Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Sanity poll - Runebound

  • Yes ($5 Tier) 32
  • No ($5 Tier) 1
  • Yes ($10 Tier) 234
  • No ($10 Tier) 14
  • 2023-06-01
  • 281 votes
{'title': 'Sanity poll - Runebound', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes ($5 Tier)', 'votes': 32}, {'text': 'No ($5 Tier)', 'votes': 1}, {'text': 'Yes ($10 Tier)', 'votes': 234}, {'text': 'No ($10 Tier)', 'votes': 14}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 6, 1, 18, 57, 27, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 281}

Content

Hey guys!

Runebound is some new territory for me, as I have it much farther ahead than my novels typically are. As such, I want to make sure everyone is still enjoying the story as it develops. 

This is basically just me checking in and making sure everyone's still liking where things are going/I'm fulfilling the promise that was given at the start of the novel. Mostly just gauging things to make sure I haven't done anything stupid. 

If there's something you don't like, please mention it in the comments - though I will say that I won't promise to change anything, as many things are intentional (such as Noah's impatience getting him into a lot of shit, and that he's only now starting to improve on that kind of thing).

Cheers everyone,

Actus

Comments

Lenora

Absolutely loving it

seth

I'm late to the party, what was the promise?

Actus

Promise is like a concept in writing, basically if the novel is delivering on what you felt like you were getting into. (IE Harry potter is a magic school story about a chosen one, not a novel about a dude with a gun).

Slathered_In_Gasoline

Shit is only now kicking off properly, so I'm super psyched to see what's coming up.

Funguslord

I have no idea what's going to happen but I have guesses and little to no proof which keeps me on the edge of my seat waiting for more. I require answers and only reading the story will give them. At the moment the story is interesting and entertaining enough to keep me here until it reaches whatever climax you have coming for this arc or book. Then I might take a break or something.

Andrei

I'm enjoying it very much, especially because of the speed of release. It's definitely money well spent for now!

Enif

Hell yeah it's delivering! Noah and his students are getting stronger, the lore is getting deeper, and the plot is getting clearer. Keep it up you're doing great!

Thomas Lawless

I joined Patreon because I liked where runebound was going. So keep it up. 😛

Pangur Bon

It's pretty dang good. My only complaint is that for whatever reason it felt a little slow to get started? I wasn't finding myself crazy interested, actually, until maybe chapter 10 or so, which is surprising since I think it's probably your strongest story yet. Admittedly, I have not re-read all of it after some of the edits you have made, and you mentioning more about how imbuing and runes work early on might have helped. I'm definitely not trying to recommend you rewrite any of it, at least not more than you have! Excited to see where it goes!

Connor Hartmann

Loving everything about the story thus far - I do hope, however, that Noah puts some effort into learning at least rudimentary self-imbuement soon and prioritizes it decently going forward.

Actus

Yep, that's coming up in the next 2 or so chapters I think!

Actus

I've actually heard that a lot, it's really funny - my 'viewership' graph shows my first 3 chapters are the slowest, and after that it suddenly explodes. I think it's because the first 3 chapters are basically me setting up the premise, and then I get things really started after them.

Arin K Nave.

I haven't personally caught up to the current 10$ chapter yet, being at chapter 52 rn so take my opinion for what you will. I will say I feel like the story needs a bit more teaching into it in the more abstract sense. So far its basically just been a guy grinding in an mmo to farm for exp (energy) for levels (filled runes). I think the magic system is unique and would like to see maybe a bit more delving into the actual higher level stuff of the system such as how best to apply certain runes for spells and what ideal combinations mean for certain magical styles from the perspective of the Noah teaching his students. Sure, he understands nothing of magic but it seems like anybody caught in a position of teaching suddenly who shows earnest interest in doing right by his students would actually take the time to learn some of the theory in the massive library or from his newfound confidant in Moxie. So far it feels like all thst has been done in the realm of teaching is the mc recklessly (from their perspectice at the time) giving away runes then sending the kids to martial arts camp. The vibe as I understand it is basically a guy get transported as a magical school teacher that is kind of like the snape of the school, so a bit more of him getting to be the hyper dramatic fop (even just as a means to blend into his assumed ego) would be fun too.

