Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey guys!Wanted to get a feedback thread going for Smutrot specifically as we gear up to launch the series to the public in the next week. Please provide concise and targetted feedback on the show (let us know if you enjoyed the pilot episode), as well as suggestions for FUTURE fan-fictions and short stories that YOU think are a good fit for the show!Provide as many as you want to, I'm going to compile a master list of the most requested stories that we can read through on the show. These should be either hilariously bad or hilariously smutty. 

Thanks,Jackson 

Files

Comments

Eric

The typing noise gotta go

Bruh

Honestly an absolute banger episode, perhaps some genuinely horrific booktok smut?

Eric

U are my sweet prince Jackson

Devin Buzzard

It was a great show really funny and enjoyed it

r1cktilian

woah is that creepcast

r1cktilian

can we get an american on the show 🙏

Alex Kostiuk

Don’t burn yourself out Jackson

theofficialpodcast

Maybe as guests in the future if the show gets enough street cred. -J

Zack

I really enjoyed the first episode. I think you guys should consider doing some crappypasta’s as well could definitely fit multiple of them into one episode.

Johnathon Stultz

Don’t listen to him, as an American I love the Aussie charm

missmosh

I LOVE the podcast. Where you might find gold is Kpop fanfic on Wattpad, or fanfiction.net especially the 2009-2011 era. I’d love if you guys also did really shit creepypasta reads, but I also get if that may be stepping on Wendigoons toes. Jordan would be a TREAT reading Jeff The Killer

Dave Matthews

First of, I loved the first episode, and the series idea as a whole is hilarious. As for feedback, I think the only important one I can provide is: when you take suggested stories, just make sure the story doesn’t fall into the “so bad it’s boring” category. There’s a very thin line between so bad it’s funny and so bad this is a slog and unlistenable. Other than that though, all I can say is the banter is great and I love the format

ScoobyDorg

Twas an enjoyable listen whilst at work

Kaiden Miller

I really enjoyed it, would be nice to try to get a variety of others hosts to do this. You and Jordies are really funny but more voices would be great.

r1cktilian

ima be honest with you i love the both of you don’t get me wrong, i just dont think you guys should cover creepypasts. Creepcast has gone over a lot of creepypastas already, me personally i wouldn’t listen to ones they have already covered. all in all good show 🙏

Johnathon Stultz

I actually like the typing noise, but it could be something different. idk if you’ve ever watched Are You Scared from Watcher but when they’re reading the story they have some background light music and a few sound effects that go along with the story. And when they start talking it stops and kinda flips. That might be cool for the show! Otherwise great work!!

r1cktilian

it’s not a hate comment so chill lol i’m just fr giving feed back cause i barely listen to red thread anymore after the only 2 americans left sorry

r1cktilian

sometimes ima be honest i cant tell them apart at times when im not really paying attention

missmosh

Under the protection of Patreon, and this isn’t public, creepcast is getting there. I think they went too hard with too many icons and are now getting a bit burned out. They could make a fucking lame story very entertaining, but it not QUITE what it used to be. I think Jordan has the ability to keep It from being a “book club” and more entertaining

Chloe💕Louise

Absolutely loved it! Id say about taking the typing noises out but I know you were already looking at that! Id love to see you do more of My Immortal too, I was loving it and it was very nostalgic for me 😂

missmosh

2nd! I like having an Australian podcast without Americans. No hate to them, but it has a different charm

Johnathon Stultz

Wattpad is a gold mine for shitty fanfics lmao, but also as far as stepping on wendigoons toes, anyone can read an online story lol, even if it’s already been read by someone else I’d still rather listen to Jackson and Jordy read it. And hear their jokes and input on it

theofficialpodcast

We don't plan on doing horror stories or such, outside of maybe a few Halloween themed episodes if the show lasts that long. We plan on delivering on the more fanfic and erotic niches.

missmosh

I just don’t know if they’re still friends and the fact they did Red Thread together. If that never happened it would be fair game.

James Becker

No feedback. Just wanted to say I liked it

r1cktilian

oh hell yeah!!! can’t wait for more than, i appreciate how much effort you put into all the shows man much love 🙏❤️

Johnathon Stultz

I mean obviously I don’t know the details but he stepped away. I don’t think he’d care and if he did I feel like he doesn’t have a right to really be upset about it. Idk I never really liked wendigoon in the first place and im happy with red thread because I like Jackson and Jordy, I do miss Charlie, but the two of them put on a great show! And I love the episodes with Jackson’s fiancé as well

Mikesome13

Jackson-sama what happened to the min min lights video 🥹 also loved smutrot while stuck in bumper to bumper traffic on i75

Cheesed

Do an episode in your best ASMR voices

TV RTA

Jackson honey, you’re a terrific podcast host and writer, you’ve done a great job. You and… fuck uhh JORDAN yeah, are great and your ideas make this patron subscription worth it. Keep it up

missmosh

Totally agree! I think they have the chemistry to take shit fan fics to the next level. C.C had to calm down because it got SO big, authors were getting butt hurt. I cannot imagine Jordan ever giving a shit and keeping us fun. Especially if Kaya got into the mix of not caring about hurting peoples feelings. For Wendi, no idea if they’re still friends, but I think him and Jordan would make it hilarious and extremely entertaining.

