, and genuinely desiring for the murder to be quick and painless - not the attitude of a sadist. Only once this approach did not work did he resort to strangling. My best guess would be he might have thought continual head bashing would create too much of a mess. My conception doesn’t really involve him being a genius, though it does have him developing a very machiavellian, multi-layered criminal plot. Not a genius one by any stretch of the imagination though - it literally comes apart all because of one glaring oversight: That his wife might run to the phone before finishing the note. Now is that part unrealistic? Actually, no, not in my opinion. I think you can find a lot of that sort of stuff in true crime. Plans that are actually quite clever on a lot of levels, but that come undone due to one boneheaded mistake. It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking, “smart people do smart things, dumb people do dumb things” but if we think about it a bit, we all know it’s not that simple at all. And I don’t actually think the plan I’m positing here was all that clever in the main anyway. Seems like there’s so many ways to get caught, and if I (or DocG, really) am right about this, I quite suspect Patsy running to the phone might have been a massive blessing in disguise for John. If he had been able to see through everything he wanted to do, I think he probably would have gotten caught. It was because the police walked in on a halfway realised plan that everything looked so confusing and the roads to John were far less obvious. My conception does involve John being evil, sociopathic, and a molester, but it certainly doesn’t involve him becoming any of those overnight. Now I’m not an expert in sociopathy, but it’s a subject I’m quite interested in (naturally) so I’ve been able to pick up a bit about it over the years. The first thing that’s disquieting to learn about sociopaths is that they’re rare, but not as rare as you might imagine. It seems most estimates put them around 1% of the population. Could even be a few points more, but 1 is pretty safe. If you saw 100 people as you were walking about today, chances are you had a sociopath in your sights at some point. So what are all these sociopaths doing with their days? Murdering small children for fun and throwing them off bridges? No, for the most part, thankfully! For the most part in fact, they’re just going about their day to day, much like your or I, and in most instances not even desiring to engage in heinous acts. Sociopaths aren’t defined by any special draw to criminal behavior, more so just a lack of empathy for their fellow man. They sort of view other people as objects, and they often pick up on all the right social cues and so forth to move through life like the rest of us, but there’s never any real feeling behind such things. Other people are just a means to their ends. There are even “Ask A Verified Sociopath” Quora threads you can check out to get first hand accounts of what this existence is like. Nothing to write home about really, and that’s the scariest part! What I’m getting at is sociopaths are very often not inherently dangerous, or even scary, but they are liable to become very dangerous if they wind up in a situation where hurting others is to their advantage. Scott Peterson never really raised any alarm bells with anyone, because he never had cause to do anything alarming. Then one day his wife became inconvenient for him so he murdered her and his unborn son. He didn’t become a sociopath overnight, he’d just never had a reason to murder someone before is all. Does the fact John didn’t have any massive deviousness in his past make the notion he may have been a sociopath fanciful? Not if you're positing a special reason to murder like I am. Also, he wasn’t exactly Mr. Rogers. He got in a spot of trouble for alleged embezzlement once, and people have often described him as “cold.” Neither of which prove him to be a sociopath, but ya know, he could fit the bill. If you’re saying all children more or less look the same to pedophiles, I just have to disagree, I don’t want to get deep into that sort of debate. In any event, I don’t think it’s ludicrous to conceive of a man with pedophilic thoughts and desires only actively molesting a child later in life. I’ll just copy/paste from another reply on that matter: This isn’t an area a lot of people like to think deeply about, myself included, but child molestation and incest are things that come about and develop in all sorts of ways. You start developing feelings, one night you try something a bit over the line, it doesn’t go all that badly, she still seems happy the next day, things develop, before you know it you’re past the point of no return. Horrible to think about, but is it batty? Unfortunately I don’t think so. Sorry - A very long reply to a short comment, but you gave me a lot to talk about!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Evan! Some of my thought on John Douglas from a previous reply: I don’t actually hold him in especially high esteem. I love the show Mindhunter, and the whole idea of criminal profiling is a lot of fun, most probably has some validity to it, but…this idea of the master profiler who strolls through a crime scene and begins to ascertain what the perp does for a living and eats for breakfast (exaggerating, but you know the kind of thing I’m talking about) is very Hollywood. Douglas may indeed have an impressive resume, but I would never treat him as infallible, and I think, like Jim Clemente, he talks himself up an awful lot. I’m not in a position to do a full auditing of Douglas’ career, but I can tell you right now he does not have a perfect record and was instrumental in the wrongful conviction of a Canadian named Guy Paul Morin. And we’re not talking about a simple error here. It appears he did a full reverse engineering of his profile, provided direct assistance in trying the man through the media (where have we heard such practices bemoaned?) and dodged all accountability for his actions once the facts of the case revealed his theory had always been flat wrong. You can read more about that episode here: http://netk.net.au/Canada/Morin30.asp I don’t hate every inch of Douglas’ thoughts on this case. I haven’t read his books, but I do recall reading a portion from his chapter on the JBR case in Cases That Haunt Us where he refutes the Burke theory using pretty much the same logic I did in my addendum - you really think these people would respond like THAT to an ACCIDENT? Still though, let’s speak to your point about what John’s willingness to work with a famed FBI profiler says about John’s apparent forthrightness and therefore probable lack of guilt. Hmm…I can’t be a fly on John’s wall and know precisely how their collaboration came about. Why should I take it as a given zero explicit or implicit assurances were made? Just the word of the two Johns? From what I’ve observed John R is fairly selective with who he cooperates with, and I’m slow to believe this was any different. It might not have been as crass as a money under the table arrangement, though it’s openly acknowledged that John Ramsey did in fact pay John Douglas for his work, which I think you have to take on board somewhat! Anyway, it may not have been as straightforward as “I pay you, you clear me”, it may simply be that John didn’t see the famed FBI profiler as any more infallible than I do and (maybe correctly) fancied him a mark. Now maybe I am underrating Douglas’ capabilities, but that still doesn’t mean he can’t get it wrong. I’d say Lou Smit did indeed have a really impressive career, but that doesn’t inhibit me from strongly suspecting he got his last case wrong, and lost objectivity where you wouldn’t have thought he would based on that impressive career. Because it seems his theories - particularly on point of entry and exit just don’t realistically stand up. So my big question is: What is John Douglas’ theory on how the intruder most likely got in and out? His credentials don’t release him from having to answer the same fundamental questions everyone else does. And if his answers aren’t any more convincing than Smit’s, I don’t really care that much about his profiling work on the case.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Oh, I wouldn't beat yourself up over that, I find the not-so-subtly-sexualised pageantry fare as distasteful as the next person. What I'm trying to get at with that, is that to JB there was nothing wrong with it, and her mother (and grandmother too if memory serves) just grew up in that sort of culture, so I don't think their was any deviousness in her intentions with any of it either. And for what it's worth, it wasn't ALL Little-Miss-Sexpot looking stuff. There was a big element of "Just an excuse to dance and sing" in it too, and JonBenet sometimes did her little routines at school on talent show type days without raising any eyebrows. With that stuff that is just gross in so many of our eyes though, I was just saying the thing that gets to me is how her murder made her a symbol of that grossness. The very worst aspects of a hobby she innocently enjoyed were really burned into everyone's mind as the thing that really represented her. Robbed of her life, and robbed of her legacy. So unfair.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It's not a bad thought (well, you get what I mean) that seeing her dolled up like that could have triggered something. A pretty glaring point of difference between his other daughters from a previous non-pageant-background marriage.

Janissa Rose

I agree in terms of it being Jon or an intruder. I also think if it was an intruder, it was most likely someone they knew in some way, who had some type of grudge or problem with them. I think it's just the weirdness of what happened to Jonbenet in terms of injuries and assaults, I don't see why the strangulation if she's already got a serious head injury. I don't understand the paintbrush either in terms of leaving it behind. I don't know. If an abduction was planned it just seems like all of this would take place outside the house? Unless being in the house was somehow part of the cruelty, but then I'd think it would be some other part of the house for the scene, and not bothering with a ransom note.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks so much for that Jennifer - some really interesting thoughts and observations here. You're right, it does take us down an even darker path still, but it would help further explain some things - Burke's undeniably strange manner in his police interviews for starters. I also think your paintbrush idea is very intriguing...violent abuse used to obscure signs of previous molestation. It would help square one of the pieces of evidence I've continued to find vexing. Very interesting indeed.

Ross Bonander

You're absolutely right, every detail is important, and the words we use have to be precise--and mine were not written with that kind of precision and care. The reason I characterized your characterization of him as sadistic, sociopathic, evil, and genius was not for the crime he may have committed that night/morning, but for his ability to ride that lie for almost 30 years. To sit in front of whomever from the media and take their questions without sweating. To attend to family daily interactions or family reunions etc without blinking. If I were hiding a secret that enormous, I would have crumbled from the stress long ago, there's no way I last 30 years--- UNLESS I was dead inside from the beginning. And as you hint at above, for John that's not out of the question. Thanks for such a point by point response Matt!

Dan

I don’t know how it’s self sabotaging. It’s certainly gross to think about. Finding attributes of a person sexually appealing, is obviously extremely subjective. I think that’s what makes people so hesitant to discuss those attributes around these sorts of victims. It seems as though they feel acknowledging the existence of those attributes as being a sort of self report, or worse. I imagine the people who would actually be self reporting would be couching their observations as more objective, or at least those they feel our objective. Screaming symmetry a bunch of times or commenting on the golden ratio or something. I find those sorts of statements much more “sus”. I feel Matt’s approach was more direct which I appreciate. Say the thing you’re gonna say rather than trying to dance around the thing you’re going to say because you feel like it’s gross. Just because I don’t know how you can get there visually doesn’t mean you can’t get their visually. I can absolutely imagine her father being that kind of person regardless of what his past was. No history? History has to start sometime. So what if his other kids got past him, if they did. Apply that logic to literally any other crime and it seems silly, right? He can’t have been a school shooter, he’s never shot up a school before, and the last two schools he went to, were super shootable. etc. there’s one thing I can certainly say and that is this is a really interesting case. The weirdest part to me is that the parents have different attorneys, which makes both of them look extremely bad, makes me Ruel an intruder out, not sure if the son got his own attorney or not, but I don’t believe he would have been the killer either way.

Tracy McClendon

I think intruder theory has way more issues to contend with but the locked door issue - couldn't the intruder have copies of the keys? A long term stalker or a family friend with key copies could be an explanation. Someone close to the Ramsays may have a similar motivation to be so brutal with JonBenet.

Positivelypolarized69

TBH, I think the main issue with this case is motivation, and it's hard to imagine anyone, let alone a father or mother, intentionally bludgeoning this little girl to death, even though that's (IMO) the most obvious solution given the circumstances. I was sold on Matt's explanation, and I think it explains the crime scene as a strange paradox of both a mess and incredibly intentional.

JB

Yeah, the issue is—if you actually feel she is attractive for a 6-year-old girl, you’re sus. Was she sexualized and dolled up in ways most 6-year-old girls aren’t? Yes. Could that lead someone who is a PEDOPHILE to be particularly drawn to her? Actually, idk about that. What I know is pedophiles aren’t drawn to children based on how closely they resemble adults. And this wasn’t a 14-year-old who could pass as a grown woman/young adult where that might be a factor. There’s no amount of work that could make a 6-year-old look like an adult, which means any attraction to her would be based on an attraction for children. Now suddenly becoming attracted to your own daughter and not having ever had feelings toward other kids is an extreme stretch. I get what you mean about school shooters, even murderers if we go there—many people only kill once. That’s not what I’m arguing. Just like it’s not impossible the intruder was a 5’3, skinny man (many exist), it’s also not impossible John had a sudden urge to molest his daughter. But it’s a reach no matter how you look at it, because that almost never just happens—at his age, given his wealth, and absolutely no hard drives anywhere with CP? And no signs of curiosity with his other daughters, nothing? It’s just a reach. I thought Matt was going to say at the end that JDI is more believable than IDI simply because there’s a real human to attach the theory to. For every “reach,” we can visualize the possibility because there’s have a real person to point the finger at. For IDI, the small variable that makes it so much harder to believe is the absence of an actual person. It might be RARE for a father to do these things, but we know fathers have done these things.

JB

Ok I’m not sold on how the force had to be delivered by a full grown man either. That just seems so subjective but important for framing John. Yeah, I’m never figuring out this riddle 😂

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks for hearing me out with an open mind, Ann. I can't expect anyone to be sold in an instant, or at all, because it is undoubtedly "out there"...Then again, out there relative to what exactly? But like I said in the description, if I can even get you to consider angles you hadn't before without actually necessarily being sold on the overall theory, that's more than good enough. If anything, Doc should probably get a cut of my Patreon this month, but no need to tell him I said that! If I can get him a few extra sales then that's the least I owe him. Hope he's still alive and kicking somewhere. He's been quiet for several years now. I thought John making quite a few media rounds recently might have brought him out of the woodwork with more observations for me to pinch, but no!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

"Overall I’d agree that JDI or IDI are the most likely but when comparing two events that both seem incredibly unlikely for different reasons I’m struggling to really weigh the likelihood of one against the other." That really is one of the major unrelenting frustrations with this case isn't it? The question on the specific nature of their door locks is one that's come up already on this thread and I've been surprised to find it difficult to pin down a straight answer to. My ASSUMPTION is the doors wouldn't have had an auto-locking mechanism, because SURELY it would be a major IDI talking point if they did. But it's still just an assumption on my part for the time being. I have to believe the answer is out there. I'll keep looking. I actually began my efforts on this case (as in beginning my background reading about 6 months out from starting in earnest) with an IDI bent, and stayed that way for quite a while if memory serves. My very first introduction to the case was watching that British IDI production that Lou Smit essentially hosts back when I was in high school. It did seem everyone had just piled on the parents and ignored decent indicators of an outsider. I slowly got more skeptical of the Ramsey's for a myriad of reasons, but the thing that started to really make me harden was simply continuing to meditate on the lack of any visible entry/exit, and in a similar vein the lack of any indications of the intruder being in the house for the time between. And yet it still remains my second favorite explanation. Such a strange case...