Actus

Awesome feedback, thank you! I think this is some really good stuff I can focus on, much appreciated :)

Randee

I'm liking everything that is in the story currently. I would like more world building to be added though. The whole world feels like it consists entirely of Arbitage and the Scorched Acres currently. I feel like the lack of knowledge about the world we're in is making the mystery of what the Linwicks are doing hit less hard than it could be hitting, and right now that is the central driving force of the story. All these people hunting down the person who killed the Hellreaver, the Linwicks, the Tarrins -- I don't know why these people matter. It's hard to care about these plot points when I don't understand the gravity or weight of any of the people or institutions involved.

Bob

I'm happy with everything so far.

TheLost

honestly i love Noah cause he just hates waiting in line, thats one of the best character traits ever

Njordt

It's good, like the characters and the world, enjoy the light cover of mystery and overarching plot that keeps us on our toes between dunking our heads in the progression cocain. Especially like the thing with the different ways to runes work, real nifty. Can only think of two moments that made me pause and walk away from the story for a while while marathon it. 1) The fact that Noah was so laser focused on killing the flame monkey that everything faded away and brushed aside. To extent he neglected his student to a degree in a key shift in teaching strategy (with Lee and Moxie joining the gang), despite being told a good amount of times that it's a bad idea to even vist the monkey; some people rely on them being there to level up and train, not many, but it's a core part of the school, it was legit used as the exam grounds. That stupid monkey was the cornerstone for keeping the rest of them in check and making sure they dont do anything unexpected or harmfull to the outside area/academy. And it's a good renewable resource for everyone involved, the flame monkey even sleeps through most of the days and does nothing except holding the rune. 2) That he is willing to let Lee get so close to his rezz, legit being there when he 'got back' is a major thing, it's his main trump-card and goes somewhat against him only speaking in allegory with Moxie not long ago (ship of theseus). The wording in the rune-oath is imperfect, most folk picked up on it, and that is one of the main reasons why Lee is even trusted or part of the inner circle that is the gang. It's just strange that for a man who is usually quite reflective, suddenly stumps in a area that he has a good track record in. Like, it's as we are seeing some bloke put more and more important things in a rowboat, that everyone can see has a huge hole in it, but the guys just waves it of. Maybe if the flame monkey fight was more thought out, like more justified to Noah than just 'revenge' for getting killed to it, such as he knows the full/partial extend of it going missing, that way we can got more info in why there is a huge flaming monkey in their backyard and what stakes are attached to it outside the very obvious. Some more thinking on the biggest thing he has done in 60 chapters, instead of just picking up the idiot ball and beating himself up for it afterwards; everyone called it out, even himself 2 sec after doing it (friend called it 'post-murder clarity' when i described it lol). But i get that maybe the full range of it's importance might give away prematurely important stuff in part of the mystery. In which case maybe make it more apperent he has given it more thought, since he is working with limited info. Did like the fight tho. Tldr: Really like the story, with only two moments that felt odd. Hope my comments aren't to harsh, not my intent to ruin your day or being brutally honest (sometimes a disgues to be a dick).

Axim

Love it. Only request is more. :)

Bunny Waffles

It is nice to know that his primary motivation for not perma-dying, aside from his students, is the fact that he just doesn't want to get stuck standing in line for a millennium again.

