Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 508367002.mp4

Downloads

Content

Another Creator Commentary to tie you over! A little Wexler bonus at the end (1:14:52) for you cat enthusiasts :)

UPDATE [Full Black Screen Update at 1:05:55 ]:

So I mentioned last month that I was picking up the Karen Read case. Boy it’s been a slog to write, as anticipated. I still THINK getting it up here by the end of August is achievable, but that won’t be a cake walk, and will be dependent on the last stretch of writing I have left going smoothly. You can’t really cram writing, it’s done when it’s done!

But if we’re approaching end of August, and I can see it won’t quite be ready by month's end, I’ll post up here and let you all know what’s the haps. It won’t be way far past that point, I’m confident in that much 🙂

Thanks as always for your patience and support! 

Recommendations:

Heaven's Gate: The Cult of CultsHow To with John Wilson - How to Appreciate Wine

Files

Comments

Claire

Yay! Thanks Matt.

sammer

The point you were trying to make at the beginning has bothered me endlessly, because you are definitely almost there and I kind of got what you were saying. Maybe something like "This observation is completely shielded from any form of proof or disproof, as well as from any possible utility either in our personal lives nor even in an abstract sense of gaining understanding of any phenomenon external to this discourse. It is like the worst caricature of philosophy, but rather than being masturbatorily dense, it is quite facile while being delivered and received in a way where the speaker is taking credit for displaying incredible intellectual virtuosity and worldly wisdom. " Is I guess how I would try to say it. But that's pretty comma-ridden and incomprehensible so I dunno.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Could do with some tightening, yeah, but I think you’re getting there! A very hard to articulate point as you have now experienced for yourself!

sammer

Yeah it is hard to phrase any objection to it, and it's basically impossible to phrase any critique in a way that won't sound like drivel to somebody who respects these teachings.

Joe Shea

I would just describe what Keith said as "pseudo intellectual nonsense". Like there is a point he's making, but he bloats it with an unnecessary amount of words like he's trying to hit a word count on a college essay, while dropping things like Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle to make him appear sophisticated and knowledgeable, which serves to boost his credibility as a (cult) leader. It also serves to make his point sound deeper than it actually is. I think you still articulated your thoughts well, but this is just my attempt at being more concise.

Shane King

The replacement words for kill yourself/suicide/killed/etc. come more from tiktok where I think those words are heavily filtered or will limit your range. They also spread to instagram, where I think maybe? But also people copy/paste from tiktok to instagram a lot. Then YouTube culture kind of adopted it just in case, I guess 🤷‍♂️

sammer

I would definitely categorize his statements as such!

nate

Let’s goooo Matt posted, time to lock in at work!!!

cool_ranch

true crime yadda yadda I'm here for Wex

PityTheHateful

I had a Tim Minchin lyric in mind throughout this conversation. And I interpreted your meaning as, "How many words does he spew to pretend to say something, whilst saying nothing of value, and how smug does that nonsense make them." Here's the quote from "Storm" " ... keeps firing off clichés with startling precision Like a sniper using bollocks for ammunition."

Mel T.

Yay, one of my faves! I also highly recommend the Heaven's Gate - Cult of Cults series. It's seriously heartbreaking hearing the interviews from some of the cult members' children.

Elisa Villou

Had to jump straight to the Wex play sesh, although The Weird World of Cults is among my favourite MOCAS vids ! The feline update we’ve all been waiting for. Thanks !

Gizmo

My cat is also kinda peculiar. He won't lay on the floor itself, he prefers to lay on a rug or a flat piece of cardboard or anything except the floor. He also won't touch anything that's pillow like either. He doesn't like fish flavored foods or soft treats, only crunchy treats and chicken flavored things are his favorite. He only sometimes likes to play with feather ended wands where the feathers are attached to a string in the end of the wand, also he likes one single toy mouse. It's the only one I've ever found that he likes, it's small, made of white canvas, it has 2 rounded leather ears all d a thin leather tail. Every other mouse he hates and I think it's a material thing.

Claire

It's very 'guy at house party with guitar'-coded 😅

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Like I said in the commentary, a far better solution would have been to just drop that point all together, open on that authenticity spiel and Alison's doe eyed response to it, then give a small spiel along the lines of, "how could this attractive young lady be so enamored with nonsense?" and jump in from there. Oh well, you live and you learn!

