Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Show Notes: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1O6lVzYWwmUxefac1M82daCw9FdfaveoaMLf8B4AJYYs/edit?usp=sharing

Files

Comments

Grelk

god damn 🙏

Alex

FINALLY!!!!!!

Ivan Zamarripa

Finally goat behavior best show on the show

Rbxty

oh yeah

SugmaNard

Just make criminally stupid official.men and patron exclusive. The occasional bonus is a treat for us paying members

Ivan Zamarripa

I think the way its being released is fine imo after what yall explained. Just keep it for paid memberships cause most of the audience is recurring viewers

colinknife

Our dreams have come true omg

The Boys

Yeah, the issue with that is that member exclusive content will naturally atrophy over time as members cancel. We still need public content to bring in new fans into the members ecosystem, which is why it's hard to dedicate time to something that has no chance of doing that. But, we're still doing it, I just don't know if it makes sense to do CS weekly.

YungOwl

FINALLY YES PRAISE JESUS

Deochar

Not doing CS will equally lead to canceled memberships, though imo the whole extra series is a selling point for memberships. It would probably help to more actively advertise the breadth of different shows you have going

Bandos Godsword

Pragmata is a great game for a refreshing new IP

DmanTuck

Just release these on patreon. Problem solved.

Jacob G

Just a suggestion but you guys could move away from pedos and just talk about general crime. I just love yours and Kaya’s dynamics too much and it would suck to lose this whole show. You could then make tcap episodes be Patreon bonuses for criminally stupid. Please 🙏

E

Theyre planting the seeds to cancel Criminally Stupid aren't they? If that happens can we at least get another Jackson/Kaya solo show?

Chandler Lujan

Why not make criminally stupid a Patreon/official.men exclusive if posting it on YouTube is dangerous to the brand because pedophiles running YouTube get pissed about it

Zodiacalbong

I'm down to be criminally stupid patsy

Lorens van den bergh

Its the best show on the network guys long time patron supporter and love the podcast but this is the most hilarity!

Chronicplayed

Brother just make it Patron exclusive

Garf

I mean if it canceled, I’ll most likely cancel my subscription. It’s the show I enjoy most, and the reason why I came here. I mean if him and Kaya wanted to do crime stuff, I’d be fine, and move away from the Pedo stuff. But getting rid of a show like this would just lead to what you said. Red Thread is more miss than hit, and the main podcast is stale. Just usually them ranting about Nintendo or something for an hour.

Garf

Cause, while they complained about strikes. It’s mostly about ad revenue. They can’t double dip the Patreon and YouTube like Red Thread or Official Podcast can.

Chronicplayed (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-13 00:00 U do get income from criminally stupid through patron
2026-04-22 14:34

JeremyBeezy

Cs as a monthly thing as a membership only show is something I could live with as long as you guys keep it alive

Garf

You guys need to adapt your content then. Evolve from Pedos into true crime, missing cases, disappearances. Obviously, you have the Red Thread, but at this point it’s just talking about Lolcows and rappers. Try it and see what the reception is. You and Kaya have a good dynamic. John Leonard Orr - the most prolific serial arsonist in U.S. history There, helped ya on your first case.

Jack Felumlee

Love this podcast , it’s the only reason I’m still here paying for Patreon

The Boys

It's not about ad revenue, CS is always demonetised anyway and, if it weren't, it would only generate $150 in ad revenue an episode max. Not the motivating factor here. I said in the episode, public releases put all of our other shows at risk on public platforms and if we can't make something public we don't get new members signing up because how are new viewers supposed to find exclusive member shows?

Chandler Lujan

Maybe release snippets of “YouTube friendly” moments of the show or just explain what the show is at the end of other podcasts and advertise it as a bonus of signing up to the Patreon/official.men. Kinda like bonus episodes of the official podcast

Gabe

Will be sad if cs gets cancelled, especially because it seems to be the only show of theirs that feels unique aside from the new show: smutrot. Red thread can be good but it seems to have a lot of issues to the point where it feels like half the episodes Jackson has to say “didn’t have time this week so we’re doing xyz thing because it’s easy and we had no time” The official pod is the same as every other YouTuber gaming podcast, of which there are hundreds if not thousands. Not many shows that started off dedicated to making fun of peds.

The Boys

It's not cancelled! We were just being upfront about why we've lacked motivation there.

Gabe

I like being a paying member but when the shows that made me sign up for membership are left to the wayside while you make a new show every other week it doesn’t feel worth the value at all. Don’t get me wrong it’s cool that you’re trying new things but it feels like the more shows that are added, the lower the quality gets across the board.