Ethan Richard

Loved it! Great vibes really fun and chill great anytime

missmosh

You also brought up a great point, bringing Keera in once on a while to laugh about “most girls do NOT think like that” or “care about that”. She’s a hilarious middlewoman

Chris

Oh man Jackson if you want to enter the smutrot goldmine. Search up FimFiction and pick any clopfic you want

Lillian

yes!! it was so funny! do a my little pony one lol

coffee_knife

Absolutely loving this series so please keep it going, esp. with My Immortal. Couple of recs that come to mind: - Sonic High School - My Inner Life (Zelda self insert) - After (One Direction self insert) I’ll circle back if I think of any others folks haven’t mentioned.

E

I just realized you both have J names, it could be either of you commenting

The Possum King (DillaDong)

Really liked smutrot, had me cracking up at work for the whole episode. I'm excited for what y'all do with it

Owen Cook

My first thought oh this is just gonna be weird hear the boys read porn but if you guys keep it too the goofy dogshit one written by teens who hate their loving parents it’s gonna be peak shit was so funny lowkey gonna relisten to it rn otw home

Roman Achille

Pleeeeeaaaasse finish My Immortal, I hope that's in the cards. That's all I have to add. Good episode guys.

Ben Crawford

I definitely enjoyed the first episode and im looking forward to more! Definitely lean into the voice acting more it's very funny

theofficialpodcast

What AI? We haven't used any AI for any Smutrot related content, or any other content.

mason

it was good and i liked it and more would be awesome

SugmaNard

How was the thumbnail for the video made?

SugmaNard

It looks extremely like AI

SugmaNard

I just dont see how thats not AI that looks exactly like an AI generated image

theofficialpodcast

We commissioned a verified artist to create the thumbnail in his style. If he used AI in his work, I'd be surprised. The style is just typical YouTube style (what works on YouTube currently).

AntonisXXIV

Maybe even venture off into the adventures of sonichan being along the same lines

alycat

Absolutely loved it. It was sooooo funny and brought back a good yet cringey feeling of nostalgia for early tumblr and being 13. My personal favorite was the supernatural fanfiction Twist and Shout. It was the big Dean+Castiel smut fan fic on watpad

hoodie_hung

"Ill let this slide" imagine thinking youre this important then being wrong about your accusation lmao

Bo Timbles

I really enjoyed it, maybe solely because it was Harry Potter but surely other IP’s would follow suit with entertainment

SugmaNard

Its a reasonable suspicion

SugmaNard

I'd be interested to know how he made yours and jordies face without ai. Are those original pictures that were edited? Where do the original photos come from. Its clearly not painted. So it has to be either photoshop or AI. Maybe looking into how this thumbnail was created isnt a terrible idea. Surely you can see where I come from. Id love to be wrong

SugmaNard

Drop the artists name so we can atleast view their other works.

SugmaNard

Prove my accusation isnt AI atleast if you have something to say then hoodie. I would love for it to be handmade but all I see is like exact bit for bit AI generation.

SugmaNard

You know how much work and time would go into physically hand drafting a hyper realistic drawing of you guys? If you paid them thousands of dollars for that thumbnail surely somebody could make that. But im not trying to be an asshole that is clearly not handmade. Much love and respect but seriously you should understand why this needs explained further.

Wade

KEEP DOING IT

BOB

I get where ur coming from man, but if you look on YouTube this is the exact style everyone in this genre is using, furthermore the drawing is not a drawing, the faces of Jackson n jordies are real pictures they use for stock, and there’s a pretty basic but slightly time consuming thing us thumbnail artists do to make the faces look uncanny and doll like/drawn, it makes it still look real but it makes it more cohesive and also lets you be creative w it, I could send u a link of how editors do it but at the end of the day i can assure you this thumbnail is not ai, especially when you’re concerned with the realistic drawing of them, it is not, it is real edited pics, I can’t say the same for the rest of the thumbnail but my take would be its all authentic. Also you did come across as a bit of an ass.

SugmaNard

Thats exactly why I asked what the original photos are from. If its NOT ai the images have to be sourced from somewhere.