Tidalais

I just find it… unexpected that many of the characters that the mc encounters turn out to be trustworthy and share the same humor and sarcasm he has :/

Tidalais

Realistically speaking, it’s far more believable for the mc to realize that trust isnt to be so easily given after he realizes that: (a) Moxie could have outed the mc to have the Master rune in order to gain benefits and recognition from her family since the mc is a member of an enemy family (b) all of the secrets about himself that he told others could be revealed accidentally or not if torture/interrogation/someone used a rune that deals with the mind/memory

Tidalais

My worry about the plausibility of the mc’s personality/character is that it doesnt make sense for him to wait in “a line” for hundreds of thousands of years after he died and NOT have a massive change in personality. Long periods of Isolation can dramatically turn a positive, joyful, witty, sarcastic, music-loving teacher into one who is cold, rigid, analytical, tense, calculated, cutthroat, and most likely insane/sociopathic . The very fact that the mc hasnt changed personality (as he constantly jokes around and shares excessive compassion toward essentially strangers) is kind of telling me that you want to create a Gary Stu :/ But it’s a good story tho!

seth

Ah I wasn't sure if there was an explicit promise, like no harem or something. The story is good. I think what you are trying to do is a hard thing. Knowing the background and plot. Have a MC drop in the middle, tabula rasa, and have him believably connect the dots with what has been revealed. So kudos on a job well done. I really look forward to some magic accomplishments. It's a unique magic system which is always fun.

Kevin Caffrey

I mostly am enjoying it, but slightly less so after the exam finished. There was a good balance of conflict and action before that, but it feels like the plot has been drifting a bit afterwards. There are some broader events pushing the plot forward, but those are all things that will take a while to resolve. “In the moment” it’s mostly a bunch of “ok I guess I’ll kill some more monsters until I die again”. My favorite parts were the professor aspects and those have barely been present after the exam. Anyway, still enjoying and will keep reading, hopefully the plot picks back up again soon!

Actus

It’s about to in the next few chapters!

Driftward

Very much enjoy the world and magic system you've incorporated. I will admit to some frustration with Noah's impatience, in some part due to the delay in learning more about the system, but also feels like an incredibly irrational response. The rational behind his not going to the library and investigating the world around him and building a foundational knowledge falls a bit flat. He's already gone to the library once for info on runes and combinations why wouldn't he do it again for follow-up questions? Maybe if the book needed wasn't available (all checked out by students?) then he would rush off to the next thing? Also, one possible continuity error. His first time at the wind location where he is eaten, how does he get the blank rune catch papers back from his presumably ingested pants? Maybe I missed this either the first time around or in a retcon but it threw me off the next time they were mentioned. Looking forward to more of this story (and your other current stories)!!

Actus

Fixed continuity error, cheers! Was just a 1 line modification. Also yoinked your suggestion, I like that a lot and it also let me do a few lines on why Noah is impatient rather than just ignoring it, so I think it was a good improvement!

Michael Rivertree

I can't point to anything specific I can think of, but I've lost a significant amount of interest in the story. I suppose maybe because it feels like the characters aren't real enough? The plot also seems like it was about to get convoluted in a bad way, but somehow neatly all came together in chapter 64. The MC does seem a bit too trusting though. It doesn't quite make sense how neither Moxie nor Lee has really tried to betray him (particularly Moxie being from an enemy family and having the juicy master Rune as leverage incentive to get benefits from someone). Maybe fleshing out the characters a bit would help. Also, the progression aspect has slacked quite a bit, I'm not able to remember what current runes he has (I thought he still had some lesser runes, also apparently he can have double of the same exact rune?) and the idea of him progressing is very back of mind right now, partially because we have no idea how it's done or initiated or means. What happens to his current abilities for example? As for value at 10 dollars, I'd say it's decent. Hope you appreciate the feedback. I know many are going to criticize me

Actus

Will have to take a look at the rest of this later, but he no longer has any lesser runes, he just upgraded them before killing the hellreaver. More progression will be coming again very soon! (I’ll check the rest of the feedback when I get back later today)

Thransk

There were what I thought of as plot holes for a while, but the demon summoning stuff actually pulled it together. Things like, why does Lee have "parents" if most skinwalkers are feral? So I think the direction is good, but it does feel rushed over the past few chapters.

