Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What to do with the Spell-less Ranger?

  • When the Spell-less Ranger is included, override the PHB Ranger but not the UA Revised Ranger 4
  • When the Spell-less Ranger is included, override both the PHB Ranger and the UA Revised Ranger 1
  • Add the Spell-less Ranger as its own class-name: "Spell-less Ranger" 41
  • 2017-04-05
  • —2017-04-08
  • 46 votes
{'title': 'What to do with the Spell-less Ranger?', 'choices': [{'text': 'When the Spell-less Ranger is included, override the PHB Ranger but not the UA Revised Ranger', 'votes': 4}, {'text': 'When the Spell-less Ranger is included, override both the PHB Ranger and the UA Revised Ranger', 'votes': 1}, {'text': 'Add the Spell-less Ranger as its own class-name: "Spell-less Ranger"', 'votes': 41}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2017, 4, 8, 12, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2017, 4, 5, 12, 20, 14, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 46}

Content

As I'm now going back  to add support for all the older Unearthed Arcana articles, I will have some decisions to make on how to implement stuff. To help me with making these decisions, I'm coming to you!

The first problem in this regard is the spell-less ranger from Unearthed Arcana: Modifying Classes.

As it is now, the sheet has two different options for the Ranger: the one from the PHB, and the one from the UA: the Ranger, Revised. When you include the latter source, you will always get the Revised Ranger when you enter "Ranger" into the class field.However, with this new spell-less ranger, there would be an effective third option that would listen to the name "Ranger". Thus, we need to decide which takes priority.

Comments

Mark Wilkins

Or, how about Ranger, PHB; Ranger, UA: Revised; and, Ranger, Spell-less? IOW, Ranger first, then the source perhaps like you do with some of the backgrounds?

MorePurpleMoreBetter

Do you really want that class field to say something like "Ranger, PHB (Hunter) 4, Cleric (War Domain) 3"? Because that's not really something that I would want. None of the backgrounds in the drop-down box on the first page has its source named in there, so I'm not sure what you getting at with 'like you do with some of the backgrounds'.

Ryc O'Chet

I'd rather have the source named if it's not from the raw books simply because a lot of people will only want to refer to them - a checkbox somewhere to allow for disabling the extra sources (default they're there) - not sure how far to take that idea, but there's even the cut down free rules they've put up on their site as a limited source...

MorePurpleMoreBetter

I'm not sure that I understand what you are getting at. Do you not know how the sheet handles source inclusion and exclusion currently, using the "Source Material" bookmark? There basically already is a system comparable to "a checkbox somewhere to allow for disabling the extra sources (default they're there)", but better. Note that the sources of the different class features will still be named as such in the "Class Features" section of the sheet.

Mark Wilkins

I wouldn't mind but I recognize that I might be alone in that. :-) Regarding the comment on backgrounds, you have two drop down boxes for backgrounds. Not all backgrounds use the second drop down box. That's all I meant. I was just suggesting a way to organize things.

Mark Wilkins

Do you have a schedule for including the newest UA article with the new spells? Some of them look really good.

MorePurpleMoreBetter

Ah, so you mean to include the source of the class somewhere in the top of the first page, not in the classes & levels line? This will be very tricky because, unlike backgrounds, you can have more than one class...

MorePurpleMoreBetter

With the update to include all UA material, the new spells will also be included. I'm now going through the UA articles chronologically, starting with the oldest. Once all are done, I will release a new version of the sheet.

Ryc O'Chet

That's the one - couldn't remember what it's called (juggling several projects at work) - but labelling where they come from is the relevant part of this. My use is printing them out for players at a tabletop game though, so not sure if that's typical to people using this - maybe worth doing a survey on that at some point ;-)

Mark Wilkins

Personally, I wouldn't mind having the classes listed each in its own line, so long as the level is included. To save space on the first page, you could consider moving the height, weight, gender, hair, eyes, skin, age, alignment and faith information to the background sheet. Mechanically that information is irrelevant, and it fits nicely with the background information. Doing so would save you a couple of lines of space on the first page. Or, perhaps you could pop up a box to capture all the class information, and then concatenate it appropriately to present it? You use a pop up box to capture all the correct numbers for the ability scores and then collapse all that information appropriately into the ability scores stack. Perhaps something similar for classes? Just throwing out ideas...

MorePurpleMoreBetter

Hmm your long comment is only showing up on the Patreon app, but not on the site, strange... Anyway, your idea is a good one and maybe having a pop-up dialogue to select classes will help people who are new to the sheet. I'll take it under consideration. However, I don't feel anything for making multiple lines for classes. First off, this would only work on the Colourful sheets, as the Printer Friendly ones definitely don't have space for this. Secondly, I am of the opinion that this will look rather ugly for most characters. I would probably have to make 3 or 4 of these lines, while more often than not a character has levels in no more than 2 classes.

Mark Wilkins

Very true -- I haven't run into anybody who multiclasses into more than two classes, but there is nothing in the rules that would prevent it, so long as they have the prerequisite ability scores.

Michael Ramm

I don't like the idea of the source overriding any previous source. Since 2 of the 3 sources are not "official" and thereby not official for things like Adv League, I would like to see someway of differentiating with source we are using. Ideally, it would be nice to have a drop-down for class, instead of typing in the Class. Now, I don't know how that would affect multi-classing. I guess people usually open a blank form and can select the Sources each time they start up a new character. I have not created a bunch of characters in my return to D&D, but my main is a Ranger so I am interested in how this goes. Thanks for all the GREAT work!

Jason Strobush

Joost, wouldit be possible to treat the various Ranger options like a cleric domain, or a sorcerer origin? "You've indicated Ranger, please pick the type of Ranger" in a modal? Failing that, I think having special keywords would be better than overrides -- "Ranger, Ranger (Martial),Ranger (Revised), etc." I've never played a Ranger (they didn't appeal to me), so please take with a grain of salt.

MorePurpleMoreBetter

Remember that the source will only override if you include it. You will only override the PHB Ranger if you actively have the sheet include the Unearthed Arcana articles that have the Revised Ranger in them. Making the class field a drop-down box would make multiclassing a bit of an issue and you will delete your whole character if you press the up or down key by mistake while having that field as active... but maybe I should just do it as a lot of people seem to struggle with the fact that they have to type the name of a class instead of selecting it from a drop-down box.

MorePurpleMoreBetter

What you are asking is not possible with how the sheet is set up. A class can have subclasses, that are the options you see. A subclass can't have further a sub-subclass. The Ranger's each have their own subclasses (like the cleric domains) to select.

Jeremy Horn

Can you add it as a selectable class feature like a fighting style or warlock pact

MorePurpleMoreBetter

Short answer: No! A selectable class feature is jut for a single class feature, not for a whole class.

Avinash Arora

New subscriber here, I don't have an opinion on this vote, I just want to say how grateful I am for all of the work you have done, and how exceptional this sheet is. MPMB you are a friggin godsend. This is unbelievably beautiful work.