Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

So... I've done a thing - my first CPE video.  I'm still working on a lot - including script writing, visual style, audio.  Let me know what you think!

Files

Previews only

City Planner Explains: How Autonomous Vehicles Could Ruin Cities if We Don't Plan for Them

City Planner Explains: How Autonomous Vehicles Could Ruin Cities if We Don't Plan for Them For years, leaders have been predicting that autonomous vehicles...

Comments

Kris Culin

I commented on the YouTube posting but I'll summarize it here. The July 2008 edition of Popular Science had a huge article on future green energy ideas. One of them was adding wind turbines to the sides of the highway. As traffic flies by, the turbines turn to generate power. One of the other points I brought up in my YT comments was about what happens with the auto-car runs out of power on the way to their destination? Even if the computer checks the traffic at the start of the trip and allows for a buffer, it can't know what might happen "after" the trip starts. So if the trip starts with minimal traffic and then there is a serious accident that backs things up, then the car runs out of battery power, what happens? Does the car call AAA? Is AAA manned or automated? Another question I brought up is whether the car would go to a charging station by itself during a trip? If during the trip it detects it needs a charge, would it stop at the charging station? If it did, would it somehow plug itself in or is there an attendant? As far as accessibility goes, it seems that would be covered by the ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act). There would have to be some auto-cars that are accessible. Perhaps they drive themselves but there would be an attendant to assist the disabled passenger to get in/out of the vehicle. There's still a job there. These are the smaller, nit-picky questions that also need to be answered. And I'd argue, these are just the tip of the proverbial iceburg.

CityPlannerPlays

Those are great questions! My guess is that we'll need better battery tech and significantly better charging infrastructure before this ever becomes a reality. Interestingly, the new infrastructure bill does include 7.5 billion for charging infrastructure, but that's just a drop in the bucked compared to what we need. Regarding ADA - it wouldn't cover this sort of mobility without some sort of change to the legislation. That is why UBER and LYFT are not required to provide accessible rides. Generally, taxi companies that provide this service do so at a loss, so it really miffs them that these ridesharing companies are able to operate and steal rides without providing the expensive, but very needed, service. Completely agree - lots of little questions that need to be answered. As I get more comfortable making this style content, expect me to really dive into these types of questions as well as seek questions from the audience and seek to draw from experience/research the answers.

Anonymous

I have to be honest, I'd rather see autonomous mass public transportation, than individual. Buses, rail, or other forms that could eliminate congestion, and improve accessibility. I'm in Central Ohio, and in the last say, 20 years, "Columbus" metro has grown, with insane growth the last 5-8 years. Where it used to be someone commuting from Dayton (~1 hour away) was not a norm, now it's becoming more and more common. Columbus struggles with the Midwest issue of poor mass transit, and reliability on personal vehicles. When I spent time in NYC and London, England one of the things I loved most was the idea that I didn't need a car, and in fact the only time I used a car was to travel outside of those areas to more rural destinations. I'd love to see America (and the world at large) look more into mass transit autonomy. And not even just local mass transit, but even regional. Maybe it's a dream, but being able to hop on automated rail to go to Chicago/NYC/DC would be pretty cool!