Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Happy New Year everybody!

We're closing the year out with a long-requested video which is my review of The Beach Boys 2024 documentary on Disney+.

Hope you all enjoy and have a safe and happy end to 2025,

E.

Files

The Beach Boys Disney+ Documentary — Review

Comments

Jacob Miller

Well Ding Dang, It finally happened!

Tyler Piper

Great video! I remember when I watched this documentary I was left feeling genuinely a bit angry at how they handled the narrative of this documentary, specifically, as you talked about, with how they tried to make Mike Love out to be such a great, innocent contributor, and how it lessened the impact of Brian. It was also frustrating to me how little they talked about some of the albums from the band's late sixties and early seventies career, as to me, and this is probably a bit of a hot take, but Smiley Smile to Sunflower is my favorite era of the group, and Sunflower is my number one Beach Boys album, followed by Friends. I know that Pet Sounds is their masterpiece and perhaps the objective climax of their creative career, but it would've been nice to see more of a thorough retrospective, and instead they followed the narrative almost everyone does of early 60s surfing, girls and cars songs and albums, the wonder/confusion of Pet Sounds, and then the transition into a second wave of success with the greatest hits album and tours. I know those three are huge aspects of their legacy, but I guess if they've already made a beach boys documentary, and there's countless books and histories of the band out there, I would, as a fan, want something a little bit different from a new documentary. Instead this was such a dud. I love the Beach Boys as a music group but the handling of their legacy and the consistent downhill slide of it really is a bit devastating to see for such a truly important group.

Ethan Ng

Happy New Year Elliot! I agree with your general sentiment that the documentary unfortunately is a bit sanitised and will be skewed by other band member's points of view. The Beach Boys story like you said is a tragic story and one that's filled with so much nuance that it's difficult to capture in an 1hr 30 doco. But I also think a Beach Boy doco down the line should dive into the artistic leanings of the other band members and what they brought to the table, as I do personally think they all brought their own skills to the table, even if they were not as significant as Brian's. Whether it be Carl's leadership and production in the 70s, Dennis' life and songwriting, Al's folk influence, even Bruce had a hand in some harmony arrangements and Mike, for how maligned he may be, did bring a Doo-Wop influenced sound to the group.

Craig Edmonds

Yeah, excellent take Elliot. I think this doc really works well for a very first time exposure to the band, but that's about it. I'd actually compare it more to a modern biopic than a documentary, with its heavy editing of the real story and this approach that feels very saccharin. I'm sad that we didn't see more of the modern day old members just hanging on the beach too, that would have been nice to hear.

Scott Whiting

I find the lo-fi trilogy (Smiley Smile, Wild Honey, Friends) to be such a fascinating phase of the band. I personally think those albums stand toe to toe with the likes of Pet Sounds and Love You. Maybe someday we can get more coverage on that period of their career, perhaps a box set of the three albums is in order. But yeah, justice for the lo-fi trilogy!

Jack Almoro

Elliot, I endorse the facial hair!

Kathryn Coffey

It's fantastic that your vid on "Love You" was featured on Brian Wilson's list of documentaries webpage! Whoever put that video there deserves a raise.

Alexander Watts

Really a big fan of all your content, would you ever consider doing content on the Beatles’ music that was made whilst they were active? considering you’ve covered almost every inch of their respective solo careers, loving the content from Manchester, England!

Mikaela Thorn

Of course the Mike Love-approved documentary would have genAI in it. He always was anti-creativity. Happy New Year, Elliot!

