Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 541644849.mp4

Downloads

Content

Rejoice or Despair, An Addendum to the Karen Read video is here!

Like I say at the outset, there’s a very good case to make for leaving it alone, and for those of you who would have preferred that course of action, I get it and PROMISE this is it. On that, I will say, for me personally, it was just what the doctor ordered, because now I have gotten out all the main stuff I had to leave on the floor for the main vid, I do feel fully unburdened by the case and like I can really take on something else completely fresh.

Also like I say in the addendum, I will be doing my best to get back to comments and challenges as best I can for a while between reading up on what’s next, so you can count my replies in the comment section as the last extension on the extension before I’m well and truly 100% done for good. For those of you who just can’t find your way to seeing eye to eye with me on this, hey, no hard feelings, it’s bound to happen sometimes :)

CONTENTS:

00:00:00 - Preamble on Why I Probably Shouldn’t Do This

00:03:32 - Hazards of Arguing Against “Scattershot Theories”

00:08:16 - Weighing All Evidence Equally

00:10:09 - Re-emphasizing the Digital Forensics

00:14:09 - Preamble to Ian Whiffin’s Cross/How I Got Knocked Off the Fence

00:19:29 - Ian Whiffin’s Cross

00:34:40 - A Deeper Look at Karen’s Tail Light

00:44:34 - The Redundant Issue of Inverted Sallyport Video

00:46:59 - Broad Discussion of Corruption

00:53:19 - Preamble on SCIENCE/Deferring to Lab Coats

00:57:01 - The Basic Prosecution/Defense Theories of How John Died

00:58:47 - The Not-Especially-Counter-Intuitive Physics of the “Clipping” Proposition 

01:04:13 - Findings of CWs Medical Examiner

01:10:01 - Kelly Dever Preamble

01:11:53 - Kelly Dever’s Testimony

01:23:44 - Summary of Kelly Dever/False Memories

01:35:04 - Perception/Reality Gap and LawTube

01:48:16 - Preamble to “Other Shit”/Volume Over Substance

01:53:33 - Albert’s Didn’t Leave the House

01:54:56 - Albert’s Ripped Up The Floors/ Sold The House

01:59:21 - Missing Ring Camera Video

02:05:37 - The Two Brians “Destroying” Their Phones

02:08:48 - Brian Albert “Destroying” His Phone Continued: Never Assist an Adversary

02:14:09 - Corrupt Governments Vs. Skeevy Defense Lawyers

02:17:31 - Closing Thoughts on Balance and Fairness  

Links:

Kelly Dever Full Testimony: https://youtu.be/DhFPEYjBABc

The Don’t Talk To Police (ever, at all) talk I mentioned in passing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE

Files

Comments

Dom

Eeeee, you've made my very late night. Sending love from California. Looks like I'm not going to sleep yet

Tianna C

just in time to fall asleep to!

SP

Thanks, from a fellow kiwi! You have such a melodic naration :)

Dom

I'll will reluctantly heed your advice :) Cheers!

ChiralSpiral

Love these addendum videos. I knew nothing at all about this case prior to watching your initial video, so I’ll go into this with a fully open mind.

AR

i can't watch for a day or two but i'm SO excited about this even though i expect to emphatically disagree with all your well made points haha

Bonnie

I’ll rejoice at any new video from you!! Just in time for my shift as well! Lots of love from Ireland to one of my fav kiwis 🩷

Rob

As someone from the Boston area ive heard so much about this case, and the general concensus was she was guilty as fuck. I know people that followed the case live & publicly campaigned against her on youtube. To me it was confusing as hell. Yours has been the best coverage I've seen.

Andy

Ah - I'm so glad I am still pondering my response to the original content as I might have had to labour over my own addendum. I'll say thanks in advance for this - whatever happens in the next couple of hours. Might return early in 2026 when I'm (almost) happy with my thoughts! Much love from Edinburgh.

Alan Holding

Just finished watching and I was already in agreement with the points in the main video, so I didn't need any more convincing but this was a great watch. Maybe one day the words "in kick dee" will stop floating around in my brain like an annoying screensaver. I think the whole memory thing is difficult to explain to people who've never experienced it. Like, my dad, he'll claim to remember things I've said or done, insist on it, until I realise he's conflating the opposite to a thing I did say and something he heard in an episode of Eastenders. He's a smart person usually but the whole idea of false memories is an alien concept to him and gets really annoyed when contradicted, so I can understand the general public having doubts. The other thing I thought about while watching this is the money side you mentioned regarding lawtube. It got me wondering whether this whole FKR movement was a grassroots thing or something the defense cooked up and paid for and led the more gullible people who always need something to get vocal about involved in the campaign. I will now take my conspiracy hat off and go have lunch! Keep up the good work Matt!

Matthew Thayer

It blows my mind that you brought up the Michael Peterson case, because I made a discovery recently that tied into that case, and I was going to talk about it, regardless. In the U.S. show Forensic Files, S8 E8, titled "All Wet," features the case of Tim Boskowski. His first wife dies in a suspicious, "accidental drowning," and, 4 years later, his second wife suffered the exact same fate. The coroner ruled the cause of death of the first wife undetermined, despite her strong suspicions of homicide, and the man's next wife dies in an extremely similar fashion not long after. He was ultimately convicted. That coroner was Deborah Radisch; the same coroner who performed the autopsy in the Michael Peterson case, and took the highly unusual step of flying to Germany to perform an autopsy on the body of a woman who died under circumstances that were suspiciously similar to those of the woman whose death was under investigation. This woman rules a woman's death, "undetermined," and another woman arguably dies as a result(they talk about that aspect in the episode). Later, she finds a woman who supposedly died in an accident, but it's deeply suspicious, and another woman connected to him died in a strikingly similar way, and it was ruled an accident. She goes back and rules that the original death a homicide. If it was fictional, you'd call bullshit. Maybe you already knew that, but it blew my fucking mind. Thematically, I think it plays into the fact that people in every part of the criminal justice system have prejudices and are shaped by their experiences, no matter how professional they may be. Like, you can't exactly argue to a court that she's impartial as an examiner in that case because of that experience, but you'll never convince me that she was objective after what happened to her the first time.

Liz

See I thought I was part of the larger group. The one that believes she probably did hit him but the commonwealth fumbled the first trial. The group that knows there’s a difference between innocent and not guilty. The burden of proof has to be on the prosecution and that proof has to be beyond a reasonable doubt. But by the time of the second trial, I think the initial doubts were quelled. A mistrial is rarely good for the defense. The prosecution knew where the defense was going to go and navigated around that fairly well. The initial shock of the Proctor stuff wore off by the second trial. All those what if questions had answers. But then I realized I was in a smaller group than I originally thought. There was such a large FKR community that truly believed she was innocent and that was a bit surprising to me. I appreciate the addendum, I appreciate all your content.

Liz

Follow up: I do think there’s a real possibility that she didn’t hit him and he didn’t go inside. If he slipped and fell all on his own, maybe due to being startled by her maneuvers with the car, he still could’ve hit his head hard enough to kill him and not show any signs of being struck by a vehicle. Maybe you cover this and I’m getting ahead of myself but my belief has always been that either she hit him or he fell. And I was surprised the defense never leaned into that. She’s not guilty if he fell all on his own. Why did they never bring that up? Am I missing some blatant piece of evidence?

Samuel Stewart

Outrageous! egregious! ridiculous! Great work as always :)

Yes Way Ted!

I can’t wait to get home from work to watch! Thank you, in advance.

SpergGurtDirt

Always love these big addendum videos! One question that I have on your personal opinion - do you think Karen meant to kill John? Or that it was an honest to god accident that she let spiral into this ridiculous conspiracy theory so she could keep out of prison?

Kaz

I know someone who is DEEP into true crime content much in the same way that FKR people are. She is a huge FKR person herself and the way you dissect the community vibe around it is spot on! She was also hugely into the Delphi Murders case and was convinced that it was a cover up, any time I mentioned solid evidence that the prosecution brought up I was met with "But what about the sticks on the bodies! And the kid who was into the occult!" Like yeah, it's a shitty attempt at covering up the bodies and sure some weird kid is into occult stuff?

Kevin Fox

Love your videos! Around 42 mins you talk about the snow on the tail lights and IMO that could absolutely be from natural snowfall. Snow falls at an angle and usually from a single direction. If the direction of snowfall was towards the side of the car with the broken light, then it would look just like the photo! 1. broken light side gets direct snowfall and is completely covered 2. the back lights get some on the top because that is the only angle the snow can hit. The sides are not hit because the snow is not directly hitting them. 3. the non broken tail lights gets no snow because it is essentially obscured by the car’s roof. If you think of the snow as light casting a shadow it may make more sense. how one can be fully light and the other in complete shadow.

Christian

these addenda - all two of them - are among your best work. they may not have the mass appeal of your polished youtube videos, but they’re extremely intellectually compelling, regardless of whether i agree or not. maybe you explore the format further.

Sarah Tomas

I shamefully have to admit it took me way too long to realize Matt was saying "lawtube" not "loretube". I was sitting here like "what the hell does a 10 hour deep dive into the gods of the Conan universe have to do with this ..."

nebulazer

poor John - what an awful way to die. hope that no-ass bitch rots 🙏

A

Speak a lil Chinese for them, Matt

PityTheHateful

I'm still where I've been all along and that's both she did it (reasonable doubt standard) but they never had a good case for those charges. And that weak case was made substantially worse by the behavior of almost everyone involved in the investigation.

PityTheHateful

The false memory part is fascinating to me. Primarily because the consensus is that it's absolutely real and the utter disbelief the legal system normally holds for anyone who makes a mistake. It's inevitably treated like a change to hide some degree of guilt in something. Getting it wrong without malice just doesn't get that grace unless it's law enforcement.

Jonathan Gill

A scenario where a drunken John just falls and hits his head near the flagpole doesn't account for all the lacerations on his arm. He didn't die from his lacerations but they were surely involved in whatever event killed him. And bits of taillight were found in John's sweater. Either you have to believe Karen hit John with the suv, or that the police later on launched a coverup where they were planting microscopic evidence.

Liz

I don’t have to believe either of those 100%.

Jonathan Gill

I get why it fault unnecessary, but I'm very glad for the addendum. It's the sort of case that lends itself quite well to these additional discussions. Before watching the main video, I knew zilch about the case. But the video was enthralling, and it sent me down the rabbit hole of online Karen Read discussion. With this addendum, I'm glad you touched on Lawtube and the sort of echo chamber that can be built up around this case. In the very comments of your main video, I saw several commenters swear that you'd have a very different impression if you "watched the whole trial" and then recommend several Lawtubers for their presumably exhaustive coverage. I followed up one of those recommendations, watched about 10 minutes of the Youtuber, and well it sucked. The Lawtuber was oddly snarky over extremely banal moments. I completely know the vibe when you mention how these circles might put "false memory" in scare quotes, and act like it's some major sign of a coverup. In the very short amount of time I was watching this Lawtube video, he was being snarky about Commonwealth expert witness Dr. Welcher saying something about "better data coming in". (I do actually have a question on this below). But for me, hearing a physics nerd talk about "better data" was about as shocking as a kid asking for a bowl of vanilla ice cream. But, no, watching this genre of Youtube I'm supposed to believe "better data" means "data that makes it easier for me to shill the story the prosecution wants, mwah ha ha ha". Actual question, and honestly it's not one I care all that much about, so if the details are murky for your recollection, don't bother. There was some quibble over Burgess changing his time estimate regarding the Lexus clock, and if I got the gist of it, the defense was upset the prosecution only got this timing change in right before the trial, something to that effect. So my question is: if they'd had access to the cell phone data and Lexus vehicle data for a while, why didn't they determine the actual time difference between the two much earlier on? That timing seems crucial to the prosecution.

Jonathan Gill

I know I've written to much, but to followup my own comment a bit more: Alesssi's cross-examinations were such nothingburgers. When examining Whiffin, he questioned something to the effect, "but [the other data forensic company's] tools still show the timestamp?" He was clearly setting up the (absurd) narrative that Whiffin's company changed their software reporting on behalf of the prosecution coverup, but other forensics would demonstrate the truth of the timestamp. Only for Brennan to call in the woman from the other company, who agreed with Whiffin's analysis. So Alessi is succeeding in the realm of theatre--making these non-narratives sound damning just by giving them a lot of inflection. And the online FKR movement swallows it whole. It's weird to see how much faith they have in this lawyer. Oh and I was shocked to see that clip of Jackson promising that the phone data "unequivocally" shows John going into the house. I know lawyers are pretty unscrupulous people, in the main, but the overpromising was shocking. And I have to imagine that deep down he knows just how flimsy the case is, at least in regard to the phone evidence.

