Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks!We return to Beatles territory with this month's bonus video which I really enjoyed making! This felt like an inevitable Patreon video for me so I'm glad it won the poll.Let me know what you think of my single-disc White Album and also tell me what yours would look like.Thanks for another month of support!E.

Files

Condensing The Beatles' White Album into a single disc

Comments

Eddie Lara

Awesome! Always love watching your bonus videos.

Eric Cheung

My favorite album because of the sprawling messiness, the genre hopping, the fact that it's the beginning of my favorite phase of the group (post-psychedelic return to their roots armed with all they've learned), and the slightly more blistering honesty. I wouldn't change it, but exercises like this are always fun, anyway.

dandyprophet

that's a solid tracklist! i think you're the first person i've seen keep both don't pass me by and good night haha. here's the tracklist i came up with years ago. i opted to cut the album directly in half, so there's 15 songs instead of 14: SIDE A: Long, Long, Long Wild Honey Pie Glass Onion I'm So Tired Mother Nature's Son Blackbird Savoy Truffle Happiness is a Warm Gun SIDE B: Rocky Raccoon Martha My Dear Cry Baby Cry Dear Prudence While My Guitar Gently Weeps Helter Skelter Good Night (i will stand by my inclusion of wild honey pie to the death)

Williguess

Dropping Back in the U.S.S.R in favor of Don’t Pass Me By is crrazzzyyy but great video!

Peter C

YESSS!!! Just finished watching, inspired to make my own fourteen track white album!!!! SO FUNNNN!!!

Euan Mangan

Gotta commend the Beatles for making a double album so good that I instinctively wanted to keep every song as you went through the track list

Peter C

Coming back - this is SO SO SO HARD! IDK HOW YOU DID IT!

Davis H

Ahhh! Yes! This is amazing! Here is my edited White Album: 1. Back In The USSR 2. Dear Prudence 3. Glass Onion 4. Ob La Di Ob La Da 5. While My Guitar Gently Weeps 6. Blackbird 7. Martha My Dear 8. I Will 9. Julia 10. Birthday 11. Honey Pie 12. Savoy Truffle 13. Cry Baby Cry 14. Helter Skelter 15. Good Night I did 15 tracks so it’s directly in half. Honey Pie is my favourite track on The White Album, which I know is crazy but I thought it would at least be a maybe but hey, I agree with almost all your opinions (except yesterday) so I can forgive you

Elliot Roberts

I'm now having regrets about not including 'Back in the U.S.S.R.' If I could have fifteen tracks, that'd be the one I'd include.

Keelan Bellard

I’m sorry but excluding it is an act of war

Multi Wiggle

I really loved this video. The White Album is my favorite Beatles album purely because of how much is crammed on it. It feels impossible to make an edited version, but I actually really dig yours. In fact, I think mine would be mostly the same. Mine would go. Side A 1. Back In The U.S.S.R. 2. Dear Prudence 3. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da 4. While My Guitar Gently Weeps 5. Happiness Is A Warm Gun 6. Helter Skelter Side B 7. Don’t Pass Me By 8. I’m So Tired 9. Rocky Raccoon 10. Blackbird 11. Savoy Truffle 12. Honey Pie 13. Cry Baby Cry 14. Good Night That puts Paul at 6 songs, John technically 5, George 2, plus both Ringo numbers, so still relatively even, and definitely plausible to see. If I had to add another John song, it’d be Sexy Sadie. That’s the fun part; we all have our own edited versions. How many other albums can you say that about? Also gotta say…it was so hard not to add “Why Don’t We Do It In The Road?” even though it’d never fit. It’s just too iconic for me

VacuousTom

Oooh this is gonna be contentious 😅

Beth Storey

As a die hard Granny Music Enthusiast, Honey Pie and Mother Nature’s Son would have made the cut for me. However I must concede that Martha is the pick in this record, an instant non-negotiable.