AR

the difficulty in cutting through the obfuscation around this gobbledygook is why cult leaders are so effective. if their level of confident nonsense (mixed with mundane self-help/new age observations) were easy for the average person to undercut, they wouldn't be able to hook so many followers.

Timothy Lane

Take your time on Karen Read! Quality over quantity, and I'm loving the commentary just as much as the regular vids. Quick question, have you ever considered a video on Lori Daybell? Very interesting case though not as open ended conclusion as most of your videos.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yup, don't know much about it, but I know there's definitely an interesting story in it, and there's plenty of raw footage and so forth associated, so it is on the "one day or another" list. Tbf, I've made quite a lot of not open ended vids at this point, so it's no kind of prerequisite that there needs to be mystery in the conclusion :)

Claire

Hey nice Mighty haha

Devon

I watched Smallville all through high school so it was personally devastating to see what became of Allison Mack when I saw she was involved in this absolutely batshit cult 😬

Samuel Hayden

This is one of my fav vids, thanks for the interesting commentary. This is also one of the first videos I recommend to friends who aren’t really into ‘true crime’ in the fullest sense. This, alongside you’re more political/cultural videos, make for a good ‘first fix’ as it were.

marrow

honestly i’d still love to see your take on a deep dive into the heaven’s gate stuff, for what it’s worth

Allie

Watching Allison Mack's interactions with Raniere was soo cringe it was difficult to watch. Also to those 20% who think they understand what he's trying to articulate.... cmon. The guy starts and doesn't finish 6 thoughts and never makes a point. This reminds me so much of that Scientology video with Tom Cruise that got leaked. Just saying words!

Stephen Hoyle

I think it’s moreso that Matt directly challenges the viewer beforehand. I feel like if the ‘there’s gonna be a quiz after this’ comment wasn’t given, more people would be more likely to concede that yeah, this guy’s just spouting a series of non-sequiturs.

Jenifer Joseph

I actually really like how the first 5 minutes highlights your point. Because yes, if you pay attention you can understand what he says, but it doesn't matter because it's so insubstantial and the real meat of the video is just how he's completely captured the attention of this woman with nonsense. I agree there is no one singular understanding for how smart educated people fall for cults, but I've always thought that in broad strokes it comes from the desire to belong. Even smart people feel lonely and want to be a part of something better. Cults take that promise and twist it and you into a quasimodo of what your ideals once stood for. It's essentially an abusive partner dynamic but instead of one person it's an entire community.

Julz XD

I like thrse commentaries of yours. Now I know it's morbid but it would be funny to see your commentary on Susan Monicas statements in the video you made. I mean Susan is a case study alone. Im only stufying child and adolescent psychology but damn, Susan is a very fascinating hilarious yet im somewhat perplexed by the sheer lunacy of her actions not to mention the murder of two poor men.

Julz XD

Yeah I know. I really liked her character Chloe in Smallville too and she's so evil in realife6

Cronker Waltite

Hey Matt what’s your next vid gonna cover??

sammer

Exactly! Criticizing his gobbledygook somehow seems more incoherent than the gobbledygook itself!

Ann Silberman

Wex is adorable! Do I feel sorry for Allison Mack? I do for the beginning of her involvement. Like many actresses, she’s empty and needs to fill her dead spaces with something. I guess acting wasn’t enough. When she turned it into control of others my sympathy vanished. I’ve been the only person in the US who didn’t care about Karen Reed. I saw the 20/20 but otherwise am uninformed. But that makes me excited for what you are going to put out. Going in knowing little is often better on these kinds of cases. Take your time. Cheers.

Michelle (B)

I in fact would rate this in at least the top 10, if not the top five. I love this one so very much

humdinger

Just before you described the intro cult session experience as resembling a "first high," I found myself wondering if any of these people had ever taken a puff of grass. They all look like a bunch of squares. If the cult leader looked like Morpheus wearing cool sunglasses with a bag of candy colored pills, i could understand the appeal. Or even if he looked like Charles Manson but had some of that really mind blowing stuff. It's been said you can only be hypnotized if you want to be hypnotized. Here, I just see people who want to be hypnotized. All you have to do is keep telling them what they want to hear and they'll follow your command, vote for you again, etc.

Jenifer Joseph

Hey there's a lot of pretty negative comments I'm seeing on your Karen Read video. Just posting this to let you know during your creator commentary it might be a good idea to address why you didn't include certain defense arguments, why you think she's guilty, etc.