ovidiomedes

mike love always at the scene of the crime

Jacob Witmer

I remember first watching this doc when it came out and by the time we get towards the end with Mike Love shedding his crocodile tears over “I never hear from Brian anymore”, I was screaming at the screen yelling, “Well, maybe if you didn’t treat him like garbage for the past fifty years things would’ve turned out differently!” It’s also absurd the way the doc contradicts itself by establishing that by the time Brian was making Pet Sounds, The Beach Boys were basically two separate entities: the touring band singing the hits to audiences and Brian in the studio making all the recordings, and then starts undercutting all of Brian’s remarkable work by having Josh Kun and Bruce going, “Well, but he couldn’t have done it without the other members of the band” when clearly, yes he could. I’m also not a fan of the way Marilyn kinda low-key defends Murray Wilson for being an abusive parent. Like, the way she’s like, “Well yeah Murray was a difficult man, but without him The Beach Boys would never have happened.” When in reality it’s like, “Yeah, but that’s not an excuse for him beating his children so hard that Brian went deaf in one ear! You can’t just be like ‘Well the ends justify the means’ when it comes to child abuse!” Ultimately though, I think Lindsey Buckingham hits the nail directly on the head when he says, “With the Beatles they evolved gradually as a group of four people who all wanted the same thing, but with Pet Sounds you had this massive jump forward being done by one person.” And that’s ultimately the great tragedy behind the whole Beach Boys story, and why for me personally they always come up second behind the Beatles. The Beatles were four close friends who were all united by the same purpose until they reached the point where they wanted to go in separate directions and went on to forage their own successful solo careers. The Beach Boys were a family enterprise reliant upon a singular musical genius who was in charge of making every single creative decision, and were constantly at war with each other about whether they should prioritize being an artistic entity or a purely commercial enterprise of selling kitsch surf music to a mass-market. And what’s ultimately sad about the story is in the end the commercial camp won out. The Endless Summer comp and then later the Sounds of Summer comp gave Mike Love his ultimate victory in proving people only wanted to hear the hits from The Beach Boys, and he got them to become the nostalgia act raking in the money at the county fairs and the 4th of July Picnics, all the expense of the mental and physical health of his cousins who were responsible for all the band’s most beloved, adventurous and critically acclaimed music. And now with all three of them gone, he gets to assert that image of the band without question, and in many ways this doc felt like the beginning of that process, with Brian quite visibly no longer had the physical strength to really take part in the proceedings (I’d dare venture to say they way they wheel him out at the beginning and ending of the film potentially verges on elder abuse) and Mike taking the opportunity to bring in all these talking heads to say, “Well Brian might’ve been a genius, but he wouldn’t have gotten anywhere without the help of people like Mike and Murray.” It’s just all-in-all a very dishonest film, held back by unreliable narrators who were given editorial control and approval of Final Cut. If there’s any Beach Boys documentary I’d suggest people check out (aside from your Love You video of course), it’d be the BBC’s Wouldn’t It Be Nice doc from 2005 that actually does have the involvement of Tony Asher and Van Dyke Parks and is unafraid to be more critical about Mike Love’s failings, and touches upon how Brian’s completion of Smile in 2004 ultimately represented his most major artistic and emotional victory over all his past demons.

David Prokopy

Excellent video, and echos my exact thoughts on this doc. Such a wasted opportunity, and all the AI slop. Not just the visual fills, but more egregiously, they used it to create audio clips from Brian that I assume were sourced from print interviews. Just terrible. But yeah, the original Endless Harmony (and the even earlier An American Band from the Eighties) are much better watches. Can't wait to hear your analysis of the Beatles Anthology! I'm sure it'll be worth the wait. Keep up the excellent work! Can't wait to hear your be

Davis H

Haven’t watched it, and based off this review, I don’t think I will 😂 Have a great beginning to 2026 Elliot!

FlyingGarfield

Happy new year Elliot, awesome hair and beard you got going on at the moment and also super cool you are featured on Brian's website!

Ron Dowd

As a part time Beach Boys fan who mainly knew their early stuff from growing up with it on the radio, I loved Endless Harmony as it gave me details to the music I had listened to BUT it also pointed me where to go next in my musical discovery. Which in my case was Surf's Up... which is still one of my all time fave albums. If this new documentary doesn't add to that (in many respects) what's the point in making it or indeed in watching it?

Brendan J. Smith

Brian is many things, lucky is not one of them.

Brendan J. Smith

“What is going on with the quality control at Beach Boys HQ?” Oh, Elliot… us fans have been asking that same question for DECADES at this point. I absolutely LOVE being totally ashamed of and embarrassed by my favorite band of all time 99% of the time!

Brendan J. Smith

We’re living in the alternate timeline where Mike Love won.