Tom Gallagher

The ONLY thing I would change is replacing Don’t Pass Me By with USSR. I really, genuinely can’t stand Don’t Pass Me By. 😂 Plus, I love the detail how you had each member’s songs distinguished by their Sgt. Pepper colours.

Ælfgifu

loved this one! I think the only thing I’d change is I Will for Rocky Raccoon bc I am a Rocky Raccoon advocate for life (I love I Will but it’s only fair to replace a McCartney track with another one and the others have to stay)

Mo Mobley

"ob-la-di, ob-la-da. that's a non-negotiable" ok but imagine if he made them do take after take and then it ended up being cut from the album. the funniest possible scenario imo.

DuxDelux

Great video! Thinking about this myself, I've pared it down to a 15-track album just under 49 minutes. SIDE A (basically the same as yours) Back In the U.S.S.R. Dear Prudence Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da Blackbird While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness Is a Warm Gun Helter Skelter SIDE B Martha My Dear Julia Birthday Yer Blues Mother Nature's Son Savoy Truffle Sexy Sadie Good Night It pains me to exclude Cry Baby Cry, I Will, Don't Pass Me By, and Long Long Long; love those dearly but I can't justify having them at the expense of these other great tracks. I will say that the tracks on Side A are just so iconic in the Beatles catalog that it makes Side B seem a bit weak in comparison. Perhaps if I came back to this in the future I'd spread them across both sides to make it more balanced.

Jonah Lee

Cutting these songs is so hard but mine would be really similar to yours except I would replace Don’t Pass Me By and Piggies with Back in the USSR and Long Long Long

JOSHUA

This was a great watch Elliot thank you! As soon as you mentioned Ob La Di Ob La Da being non negotiable I knew I was going to agree with most of your takes. Amazing video as always😊

Kathryn Coffey

How I Would Order the Tracks (I also went with the 15-track idea): Side A: While My Guitar Gently Weeps Mother Nature’s Son Don’t Pass Me By Yer Blues Blackbird Julia Helter Skelter Side B: Back in the U.S.S.R. Dear Prudence Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da Savoy Truffle Martha, My Dear Happiness is a Warm Gun I Will Good Night I fell in love with the While My Guitar Gently Weeps leading side A, so I decided to keep that momentum going here. Ordering these tracks was very tricky, maybe trickier than picking out the 15 tracks I wanted to include. Savoy Truffle's inclusion was largely based on me liking that song more than I do "Piggies." Now I'm wondering what's a bigger act of war: not including "Back in the U.S.S.R." or having it lead side B instead of A?

Rocky Road

It's hard to believe a trip to India resulted in such "American" sounding songs except for Paul's granny tracks. I always thought this album was a hot mess and usually can only listen to the first disc. But, sad to hear Rocky Racoon didn't make the list---fully biased in saying that.

Judah Quinn

My friends and I did this once, I love this kind of conversation.

Steven Pantaleoni

Such a great video as always and I really liked the way you approached the topic. Your impression of yourself having your mind blown also caught me off guard and had a food laugh. Looking forward to the Ringo video but I just say almost everything that has been slowing you down along the way was certainly worth it! Like most of the others I couldn't cut it below 15 so heres my take: Side A: Back in the USSR Glass Onion Obladi Oblada Dear Prudence Sexy Sadie Don't Pass Me By Blackbird Side B: Yer Blues While My Guitar Gently Weeps Long Long Long Helter Skelter Happiness Is a Warm Gun I Will Juila I'm So Tired I believe that side A songs tells a story while side B songs transition nicely together. John got a bit spoilt with 7 tracks but I feel Sexy Sadie is an essential part of the India trip where as I would have prefered to include Rocky Raccoon or Mother Nature's Son.

