Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Do the blurry backgrounds distract from the page at all? It's a quick way to make backgrounds rather than just relying on single color fills and gradients but I worry it's distracting.

Files

Previews only

Comments

PatManDX

Honestly, they do distract a little bit, at least IMO. I would stick with flat colors or gradients in the last 3 panels, since the focus on those panels are primarily on the moment between Greg and Merial, not so much on where they are. And the perspective in panel 3 is a little wonky relative to the characters, making it feel very out of place. I could take it or leave it for the first panel. Sorry if I'm overdoing it, I hope this help!

korybing

Nope that's exactly what I wanted! I'll play with it a little more tomorrow, see what I can do!

Simone Spinozzi

It's not distracting in my opinion. I am sorry but i have to disagree with Patrick on all accounts. Let me explain: a uniform background has always felt to me like an excessive abstraction. Especially in cases like this one where the fantasy aspects are secondary and the main problem is extremely relatable to humans, seeing a background helps a lot to ground the sequence in the "real" world. If here we were to be talking about metaphysics or magic to the point where people have to suspend belief, then yes, abstract backgrounds are actually preferable to set the mood. But here we are talking about very human-relatable emotions. So no. I do not agree to an abstract background. Let us ground this sequence to something that feels real.

Anonymous

I really like the blurred background, especially in the first panel. It makes Michelle and what she's saying and how she's reacting the biggest focus. In fact it reminds me of the times when I have anxiety attacks and the world seems to fizzle out around me and I can't quite seem to focus my eyes. It really pushed Michelle's emotion through. If anything, I would make the backgrounds of the last three panels a little sharper and more defined to show that we've moved out of her headspace.

PatManDX

I take back what I said about the last 3 panels, having them be sharper sounds like a better idea.

PatManDX

Okay! I will say, I don't want to say that blurred backgrounds CAN'T work, Makinsey made some really good points about how the abstraction adds to the mood (in that light, I especially like panel 1). I just think some tweaking might help make the individual panels work better in terms of composition.

korybing

These are all great suggestions, y'all! Thanks for helping me out!

PatManDX

I would argue that the blurred backgrounds feel less real than abstracted backgrounds do. Issues with perspective are honestly my biggest gripe about the blurred backgrounds and they can really take me out of the moment. I honestly think if fully rendered backgrounds aren't an option for Kory at the moment, then using simple colors like she did in the previous page would be a better option than blurred bgs. I'm not trying to advocate using only flat color and gradient backgrounds, I agree that basing the characters in reality during human moments adds a lot to those moments, I just don't see blurring what appears to be used backgrounds as being the best option.

Simone Spinozzi

Given Makinsey's comment i would suggest to keep the blurred background. This scene has to be grounded in reality. You can't have "talking heads" moments in a moment like this one. Also i would have accepted the sharper background too, but the blurred background means that thematically the focus is on the characters, and Makinsey's comment adds a new layer to it. Which i just noticed now that (s)he said it out loud. When you're crying, when you have anxiety... the world isn't sharp anymore. You need to know you are in this world, but at the same time everything needs to be blurred. Soooo yeah.

PatManDX

You've made some very good points and you know what? I'll admit I'm starting to agree with you as I've thought about it. Maybe I've been staring at the page long enough to not be phased by what initially bothered me, who knows. Honestly, all this discussion and back and forth makes me very excited to see what Kory decides to do with the page.

Simone Spinozzi

in the end the decision is up to you but i hope this discussion helped you think about the pro and cons of every aspect.

Anonymous

Honestly it's not Distracting at all! The first thing I see is the characters. Which is the intended focal point. I didn't really notice the background until you mentioned it!

Thisfox

Personally, prefer the gradients to the blurs. Might be because I'm short sighted, and I honestly did clean my glasses and look again before reading your question.... An indication that I wasn't really coping with what I was seeing, blurwise. That said, the blur does show a more stressful view, similar to our beloved sphinxes stressful situation.

Anonymous

I didn't notice the backgrounds until you mentioned it!

Anonymous

Honestly, this is not a page for worldbuilding. This isn't a page for London's Avalon. This page is for Michelle. Reason for them be damned, they put a focus on the emotions and not the decoration.