E

Gonna swoop in here real quick to ask: would you consider making an addendum to the West Memphis 3 video? It's my favourite of yours and I would love to know your personal take on the case!

Ty P

Let me present my strongest against Matt. Did you notice how often Matt said Commonwealth? He said it quite often, didn't he? Did you know that Matt has also spent his entire life in a Commonwealth?!! Coincidence?! Ok but seriously, this seems like a cluster problem. Cluster problems occur when a sample is taken from group that differs for some reason from the general population, simply put. Matt is from New Zealand. The trial happened in a certain part of the US. There is a significant difference in perception. Trust in the police is probably at an all time low, especially in that region. There was actually a corruption case in Boston in 2024, involving several police officers. Then there is the fact that misogyny and incompetence were certainly a part of the investigation. On top, there is broad and growing distrust of science and expert opinion in the US. That and a few other aspects probably produced the verdict. To me it sounds like Read was drunk, maybe thought she hit the flagpole and drove off. Only later realizing what happened.

Ty P

Of course, I write my stupid little opinion 10min before the end and Matt starts talking about bias. Almost getting into a relativistic argument only to then backtrack and says something along the line of "Well, everybody is biased as am I but I am fair." Ok, full disclosure, I'm not a social constructivist but I think it has some merit in some areas. The law and court proceedings being one of them. Matt's argument sounds like what Americans call "eating your cake and having it, too." Everybody is biased. Yes. To be fair, you have to work along certain principles, standards and acknowledge your bias. Did Matt do this? In other words, has he made sure that his work is produced along well thought out guidelines to limit his personal bias? Is that maybe too much to ask of a content creator? i don't know.

nope not

imo, karen read is OJ for white people. this verdict is going to heal american race relations

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think a good majority of people have had the experience of having a memory they were damn near certain of disproved...or at least disputed by someone equally certain, and with equal claim to being in a position to know. Yet it will still bug us out when it happens, and I'm no exception. The Mandela Effect is basically this. Either you accept it was always "Berenstain" or you adopt the position we're shifting between parallel universes - and hell, I'm prone to be tempted by such kookiness, but come on, if we're being honest, it's by far more likely the former. It's pretty well established that Karen and her defense made conscious efforts to get their "alternative narrative" out via unscrupulous local commentators and other internet personalities - Turtleboy being the earliest and chief example. The precise mechanics of it may be disputable, but I think it's pretty obvious the FKR movement didn't develop fully organically. There's drama brewing right now over leaked recordings of KR and TB phone calls (shit never ends) and you don't have to read too much between the lines of those to get they've been feeding him information basically from the start.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I did not know about that, no! FWIW, My ultimate takeaway of Deborah Radisch on the stand was that she was pretty darn reasonable. I'd need to go back to even decide exactly how over her skis I think she was with her finding on Ratliff - all I can say for sure right now is it at least *seems* pretty fucking bold! In general though, I thought she was impressive and by and large fair. She didn't really fight Rudolf on Kathleen's injuries being notably anomalous, just held firm that they were not irreconcilable with a bludgeoning, because...well you just never know really. Totally fair, and totally frustrating! MP is such a good case because it's one of those uber divisive ones where there are ACTUALLY genuinely strange things, as opposed to things that are blown out of proportion to seem strange (cough, Karen, cough). All I'm 100% sure of is Kathleen didn't sustain all her injuries by falling. Sensibly speaking, that should really only leave you with anomalous bludgeoning as an explanation, but it's so deeply unsatisfying. RIP Kathleen :(

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Cheers Liz! It's often said trials are won and lost in jury selection, and I think this is an example of that. The Defense didn't win by establishing reasonable doubt in the courtroom, they won by establishing their narrative in the minds of the public to an extent that finding 12 people who could truly look at the case with fresh, impartial eyes was probably impossible from the outset. Some may call it sour grapes, and I usually try to refrain from blaming the jury when I don't like the outcome, but...I mean anyone who can look at the scene outside that courtroom and not see how it could be problematic is just BSing imo!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Na, a natural fall isn't workable with the final scene: skull fracture, shoe off, multiple arm lacerations (as Jonathan mentions) - and more circumstances I could go in to, but that's more than enough to establish John didn't just fall down. It's also not exactly true that John showed no signs of being struck by a vehicle - it's just that typical vehicle impact injuries (leg bruising/cuts for instance) were absent, because it was an a-typical vehicle impact (a side-swipe). I contend (as do the prosecution and all other "Antis") that John's arm injuries are perfectly compatible with that taillight smashing over it, though some cuts and scrapes could also have been incurred when he hit the ground. Those injuries I'm sure aren't *solely* consistent with *only* such a scenario, but it's far from uncommon for an ME to not be able to attribute injuries like that to one explanation only. Also important to remember you should never try to establish what happened to someone using medical findings alone unless you literally only have those. The broken tail light around John's body is a *gigantic* sign he was struck by a vehicle, and is every bit as valid as any medical finding.

nope not

&now that i've finished watching: i appreciated this addendum quite a bit. the tail light evidence was the most influential piece of evidence that the main video presented. i hadn't consumed anything that dealt directly with the case prior to the main video, and any existing opinion (mild as to hardly be called "existing") was formed around evidence presented in youtube comments and accepted based on my cynicism toward american police. in passing, it'd seemed as though the prosecution had represented the collision as intentional and done out of anger, but a drunken accident that knocked him out and left him to freeze to death is infinitely more plausible than either "story". identical fibers on his clothing indicates that there was some kind of forceful contact, and given that he was drunk, it wouldn't have taken a lot to knock him down. from there, maybe injury, maybe resignation, maybe drunkenness sufficient to make him think it was a good idea to take a damn nap - the most plausible results are those that could cause death in that weather and on that terrain. and then there's the black box data, and the watch data to compound a fairly indisputable fact. the prosecution absolutely had the harder battle. proving intention to harm is a huge leap from carelessness, and intention to kill even more so. all that, and they've gotta compete with unscrupulous men in suits. I'd really been left with the impression that the defense succeeded on confusion - all that misdirection, obfuscation, and overcomplicating was bound to confuse at least one juror as to their right or left. the alternate scenario was absolutely ridiculous, but their sticking with it required that it be addressed, adding additional possibilities that, even if ridiculous upon inspection, are liable to create reasonable doubt unless addressed.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks for asking! Ya know, there's so many distractions in this case, I barely ever get time to even *think* about the most likely specific scenario, something that's usually a top priority in just about any (contentious) case. Because of that, you should take any opinion I have on the matter with a grain of salt because, again, I never actually have found the time to properly consider what the evidence most likely points to when it comes to things like Karen's state of mind and how things actually unfolded. My best guess: I don't believe Karen consciously decided to kill John, and in fact lean toward she never intended to hit him. It being an impact with only the side of her car seems to speak to that: if it was more of a conscious "I'm going to run this MFer over" type thing, you'd think she would have gotten him more full on...though there's always the possibility he made a bit of a dash when she began reversing. I think that Karen and John were having a blowout argument (or at least Karen was, who knows how John was behaving), John got out of the car and was continuing to "spar" with her. Things reach their crescendo, and Karen decides to leave "in style", backing up violently, and way too close for comfort so as to scare the living daylights out of him - but she misjudges. *THWACK, THUD*..."Oh...fuuuuh...." Karen was therefore conscious of what she had just done, though it's my guess she was also in denial. This is my explanation for the voice messages. She fled in panic, and also in denial fueled panic, began to sort of act the way she would have had she not hit him, calling him to continue the argument they were having. So, not as a future legal strategy sort of thing, more for her own mental benefit: "No Karen, you didn't hit him, you so didn't hit him that you're actually still pissed off at him for fucking around on you and leaving you to look after his fucking kids" - that sort of thing. Have you ever had something bad happen, and the first thing you do in the immediate wake of it is go through the motions you think you would if that hadn't have happened? It also speaks to her extremely ill-advised behavior of floating the possibility of having hit John, or that John may have been hit by a plow or something to Jen, Kerry, and Kaylee (the vid doesn't talk about the last part, but yes, Johns niece testified to the same sort of statements). There's no real Machiavellian plotting at that point. She's more just trying to get ahead of what she, not all that deep down, knows is coming. "DID I hit him? COULD I have hit him? DID SOMETHING hit him? All I know is if it does turn out he was hit, even if it was by me, I wasn't aware of it at the time, that's why I'm ASKING!" And yes, I believe the flat out "I hit him!" remarks the first responders recalled also happened. At that point the body had been found, and I think Karen was transitioning her act to one of distraught realization - she didn't know the collision wasn't caught on video yet. If what I've outlined were true, from my understanding she'd still be good for Murder 2, as that only requires her knowing she's put John in peril and failing to get him medical aid. But if I had fellow jurors twisting my arm, I might still throw her manslaughter just to call it a day!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Kaz! Yeah, it often seems to be a matter of someone more being into the community than the honest to god case itself. God bless though, I'm sure your friend is a nice person. Delphi/Richard Allen is another one I'm going to do, but I've pretty much decided it's not next, and probably not next after next either, because it's another one where I'll cop flack no matter the conclusion ESPECIALLY if it's not straight down the middle, which I'm man enough for, but not man enough for fucking two back to back! And again just like KR at the outset, standing where I am right now, I'm open to either side...but can't help but notice those sort of over zealous red flags in the innocence camp. Still though, very atypical profile, and some of the crime scene stuff does sound absolutely bizarre. We'll see!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Kevin, I mean I can only go so far with this because I'm not exactly qualified to give specific projections on snowfall patterns. You're saying if the snow is falling at a leftward angle, it's going to accumulate on the furthest right side tail light as that's unprotected by the roof, and by the time we get to the furthest left the roof is obstructing most of the snowfall - do I have that right? If so, it works enough in theory to account for why snow accumulation on the back of the car shouldn't be expected to be perfectly symmetrical - but for it to perfectly white out the section that's going to be observed as missing, and for that effect to abruptly stop RIGHT as the backlight kicks in (there's basically a straight dividing line, no "dusting" effect at all) seriously strains my intuition to put it mildly. There's also snow build up on the bumper beneath both sides that looks very symmetrical - I dunno if that runs counter to the explanation you're positing or not.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Christian, don't forget Apple River! There's at very least one other case I've done that I plan on doing an addendum for. I'm also thinking of "exploring the format" further like you say. There are some cases and stories that don't suit themselves to the polished format because they don't have enough raw material or visual aid associated with them, that I could make something of in the "vlog" format. One really interesting true crime case in particular I'm thinking of. It might be you see more of these style of things with original subjects once I run out of vids to do standard commentaries on - they come out more regularly than main releases, so inevitably I'm going to catch myself up to present day eventually.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good news: Definitely, Bad News: Ages away. Could be more than a year. I wanna do a big, big one for that, and I just can't afford to block out a month plus for such a thing, much as I love to look after my paying supporters! A big part of the reason I know this addendum was probably on balance a bad idea is exactly that. Nearly 3 damn weeks I could have been focusing on an actual proper release instead!