Ayumu Kasuga

I loved your set-list for the theoretical half-sized White Album! My ideal set-list would be the same with a few substitutions. I'd swap out Ob-La-Di with Birthday. I respect the historical context of the song (similar to Rocky Raccoon) but it doesn't quite land for me. Birthday is both a genuine Lennon-McCartney collaboration and a bangin' rocker. I'd also swap out Piggies with Long, Long, Long. Piggies is a clever allegorical tune but the deeply spiritual nature of Long, Long, Long is unforgettable. I'd also add one extra song (half of 30 is 15 after all) so I would put Mother Nature's Son between songs 1 and 2 on your list. This was definitely a fun thought experiment!

Ian Usher

Love this exercise! Going off the same rules as you: SIDE A Everybody’s Got Something to Hide Except for Me and My Monkey Dear Prudence I’m So Tired I Will Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da Happiness is a Warm Gun Helter Skelter SIDE B While My Guitar Gently Weeps Blackbird Back in the USSR Mother Nature’s Son Yer Blues Long, Long, Long Good Night I ended up spending WAY more time on the sequencing than on track selection. It’s really interesting to see the patterns show up in what people have chosen so far. Apparently everyone agrees Prudence is a perfect #2, Helter Skelter is a first side closer and Good Night is the final track (of course). While My Guitar Gently Weeps makes more sense to me as the Side B opener; I think it drags just a tiny bit to be leadoff. “Monkey” is probably an odd choice to open the album, but I really love the idea of it hitting you in the face up front with that exuberance (Come on! It’s such a joy!)

Elliot Roberts

These are great observations. And I hear you on the MGGW opener. Everyone’s lists have made me rethink my own!

Joe St George

Your side one is absolutely perfect! The only change i would make is i will and i’m so tired would be swapped out for back in the ussr and birthday and then I would rearrange side 2 but this is still an incredibly solid album. I only would change those two songs because i feel like these two are just too strong to be left out of the album, while the two i cut are not as essential to me

Patrick Farrugia

As a Don’t Pass Me By defender I’m happy to see it make the cut, although I probably would’ve dropped a song to also include Savoy Truffle (those saxes mmmm)

Sam

It’s always interesting because everyone has their preferences on TWA

Þorgeir Tryggvason

This parlour game has influenced my life quite a lot. In 2021 I made my own one-LP version of The White. And it got me thinking about why we don't do this exercise on other double albums. I got to work immiediately with Zep's Physical Graffiti. This turned into a weekly thing on Facebook, where I posted a suggestion for 50% off versions of double albums, with comments and rationale. I did this for two years, to 107 double albums. Got to know all kinds of music I had ignored, and listened very attentively to a LOT of old favourites. The playlists should be findable on Spotify. They are all called „[name of album] í hófi“, which is Icelandic for „in moderation“. Here is my Half-White: Back in the USSR
 Dear Prudence Blackbird
 Glass Onion
 Honey Pie Cry baby Cry While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness is a Warm Gun Julia Savoy Truffle Revolution 1 I will
 Revolution 9
 Good Night I hadn't listened to the White Album for many years as a whole when I did this, and one of the surprises was how effective R-9 is, and how brilliant the segue into the saccarine Good Night, after the nightmarish soundscape.

Connor Lammas

Total Runtime 45 mins; 15 tracks Side A: Back In The U.S.S.R. Dear Prudence Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da Piggies The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill Blackbird Julia Side B: While My Guitar Gently Weeps I’m So Tired Martha My Dear Happiness Is A Warm Gun Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except Me And My Monkey Mother Nature’s Son Helter Skelter Good Night I don’t think too much could be said about my picks that hasn’t already been said by others. USSR and Gently Weeps are clearly worthy of opening either side of the record. I definitely have a run of the “silly” songs on the first side with Ob-La-Di, Piggies, and Bungalow Bill. Decided to let Paul and John duke out side A’s end with their acoustic highs. I went into this thinking I’d have a much easier time choosing which John songs would make it and a harder time picking the Paul’s but was surprised it was actually the opposite. I controversially cut Yer Blues, just personal taste, never really smacked me across the face like it does for others. Ended up being split almost dead even between Sadie, Cry Baby, Bungalow, and Monkey. I don’t have a great reason for cutting Sadie. Cry Baby I almost chose but I already had more mellow John’s in Julia and Dear Prudence. Bungalow made it because I felt like I needed a silly John to match Piggies and Ob-La-Di plus I’m a Yoko defender. Monkey got picked because I felt like if I didn’t pick Yer Blues, then John needed a rocker than could compete with Paul’s USSR. I’m also proud of the whiplash I’ve created with the closing two being Helter Skelter and Goodnight (sorry Don’t Pass Me By).

