childstar 88-89 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter 88: The Picky Kristin
Leonardo stood beside Charles, looking visibly nervous.
He had already done Peter Pan on Broadway, so he thought he was mentally prepared. But he had seriously underestimated how big Oliver! was going to be on opening night.
When he performed in Peter Pan, the theater was only about a third full, and most of the audience had been parents with little kids. After all, that show was aimed squarely at children. A fairy-tale adventure was enough to pull in the younger crowd, and that was considered a win.
Oliver! was different.
This was a musical adapted from Dickens’s gritty, realistic novel — serious literature turned into stage spectacle. Its appeal stretched far beyond kids. The audience sitting out there right now proved it: middle-aged men in tailored suits, society women wearing pearl necklaces, young couples dressed for a night out, and several sharp-eyed theater critics who looked ready to judge every single choice.
And every seat in the house was taken.
For Broadway, that was rare. A theater this size held close to a thousand people. Only a show on the level of Oliver! could sell out its very first performance like this.
Which meant every actor standing backstage tonight was about to be scrutinized by a lot of very attentive eyes.
Behind the heavy red curtain, low conversation drifted up from the audience. Leonardo swallowed hard. His palms were starting to sweat. He adjusted his collar without thinking, still feeling the pressure.
His role wasn’t huge — just a supporting part. Compared to Charles carrying the lead, the weight on his shoulders was nothing in comparison.
He glanced sideways at Charles.
The other boy looked completely calm, like the packed house didn’t affect him at all.
Charles always seemed to carry that same quiet confidence, whether it was during the E.T. audition or right now.
Charles suddenly turned his head, catching Leonardo’s nerves.
“Don’t be scared,” he said quietly.
Leonardo opened his mouth to argue, but Charles kept going.
“Worst case, if you mess up tonight, the papers will probably only blame me anyway. So relax.”
Leonardo blinked.
Then he almost laughed. The tight knot in his chest loosened all at once.
Only Charles would crack a joke like that right before curtain.
He took a deep breath and tried to mirror Charles’s steady posture. If he wanted to be taken seriously as an actor, he needed to learn how to stay loose no matter what was happening around him. Only then could he actually disappear into the role.
So Leonardo stood there beside Charles, both of them still as statues in a quiet corner of the backstage area.
A moment later Jennifer Aniston walked over in full costume. With the help of the makeup and wardrobe team she looked like a completely different person.
During rehearsals she had usually worn comfortable clothes, hair pulled back in a simple ponytail, looking like any regular girl who had just run out of school. But now, in the deliberately worn and aged dress the costume designer had given her, with her hair styled into artful disarray, she carried a completely different energy — softer, more lived-in, less polished.
Leonardo felt another flicker of nerves when he saw her.
Not because of anything she said. It was because Aniston looked genuinely relaxed, like she wasn’t about to step onto a Broadway stage in front of a sold-out crowd.
She noticed the tension immediately.
She took one look at Leonardo’s stiff expression and had to cover her mouth to keep from laughing.
“Leonardo, you look like you’re about to be marched to the gallows. Breathe. It’s going to be fine.”
Leonardo’s mouth twitched. Was it really that obvious?
Aniston raised an eyebrow and leaned closer to Charles, dropping her voice to a dramatic whisper.
“Boss, I’m so nervous right now. What do I do? Any advice?”
Charles turned and took in the excited gleam in her eyes, then barely stopped himself from rolling his.
Nervous? She looked like she was about to burst from excitement because she finally got to perform.
He sighed and didn’t bother answering. Typical future television queen — give her a stage and she immediately felt at home. Any opportunity to shine and she was ready to take it.
A stagehand hurried over and spoke in a low, urgent voice.
“Everyone ready. Three minutes to curtain.”
The backstage area instantly quieted. Actors began double-checking costumes and props one last time.
Charles stayed where he was, eyes on the curtain.
Tonight’s opening mattered to him too.
This was his first real public appearance since the emancipation hearing. The papers had been running his name nonstop since the verdict, and his local profile in Los Angeles had jumped significantly. People on the street were starting to recognize him.
He understood something important now: an actor’s fame couldn’t live on film alone. If he wanted to stay relevant, he needed to make an impression in as many arenas as possible.