TinTicket

As a dyslexic and chronic mistyper having a spelling mistake associated with my name forever is a genuine fear. Being accused of helping out a murder isn't great also but the constant reminder of the mistype is so much worse. On a more serious note - I think they included the police officer who misremembered to just throw more shit in the pan and confuse matters even more. I sat through your edited copy of it going "what the fuck is this, is this even important, oh shit the defence are dick heads, wait are they saying she lied to help the conspiracy theory, oh wait they're trying to imply she changed her story as the police threatened her, but wait she physically couldn't have been there". Hearing that over the course of an hour plus hours and hours and hours of more stuff I think my little brain would just hurt and come to the conclusion there is a lying going on. I remember reading a reddit post about a woman who dropped her partner off, he went into a house for hours, had obvious signs of a beating and then police blamed the lady for running him over because they wanted to protect the cop gang that killed the dude. I didn't follow the case onwards. Come to your main video and this one and connect the dots. The surface FKR is plausible but the actual case itself is not. The phone not moving is the real point for me. The UK gov's stats are that If someone is hit by a car at 40 mph they are 90% likely to be killed. If someone is hit by a car at 30 mph they are 50% likely to be killed. If someone is hit by a car at 20 mph they are 10% likely to be killed. (Though some people dispute these). Karen was going closer to 30 than 20 - John was drunk, angry, and it was icy each of these alone make you unsteady, all of them together is a recipe for disaster. I think we forget how fragile the human head. A woman who wasn't safe to be driving, unknowingly hit someone (or maybe knowingly but didn't realise the extent of the damage), and because of a desire to not take ownership of her mistake + the nasty dude who in charge who sent the messages + issues of corruption in the area + the internet = this mess. I know she, obviously, claims innocence but it would be interesting to know what Karen really thinks. A part of her must know she is responsible for John's death - but then cognitive dissonance is a powerful thing. I enjoyed hearing about the process of the main video being a story and how you pick content to tell that story - which is why you never trust any doco (they are doing the same). Enjoy these addendums, to get your unfiltered thoughts.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah, like I said, the "I watched the whole (or both) trials" flex drives me nuts when it's often followed up by links to absolutely out of the stratosphere slanted LawTubers. It's far superior to watch some of a trial properly than watch all of one with a little man (or woman) on your shoulder telling you what to think of it...and I'm kind of despaired by how many people genuinely can't see a problem with that way of taking things in. I believe the quibble you're referring to had to do with Burgess recalculating the occurrence of certain things based on time differences between the Lexus clock and Johns phone, and synchronizing the two by accounting for the time differences yada yada. The defense argued that because some of that work was done late in the game, it was basically an ambush, but that argument didn't win out and Burgess was allowed to present his data. I don't know when exactly the adjustments were made and why exactly it's said they were made at that time. There was some stuff in Burgess' direct about him cluing on to some data that might have been missing from the first extraction, and successfully recovering said data so it might be related to that? I'm just going off memory. With Burgess, I'll be straight with you, I can't give you much of a lay of the land for his methods. He is one expert I DID in fact watch in full because I I knew his conclusions were extremely important...but man, speaking of LawTubers, he was one witness where you understand why some people use them as a crutch, because I really could have used a guy in the corner making wisecracks then - aggressively boring. At least for a non data nerd like me. I'll say this much, part of the reason he was so boring is he walked you through his methodology in absolutely excruciating detail. So while I'm not in a position to opine on the merits of said methodology in any specifics, because it was frankly in one ear out the other...sounded legit. And from memory, after spending 45 minutes or something on the CV bullshit (pretty massive tell they're low on substance yet again), the best the def could do was poke holes that would amount to seconds even if they did pan out, which further speaks to how quibbling over the precise timing of the reverse is missing the forest for the trees: The mere existence of a *highly abnormal and very dangerous* reverse by Karen's vehicle, in the area where John will be found dead the next morning, is already bad beyond words!! timing it precisely with his phone interactions etc takes it to a whole new level of course, but it's sort of overkill really! No one's saying she didn't do that, and no one's saying she did it outside Waterfall or Meadows!

Kaz

I think it’s a combination of in-group/out-group conflict as well as an explicit desire for the scandalous option (a cover up in this case) to be true - much like with Epstein. I think the most likely thing about the Epstein Files™️ is that there is NO black book or obvious clear papers incriminating anyone - but people WANT there to be something even more scandalous and vile than what we already know because it satisfies that need for validation.

Felix V

hey im really loving the new addendum video! im not really in the "scene" i guess and was not really following the case from germany except for your content about it. at ~1:40 you talk about a stream that might have made an impact on the perception of kelly dever? checking out other "body analysis proof she lied" videos is pretty interesting. stunning even. to see and analyze the way public perception was forming after having the luxury of getting introduced to the case only through the more or less distanced accounts of your videos. its is like an opportunity to look at it all from very far away and watch how that phenomenon of mass perception can form. that said, any chance someone can give me a hint or keyword to look up to find the mentioned stream? is that okay to ask that in here? im genuinely not interested in bad mouthing any creators and would like to see how it all snowballed into a public being convinced she is innocent but cant find any videos of streamers reacting to it the way it was described in the video.

Big B

This was fascinating, I knew nothing about this case ( I had heard of it, but didn’t get into it) until I watched your video. Appreciate your immense attention to detail.

E

Great news! Take your time, Matt. Your vids are always worth the wait

Matt

Honestly I was hoping for this. Thanks, Matt.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Re bias/fairness: What I'm saying is, like everyone, I have certain biases. And going into this one, I guess one bias I had to manage was that in my experience these last few years, whenever there's a big group lobbying for a cause like this, they're almost always wrong lol. I still don't know why it seems to work that way. Another is that very early on, I found Karen quite unlikable. Those sorts of feelings and inclinations (bias) can't just be erased at will. All you can do is acknowledge them and do your best to put them to the side and focus on the substance of the case, going through step by step and not just writing certain things off because they're coming from the side you err toward being more wary of. That's fairness, and that is a choice. And yeah, I think by and large I'm good with that part, and I was weighing the Read case up without firmly landing on one side for a good couple of weeks...Which seems kinda crazy in retrospect, but there were a lot of arguments and angles to wade through! Some people act as if fairness means that the final product should always treat both sides as having an equal amount of valid points, and that the ultimate conclusion is always more or less 50/50 in likelihood. But if we think about that proposition for a second, I think we can all see why that's not true, and operating under such a model would yield some extremely unfair and bizarrely skewed pieces of work. So basically I'm saying that I approached the material in this case from a fair, open-minded place, and that approach ultimately resulted in the takeaway of "guilty as all hell", and there's no contradiction there.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Oh Karen knows damn well, lol. Yeah that's another thing with Dever - Not only is what she has to offer already far from explosive, because she actively doesn't want to help the defense, it can actually be kind of tricky to even tell why she's there if you're not paying proper attention, especially in the raw version. Further speaks to why people viewing her as a big deal is surely owed to commentary about her testimony rather than the actual content of that testimony itself.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I wasn't talking about any one stream. There's a whole "scene" of youtube "legal analysts" (and yes, body language analysts too) who heavily cater to FKR (as that's basically become their audience) and I'm arguing people like that have shaped the online perception of Dever's testimony much more than the actual content of the testimony itself...which when watched by itself is quite remarkable for it's nothingness. If you were to just search "Kelly Dever analysis" in YT I'm sure something quite representative of the sort of thing I'm talking about will come up.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Hmm, this was white on white miscarriage of justice though. In theory, you would need a nearly all-white jury to acquit an obviously guilty white person of killing a black person (or two) to equalize OJ...Though I have a hunch that sort of eye for an eye approach would not in fact do a great deal to heal any sort of divisions. Dear I say it might even make things...worse?

Matthew Thayer

To be clear, I'm not a Michael Peterson defender. Interestingly, I feel much the same way about the Michael Peterson case as I do about the Karen Read case, where I have no reasonable doubt as to the factual guilt of either of them, but I do have reasonable doubt as to the integrity, and therefore the veracity, of the investigations, if that makes sense. Like, I wholeheartedly agree with the conclusions of the investigations, but the way they reach those conclusions is clouded enough by misconduct, incompentance, and possible evidence manipulation that, while I still wouldn't find reasonable doubt, if one were to be deciding just the merits just of the case built by the respective PDs and prosecutors, not factual guilt, I can see how some reasonable person would be able to find reasonable doubt in both cases. But, from what I've seen, I think in this case the jurors were just fucking morons, and that's how this happened.

TinTicket

Just jumping back on to add - I went to the prosecutors podcast via youtube, just their one on the verdict in trial - I cba with all their podcasts on this case. Just interesting the comments that say the podcasters are wrong because the jury made their verdict, as if what a jury decides is the truth. Like there is an objective truth and a jury always finds it. Just an interesting world view. Also interesting the FKR people saying "there is loads of evidence she didn't do it", but (and admittedly my only source on this is Matt and the substack he referenced somewhere) this feels like people think it is a "is the dress black and blue or white and gold" case when it's really not.

Ember Bennett

I’m from the Delphi area. I think the conspiracies stem from the fact that the police suddenly came out with an arrest when the case had little public information released beforehand and until the trial we had pretty much 0 info on why they felt it was him. Not to mention the fact that the long investigation led to conspiracies about the occult (which is pretty unpopular around here 🙄). Also, the cops around here are generally not trustworthy at all. They don’t do their jobs unless the media gets on their ass. Im really surprised they managed for find anyone with even a scrap of evidence.

Ember Bennett

Why would I ever complain about a new MOCAS video?

Ann Silberman

Matt is right, as usual. All is right with the world.

Jonathan Gill

If I might ask one more question: is there anything to say on the dog bite expert (or "expert", take your pick)? I've not watched the trial footage, so I have no opinion on her, though I've got a fairly good guess for what might be in store.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

"Dog bite lady" was probably a bit rude of me, she *is* a doctor. Her chief claim to being an authority on the matter though is having treated multiple dog bite wounds during her time in ERs. Better experience than I can claim, no doubt, but is that really a level of expertise where we should be able to trust you can attribute such a specific cause of injuries to the exclusion of all other possibilities based only on photographs? I mean tbf, one thing that came from her testimony is there really isn't any such thing as a leading dog bite expert (pretty niche) which is all well and good, but it further speaks to why this is an especially unreasonable thing to just "defer to lab coats" on. In terms of her specific analysis, one thing that jumps out at me is she acknowledged there are no puncture wounds, which has always struck me as a massive problem for the theory, and her best explanation was that Chloe just "never latched on" - wtf kind of dog attack are we being asked to picture here? If you want more on witnesses I haven't covered without sitting through the testimony, Tuesday Gazette did really good coverage of the retrial. She's an unambiguous Anti, but I find her analysis consistently sober and reasonable. Here's her write ups of Dr. Russell: https://www.tuesdaygazetteblog.com/p/day-25-karen-read-retrial?utm_source=publication-search https://www.tuesdaygazetteblog.com/p/day-26-karen-read-retrial?utm_source=publication-search

Claire

May this kind of love never find me.

LapisScarab

The thing about "hos long to die in cold" is that it's just... not a suspicious thing to search during a blizzard? Especially if you think someone might be lost in one.

Riket

Has anybody considered that an owl hit him with it's car?

Jonathan Gill

Oh god--that's so much worse of a testimony than I was expecting. That looks like a really messy testimony, and what I gather from the blog is this is the expert behind the FKR talking point that there'd have to be bruising on the arm in a vehicle collision. The more that I look at the arm wounds, the harder it becomes for me to see them as dog bites: this would have required at least 5 bites all roughly parallel and in the same direction, all involving just a few teeth (with different spacing between wounds), and never once does the lower jaw clamp down on the underarm? Meanwhile a dog this persistent never once goes for any other area of the body? Why is this such an article of faith for FKR? (Rhetorical questions here, not actually asking)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think in a situation where Jen had zero explanation for it, and the rest of the evidence in the case were different, it would be sufficiently suspicious. But you're right - forget searching for someone, because if it were made at 2:27 AM on that date, that particular explanation wouldn't apply, but even going with 2:27, If Jen had said, "Oh I was talking to my husband and he joked [yada, yada, some story about how they came to speculate how long it would take someone to die in a blizzard without appropriate clothing] so I searched it on a lark" - That would be buyable enough. I mean googling niche questions during conversations is something we all do once in a while. I'd believe it before I believed the sorts of scenarios people try to cook up for how John could have died from non-Karen causes in a way that tracks with his cel phone data. Even without the timestamp explanation, it wouldn't be smoking gun level evidence against the McAlberts. Absent the digital forensics, absent the tail light evidence, and absent the timestamp explanation, maybe it would be enough of an oddity to raise reasonable doubt for Karen...MAYBE. But we're not living in that world! :)

Ty P

Yes, acknowledging the bias that you are aware of is a first and important step. Sorry, if my intent wasn't clear. I'm in a very emotional phase and a complete mess right now. Apologies! Let me put it like this. There is a reason why Foucaults most famous work is „discipline and punishment. " The area of crime and how society deals with it is an extremely controversial topic. On top we also now have a meso and macro level of media, recently even a more and more intense micro level. Besides the issue one could have with primary sources like court documents Ok, so you have acknowledged your conscious biases and tried to minimize them. How do you deal with your biases that you are unwilling to acknowledge or biases that are unconscious? That is what I meant with procedures to minimize bias. Let’s keep in mind, everybody thinks that they are fair and open minded. I haven’t done qualitative research or questionnaire construction for quite some time but let me tell you, people are filled to the brim with unconscious biases. There are methods to minimize it. To be fair, your videos are already far above the quality of most true crime channels. I’m not going to fault you one bit for not trying to achieve criminology levels. :)

Janissa Rose

I know this is ridiculous, but when you talk about law enforcement, I picture fuckin Wellington Paranormal and that's the cops you're referencing haha

Noella

I liked the YT video and was disappointed reading the comments at the seemingly poor reception. I'm glad that you've got that understanding of the online crowd and context. And I'll never be sad for an addendum!