Drew Engel

My problem with any attempt at doing a Beach Boys history is that it is beset by a person having to choose one of two sides: Brian or Mike. Brian's side, which holds that Mike was a talentless hack who contributed nothing to the band and is the biggest villain of their history. And that Brian did not contribute to the growing strife in the group due to him going off on his own thing and then forcing the band to tag along. Mike's side maintains that Mike was always supportive of Brian's work and never was a malcontent. Also, Brian would never have done anything without the rest of the band. I think that the truth is much more in the middle. Brian was a genius, but he did receive a lot of help that people love to downplay. Both Mike's and Van Dyke's contributions have only recently been fully acknowledged in the band's history, with Mike receiving songwriting credit for many songs and Van Dyke receiving full appreciation for his work on Smile. However, Mike was a malcontent who objected to the way Brian was going musically, starting with Pet Sounds. Telling the story that way would piss off Mike, as it does paint a complicated picture of him. But it would also piss off Brian stans who see him as a lone genius in the group and conveniently ignore the recording of Smile, in which Brian has written a bunch of songs with Parks without the knowledge of the rest of the group, forcing the band to record what was basically a Brian solo project. And to your point about why the Beach Boys suddenly fell off in cultural relevance after Smile. I think the biggest reason is that the Sixties were over, and, like most artists and bands of all eras, the Beach Boys could not weather the shifting cultural and musical tides. Only a select few artists or bands, like Paul, have remained culturally relevant throughout their entire careers. Mike understood this and believed that if he could just keep the band earning money, it could reemerge later, once nostalgia set in. Thus, the endless touring that kept the band financially solvent until the late 80s, when they reemerged with the rest of the Sixties acts that were still alive and together. Unfortunately for Mike, he cashed in the nostalgia chips too late and released the awful "Summer in Paradise," which sent The Beach Boys off to the land of legacy acts.

Brendan J. Smith

I have to disagree with a lot of your conclusions. The Beach Boys are a ‘60s band, but also not really. Their image has much more in common with the American High of the 1950s. An image that was never true to begin with and would ultimately lead to their downfall. The 1960s as a decade had the most rampant social change in American and British history. When people think of the 1960s, they usually think of the hippie movement from 1967–1969. The Beach Boys helped to usher in that change, but they failed to be a part of it. And that can be entirely attributed to the cancellation of SMiLE and consequently pulling out of the Monterey Pop Festival at the last minute. That was their ticket into the biggest pop culture movement of the 20th century, but they blew it. No matter how well or how poorly you think SMiLE would’ve sold, putting it out there would’ve been FAR better for them in the long run. It would’ve kept them in the cultural conversation and shown the world that they were capable of so much more. And they could never bounce back with Brian losing his creative ambition after his dream was shattered. Also, Mike didn’t cash in on the nostalgia too late, he cashed in too early! They were already a legacy act LONG before Summer in Paradise. 15 Big Ones was the moment they gave up on being artists. It was roughly only 10 years after they first began. Nostalgia is for 20 years ago, not 10. If they had waited until the ‘80s to get back to their summer fun roots, it would be more understandable.

Mister acidic

Man I wish this was public honestly! I know it’s not too serious, but it still scares me how Mike keeps clinging to ruining the legacy of an already poor beaten down horse. I know we already have the beautiful love and mercy to help keep Brians true nature connected with the right people from the newer generations, but this really could have been big for them! But they fucked it all up with their horrific pride and ego!

Erik

I've tried before, and maybe I will again soon, but, I am not a beach boys fan. it all sounds so teenybop soda shop to me, i keep hearing the comparisons, and gushing, even by the beatles themselves, but I dont get it. I have to be missing something.

Elliot Roberts

Do you think Pet Sounds sounds like teeny bop soda shop?

Erik

I'm listening to again now... so far, yeah.

Erik

the way the beatles sound changed over time, from the teeny bop style of beatles for sale, please please me, etc to rubber soul, revolver and even more going on to pepper and magical mystery tour... I dont really see that same kind of change and growth with the beach boys. I may not be describing it well calling it teenybop soda shop, but thats what comes to mind. a scene from a movie in the 50's of a football player taking a cheerleader out for a soda or something... the same way really early beatles songs would fit that scene, all of the beach boys would too. I'm 7 songs in again, and still sounds... old. maybe to my ears it doesnt hold up the same as the beatles. its weird. I have to be missing something.

Erik

i started a station based on pet sounds, the other songs all go together great and sound awesome. so far all the beach boys songs stand out in a bad way. after pet sounds, there was Darlin, sunny afternoon from the kinks, we can work it out, surfin safari, paint it black, happy together by the turtles, im a believer, fun fun fun, light my fire, california dreamin', young americans, brown eyed girl... I dont know what it is that makes them stand out in such a bad way to me. I'm not a big fan of how spector produced them, reminds me of an elementry school music class, everyone gets an instrument, everyone makes noise. doesnt matter if its good or adds to the song, just more noise on top of more noise. especially among the other songs youtube music has added in, they sound at least 10 years behind all the others.