Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody, I'm back with another YouTube video!

Here's the exclusive, ad-free early-access link for Patrons. It'll be up on YouTube publicly in a few days.Also, I'm aware there's a masking error 53 seconds into this video. Don't worry, it'll be fixed before it goes public. And the thumbnail is set to change.

Hope you dig it, and let me know what your thoughts are on the new Anthology, and where you see the Beatles going after this.

Cheers,

E.

Files

The Beatles Anthology (2025): A Bittersweet Miracle

It's been 30 years since the surviving Beatles reunited to reflect on their time as the biggest band in history, and now we're all reflecting once again with a newly remastered Beatles Anthology documentary series on Disney+, and an additional 4th volume of demos and outtakes. In this video I review the entire release of the 2025 Beatles Anthology in considerable detail, and muse on what's next for John, Paul, George, and Ringo. Chapters 0:00 - Intro 02:28 - A Brief History of The Beatles Anthology 06:26 - Anthology 1-3 | Remastering Review 08:44 - Real Love & Free As a Bird 17:06 - New Unheard Tracks 32:39 - Why they messed-up this release 34:48 - Disney+ Series | Remastering Quality 42:30 - Disney+ Series | What's Lost/Gained 53:47 - Disney+ Series | Episode 9 1:00:22 - The Future of The Beatles Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/elliotroberts Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotroberts Twitter: https://twitter.com/ElliotRoberts5 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliot.roberts Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/elliotroberts

Comments

Carlo Davies

I love being a Patreon member of Elliot Roberts

Grace Marie

George, with love and respect, what was that awful lunch? Also completely agree about the fumbling of the roll-out. The Get Back roll-out was insane and I knew it was releasing months before it was finally out (after years of anticipation that was also publicized heavily as well) but I found out Anthology was remastered maybe three days before it came out? They could’ve done a much better marketing campaign for the series and the 4th edition.

Carlo Davies

I think you forgot to change the text at 28:37 to fool on the hill

Andriy Griffin

I’ve been dreaming of this video since becoming a subscriber back in 2023, 65 min, you spoil us Elliot. x

Maxwell Dziabis

Also around 30:00 for Hey Bulldog, it still has (Rehearsal for BBC Broadcast) on there - might want to double check each of the captions around there. Great video so far!

Cole Switzer

Great video as always! I agreed with pretty much all of your takes. Especially the one about the difference between FAAB and Real Love. FAAB new mix, I thought, was pretty good! It’s good to have that one AND the 90s one, as they are both very good in separate ways. But the new real love is weird and terrible, I don’t know how Lynne fumbled that one so hard. And the Disney+ series was 1000% the best part about this whole fiasco. I’m a younger fan so I had never watched the series before, and I absolutely adored it!

Kincade Bischoff

It’s funny how excited I got to see my name zoom by on the list of patrons. I’m in the same camp as you with the documentary series, I think the changes made for the new release were for the better. The pacing was much stronger, allowing the story of The Beatles to flow without having to sit through another live performance of Twist and Shout (as delightful as those are) when we could be learning more about how the rest of the world was reacting to them, and how the band felt about it. Great video as always, Elliot. I look forward to whatever you do next!

Tom Gallagher

I’m actually surprised you didn’t mention this but my FAVOURITE change was just at the very end when the four Beatles give kind of closing thoughts. And they replaced John’s negative ‘It’s nothing important’ comment with ‘Nothing will ever break the love we have for each other’ which I thought was so much more powerful. 🥹

pwdrinha

OMG first time seeing my name at the end, thats so cool! hahaha Amazing video as always

steven anderson

Looking very 1994 George there, only younger and without the slightly off putting aura of seeming as though you’d rather be gardening instead. I remember being 15 and watching the anthology over the winter of 95/96 in the UK, then later the ‘directors cut’ first VHS then DVD box set. Shout by Philip Norman on my uncles book shelf was the first to blow my mind and bring context to the music I’d spend my early life marvelling at, and now this was the guys themselves, all stone wash denim and mullets and beards and pony tails, befitting of a legacy rocker in their early 50’s in the mid 1990’s. Those classic 60’s guys seemed ancient at the time, now it’s really shocking to think of the surviving Beatles being so hale and healthy and damn youthful. Yeah I noticed that Lennon quote change, end of the day loads of stuff has been taken from that JL rolling stone interview where he was in a bad way, coming off junk, very vulnerable and just lashing out. John was proud of the Beatles and if he’d lived he’d have been overjoyed at what they could do with the AI to get them sounding this good.

Hannah Moran

I think that question of how the Beatles exist in culture now/how they will exist in the future is an interesting one to ponder. What will their legacy truly be, now that it's over 60 years later, and all those Beatle people are getting older? Will they be a relic of a previous generation, like Frank Sinatra? Will they be constantly resurrected and re-mythologized like Shakespeare? Will they be commodified beyond recognition like Marilyn Monroe and Elvis? Popular culture is more fractured than it ever has been, so it's hard to say for sure.