So tonight he had to deliver. He needed the audience to see real acting — something that would make them remember him.
Charles closed his eyes and steadied his breathing.
He wasn’t nervous. If anything, he felt alive.
As long as he could still stand on a stage in front of people, it meant he was still an actor. And as long as he had performances to give, he had a reason to keep going in this world.
Acting was everything to him now.
He never wanted to go back to the pain of his previous life — the endless background work, the talent that never got a real chance.
So come on.
Let them all watch.
Let them all remember that he was an actor.
Charles opened his eyes, gaze steady.
The show was about to begin.
Kristin sat in the audience, adjusting her gold-rimmed glasses. Her legs were elegantly crossed. She stifled a small yawn.
She was an independent theater critic. Most days she simply went from one Broadway house to another, watched the shows, and wrote her reviews. Major papers regularly commissioned pieces from her, and she appeared on television panels often enough that even some of the Tony Award voters were people she knew personally.
In short, Kristin carried real authority in the theater world. Her opinions reached a wide audience of serious playgoers.
Tonight she had come specifically to see the new revival of Oliver!
To be honest, she wasn’t expecting much.
She had already seen the classic version years ago. In her opinion, both the execution and the staging had been nearly perfect. No matter how much money and effort the current production had poured in, she doubted it could truly surpass the original.
Revivals were tricky that way. Even when the budget and technology were far better than they had been decades earlier, most of them still ended up feeling like they were walking in the shadow of the thing they were trying to replace. Audiences came in already carrying memories of the older version, and that made it almost impossible to win them over completely.
Some revivals simply failed because they were badly made.
Kristin was curious which category this new Oliver! would fall into.
She settled back in her seat, adjusted her glasses again, and shifted her crossed legs with the quiet poise of someone used to the best circles. A notebook rested on her lap.
Inside it was a half-finished review she had already started writing based on her expectations. If the production didn’t exceed what she anticipated, she could probably finish it tonight without too much extra work.
She was still thinking along those lines when the house lights finally dimmed.
The performance was about to start.
Chapter 89: This Review is Ruined
The house lights dimmed. The low murmur of conversation in the theater faded as every head turned toward the stage.
Kristin’s previously relaxed posture straightened slightly. She lifted her eyes just as the heavy red curtain began to rise.
The set for the workhouse appeared — cold, shabby, and oppressive. Grayish-white walls, narrow windows, rough wooden tables, and rows of children in ragged clothes standing with their heads bowed in silence. The lighting slowly isolated them under the spotlight.
She had to admit the opening design was strong.
She had heard that the new director, Clara, was a rising talent who had already staged a well-received original production on Broadway. Handing her this classic musical revival had clearly been the right call — at least visually, the show started on solid ground.
Kristin made a quick mental note of approval.
The design didn’t try to dazzle with bright colors or flashy detail. Instead, the entire palette was deliberately muted and grim. It was a smart choice. It immediately told the audience what kind of story they were about to watch — dark, cruel, and grounded in poverty.
A story like Oliver! didn’t benefit from being prettied up. Overly beautiful sets would have undercut the raw, rough texture of life at the bottom.
Kristin lowered her head and jotted a few quick words in her notebook:
“Set design restrained. Atmosphere effectively established.”
She looked back up at the stage.
One good opening wasn’t enough to change her overall opinion. Excellent sets and lighting were common on Broadway. What actually mattered was whether the actors could carry the show.
Especially the lead.
She already knew the new Oliver was a Hollywood child star named Charles. His name had been everywhere lately — in newspapers, on television, in every entertainment segment. The young prodigy. Hollywood’s latest darling. The standout child performer in The Shining. And now the first child actor to successfully win emancipation from his guardian.
All of it wrapped in a thick layer of media hype and gossip.
Kristin didn’t particularly like actors who lived permanently in the spotlight before they had truly proven themselves — especially not a child star with limited experience.
Hollywood and Broadway were not the same thing.
Film could hide a lot of flaws. With a clever director, good editing, and the right lighting and score, even a mediocre performance could look compelling on screen.
The stage was different.
