Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

In the same way that Doctor Who fans have their One True Doctor, and Trek fans have their Captain, I think a lot of us have our One True Holmes. For me it's always Jeremy Brett, no matter how wonderful other actors have been in the role. (And they certainly have been.) I've had the old Granada TV series running in the background while I pack, and today during The Adventure of the Empty House I realized that I also have a One True Watson, and I'm a bit surprised to find it's Martin Freeman from the BBC Sherlock series. I always did want Watson to punch Holmes in that episode, and the Sherlock writers apparently agreed. Poor Watson, he really does put up with so much.

My kids have, by the way, declared for the Miyazaki "Sherlock Hound" Holmes. 

I'm running out of Holmes though, so I need to find some other costume drama series to keep me company. Phil has suggested Sharpe's Rifles, but I might put in Cadfael again since I've got it sitting around.


Files

Previews only

Comments

Elka Tovah Davidoff

I really love Franz! Wondering whether we will find out what happens to the Iram Solis before this story ends.

Kevin L. Nault

You definitely can't go wrong with Cadfael. I think a lot of productions and/or Watsons got the relationship wrong in a way Martin Freeman got it right, where Watson isn't as smart as Holmes, and is impressed by him, but is also a social equal and pushes back against Holmes' interpersonal excesses (like using Watson as a patsy in Hound of the Baskervilles).

AlpineBob

"EVERYBODY GRAB YOUR TOOLS!"

Anonymous

Just came here to say I adore Cadfael also and agree about Martin Freeman-- fantastic Watson!