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Christian, These are all very fair points - including the one I did my best to address. I guess the overarching point I’d start out with is - good luck finding any theory that makes every person’s behavior make perfect, intuitive sense under the proposed conditions. Some way, some how, some people were acting weird that day. Just to be thorough, with saying the doors were locked: Again, my best guess is it’s just a consequence of John having to rethink his whole strategy within mere minutes of giving his statement to the officer. Saying he checked all the doors and they were locked could have been his way of conveying he was being a responsible, non suspicious individual, and he was so preoccupied with trying to make sure the police did NOT scrutinize the basement window, he’d neglected to even think about the necessity of creating a new entry point, even one as simple as a door he’d “forgot” to lock. It could have even occurred to him how idiotic it was to say all the doors were locked the second the statement passed his lips, but ya know…too late, and he had to keep moving. I know it can feel like a lame explanation, but it’s really hard to get in the mindset of someone in total panic with no time to think while we sit at a computer considering everything with sober logic. Handing the notepad right over: It’s the same sort of thing. Is it POSSIBLE in that moment, John had momentarily forgotten the pad he just handed over was the very same he’d written the note on? Seems pretty fucking far fetched, I must say, but then again, if anyone were to make such a jaw dropping oversight, it’d probably be the guy who’s had to reset his entire murder scheme and has to try and put out multiple fires at the same time while looking normal. Additionally, it isn’t far fetched in this conception to think John had not anticipated being asked for handwriting samples. Again, internally he’s still trying to process how he’s even talking to police right now. So when Officer Whitson asks, “do you have any samples of you and your wife’s handwriting?”, and John looks over at those notepads…Think of it like “Better Vs Worse” again. What’s better and what’s worse, handing over something you’re going to have to do some serious explaining of later down the line, but at least look transparent, or replying, “Err, no. No you can’t have that.” I suppose an objection might be that he could have stalled and found a less incriminating source of handwriting samples. But could he? Based on Whitson’s report, it *sounds* like those notepads *may* have been in everyone’s line of sight at the time John was asked. He might have wagered he couldn’t inconspicuously ignore them, and he might have been right. Otherwise I feel such non-optimal plays are still explainable enough with simple panic. The “Inside Job” remark to Arndt: It’s an absolutely incredible statement, isn’t it? And personally, I find it hard to figure out what he must have been thinking when he made it, no matter what conception I’m framing it in. I imagine it most comes in handy for people who believe in an RDI conception without John’s involvement. Like Patsy covering for Patsy, or Patsy covering for Burke. We both agree those scenarios just don’t seem to wash. It’s also possible he said it with his mind on trying to get police to focus on outsiders who have a key - like the maid, who The Ramsey’s had mentioned that morning. Then there’s just the “getting ahead of it” mentality. In the JDI conception, no one would have been more aware at that moment just how little sign of an intruder was going to be found than John. That’s on top of how much was already clearly apparent to everyone by that time. I mean you just carried your dead little girl up from your basement for christ’s sake. Though I can’t think of specific examples right now, I think it’s quite common for guilty parties to play half-dumb. Can you recall moments in cases I’ve covered and elsewhere, where a very guilty person has said something along the lines of, “You know, I find it so strange because [identifies key factors that point right in their direction].” As a rule of thumb, we don’t usually take “this looks really bad” type statements to be very exculpatory. “This must have been an inside job.” - Yeah, very observant of you, John. And in light of the discovery you’ve just made, why do you still seem no more interested in that broken basement window you found open but decided to latch shut earlier this morning? Or the Samsonite briefcase so out of place beneath it. Because if you had even the faintest of suspicions of such things, it would seem to me that it shouldn’t be obvious this must have been an inside job at all. The only reason we know such things are basically non-starters is because we’re looking at all the info collected and documented about them all these years later. Standing there in that living room with Detective Arndt a bit past 1 PM on the 26th, John should not have been in a position to say such a thing with such confidence. That he did suggests to me that he was far too ahead of the game.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I mean, this just isn't a subject I want to delve into very deeply - like a lot of people I can only bear to contemplate it so much. I personally think it's likely enough a child beauty queen would be more appealing to someone with pedophilic tendencies than the average child. Another comment raised the possibility that actually seeing JB dolled up like that may have triggered something in John. Maybe, maybe not. I've said as much on this particular matter as I care to!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Like I said toward the start, there is a school of thought out there for this sort of thing. Some involve Patsy being a part of it too. Anything that has one or both of the parents as active participants falls under the RDI umbrella, it's just now there's also a 3rd (maybe 4th, maybe 5th!) party as well. Though they're not "intruders." I mean, I don't buy it. Aside from anything else it's sort of a worst of both worlds proposition, because now you've got to inculpate the Ramsey's AND figure out why there's barely any sign at all of someone else being in that house when they were.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The glaring oversight is actually one thing I really LIKE about the theory. I feel like we're often hearing about otherwise quite clever plans that fell apart because of one really boneheaded mistake. John didn't have any previous active kidnapping experience with Patsy, but he may well have had tons of reference points of her turning to him as a source of strength in difficult situations. The idea that John was so SURE Patsy would run straight to him, that he never even envisioned a scenario where she ran straight to the phone...I can just see it. It rings so true to me.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Well I guess kind of an overarching point here is, how far fetched is the JDI proposition, really? Because obviously it’s far fetched in a vacuum, but we can’t assess it in a vacuum. How far fetched is it relative to other propositions? My conception doesn’t involve John developing sexual feelings toward children for the first time ever only after JB came along. All I really concede on that front is I don’t view it as likely he molested his two other daughters when they were children. Had he acted out in other ways outside his family? I’m certainly open to that possibility. I definitely don’t think it’s all but a given he would have been caught if he had. Most men who molest their children don’t wind up deciding it’s necessary to murder their child to stop it from coming out, that’s true. I don’t think that’s sufficient to mark this concept as being more far fetched than any other. I can pretty much guarantee any other scenario you could care to put forward can have a “Most people who do X don’t act like Y” statement fairly applied to it.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

My main problem with it being someone the Ramsey's knew is just...wouldn't we have caught them by now (within a year, really) if the perp had a clear connection to the family? Say what you like about investigative tunnel vision, but the police did follow up on any decent lead they were given, and the Ramsey's weren't shy about making suggestions when it came to various associates. Nothing ever went anywhere. Steve Thomas' book discusses this sort of thing a fair bit.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I said in the comment below why I don't really see a known associate as viable. Now keys copied by an intruder who may have sneaked in on a previous occasion....That's the sort of thing you'd file under "something massive we're all just missing." It's physically possible and would allow the intruder to get in and out, so it's good that we've got that sorted. But you have to allow so much: First, that it happened, then that the Ramsey's didn't notice a set of keys missing for that time, that the intruder made a point of returning the keys...at least there's a decent rationale for doing so, but still. And in terms of locking the exit door behind them, I guess the idea is to put attention on the family, but that seems like a pretty amazing level of forethought given the circumstances. I'd have to imagine most people in that situation would be solely focused on getting the fuck out of dodge and just take it as a given they'd already left behind some indication of their presence after everything they did. Like I said in the addendum, it seems so often when arguing for Intruder you wind up spending most of your time trying to cook up things that COULD happen, and defending them as POSSIBLE, rather than pointing to things that are actually present, observable and best lend themselves to an intruder as their explanation.

Dan

Not knowing is not the same as knowing it’s false. John has no history? That’s impossible to know. Don’t know what his Wealth has to do with it. No hard drives filled with CP in 1996 is less impressive than you might think even for the most virulent pedophiles.

Brandon Tingle

REALLY enjoyed listening to this. Wouldn't mind more under a similar format. Please keep them coming, Matt!

Liisa Turunen

John wouldn’t have found an unlocked “back door” if the intruder locked it behind him also locking himself in.

Gigi

My mind is blown by the JDI theory. It makes me rethink everything I have believed about this case. It’s as if we all settled on our theories and missed the obvious. I never thought Patsy or Burke were involved. I mentally cleared them with the things I’d learned about the case. The DNA had me stuck on the intruder theory. I just realized while watching this that I didn’t rule Jon out because I never really considered him a suspect. It’s a total facepalm moment for me.

Jonathan Gill

Thanks for all the work you've put into this. You're probably sick of thinking about the case, but I wanted to pose one more question to you: what about the fiber evidence? So, James Kolar reports (and Steve Thomas covers it in less detail, I believe) that fibers consistent with the red Christmas jacket Patsy was photographed wearing the night of the crime (!) were found on the adhesive side of the duct tape placed over JonBenet's lips. These fibers were also found on the paint tray, the "wrist ligature", and wine cellar floor. In other words, they were in multiple locations. Not just on JonBenet's body (which could be explained--maybe--by transfer after Patsy held her once John brought her up from the basement). But on the duct tape that was left in the room where the body was found, plus the paint tray that seems to have contained objects used in the death/staging. Just how much of this can be explained by innocent transfers? Because, setting aside theoretical exculpatory explanations, surely you'd agree that these fibers, linked to the clothing a suspect was known to wear the night of the crime, appearing in multiple damning locations of the crime scene looks really, really bad. In fact, this evidence is the one thing I wish your video went into more; at least to me it looks very important, and hard to wave away for any theory not placing Patsy at the scene of the crime. I almost wonder if we're overcomplicating things. The fibers point to Patsy. And there's at least some weight to the belief that Patsy wrote the ransom note (though you've argued quite persuasively that John is being discounted too much in this). Maybe we should start with her as the culprit. If you accept that evidence, then it might be easier to move past the seeming lack of motive. I agree the "accident' possibly involving bedwetting feels too weak of a motive. Was this a psychotic break? Or, using nonclinical language, did she just "snap" that night?Heck knows your channel's covered mothers who have just snapped. While Patsy doesn't necessarily give off the same crazy-flags that Darlie Routier might, you could at least point to some stress factors possibly at work here. Recovery from cancer (what medications are she taking?) Maybe there're strains on the marriage (I don't care to speculate too much here). Or, and this is still tossing out ideas, maybe she has some inkling that John (or whoever) is abusing JonBenet, and that's trauma she doesn't want to confront. The point is: the motive almost doesn't matter if there are some strong indications that she's the perpetrator. That contention simplifies the case for me, and I'm willing to handwave some of the minute oddities as smoke and mirrors. I don't think it was an accident, though. I would submit this scenario is at least easier to entertain than an Intruder, which your own Addendum puts very well in saying that you effectively need to distort the facts of the case as we know them to make that scenario even theoretically possible. And I would say this scenario (Patsy) is easier to believe by several orders of magnitude. If it wasn't Patsy, then I'd leave room for John doing it. Mostly because Doc G's theory has a neat psychological coherence to it. And your addendum really helps connect the dots for that theory. But I struggle to think those fibers in all those locations could have been transfered innocently.

Bri Cousineau

Not here to argue about who did it, just here for kitten update :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

He's doing well! I've been taking less pics and vids as he's been settling in more, but there are a few in the Photos room on Discord :) He's taken to attacking my feet on occasion, which is a touch annoying lol.

Obsolete Man

Where was the blood? Was there no laceration from the blow to her head? Burke had behavioral problems. I believe he could have dealt the blow to her head. Kids that age can be pretty strong when enraged, even if they are small. The test shown was just one hit, and the skull can be damaged in several different ways depending on where and how it is hit. Also, there was a thick wig and adhesive on the skull. That can make a difference on how it breaks. Patsy's behavior was strange. In the 911 call, rather than saying "my daughter is missing" it's "we have a kidnapping". Then she just leaves her son in bed? I understand not wanting to expose another child to this, but it seems a mother, upon finding one child missing, would naturally want to keep the other close by out of fear. And that note looks like it was written by a female who was shaking. Minor note of other strangeness: the note says for John to use his "good southern common sense". John was born in Lincoln, NE (I can assure you we Lincolnites are not Southern) and went to school in Michigan. So, why would either of them write that? Maybe to make it look less like they were writing the letter. Maybe it was someone else who thought he was Southern. Maybe, directly after getting home, Burke was enraged, hit JonBenét, the parents sent him to bed, they had all night to do the staging, clean up the blood, write the note, they discovered she was still breathing and did the garotte, someone did the paintbrush thing (shudder) to drive home the fact that it must have been an adult. They were all involved. But, who the hell knows. I can't believe you read all of this. I wouldn't have.

ryan

Excellent video. It won me over from 50/50% JDI/RDI to like 95/5% JDI/RDI. The last thing with JDI that I struggle with is that I’ve seen somewhere that Patsy still had the same clothes on from the previous day, full makeup, hair, etc. The reason I bring this up doesn’t have anything with red fiber, I just think it’s strange to not change clothes unless you were up all night. There’s plausible explanations, but she gives one that I don’t think is good: She apparently said that she doesn’t like doing laundry so she wears the same outfit multiple days in a row. I would totally buy it if she had said “I called 911 in a robe, so I threw on the first thing I found, even though it was on the bathroom floor.” Or maybe even “I fell asleep in my outfit, I was exhausted/drunk” or whatever. I try not to profile her… but that just seems strange for a wealthy woman that seems to care about her appearance to say that she hates laundry so she just wears the same outfit again. People are unique, of course, and don’t always adhere to a box that you place them in. Can someone tell me what they think and if I’m misunderstanding something?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It’s all good, I plan on continuing to think about it a little more as I keep replying to questions and challenges on this thread. Just gearing up to quit the case once and for all, but not quite there yet! Let’s start with what we agree on. Considering potential motive or lack thereof is always valid to varying degrees, but it’s still ALWAYS SECONDARY. If you had 100% Smoking gun proof someone committed a crime, it wouldn’t matter if there was still zero evidence of any motive. Obviously there’s something we just don’t know, because that person is proven to have done it - end of. Absent such a thing (I’ll talk about the fibers soon - they aint it) potential motives/lack of are definitely worth weighing when figuring out who we should be scrutinizing most closely. I’d argue Patsy’s the weakest candidate in the house in that framework, because her motive problems don’t actually stop with the murder, but we will start there! We seem to agree all signs point to intentional murder - It’s extremely difficult to imagine a motive for Patsy to intentionally murder her daughter. some PDI theorists have even resorted to child sacrifice/turning JB into an angel (the cancer meds were really taking their toll on her psyche) Her Motive to call the police - This one gets overlooked badly by a lot of people. As an exercise, it’s worth spending some time to see if you can cook up an explanation for it that passes the smell test. I bet you’ll find it a real head scratcher if you haven’t actively grappled with it before. When people even bother trying to explain it, it’s usually just that she’d run out of time to keep staging. But she called super early, and the note she would have written (with or without John’s direction) AGGRESSIVELY provides cover for a delay in calling the police. Her motive to hide the body - It ONLY works if she were hiding it from John. The police would be looking in that room sooner or later, which circles back to the last problem. There’s very scant justification for an intruder stashing the body either. The most plausible explanation by a fair margin is a parent hiding it from another parent, and there’s a much more direct road to John for that. Now onto the fibers… Not all fiber evidence is equal. Just going off the dome here, I think it’s actually impossible to say with 100% certainty that a given fiber came from a particular piece of clothing, but don’t quote me on that. Regardless, some fiber evidence can be pretty strong, like if it’s a very specific, rare kind of material of a very specific shade of color for instance - and when you compare it to a fiber sample from the suspects clothing it’s microscopically identical (think of Darlie’s fly screen vs the fiberglass on the bread knife). But then there’s a lot of other, much murkier situations where the material/color is not all that uncommon, and the fiber comparisons are merely similar - consistent enough where they could be a match, but not with such microscopic precision that any alternative explanation is laughable. Patsy’s red sweater falls under this flimsier category. Already right there, I think there’s enough that you should lose interest in Patsy. Even if I were to rate the fiber evidence against her as 7/10 suspicious (I don’t), it pales in comparison to the factors I’ve outlined above that seem to basically eliminate her by logic. However, if you still can’t get past it because of the placement of the fibers (that we don’t know for a fact came from her sweater) because an explanation of transfer is far out of reach…it’s not. I’ll blurb a bit from DocG on this and give you a couple links to read more: “Patsy's fibers must have been all over JonBenet, since Patsy was her mother and was no doubt fussing over her, hugging her, kissing her, etc. all day. When JonBenet's body was taken upstairs, Patsy reportedly embraced it, sobbing uncontrollably. She's been accused of deliberately "contaminating" the crime scene, but you can't have it both ways. If the body was "contaminated" by Patsy, that would also explain how her fibers got there. And don't forget, the duct tape had been pulled off of JonBenet's mouth by John, so her fibers could easily have got on the sticky side of the tape at that time.” And a weakness acknowledged by Steve Thomas, probably the biggest advocate for this talking point, as blurbed by DocG: “As you know, on the adhesive side of the duct tape, which was removed from the victim's mouth, there were four fibers that were later determined to be microscopically and chemically consistent with four fibers from a piece of clothing that Patsy Ramsey was wearing, and had that piece of tape been removed at autopsy, and the integrity of it maintained, that would have made, I feel, a very compelling argument. But because that tape was removed, and dropped on the floor, a transference argument could certainly be potentially made by any defense in this case, and that's just one example of how a compromised crime scene may, if not irreparably, have damaged the subsequent investigation.” https://solvingjonbenet.blogspot.com/2012/08/patsy-patsy.html https://solvingjonbenet.blogspot.com/2012/10/folklore.html

