Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Vote on topics for Bonus Video - January

  • Wings: An assessment of every iteration of the band 47
  • A brief history and review of The Beach Boys’ SMiLE 31
  • Ranking David Bowie's personas 15
  • Elliot's favourite non-album tracks by Paul McCartney 1
  • The story of Klaatu: The band people thought were The Beatles 17
  • The Beatles Rockband: The Official Video Game 37
  • Elliot predicts how media/art consumption will change in the coming decade & what it means for artists + musicians 3
  • How the Beatles were viewed by contemporary musicians of their time 9
  • 2025-01-18
  • —2025-01-22
  • 160 votes
{'title': 'Vote on topics for Bonus Video - January', 'choices': [{'text': 'Wings: An assessment of every iteration of the band', 'votes': 47}, {'text': 'A brief history and review of The Beach Boys’ SMiLE', 'votes': 31}, {'text': "Ranking David Bowie's personas", 'votes': 15}, {'text': "Elliot's favourite non-album tracks by Paul McCartney", 'votes': 1}, {'text': 'The story of Klaatu: The band people thought were The Beatles', 'votes': 17}, {'text': 'The Beatles Rockband: The Official Video Game', 'votes': 37}, {'text': 'Elliot predicts how media/art consumption will change in the coming decade & what it means for artists + musicians', 'votes': 3}, {'text': 'How the Beatles were viewed by contemporary musicians of their time', 'votes': 9}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 22, 11, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 18, 8, 56, 46, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 160}

Content

Hey everybody!

Got some great topics for you all this new year.
I received another good Beach Boys one so I temporarily retired the previous BB topic so as to not split the vote between them.

I wanted to ask though... is this too many topics? I was concerned about the paradox of choice and am considering lowering the max number of topics to vote on (ironically, as a way of calculating this amount I may use another poll that you can also all vote on).
Let me know your thoughts in the comments to this post.

E.

Comments

Chris Lujano

I wish your more in depth review of Better Man was apart of this poll.

Jesse Hart

I would maybe consider lowering it down to 5 topics. They're all great topics but maybe you can bank some for future polls

Canned Rat Meat

Honestly even though I suggested the Beatles rock band Klaatu would be a good one too

Elliot Roberts

Yes, I think that's a fair number. I've also got to consider the people in the tier above and their topic-submitting benefit each month. Tricky one!

Connor Lammas

Beach Boys fans rise up for our long lost Pet Sounds follow-up Smile 🫡

Jesse Hart

All fair points. Way to be so good at what you do that so many people want to be in the topic submitting tier

Hannah Moran

I would amend the Bowie option to just be an exploration of his personas instead of a ranking, simply because everyone’s idea of David Bowie is so different, and people can get very nitpicky. This was a VERY tough choice, though, because all of the ideas sound great!! I’ll be happy with whatever wins ☺️☮️

thisguy

Just a curious question about Klaatu (it’s definitely an interesting topic to make a video about), how much would really be different from Polyphonic’s video on the same topic? Just curious as to how much more to the story there really is

Elliot Roberts

I'll be transparent, I actually don't know much about them and haven't seen that video. This was submitted by a Patron and so it went in the poll. It would mean I'd be researching them on my own terms, so vote with that in mind I suppose!

thisguy

Ah I see, thanks for the clarification! The story’s just kinda “this 70s band sounds Beatlesesque so they must actually be the Beatles secret reunion. actually wait, no just kidding but they’re still pretty decent” so I wasn’t sure how much more there really was to it lol thanks again!

Guitar Beatle

PLEASE GUYS ITS EITHER SMiLE, BEATLES ROCK BAND, DAVID BOWIE, OR THE WINGS ONE, ill be a very happy person!

Justin Ciner

These are all super interesting topics, I hope you get to all of these eventually someday!!

Zainab Hassan

The Klaatu option is a very nice surprise!!

JCS

In response to your question about having so many topics, I agree we need a mechanism for narrowing the field (mostly because we now how a large group of voters). Thus, I too recommend limiting the poll to about five topics, but I also think you could do something else, such as: (1) have a sccond poll of only the top X options, or (2) send a request that we change our vote to the X most popular topics at about the 2-day mark since by thenb most of us appear to have voted. X = the number of strong contenders for that month. That would actually boost early voting.

Rocky Road

I think limited options would make your life easier! Then you can save the extras for later in the year, or when a topic consistently is at the bottom, you can replace it.

Gaby G

I almost voted for the Klaatu video, since they fascinate me, but I had to stay loyal to the Wings video until we finally get it 😂

Connor Lammas

Maybe split polling into two phases. After topic submitters submit, people in the topic-submitter tier and up get to vote amongst all the submissions to narrow it down. The top 3-5 from that first round then get passed to the rest of the Patreon to vote on. Basically you add an extra bonus to the topic submission tier where we get to do an initial voting round just among ourselves.

Aaron Weiss

We need more Beach Boys and more info on SMiLE. I've been studying it for years and even I'm confused by its history. A clear Youtube video and timeline would be so helpful!

Jon Reynoso

I have a topic idea -- a look into rock artists composing soundtracks to films like Pink Floyd's More or George Harrison's Wonderwall Music. Would be a fascinating video.

Lou Watson

I missed the vote but I'm glad Wings won. My 2nd choice would have been Klaatu.

Brendan J. Smith

I maintain that SMiLE is the greatest artistic loss in history. It breaks my heart just thinking about it. I’ve listened to The Smile Sessions more times than any human reasonably should. I really hope you can make a video about it someday.