Dances with Wolves is an Embarrassment. (Patreon)
Content
Dances with Wolves is not just a poor choice for Best Picture, though- it is a series of cardinal film sins stacked atop one another like a sadist's Jenga tower. It is a movie that tries so hard to be entertaining and profound, and is so certain that it succeeds, that it functionally operates as a visual catalog of Hollywood's worst autofellating impulses.
The story itself is an obvious target. John Dunbar's personal quest to see the frontier "before it's gone" plays out in tropes so fundamental that even the least self-aware filmmakers will joke about them, and even those jokes have themselves become the obvious, overwrought tropes of the try-hard.
Dunbar only encounters white men of a disgusting or harrowingly violent variety, which primes us to see them as "the savages," while the Lakota are shown as civilized and sane. Haha, wow, that's kind of ironic, huh? Because historically the Natives were framed as the savages, but in this movie it's like- y'know, it's a reversal. Because actually the white people were the bad guys!
Let us not interrogate that the very concept of "the white people" others us filthy whites from the actual genocide committed by our predecessors, the continued devaluation of Native peoples as an extant population, and the fact that we still profit off of these monstrosities to this very day. After all, they were the bad whites, but we haven't done anything wrong. Besides, I have a friend who's 1/16th Cherokee and he swears up and down it's totally cool that I wear a Muscogee war bonnet for Halloween, and my favorite movie is Dances with Wolves, so how can I be racist?
But let's not get too progressive, says Kevin Costner to a crowded bathroom- this is still a western, we've got to have some kind of Native American threat. Hey, why not the Pawnee? We'll make them the monsters who kill children and orphan Stands With A Fist, and who cooperate with The Evil Whites, which is a bad thing, and we know it's bad because they're aligning themselves with a group that has "evil" right there in the title. "This is a good dramatic choice," Costner says, "and one that definitely does not invalidate any other attempt by the film to be sympathetic to Native American peoples."
This film is convinced of its own even-handedness and importance as a Work of Cinematic Art. The theatrical cut, a mere three hours long, gave way in the first year of its release to the nearly four hour "special edition," whose girth seems to have been drawn from about six reels of Costner walking silently through the Great Plains at sunset, wistfully brushing his fingers across the tops of tall prairie grass. Just pop those bad boys in wherever the movie starts to actually have a bearable pace, put on some of that Inspiring Western Music you bulk ordered from John Barry, bam, you've got yourself an Oscar-winning masterpiece.
With three and a half hours of the film devoted to furtive, meaningful glances towards the horizon, it's no wonder audiences at the time completely overlooked Dances with Wolves' emotionally manipulative construction. As Roger Ebert famously wrote in his review of the film, "I don't exactly remember when I fell asleep, but I knew by the time I woke up that I'd just seen something very important. Four stars!" (1)
John Dunbar is such a good soul. Look how much his horse loves him! No matter how many times he's stolen, Cisco always comes back. And a good thing, too; without that horse, the adult Lakota would never have decided to approach him. Then there's Two Socks, the lone wolf of the prairie that Dunbar finally goes to prom with at the end of act two, giving him his titular title. Dunbar then rescues Stands With A Fist, a character who conveniently provides a linguistic and romantic gateway into the Lakota tribe, and whose whiteness allows us to avoid confronting the reality of miscegenation and thus perhaps question the arbitrary nature of "race" as a social construct.
The script of Dances with Wolves is the diametrical opposite of a comedy of errors, an extended deus ex machina of happy accidents whose absence would render the plot impossible. Obviously, contrivance is a fact of all fiction, but ideally contrivance is a shortcut to "the good stuff." In this case, every single plot event is a contrivance, and one realizes with astonishment that this is supposed to be "the good stuff." John Dunbar is not a character, he is a tone poem meant to express a white man's masturbatory desire to honorably return to nature regardless of logic or respect. Take away his horse, his wolf, and the suicidal white woman who just so happened to have become recently single and is way DTF, and Dunbar gets shot in the chest with an arrow thirty minutes into the film (or two hours, depending on your version).
And yet, this doesn't really seem to kill the film for most (white) people, because the whole emotional appeal of it is as a guiltless voyeuristic second-life fantasy of an idealized nature-bound agrarian existence filled with spiritual and communal purpose. The plot doesn't matter, the realism doesn't matter, it just needs to feel like what we think reality feels like. It lets us indulge in anger and outrage without forcing inward reflection, and it allows us to congratulate ourselves for feeling any kind of empathy for a Native American tribe.
This variety of cultural propaganda is undeniably effective. It certainly worked on me when I was a stupid teenager, and I wept for the cruelty of "the white man." Funny that I never once questioned who "the white man" were supposed to be. The film situates us in the shoes of John Dunbar, and presumably the entire (white) audience feels disgust at the conduct of the other whites. So, who were they? Who could they have possibly been but monsters borne of a primordial soup of sin and violence and evil? By dehumanizing "the white man," by distancing us from their actions, Dances with Wolves convinces us that nothing this bad could ever happen again, because "we" are better than they were, because "we" are human. What a funny coincidence then that publicly liking Dances with Wolves operates as a signifier of that betterness. Giving it awards acknowledges that we are disgusted by the conduct of "the white man," thus marking a notch on the great bridge of progress, which is in reality a closed circle, because nothing has actually changed.
The fact is, any tenuous sense of even-handedness is drowned out by its one-note, lazy characterization. Dunbar is The Good White (an early working title of the film), the rest of the whites are the Uncivilized Beasts, the Pawnee are the Brutal Savages Who Always Do Bad Things, and the Lakota are, yes, The Noble Savages. But they are also a real people whose existence was capitalized on by Costner to create a Disneyland attraction for suburban white families who wished they still had time to go camping on the weekends. Dances with Wolves is one in a very long line of films that confront racist violence against Native Americans without ever confronting the human reality of Native American existence, without ever forcing us, the white audience, to accept our complicity in the shedding of blood still wet beneath our feet. It simplifies to the point of irrelevancy, yet is certain of its relevant complexity.
We have to ask the question we always ask of these kinds of stories: why does the protagonist of the film need to be a white man? If Costner was so dedicated to historical and tribal accuracy with the Lakota (2), why not go the extra step and empower them in the creation of their own art? There are obvious industry-related answers to that question, but it ultimately comes down to the same racist claptrap we've unquestioningly repeated for centuries. "You are noble and wonderful and deserve respect, which is why I need to tell your story." Because, obviously, the only context in which a person of color has value is through the eyes of a white man.
Fuck this movie.
- - - -
(1): Actually, Ebert said "it abandons the contrivances of ordinary plotting," which is arguably true in the same way that the Civil War was about "state's rights." https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/dances-with-wolves-1990
(2): Though Dances with Wolves was praised for its "accuracy" at the time of its release, apparently its language coach only spoke the feminine Lakota dialect, which the men would never speak. This caused uproarious laughter among Lakota audiences. There's probably a lesson in there somewhere.
Files
Previews only