Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey gang!

Here is March's Bonus Video where I react to Rolling Stone's list (compiled by Rob Sheffield) of the 100 best solo Beatle songs.In what has become easily my longest Bonus Video at over an hour, I had a ball going through this fantastic list and didn't skip a single entry.What are your thoughts? What's missing? Let us know in the comments to this Patreon post.

Enjoy the video!

E.

Files

Reacting to Rolling Stone's 100 Best Solo Beatles Songs

Comments

Kevin Mattocks

Rob Sheffield lost the plot when he called Now and Then a "masterpiece" and it being "the final statement Beatles fan deserve". Pretty sure Abbey Road is a masterpiece and the final statement we already had and deserved. I'm scared of looking at this list.

Kevin Mattocks

Haha thanks. I'm currently watching it and apart from the Ringo stuff there's nothing outrageous. However him telling you it's more a "playlist' then a "ranking" is a bit of a lame excuse. It's called The 100 best solo songs and they are ranked. Anyway great video so far. As always! Looking forward to your Ringo video!

Heath Bradshaw

Am sure some rankings are going to annoy me..but hey, list is subjective..hoping Junior's Farm is up there..best Wings song in my humble opinion 😁

HappyRon

Thanks for doing this and your other solo rankings. One of the tragedies of the breakup is that so many great songs aren't as well known as they should be. Every song on every Beatles album is known by tens (hundreds?) of millions of people but few have heard all of the solo work. Ironically one of the reasons for the breakup is that they felt like it was a fight for space on the albums, but by breaking up they made some of their good solo music relatively obscure. I'm looking forward to your Ringo list: when people ask me what are my greatest influences as a performer I always say 1) The Beatles and 2) the early 70s work of Mr. Ringo Starr. His RINGO album sounds the most like an actual Beatles album and is all fun. I got into music seriously in my 40s and I found that when I played at open mikes with my Ringo-like music people were so relieved to hear music that was just trying to have a good time. I don't like really any of his music after the early 70s (and feel that more of those early songs should have been included in this list) and I'm hoping your new list will spark some interest in later music. Thanks again!

amanda siegelson

i agree that is a totally lame excuse for ranking some of those ringo songs so high. it also bugs me that he got the year paul was in jail wrong (1980) but that’s because i am such a bitch! 😂

Kevin Mattocks

Unless bitch means being right, I wouldn't call myself that 😂. Being a Beatles expert means getting things right. It also bugs me when things are wrong.

August Hutchins

For the Dolby Atmos mixes: if you’re listening to them on Apple Music, just turn off Spatial Audio. You’ll be able to enjoy the original mixes of those George Harrison albums.

Erin Wiggins

It wasn’t a bad list & I loved your reaction. Maybe I’m Amazed is my favorite song ever. However, I’d have specified the Wings Over America live version, as I feel it is superior to the McCartney version (not that I don’t love that album).

Amy Lineaweaver

Why am I crying? Did this encapsulate so much of what I adore about The Beatles? Did Rob Sheffield’s words hit on the extraordinary gift The Beatles are to all of us?

noremac

perfect timing! i’m relistening to their solo albums for the first time right now, my first reactions can be found on IG @toomanysoloalbums in case anyone is intrigued

noremac

also i’m incredibly excited for your ringo list, everything after vertical man pretty much confounded me so i’m curious to see how you rank his later material

Emily Walton

This was delightful to watch. To me, I like lists like this because it really gets people talking and thinking.

Sam

well there ever be a beatles album ranking

jackie tanner

i knew when he’d put i’d have you any time at 98 i would be personally disagreeing a lot on this list 😭 great video! happy to finally be a patron!!

Stella Lampe

Love seeing Queenie Eye relatively high up! New was the first McCartney album I remember being able to anticipate coming out. As a relatively young fan, the singles, especially Queenie Eye, hold a lot of nostalgia for me. When I saw Paul in 2022 he played it at my show and I absolutely lost my mind, I thought he'd never play those songs again after Egypt Station and McCartney III came out.

Stella Lampe

also fun fact about You're Sixteen was written by the brother duo who wrote Its a Small World and several Disney movie soundtracks like Mary Poppins. The surviving brother just died on Saturday.

Wilts

I looked up the article seconds after watching because I felt so flabbergasted at myself for somehow missing the ranking and comments on Silly Love Songs... I think some people really had enough. 💔

Scott Whiting

On the topic of scrapped Harrisongs: Sat Singing is, to me, George’s best song of the 80’s, it beats most of George’s output that decade by a mile! Wish they would put it on streaming though…

Tyler Piper

I think this is a really cool varied list! The one song I'd add would be Behind that Locked Door from George. Also I'm biased but I would've loved to see more Beacoups of Blues tunes, as that is probably my favorite solo beatles album. Great video!

steven anderson

I find the trendy aversion to cloud 9 and the over inflation of some of the MOR slop from GH’s 70’s output mystifying. Devils radio in particular is a scandalous omission given some of the truly average stuff included, it’s a list made by someone whose basically showing off, look at all the b sides and deep cuts I know.

Davis H

I find that to be a bad faith interpretation of this list. This is all just Rob’s opinion, what he likes most. I get it if he isn’t a fan of the 80s stuff and is more a fan of George’s B-sides. I definitely don’t think he is trying to show off, I think he’s just made a list of what his favourites and it’s nothing more than that.

steven anderson

I have no trust in a man who genuinely thinks that a snippet of a half remembered strum along from the late 60’s India retreat is worthy of inclusion on merit as a great song and that’s what it takes, fish on a sand or devils radio aren’t! Of course it’s personal opinion but there’s a lot of snobbery in music appreciation circles in general, and hey absolutely sometimes there are b sides and deep cuts that are horrendously under appreciated in favour of the hits or more obvious album tracks, I just find the ones chosen here a bit meh. That’s just my opinion, bad faith, well, yeah maybe, I read his book and fundamentally disagreed with a lot of his hot takes but that’s not say it’s not an interesting book very much worth reading. Revolution in the head, the entire introduction is wank as far as I’m concerned but it’s a fascinating read even when you disagree. People used to do that all the time, disagree, it made for lively debate, and a great night in the pub for sure! Now online if you have divergent opinion you’re just an idiot etc. I know btw that’s not what you were saying but you take my point.