Rowan Thorne

Side 1: Back in the USSR Dear Prudence Honey Pie Sexy Sadie Blackbird Happiness is a Warm Gun Don’t Pass Me By Side 2: While My Guitar Gently Weeps I Will Mother Nature’s Son Long, Long, Long Julia Cry Baby Cry Helter Skelter I know there is tons of goofiness and whimsy on the White album but to me it’s overall a very dark, harsh and chilling album which was the direction I wanted to go in and I hope my version reflects it (while keeping a lil whimsy because you know, Beatles). Really fascinated by everyone’s different takes on the album, however! Great video 😁

Starspeed

I really enjoyed this list! Even though I obviously had differing opinions on which ones to throw out (I was pretty sad to see Birthday go, lol!), you always have such great insight into the band's personal history and you provide such intelligent reasoning to back up your choices that it was still a ton of fun going through everything. My playlist goeth thusly: Side A: While My Guitar Gently Weeps Glass Onion Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da Happiness Is a Warm Gun Blackbird Helter Skelter Side B: Yer Blues Mother Nature's Son Julia Martha My Dear Birthday I'm So Tired Good Night/Dear Prudence* I agree with your 'Side A' pretty closely, though I'll get to my wild card take on 'Dear Prudence' in a moment. As much as I appreciate 'Don't Pass Me By' as Ringo's first song... it's still a song I often skip since it feels a bit lightweight compared to so many other heavy-hitters on the album. I feel like 'Yer Blues' works as a nice side-opener, and from there it gets into a decent 'Paul-John-Paul-John rhythm' until 'Birthday'. 'Birthday' I included since it breaks up the slower, quieter songs with another fast-paced banger before settling down with 'I'm So Tired' again. OK, here's my wild card idea: * I really like Good Night, and I ADORE Dear Prudence. I think it would be fun to do a mash-up between Good Night, Take 10 (as heard on the White Album Super Deluxe album) with DP, with the former fading into the latter. As much as I enjoy the final album version of GN, I love Take 10 because not only is it a nice stripped-down acoustic version of the song, but to have all the other Beatles singing backup harmonies bumped this one up considerably. The acoustic strumming is also close enough to DP that the two would go pretty well hand-in-hand as a combo-mashup (in my opinion). I mash these two together because DP is so lush and dreamlike as is that to have Good Night lead into it would give it the feeling of someone going to sleep and waking up to a soaring dreamscape that builds and builds as it goes on before returning to its quiet, acoustic finish.

Allan Massie

A valiant effort and obviously any choice won't please everyone, but I must say there's no way I would pick Ob-La-Di AND I Will AND Martha... and no Mother Nature's Son! John would lose his mind, haha Here's mine (no attempt to resequence) Back in the U.S.S.R. Dear Prudence Glass Onion While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness Is a Warm Gun Piggies Don't Pass Me By Birthday Yer Blues Mother Nature's Son Sexy Sadie Helter Skelter Honey Pie Cry Baby Cry

noremac

here’s my tracklist: Side 1 1. Back in the USSR 2. Dear Prudence 3. While My Guitar 4. Glass Onion 5. I Will 6. Revolution (single version) 7. I’m So Tired Side 2 1. Ob-La-Di (Esher demo) 2. Julia 3. Blackbird 4. Happiness is a Warm Gun 5. Long Long Long 6. Helter Skelter 7. Good Night

JCS

I went through this process back in my custom CD-making days, but of course I had 80 minutes to work with. I never challenged myself to cut it back some more, and so, yeah, no one is going to agree to a single LP. Thanks, though, for tackling this topic.