Rusty Shackleford

Posting this here because I'm just a $2 patron, but I agree, I'd like to hear more of your thoughts about the Karen Read case. I was unfamiliar with the case before your video, but friends of mine who kept up with the trial disagree with your take, so I'd like to find out more. Thanks, love your videos.

Allie

Just a reminder: even the vids you wouldnt consider your top 10 have an impact. The specific cult characteristics you highlighted (especially the "first fix" got me thinking. Then I had my husband watch. We got to talking and realized we had personal or second hand close encounters with 3 quazi MLM type cults in our area. Always got the heebie jeebies from them but couldn't say why, but this video spelled out exactly why. Glad we trusted our guts. This is a stellar vid & a personal standout for both me and my husband!

Jonathan Gill

I definitely can't speak for what Matt should or should not include in the video. I found this blog a very compelling summary of the case (note it's not short). It does argue, quite forcefully, that Read is guilty, so it's certainly not a perspective that the critics of Matt's video would endorse. But I found it very insightful: https://anonymasslawyer.substack.com/p/yes-karen-read-did-it

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Jonathan, if I could give you a double like, I would. I also stumbled across that post during my time on this and it is an absolutely excellent, well written, concise, and as thorough as reasonably possible breakdown of the case against Read. A little tip for those who would struggle to read it in one sitting (I certainly can't) if you copy paste it into a google doc, download it is a pdf, and then send it to a kindle account (you basically just need an amazon, account, give it a google) you can read it either on a kindle, or on the kindle app through your phone/tablet at your own leisure as if it were an ebook. I am actually, probably against my better judgment, working on a rather long addendum to the Read video. It will be available to all Patrons, hopefully by the end of the month :)

Merglo Mclaughlin

This vid is one of my personal faves even if its not in your top ten. Cults are weirdly fascinating!

SpergGurtDirt

My partner and I were thinking about how to separate cults from organized religion, and I came up with something like this: Organized religious entities tend to expect you to give something (money, time, etc) to be considered involved in the congregation, but they only expect very few (think “youth pastors” or pastors themselves) to “give it all.” Mainstream religions with real staying power won’t demand you work for free for 40+ hours a week, give up your property, or your personal freedom (in meaningful ways). Cults do expect everyone involved to “give it all.” That’s why they can expect their congregants to drink the kool-aid (or in heavens gates case, eat the pudding), because they’re already used to “giving it all.” Probably also imperfect, but this was my thinking.

Eli

Yeah I followed your point in the first bit of the video. I thought what all tied it together was “imagine if a friend walked in and asked you to tell them what the video was about, what would you say?” Because I don’t know if most people really could. Bro was just endlessly pondering things.

Tearyawna

So I have a theory about the 1975 Heaven's Gate meeting in Waldport, Oregon and why such a significant number of people joined (older coastal residents will still bring it up). Let me preface this saying this is part anecdotal ( I grew up in the western part of Oregon) and speculation. Historically speaking, the west coast, particularly California but also Oregon and Washington, were and are still somewhat, fertile breeding grounds for alternative religions and lifestyles. The motto for our major city is, "Keep Portland Weird" and just general oddities tend to be celebrated. I know this does not speak much to the psychological answer you're pondering about but from a cultural and social perspective, I am not too surprised that many Oregonians (albeit in a “small” group size of 200) jumped on board with Heaven's Gate right away.

Shakespearerabbit

Matt, this was one of my favorite videos. I’ve watched it many times. I think it was worth it to hammer home that point at the beginning you thought was overlong, where you really break apart and show the inner workings of how Raniere gives the impression of being profound when there’s no “there there”. Plus… you know we like long form. I’m glad there’s some awkwardness baked in, that’s a necessary thing. It’s awkward because it’s exposing the conversation that’s being had as… wildly awkward! But without your walkthrough of how the sausage is made, his dumbass disquisition might have just slid by to some, seeming debonaire or deep. I haven’t seen the cult leader “patter” explained so well anywhere else. You chose great examples. “It increases one’s knowingness” 😂 I was asked as a favor to a friend to produce a project with and “manage” a B grade guru type who spoke exactly like that. The high flying idea salad designed to impress. But then… the underhanded insults meant to bring to heel someone who he sensed wasn’t taken in by him. Needless to say, he did not like being managed and I was removed from the project. His psychology was fascinating.