Liisa Turunen

We live in a house with lots of doors and windows and we never go around every night checking them all. We just tend to think that if someone opened it they would lock it. I have found some open and been surprised. So I say the weirdo came in an unlocked door, locked the door back up so no one would find it, wrote the note, snooped around, and probs just had some fun. Hid until the family went to bed. If she was deep asleep I don’t think it would be that hard to pick her up without her immediately screaming. Weirdo is insane so I can’t explain the actions with her. But, now he leaves most likely through a door or window that isn’t the basement. He probably tried that but looked elsewhere. He probably brought the rope thinking he is some action hero who’ll climb up to the balcony. The family not noticing an unlocked window or door seems the most logical thing that can go wrong out of everything that could go wrong lol

MG

Yes, exactly. I think there’s also an element of unconsciously seeking to dehumanize her because then it’s less painful to think about her horrible murder.

Frances McCarthy

I think BDI still works just fine - Burke also hit JB with a golf club in the face, with sufficient force to cause a gash and a scar.

D

Great video, Matt! For what it is worth, I know one of the prosecutors who worked on this case. The prosecutor strongly believes in the IDI theory. The reason is there was apparently an unknown sample of DNA found on both John Benet’s neck and in her underwear that matches. The prosecutor believes that the note was the killer fantasizing, which apparently happens with some deranged pedophiles. I am hopeful that one day we will get a genealogical match to the unknown sample so that we can finally get closure and justice for the victim.

Frances McCarthy

Hm. Okay JDI does also rely on there being a significant penalty for a father abusing his kid. We've hadecades of children coming forward and accusing their fathers of abuse and being either ignored or vilified. I don't think that was a significant risk TBH.

James

Wait wait. John was not accounted for almost an hour and a half the morning of his daughter being reported missing???

Yes Way Ted!

I don’t usually watch your commentary vids (sheepishly kicking the ground), but I gave this one a try on my break and now I’m pissed I have to go back work! Really, really interesting add on to the original upload. (Seriously, how can you wrap up all the information you gather - and deliver it in digestible story form - without losing the flow - and remain funny? Very impressive and I’m so grateful for you!!)

Mack The Finger

Could John have been influenced by watching Fargo (it came out the same year) the plan is eerily similar.

Jonathan Gill

I'll keep mulling it over; I certainly find many aspects of JDI attractive. I'll consider getting the book version instead of reading through the DocG blog (which I had done after your original video came out.) I guess I'll just end by saying that I might be taking a different interpretation from that Steve Thomas quote than DocG. It sounds to me like Thomas is saying the fibers are actually strong evidence, but because John removed the duct tape in the cellar, they wouldn't be successful as a courtroom argument. That is, a defense lawyer hellbent on amplifying any theoretical possiblity to exclude his client could make a theoretical case to downplay them.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

So there’s some things here I just can’t speak to. Like with the note for instance, it doesn’t matter if I put on an IDI or any variation of RDI hat - not only could I not tell you the thinking behind every phrase written, I don’t even care to try. There’s things in there that on their face don’t seem to make sense no matter who you argue wrote it…but someone did write it, nonetheless. I believe as a whole it’s more compatible with John than anyone else, mainly because it stresses not to call the cops (the thing Patsy did) and wants John to be the one to handle everything. Toward the start of the addendum, I talk about how I think it’s really helpful for anyone looking at this case to try and at least start by focusing just on the BIG things. Patsy saying “we have a kidnapping” first rather than "my daughter is missing" is a really good example of why I’m giving that advice. You will just get yourself spun out too much if you need any theory to reconcile itself with minutia like that. Not that I find it suspicious to begin with, but she does say, “our daughter is gone” in her very next response. Is the idea that this remark was just a few seconds too late? The action of Patsy calling the police is many times more exculpatory than her choice of wording is inculpatory. I also find the call as a whole sounds like a woman in extreme panic, out of the loop. Again, I put more stock in that than her verbiage.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

This one cuts both ways a bit - If she wore those clothes the previous night (she did), it means she was wearing them while murdering her daughter. In that case, you'd think a shower and change of clothes would be an absolute top priority before calling the police over. According to both Ramsey's, John was in the shower at the time Patsy woke up btw. Steve Thomas was especially suspicious of Patsy wearing the same clothes from the night before. The thing that really irked him about it was that Patsy was especially conscious about appearances. Wearing the some clothes two days in a row is a bit low rent, especially for a woman of her standing and background. He does have a point. However, it was a flight morning. If anyone's going to be less vigilant about their appearances than usual, it'll be when they need to get to the airport soon. This is an example of where I don't think you should let small things get in the way of the big things.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

And significantly insufficient force to put her in any mortal danger, let alone kill her outright! Her parents responded to the incident by seeking immediate medical attention, and did not try to hide the fact that Burke was responsible, though they did maintain it was an accident and I personally believe them. I've never seen the golf club incident as compelling. There's no indication it was a malicious attack, and decent indication it wasn't in the fact JBR sustained very limited enduring harm - a small scar.

Andy

I'm just gonna say huge thanks for this one, Matt. I've always been in the JDI camp. Love seeing and hearing your workings that further convince the jury of one that lives in my mind.

Freya

after this im definitely in the JDI camp after this-i think your analysis/points are SPOT ON. but, that being said, is it possible John woke her up in the middle of the night to sexually assault her, which maybe he’d done before, and then during the commission of the sexual assault began strangling her, realized he had gone too far, and then hit her on the head to end her life (sorry i know that’s horrific & very graphic)? then came up with his plan/the ransom note, which was ultimately not carried out, just like you said. that seems really plausible to me, but i also could be forgetting/leaving things out that would make this impossible (like whether we know is she was strangled or bludgeoned first, etc.) anyway, just something i thought of while listening, would love to hear anyone’s thoughts!! this case is truly such a tragedy. i hope her little soul is at peace now. great video as always Mr. Orchard-you are the best!

Janissa Rose

I think my hesitation in fully believing that it was the Ramsey's is that their behavior does seem kinda normal to me for people in their social class who lived in the south. They're just a very specific kind of awkward and shitty. Men are stern and unemotional and women are supposed to be a lot like Patsy. There's also a kind of self absorbed thing, and image obsession. I know everything I've said is not very specific to their particular social group, but it's the particular flavor of the way it's expressed. So throwing out all the behaviors that in my mind are explained by their unlikeable nature and social class, it's less certain in my mind than they were involved. On the other hand I am not convinced John DIDN'T do anything and I think your feelings regarding the interruption is pretty convincing. After you posted this I've just been watching a bunch of different stuff and I feel like most people extrapolate a lot more than is reasonable

Amy Culham

To be honest I find it more disturbing that you use the word ‘fuckable’, than Matt trying to clearly but sensitively articulate the uncomfortable fact

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I feel the same way, even as someone who extrapolates a fair bit. It really gets out of hand sometimes with the amount of small tidbits people try to spin into grand meaning. Just "SBTC" as one example among many.

Howell

I just love your videos, man. New Matt videos are truly a treat

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I don't know specifically what part of my argument your attributing that fallacy to. It's true I do underline many of my points with my incredulity toward various notions (very hard for anyone to argue anything without ever doing that much) but I think I always put forward my own actual logic in any given instance, rather than merely say "I find that hard to believe X, therefore it's not true" For instance, I express a lot of incredulity toward the idea that upon discovering Burke had killed JonBenet by accident (hitting her way hard, but not intending to kill her) both Ramsey's agreed, and continued to agree over multiple hours, that the best approach to this situation would be to stage an incredibly extravagant kidnapping and then call the cops at 5:52 AM with the body still in the basement. My incredulity at the above certainly doesn't prove it didn't happen...but is it still not well founded incredulity?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Well, I do agree the deranged fantasies of a madman are the second best explanation for that absolutely nutty document! If the DNA really does belong to a crazed perpetrator who's still out there (or dead for that matter) I certainly hope we get a match one day too :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

There are also many instances of children being believed, and when parents/guardians are convicted of such crimes, the penalties are often (rightly) very severe.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think I might have worded that too strongly/confusingly. I don't THINK we're supposed to take Arndt's report as meaning between aprox 10 40 AM and Noon John was 100% AWOL. Though I have heard that claimed. What I can say for sure is between those hours he left the house to collect the mail. Arndt doesn't know when exactly he did that, or precisely how long he was gone for. Which means between those hours there's no time we can say for sure if he was in his office/the living room/outside - Arndt just can't confidently account for him at any given time in that window. So it's significant, but not as earth-shatteringly significant as if he flew the coop for a full hr and a half! I shouldn't have worded it so strongly.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Anything is possible. It's been pointed out by both RDI and IDI camps that the note seems to have movie inspired lines in it. "Don't grow a brain" is a line from either Dirty Harry or Speed. There's more, ya can give it a goog! Love that movie though. "Blood has been shed, Jerry!"

ryan

Thanks for the clarity. Totally agreed. I just hit this point in chapter 5 and 7 of DocG’s book. Cheers.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

[This reply has some pretty heavy ideas in it] So within JDI, there are indeed variations on the theory where people think it was spontaneous, rather than something John had been plotting. In fact, in the description there’s a link to Cyril Wecht giving a talk where he expounds on his theory that John accidentally strangled JB to death during a sex game. I don’t believe that one. I also recently came across another JDI theorist who goes by CliffTruxton. He has his own theory that involves everything being conceived night of. It also involves chronic sexual abuse, but he conceives of it being more of an incestuous *relationship.* Let me pause to be very clear here: All child sex abuse is child sex abuse. A 6 year old can never be in a legitimate romantic relationship with anyone, let alone an adult - obviously. They can think they are, though. CTs idea is that John and JB had been secretly “seeing each other” for some time. John had come to realize how this couldn’t go on, but rather than having a plan of killing her, he just wanted to “break up.” But JB was having none of it. Things got out of hand. One thing I find really intriguing about CTs idea is it incorporates a strange little piece of evidence that’s not often discussed. A magazine clipping was found near John Ramsey’s upstairs desk. The clipping featured pictures of John Ramsey and three other businessmen who had recently won business awards. The faces of the other men had the word “NO” written over them in red sharpie, while John had a sort of heart flower pattern drawn around his picture. You can see it here: https://websleuths.com/proxy.php?image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.postimg.cc%2Fnr4N2FV4%2Farticle.jpg&hash=d309143fddaff2f93ddda630dad77ac1 Weird. The Ramsey’s have no explanation for the markings. CT speculates it may have been JB who made them - “I love JOHN, not THEM” sort of thing. Support for the incestuous relationship idea. TBF, a little girl could do such a thing just to innocently express she loves daddy. JB also had a heart drawn on her left hand in red ink. Patsy says it was not there when she went to bed. Could it have been drawn there as part of some sort of romantic ritual between the two? Seeing as we’ll never be able to know, I don’t like sitting around daydreaming various scenarios, it’s just all too gross. But something like that is possible. Here’s CTs write up, you can click on his username to go through more of his writings on his theory: https://www.reddit.com/user/CliffTruxton/comments/opju8w/timeline_findings_what_i_believe_happened_the/ Clearly I prefer DocGs overall theory to Cliff’s, but there’s obviously a lot of crossover, and there’s every possibility the actual truth could draw from both wells to some extent. What I put forward in my addendum is just an approximate scenario. The reason I personally, quite strongly, favor a plot in advance, is the ransom note’s length, as well as the relatively advanced plan I’m positing was behind it. I struggle to see this all being conceived and executed within a matter of hours - say 3-5. Possible, but hard to picture. This is another reason I quite like DocGs tracing idea. Even if the note was actually *penned* on the night, it would help an awful lot if the *content* of it was already written up and ready to go.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Jonathan - and just to clarify, yes your reading of STs statement is right. He's not personally saying he thinks the fiber evidence is trivial. It's just that he does acknowledge the nature of the fiber evidence. The reason a defense lawyer could make the argument of innocent transfer is because that is indeed a possibility. We can just agree to disagree on how plausible it is :)

James

I’m gonna be getting that book you recommended. If John truly did do it he is one lucky sob because the police did a horrendous job on so many levels. From the crime scene not being secure, having John and Buddy search the house AGAIN, lack of police presence at a certain point, not talking to Burke immediately, etc etc

Freya

Wow-that is all very interesting, especially that picture with the drawings you linked. Thank you for taking the time to respond so thoroughly!!! I also don’t like the idea of JB being in a “relationship” with her father for very obvious reasons, but I think it assumes JB would have the wherewithal, as a 6 year old, to understand and be upset about, to use your words a “break up” with her father. I just find a lot wrong with that, but it is interesting nonetheless. After thinking about it, you’re definitely right though- there’s no way John wrote that note without some sort of planning/forethought, also while rushing for time after committing the act spontaneously. That just seems completely impossible. I think your point in the video about the letter’s aim to get Burke and Patsy out of the house so he would have time to properly get rid of evidence/dispose of JB is REALLY interesting and likely correct, which, again, would have required some forethought, no matter how fleeting. Thanks again for taking the time to respond, I really appreciate it :)

Jake Stevens

Not wanting to go too deep into this, but why is it such a ludicrous leap of logic to people that John could have started molesting at such a late age? I understand that it's unlikely for sure, but someone on your very CHANNEL didn't start committing crimes well into his adulthood, that being Russell Williams. Unless you want to make an argument that power corrupted Russell, but I'd wager John had a decent amount of power in his own right so that goes out the window, no pun intended. Is it unlikely John's brain just decided one day in his 60's to start molesting? Absolutely! Is it unfathomable beyond a reasonable doubt? No, I wouldn't go that far. Really enjoyed the video though Matt, thanks a lot!

