PREVIEW: Mother of Dragons Montage (and stray thoughts on Game of Thrones) (Patreon)
Content
This isn't every time. There are a couple in Dothraki that I cut, and I'm 100% certain I missed a few in scenes where people in Westeros are talking about Dany. But it took me nearly ten hours just to comb through every scene in the show with Dany (excluding the first season), making pitstops at some of my favorite moments. To get the rest, I'd basically just have to rewatch the entire show. Who has time for that?
This partial rewatch was enlightening in a number of ways. One of the things I realized is the convenient, unquestioning heroism of Dany's story up until season 7. Her entire narrative involves freeing slaves and learning how to be a queen, and as a result we as viewers have never had to really wrestle with the morality of her actions. There are a couple conversations where people say "you can't just kill the masters!" but ultimately the show says that killing them would have been the correct answer. And we, as enlightened citizens of a (mostly) slave-free society, have no sympathy for anyone who engages in slavery, even those who appear moderate in that context.
As season 7 aired, a lot of people expressed worry that Dany was becoming a "mad queen" following in the footsteps of her father, and I simply did not see it -especially considering the very literal unraveling of Cersei and the clear setup to get Jaime to stab her in the back come season 8. I think part of why people were theorizing about Dany's "madness" is that season 7 is the first time we've ever had cause to truly doubt the morality of her actions. The mistakes she makes are no different than the mistakes that Rob made (remember when he beheaded a Karstark?), or Jon, or anybody. The only real difference is that instead of swinging a sword, Dany is using dragons, which definitely elevates the optics of those mistakes.
Also, the shift in quality between the first four seasons and the last three is so sudden it is kind of impressive. Season four ends on such an incredible note, it may as well have had a curtain close and a subtitle that said "End of Act One." And then... season 5 opens with a fucking flashback.
I don't mind flashbacks generally. My favorite show is Lost, after all. But we spent four seasons in the present tense. Everything happened in real time, in a linear fashion. I talk about this a little bit in the video, but a huge part of the show's success is its "realism," to which this sense of linear time is a definite contributing factor. And that's not to mention that, stylistically, it's nonsensical to include a flashback for the first time at the midway point of your series, and then never really do one again (save maybe Bran's mind-time-travel).
That season 5 was also the moment that the showrunners started running out of book is hardly coincidental. It really speaks to how thoroughly weak their grasp is on the stylistic narrative elements of the show (and how short their vision was) that they felt the need to create drama by introducing a conflict we'd never heard of until that moment. You see this again and again in season 5 onwards -everything is fine, until suddenly a problem occurs that everybody knew about except us, the audience. The most egregious of these is, of course, Euron Greyjoy, who I talk about extensively in the video.
ANYWAY. Those are my stray thoughts about Game of Thrones for now. The full video will be coming out soon (no dates because I have a very busy week ahead of me). I hope this tides you over until then.
As always, thanks for your support and I hope you have a great week!
Files
Previews only