Sarahhh

fyi morecambe is pronounced more-come (classic brits being awkward ey)

pwdrinha

no worries at all! I'm just happy to feature :)

TDK92

A couple of editing issues that I noted: 1. 13:38 - Masking Error 2. 35:47 - Masking Error 3. 28:36 - Incorrect Track Title 4. 29:57 - Incorrect Track Title 5. 14:49, 14:59, 15:19 - Incorrect Album Cover (Album cover for Anthology 1 shown, instead of Anthology 2) Aside from these editing issues, great job on the video Elliot.

Luke Hall

Completely agree with on the documentary though in the future I would like a more comprehensive documentary on the journey from John making his demos to now and then. I do they dropped the ball not saving bow & then for 2025 it would’ve made this release a bigger deal & in terms of the 3 volumes, I actually think it might have been a better idea to reimagine each volume as a shorter compilation with less material. A 12LP and even a 9LP Boxset is way too much for a younger fan to afford and I’ve never personally cared much for the live recordings on anthology 1 & 2 for example and some of the outtakes on anthology 4 really should’ve been on the original anthology, so to me this would’ve been an opportunity to streamline Anthology as 3 double albums, maybe even released every 3 months like the original anthology. Apparently according to forum they’re currently putting the rubber soul Boxset together so 🤞 though personally I was hoping they’d now do year boxsets like a 1965 Boxset because there’s still so many albums left.

Davis H

Alright commenting before I watch this, what are the chances Elliot will make me cry with this video? I’d say fairly high knowing his track record

Davis H

I haven’t seen the original documentary but was weirded out by the fact that Stuart Sutcliffe’s death isn’t even brought up in the new anthology. Is it in the original or something they’ve left out?

Davis H

Update the answer is yes whilst discussing George saying he felt sorry for John

Davis H

Strange. Makes it weirder that it wasn’t included in the new one, seems like an important detail to me

Davis H

I feel like The Beatles are different to Sinatra and Elvis in the sense that so many young people are massive fans of the band (despite what Sean Ono Lennon says). I do think they will stay alive in culture better than Sinatra or Elvis because most younger people couldn’t name a song by either of those guys but they can came heaps of The Beatles songs. Who knows though, it’s gonna be so fascinating to see.

Rankirakira

Great video! As a younger Beatles fan, I have only seen the Disney+ version Beatles Anthology. Really cool to compare and contrast between the 90s version and Disney+ version for the documentary. I would love it if Disney+ and Apple put a bonus feature of footage they cut and edited from the original either on the streaming service or in physical media with blu-ray dvd. Hopefully some day Apple will release 2025 Beatles Anthology documentary as a blu-ray DVD set. I am glad that the cut out clips from the original Anthology are resurfacing on social media (e.g. Rubber Soul cover album story). I still want to check out the original Beatles Anthology whenever I have free time. Because, I love watching anything Beatles related. The Beatles touched my heart and I am so grateful for their music and being Beatles fan. Thank you so much for making this video and spreading the Beatles' love for everyone!

Chris Buchanan

The stuart stuff is in the original. I have the original (on several different media platforms) and it is skipped over a lot more in the disney version.

Starspeed

It really says something when random people on YouTube are able to put together MUCH better cleaned-up versions of Real Love than the one that was officially released. Oh, well. Here's hoping Apple is paying attention to the online feedback... Anyway, I loved the deep dive! Thanks for the big, long video, dude! 😊✨

Ben Dowson

Hi Elliott, it was actually Jeff Lynne who did the 2015 mixes of Free as a Bird and Real Love. I even checked the credits of the 1+ box set just to make sure.

Kathryn Coffey

First of all, love the look! 1994 George really suits you! (And yeah, of course Paul has the best skincare of the four of them; he's your favorite lol.) Second, I was more ticked off about George's guitar parts being completely left out of the 2025 remix of Real Love than I was about John's voice sticking out like a sore thumb (though that didn't do the mix any favors). George's guitar was the best part of the song, and I felt my stomach kind of drop not hearing it when I first heard the 2025 remix. The fact that Jeff Lynne was behind production has me even more baffled. For some reason, I thought it was some intern doing it, but finding this out makes me even more disappointed. This was the man who was pretty close to George Harrison to the point where they were collaborating musically and going on vacation together. I think it does come down to old age getting the best of his hearing and not some weird revenge for not being involved in the 2023 remastering of Now and Then. Anyway, now that I heard your review of the Disney + version of the documentary, I feel more confident about watching it without feeling somewhat let down. I remember watching the documentary on tv, and that's how George became my forever favorite Beatle, and I'm glad to know "For You Blue" is not one of the clips left out. Though I agree that leaving out John's physical mockery on stage does leave out a bit on how much pressure he and the others were under during the 'Beatlemania' phase. Guess it's no wonder John said the Beatles were bigger than Jesus if people saw them as some kind of miracle workers. Also, in the "restored" tv clips, Paul and Ringo look more like aliens than ever before. As for the tracks on Anthology 4, I loved "I Need You (Take 1)." Also, George's laugh in "This Boy Takes 12 & 13" sounds kind of like Snoopy or a chipmunk. It's so funny. Lastly, I thought it was kind of strange to see Beatle influencers get special box sets and not YouTubers like you or Andrew.