Obsolete Man

I used to have a job interviewing people; not job interviews, something less positive, which I won't get into, but the people were under stress. I find that words do matter. When someone who is distressed starts off with a story, it gives me pause. "We have a kidnapping" makes me curious, because it is not natural. It is too technical and she almost repeats it. I am not saying this is proof of guilt, but it is something that is noteworthy. While she does sound frantic, she would be frantic even if she wrote the letter, because of what happened during the night and because making the call would be the start of shit going down with the police. It seems strange that even though she wrote the note that she would call the police, but consider the fact that during this time that things are fluid, stress levels are max and plans change. They may have planned to follow the note and have time, but then decided that something might come up and they need to call the police that morning. Maybe because their family in Michigan would suspect something. Idk. But high stress situations cause unclear thinking and irrational moves. Just a thought. I'm not married to Patsy being invloved and I think your theory of John being the only culprit has legs. I just can't get all the way there, because the above and because she left Burke in his bed. I know that seems small, but it seems so contrary to a mother's nature. And a Grand Jury decided to indict both the Ramseys, not just John. But, maybe there was an intruder who came through an unlocked door when the Ramseys were out during the day/evening, was hiding in the house (like in a crawlspace, etc) when the Ramseys woke/police were there) and simply left undetected later when police were gone. Maybe he didn't leave initially because he saw the alarm system and didn't think he could get out in the night the crime occurred. But, for this theory to work, she would have been sexually assulted and DNA would have had to be left behind (not a trace amount). There is no way around that. What a puzzle. What a horrific crime.

Basia Śledzińska

I come from a similar societal background/class to Jonbenet and my mom used to not remove makeup and not change into her nightgown before early morning flights. She said she would get 0 sleep if she woke up early enough to do her makeup and hair, and that she would want to take a shower after flying anyway. I think Patsy might have done exactly that. When looks are important to you, you sometimes fake it a little.

Björn

If John had Indeed planned this in advance (even just for a couple of days), his "solution" seems like an unnecessarily complex and risky way of getting rid of his daughter. Staging an accident (hiking/traffic/slip and fall) for instance, seems like a far better method in almost every way. Why bother with something this complicated which is prone to all sorts of dangers? I still belong to the BDI camp since I believe it is the only theory congruent with all available evidence except for maybe the knot on the garotte (although that could have been done by someone else prior with a completely different purpose or maybe Burke was just good with knots) and the Patsy phone call (which I honestly think can be chalked up to emotional distress combined with a constantly evolving gameplay in concert with John). Maybe the crack the skull is too severe for Burke to have caused with a single hit with a flashlight. But has it really been definitely established that it was caused by a _single_ impact? And if he used a golfclub to make the strike (or strikes), that damage seems very reasonable to me. The only reason for the Ramseys to conjure up a story this complicated would be if they were left with no other choice. I.e. one or both of them discovered her when she was already dead. And since there are so many facts pointing away from an intruder, only Burke could have done it.

Allison

I’d be so curious to hear your take on Madeleine McCann

Claire

Damn Matt this hit the spot for me! In your David Bain recap, the factoid about throwing the newspaper at the neighbour's door had a significant impact on cementing my view that he was responsible and this video had a similar effect! (An effect not an affect!). The handwriting thing was especially compelling. Personally I believe still that Burke was involved and that there were two killers - one for each major injury. Burke was adept at tying knots and whittling wood and if that was him overheard on the 911 call as he later conceeded on the grand jury witness stand, his voice (to me) contains a guilty or nervous element. It's not inconceivable that John found Burke mid-assault with the cord, possibly even with his friend Doug Stein, and used a nearby golf club or baseball bat to hit her on the back of the head. I do think it's possible for scrawny Burke to inflict that kind of damage if using a long-handled golf club or a bat. I'm impressed with your ability of persuasion regarding Patty's lack of involvement - when you take away the handwriting analysis evidence, there is not an actual lot tying her to the murder. Off to read that e-book!

Claire

Agree, we often see examples where a paedophile father is particularly interested in just one of their children. Not always but it's definitely a thing.

Claire

Absolutely love that ransom note VO, I hear it in my head very often 😀

Claire

That was a lovely tribute to Jon-Benét at the end there Matt. I'm not religious but I like to imagine her up in heaven fussing over all the baby angels and making sure they all get a turn in their heavenly games.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I get what you mean, but I don't think it's quite the same. So first of all, you are right that all theories (one of which, broadly speaking, must be right) involve one or more "Big Asks." JDI in my estimation has approximately two Big Asks (sort of depends how you count them). 1. John was a pedophile, and an especially evil one to boot (I think it should be counted as one) 2. John hatched a dastardly scheme that sounds like it belongs in a movie (I mean the whole case sounds like that really, but lets count that as an extra Big Ask) Grant those two Big Asks however, and I contend that basically everything about the case that was previously vexing starts to fall into place and make sense. In my view this isn't the case with all other theories. It's like you grant one big ask, only to be faced with yet another and another. Although I emphasized the difficulty of getting the Intruder in and out of the house, I never meant to imply that's ALL I see wrong with the theory. The near total lack of any sign of an outsider being IN the house for that time sort of requires major allowances each step of the way - more than just one Big Ask I mean. JonBenet being molested for an ongoing period of time isn't actually a *Big* Ask under the case information, though it wouldn't be fair to frame it as an established fact either. JonBenet’s autopsy noted “chronic inflammation” in her genital area. Several medical experts have interpreted that finding to be indicative of sexual abuse prior to the night of her death. That's not the sole possible explanation for such a finding, and her pediatrician has always swore up and down he never observed anything suspect.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

You're right to differentiate between clothes and makeup and their potential significance. But Patsy's story is actually that she did do her hair and makeup before heading downstairs to make coffee. So same clothes, not same makeup - according to Patsy :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

You know with that point about staging an accident, I’ve got to be careful not to go off on too much a tangent because I think it’s such an interesting crime subject in and of itself. First of all, I’d say - yes, going on a hike and having JB “trip” would seem less high risk than staging a full on kidnapping and so forth, all things being equal. All things aren’t necessarily equal though. A couple of BIG things: 1. Opportunity. From John deciding JBs death was necessary to whatever his deadline may have been (I can only speculate if he had a deadline and what the reasons would have been for it) he may well just have had no way of inconspicuously getting JB to the edge of a cliff or what have you. You might say, “well it doesn’t have to be a cliff” and I get you, but take it as a metaphor. Whatever your method is, you’ve got to create the circumstances, and contrived circumstances look suss. It’s usually way harder to kill a person on purpose and have everything come out genuinely looking like an accident than you might think. Accidents look like accidents because they’re accidents sort of thing. I’m sure there are exceptions, but as a rule of thumb, staging an accident isn’t a piece of cake. 2. Certainty of Death. Staging an accident is a real “one shot/one kill” sort of strategy, and the more surely fatal you make the circumstances, the less it’s going to look like an accident. Conversely, the more you make it look like a genuine accident, as a rule of thumb, the higher the odds will be that your victim will survive. Things that make it look less like an accident: Going in for seconds/thirds, delaying calling for medical assistance. And if they do survive, good luck making any second attempt putting them in unnaturally dire circumstances and avoiding suspicion. Honestly, “It Was An Accident!” Could make a great video - you’ve got me going now! In terms of that head wound - I believe it’s pretty well subscribed to among theorists of all stripes that it was a single blow. Doing my best to explain without any expertise - the single, large, clean break, along with the gash that represents the point-of-impact, speaks to one large thwack. If she was hit multiple times, you’d expect more impact patterns - think Kathleen Peterson. Also, no external bleeding. The skull fracture was only discovered at autopsy, no one even knew she’d been hit in the head til then. “Definitively established” is probably still a bit too rich though - a pretty high bar in pathology! Obviously I just disagree that BDI is more congruent with the evidence than JDI, and I’ve outlined why in the addendum so I should probably just leave it there. All I’ll say is that I think writing off the cops being called so early with emotional distress highlights a flaw in the argument. The note spends a whole paragraph giving the Ramsey’s the perfect cover to delay calling the police. So the idea is Patsy threw out that whole fundamental part of the plan (that wasn’t all written for no reason) and calls the cops with the body still in the basement because things were just getting too overwhelming? Doesn’t wash at all with me. I still think her not knowing the body was in the basement is a much more elegant explanation for that action.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It's on the more or less "definitely" list. Not necessarily soon, but basically for sure some time or another - probably at a time I feel well rested! Looks like a massive one. I don't have a strong opinion rn, just know the basics.

Claire

For real it is! I am almost cross with myself for not subbing to the Patreon sooner and acquiring that tidbit of information. PS: tell Wex I said 'pssst psst psst psst psst <3'

Jessa Nather

Thank you, Matt!! I love your analysis of this case and I really think it's the best one out there. If you're interested in my ideas, the thing I disagree with you about is that John and Patsy were too smart to come up with that ridiculous plan with the fake kidnapping. You obviously know a lot about crime, so I think you might be overestimating the average person's understanding of how a kidnapping/murder scenario would work. I know it would be a really stupid plot, but I think it's realistic for people who have no idea about crime or any of it to think that a "small foreign faction" might kidnap a child for ransom, leaving a (comically long) ransom note to really drive the point home, because they just didn't really know that ransom notes are usually short and "small foreign factions" wouldn't do this sort of thing. Maybe they watched a lot of TV and thought of stories of terrorist or criminal gangs kidnapping people. They could have left Jonbenet in the basement, imaging that the cops would simply believe that the kidnappers' plan went awry between leaving the note and leaving the house. Maybe the kidnapper got violently carried away and killed her by accident, or when carried away by the desire for murder. That would be a scenario if you imagine that a comically evil group wanted to kidnap her, but then had a mistake along the way. Then, if they got really carried away with the imagining, they could have gone so far as to stage the evidence with the garrote and the paintbrush. I've seen many cases of parents doing horrible things to their children, and I don't doubt that it's possible, especially if they thought it would make the plot more realistic. I also think it's believable that they would think that Burke would be taken from them if he was involved, even by accident. They would probably believe that he would be branded as a dangerous child, suspected of murdering her on purpose, might be locked up in a juvenile jail or smth for years. If the killing was suspected to be really violent on his part. I can see why they would imagine that as a real possibility. Anyway, I just think that you're smarter and well-read about crime than most regular people, and this may lead to a bit of a different perspective. Thanks for your content! Much love <3

AR

i'm so glad that i signed up for your patreon just in time for this post! this is one of the cases i most love listening to my favorite podcasters cover, and the case i most judge new podcasts on (if they seriously argue that Burke did it then i know they're not serious haha). i really loved your take on this and i really appreciated the way you laid everything out in this! i honestly don't think anything you said here really excludes the intruder scenario for me, though, because 1) i've never assumed the intruder was a stranger, and 2) i've never assumed all the doors were locked just because John said so. I recently bought my first house, which is roughly probably 15 times smaller than the Ramsey's house, and even though i only have a grand total of four (4) doors to keep track of, and even though i make a point of regularly checking them to make sure they're all locked, and even though i need a key to lock the deadbolt for 3 of the 4 doors, i STILL am constantly discovering that somehow i have left one or more of the doors unlocked without realizing it, sometimes for a whole day, when i was absolutely convinced i had locked it. Just yesterday I went to unlock the patio door only to realize that while the little flip latch was locked, the deadbolt somehow wasn't, and I genuinely have no idea how that happened or how long it was standing unlocked like that. And that is just me with my four easy-to-keep-track-of doors! Not the Ramseys with their enormous house with dozens of doors and windows and balcony-doors. I say all that to say that if you are positing which scenario seems more likely, to me "John Ramsey thought all the doors were locked when they weren't and someone walked in" is a vastly simpler explanation to me overall than "John Ramsey suddenly manifested pedophilic tendencies for the first and as far as we know only time in his life." The intruder could also have easily pushed the push lock on a doorknob as they left so it locked behind them. There are multiple true crime cases in which pedophiles bide their time and target a specific child, then stalk that child and their family until they have an opportunity to harm them. Given that we know several pedophiles were in JonBenet's pageant circle, and given how public their family was and how big their social circle was, it just does not seem that far-fetched to me at all that an intruder could learn that the family would be gone to the party, realize that would give them a long time in the house, and take advantage of that time to enter, learn their way around, write the note, and lie in wait. It's most likely in this scenario that JonBenet knew them and they wouldn't have any trouble luring her downstairs. The biggest problem with this theory to me is how an intruder would know about John's $118,000 bonus for the ransom note, but again, this was a loud and public family with a big social circle, and people talk, so, not impossible. I think the biggest mental hurdle I have with the idea that John did it is that the leap from zero known pedophilic proclivities, to a specific pedophilic proclivity that still went undetected by anyone (again, despite how public a family they were!), to a specific pedophilic proclivity that immediately escalates to the murder of your own child, just all feels like such an increasingly narrowly psychopathic behavioral profile that it feels as though there's no way to reconcile it with the complete lack of psychopathy exhibited anywhere else in his life. That enormous skull fracture combined with the paintbrush assault makes this a deranged, Tommy Lynn Sells or Oba Chandler-style murder, and those were the kind of men who just couldn't stop being creepy and leaking their sexual proclivities and violence everywhere they went, even when they weren't killing. If John Ramsey really carried out this unthinkably violent act on his own daughter and then never did anything like it ever again — I don't really know who else I'd compare him to, psychology-wise. I don't even know who fits into that profile. God, maybe a total and complete narcissist like Chandler Halderson or John List? They were both motivated by the same kind of desperation you're describing here. But they were also both pathological liars — we would be swapping in a very well-known criminal profile of pathological liars with narcissism killing when their lies are discovered (Chandler, John, Sef Gonzales, Jennifer Pan, Christopher Porco, that one kid from the UK who claimed to be a tennis pro, the list goes on and on and on) for a more or less unknown profile of a narcissistic pedophile with, apparently, a middle-aged manifestation of both his narcissism and his pedophilia. I just don't know anyone else in the annals of true crime that fits that profile, at least not that I can easily recall. IDK IDK. But you've given me tons to think about!