Jeff Fischer

Overall the story is pretty good, and it's of much higher quality than many others I've read. I'm happy with it so far. As others have pointed out there are some slight pacing issues here and there but I don't think they're major. What I'd recommend is getting a serious editor to work with you if you plan on releasing this as a book to iron out some of the pacing issues that naturally crop up with a serial format. One note, I think it's smart that you're not using a standard LITRPG "wall of stats" format. Your magic system is explainable with a way of progressing, and I don't think you need to go to Sanderson levels of mapping out the mechanics of it either. Some of the standard tropes on RR / in Light Novels / among LITRPGs in general are getting a bit stale and played out, so going systemless is actually pretty refreshing imo.

OpN

After the exam, his reasoning for his goals felt less impactful. He's done almost no research on his goals after setting them, and is doing a lot of doing. It's felt incredibly shortsighted for someone who claims to be wise in all manners of things. The side characters have felt less like people in spite your attempts to show that they have problems outside of the plot. The deals and pacts they've formed with Noah haven't been fulfilled from his side in any way and it's led them to feel less like characters and more like helpers who will stop their dealings while Noah is busy with his murder mystery. Like when he was given the info for the greater wind rune and he just stopped after getting his runes. He said, "I'll get her runes after I kill hellreaver" but I couldn't figure out why hellreaver was important. I feel that the characters would be better if they moved on timelines seperate to the plot. So I've felt that his character has deteriorated after the exam, as it feels like there's an undisclosed deadline that he wasn't aware of in story that's being imposed on the plot. He's rushing through things, even though there's been no reason for it shown until the most recent chapter. His character did research and look to research things, but as shown recently, he's stopped doing that for reasons I feel barely cover it. "I don't want to sit around, I've been doing a lot of that" Okay? and what reason do you have to move at such a breakneck pace if not for a deadline we weren't aware of at the time? As such I think it's important that the story before he knows about the Linwicks plan be more mellowed and show the character taking their time more. I feel like I'd drop the story at this point, because his actions are starting to feel less justified, and the characters are behaving as if they're also aware of his murder mystery timeline. Withholding their own needs and interactions because Noah is busy solving something and can't be bothered. The characters just feel like addons, and not people also living lives. If I were Moxie, I'd feel like I'm sufficiently involved with Noah, and would want my side of the deals I've made. It's becoming less and less clear why she's helping Noah despite the lack of help he's given her. It's become very one-sided and it's difficult to say that the Moxie we've known to this point is so generous that she'd give up all benefits to help Noah. She's become a power ally crutch that doesn't feel deserved, because Noah hasn't done anything for her yet, other than be a nicer person to someone 3 times his rank. Moxie feels like she shouldn't be obliged or willing to do so much for Noah, as he hasn't done anything for her. His students have essentially been told to self study, because he killed the guardian/watchdog of the training grounds he used to visit. I'm curious what he intends to do with them, but his continuous epiphanies that he's essentially training them to be shock-troopers in a suicidal teaching method others don't do because they're not poor is getting tiring. It's been shown that when an enemy he could barely handle like the throwing monkies, he asked his students to retreat, and then DIED TO THE MONKEYS. How was it ever a question that he was treading a line just barely removed from death in his excursions with his students? His opinion on how he teaches his students doesn't feel realistic, and he's done little research on how others teach their students. His reason for killing the Hellreaver did feel forced, and didn't have a lot of meaning behind it, other than he'd died to it after entering its ring of fire before. It wasn't like it was the cause of any of his grief before this, and it's even been known that because it's in control of the monkeys in the area that they're easier to handle. Why he killed the Hellreaver doesn't feel sufficiently fleshed out in the context of the story, and that he did no research on it at any point feels incredibly dumb, even if he realizes that in hindsight.