HappyRon

Back in 1980 when I first got into The Beatles and was young and have almost no information about them I remember being very disapointed in them that they didn’t write one of the songs, who was that Richard Starkey anyway !!!???

Brendan J. Smith

Revolution 9 would’ve worked better if it had been broken up into parts and dispersed throughout the entire album instead of feeling like a giant tumor that the listener is forced to sit through all at once right before the finish line.

Eli Hess

I know I'm super late to this but this was the best I could come up with: Side 1: 1. Back in the U.S.S.R 2. Dear Prudence 3. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da 4. While My Guitar Gently Weeps 5. Happiness is a Warm Gun 6. Martha My Dear 7. Blackbird Side 2: 1. I Will 2. Julia 3. Birthday 4. Yer Blues 5. Mother Nature's Son 6. Everybody's Got Something to Hide Except Me and My Monkey 7. Helter Skelter Super difficult and probably not as balanced as it should be, great video though!

Drew Engel

I honestly think that Helter Skelter should've been kept as it was at First Version/Take 2 on the 2018 remaster and been the B-side to Revolution. It has that great lumbering feel that makes "She's So Heavy" that incredible end to Side A on Abbey Road. I also think that if John didn't die, the Beatles would've reunited to play Live Aid, Paul already played it and George was a big fan of charity concerts.

JustAnotherCover

Omg, I felt like “Look how they massacred my boy” when you got rid of Long Long Long

Scorpio 2

That was some serious mental acrobatics you put on display there! I once heard a music critic say that Rubber Soul is their "best collection of songs," Sgt Pepper is their "most important album," Abbey Road is their "best album," and The White Album is "everybody's favorite Beatles album." True, it's a generalization, but it sort of works for me.

Scorpio 2

I won't list my version of this album, but my favorite most essential track would be "Glass Onion" because I think it's just so funny that John was actually making fun of his fans for looking into hidden meanings into their songs. The Beatles might have *indirectly* invented conspiracy theories as we know them today!

Luke Hall

I’ve always never understood this idea of editing the album down to just one album. To me it would make more sense separate the songs into two more cohesive albums, one more whimsical the other a rock album. Something like this: First One (Whimsical One): Side One: 1. A Beginning 2. Glass Onion 3. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da (Anthology Version) 4. The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill 5. Rocky Racoon 6. Piggies 7. Blackbird 8. Honey Pie Side Two: 1. Dear Prudence 2. I Will 3. Julia 4. Mother Nature’s Son 5. Long, Long, Long 6. Cry Baby Cry 7. Martha My Dear 8. Good Night The Rock Album (The White Album): Side One: 1. Back In The USSR 2. Hey Bulldog 3. Not Guilty (Anthology Version) 4. I’m So Tired 5. Why Don’t We Do It In The Road 6. Happiness Is A Warm Gun 7. While My Guitar Gently Weeps Side Two: 1. Birthday 2. Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except Me & My Monkey 3. Don’t Pass Me By 4. Sexy Sadie 5. Savoy Truffle 6. Yer Blues 7. Helter Skelter Then a Zapple EP: A-Side: Revolution 9 B-Side: Wild Honey Pie B-Side: What’s The New Mary Jane (Anthology Version) Also would mean we get more George songs and that’s always the best outcome.

Tyler Piper

I totally agree with all of your initial cuts even though they’re not bad songs by any means. Of your maybes I’d personally pick dear prudence, Don’t Pass Me By (my fav ringo sung song of the band), and Long Long Long, and mother nature’s son. I agree with all your automatic yesses too. It just shows how great the material on this double album are even though it’s so stylistically varied and doesn’t really have one theme or concept like a lot of double albums do. This was a cool experiment in music and album assemblage.