Ravie Jones

The cumtown bit was great!

gillygull

I’m disappointed you didn’t recruit a mate to recreate the crash like a mashup of Mythbusters and Jackass

Sam

Love the livestreamer bit haha

John M.

I appreciate the Frank Rizzo "crumb bum" references. Nicely done mocas.

Ty P

Phew, I criticize Matt quite a bit but every time I go to one of the other channels, this time coffeehouse crime, I'm reminded that compared to those Matt is an ocean of neutrality and good research.

Steve

Re the strength of evidence: In antitrust, we use the terms “plus” and “super plus” to describe good and great evidence of conspiracy.

Steve

Good video, but this case has never really interested me. I’ve always thought she was guilty. I mean, just look at digital evidence and the fact he was standing near his mad, drunk, reckless girlfriend’s vehicle. The alternative defies logic.

Matthew Thayer

Matt, I want to second what appears to be a reasonably common sentiment, which is that the addenda are easily some of your best work, and I really hope you continue with them, even if it'll only be once in a while(I'm personally still holding out hope for the prophesied West Memphis 3 addendum to come someday). In either case, you deserve congratulations.

Steve

I agree. I like how this framed in the first person because it’s your filtering of the evidence. I enjoy the narrative of the original—which necessarily trims some details—but I like the width and breadth of this deep dive.

Steve

One more thing: I know you’re a fan of JCS and want to make sure you saw a recent history of that channel by The Right Opinion. I had not realized True Crime Loser worked with JCS.

Janissa Rose

Lol. If we're talking eye for an eye here in the south.... That's a lot more OJs we're gonna have to sit through y'all

Andy

Au contraire, Sir! I'm so pleased you published the addendum - for me, it was worth it, not just because I get more of your content, but it did sway me. I enjoyed the first immensely. When you unveiled the project was coming, I probably said at the time something along the lines of, "Good luck with that!" and you did a great job. It was always going to be a case of what you decided to leave out, so the finished product was heroic. My wife has recently succumbed to my praise of your content and has watched a few past posts with joy recently. She had also heard me bleating about the Read case and knew nothing of it going in - it did a great job of explaining something that would have taken me days, and she sends thanks for that. I fell firmly in the camp of, "Yes, but what about...?" after the first one, but you made a very good case in the follow-up, much like the DocG fella in the JonBenet Ramsey link - strip away all the chaff and here are some central facts...focus on them. Even Karen in one of her many outside-the-courthouse snippets, referred to "we have the data" and then either ignored it or didn't show any a la opening (likely again soon after the recent civil trial motions). I both laughed and felt daft because, had I replied after the first release, I would have added "But I watched the whole trial!" to my "Yes, buts...". However, in my pro se defence, I knew exactly where you were going when you said you'd reveal what you hate about true crime currently, and I echo that. Please also be aware that I did watch some of it without any commentary and can see what's going on there when I do. Again, without mentioning any names, it is probably noteworthy that a particular commentator was too busy having meetings on the day the verdict came in, and others who had previously been more balanced saw their numbers grow on that day...and their opinions have changed along with the donations. Another tragedy of LawTubers is that the central characters become those in the courtroom room and the victim and their families are all too easily forgotten and given a bit part at best. This is arguably even more true in something like the Dan Markel murder. See, even there I had to stop myself from calling it the Adelson case. Oh, and extra good luck if you decide to have a nip at that saga! Where do I sit now? You certainly mellowed me, but I think the jury got it right with what was put in front of them. Part of the reason for watching a trial without commentary is it puts you more in their seat, right? I think the prosecution was terribl,e and it's very clear that the police and authorities in MA have a whole heap of dirt in the background. That said, which other police or authorities don't? The defence played the jury well, against the odds, in the retrial. Several of the jurors mentioned Dever/Bukakke in particular were obstructive, and that's the way it crumbles in front of them. I understand they hired a juror from the first trial to help with that second time around and did their job. I think I'd probably want that team if I were in trouble and could afford it in the absence of a potential film deal. Thanks for ruining Alessi btw - I just can't listen to him now! I think on all sides, there is a cast of terrible, horrible people on this stage, and no heroes at all. Where I live in Scotland, we currently have three jury outcomes. The addition to guilty/not guilty is not proven. There is talk of removing it currently, but had this jury had that option I suspect they would have taken it. I'm pretty sure I would had I been there live sans hysterical commentary. Finally, I think this particular diptych of content does your channel name proud. Crime AND Society. You covered so much ground on both that doesn't need repeating here, but again, bravo, Matt. I watch a lot of true crime from a societal standpoint and with sheer bewilderment. Sure, it's the most entertaining thing around sometimes, and I often feel bad about that. The echo chambers described in the latter really do echo those of politics and religion and gender, and everything else. It's scary stuff, and I hope we can all find a way of resolving that - I currently can't see how without a mild oblivion. P.S. - It took a few days to fully acknowledge the bravery of your position being out in the open on YouTube. It does sound like you have mostly had suppor,t which I'm really pleased about. It could have been a risky move out there in the wild west where the hunting packs roam. I'm off to read the YouTube comments right now! Thanks and love ya, man.

srahhh

Is TCL not just credited in those video descriptions for the joke clips JCS included at the ends? I thought the TRO video was a little poorly researched personally.

Merglo Mclaughlin

Matt this addendum is worth it. Not to echo other people but i enjoy. hearing your first person perspective. Like both the narrative structure of your main vids and the personal argument of your addendums are great in their own ways. Plus i get more mocas.

Merglo Mclaughlin

Im also glad for this addendum bc i was introduced to this case by my sister who lives in Boston and very much believes Karen is innocent and for a bit i was convinced the case was more complicated than it really is. My family and i spent 3 hours in a car together arguing over the case while listening to a creator who was also very much FKR, and by the end of it i was on the fence. Going into your original vid i had all these points in my head that supported conspiracy, the main one being the phone being thrown out at a government base. When your og vid didnt touch on it i was like "i agree shes guilty but what about the gpvernment base?!?!?!?" So long story short im glad to hear you talk about it lmao

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Ya know if Alan Jackson or Turtleboy can find me a Lexus and name a cold as balls location in front of someone's lawn, I'd be more than happy to back into one of them at 24 m/h with the gas peddle 3 quarters of the way down to find out what happens. A small caveat though: If they don't flat out die I'm still not changing my position - variables and all that.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I mean yeah basically this - the actual substance of the case has no business getting 4 plus hours dedicated to it. It's not a head-scratcher, and frankly wasn't even on day 1. It's the social phenomena, and ability of lawyers and influencers to make people believe such a simple thing is so complex that make it interesting.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think the bottom line here is that if we want to soothe race relations in the US, outrageous miscarriages of justice on the basis of the defendants race is probably not optimal no matter what direction we're doing that in lol.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks so much for that Andy! It's always especially nice to hear when people have gotten their partners/family into my content :) And look with the LawTube stuff, again, I really don't mean to be judgmental towards people who get much of their trial coverage through it. I'm merely trying to convey the hazards of the format. It's not really reasonable to expect people to just sit through 100s of hours of raw material in their spare time. All I'm saying is you've got to be conscious the hosts of those platforms have certain incentives that go against them being purely neutral guides. So long as one gets that, which you obviously do, whatever, god bless! Keep watching it, just take it with a grain of salt (or more!) ;)

natalie steiner

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this, Matt. I appreciate your ability to frame things on your main videos in the objective way that you do. That’s a big reason why I love your content, you let the viewer do the heavy lifting on certain matters, and especially on overall opinions/takeaways. I only consume “true crime” and “lawtube” through full trials and full interviews, other than your channel and Dave’s. I think you are both extremely respectful to the real people impacted by these events in the way you cover content. I would love to hear more about cases near you in Australasia. I thought that was a rather cool aspect of the David Bain video (I didn’t know what an All Black was before that haha.) It would be interesting to learn more about the legal process over there as compared to the States. Thank you again for the thoughtful commentary on this case! Cheers from Florida ❤️

Natalie

Great work. As always!!! I’m sick of Karen Read now. Not her, but the case. The interesting part is all of this!!! Karen herself, isn’t interesting and this isn’t the type of case I usually get into!! Thank you ❤️❤️

AR

as someone unfamiliar with much of true crime youtube, I automatically worry that a channel with a name like "The Right Opinion" sounds like a MAGA trashfire. Could you please explain what you're talking about for the uninitiated? Is True Crime Loser bad? Is TRO? (My unpopular opinion is that JCS was never very good and he won widespread unearned acclaim for being first, but just not very entertaining or quality at all.)

AR

It's also the context. Boston cops have decades, at both the local *and* the state trooper level, of well-documented instances of rampant corruption, including fabricating evidence to secure convictions. Given that, it wasn't hard *at all* for the whole town to buy into the idea that they had tampered with the evidence in this case.

D

Love the follow-up. You are very good at logically and concisely dismantling arguments—it’s why you’re one of the best in the business! Thanks for the vid.

Clare

I've watched this multiple times now and just love your delivery and logic Matt. Thanks for another great video

Amelia Patterson

Wow. I totally flipped my opinion an hour and a half in. I really was influenced by true crime creators (which I have since unsubbed from, for obvious reasons) who really made me buy into the conspiracy. It's crazy how easily influenced we can be just by the delivery of a case.

Rosalind Margulies

I think I might start a random maniac with a baseball bat movement. Just to shake things up

Virginia

Just to feel something

sammer

My current understanding of this case in a jargon filled sentence: AWFLs got QAnon FOMO, so they made their own version of it in Massachusetts with funny accents, with the takeaway being to not drink and drive.

sammer

I know you are trying to do commentaries in chronological order, but I hope the next addendum you make is on the West Memphis 3. You mentioned as an aside at some point that you think they are guilty as hell. Maybe it's my liberal background speaking, but not only do I have a hard time believing that, and not only do I see very few people advocating that position, but I don't entirely get that sense from your video on them. (An addendum to the Suspicious Minds analysis is an acceptable substitute as well. Or you can have me on and I'll tell you about how I saw Elvis Presley busking last week at the Speedway in South Vienna, Ohio.)

sammer

Please don't be mean to Alan Jackson. He may be a sleezy lawyer, but Chattahoochee is still rightly the state anthem of Georgia.

Haili Devillier

very good, addendum really put the nails in the coffin for me that she did in fact do this after being on the fence for some time. as an aside, i was looking around for your prince andrew video in lieu of the news, was it removed/privated? my partner isnt familiar with his antics and i was dying to show him lol

Theresa Mary

And it looks like that JCS Prince Andrew video is gone :(

NattyCat Pin Club

Hey Matt, would you ever consider covering Richard Allen's trial in the Delphi murders? It was a crazy trial, I'd absolutely love to see what you'd have to say on it. Figured I'd ask!

claumz

I really hope you do an addendum on the West Memphis Three! Would love to hear your thoughts about the case, I got the feeling that you were hinting that you believe they are guilty!

ethan

I'm surprised that I came away from the original video with a relatively even, leaning towards not guilty, stance. Considering how strongly you feel about your opposite position.

Matthew Thayer

He says outright that he believes they are guilty in the old creator commentary on the Dennis Oland video. I would also love a WM3 addendum.