AR

oh! the other thing that's really a huge leap for me here is the underlying assumption that John would just assume Patsy would patiently read this whole 2-page ransom note before freaking out. I've known Patsy Ramsey through a two-minute 911 call and maybe 5 minutes total TV footage and I feel like *I* already know she's a woman given to dramatic overreaction, and if that woman was my wife, I would certainly know and trust her to immediately fly into hysterics the moment she realized her child was missing. At MINIMUM i would make sure my "DO NOT CALL THE POLICE" was the first or second line in my note, and i would keep my note very short to match her likelihood of panicking. Or I just, you know, would not pin my ENTIRE murder plot around the faint possibility that my panic-stricken wife, who was often painted as the dominant one in the family, would listen to my written instructions while in the middle of panicking.

AR

Wait, Matt... you're not using Grok seriously as though it's giving you facts, right? I'm sort of unsure if you're just being funny with this, but a lot of people *do* sincerely believe that gen AI tools are giving them actual facts, so I just want to ask to be sure!! Especially because if you're actually asking Grok or ChatGPT or some other generative AI tool to give you information for cases, you risk winding up with a really serious misinformation problem at some point. (For anyone reading who might not be sure how generative AI works, it's a pattern generator. It isn't curating facts, it is running through iterative data sets and then spitting out words next to each other in order of probability. It takes millions of dice rolls to get the probability high enough so that the words sound like they go together. But that's what's happening: The generative AI tool has rolled the dice millions of times to generate words that probably go together, forming a sentence about the locks on the Ramsey's house. The sentence *looks* like it is a real fact, but nothing about it is a real fact at all. And every word you read from generative AI is this way. Nothing about it can be trusted to be real at any given moment. People who want you to believe in gen AI tools frame obviously false gen AI statements as "hallucinations," but that obscures the reality that the whole tool is a hallucination. It is not trustworthy in the slightest as a fact-checker or a search engine — it is effectively a ouija board for tech nerds.)

Björn

Maybe you are right, maybe staging an accident would be similarly difficult or present other risks (I would love to see a staged-accident-themed video btw) But even in keeping with some kind of 3rd party murderer-setup, the "plan" could have been executed with any number of variations to decrease the amount of risk to John. So why didn't he? Since my previous comment I have read DocGs material and reconsidered my position (now perhaps 55/45 JDI/BDI). Patsy calling the police is a major issue - one that is difficult to reconcile with a BDI world view. I admit that the fact of Patsy having her makeup on with the same clothes the next day, has been instrumental in keeping me within a theory that in some way implicates her. But I realise now that that particular fact is easier to reconcile in a JDI view than the phone call is in a BDI view.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I'm glad you're taking on board the significance of the 911 call, It's one element I find especially hard to write off. Also, John walking up to the window, shutting it, and latching it. Even after I made the addendum and already put all that emphasis on that point, I was sitting on the couch watching TV an evening or two later and started thinking about it again, and I just started saying aloud, "no way" or something like that. It's a point that just gets stronger with time, even for me at this stage in the game. In terms of why John decided the best approach would be one as convoluted as this - I mean, the short answer is I just don't know. But sometimes, if you've got a *set* of problems, any plan you come up with to address all of them at once could be destined to look a bit colorful. I think it's strange he thought the ransom note needed to be that long - then again I'd say the same of any proposed culprit. He may have just thought the theatrical nature of it would have all the more impact in scaring Patsy into compliance. Also, if instead of looking at it the way it turned out, you assume the JDI theory is true, and put yourself in John's shoes on the 25th, it's not actually all *that* convoluted, is it? You take your daughter downstairs, kill her with one big bonk to the head, stash the body, get your wife and kid out of your hair via the note, dispose of the body, stage the scene properly, return to wife and kid in a day (maybe having lost the note) and tearfully tell them that things went wrong, then contact the police with your harrowing story - oh, I'm sure they would have had questions, and I assume John would have anticipated that much, but...hands clean(er). I'm not saying it's not more multi-layered than most criminal plots we hear about - but is it totally otherworldly? As I've said elsewhere on this thread, John being a secret evil pedo, and the theorized plan being as Machiavellian as it is are the two "Big Asks" in this way of looking at things. Grant those Big Asks though, and imo just about everything starts falling into place. Also imo, the same can't be said when you grant the Big Asks of other theories - there still seems to be a lot of round hole/square pegging - BDI and the timing of Patsy's 911 call being a great example.

Björn

If John for some reason came up with the plan on the spot on the 25th, then yeah, the plan makes alot more sense. But if he planned it days in advance, why not dispose of the body prior to getting his family out of the house via the note. Any one member of the family could potentially have wandered into the cellar (maybe to grab a suitcase if they anticipate being away for a while to hide from kidnappers or whatever) and discovered JB. If he planned it, and if he was acting rationally, I fail to see how he would be ok leaving such a catastrophic potential disovery in the basement of his own home. But hey, maybe he overestimated the amount of control he had over Patsys behaviour. Maybe some intrusive thought that night/morning made him panic and decide to execute a plan that was imperfect, maybe a plan that would have been much better if it had more time to mature. But yea, square pegs and round holes is pretty much this case in a nutshell. Each theory sucks in some way but one of them must be true. And the least sucky theory seems to be JDI, at least for the time being heh. Thank you very much for this video, it was great btw

Connor Evans

Thank you for ending your video with a reminder of Jon Benet's humanity - it's something I always really appreciate about how you handle true crime cases. The victims shouldn't be remembered for the way they died, but for who they were and how tragic it is we lost them.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks man - and yeah just for clarification, I didn't mean to say I thought John conceived it all on the 25th, I was just saying his plan might seem more complicated in light of how everything looked after it went wrong. Before that point, it was still pretty complex as far as these sorts of plans go, but not *that*complex. He just flat out wouldn't have had enough time to dispose of the body before Patsy woke up, and presumably always knew he wouldn't. Hence the purpose behind the note. That's the thing about the storage room known as the wine cellar, it's literally the most remote, least trafficked area in the entire house. And it was initially latched shut - so very much hidden. Not much point in an intruder hiding it (I guess they could have had their reasons), no point in either or both of the Ramsey's hiding it from the police - they would have searched there eventually for sure. But a Ramsey hiding it from another Ramsey works fine. Patsy's 911 call (among many other things) again makes John the best candidate.

Claire

Congratulations on buying your first house!!

sammer

Incredible video and I am very glad to have paused rewatching one of your videos at the intro and subscribed here. I am pleased by your refraining from discussing the paintbrush, and even taking an L so you don't have to talk about it. It does, as someone just learning this case from you, seem to be an extremely strong piece of JDI evidence. To just put it out there and let you take a shower after, it seems like this is a way to account for a certain membrane being torn that would show up in a post mortem examination, that is generally intact in 6 year old girls. Even if these sorts of tests are not generally considered medically sound and probably inadmissable in court, not everyone knows that. The paintbrush also makes BDI and probably RDI really absurd . Time me to take a shower, maybe in slight bleach solution. Probably other people have had this thought I'm sure.

Kevin Fox

I have rewatched this 3 times now, amazing video! This is the only Jon Benet media that has helped me form anything close to an opinion on what may have happened. Thank you for all of your hard work!

Steve

John Douglas published his bestselling Mindhunter in October 1995. We’ve learned Rex Heuermann (Gilgo Beach) studied it and took notes. And there are reports a copy was in the Ramseys’ master bedroom. Take a look at the intertextualities between this case and Chapter 16 (“God Wants You to Join Shari Faye”). They range from girls kidnapped from home to rare mixed motive (sex homicide + ransom demand) to no fingerprints on letter to two words: “Listen carefully.”

Steve

Hey Matt, here in DC, I’m following the Erin Patterson case via the Australian podcast “The Mushroom Trial: Say Grace.” I really hope a video about this case is on your to-do list. We need someone to put it in the context of what—to an outsider—seems to be a rather bizarre mushroom culture down under.

AR

Thanks, i should have said first and only house since I'm well into middle age 😅

futures

Finally got around to this after being very sick for a bit. Glad I saved it when I can think it over clearly. I do agree with your conclusion that John or an intruder are really the only suspects I consider legitimate based on the strike. I just have a hard time squaring John as a pedophile given his history before and since. Sure it's possible he had a fixation on JB but pedophiles just don't act once. That is a continuous urge that must be filled which is why recidivism rates are insanely high compared to other crimes. No matter how intelligent they usually don't get away with it and surely there would at least be an inkling of something or anything in his 80 years of life. And for someone apparently pretty intelligent his plan was quite terrible and not well thought out to get rid of this supposed problem. There is no doubt easier ways to do this. Why would he wait to dispose of the body? Surely that is something you need to plan how you are going to do right away, as of course finding it in your own house makes you look insanely guilty. The ransom letter is also another point of contention. If you are going to fake this then why wouldn't you keep it pretty short and simple like most of these letters are? The rambling almost nonsensical way it is written doesn't really track with someone of a sound mind. It's hard to fathom thinking John wrote it that way deliberately. It being written like that really only points the finger at you because of how insane it is. I just have to lean with an intruder given how much of this case doesn't make sense and given how the investigation was clearly bungled and think there has to be huge stuff they missed. I also do think that experts who worked on the case largely lean towards the intruder theory which means a little, maybe there is some stuff just out of the public's eye. Hard to believe they all believe something seemingly preposterous with the same information we have. JB also wasn't a normal kid and definitely drew some attention which raises the likelihood compared to someone unknown, could've been a stalker of some sort. I think all the oddities could easily fall into place if we had the full picture. As for why there was never a hit for DNA, it could actually be transfer contact or the perpetrator could've died shortly after because I do concede it would be hard to imagine a murderous pedophile not offending again. Awesome video though, gotta be some of the most comprehensive stuff on the case!

Matthew Thayer

As to the paintbrush thing, without getting too graphic, it's easy for me to imagine him wanting some kind of, "one last time," but, knowing that any part of his body would potentially be highly incriminating, he used a paintbrush.

Steve

Matt, I have a treat for you. A&E recently relaunched their iconic true crime series, City Confidential. The first four seasons were brilliantly narrated by Paul Winfield, who died in 2004. The 45-minute episodes spend half of their time explaining the cultural setting of high-profile cases. As a student of the genre, you’ll appreciate the scripts, narration, and sometimes arch comedy. I just discovered the series because the first four seasons are now free on YouTube. The first episode is “Deadly Odds in Biloxi.”

2bit

On the timing of it all - given that night they went to a Christmas party, I can imagine perhaps JonBenet said something to a relative that Jon overheard, something that made him think “Shit! If this goes on any longer, I’m truly fucked!” And given the upcoming trip, they’d be surrounded by family yet again, for an extended period of time. So it’s easy to imagine Jon having this plan in the back of his mind for some time - maybe even having the note ready or at least thought out - and something JonBenet said or did that night just made him feel like his back was against the wall and he had to act sooner rather than later. TBH I don’t believe this with full confidence - it’s impossible to be confident about much in this case - but I’m just saying it’s a pretty elegant explanation for the timing.

N. M.

just a thought re: Patsy's phone call sounding like a mother who called the cops immediately and is rifling through the note as she's on the phone... she reads "Victory SBTC" and then maybe her eyes passed over one of the many threats not to call the police, which is why we hear her manic energy fluctuating and ultimately causes her to flat out hang up on the operator

Amy Culham

Your channel is my absolute most trusted place to go for true crime, because I can’t bear it when the facts of someone’s murder aren’t treated with proper respect, and you are so measured and, as you say, cross your t’s and dot your i’s. The thing that most strikes me about the JonBenet case is how one crime scene could possibly be the creation of a panicked family coverup OR a crazed, calculated maniac. How come the crime scene suggests a rushed coverup when the murder itself seems so methodical and deliberate? How can that note be so heavy handed and such an absolute failure to disguise the murderer, almost comically theatrical, yet its author and its planned effect are still unknown! I was also wondering how likely it is for an intruder to have kept quiet up to now, considering how famous this case is? Could they resist telling someone? Could those people have resisted spreading the word?

Fletcher Henery

Not Case related but what are your thoughts on the Erin Pattinson ‘Death Cap Mushroom’ murder trial? Would this be a case you would consider covering in a video?

Rosalind Margulies

I wonder if the note was written by somebody on crack. The maid, who worked for them at the time of JonBenet’s killing was later arrested for selling it. So it could explain where John got it. I think it would explain a lot of things I think it would explain: the note, both length & fantastical content; the varied & intricate nature of the injuries to jonbenet. maybe it even explains his motivation to do it + sexually assault jonbenet at all. or if you think john was too highbrow for crack (though i've known millionaires who do crack, lol) you could call it adderall psychosis. i think my theory makes a lot of sense if you ignore the fact that there's no evidence for it at all

Reiken Kayzer

And/or indeed covering his tracks if he indeed sexually abused her before her death. Fearing they would be able to tell she had been abused, he created a plausible reason as to why.

Iron

I've got a left field suggestion for you. I am not sure if you know who Chris Chan is, but he was arrested in 2021 for alleged sexual crimes against his... geriatric mother. Here's the thing: He got off scott-free. All charges dropped. The common belief on the internet is that he did it. However, in a legal context, there is a reasonable doubt. Enough doubt that his case was dismissed. He is autistic, and has been shown to have a rather loose grip on reality. In the past, trolls on the internet have brainwashed him into believing some pretty bizarre stuff. Despite the fact that he made repeated claims that he was guilty in writing from jailhouse letters, charges were still dropped. The rabbit hole goes incredibly deep on that case. There is an entire wiki on the guy documenting every public statement he has made, public sightings, documentation on his trolls, etc. There are dozens of documentaries on the net about him, but none actually posing the question of whether or not he was actually guilty. It would probably bring in some mad views as well. Just something to consider. It could be interesting to explore what might have gone down in the courtroom on that fateful day his charges were dropped.

Amaya

I never get tired of hearing about this case. In fact I only subscribed to your patreon because I wanted to hear more from you. This one is wild, I can't make up my mind on what happened here... There's weird details to "prove" any pet theory. But you are right. An adult male hit her head, no way around it. I also wonder, why are people so intent on blaming JR for the abuse (he had older children, none have reported this sort of thing. People don't become child molesters suddenly at his age when this happened, right? Also, no allegations of abuse after). I don't think he was abusing her. Thanks for sharing your views.

Amaya

I agree. I'm also very suspicious of their help. They could be the intruder (no forced entry needed).

Amaya

And now that I've finished listening to the whole vid, yes. It's also very weird that if IDI, this perp has not gravely offended again and not entered in a DNA db.

