Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

šŸ”“Vote for next Tier 3 Anime

  • Hinamatsuri 75
  • My Dress-Up Darling 178
  • Cinderella Grey 64
  • Call of the Night 183
  • Bunny Girl Senpai 118
  • 2025-12-27
  • —2025-12-29
  • 618 votes
{'title': 'šŸ”“Vote for next Tier 3 Anime', 'choices': [{'text': 'Hinamatsuri ', 'votes': 75}, {'text': 'My Dress-Up Darling ', 'votes': 178}, {'text': 'Cinderella Grey', 'votes': 64}, {'text': 'Call of the Night ', 'votes': 183}, {'text': 'Bunny Girl Senpai', 'votes': 118}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 12, 29, 2, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 12, 27, 23, 55, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 618}

Content

We finished Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! this past Friday. Please vote for what you would like as the next up anime on that tier. This vote will be open until 6 pm Sunday (tomorrow), and the winner will start on Monday. Thank you! These were the most suggested titles:

Comments

Kevin Baker

Hinamatsuri! Makeine voters help us! we were 2nd in the last vote.

GardeninTool

UMA BROS. WE GOTTA PULL UP!!!!!!!!!!!

JoeyGuy7

I voted for it but I fear it stands no chance vs mdud. I bet it'll replace haikyuu tho

JoeyGuy7

Every show on this list is a banger

Dolfy

Damn, Cinderella Grey is but it's looking like an uphill battle.

Sam

I’ve only not seen Hinamatsuri but all of the others are unironically great in their own way

Avalon

Neck and neck for dress up or call of the night? Shit man Either way I’m eating good

Red Menace

šŸ˜”no food wars, oh well, maybe next time, lol.

Red Menace

Well I got to say, don't know how Tony will feel about call of the night given the age of the protagonist, but it is chill, Hina is fun, my dress up darling is super cute, don't know the other 2. Lol, when I put Tony in it auto corrected to Toby

Red Menace

Gonna go with my dress up darling

Edgar Lopez

it has got to be dress up darling

Shucks

Hope call of the night wins. it is something special, especially in season 2 and it will only get better

Sam

The soundtrack is incredibly vibey

PlatypusPrince

This is such an unbelievably stacked line up. Gotta go Call of The Night though it is something truly special (especially the second season)

Lock in

Tony has made it quite clear that’s he uncomfortable with the age gaps and those type of scenes. Which is why he doesn’t want to watch Mushoku. And you guys want him to watch Call of the night, which is pretty much the same thing?

A

I think you'd be amazed by Rascal Does not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai, as it's all-around one of the most *fantastically* written romance anime -- or any anime -- of recent years. The dialog and writing is absolutely phenomenal and is an easy top-tier recommendation to almost anyone who appreciates well-written characters. Surprised to see Call of the Night here, as while the vibe is great it has aspects that you've seemed to not be a great fan of before. "Insomniacs After School" might be a future alternative to it that deals with a grounded and non-supernatural take with still some of the same atmosphere.

Makotheq60

The dub for my dressup darling is good

Shuuuuuu

I know umamusume wont win but it is an incrediblely fun one

Shucks

lol there is a vast difference between how call of the night handles that and how mushoku does. I can't watch mushoku for the same reason but love COTN

Lock in

I don’t see the difference, they both glorify pedophilia. The age gap romance in Call of the night is literally a 14 year old with a 40 year old. They don’t even treat it as bad

Red Menace

I will agree that there is a difference in how age plays into call of the night and mushoku,. Ive watched and enjoyed both, but even still, the age dif is enough in call to potentially make tony not like it. I love the chill vibes and soundtrack to chill to, but i, personally, as someone who does not know tony, just from hearing and reading his tastes here on the patreon, think he wont vibe with the show. That being said maybe the soundtrack will overcome it or something, looks like night is going to win, so we shall see. Edit: to clarify my point, the problem is not that there's an age difference per-say, its that its a 14 yr old and a above 18 yr old, its not that there's a huge dif in years, more that its a CHILD and a ADULT in a romantic setting, whether it addresses it or not. but again, if it wins, its something for tony to decide, the soundtrack is truly great. Second edit: and i don't think that tony will neccesarily vibe with dress up either, its not over the top like kaguya, it doesn't have the killer soundtrack of heroines. I also don't think the humor type in hina will fit him either, and i don't remember enough of bunny girl senpai to be definitive, but i don't think he'll like that one either, and ive never heard of, or seen the other 2

Jet Man

šŸ¤

Sam

If we’re gonna do another sports one at some point it should 100% be the choice

Sk dragon

We need to keep the momentum up for the next one

SimplySora

Bunny girl senpai is peak

guapaholic

Bunny Girl Senpai is a gateway drug into Bakemonogatari and i really wanna see one lead to the other LMAO

JoeyGuy7

What are ur thoughts on twilight

Lock in

Never seen it.

GardeninTool

Our time will come. The more we shout the bigger our momentum going into the voting will be!

Shucks

they absolutely do treat it as bad, that kind of plays into the idea that EVERYTHING Ko is doing he shouldn't be because he is 14. These are decisions that can't and shouldn't be made yet. The vampire thing is one big allegory and that plays into the themes of the entire story. the actions of vampires are still treated as immoral, and a twisted method of survival. They feel predatory because they ARE predatory. That is why multiple vamps opt out of the usual methods. Without spoiling, all I'll say is that we are only 2 seasons in. There's a lot of discussion about the fact that they are vampires that are immortal, Nazunas situation is particularly unique in how age affected her, and her maturity in relation to Ko and the other Vamps. Ultimately, that sort of discussion always feels weird to me. I think I'd have an issue depending on the direction of the story. Mushoku rewards and ignores the problem, this story does not, at least thematically. It is not blunt in that fact, so will it go over well still? I dont know, but its not even close on the same level as MT.

HaruhiDream

Literally every vampire story has age gaps. The original Dracula story had age gaps. Presentation matters and Call of the Night keeps things grounded in a way I don't think Tony would have a problem with. I think he is a lot less likely to enjoy Dress Up Darling due to all the fanservice.

Lock in

So what, Mushoku is literally the same thing and Tony is disgusted by that. The problem here is that it involves a 14 year old kid. I don’t see Tony liking this series because of this at all

Shucks

lol Whether it ends up bothering him or not we just cannot be calling this portrayal and MTs portrayal the same thing. that just is not true

Arsenic805

Yup I agree with shucks. As someone who is caught up on the COTN anime and has read the manga in it's entirety, it is honestly more of a thriller drama with romance, with the main romance being a background plot at times. They address the age gap issues pretty well throughout the story. The only similarities to MT is the age gap but I'd argue the portrayal is handled more maturely in COTN.. And the ending of COTN is handled pretty well in regards to the age gap as well. But yeah, regardless, let's let Tony form his own opinion.

JoeyGuy7

Media literacy is dead smh

Red Menace

this, it surprised me how good it was, i wasn't expecting it

peeps

Insomniacs After School is super underrated. One of my personal favourite romance anime/manga to come out in recent years.

MGC

gotta be call of the night

Astellar

Are there any anime you think have bad dubs?

Makotheq60

Plus I just really love amalee everything she does is fantastic one of my favorite English va and vtubers

Bylov6812

Cingrey with the John Williams soundtrack

sky

There’s no way those are the choices