Onstage, there was nowhere to hide. Kristin could tell within seconds whether an actor had the skill to inhabit a role. Musicals were even harsher. They demanded acting, singing, movement, ensemble work, and the ability to keep the voice steady through a long performance.
A child star who did well in movies wouldn’t necessarily be able to anchor an entire Broadway musical.
And Oliver was not an easy role.
If the boy played him too weak and pitiful, the character would lack depth and any real arc. If he played him too clever or knowing, he would lose the essential innocence that made Oliver compelling. Striking that balance was difficult even for many adult actors.
She glanced down at the program in her lap. The promotional photo of Charles was carefully styled to look delicate and sympathetic — clean features, youthful softness, and just the right touch of melancholy. It was designed to make audiences like him before he even opened his mouth.
Kristin didn’t fall for that kind of thing.
She placed the program back on her lap.
She hadn’t come here specifically to watch Charles fail. But the media had been building him up so aggressively — especially after the emancipation ruling — that the coverage had become almost entirely one-sided and positive. She disliked that kind of manufactured narrative.
Sometimes the job of a theater critic was to pull overhyped performers back down to earth.
If Charles’s performance tonight turned out to be merely adequate, she would write exactly that. If he couldn’t live up to the reputation being handed to him, she wouldn’t soften her words just because he was young. That was the standard she had always held herself to.
The children’s opening number began.
They filled the stage, standing in tight groups, and sang with deliberately quiet, almost suppressed voices:
“Food… Glorious food…”
The sound wasn’t big or bright. It felt hushed and strained, exactly like hungry children who had already learned not to complain too loudly. The restraint gave the number an uncomfortable, suffocating quality instead of the usual rousing energy of a traditional musical opening.
Kristin raised an eyebrow.
This was different from the classic version she remembered. The old production had gone for a more immediate, crowd-pleasing approach. This new one seemed content to make the audience sit with the discomfort first.
She had to admit it was an interesting choice. At the very least, it wasn’t simply copying the original structure.
Then her attention sharpened.
She finally spotted the boy standing among the others.
Charles.
He wasn’t positioned front and center. He stood with his head slightly lowered, shoulders drawn in, looking small and quiet among the group. At first glance he didn’t draw the eye.
If Kristin hadn’t already been actively searching for him, she might have missed him for those first few moments.
Then he took one small step forward.
For some reason she couldn’t look away.
It felt almost as if he had quietly pulled the focus of the entire theater onto himself without any obvious effort.
Kristin’s pen paused above the page. After a moment she wrote, almost against her will:
“Lead actor’s presence is immediately memorable.”
She rarely wrote straightforward praise in her notes. The fact that she had just done so said something.
The scene moved forward. The other children instinctively shrank back as if under some invisible pressure, leaving Charles standing alone at the front.
He slowly raised his head and looked out at the audience.
That single movement made Kristin sit up straighter without realizing it.
There was no fear in his eyes. No calculated tears meant to manipulate sympathy. Only a clean, almost painful bewilderment.
It was the look of a child who still didn’t fully understand why any of this was happening to him, but who already knew — on some instinctive level — that no one was coming to protect him.
Because he was just another ordinary, unremarkable orphan in a brutal time.
Charles held that fragile balance perfectly.
Then he began to sing.
His voice wasn’t loud or showy. He didn’t push for big notes or try to dazzle with vocal power. It was simply clean and steady.
Kristin had been prepared to critique his breath support and technique. After a few lines, she had to acknowledge that his control was remarkably solid for someone his age. His diction stayed clear even against the soft accompaniment, and his phrasing never faltered.
More importantly, there was storytelling in his singing.
He wasn’t just performing the melody. He was using it to show Oliver’s situation — the careful pauses, the cautious breaths, the quiet shifts in tone all carried the character’s changing emotions.
The audience had gone completely still. Several women in the front rows had unconsciously raised their hands to their mouths, looking genuinely moved.
Kristin stared at the stage, her brow slowly furrowing.
Not because she disliked what she was seeing.
Because she was starting to realize that the review she had already begun writing in her notebook was probably useless now.
Charles’s performance had just made that version of the article obsolete.
She would have to start over.
At the same time, her pen remained motionless above the page for a long time. She was too focused on what was happening onstage to write anything else.