ChiralSpiral

I was very interested to listen to this, because after researching and thinking about this case a lot I’ve also come to the conclusion that it’s either John or an intruder. I’ve never found any of the Burke theories convincing and nothing in particular, except maybe handwriting anaysis (which I don’t put a lot of stock in) points to Patsy. Regarding the DNA, is there any published research on DNA transfer that would help set a statistical baseline? I’m thinking of studies where a large number of people’s clothes was analysed for contact DNA. That would help us decide how suspicious the two samples on her long johns and underwear actually is. I agree that at first glance it seems really suspicious, but thinking on it more I guess I don’t know if that’s true. Especially since was a young child who had just been at a busy party. Regarding Doc G’s book, I attempted to read the kindle sample last year but I was turned off by some very spurious logic. If I remember correctly, early on he asserts that the ransom note was written by a man because it uses phrases like “one hunted percent” or something like that, which is complete bullshit. Is the rest of the book any better?

Lb

I love your story about discovering Doc G’s blog. It was a lot like my own experience, tho unlike you I am merely a causal follower of the JB case. I stumbled upon Doc G’s blog way back, maybe 10 years ago, after finding some of his writings there on the Making a Murderer (that documentary bothered the hell out of me). Doc’s case for “John did it” blew my mind. Since then I have considered this the strongest theory around. I am amazed it hasn’t gotten more traction, and that Patsy is seen by most as a more plausible suspect. Perhaps the temptation to blame the mother is just too great for some. (The mother figure is so evocative of strong feelings about protection, harm, love, betrayal…) I am equally amazed at how certain some people are about their own theories. In reality, this one of the most ambiguous and confusing mysteries ever, which is why I dip back into reading about it every few years. On a broader note, your videos are fantastic. You have an amazing ability to choose just the right word or turn of phrase to describe things. I wish I knew how to write like your scripts. They are just A+. Thanks for the enjoyable and thought provoking content.

ethan

If there are outsiders who buy IDI, then I have no doubt Patsy could.

Samantha Pullen

I’ve read the entire book by Doc G and I found it to be solid in the main and more shaky on smaller elements. For example: He spends a good deal of time comparing John’s one known handwriting sample to the note: sometimes letter by letter, sometimes in letter segments. He also quotes a handwriting analyst who agrees with him and shows links to their work (most of which are older links, some of which do not work). He then later acknowledges that the Ramsey’s attorneys claimed(in a lawsuit filled against them) that handwriting analysis is not a strongly supported science. Which is true. But undermines both the Ramsey’s assertions that handwriting analysis clears them and Doc G’s assertion that John’s handwriting appearing similar is something that can truly be counted as strong evidence. He acknowledges that this is a flaw with the Ramsey’s but doesn’t apply it to his own comparisons. I think handwriting analysis is interesting but too a red herring, much like the note itself. And it weakens his argument in my mind. But can I fault people for trying to engage with something so strange? Not really. He’s at his weakest when he presents an argument based on intuition or without baseline data, then tries to apply logic to it afterwards to make the point more robust. Which he genuinely doesn’t need to do. His logic (in the main) is sound enough on its own and doesn’t need to be supported by weaker arguments. It’s an imperfect work but if you go into it with an open mind, you can glean his stronger, compelling arguments and dismiss those you think are weaker. It’s a fascinating theory overall and, in my opinion, worth your time.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I basically agree with what Samantha's outlined above. I strongly endorse (well I leave a bit of wiggle room, but pretty darn strongly) the core of DocGs theory, which I guess can be boiled down to No Break In>Grown Man>Patsy Called The Cops = John Did It. I think that core logic is very sound. And it's worth the purchase to hear him flesh that out a bit and handle the most common objections, imo. Like I believe I said in the addendum though, that doesn't mean I sign off on every inch of what he says. I can't specifically remember him saying only a man would use an expression like "100%", but I do agree that's bullshit, and there might be other places he's prone to saying bullshit. I just give him those allowances because I think the bulk of what he's come up with is...basically some of the most illuminating stuff I ever came across on this case.

ChiralSpiral

I ended up buying the ebook out of curiosity, and I think we’re broadly aligned on our opinions. I find the overall theory very compelling, but he has a tendency to fly off into unsubstantiated speculation when getting into the specifics. It’s kind of a shame, because I imagine the weaker aspects of it give his critics a lot of ammunition to use against him.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I've been reading the updates, so I'm somewhat interested. Unfortunately that's a great example of great case/poor supporting material. Aussies do not broadcast their trials, and they are way less prone to releasing full police interviews too. Same with all countries outside the US. There's just not that many (if any) parallels to America's FOIA system. One thing I think makes that case super interesting is how it illustrates, "no motive!" isn't a very compelling argument. If all else is equal, sure...but when all else is not equal (real Darlie vibes here!). There's no good motive to be put forward for Patterson to have done what she's accused of doing. You might wanna say, "but she was broken up form her husband, and those were his friends and family!"- but that aint a motive. The starting point for finding one maybe, but not one in and of itself. Patterson had nothing to gain by killing those people that we know of - no financial gain, no custody benefits (I mean her ex didn't even wind up attending thank god), and the crown even opened their case by acknowledging as much, opting to get ahead of it rather than try to carve on out, because it's genuinely super tough to articulate what good reason she could have to want to poison those people. ...But she did. I mean dead to fucking rights she did. They have her doing online research for where to find death caps, they have her attempting to dispose of a dehydrator after the dinner, they have her attempting to fake her own illness following the meal - not to mention telling lies about her health to the dinner guests prior and pressuring her ex HARD to attend. Those are just the crib notes as I'm sure you know. Dead to rights. But no motive to speak of really - funny one for sure. I might be able to cobble something together with news reports and so forth. I might wait to see if there are any big budget docos and/or dramatic productions on the case on the horizon to give me some more visual options. I really need those to have something to talk over when there isn't trial/interrogation footage.

Fletcher Henery

There’s a person I’ve been watching who’s done day by day updates during the trial which has been captivating to watch. I know under the Victorian Freedom Of Information Act 1982 it could be possible to make a request however until the dust settles and any appeals (provided any guilty convictions, which I fully believe she will with the amount of evidence)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I mean, that plays out in my head just fine - yeah! I don't believe Patsy's ever characterized her actions specifically that way though.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Steve - I gave some thoughts on the case and the problems with making a video on it, which my not be insurmountable :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

With the unlocked doors - It's not just a matter of John thinking he locked them last night. He told the cops he'd run a bit of an inventory upon discovering the note. So he's saying he just checked them based on the police reports. Police also naturally checked the doors. So yeah, the most give I can give on that front is maybe they neglected to check less obvious doors, like the one to her balcony. I want to reiterate, my argument in the JDI prism is not that John developed pedophilic tendencies "overnight." Presumably something was always there, he just didn't act out on his previous children. It doesn't necessarily go without saying he never did anything with any other children - I really don't know. I think the contention that if he did we would like 99% for sure know about it is just wrong. I think it's also wrong to say if he molested JonBenet then he like 99% for sure would have acted out in some way in the past. I just think it's more dicey than that and you can't paint how child molesters behave and find outlets for their desires with a super broad brush - though I'm no expert in the area. I've spoke previously in this thread about how I actually specifically really LIKE the part of the theory with John arrogantly putting all his chips in on how he anticipated Patsy to react, so I'll copy paste that here: I feel like we're often hearing about otherwise quite clever plans that fell apart because of one really boneheaded mistake. John didn't have any previous active kidnapping experience with Patsy, but he may well have had tons of reference points of her turning to him as a source of strength in difficult situations. The idea that John was so SURE Patsy would run straight to him, that he never even envisioned a scenario where she ran straight to the phone...I can just see it. It rings so true to me.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

If Burke did the lot - head blow, garroting, paint brush, etc. I could much easier see fears of him being institutionalized. It's just hard for me to picture all of that. I mean hell, as stated, its hard for me to even see him creating the skull fracture!

Mack

I found Doc G's book a few months ago after rewatching your video for the 100th time and it is easily the most convincing theory on the case. I subbed to your Patreon to watch this video specifically - honestly I was not expecting you to be a full JDI. Imagine my surprise when I clicked the description and the first thing I saw was a link to Doc G's blog! My favorite point that he's made about the DNA evidence is that it is both the biggest positive and negative for the IDI side. Because of it, IDIs forever have a phantom scapegoat they can point to - "an anonymous serial pedophile snuck into the house and killed her!" But then evil serial pedophiles actually admit to the crime - the gold star suspect the Ramseys and IDIs have waited for - and lo and behold the DNA doesn't match. The DNA doesn't mean shit.

Julz XD

Joe Berlinger who helped create Paradise lost also made the Netflix biased show Who killed Jon Benet. Needless to say, I dont put much stock into anything he produces because its always a biased narrative that omits facts so glaring and obvious that its infuriating. Werner Spitz who helped on the "Burke did it" CBS documentary also testified for Casey Anthony and made claims, yes claims that dogs mutilated the boys in the robin hood hills in West Memphis. Its ludicrous and cruel to the memory of those poor boys, off course later on other "experts" blamed snapping turtles and fish. We are getting the entire zoo here.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Co-signed. It should also be noted that Berlinger and his buddy are the ones who made the decision to open PL with the most graphic imagery of Stevie, Michael and Chris imaginable, without so much as asking any of the parents if they were okay with it (surely aware it would have been a resounding, unanimous "No!") Not just any parents of slain children, parents of slain children who had Berlinger and his buddy into their living rooms during the peak of their unimaginable grief, because they thought their participation might in some way help people in the future. Talk about demonic.

Julz XD

I know. That is just abhorrent of them, no wonder Pam walked out during the horrific spectacle. Seeing your own son murdured up close like that without warning is unbelievably cruel. The fact they got away with that is a crime in itself.

David McKinnon

I’m not particularly familiar with a lot of the details, but it seems to me that a problem with the BDI theory is that, if I understand correctly, the day this happened Burke was sent to a family friends house [without supervision from one of his parents?], and I don’t think the parents would take that risk if they knew he had done it.

Queen of Hearts

Thank you so much for going into how ridiculous BDI is, it frustrates me to no end how many people insist that BDI is the only logical conclusion when really it's the most illogical one. Why would the Ramseys spend decades being labeled pedophiles if it was an accident the whole time? It'd be really easy to just say the kids were roughhousing. As the younger sister of my family and having a similar age gap to my brother as JonBenet and Burke, my mom was absolutely convinced my brother was gonna accidently kill me. We definitely played rough, I remember one of the games we had where my brother would take the mattress half way off his bed, put the other half onto an old sofa so it formed a slope, and recreate Mufasa's death in The Lion King by flinging me off the mattress and onto the sofa. Kids are weird. Point is, I certainly got enough injuries (including once cracking my skull) to have first hand expertise in how easy it is for young boys to underestimate their strength or get a little wild. If it actually was just two kids being rough then it makes no sense not to just say that, and if he was some tiny psycho deliberately trying to hurt her then it's still easy as fuck to just say they were roughhousing

J. Anitra

do you think if we had bodycam footage when police arrived it would shed light on if the Ramseys were guilty of anything?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It would certainly be interesting to watch for behavioral cues, but my suspicion is if it existed it would wind up being as subjective and debated as anything else in the case.

W.D Taylor

YES if IDI is true, then we should have seen the perpetrator reoffend. Especially since they seem to have gotten away with their extremely messy first kill with no issues. Unless killing JB somehow scratched that itch permanently, but that doesn't hold up with established patterns.

Jeremio

My biggest problem with everything aside the RDI or BDI accident is how come nobody heard anything? Was this that big of a house so the sounds of: 1.. Entering the scene. 2. Going upstairs to kidnap the girl. 3.Bludgening JB to death. were muted? While your coverage of JDI and IDI is compelling, I really struggle to imagine anybody being able to do the did without any screams or comments from the girl herself. On the other hand, this alone could support a parent being the culprit, but I still truly doubt that nobody would take notice. Why would John be so confident of his plan not wakening up the familly? For that matter, why would the intruder be? Yet another puzzle..

Queen of Hearts

She was in the basement when it all went down while any family members not involved in the murder would have been several floors above her, so the sound wouldn’t have traveled

Emma

People say that house is very creaky/noisy, not sure if sound would carry that well or not. Patsy could have been dead asleep especially if she had drank enough, and Burke was just a kid.

Emma

I hadn’t heard the arguments for JDI before but wow that handwriting honestly spooked me. Even though handwriting is not exactly a science - it looks extremely similar both at a glance and in detail.

Emma

Good point about the DNA. JB was at a Christmas party with many other people and was likely playing with other kids, it’s reasonable to assume she got some DNA on her hands (snot, etc) & pulled her long-johns / underwear up and down from the sides when using the restroom. She may have touched other parts of her clothes that, later, she bled on. It is not a stretch at all.

Emma

The “male phrasing” argument, obviously BS, also doesn’t go against the theory that Patsy wrote the note while John was dictating it. So it’s unnecessary and a red herring overall.

Silentt

Late reply and sorry if already been brought up below. I think the fact that Patsy was wearing the same clothes as the night before, and still had her makeup on is a severe hindrance to my believing JDI. Bearing in mind the - admittedly surface level - things we know about Patsy, that seems blindingly out of character. In my opinion she never went to bed that night. Of course the points about the note and the injury are difficult to reconcile with Patsy being a clear cut culprit, but I don't think it unreasonable to say that IF Patsy truly did not go to bed on the 25th, that she was involved. Not an expert, so if I'm missing something please let me know. :)

nope not

the phrase MOCAS caught my attention - i thought you were saying marcus and got confused because your name is matt. i've been edging to your ads ever since, and the reacher one made me click through and join to unlock this banger ❤️

Queen of Hearts

Both of John’s favorite daughters are deceased so if there’s a pattern we’ll never know. As said in the video, he would have had a plan, the plan just got interrupted. It wasn’t his original plan for the house to be crawling with cops, his plan was to get Patsy and Burke out the way and use the ransom note as a cover for body disposal. The ransom note is so long both to scare Patsy and give himself a reason to be going somewhere secluded with a large bag to ~~dump his daughter’s body~~ ransom her

Wes G

Hey Matt, even though I am definitely in the PDI camp, I think this is an amazing addition to my favorite video by you (and in fact, my favorite video of all time.) I'd say I'm somewhere in the realm of 98-99% sure there was no intruder, and lean on it being Patsy somewhere to the tune of 60-85%. Something that goes well with your scenario, but I'm surprised that you didn't highlight quite as much as I would've thought, is that almost all of the medical experts seemed to be in agreement that JBR was being abused- At least, all of the medical experts who examined her up close post-mortem. I think because of this, I would put JBR's ongoing abuse as being a 95+% certain probability. In my view, it's not even worth considering if John or Patsy had a history of it, the bottom line is that it was almost certainly happening. The podcast podcast "A Normal Family: The JonBenet Ramsey Case Revisited" seems to advance the viewpoint that Patsy may have actually been the one responsible for the sexual abuse, and also includes a certain allegation from the housekeeper, which I really don't want to repeat. (To be fair, the housekeeper's unpublished memoir seems a bit unreliable at best. I definitely think it's interesting, though.) Another compelling point I've heard people bring up is that the abuse JBR sustained on the night of her murder (the paintbrush) may have been an unsuccessful attempt to cover up previous signs of abuse. The concept of "A Plan Interrupted" could also jell well with the PDI scenario put forth in the podcast. (Now I want to preface by saying I’m not sure how much overlap this has with Steve Thomas’ book, because even though I like him and broadly agree with him, I couldn’t get through the book as I thought it leaned a little heavy on the local politics side of things.) Anyways, the theory put forth in the podcast goes that Patsy killed JBR in a similar fashion to Thomas’ theory, then wrote the note as a way to control John into leaving the house and going to the bank to arrange the money, giving her enough to time to finish staging the scene as well as bringing JBR’s body out of the house. At some point in the morning, John woke up and Patsy had to pretend like she just saw the note for the first time. I think it's interesting because it's similar to the DocG Theory, except with Patsy as the mastermind instead of John. I'd say I find this scenario to be what I generally subscribe to the most. The podcast is pretty interesting and worth checking out if you haven't, although I do think it leans a bit too heavy on making a criminal profile of Patsy. I'd write more on this topic, but similarly to your video I fear that I'd veer off into too many rabbit holes and never stop typing. Cheers. Thanks for all your inspiring content.