Queen of Hearts

But yeah, I was just thinking that this is the white woman version of OJ Simpson, a wealthy privileged person digging up dirt on the cops to make it look like they’re a victim of the evil police while the cops and prosecutors completely fumble the case

Queen of Hearts

Oh wow, the way Karen’s team treated Kelly is just horrible.

Queen of Hearts

Not sure if you’re still responding but I would like to know your thoughts on FKR people appropriating the murder of Sarah Birchmore

ryan

Thanks for doing this! I always thought she was guilty... I think I'm too boring of a person to believe a great conspiracy. Anyway, as a guy working in tech: you did an excellent job summarizing that stuff. It was a little wild hearing someone on the stand talk about SQLite, its WAL, Apple plist files, etc... I'm guessing the jury's eyes probably glazed over for parts of that dude's testimony. But that witness resolved the "2am" Google search for me, that was kind of the last thing that bugged me about this case when I heard about it in passing. I was a little annoyed at how assertive the defense was, in general, but once I understood how a forensics engineer looks at that data and what the data was actually saying, I knew that the defense's arguments didn't hold any water.

Ty P

Nobody open for an accident hypothesis? She was drunk, hit him by accident-ish, thought "i probably just hit the pole", was to drunk, angry and unwilling to get back into the cold to check. Then went on her merry way. It lines up with her comments directly after finding out "Did I hit him? Did I hit him?". Do you know how it sounds to hit a human being during a snowstorm? Involuntary manslaughter. Lines up with the facts. If she really killed him on purpose then screaming "did I hit him?" Is not a great way to hide her guilt, isn't it. 🙂

Dani

Subscribed to your patreon to this see gem. Thank you so much for doing this despite being on the fence about it!

Luthen’s Reality

1:02:10 As a Massachusetts resident, the proper term would be “wicked fast” 😂

Luthen’s Reality

Yeah for sure. I think that the prosecution should have entertained that and charged her for that too. I don’t know exactly how it works state by state but I think I’ve heard of trials where someon e is charged with murder, and the jury has the option to convict the defendant of murder OR to convince them on a lesser charge like manslaughter; basically they think the defendant was involved, but the evidence didn’t satisfy the definition of murder. I think that would have been a better sell to a jury. Prosecution: “I think it’s clear we have proved Karen reed’s car hit John and that killed him, amounting to manslaughter at least. However, due to her angry state of mind as shown by text messages along with the fact she was drunk, leads the commonwealth to the ultimate conclusion that she reversed her car into John in a drunken rage with such force that he shattered his skull, leaving him to die, making Karen Reed guilty of murder.” Boom. There’s your closing argument prosecution. But what do I know 🤷‍♂️

LeeBee

Not that your theory doesn’t have merit, but I think her repeatedly screaming “Did I hit him?!” aligns more with *pretending* to be in the exact scenario you suggest. Certainly at that point in time her defense was not “he died in the basement after I left,” all the stuff she now ascribes to comes later in the court timeline, of course. She hit him in a moment of drunken anger, got scared, and took off. The next morning, her strategy is to pass it off as a complete accident—it’ll hurt your reputation, but it’s far better than having people think you intentionally tried to hurt him. Maybe she even thought she wouldn’t be prosecuted if the whole thing was determined to be one big “oops.” Not to say your theory is bad or inconceivable, but I think “if she hit him intentionally, she would have feigned 100% ignorance” is a poor defense of that position. In a scenario where your boyfriend has been hit by a car a few feet from where you dropped him off that night, and all your friends know that fact, only a stupid person would shrug their shoulders and say “Dunno.”

Ty P

Sure, that is possible, too. But that makes her out as real criminal mastermind. There is not only the comment but also the voice message because of the kids. It seems contradictory that she on one hand has so little self control, that she killed him in a drunken fury but was at the same time cool headed enough to come up with several steps to play this off as an accident.

muruba

I definitely don't regret my Patreon subscription for once. These addendums really help me understand your way of thinking better (I'm autistic and every bit of context for how any given person reaches their conclusion helps, it's hard to explain, it just does). I also love the more personal opinion-based content you put up here. Cheers! (Sorry for any mistakes, english is not my mother tongue.)

Queen of Hearts

I definitely think that if they had kept cooler heads and charged her with vehicular manslaughter or something else more reasonable then they would’ve prevented things from getting out of hand

Ty P

And she wouldn't have gotten away with it, if it wasn't for those meddling cops. That police department must have thought:" We are too popular. We need our own metoo moment! Any ideas? Trooper Proctor, you have something?" "Yes sir, I have this brilliant friend, Chandler. He always knows what to do."

AuntFromHell

Subscribed to see this. Well done!

Douglas Genuske

Judging by her reluctance to care while backing up into John's car the morning going back to the Mcabe's. Not checking to see what was hit or caring etc seems to be in her wheelhouse.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I've seen those sorts of murmurs...I don't know anything about the Birchmore case, so just going with the assumption the circumstances around that are 100% confirmed as 100% as shady as is being made out when comparisons are made between that and the Read case - yes, total victim appropriation!

Queen of Hearts

It comes across, at least to me, like these people want the trappings of being progressive and caring about corruption and the crimes police commit against citizens but they don’t actually want to give a shit about real victims. I saw people in the comments saying that you were “pro cop” and as a black person that absolutely floored me given your coverage of George Floyd. They don’t care about actual victims. Someone else said it’s like Qanon for white liberals, the same underlying thing of taking issues like police corruption and human trafficking, removing the actual victims, and claiming that the photogenic upper class white women are the real targets. I guarantee not one of the FKR people ever gave a single shit about Brianna Taylor

Aurora H.

life-long masshole here. calling our cops corrupt is a term of endearment

Aaron Garcia

It's amazing to me how much people are quick to criticize in the YT comments about how not enough was covered... and then complain that vids aren't coming out fast enough

Björn

Appreciate the video, I like the candour. That being said, I think you're wrong. There is no way, with that investigation, with that evidence, and with that testimony that a person can or should be found guilty beyond any and all reasonable doubt. In my opinion, the Commonwealth failed to show that a collision was possible, but let's say that they did. Brennan did say in his closing that "[the paint video] alone shows that it's possible". OK. Should we convict on "possible"? We need "probable", right? And preferably a lot more than that aswell? Just curious, which crime that she was charged with do you think she should have been convicted of? Also, can you expand on your thoughts on Alan Jackson? I get that he’s a dramatic kind of lawyer, but I don't see anything unethical about his work in this case, wondering what you think. I thought he was extremely effective. Again, thank you for the video, It's cool to see I don't agree with your material _all_ the time 🌹

bundaga borbo

oh this is actually interesting, because i legitimately wouldn't find it reasonable to see the car's backwards acceleration, the fact that the tail light was broken around then, and the fact that a body was busted up precisely at that same site at exactly the point in time when all of this occurred as totally disjointed facts that don't align to produce an apparent, rather singular possibility: that she hit him with her car. from there, the fact that the body didn't move in any way kind of suggests that the crash led inexorably to his death, thus, guilty, no? i can't think of any reasonable alternative which could retain all of these incontrovertible facts as being true yet somehow finds karen read as not responsible for a murder.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I agree with what bundaga said. On it being possible John was killed by the sort of collision posited by the CW (a clipping collision): I spoke to this in the addendum. The notion of a man being hit somewhere in and around the shoulder by an SUV at 25ish miles per hour, and the force from that impact projecting him to the ground with enough velocity to kill him should he smash his head into a hard surface (especially if left for hours in freezing conditions with no medical attention) is something I’m happy to accept as possible without seeing any expert testimony on the matter. I struggle to see how anyone is genuinely skeptical of the above. But anyway, that’s the tack Read and her team took - “Even if one accepts Read running around that morning telling every witness she could find that she (could have?) hit him is suspicious, well it breaks the rules of physics, so I guess you just have to follow the science and accept it didn’t happen” - That’s gonna be a massive eyeroll from me, dawg. When you frame Brennan asserting the collision theory is possible as a way of him trying to secure conviction on mere possibility, you’re moving the goal posts, even if that’s not your intention. As stated, the (silly) notion that the collision breaks the rules of physics is a defense argument. In refuting it, Brennan is not implying mere possibility is the CWs only threshold. If you start looking at things through that kind of prism, you’ll create a situation where the pros is giving up the game every time they so much as respond to the defense - it’s extremely slanted. And on slanted - “beyond a reasonable doubt” means just that, beyond doubt which is *reasonable* - it cannot be an imagined, speculative doubt. It must be based on the evidence presented to you once considered fairly and soberly. It does not need to be proven to the point of absolute scientific certainty - although I genuinely believe the evidence against Read is at least approaching that even higher standard - John’s location data rules out any attack inside the house, and Read’s car activity, in conjunction with John’s documented final steps categorically implicates her. But just the tail light evidence in conjunction with Read’s documented behaviour should be enough to get you past the RD threshold. Plenty more things I could name check - we’re absolutely spoiled with evidence in this case. There’s a point I want to make on this. Sometimes when people are making an argument based on the "reasonable doubt" standard, they lean hard into the rights of the accused - what WE would want if WE were accused. And that’s a great thing to remind yourself of - I’m all for it…but it’s only half the picture. You should also give serious thought to how seriously you’d like the system to treat your life or the life of a loved one if someone were credibly accused of taking it. Let’s not bother with an analogy: Say your father/brother/son wound up dead on someone's lawn. Subsequently it was confirmed that their girlfriend was the one to “drop them off”, was leaving vmails screaming at them minutes later, had pieces of her tail light found around the body, then more microscopic pieces of that tail light were found embedded in your father/brother/son’s clothes. Then upon even further investigation due to (unwarranted) public scrutiny, it was further established your father/brother/son’s phone never moved from the spot where it was found beneath their body, they only made 36 steps upon arriving on scene, and their steps stopped cold right when it was confirmed their girlfriend reversed her SUV with the gas-peddle depressed 75% of the way down, reaching a speed of 25 m/ph before stopping. Imagine the jury failed to convict that woman on the basis that the prosecution asserted the collision was possible, and they felt the standard should be higher than that. Can you really tell me you wouldn’t be absolutely incensed? I’d convict Karen Read of Murder 2 easily based on the wording of the charges and evidence presented at trial. I might go down to Manslaughter if my fellow jurors were holding out and that’s what it would take to make something of some weight stick - but only for that reason. Murder 2 should be an absolute slam dunk. On AJ - short version is, I’ve got nothing against defense Atty’s doing everything they can within the bounds of ethics to defend their client. Alan Jasckson doesn’t live up to the “within the bounds of ethics” part. If you want to put on a 3rd party culprit defense, you’re not actually supposed to be allowed to sling mud at whoever you want, however you want, on the basis of the thinnest of conjecture and tabloid innuendo in and outside the courtroom. You are supposed to have to actually establish some substantive evidentiary basis for such accusations before dragging peoples names through the dirt, like Jackson did so gleefully and regularly. Karen Read’s victims (some of them minors at the time) are still being put through the wringer on the daily for the tactics Jackson and his colleagues employed, and continue to employ. He isn’t the only guilty party by a long fucking chalk, but he’s the most prominent, ruthless, and yes, “cartoonishly skeevy.” I wouldn’t mind if he were locked up in a rocket and fired into the sun. Anyhoo! Sorry if my response sounds a little harsh, but I’m between tasks, and when I start to get going on the Read case I can really get wound up, as previously noted!

