Icarus Games' Response to the Rumored OGL Changes (Patreon)
Content
Greetings folks, as I'm sure you'll have seen over the last few weeks there's currently a lot of turmoil in the 5e space over the proposed and rumored changes to the Open Gaming License.
This post will lay out Icarus Games' position, as well as give some information on what we'll be doing going forward. It's not going to be nearly as fun as our usual posts, but it's important stuff. I will edit this post with more information as and when needed. [Edits will be in bold and contained in square brackets - Latest edit 18th January added to bottom of post]
This post is broken down into 4 major parts.
1. What is the OGL
2. The rumored changes
3. How this impacts SIDEQUEST magazine
4. How this impacts Icarus Games products
1. What is the OGL
The Open Gaming License is a document released by Wizards of the Coast that grants 3rd party publishers (that's us!) the right to use elements from their core rules (called the System Reference Document), allowing 3pp to make content that is compatible with the fifth edition of the world's oldest roleplaying game. If you've picked up almost any 3pp product in the last decade, you'll have seen a copy of the 1.0 OGL in the credits page.
2. The Rumored Changes
In December 2022, rumors started to circulate that Wizards of the Coast were going to be changing the OGL with One D&D in ways that would impact creators big and small. This change is version 1.1 of the OGL
In response to the utter chaos this caused, WotC released a statement to "clarify" some of the rumors.
The statement was short, full of PR-speak, but confirmed things would be changing. Most notably, 3pp would have to register their creations with WotC, report revenue over $50k, pay royalties on revenue over $750k, and put a special badge on their work to show it was OGL compatible.
In the weeks since that statement, there's been a lot of speculation about WotC potentially attempting to make the 1.0 OGL invalid going forward.
Well, today (January 5th, 2023), Gizmod published an article discussing a leaked copy of the 1.1 OGL that they had been sent.
The full article is well worth reading, but there are several key points I want to highlight;
OGL 1.0 is “no longer an authorized license agreement.”
This is the big one. The 1.1 OGL is supposedly going to try and make the 1.0 version invalid.
There's a lot of discussion happening in the creator space (including many people bringing in lawyers) about whether this is actually enforceable, but it seems that what WotC wants to do is undo section 4 of OGL 1.0
4. Grant and Consideration: In consideration for agreeing to use this License, the Contributors grant You a perpetual, worldwide, royalty-free, non-exclusive license with the exact terms of this License to Use, the Open Game Content.
This would essentially mean that if you want to make material compatible with D&D, your only option is to sign up to OGL 1.1.
Registering With WotC
The leaked OGL 1.1 supposedly says the following;
“no matter what Tier You are in or how much money You believe Your product will make, You must register with Us any new Licensed Work You intend to offer for sale... including a description of the Licensed Work. We’ll also ask for Your contact information, information on where You intend to publish the Licensed Work, and its price, among other things.”
This means a whole new avenue of book keeping for creators, stifles creator's ability to move and create quickly, and means WotC will potentially be able to much more easily block the publication of 3pp material.
Money, Money, Money
One of the biggest changes to the OGL between 1.0 and the rumored 1.1 version is that the license is no longer royalty free on the side of 3pp.
3pp earnings are broken down as follows;
A. Initiate Tier. If You have registered at least one Licensed Work but haven’t generated $50,000 or more in total (gross) revenue from OGL: Commercial products in a given year, You are at the Initiate Tier.
B. Intermediate Tier. If Your Licensed Work(s) have generated more than $50,000 in total revenue in a given year but less than $750,000, You are at the Intermediate Tier.
C. Expert Tier. If Your Licensed Work(s) have generated at least $750,000 in total revenue in a given year, You are at the Expert Tier.
Those in the Intermediate and expert Tiers have to report their earnings to to WotC, and those in the Expert Tier have to pay 20-25% royalties to WotC on qualifying revenue (anything over $750k/year).
It's pure speculation, but it seems like the only reason WotC would want creators earning over $50k/year to report their income is to get a census of how much 3pp are making, and adjust the threashold for the expert tier in the future. After all, D&D is under monetized according to the CEO.