Sharon Straker

I remember hearing/reading that the nylon cord could have been from patsy’s paintings. Used when framing to hang them on the wall.

Adam Berck

I think there is more to reason for intruder to write a note like that than being crazy. (I should say by crazy I mean erratic and without reason, child murdering puts you somewhere on the spectrum of insane). My favorite theory is JonBenet had a stalker who wanted to delay the police response as long as possible. This was to give as much space between him and the crime as possible. He doesn't know when the crime will be discovered and wants to give as much space as possible. In addition, he wants the crime to be looked to implicate kidnappers not a domestic predator. Thow off the scent as much as possible. Why the body is in the house at the end of this. My problems with DocG's theory and none of them are enough to rule him out is... John has written a note that implicates himself highly in a murder. He knows it will to some degree match his handwriting it was written in his house, and the whole reason for the note is so Patsy will not call the police. So instead of say... "waking up early" to find the note and telling Patsy about the note he leaves it to chance that she won't immediately call the police. It's the one case of the theory where John is not under much time pressure, but he does something that destroys his plan. And then the state of the body. To put is delicate as possible a person who's "been" with JB for a period, would have less motive to do something to the body. Whereas a stranger would have never been alone with JB before would want to do something like that. For me those issues (and I must admit the positive vibe check I get from John) are bigger than an intruder somehow getting in and out without leaving a sign in addition to the other issues with an Intruder theory.

Queen of Hearts

I just don’t see any world where a family as rich as the Ramsays wouldn’t be able to keep Burke out of trouble.

Queen of Hearts

Apologies for the necro-comment but I absolutely agree. I have thought for a while that the reason why she in particular would be because it seems like, due to her being born around the same time his original favorite child died, he projected a lot of emotions onto baby JB. He always speaks of her as being the one to comfort and care for him as though she were a grown woman and not a six year old. The older sister was a young, beautiful woman when she died. Taboo feelings for an adult daughter get transferred onto a significantly younger daughter who is constantly made to feel responsible for the emotional wellbeing of others around her, and it’s not hard to see how the poor girl might’ve ended up coerced into “making daddy happy”.

Luthen’s Reality

Ok am I crazy but guys there are THREE windows in the basement. I get that we assumed it was the broken one due to the briefcase being out of place underneath it but why are we saying that it couldn’t be any other of those windows?

Luthen’s Reality

Also, with the handwriting analysis, I think 2 things can be true at once; the handwriting matches patsy’s; also John could have written it BASED on her handwriting. He wanted to disguise his handwriting to PATSY. Patsy would know if he used his own handwriting pretty quickly I think; and assuming John never intended for the note to be viewed by police, all he had to do was make it not HIS handwriting to avoid suspicion (from patsy). Like you said, he probably meant to dispose of the note, or re-write it, or whatever. So, when writing the fake note, he wanted to adopt someone else’s style of writing. Whose would be accessible quickly and easily inside the house? His wife’s. All he needed was to avoid suspicion from HER (if his plan had gone correctly)

Hamble

I know right??

Emily

Matt, you really are brilliant and articulate. You're brilliant at weighing up the facts in the best, balanced way that you can. I would love to hear your thoughts on Madeleine Mcann but I wonder if this is an eye roll and you've been asked this a million times before. I also don't think it has the crazy shit like the JonBenet has but, if anyone has gone down the rabbit hole like I have, I find there's some very dodgy shit there and some real parallels between the two cases. Anyway, ace work sir! Hats off!

benlaorg

Regarding the randsome note. What always stood out to me is the whole theme, its written like someone from usa would think someone from the middle east would talk to an american.. its like its written to convince a housewife who watches national television that a bad middle eastern guy with a long black beard wrote it.. Like John would think Betsy would think someone like this would write.. you know what Im saying? Did you guys also ever notice that?

Queen of Hearts

I don’t see how, from John’s perspective, the note would implicate him. Like the video said, handwriting isn’t really that unique, and if the note is for Patsy’s eyes only then I don’t think he would be thinking about handwriting analysis at all. Besides that, he is still on a time crunch of needing to get at least the bare minimum done to prevent Patsy and Burke from suspecting him. He was in the shower when she got up and found the note, which would likely be him trying to get rid of blood, hair, urine, etc that could’ve gotten on him. I think he just felt confident in believing that Patsy would read the note all the way through instead of immediately going into a blind panic.

Richard Johnson

The most maddening (and genius) part to the original video was that every theory had a basis to it. But at the same time, there were giant hurdles to overcome to subscribe to that theory. This theory on John (while not seamless) really makes the most logical sense. It really answers any questions I had. The ransom note seemex My biggest hurdle would be a person (John) with no known assaults against children elevating to this level of misconduct? Not impossible, but would be a bit surprising if that’s the case.

SpergGurtDirt

I decided to listen to the Foreign Faction audiobook, since I found BDI to be the most interesting theory, and I’m surprised by how unconvincing the book was. I think it’s the first time I’ve come into something more convinced of what it wanted to theorized than when I finished…

roman

1:58:9 made my skin crawl

Andie Malone

Even the extra audio picked up on the 911 call makes more sense with the JDI theory. If what is heard is indeed “honey, what did you do?” as noted in the BDI theory, Patsy could be confronting John about what he did to be extorted.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good point! And I’ve never thought of the point that nothing about “honey, what did you do?” necessitates it’s being spoken to a child.

Jay

Big fan of your videos for a while, appreciate your in depth analysis. I do have to say that the "Jonbenet was just especially molestable" line of thought to explain why John wouldn't have molested his other kids shows a lack of knowledge about sexual predators and sexual assault. Sexual assault is rarely about attraction. It's about power over someone and opportunity. The JDI theory has never resonated with me because so much of it is vibes based and things that "could" have happened and doesn't account for so much of the other evidence. I also disagree heavily that a woman couldn't cause the skull fracture.

Lauren Goff

I work with kids and have personally known one of my five year old clients to jump on and strangle a sleeping classmate, as well as grope myself and female teachers. His imaginative play included sexual scenes and killing babies a lot. I have no doubt that if a kid like him were ignored and laughed off for long enough, he could at least try to do something like that to his sister on purpose—not that I don’t find Matt’s JDI argument here compelling.

Jessa Nather

seconded! would love to see Matt's take

KatieASMR

do you think maybe the intruder could have entered the house a day or multiple days before the christmas party and just hid for sometime?

Mjj

Only thing worse then being suspected as an incestues sex offender is having people know for sure your 10 years old son is one

Queen of Hearts

A. He was 9, it’s highly unlikely that he’d even be physically capable of doing that B. There’s zero evidence of Burke committing any crimes in the over three decades since the murder. If he got away with raping and murdering his sister at age nine, why would he just stop? C. Again, it makes way more fucking sense to frame it as roughhousing gone wrong than to make up a half assed excuse about kidnappers and do zero real staging. If all three of them are in on it then what’s the hurry to call the cops so soon? D. Do you seriously think a nine year old knows how to make a garrote? E. How come none of the fucking evidence points to him?

Queen of Hearts

Admittedly got exasperated towards the end. Not trying to be rude

Mjj

There is no doubt he did it . He confessed. At the same time he had hinted to several other people he was in a "relationship ' with an older woman . Sexual offences are notoriously hard to prove and Chris would have been hard to incarcerated. I dont think its a coincidence they kept him the maximum term of the offense in arrest (shockingly low) then booted him and called it a day

Steve

Long time listener but new Patreon subscriber. I’m a JBR junky , and this is great stuff and analysis —and I say that as someone who nonetheless remains BDI. I wanna just offer one theory in regards to the note (I hope you don’t address this later cuz I paused it to comment lol)—-I’ve came to believe the note’s contents speaks to an initial plan to leave the house and dispose of her body —a plan for whatever reason they scrapped . If that was the plan, everything in the note makes more sense (eg bring a large bag—this helps if he’s seen leaving the house with the body). Would be interested in your thoughts on that theory… Great work as always, appreciate ya! *Edit—So you kind of acknowledge that the note could have been go buy time/allow for an opportunity to dispose of the body, I guess the only difference is that I think that was John *and Patsy’s plan).

BrianC

Well done on trying to make your yt video unbiased, when i watched the original I never would have guessed John as your preferred theory. Particularly well done on resisting the temptation to add the section on John's handwriting into the yt video, I probably couldn't resist lobbing it in. The only quibbles I'd have is I wouldn't be so definitive to say Patsy would not have the strength to cause the fracture, I feel the margin of error in assessing the force needed could easily be the difference between a man and woman. Although it's definitely mad to assert Burke did it accidentally.

Trent McNoName

“War: What is it good for” of ransom notes.

Queen of Hearts

I’ve thought this too. If there was an intruder then it was absolutely an “I am inside your walls” phrogging thing. This MF was there and there for a long time.

Queen of Hearts

The problem is that BDI is nonsense built on ableism. There’s no evidence that Burke would have or could have been the one to kill Jon Benet, it’s all just “he makes faces that neurotypical people usually don’t, get him!!!” Like this kid supposedly learned at age nine that he can commit murder with zero consequences whatsoever and yet in the 30ish years since that night we haven’t heard about a single violent incident from him?? What’s the point of this garrote? Why shove a paintbrush up her vagina? Why make up a fucking kidnapping instead of just calling an ambulance and trying to save her? It makes no sense!!!!

Queen of Hearts

It’s not like rapists rape everyone. Every single theory out there is based on what “could” happen and has evidence it doesn’t account for.

V3NUS

Speaking to the theory that John possibly killed her—Patsy even said in one TV interview that quickly followed the murder, “She loved her daddy, she was a daddy’s girl.” So I think that makes an ever stronger case for him being able to easily get her out of bed and downstairs. Just a little thought.

Beastman

I love the level of detail, the control child in the documentary is too hench!

Kyra Hayes

I never understood why they didn't get the DNA of all the men at the Christmas party

Loren Kennedy

Just listened to this now after joining Patreon. It's the first ever time I've listened to Matt Orchard and experienced his interpretation as so far off. Describes the intruder theory as so far off and yet describes John as persuading Patsy to not call the police for their kidnapped daughter so he has time to "get rid of the body and and misplace the note." It's not difficult at all to visualise a sadistic paedofile sitting bored in the house and writing a long note with references constantly to movie lines. The ransom note is the biggest red herring. The intruder seems to know and hate John and knows his way around the house so quite possibly someone in their social circle who has had their eye on JonBenet.

Bailey Lohmann

The ending of your YouTube video still gets me emotional to this day. How necessary it is to see her as a person instead of a symbol of this crime and its cultural shockwaves.

Pia S

I am really glad you have advertised your patreon in your latest video with a sample. I basically never pay attention to plugs but since I saw that video all I do is binge watch your patreon posts.

Queen of Hearts

He didn’t say that intruder theory was far off, he said that he thought it was plausible. He spent like half an hour on that.

Joe Best-Rotheray

One thing I'll say is I've accidentally locked the back door when I was supposed to leave it open for my wife when she went out without keys. I could've sworn I didn't lock it, but I must've done it on autopilot..

Kristen Surya

hi! new subscriber making my way through your content. really, really enjoyed this addendum, as your original video is one of my favorites on this case and one that I actually point other people to when they need a "lay of the land." I generally agree with you on your broad strokes position that either JDI ALONE or IDI. I lean more IDI than you, though I do acknowledge that you've made a really compelling argument for JDI here, and I am thinking about it! Just a few things I want to note as to why, some of which you did touch on: 1) surprised you didn't get more into the forensics behind the petechial hemorrhaging. acknowledging that neither of us are experts, I will say forensic evidence is for me always the most compelling (maybe because I grew up in a medical household), but very surprised that it does not carry more weight for you. I follow a forensic pathologist and CSI on TT who has done a long breakdown of this case and why she is firmly IDI (her name is Amy Santoro) and I would LOVE to hear your takes on her takes and vice versa. in her breakdown she talks about how the presence of petechial hemorrhaging makes it essentially impossible for the strangulation to have been staging (which you do acknowledge!). 2) skimming through the comments, someone else already brought this up, but the doors things has never been a barrier for me in IDI. in a large house, especially in the 90s before we were tracking everything with ring cameras and whatnot, it's totally conceivable to me that someone would think they locked all the doors and checked them but actually didn't. I definitely agree that point of entry and exit is one of two places where doubt most easily enters with IDI (the other of course being the ransom note), but if it's not the basement window, I can easily see it being literally any door. related: a detail from the Cheshire murders case that stands out to me is the one about how one of those guys practiced breaking into people's houses without them noticing just to hear them breathe. in that scenario, a door doesn't even have to be unlocked. someone can get in and, as another commenter pointed out, hit a push button on the door to lock on the way out. I acknowledge we are dealing with some unknowns and ifs in this territory, but they don't feel totally "unreasonable" to me. 3) wondering also what you think about the pineapple as a red herring. because I follow Amy, I've now read the official autopsy report, and in her analysis of it she talks about how the material analyzed could have been any fruit, and it didn't have to have been eaten at 1:30 in the morning-- it could have been eaten as late as the white's Christmas party, for instance (where no one remembers pineapple being served, but let's not pretend rich people don't just have copious amounts of food available at all times). IF the material was definitively pineapple, and absolutely had to have been consumed no earlier than 1:30AM, I agree with you it's a problem, but I'm not sure that it is! Ok this comment is way too long, thank you again for your work!