Björn

No need to apologize! I appreciate the debate. I’ll dig in a bit more, try to go point-by-point somewhat :) ‘Happy to accept' a 25mph SUV clip could kill a man without causing lower-body injuries is strange to me. I’m not sure we should be so quick to accept that when it defies both common sense and expert analysis. If a three-ton Lexus hits a man at 24mph, physics, aswell as common sense, dictates there would be injuries around the waist, right? Shattered femurs, legs, a broken pelvis, or bruising to the torso? John had no broken bones below the neck. That isn't a “defense spin”, it was the finding of the ME. As to the “physics argument” just being a defense strategy: that is just factually incorrect. The expert testimony on physics didn't originate from the Read team - it came from the federal government. The physics experts (the ARCCA labcoats) were hired by the DOJ/FBI, not the defense. The Feds investigated the case, they hired independent engineers, and those engineers said the damage was inconsistent with a vehicle-pedestrian strike. You’re claiming location data rules out John being inside house, while data from (basically) the same source would indicate othrwise. Apple Health recorded John climbing/descending from the equivalent of three flights of stairs after he arrived. Now unless there were invisible stairs on that snowy front lawn, that data puts him inside that multi-story home. You can either cherrypick the data that fits your (anyone’s) version of events, or you can conclude that the datasource (Apple, Health) is unreliable. But if you are to weigh the evidence equally, and you find that the Apple data is accurate, then you have to explain why he climbed those stairs, or at least ascended that distance. Regarding the car data: The 75% throttle log doesnt have a timestamp. The Lexus records “key/ignition cycles”, not clock times. The prosecution had to - pretty much - guess that _this_ exact cycle was the incident, but the key cycle count didn't even match the number of known trips the car took that day (tow truck, drive to parents, etc.). I get why AJ rub some people the wrong way. But Jackson’’s job was to expose a botched investigation. When the lead investigator is trading texts of such a biased and unprofesssional nature while evidence is being handled in solo cups and police testimony changing at the drop of a hat, the defense pretty much has to go on the offensive. As you said, it MUST either be a frame-job or not. I would argue it would be unethical of Jackson, as a defense lawyer, _not_ to highlight potential third parties (altough I agree that the FKR movement has caused tragic damage to innocent and undeserving people). And at last, as to the “what if it were your family” point. I don’t really see the merit in arguing from these points of view if we are discussing guilt or non-guilt in a criminal case (maybe there is, I just don’t see it). BUT. If one of my loved ones were found dead, the greatest injustice would be for the police to put the worst, most biased investigator on the case, pin it on the wrong person due to the sloppiest murder investigation of the century while the actual killer remains in bed. And I would be incensed that I would never see justice. And it would all be on that policeman and the people around and over him, no matter how the death occurred, and no matter how I felt about it.

Björn

By the way, I haven't listened to the Prosecutors podcast yet, but I will. Maybe they'll change my mind. Bonus question: how do you think the civil lawsuit(s) surrounding Karen Read will turn out? and also, to somewhat mirror your last-line apology: "because really, as a creator, what should you be trying to get across to your audience if not the truth as you see it?" - this frame of mind is the reason I look forward to every video you make. love your stuff

bundaga borbo

"You can either cherrypick the data that fits your (anyone’s) version of events, or you can conclude that the datasource (Apple, Health) is unreliable." is kind of a dazzling ultimatum, because of course we can do more than that. who says certain pieces of data can't be more or less reliable than others? if a single bit is off in the digital forensics we have to throw everything out or it'd be fallacious to include any of it? that's a bit nuclear and bad faith, no? if we understand all the digital forensics to be within SOME boundary of reliability, we can take the general impact of all of them together which suggests o'keefe's body stopped moving where it was found shortly after drop off, as it's the explanation which lines up far, far, far more accurately with the whole of the data. it butts against far fewer points of data than any other explanation, and since we know SOME literal, physical occurrence is described by all of these data points, we can use basic deductive conjecture to reason out the most likely such occurrence. but regardless, i am curiously interested in hearing what your timeline would look like. can i ask you to present an affirmative sequence of events that you think the facts, as we are given them, most logically suggests, which positively exonerates karen read?

Björn

Regarding the ultimatum - I agree, there is a third option. Evidence could be produced that proves the dataset to have parts of different quality. Without that evidence, I have to assume that data points from the same digital source would have similar quality / accuracy (if I'm on the jury). "present an affirmative sequence of events that you think the facts, as we are given them, most logically suggests, which positively exonerates Karen Read?" , I don't think anyone can - I certainly can't. I'm not sure I've ever truly considered the "most likely" sequence of events that night. I've just pondered the numerous reasons to doubt

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

One more MASSIVE reply, then I’ll have to make a hard point of bowing out for the time being. Maybe in a year I’ll compile all of these sorts of replies and put them in the post as a sort of Q and A. Paraphrasing: If a 3 ton car hit him, why no lower body injuries? Because it was a clipping - corner of car impacts corner of body. John was spun out and projected backward at high velocity. It’s true that it’s an a-typical outcome for a car impact death, but that’s just owing to the fact it was an a-typical car impact. Not the usual scenario ≠ violates common sense/physics. That is just defense spin. “It was the finding of the ME” is the sort of thing I spoke to in the addendum. FKR will say something like, “The CWs own ME even said it didn’t look like a car impact”...not really…at all. She found there were no injuries of note to the lower body - because there were none, so as the one examining the body, of course that’s what she’s going to find. It’s a fact that’s never been in dispute. Then on the stand, when asked if most car crash victims she’s examined had injuries to the lower body, like what you described, she replied, “yes.” Because most do. And most crash victims have their full bodies impacted by the full body of the car. Total nothing-burger. It’s a great example of how so many FKR talking points turn to dust under the tiniest bit of scrutiny. For further reading, a great “anti” blogger, Mabbe8, did a superb write up on the issue a few weeks ago that breaks things down really concisely in more technical detail than I could ever manage. The only thing I don’t love is their hook about “we can all agree John wasn’t HIT by a car” - being clipped is being hit in my book, but I totally get what they were going for! Link: https://mabbe8.substack.com/p/we-can-all-agree-john-okeefe-wasnt Paraphrasing: The arguments that the CWs theory of the collision violates the laws of physics didn’t originate from the defense, but from ARCCA, an impartial organization hired by the Federal Government. There is *some* truth in this, but that perception lacks a lot of really important context, and the sorts of claims that are spun from ARCCA’s involvement are often heavily exaggerated. Time doesn’t allow me boning up on the intricacies of ARCCA and the feds involvement in the case, but I can give you a decent broad strokes rundown. There’s been accusations out there that the Fed probe was actually initiated through direct finagling from the defense through their contacts. I don’t believe that’s been proven, but I can say it was sparked by legal filings and other noises from the FKR side. In short, a whole bunch of people are saying there’s a murder coverup in Mass, and the local, even state authorities are in on that coverup. If the Feds catch wind of that, it would make sense they’d want to look into if there was a there there, and fair enough too. Very much within their purview. For what it’s worth, the investigation has been closed for some time with no wrong doing found from any of the named suspects, or corruption from any of the investigative bodies. Now while that investigation was ongoing, ARCCA were indeed hired by the feds to look at the vehicle damage, John’s injuries, and so forth, and ARCCA did indeed find what was in front of them was broadly inconsistent with what they’d expect to see from vehicle impacts at the sorts of speeds posited by the CW - basically the damage and injuries were too minor. Thing is though, those initial findings were based on typical expectations from typical collisions. So we circle right back to the a-typical collision issue again. In those preliminary findings, the origin for those, “ARCCA have said CWs theory violates the rules of physics!” proclamations, ARCCA weren’t attempting to look at the outcome through the specific lens of a clipping collision - the CWs actual theory, but rather just collision outcomes in the main (usually full body/full car impacts). And even THEN, the “breaks the rules of physics” stuff is still FKR bluster. ARCCA have never at any point used that sort of definitive language - just “inconsistent” and things of that flavor. But anyhoo - regardless, the sorts of above mentioned findings were obviously a promising lead to the defense, so they got in touch with the ARCCA guys, and ARCCA’s direct relationship with the defense developed from there. And from there, they were working for the defense, not the federal government. There’s often a positioning that outfits testifying for the CW (ARCCAs counterpart being Aperture) are the CWs people, and will be biased in favor of them, while ARCCA are a totally impartial body accountable only to the federal government, who will never slant their methods in favor of the side putting them on the stand. I see no reason to accept that, and indeed I think things we have them on the record as doing, like bypassing rules of disclosure by communicating with the defense through encrypted messaging apps, and choosing a significantly lighter dummy arm to run their experiments on, when an arm with a closer weight to JOKs was readily available - show they are as slanted toward their side as just about any other expert witness you could care to mention. More so, I’d argue, especially if we’re doing a one to one comparison with Aperture. Though I will concede the CW wouldn’t put Aperture on the stand if their findings weren't at least broadly in their favor. That much is sort of always true of both sides, and why you should take most EWs with at least a grain of salt - especially if you’re being asked to trust their authority more than the specifics of their actual work. Anyhoooooooooo - by the time we get to Trial 2, ARCCA were running tests with more of an eye on the CWs specific theory, and while they were willing to sit on the stand and say that magical word, “inconsistent” - the fact of the matter is their tests most closely mimicking the posited conditions yielded strikingly similar results. You can say, “well, the diffusers weren’t broken” or point to anything else that shows the outcomes to be less than totally identical…but “not totally identical” is a far cry from “inconsistent” in my book. And a much further cry from “physically impossible”, which I’ll point out again, is purely FKR bluster representing ARCCAs findings. ARCCA themselves have never, on or off the stand, issued any proclamation that John meeting his fate by way of an impact from Karen Read’s Lexus is fundamentally incompatible with the laws of physics. The most they’ve said is basically that if it happened that way, what we see is not typically what they would expect the outcome to be. In a vacuum, I can see how that much of a finding (should I actually agree with it) could be cause for some doubt. But not in a vacuum, relative to the avalanche of evidence against Karen previously outlined, “that’s not what you’d normally expect it to look like” is an extremely underwhelming piece of evidence, even if accepted as true. I mean, with that sort of standard, you could just about be caught on video shooting a guy, and still be acquitted if anything about the state of his body, or the bullet, or what have you, was relatively anomalous to what’s typical in such shootings. Anomalous outcomes of various sorts crop up in all kinds of situations due to innumerable variables that are impossible to completely model for. “Apple Health recorded John climbing/descending from the equivalent of three flights of stairs after he arrived.” You’re mistaken on this. John and Karen arrived at 12:24 AM and something seconds - we know this from both John’s cel data and Karen’s Lexis data, so we’ve got a very good handle on their time of arrival. At the conclusion of John’s 36 steps (12:32:16), his phone registered no movement until being recovered from beneath his body the next morning. If there were stair climbs registered after that point, I absolutely would have mentioned it, because the above statement would be contradicted by that occurrence. The stair climbs were registered at 12:22 AM - so, while Karen and John were still in Karen's car. Obviously there’s not a flight of stairs in Karen’s Lexus. The explanation for the event is that iPhones sometimes have these events triggered by sudden changes in elevation, which makes sense, because you wouldn’t expect phones to be scanning for actual physical stairs. So hilly terrain on the way to Fairview is what caused the stair climb event. It couldn’t have been John going down into or up from the Albert’s basement (the theory the defense was trying to get at, though it seems they’ve actually switched to the garage now - lol) because John hadn’t even gotten to the outside of the Albert residence at that time, much less inside of it. So just to reiterate: John’s phone recorded zero movement after his final steps. There is no data from his phone, or any other source I’m aware of, that contradicts that. --- Paraphrasing: Timestamps for Karen’s Lexus events aren’t reliable. A quick point on the 24 m/h reverse at 75% throttle, because I don’t have time to do an extra dive on just how precisely we’re able to calculate the exact time it was initiated, and through what methodology - I think this is a great example of how spoiled we are with evidence in this case, and the modern day in general. Would you not concede that a reverse at 24 m/h with the gas peddle down three thirds of the way is a highly abnormal, and indeed violent/reckless maneuver? Just the knowledge that Read did that at some point that night, is in and of itself extremely damning. Obviously if it was 100% confirmed she did it at say 1 AM, or 12 AM, then we’d have to concede it was just a shocking coincidence. But if the objection is not that, and merely that, “well you haven’t shown to a scientific certainly that it was indeed initiated at the time JUST before John’s phone stops moving” - the fact such an abnormal, dangerous reverse maneuver occurred some time in the window where John’s phone stopped moving, coupled with the fact he was found lying on top of that phone with pieces of shattered tail light around his body, is enough to extrapolate what must have happened by putting 1, 2 and 3 together. It’s the only explanation that works unless you either a) just dismiss all the data points arbitrarily, or b) accept them, but try to entertain a scenario where Karen reverses like a maniac, but doesn’t hit anything and drives off without incident shortly before some psycho walks up behind John and smacks him in the back of the head with a brick or something, and then Karens’ tail light gets extra coincidentally broken by some other means some time in the hours that follow. Both approaches of course are simply unreasonable. Paraphrasing: If it were my loved one who died, and a person in the position of Karen were acquitted, I would be incensed by the sloppy investigation, like the collection of evidence in solo cups and assigning of a biased detective. So this is why I wanted to put that to you. While I’m not able to prove it, I would honestly just about bet my life that’s not really how you’d see things if you actually had skin in the game. The investigation wasn’t especially sloppy, and certainly not the sloppiest of the 21st century. The police got the call, arrived on scene, collected what they could, were somewhat hampered by snowfall, but basically got all their ducks in a row at a reasonable pace - sometimes it’s claimed no tail light was found for 24, 48 plus hours, but that’s a myth. The first pieces were discovered that afternoon/early evening with Karen’s Lexus arriving at Sallyport only 10 minutes earlier, as documented in my video. Proctor was called on to the case very early - a state trooper recruited especially to avoid the perception of/actual bias, because he was outside of Canton and didn’t have any links of note to the involved parties. The main attack against him on a background level is that his sister is very good friends with Brian Albert’s sister-in-law. So Chris Albert’s wife, and Colin Albert’s mother. Bear in mind, there wasn’t any sort of suggestion from anyone that Colin or Chris were involved that early in the investigation. As a matter of fact, there weren’t any allegations that any of the Albert’s, or anyone gathered at Fairview the previous evening were involved. FKR just insist they should have been treated as suspects as standard protocol, even though the body was found outside, out front, and Karen, at a bare minimum, was yelling at multiple people that she could have hit him. What I’m getting at is putting Proctor on the case that morning couldn’t easily be seen as a conflict of interest with what all the key players knew at the time, and you can see how even Proctor himself wouldn’t view the crime scene being the front lawn belonging to the brother in law of his sister’s good friend as a potential can of worms - hindsight is 20/20, and even with it the link is pretty damn weak. So anyway, Proctor, and other personnel interviewed all the key witnesses, collected relevant evidence in a timely manner, and put a theory of the case together based on all the information that was coming to them - by and large textbook, not sloppy or bungled. And over the course of things, Proctor made some wise cracks about Karen Read’s bunghole, among other disparaging remarks, in a group chat with some of his high school friends. That much, I’ll grant you, was certainly unprofessional. Although, I must say, what REALLY gets my goat about it, is that the most severe transgression in Proctor’s actions was sharing privileged details of an active murder investigation with his totally unauthorised personal friends. That’s the really big no-no. In terms of expressing strong, negative, personal feelings against the person he’s investigating - eh. Yeah, you should definitely endeavour to speak as professionally about such people as you can, especially when there’s some chance what you’re saying could ever be committed to record. I’m not aware of any rule that you’re not allowed to have personal animus against someone you’re investigating, though. And if we’re being real, most detectives probably feel quite negatively about their prime suspects, no? Given the witness statements, interactions with Read, and other info he would have been getting back then, I can totally see why he would view her as a “whack job c**t” - Again, I grant you he shouldn’t have expressed as much that way in that forum, but it’s not much of a basis to believe he framed her, and much less of a basis to discount evidence Proctor had absolutely zero control over. One last specific thing you name checked: the solo cups. Something I sort of joked about still not getting to at the end of the addendum, and a very low priority for me in addressing this case. It was an extremely minor aspect of the investigation. In short, responding officers noticed blood in the snow when on scene, and with active snowfall, if they wanted to preserve it, they had to act quick - like right away. There was no time to run back to the station and grab a more formal evidence collecting mechanism, so they scooped up the blood stained snow in some solo cups that happened to be in the back of a cruiser. The blood stained snow was never a key piece of evidence in any event. So when I ask you to imagine it was a loved one of yours at the center of all this, what I’m getting at is that if it were, and someone with the same magnitude of evidence against them as Read were let off the hook, if you’re really saying you believe your reaction would be something to the effect of, “it’s all the police’s fault for assigning that detective, and opting to collect blood stained snow in solo cups”, and that rather than be outraged the accused was walking free, you’d have a sick feeling the real killer might still be out there on account of these supposed missteps…I’m sorry, my friend, but I cannot believe for a moment those would really be your sentiments in the real world. That’s why not a single family member or close friend of John O’Keefe has ever had the time of day for any of this stuff. When you’ve actually got skin in the game, you don’t treat things that frivolously. You don’t “weigh all evidence equally” - something the appeal to solo cups is a classic example of. And yeah, I do think the jury in this case treated their duty frivolously, and it’s quite clear at least a couple of them outright lied (about their familiarity with the case among other things) during jury selection. So in regards to the outcome of the civil trial - I don’t know if I’d say I’m pessimistic per se. There’s always hope, and I think the O’Keefe’s at least seem to have put together an impressive team. We’ll need to wait and see what shape the witnesses’ war efforts take in court, and I wish them nothing but the best. The case against Karen merely needs to be proven to a 51 percent degree of probability in the eyes of 10/12 jurors (I think I’ve got that right), so, I mean, given I think the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard for Murder 2 is a slam dunk, personal liability on the civil standard would be…I don’t know what, a 2mm putt? But the defense's main strategy in all of this is jury tainting by trying the case outside of court. It’s already proven successful in criminal proceedings, and there’s no reason it can’t be successful in the civil proceedings. A tainted jury is a tainted jury, and if they can willfully ignore the instructions under one standard, they can just as easily do so under another, lower standard. So yeah, the O’Keefe’s, and the witnesses, have the same A-Grade evidence as before, and a much easier standard, which is very helpful. But what they REALLY need is a better jury, which is easier said than done. So again, I’m not pessimistic exactly, but definitely guarded in my expectations. Time will tell. Now I truly do need to walk away from any more dialogue on this case, because when I start talking about it, one thing always leads to another and my output just balloons, and balloons, and I really need to dedicate all my attention to the current project. If you have more questions about the case, I recommend having a look at the substack I mentioned earlier from Mabbe, as well as AnonyMassLawyer. Whatever you may be thinking of, chances are they’ve spoken to it in more detail than I could even if I had the time. I’ll note too, the quality of writing (and reasoning!) from them is just head and shoulders above anything I’ve ever seen on the FKR side - and that’s gotta count for something! https://substack.com/@mabbe8/posts https://substack.com/@anonymasslawyer/posts