Bronẽlso

Piggies over Long, Long, Long!? You’re a dangerous man, Elliot.

Richard Allsop

Not watched this yet (literally just joined your patreon after enjoying your youtubes for years) but I can tell you straightaway what my single LP White album is 1.1 Back in the USSR, 1.2 Dear Prudence, 1.3 Ob-La-Di, 1.4 I'm So Tired, 1.5 Don't Pass Me By, 1.6 While My Guitar, 1.7 Happiness Is A Warm Gun, 2.1 Revolution 1, 2.2 Honey Pie, 2.3 I Will, 2.4 Everybody's Got Something To Hide, 2.5 Sexy Sadie, 2.6 Helter Skelter, 2.7 Long Long Long

Richard Allsop

Now watched. Loved seeing your workings out. Mine is purely personal favourites placed in a good sequencing order but ended up a good split between all members and most of the "essential" tracks are on it. I do have a bias to Lennon but the single LP ended up a fair split. Where I differ from nearly all Beatles fans is "Blackbird." I've been listening to the White Album since my double cassette in 1990 and Blackbird has always been one of my least favourites. It didn't make it to my single CD version (along with Why Don't, Martha (Sorry) & Rev 9) and I've watched with interest how Blackbird has grown in stature over the years to become a standard (sure it wasn't back in the 90s) so much so that it was a given on the revamped Blue album. To me, I still hear it as I heard it at the time, a twee throwaway, and I know I am in the huge minority here but my single LP White Album will always be different to most because of this.

steven anderson

The thing is, if you do trim the white album down, I think you just destroy its ramshackle charm, the bizarre but iconic transitions (Lennons exaggerated northern ‘ay up’ going into the opening of gently weeps, that spooky untitled McCartney track that leads into the nightmare of revolution 9, long long long coming out of the heavy metal cacophony of helter skelter)… you can call it unfocused but it’s kind of the point… it is sprawling and unhinged but that’s why I love it, every Beatles album including and after rubber soul is a totally different sonic and textural experience, and the white album is so messy and dirty, but that’s why I love it, the filthy guitar sounds, the palpable tension resulting from and exemplified by the dizzying array of styles from hard rock, to music hall, to country, full on Chicago blues, folk, Musique concrète… it’s all here, and listen, I’ve done a 14 track WA loads over the years for fun, and I know it just doesn’t work, and in the words of an unusually exasperated macca on the Beatles anthology, it’s the bloody Beatles white album, shut up! Great video though, like all your content, loads of fun, and great viewing.

steven anderson

In the end for my track listing I tried for something that worked as tonal experience… it meant leaving off a few things I really really like, the most egregious example of this being the scandalous non inclusion of Julia, but as much as I love it, it’s so touching and meaningful, it feels as if in another universe it would’ve been the perfect closer to the plastic Ono band album, after God instead of my mummy’s dead, imagine Julia coming in, opening with the screaming blue murder of mother then the serenity of Julia, and hey on the double white album is works, but once you make it a single, I could not find a place to put it where it pops, it’s too significant to place track 4 side 2 or whatever, it has to close a side and I had my mind made up on those, so without further chew, here we go… Side one Glass onion Martha my dear Savoy truffle Sexy Sadie Blackbird Cry baby cry Helter skelter Side two Dear prudence While my guitar gently weeps Birthday Happiness is a warm gun Everybody’s got something to hide except for me and my monkey I will Long long long The ‘fuck ringo’ mix call it… and George had 3 on revolver so why not here! Glass onion is a perfect intro, setting the scene, helter skelter ends side one which is like yours and I think really pops, but long long long is an exquisite ending, perfect with that amazing death rattle ending, then almost the redux of the hard days night chord at the end, slamming the album shut.

adrifatw

It is blasphemy to cut the White Album down to 1 disc (but it is a fun thought experiment)

rivers!

imo Back in the USSR as the opener and Good Night as the closer is non negotiable, though i like your tracklist

TheMr.L01

Kinda like Not Guilty