Simon Hughes

just promote the shit out of it on the main shows, having it be patreon exclusive would actually give people a reason to subscribe instead of just a 30 min bonus

G07HD4D

I didn’t know we had to say it out loud: I want more criminally stupid, I don’t care if you have to sacrifice your whole career for it, we need to hear you giggle at perverts!

klongus

I can’t imagine a worse direction for this show than becoming another one out of a hundred million true crime podcasts. They already have one ffs. Reading gross chat logs with silly voices is the point of this show, it doesn’t have to be just pedos though I agree with that

Ed

They get income from Patreon from patrons who pay monthly but Patreon does not specifically pay them for putting out eps of cs

Wyatt

Same here

G07HD4D

The Boys content in order of best to not the best: Criminally Stupid The Official Podcast Red Thread (was the best with Isaiah and Charlie but the vibes just haven’t been the same since) Smutrot (I haven’t watched much yet tbh) . Never give up on this show boys, it’s the best and it seems the one you have the most fun doing, only thing that would make it better is having Andrew on.

klongus

I’m just gonna put in my 2 cents because I love this show and network. If you can’t even put this show on public platforms without it being a time bomb for every other show I think the answers are clear unfortunately. A.) keep this show Patreon only which sucks because you get no growth Or b.) try to modify the show enough so you can exist and not be a detriment to everything else. The great part of this show is that it’s just Jackson and Kaya alone that’s not a dynamic we have on other shows and I think it’s uniquely enjoyable. I also think the format of reading things with funny voices is great but maybe it just needs to be shifted to something not pedo related but still funny and engaging? I’d hate to see this show go, but having a few episodes a year with an undertone of “I don’t even want to be here” isn’t enjoyable either. Much love to you guys

Chronicplayed

I get that but exactly why it should be on here if we pay for exclusive content do you see what I’m saying?theyre complaints are monetization and they cant do that on public platforms but patron can make up for that by being an exclusive

Joe

WE WANT ITTTT

cas.ko

personally I would be fine with cs being a monthly-ish patreon treat but I think it would be nice if we can get smutrot weekly to make up for it. in fact I think it would be fun if it rotated between kaya and jordan if jordan isn't able to record that often. while I like cs I'm not a superfan and I think that there's a ceiling on how entertaining episodes of pedo rp can be compared to the thousands of fun-bad fanfictions out there

cas.ko

like I can comfortably recommend smutrot to my friends who wouldn't like the main podcast and red thread but the second they listen to an episode of cs they're gonna ask me wtf I listen to lmao

klongus

Having Kaya on smutrot is a fantastic idea

Vincent Shirayuki

I memb for the after show which is like 40 mins now and crim stupid. Beyond that there is no reason to subscribe. Maybe every other one can be a general dumb crime one that can go on the main and ppl can sub for the Tcap other half.

Tomas

I love love love love the show. But please, just cancel the show and channel the energy and time into something else, its been like this for too long, time to pull the plug. If the show cant grow on public platforms and youre not motivated to be consistent with it for those of us who pay, having it as a show at all is not worth it if it doesnt feel good for the fans or the creators. Appreciate the update, happy theres finally some form of communication between the network and its patrons.

Garf

It’s more or less for them to keep the chemistry between Kaya and Jackson. Which I highly enjoy. But I agree, I want them to keep this show, if they can’t. At least adapt it.

Garf

150$ is 150$ 😂

Garf

You can advertise the show as a patron exclusive on your other shows. This shouldn’t nuke your channel, unless YouTube hates you that much. I understand the lack of motivation to make stuff. You guys can try to adapt. You and Kaya’s chemistry is too funny to give up on. This might entice people more to come watch.

Rachel M

Criminally stupid is the only reason I even listen 😭

Western Philosopher

Is this the tenth time they’ve forgotten that Del is a lesbian?

Pai N

Talking about and making fun of predators should BE PROMOTED and appreciated, wtaf. Advertisers should love this.. this world is insane to hate on hating on preds

bigboigangleader

I understand the liability risk the show is but I still find it crazy that it is one. I also understand that here isn’t much room for growth, if only the advertisers and YouTube moderators understood that this is comedy gold and that it’s making more people aware of predators.

Valentine

I could only talk from my perspective, but I'm sure a lot of us are pretty chill, but it's more of a communication thing. There's gotta be a few of us have a subscription active for this show since the writing was on the wall that it won't exactly be the best for you guys to keep up with, but we've been kinda in the dark on updates for those of us who do wanna fund it. Can't say it makes huge difference for me since I like supporting you boys as is, and I know some WORK gotta go into it, but it was a bit frustrating to not know what was going on with this show despite the obvious.

