Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

So I actually did a LOT of experiment on the water stream stuff. This ones just a little behind the scenes filming of an experiment that suggests the water deflection in the electric field is nothing to do with ions! Basic idea goes like this: IF ions are important, then something with less ions should deflect less, and more ions should deflect more. Water always has some ions in it. If not from gases like carbon dioxide dissolving to give hydrogen carbonate, then from the auto ionization of the water to give H+ and OH-. However the latter two are present at about 1 part in 10 million. Vodka should have less ions, and methanol even less. While conversely a solution with a million times the ion concentration of water should deflect more. In reality, they all seem to be almost the same!

Files

Previews only

Probably not the ions!

Uploaded by thunderf00tCC on 2014-10-23.

Comments

Anonymous

Hmm I would be curious to see if non-polar liquids behave the same, as this is the traditional explanation for the phenomenon. Something like naphtha or mineral spirits maybe.

Andrew Brown

Hey Thunderfoot what do you think of his recent videos featuring Kelvin's rain storm?

Thunderf00t

I have tried similar experiments with hexane, with no effect. I stress the similar. You have to be a little careful you dont burn the house down when you are pouring 20ml of flammable liquid down next to a staticly charged object which can spark. Methanol isnt too bad as it mixes rapidly with water and loses its flammability. Hexane is a nightmare. It floats on water and remains v. flammable. The experiments I did involved a single drop of water falling near the VDG generator. Its strongly attracted. I do the same thing with a single drop of hexane. -No effect.