Daniel

As others already mentioned, MC's actions seem completely nonsensical after the exams priority wise and the timeline doesn't really fit to MC's plans. Like he wanted to read about his family but after that one week where he could've gone to the lib to request the book he just didn't do it but instead waited for Moxie like a month until he got the book? No real reason to kill the Hellreaver? Would make much more sense to up its priority NOW that he knows theres more lurking in the forest so he needs some power? Also why does it need to be killed before he holds the end of his bargain with Moxie? MC is running around as if on a timer only he knows about and I don't understand it. First thing after the exam deadline any sane person would do is read up on as much info as possible. Apparently MC tries to fly under the radar while at the same time still doesn't even try to get up on speed with his knowledge and asks children's questions to other people. Yeah, very inconspicious... Another problem is that the plot seems to be created on the fly like that old cartoon where you build the train track right in front of you while at the same time riding it. Get in the world, somebody tells you theres a deadline. Reach deadline. Somebody tells you, yeah theres another deadline coming. At the same time see monster, kill monster, next monster is introduced. Kill next monster, new monster is introduced. Now we are getting closer to the 2nd exam and still have no idea where the story is going. After that exam is done will another person come up and will be like "nice work, the next exam is again in three months" and MC is like "wow didn't know, time to train more guys"? And after the regionals come the next regionals and then the next regionals, lol. The teaching aspect was also completely abandoned after the exams. Just let them train with Lee, MC has more grinding to do because, well, I don't know. Why? I hope the review doesn't sound too harsh. I still like the story, but I think like many others that it feels really lackluster since the exams. I really like your high pace but I wouldn't mind if you took a time off writing and instead maybe restructure the story a bit, make timelines, intentions and priorities of the characters more coherent.

Maplanic

"I don't want to sit around, I've been doing a lot of that" Okay? and what reason do you have to move at such a breakneck pace if not for a deadline we weren't aware of at the time? He doesn't want to sit around because of the potentially thousand years of sitting around doing nothing in a line, my guess is that he feels any time he spends sitting around is time wasted for when he goes back to the line. (though i'm also pretty sure he's trying to find a way to escape the cycle of reincarnation and by extention that damned line)

Aegir

Wow you made a lot of great points. If i remember right, his feeling of being rushed and rushing through comes from the innumerable years being stuck in the "afterlife reincanation line" and its effects on his pysche. Other than that I agree with why rush the hell reaver, why is the teacher that hated him helping this much, and his students being shallow addons.

OpN

We're aware that his overarching goal was to be strong enough that he could potentially rival the goddess Renewal or the one who attacked her, but that's so far away that short term power gains by his current actions seem unreasonable. Because he's not researching, he has no goals other than the ones currently infront of him. I agree with your point, I don't think I was able to communicate it clearly like you did, it does feel like the monsters he's facing are just whatever is infront of him at any given moment. That he's not researching or asking around for monsters to gain power, he's just killing anything around him with no knowledge other than throwing himself at them.

Daniel

Yeah, this also somewhat plays into the thing you wrote about the side characters. MC acts rather whimsically or arbitrarily and the depictions of the side characters are paying the price. In one moment big teacher that kills himself over and over to give his students better chances and next second doesn't care anymore and goes hunting for weeks on end for his own goals, whatever they may be. It's like, where should the plot go? In comes Moxie and gives the next targets. Pure plot device. No real interaction and character outline. This is obviously exaggerated, but I believe you catch my drift.

OpN

I had a moment while reading that left me reeling. It was when Moxie said she was shadowing his class for his methods of monster fighting. He vaguely waved his hand and dismissed the conversation. I felt that unless they were on the best of terms, that level of dismisal would be disrespectful, even flaunting authority. I thought, "what kind of cardboard cutout replaced Moxie?".

Abbi

Yes, but because of currency conversion I'm not sure which yes I should click - Big Hungry Orc

Actus

That's the $10 tier