Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody,Tough month this June with the loss of Brian Wilson and so here I've done my best to sum up why he was so special and how dearly he'll be missed.The main chunk of the video though is a comparison and analysis of the three key versions of the SMiLE project: Smiley Smile (1967), Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE (2004), and The SMiLE Sessions (2011). Let me know which version is your favourite or any other fun tidbits I've left out.Hope you enjoy the video.Vale Brian Wilson ❤️

Files

Remembering Brian Wilson + Comparing the three versions of SMiLE

0:00 - Intro 1:14 - Remembering Brian 7:06 - Comparing the 3 versions of SMiLE

Comments

Andrew Kuder

Yes, thanks for doing this Elliot! And you were right the first time, my last name is pronounced koo-der

Elliot Roberts

Oh geez, that's crazy I didn't pick that up. Well, enjoy this video from the future everyone!

Elliot Roberts

Yes, I do say June 2026 at the start when it is in fact 2025. It's been a long month.

DuxDelux

Your hope for a stereo Smile Sessions is not in vain! There's a Pet Sounds/Smile boxset in the cards for next year, expect to see new stereo mixes there.

Accordingtoallknownl

Would love to see a remaster of BWPS using Peter Jackson’s MAL as well as a remaster (and vinyl repress?) of the Smile Sessions in true stereo. A man can dream

Wartortle

I loved the Pop Music Video! It made me tear up!

Judah Quinn

Oh yeah, a video referring to my favorite album, smile sessions. Rip Brian, you were the man.

Scott Whiting

I also prefer Smile having instrumental breaks in between songs with lyrics. There are a lot of great albums that do that: Caravanserai, Dark Side of the Moon, Illinoise. But I’m glad Brian got to complete his magnum opus the way he wanted it to be. Rest in Peace, Brian Wilson

JorgeFT

Great tribute to a gifted man who’s been through everything and then some. May he rest in peace. Really cool understanding the differences between the 3 versions of the Smile project. I’m sure it was a relief to get the monkey off Brian Wilson’s back to finally complete a chapter that haunted him for decades.

Kathryn Coffey

Very well spoken, and there's no better way to honor his memory than talking about Smile. I did have the same reaction as you did when I heard of his passing. There's relief that he's finally with his brothers Dennis and Carl in the Big Bandshell in the Sky now, and he's at peace after all that suffering. It still breaks my heart that he's gone, but he won't be forgotten.

Lucas Lieu

Beautifully done. Brian was a beautiful soul, and his music will continue to resonate within the hearts of many for years to come.

Craig Edmonds

Welled up at your tribute dude. I read it on socials of course, but something about you reading it was very different. Also, a great analysis on the Smile versions, my go-to is always the sessions over the 2004, and the live version over the sessions too. And Smiley Smile is a different body of work in my mind, having worked on music personally, I'm certain that our beloved Smiley Smile as it exists couldn't have happened without everything that led up to it.

Craig Edmonds

PS, I know you're not a fan of the AI stuff, but I do REALLY like the idea that as Smile was never completed "as originally envision" (as only 1967 Brian could have done that), the fans have taken Smile over as a project that they can adapt and change and arrange however THEY envision it. Dae Lims example is particularly impressive, and if nothing else, listen to their interpretation of Surf's Up at the closing of the album. Despite using AI voice models to replace his own vocals, it really is very moving. I'm not sure of many other albums that would have this fan ownership around it, bar perhaps the single disc White Album concept.

Davis H

Beautiful tribute Elliot, I shed a tear while watching. It’s such a huge loss, there will never be anyone like Brian ever again

MJ Sanfilippo

The channel that did the alternate universe version of smile also has an alternate universe where the Beatles never broke up in 1970. The channel is called Earth- 347 and I think you'll enjoy it because he mashes up the Beatles solo content to make cohesive albums. https://youtube.com/@earth-347?si=xcSgjHA06nqC5gg8

JustAnotherCover

Man, I really loved that pop video you made. I don’t know how well it did but it was great! It really got me excited about music (old and modern) and I got into Chappell Roan thanks to it so yeah, keep it up! 👍 Also, Brian was obviously a genius and he will be deeply missed 💔

Harding Kinnaird

Your almost looking like a pirate rn in the BEST way possible 🏴‍☠️

Brendan J. Smith

To those of you who checked out tragiclifeform’s version of SMiLE after watching this video: You’re Welcome.

Brendan J. Smith

The only thing from Dae Lims’ version that I really REALLY liked was their unique ending for Heroes & Villains. Although their version of H&V is an over-complicated mess and that ending would’ve worked way better if they put it after the outro of Vega-Tables IMO.

Brendan J. Smith

What do you mean by the Live version? You mean Brian’s live show from 2004/2005?

Sam

Forever a musical genius

Luke Hall

Wonderful tribute, you summarised my feelings on Brian’s passing exactly, you have a real talent for putting our feelings about a topic (in this case Brian’s passing) into words. On an unrelated note, your beard and hair looks especially great in this video, like a mix of 1974/1976 George Harrison.

Tyler Piper

A lovely tribute to a lovely man who we all miss so dearly. I’m so thankful for the wonderful music and impact Brian gave us. He was unparalleled as a creative and just a gift to this world. I personally love the smile sessions beach boys set so much. I bought that on a trip to LA for my 18th birthday and drove around Southern California blasting the whole record with my parents. I marvel at its originality and creativity, and I’m thankful we now have a few different iterations of the music from it. Great video!