SugmaNard

AI is a serious problem. I may have come across as being an ass but I genuinely dont care. AI is something im passionately against. I stated multiple times how id like to be wrong and it not to be AI. I just want proof of it because like YOU said. It does look suspicious.

SugmaNard

At the end of the day I spend my hard earned money on this podcast. If I ever feel somethings amiss its good to ask questions.

Gavin Gulick

genuinely love it, would love to hear some cooked ass books like icebreakers

Connor Arrington

Please keep going. The episode was so funny I’d really love to hear some twilight fanfic

MeMEGoingGreen

It was hilarious and eye opening at the same time

SugmaNard

Okay awesome thank you and my apologies.

Cthonaut

I like it , it s a good idea , creepypastas are kinda meh these days so smut reading is taping into a lot of "good" internet writing that not many people read

klongus

Really fun. I think the typing sounds are a fine way to distinguish reading and banter but maybe just make them quieter or less intense. Also that thumbnail is shamelessly creepcast come on now

klongus

Embarassing interaction

SugmaNard

Brother it deadass looks exactly like AI and Jackson was very helpful in covering any confusions. Its not AI ive ran it through detectors at the end of the day it does look AI and you should be equally suspicious of anyone using AI. Not to mention Im not the only one with the same suspicion. Just the only one that said something.

SugmaNard

Im sorry you dont have the nerve to stand for something ✊️

Richard Wagner

I did enjoy it but I feel like we don't need 10 different podcast series & stuff like this could just be used as occasional bonus episode content for the main series

SugmaNard

Yeah I feel like the typing is absolutely necessary for their level of ADD i cannot tell when theyre reading or just talking half the time otherwise. Especially when jordy is supposed to be reading something and hes just freestyling his own smut.

Jacob Tuck

Thumbnail and logo feel like its trying to hard to emulate creepcast

Simon Hughes

The Mario and Luigi gay slash fiction "Brotherly Love", the best part in my opinion is that they act like the shocking part about the whole thing is that they're gay, and not ya know.. the fact that it's incest

Wyatt

Absolutely and I love it

Wyatt

Holy chill. Of course we agree ai is an issue, and it’s frequently discussed on the official podcast. But holy shit leaving 10+ reply’s is not a good look for you

Not_Muchh

Jackson I know you want to read some Mass Effect smut lol

SugmaNard

Brother everytime someone like you replies you add another reply from me its how conversations work. I had gotten my original point out like 3 times and someone new (you) has something else to say. 🤔

SugmaNard

Not to mention I was replying to Jackson and other people at the same exact time lmao

Aidan Ryan

Very cute kawaii please I need more senpai

The History of Forgotten Lands

I think that the content of the show is very good and you should continue doing it! I know you had said that edited took a lot of effort, so you should dial it back if you need to in order to keep the show going

theofficialpodcast

I think the thumbnail is a bit too close as well currently but it's more so in line with general YouTube thumbnails that perform well. I think leaning into more saturation and colour in the future will differentiate. -J

Gerry Garcia

Enjoyed it a lot pls keep going with it , for sure have to read at least some snippets from the books that were trending on booktok

Awwwcrap

PLEASE! NO Flaming!

Gerrit Ringling

Honestly only input is to keep the fan fiction super cringe

Christian Behne

One of the funniest podcasts I’ve heard in a while

astr0Slime

absolutely keep going LOVED IT

Connor

Definitely need more of this

CheeseBread

Make it more smutty, that’s my only input. Reading bad smut has got to be in my top 5 of funniest podcast experiences, especially when it makes the host(s) uncomfortable, a work of art if you will. :)

Jacob Tuck

Jackson can we make out?

GelatMaru

I'm late to this, everyone else really said everything I was gonna say. Though my only suggestion, please please please read the My Chemical Romance Milk fanfic. That and maybe read fanfics that turned into popular novels. EX: Heated Rivalries was originally an MCU Captain America x Bucky Barnes alternate universe hockey fanfic. Other than that I really enjoy this show and can't wait to see more awawaw :D

Llew3y

the pilot episode alone was worth the monthly sub fee, one of the funniest things I've listened to in a while, please keep it up

Quesadean

honestly god tier

Rickdean0

I had mentioned this in the comments of the Pilot, but I think that you guys would have a blast with Garfield Royal Rescue, as well as the following fanfics from the same author. They are hilariously bad and every other line is gold!

Gabe

Love this show. The only bad thing is the keyboard sounds in the background annoying the shit out of me.

Reamond Nuudles

I joined for smutrot, I used to write awful fanfics when I was in high school so I love laughing at the others, too; but yall should get into the gay fanfics, they’re absolutely unhinged