Kristen Surya

also (sorry I keep making comments on a very old video but I wanted to add one more thing) re Linda Arndt: I don't trust a damn thing out of that woman's mouth lol. I've watched the whole of that interview she gave and not only does she sound kooky to me but I think it's a little rich for her to expect us to trust her instincts when she was at least partially responsible for one of the most epic mishandlings of a crime scene in American crime history. so yeah-- don't trust Linda's instincts for shit. which brings me to the point I return to often regarding this case, one that I'm genuinely so glad you handled so responsibly, which is that a lot of the suspicion around the Ramseys often begins with the fact that they lawyered up. and that is, in my opinion, completely unfounded and irresponsible if you believe our justice system has even an ounce of merit left. (arguable, I'll give you that, but all the same). I'm an attorney myself and it is, quite frankly, extremely disturbing to me to see how many Americans are ready to do away with what is arguably the most important part of our justice system: the presumption of innocence, and one's right to representation in defense of that presumption. I would even gone so far as to say RDI campers who use the ramseys' lawyering up as evidence of their guilt are closet conservatives (maybe some of them are open about it though lol). I think the way that the Ramseys have dealt with the police in this case is very unsettling and unfamiliar to white people, but for people of color (like myself) distrust of the cops and the system is very much part of the fabric of our lives, and one of the most interesting things about this case to me is that the Ramseys appear to begin their interactions with police with a certain amount of trust (e.g., calling the cops despite the contents of the note) that is common among wealthy white people, but had to secure appropriate counsel when they realize the system is not on their side. it's a pattern that literally happens all the time to people of color (call the cops only to have it bite you in the ass) but the prominence of this case and the fact that the Ramseys are both white and wealthy acts as a barrier for a lot of people to draw the connection. if it DOES turn out that IDI, then this case will serve as an example of exactly how badly American policing has failed.

Sam

Occam's razor- prefer the conclusion that requires the least amount of assumptions. Your explanation definitely requires less than the intruder theory, imo. It makes sense and all of it is super precidented, as opposed to said theory.

VibrantWeaver

JDI is really the only theory that aligns with all the material facts of the case (the manner of injury, hiding the body in a wine cellar, sexual assault, the ridiculous ransom note, the 911 call, etc). It also explains all the oddities in the ransom note, written by a rich white man, who's seen all the summer action blockbusters and is very familiar with genre tropes. Everything in the note that sounds so extremely weird suddenly makes sense: - "Do not talk to the police!" (over and over again) The note was just supposed to dupe Patsy, never to be seen by law enforcement. I'm sure John intended to 'lose' it later. - Addressing John directly, multiple times: Gives him sole control of the situation. The kidnappers want to talk to _him_ - "be rested" , "delivery will be exhausting": a stage direction giving John a reason to stay in the house alone while Patsy runs errands. "Patsy, can you go to the bank? Take Burke with you. I don't want him in this house right now." - "if we monitor you getting the money early, we might call you early.": The call might arrive at any convenient time, maybe just when Patsy is returning from the bank? Very easy to stage the subsequent phone conversation with the "kidnappers" that Patsy will not be privy to, or just enough to catch the tail-end of the conversation and a very distraught) While Patsy and Burke run errands John has enough time to stage the kidnapping, stow the body in the car, and pack a suitcase for Patsy ("I will take care of things, take Burke to the White's house. The kidnappers said I must come alone!"). This ofc giving John a whole day to stage the second crime scene away from the house, featuring a botched exchange and coming back empty handed, minus money and daughter, very very distraught.

Kathleen

I always found the line "make sure you being an adequate sized attache to the bank" in the random note confusing. This JDI theory explains it. He's going to have to go buy a large bag in order to move her body out of the house. That line in the ransom note is almost like John explaining to Patsy why he's about to make such a purchase (so he didn't look suspicious if she saw the purchase in their bank statement or something).

Andrew T

Unrelated: courier new font is great, looks like a typewriter

Andrew T

If John did do it I find it a bit surprising he’d be so interested in bringing it all back to light with the latest Netflix doc and I think I saw him on crime junkies too.. seemed like charmed the host from that show pretty good tbh. But yea I mean if he did do it he played it pretty good I thought and also why not just say no??

Andrew T

If so, why do you think he decided to do the Netflix doc? And I saw him do an interview w the lady from crime junkies who seemed to belive what he was saying from what I could tell (didn’t watch it all or even a good amount tbh). But if he did do it I find being eager to be in these high profile situations to be a little nonsensical.. and risky if he actually did do it…

Andrew T

If so, why do you think he decided to do the Netflix doc? And I saw him do an interview w the lady from crime junkies who seemed to belive what he was saying from what I could tell (didn’t watch it all or even a good amount tbh). But if he did do it I find being eager to be in these high profile situations to be a little nonsensical.. and risky if he actually did do it…

Koda Chimera

There are a few things I’d like to point out: for one, in the IDI scenario where the intruder enters earlier in the day through an unlocked door, I think there’s a definite possibility that they would have locked the door behind them to cover their tracks. If they came to hurt JonBenet they were clearly intending to be there for a long time, might as well get settled in, and provide the Ramsey’s with a false sense of security to boot. I also don’t think it would have been their first time in the house. When considering IDI theory I always picture someone who’s more of the stalker type who gets a kick out being places they’re not supposed to be and existing in peoples space without their knowledge. That’s part of the allure, to make the victim even more viscerally uncomfortable when they find out. Violating their space first, before escalating. Another factor mentioned in both IDI and JDI is “how did they get JonBenet out of bed?” And I think the more important factor was that she was out of bed at all. She could have gotten out of bed and downstairs herself for a midnight snack, then John or the intruder waiting in a nearby room could have heard her get up and go downstairs took that as an opportunity follow her down, away from the rest of the family, and strike. Maybe John followed her and fixed her a snack to draw her in before luring her into the basement. Maybe the intruder pitched himself as a family friend who’d stopped by to visit. Maybe he was already a familiar face to her, skulking around the neighborhood, or at pageants. Maybe JonBenet got out of bed herself and went to ask her father for a snack, her deep sleeping mother none the wiser. No matter how you slice it, it sucks. That poor girl deserves so much better. May she rest in peace and one day see the justice she so rightly deserves.

IrishRoo12

This was a fantastic follow up. One question I’ve always had regarding RDI or PDI, is the mention of Patsy being in full makeup and not having slept (because she was up all night staging). Is that an established fact or just conjecture?

Queen of Hearts

There’s just no putting that genie back in the bottle. It’s one of the most famous unsolved cases in American history, putting his head down and trying to ignore it just isn’t gonna work. Getting involved with podcasts and documentaries lets him control the narrative and sway people to his side.

Queen of Hearts

Gives him control of the narrative. The case is already high profile and has been for decades. After that stupid fucking TV special about Burke the Ramsey family became much, much more directly involved in documentaries and series about the case to prevent something like that from happening again.

G◇nSqu¤chn

Another reason Patsy may have ignored warning signs about the JDI theory, is due to how he fervently supported her amidst all of the media attacks against her.

Logan

Damn that's a crazy theory I love it

Laura Polley

Love your takes but I lean Patsy on this one. Always have. I believed she intended to kill, and premeditated the murder and the staged kidnapping. I believe she showed a pattern of sociopathic utilization and objectification of JonBenet, and also that she herself suffered from identity crisis and rage issues. She'd been likened to Jekyll and Hyde by a close friend. She was also fully in the grip (in my opinion) of a religious psychosis brought on by her full cure which she termed a miracle. Is it so farfetched to think she may have felt that God demanded a sacrifice in return? She may even have staged a crucifixion tableau, with loose bindings and a last supper of pineapple. Or she may have noticed John's devotion to his lost daughter Beth and hoped to bind him to her by creating a dark and twisted loss-in-common.

Melissa Anne

Do we know if they had any of those types of doors where you could lock the know on the inside, shut it, and it's locked from the outside? I'm assuming we'd know if they did. Plus the house is a very nice house and probably wouldn't have that type of door Just didn't know if that info was out there!

Eva Preuß

I have listened to this addendum the second time now and I really think that John writing the ransom note makes the most sense. I also think the odd sum of money mentioned in this plays a role. It's very small compared to the Ramsey's wealth so an intruder wouldn't be so modest about it, neither if they actually wanted the money nor if it was just a ruse to make this whole thing look like a kidnapping for money even if that was never the intention. Why not demand a round million if you don't get the money either way? My thought is that John actually planned to "pay" the money to keep up appearances. His daughter never is found, obviously, but the money is neither. In that case, the modest amount makes sense. It's literally a bonus, an amount John won't sorely miss, it doesn't make a dent into his wealth or his day to day dealings, he doesn't need to liquidate assets or anything. He can just take the check and sacrifice it for getting away with murder.

Margaret Graham

I just can't abandon the idea that Patsy was involved. Firstly: didn't she say she called the cops because John told her to? Also the ransom note is to me so clearly in her handwriting. The main differences with the samples seem down to one being written with a big Sharpie. I'm sorry, but Becky's theory doesn't make sense to me. I can tell the difference between my dad's handwriting vs. my mom's vs. my brother's vs. my husband's. There are way more than 50 handwriting styles out there. Also, Patsy is weird as hell: detached and performative. In her second interview, she refers to JonBenet as "that child" in a pure echo of Chris Watts. "I loved that child." She's also (paraphrasing) "appalled that anyone could think she and John committed such a heinous crime" -- really? That's what you're worried about, being perceived as criminals? Not horrified by the thought of causing unbearable suffering and fear for your child? She then says something like "There are only 2 people in the world who know what happened. The person who did this and whoever that person confided in." She then looks directly at her husband. Awfully specific right? The fact that everyone so readily believes that a father could molest and murder his daughter because he's male, but can't believe that a mother could come to hate her daughter out of jealousy or something -- that one is farfetched and not the other -- feels like a huge, sexist cultural blind spot to me.

Queen of Hearts

Respectfully, I think you’re misunderstanding things here. John claiming to have told Patsy to call comes way, way after the fact. There’s nothing to say that on the day of the event that’s what actually happened. Four people having different handwriting doesn’t invalidate the notion of there being 50 different types of handwriting. It’s really not unusual that two people would have similar handwriting. Handwriting analysis isn’t a hard science, neither is body language or speech analysis. Her being weird or saying things that come across as tone deaf isn’t proof of guilt. For everyone Chris Watts there are hundreds of completely innocent people who have been harassed and wrongly accused for sounding “cold” or “suspicious” in an interview, just look at Lindy Chamberlain. Patsy did it was a popular theory for decades. It doesn’t make anyone sexist to disagree with a theory that has been thoroughly discussed. The argument isn’t that John is a man, it’s that John is stronger than a nine year old and a cancer patient and that the structure of the ransom note is perfectly designed to give him an alibi and a foolproof body disposal plan.

Margaret Graham

I completely respect your opinion and thank you for sharing it with me. 🙂 I am actually a total n00b to this case and just sharing first impressions -- and to be clear I find all 3 of them weird and detached, I know cameras change a person but I feel like I've seen a lot of footage of people grieving. I lost my husband to an overdose about 15 years ago and it's hard to measure anything without comparing it to that barometer. Sorry for dropping that weight on you, I've had a weird night. But what I remember from that horrible time is a collapse. Physical and literal, like a push puppet. I don't understand this removed, Saltburn style of grief. Everything they say sounds like the dress rehearsal for a play about loss. So I don't know who to believe really, and it actually makes it harder for me to empathise with the victim I'm so sorry to say, because would she have also grown up to be like this? This artificial person performing feelings. I'm sorry. I know she was just a little kid. She deserved better all around.

Queen of Hearts

I get it, the case is absurdly complicated and has way more evidence, theories, and potential suspects than any one person can reasonably keep track of. As someone who is neurodivergent (meaning a person with a learning disability, mental handicap, or mental illness that causes me to think and react differently from the “norm”), I do get a little defensive when body language comes up since a lot of things people commonly think of as signs of guilt are also symptoms of ADHD, autism, PTSD, or other conditions. The Sandy Melgar episode is a good example of that. For any other suspect, suddenly blacking out and not being able to remember the window of time where the crime occurred despite being mobile and coherent would be just short of a confession. For Sandy, it’s not only completely believable but most likely the full and honest truth, because that’s how her seizure condition works. Not that I can claim to diagnose Patty with anything, I think more likely Matt is right and she either chose to stand by her man or spent the rest of her life in denial like Darlie’s family.

James

But then why did she ignore her own written instructions by not calling the police which in turn would give her ample time get rid of the body?

James

Which he’s always been about controlling the narrative. From the very beginning of getting him and his drugged wife on various news outlets to talk about it all before even talking to the police.

Laura Polley

It could be that the ransom note was intended as instructions for John to remove the body, and/or for him to leave the house to get the money so that she could remove or hide the body. I've always felt that John saw Patsy all over that note right away, never bought it for a second, and forced Patsy to call the police. She couldn't refuse without appearing even more guilty to John, and I think at that point she pivoted to convincing John it had been Burke and rallying John to help her protect their son.

Rochelle Nicholls

I’ve never had patreon for anything until yesterday

Rochelle Nicholls

ffs just wanted to say i enjoyed that immensely and thank you . I really needed a distraction as always you never let me down.

Brennen Balsamo

The note has always been my big sticking point with IDI. Though you laid out a decent explanation for it, I'm far more inclined to believe one of the RDI/BDI theories based on that alone. I have a hard time believing the presence of some sadistic, crazed pervert who broke-in in an exceedingly unlikely way, and then proceeded to basically write a short story to fuck with them in his own twisted game of mind-chess. All that, over the more elegant explanation...someone in that house is in hot water, desperately needs to COVER. THEIR. ASS. The note was a purposeful action. We're just not certain to what end. Another thing about the note that piques my curiosity, though it may not mean anything at all...what exactly is "S.B.T.C." supposed to mean? Obviously this "small foreign faction" doesn't exist, but those letters must have some kind of meaning to whoever wrote the note, right? Maybe something that could point us toward their identity? Or maybe they really did just choose some random letters to use as a fake abbreviation. Yet another strange detail that only has the same 50/50 chance of actually being relevant to the truth, like so many other things in this case. Also, as you pointed out, the whole idea of the mystery killer writing the note only works at all if they have those hours of time where the family is out. Otherwise, it becomes EVEN MORE insane and improbable, because unless they're getting off to the thrill of the danger or something, NO home intruder no matter HOW twisted is going to hang around to write the script for "Taken 2: Small Foreign Faction" and risk getting caught. On THEIR NOTEPAD no less!! It's just not happening. The note alone tells us SO much about this case by merely existing. If the Ramseys are indeed guilty, I think they stood a much better chance of getting away with it by NOT crafting such a convoluted story. They could've said simply said "someone broke in and kidnapped our daughter!" and left it at that, but the fact that they (potentially) wrote a note ON THEIR OWN NOTEPAD and left signs pointing to them was a huge mistake.

bebtheimp

the sailor bit convinced me at least 99% of the way