Björn

Appreciate it - but I just can't help myself from responding - maybe you'll get a moment to read it in the future. First, I don't think any impartial and reasonable person would frame ARCCAs analysis as concluding that a collision strictly 'defies the laws of physics' or is entirely impossible. If that’s the hyperbolic spin the defense puts on it in court, that’s their business as advocates. But at the end of the day, it’s not the defense's job to prove a collision is physically impossible; it's the government's burden to prove it did happen, beyond a reasonable doubt. It is also their burden to prove the reverse wasn't a wheel-spin while stuck in the snow, or happening while being towed, or any other reasonable explanation. And if you are going to point out that Dr. Wolfe routinely deletes his text threads with attorneys, we have to recognize the difference between an independent expert purging informal, post-report attorney communications (standard practice to avoid draft ideas being misconstrued, see https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_26 , scroll to b4) and actual police officers destroying primary evidence in an active murder investigation. As for ARCCA using an 'encrypted app' (Signal) to communicate and supposedly bypass disclosure: iMessage, WhatsApp, and Facebook Messenger are also all end-to-end encrypted. You know what else bypasses written disclosure? A regular phone call. I fail to see anything inherently suspicious about experts using standard modern communication tools, nor does it violate any ethical guidelines that I'm aware of. Framing Trooper Proctor texts as just 'a guy' unprofessionally venting about a suspect: The Massachusetts State Police clearly disagreed, officially terminating him. Proctor appealed his firing, but dropped his appeal entirely when even more inappropriate texts were discovered in his cloud data, causing his own police union to withdraw their support. At this point, Proctor himself doesn't even defend Proctor. And just recently - speaking of missing phones - it came out that Proctor conveniently 'lost' his phone (the phones seem to be real slippery in Massachusetts ;) ), which is now actively delaying Reads lawsuit: https://www.masslive.com/news/2026/02/former-mass-state-police-troopers-lost-phone-among-issues-delaying-karen-read-lawsuit.html . This, in my opinion, is evidence that he clearly does not respect the rule of law and apparently does not even care about the perception of respecting due process. Finally, regarding the 'what if it were your family' point: you are right that in the moment, I wouldn't be coldly analyzing police procedure. My anger would obviously be directed at whoever I believed killed someone I love, and I would be incensed if they walked free. But looking at it objectively, the reason that hypothetical family is denied justice is entirely due to the nature of the investigation. Now, let me flip that: If your mother, sister, or daughter were being investigated for a crime, would you want Michael Proctor assigned to the case? Would you expect them to be treated with basic dignity and respect, let alone investigated fairly, by a man who jokes about searching a suspect's phone for nudes, assures his friends the homeowner 'won't catch any shit,' and then mysteriously loses his own phone when he's finally being held accountable? That isn't personal buffoonery - it is a complete corruption of the investigative process. If Karen Read is innocent, the family doesn't get justice because the police refused to investigate the house or other potential culprits. If Karen is guilty, the family still doesn't get justice because the police conducted an investigation so compromised that it handed the defense all the reasonable doubt they needed on a silver platter. Either way, the failure is the government's. I appreciate the back-and-forth! Good luck with your current project - I look forward to seeing it!

Queen of Hearts

If multiple grown men were beating the shit out of him then he would have had broken bones, plus if a dog was mauling him he’d have deep scratches, clearly obvious bites, and torn flesh. If the reverse were from being towed it’d be clocked hours after it was. The phone getting lost and the firing aren’t evidence of anything nefarious. I find the reaching people do in defending Karen pretty absurd to the point of being infuriating. If the argument was that drunk ass John was too sloshed find the door, fell over a few times in the snow, failed to find Karen’s car before she left, and passed out drunk in a snowstorm, I could see finding her innocent. Shit happens. I don’t see any possible world where the homeowners, the police, the EMTs, the desk lady, several minors including the now twice orphaned niece and nephew, the dog, the medical examiner, God Himself, the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker all got together to plot against one affluent white lady. It’s not that the family didn’t get justice, what they got was a harassment campaign stoked and encouraged by Karen and her team. Fuck, people are genuinely saying that Matt is pro cop because he didn’t believe Karen as though the George Floyd video never happened. This all just feels like the same people who disregard it whenever a person of color or a poor person is brutalized or falsely convicted suddenly deciding that police corruption matters now that it’s one of them. Dragging in the Birchmore case too like Sarah’s life only matters as a prop

Queen of Hearts

The Right Opinion is something of a drama channel, not MAGA

Björn

If multiple men were beating the shit out of him, he would have had broken bones. And if a dog was _mauling_ him, he would have obvious bites. The theory from the defense was that John was hit once and fell back (I believe I remember that right). And if a dog bit him once, those were the marks that would result (according to Dr. Russell). Coverup: A cover-up or a botched case doesn't require all participants to be in on it. It only requires one or two people, or small groups of people, to lie to protect themselves, and a heavily biased or corrupt part of investigative team. The EMTs and dispatchers aren't "in on it" - they're just operating downstream from a fundamentally compromised investigation. "It’s not that the family didn’t get justice, what they got was a harassment campaign stoked and encouraged by Karen and her team": Ok, but that doesn't really speak one way or another towards her guilt or non-guilt. Unless, of course, if you think she would have been convicted _but for_ the media coverage (which I disagree with considering there is no evidence AFAIK to support that notion, and plenty of evidence against it - e.g. the three post-trial juror interviews). "Dragging in the Birchmore case too like Sarah’s life only matters as a prop": I've never heard of this case, sadly. I am not saying I know what happened, or even that this is the most likely scenario - I think she probably (a significant probably) struck him. All I'm saying is that she wasn't guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I'm not defending her, and I'm not pro-defense. If anything I would say I'm just pro-due-process (not very punchy, sure, but you understand what I mean).

Jack

Don't choke, mate

Björn

I have read both Substack pages you posted Matt , and while mabbe8 seems to be written by AI, anonymasslawyer seems to be really well put together. It's made me far more uneasy about my position. Was all of this data actually presented during trial - did I just overlook it? Was it poorly presented? (thinking particularly about the key cycles). I think I might have to rewatch it before discussing anything further...

Evan

Second this! As one of what feels like very few people who think they are guilty I'd love to hear his opinions. For me, Damien's medical history and first police interview convince me without a shadow of a doubt he did it but probably isn't enough for a court case.