Valentine

This is definitely a huge idea, especially if there's any chance of getting Kaya on smutrot. One of the best parts of this show is the ridiculous fake flirting, and there's bound to be enough characters in fanfics to divide it up enough.

Kurako

Forgot to comment here but this is one of the most entertaining and funny podcasts you guys do. I literally can't keep a straight face while I listen to this while I work lol and it would be awesome if it could get back to a weekly schedule some day. The hype is there,. hopefully yal can figure out a solution to the monetization of the show 👍

Yasir C

Just a point: I'd say 65% of the reason why I keep my subscription is because of CS. I understand why it doesn't make sense to continue this series for growing the platform, but will you consider retention as well? Thanks.

The Boys

I hear you! Reg lack of communication, partly because I've been so busy with other projects including Smutrot and also not really ourselves knowing what to do about the situation. We always come in with plans on how we want to deliver content and then fall flat with those promises because episodes are removed, or some other thing comes up that takes precedence, etc. I want to be more communicative though as I know Criminally Stupid means a lot to a lot of patrons.

systemmuncher

I’ve only ever subscribed for Criminally Stupid, and I only remember to catch up on other shows from you guys because of Criminally Stupid.

Thomas

I am only subscribed for Criminally Stupid

LJ

I've just resubscribed only to check up on what's happening with Criminally Stupid, and I'd pay the subscription every month if the releases were regular. Without this show, save for the bonuses the Patreon just feels like Jordan's second YouTube channel, great if you're into that, not so much if you're not.

Yaboystef8

To be fair this started as “podophiles” so how much marketing were you guys assuming would be available for such a show name and topic ? I could understand the fear of strikes but is this just for the Tcap segments? Why not pull the focus towards general criminals instead of predators primarily.

Dreezy

We can’t have nice things like pragmata bc now the weirdos will say something and have an army to back em up.

RippZipp

There are plenty of people in the comments on this post saying how they’re only here for Criminally Stupid. Making this a 1-2 times a month Patreon exclusive would work wonders, especially if they perhaps just put out edited clips of this show in their YT channels to advertise it.

Greg

😭

Dead Moonlyte

Liesss we love criminally stupid i need more

Lilpphead

I've listened to every episode of CS probably 20x or more now. It's why I'm here 🙏🏾🥹

deprived

This is the best podcast on the boys

systemmuncher

Pls patreon only tcap and the rest can be public

Brock

Just make it patreon only.

ArmoredNoodles

I wouldn’t get rid of CS. Like everyone else, it’s the podcast I look forward to the most. You’ll likely end up losing a lot of viewership with the main Patreon. I understand your frustration with the strikes, though. Someone suggested making it a Patreon exclusive and I think that’s the best way to go about it. You don’t harbor the risk of career suicide and you get a lot of people to stay being a member.

Ooh Lee

Just focus on like bodycam footage or other criminals

Unidentified21

I had commented this on a earlier episode but you guys could expand past just pedos. Like just the goofiest crimes in general

Rhys

Jackson I don't care how much you can profit from this show we as paying members love it, it's the only thing that keeps me here as a member. Jordan is cool and all but I started giving you guys money while moist was still here and this is the only show you guys have that hasn't changed since it began (excluding Smutrot that's brand new and also not enjoyable for me). I really don't care about the profitability of it for y'all. I started paying $5/mo years ago for over an hour-long exclusive bonus episodes, which are now long gone, and the big thing that kept me here paying was this show. Maybe do two episodes a month, one traditional criminally stupid and one converting the subreddit bit on the main show into a criminally stupid style? more like the Dylan hefterpen episode, that isn't pedo exclusive and is more advertiser friendly, to promote the TCAP exclusive ad-unfriendly member episodes. keep it paid exclusive, only make one a month, whatever, but please don't stop making it

I_it_Believe

Well i like the OP regular and bonus eps combined that you have been doing lately. CS with different sorts of criminals i would enjoy personally also. have a good one guys.

Cris

I can I suggest making this a member’s only show that way we have something special to look forward to and you don’t have to worry about strikes. It’s a way to win all around.

Alexis Rivas

It would be nice to have this only for the website and Patreon. It will encourage more to sign up.

Alexis Rivas

They can keep this show behind the pay wall. Criminally Stupid is a good incentive. I love this show too.