But what's worse is the 1.1 OGL grants WotC a “nonexclusive, perpetual, irrevocable, worldwide, sub-licensable, royalty-free license to use that content for any purpose.” which means they can make money from the content 3pp make and not have to pay them a cent, but 3pp have to report income, register, and pay royalties.
Another thing to note is that the Expert Tier isn't the only way they can get money from 3pp. Elsewhere in OGL 1.1 it supposedly says;
“Note that if You appear to have achieved great success... from producing OGL: Commercial content, We may reach out to You for a more custom(and mutually beneficial) licensing arrangement,”
Uncertain Future
As part of OGL 1.1, WotC have added the following clause which states they :
“can modify or terminate this agreement for any reason whatsoever, provided We give thirty (30) days’ notice.”
This is a huge problem 3pp as it means you could spend thousands developing a product within the guidelines, only to have WotC change their license terms and prevent you from publishing it.
3. How This Impacts SIDEQUEST Magazine & This Patreon
Until we have concrete information on the OGL and the future of third party publishing for fifth edition content, SIDEQUEST magazine will not use the OGL or publish 5e compatible material.
This is a significant departure from our previous publishing approach, and it is going to cause some problems for us internally in terms of figuring out what we can and can't reference/allude to, and as such, I expect issue 20 to be delayed while we figure out what content we currently have can be published and source new content.
4. How This Impacts Icarus Games Products
While this leaked details could still turn out to be false, or WotC could U-turn based on public backlash, this entire situation has been hideously stressful as a solo-creator who works full-time making ttrpg content.
I'm confident that even if WotC pull the plug on the OGL, Icarus will survive, but there will potentially be some tough times ahead.
As such, I am scrapping all projects involving OGL content that I had planned for the next couple of years. Fortunately, the next couple of Kickstarter projects I have in development are generic fantasy and don't require the OGL to be made, but there are several books that were super early development which I am putting aside for the time being until we have concrete information about the future of the OGL.
Regardless of what happens, I currently have no plans to produce any content for One D&D or publish under OGL 1.1.
What WotC seem to be trying to do is not an open game, and I refuse to bend the knee as they try and demolish more than two decades of development under the OGL.
In the short term, I have no plans to produce any D&D compatible content, either through SIDEQUEST, independent PDF and print material, videos, or any other medium.
If it transpires that 3pp can continue creating content under the OGL 1.0 without having to interact with WotC, I will continue to produce 5e-compatible materials, or else all my future content will be system-agnostic, or compatible with other popular systems.
What You Can Do
The best thing you can do is make a lot of noise. Tag WotC/D&D on social media and let them know your thoughts on these proposed changes.
Use the hashtag #OpenDnD in these posts to help spread the word and let WotC know that the only D&D you're interested in is an Open D&D!
[JANUARY 18th Update]
Hey folks, WotC just put out a statement on D&DBeyond which has changed some things that I want to talk about.
First of all, their claims that the leaks were drafts are just lies. The leaked documents were sent out with ready-to-sign contracts; you don't do that with a draft you intent to solicit feedback from.
Secondly, they have been very vague in regards to whether they still intend to revoke the 1.0a OGL. However, they have said the following:
Your OGL 1.0a content. Nothing will impact any content you have published under OGL 1.0a. That will always be licensed under OGL 1.0a.
This should mean we are safe to publish content as usual until such a time that WotC introduce the new version of the license.
Based on the timeline given in that article, the feedback surveys will remain open until February 3rd, and then there will be a period of time for them to "compile, analyze, react to, and present back" the responses.
As of today (January 18th) my plan is as follows:
- Take the existing 5e content we have written and publish it in Issue 20, which will release on or before January 29th
- If there is sufficient additional material in the bank, I will put together issue 21 to be released as early into February as possible.
Doing this will give us more room to solicit new, system agnostic content for future issues just in case WotC do still go forward with their plans to revoke 1.0a.
I will update you if and when we get more information from WotC.
I've also got some plans in motion for future content, which I will hopefully be able to talk about soon.
Files
Previews only