Evan

For myself, any conspiracy that requires more than 3 people to keep their mouths shut is just a non-starter. As the number of people involved goes up there is just far too many variables to ever keep it under control.

Queen of Hearts

1. If he was only hit once under this theory, then how were they sure he was dead? All those people were lying in wait to hit him exactly once, let a pupper nip at him once, and then drop him in a snow bank? 2. Your point about the coverup is just wrong. Yes, in theory a conspiracy only takes one or two people. The theory being presented here by the defense requires the entirety of Boston’s emergency services apparatus to be in on it. That’s why they’re grilling Kelly so bad, they’re using her misremembering what she saw that day as proof that her superiors told her to lie as part of the cover up. 3. I said absolutely nothing about whether the media impacted her conviction or acquittal. I was talking about people like Turtle Boy going up to the people she accused, including minors, and harassing them in real life. I’m talking about people slandering orphans as bad people for not worshipping at the altar of Karen. She has had every opportunity to speak out against this and tell people like Turtle Boy to stop and yet she hasn’t. She rewards channels that spread misinformation with interviews. I really don’t see why someone who is innocent would be pissing on John’s loved ones this much. 4. Karen has been given due process. Karen has been given far more due process than someone who was poor or a minority or heaven forbid trans would get in this situation. Karen got way more doubt than is reasonable.

Queen of Hearts

Respectfully, as someone who isn’t convinced of their guilt, what is it about his medical history that you find compelling? Admittedly as the daughter of a nurse I kinda grew up around psychology and medicine, plus being born in the 2000s when goth kids went from being scary to being cringey at worst, it’s hard for me to look at these three and feel threatened or intimidated by them in the slightest. It’s been a while since I looked at his records, most I can find is that he was depressed, bit somebody, and (correctly) said his stepdad was a child molester

Steve

Revisiting this I really think Proctor must be why the jury did not convict.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

You're being too generous to the jury lol. Watch that interview clip with what's her face juror at the end of the main video again. The jury was clearly tainted by the propaganda Read's team had been putting out there. The foreman has said ridiculous things on record too - like that he "saw what was going on" after the state put on their very first witness...The medic who heard Read say "I hit him" 3 times. New (not Read!) bonus comin in 2-3 days :)

Jordan Post

Anyone else think she backed into John's car on purpose

itssomethingabout_mary

I love your content. Hate your takes on this case. It was bound to happen sometime. At the end of the day, no conspiracy, no nonsense, even stripping away most of the case, the cops in this case are extremely corrupt. The prosecution was slimy. Reasonable doubt was there. The prosecution couldn't prove it, and they didn't deserve it. Still adore your other content though!

Conman

The Cumtown reference was such a flashbang lmfao (also this video convinced me thank you)

Jordan Post

I found the Karen read defenders not only pick and choose the evidence that works for their arguments but also straight up lie they claim phone evidence shows John was inside the house and even went in the basement 😂

maetreon

TRO is english and seemingly very progressive, iirc he’s a gay man

Hank J. Wimbleton

I think the idea of a bunch of crooked cops covering up a murder or accidental killing is totally believable IF the facts indicate such a thing happened. But I was thinking about this case the other day, and sort of just went, "you know, she probably did just drill him with her car, probably by accident while drunk, and he died out there in the snow". When you cut through all the theorizing and fanfic writing, and look at things as they appear, that's just the logical endpoint you reach.

Gilbert Aquino

Coming in late to this addendum. I guess I'm on the fence now, but I do have to take issue with the Commonwealth vs. skeevy lawyers part. Not in defense of Jackson, but taking these two ideas as equivalent. A corrupt government is an ongoing issue that affects every single person in a jurisdiction/state/nation. A high-priced unethical defense team at worst helps a guilty person get away with something. One is much worse if you are interested in justice as a whole. The government is supposed to be there for the good of all not for those who work for the government above others.

Jess of the Planet

Tardy to the party (just joined, obsessed with your addendums), but just gotta say about your mass delusion point—broooooooooooo you shoulda been here for OJ 🤣🤣🤣 I watched that shit on tv while babysitting as a young teen & it. Was. Wild. I have yet to see anything beat it, on so many levels. It’s why I’m here, more or less (the case, not the delusion).

chavonwright

The EMPHASIS is for the jury. Because there could be people like you who believed John was hit by a car. So ya gotta slow things down and make the jury hear what you need them to. Ya know. Like the entire meaning of emphasis.

chavonwright

Also, you are saying his name incorrectly. And I am genuinely flabbergasted that you are criticizing such a brilliant lawyer. It is so annoying hearing you say moving like that. That cross was amazing.

chavonwright

Sorry, you are just going to keep being on my nerves hopefully on for this segment, but the REASON why its so important that they know it wasn't in the report is because.....think hard....they heard testimony about the report the day before. So what he is saying to the jury is: Listen carefully, because if you came to any conclusions yesterday, this same expert has information that he was not questioned about that you need to hear. I cant tell if you are just doing that like play both sides bit, but it's embarrassing. Because he's a lawyer and you are....whatever this is because it is not what's on your main channel, you are thinking he is doing what you are. Bring critical when not necessary, trying to pull off some gotcha with the defense. He's speaking to the jury and you do not understand his style at all so it stinks to hear you talking about it.

chavonwright

So, in America, the defense has to prove, nothing. Are you sure, beyond a reasonable doubt, that he didn't put his phone down on a table right when he got inside? well of course you aren't. Because you are saying theoretically as a pejorative, despite the fact that both the defense and prosecution are sharing....theories. Lol, I gotta get out of your commentary so I can just keep enjoying the way you share other people's research.

Queen of Hearts

The only one really embarrassing themselves here is you. The patronizing attitude is a bad look.

Dustin Anderson

Matt, have you ever considered covering both sides of the Woody Allen allegations? Your discussion of both implanted memory and media influence on common opinion in this commentary made me think of that, and I think it would be a good way to discuss those and similar topics. Though, I reckon if you came to the conclusion that you agree with the Woody did nothing wrong camp, you would risk losing face with a lot of viewers. I don’t have a full opinion myself, but I think it would make for a good MOCAS video.

DL

My overarching view is that I am ultimately fine with the outcome even if she did do it (and Im fairly certain she did). Mostly because hopefully it gets the cops to stick to the procedures in place. If this was a well run investigation, there’s no way she wins at trial. I do feel differently about some cases. Currently studying for the bar, and last summer I worked on a CSA case involving a 8 year old girl and her two teenage brothers. Wasn’t prosecuted until 5 years later, and the victim didn’t have super clear memory. One of them almost got off because the sheriff didnt think to mirandize him before locking him in the back of his cruiser and interrogating him for 45 minutes. Luckily he pled guilty, but to think that he would get to walk free made me so angry, especially knowing he had kids of his own. I’m not especially worried about Karen reoffending

Erin

Late on commenting i know. But I swear after watching matt's original video i thought Karen was innocent. Maybe I'm remembering wrong? Or was that his intention?

Emily

That's my recollection of it. But I was already familiar with the trials before watching, so I still am on the side of not guilty. Conspiracy or not the cops bungled it from the start.

Livia L.

Absolutely great addendum! This just pushes me further in the direction of 'she did it, but with the amount of police misconduct, I'm not surprised she was found not guilty' Cheers!

Sherri

I just want To have you reply to me. This particular case is the same old… you get what you pay for. Casey Anthony, OJ Simpson, Karen Read among others. I sincerely enjoy your videos and have just last week purchased the bargain $2 Patreon. I hope to read from you. 😊

Queen of Hearts

The problem is that “reasonable doubt” requires some aspect of the conspiracy. For her to not be the one that hit him, intentionally or unintentionally, there needs to be a whole fuck ton of people up to and including God in on a conspiracy against Karen Read. It’s not like there’s anyone else that could have hit him and as far as we know he can’t have just passed out in the snow on his own. The cops being corrupt isn’t itself a reason for reasonable doubt

Queen of Hearts

What is this a reference to? It’s been living rent free in my head for months

itssomethingabout_mary

Actually the reasonable doubt is that a car crash did not cause John's injuries. That's it.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It depends what we're calling a "car crash" - In broad strokes, the corner of John's body was impacted by the corner of Read's SUV, spinning him out and throwing him back at high velocity. The resultant injury to the back of his head when it impacted the hard, frozen ground is what ultimately caused his death. He also sustained cuts to his arm in the process, likely mostly from the tail light braking over his arm. He did not have injuries consistent with a typical car crash, i.e. he was not "run over", nor was his full body impacted by the full body of the car. Because of those narrow sorts of facts people sometimes try to represent the situation as "the scientists have eliminated the possibility of a car being involved" - but that just isn't true. You won't be able to find ARCCA making a claim so bold or explicit. They make much narrower, qualified findings like, "inconsistent", "not what I'd expect" and then the twitter people pump that up to 11.

A

There's this comedy podcast called "Cum Town" that has a bit where he has an insane trial lawyer

Sherri

Nah. I'm just leaving a note. You give some good insights into the true crime you cover. Plus you crack me up. Have a great day.

Sherri

i.e., Darlie Routier about the outside gate still not opening correctly, "It was just one fucking thing after another."

Koda Chimera

For me the conspiracy angle was interesting, and somewhat plausible until I stopped at some point and remembered that this was the DEFENSE making these claims. Reminding myself exactly WHO was presenting this narrative was definitely helpful in taking a more objective, critical approach to the case. As soon as I remembered whose story this was I was like “oh god, it’s like Casey Anthony all over again” with the defense coming out swinging with a crazy alternative scenario to the much more straightforward one already alleged. But the alternative scenario is so batshit insane you’re just along for the ride until you get a chance to think it over.

Ethan Wendt

Not at all, but he does a masterful job of laying out both sides to not offend anyone coming in with a preconceived notion. If you pay attention towards the end he makes it clear that you have to suspend an inordinate amount of disbelief to think Karen is innocent.

Cole

lmao the cumtown reference! (1:04:14)

Annette Palmer

Yep, this has been my feeling all along. Completely plausible that she hit him by accident. And if this is what happened, the cops messed up the investigation so badly, justice was never going to be had.

Margaret Graham

Respectfully: it's not really totally believable though, is it? You know the old adage "2 people can keep a secret if one of them is dead?" I've always found that to be overwhelmingly true. You're asking me to believe that upwards of 40 people can keep a secret? I just don't. And that's my problem with conspiracy theories in general.

Queen of Hearts

If it wasn’t a car crash and wasn’t the conspiracy then there’s no reasonable explanation for the injuries.

Margaret Graham

I can believe Echols or even maybe Miskelly could do this. But I've just never been able to make myself believe that Jason Baldwin would. The argument seems to be that "Jason would do whatever Damien told him to" but...this?

Dobert

i laughed at the wkuk reference and then exploded at you playing the actual clip. You've got great taste as always mate

Margaret Graham

Oh he offended SO MANY people. "I'm going to have this video taken down!" "You're being paid by the BPD!" And yeah, I'm going to judge them: these are people who are used to existing inside a bubble, with a clear divide between good guys and bad guys, bad guys safely on the outside and flying enemy colors. And Matt being able to scramble their usual binary organizational structure was a thing of beauty. The idea that a smart and educated person could disagree with them about something. Acknowledging this is such a critical part of growing up. That's why this is one of my favourites; it serves a far greater good.

Eythan Slootweg

i'm really glad you did this, after watching the main video i read the comments and thought maybe you'd gotten it wrong. the caveats that linger in my mind are for one that all the facts clearly demonstrate his *phone* never went inside the house, and for two that i'm unclear on whether karen started freaking out about maybe hitting him *after* noticing the broken taillight or if that started before she saw it.

Eythan Slootweg

having written it out and thought about it more, i do think it's clear he also didn't go inside the house. particularly because the phone gets colder after he's moved, indicating he must have been on top of it all night. i'm not convinced either way on whether or not karen read intentionally did it or if she even knew she did.

Semilocon

Finally got around to watching this and wow. I didn't know anything at all about the context and the whole "fandom" around the case, so I was very surprised that there are people defending her. The critiques on the true crime space are spot-on.

Ravelineffm

Couldn’t agree more. Thanks for sharing your view