Jacob Witmer

Very good vid, I do feel it's worth pointing out that all of the sequences that were added into the new Anthology talking about their music and albums were actually repurposed from the 2009 mini-documentaries that were bundled alongside the Stereo CD remasters and have been readily available to watch on YouTube for ages. But considering those mini-documentaries were built upon unused portions of the interviews that were done for the original Anthology, it was nice to see them re-integrated back into this new version of the series. I think they function better as flavor text here than they did as these little sizzle reels awkwardly tacked onto the albums themselves. Plus, it allows us to go more in-depth into the stories of the singles which the 2009 mini-docs didn't cover since the Beatles didn't put their singles onto the albums. And while it is a shame that some of the full-length song performances got cut, I do think the brisker pace the new Anthology edit takes is for the best (even if I do object to the removal of some things which I think are crucial to understanding the emotional stakes of the story like the Beatles being brought people with disabilities backstage to "heal" or the story of Paul's standoff with the other three about the Allen Klein contract leading to one of the Abbey Road sessions being cancelled). A funny thing I found actually was that if you go back and look at the original truncated TV edits from 1995 these new Disney+ edits actually hem closer to those versions of the original series and the things that got cut from the DVD edits (like the story of Paul and Pete burning the condom in Hamburg or the band's trip to Greece) were actually absent from the initial TV broadcast versions of the series as well. All-in-all, I can see why some of the diehards have their gripes about this new release (and I do think some of their concerns are valid), but if the purpose of the Anthology series is to act as an easy way for more casual fans or newcomers to hear the Beatles' story for the first time (which ultimately I think it is), then I think this new version of Anthology is likely the most definitive version. Plus, with the new Episode Nine, I think it's significant in that a.) It acts as a nice epilogue where you get to see the friendships between the remaining three Beatles fully mended after spending the '70s and '80s constantly waging war with each other. and b.) I think it sets the stage nicely for the upcoming series of biopics (in Episode Nine when Ringo says "My Anthology would have different things in it than Paul's or George's Anthologies" it was hard not to see that as a prelude to a series of movies where each individual Beatle has their story told in their own unique way).

Jacob Witmer

The DVD version of the doc mentions that Stuart stayed behind to get engaged to Astrid, but after that he's never brought up again. His death is only mentioned in the book on page 69 where George talks about how it took the band by surprise and Paul rebukes the story that John reacted by breaking out in hysterical laughter.

Mike Pope

"George ordering a truly mid sandwich" 😄

Byron Davis

Excellent video and incredibly thorough. As one of the Gen Z Beatle fans of which you speak (actually 26), the Anthology series has always sat in a bit of a weird bubble for my burgeoning fandom. It was well in the past by the time I was getting into the group (circa 2014) and not something any of the other fans my age knew much about but it was still readily available in home media stores at the time. It was always this rather daunting touchstone of their legacy that felt very out of reach. As you can imagine, this re-release had me very excited and I went in with really no relationship to the episodes other than years of Beatles fans online telling me that it's the best thing ever made. And, yeah, it's pretty good but my experience probably speaks strongly to an (and probably the only) aspect of this re-release that Elliot didn't quite touch on which is the actual necessity of the Beatles Anthology in 2025. Because, the thing is, I had never seen this series before now but it turns out I, not only knew the Beatles narrative pretty damn well already but, had seen a staggering amount of this footage, unknowingly, after years of trawling the internet for interviews and clips of the Beatles. Herein, at least in my opinion, lies the most pertinent reason to cut so much down from these episodes, especially the live performances. Obviously, the restoration is wonderful and there is so much value in having a one-stop shop that collects all of this material and can serve as a starting point for people (and I hope it does for the fans younger than me! I seem to be in the awkward middle generation of this era). I loved watching this and am glad it exists. I completely understand why fans and audiences were captivated and converted by this series in 1995 and on VHS/DVD. Obviously you guys couldn't see clips of them play live or look up Neil Aspinall's names or read up on the historical details or anecdotes at any time. But, it goes without saying, I had the entire history of the Beatles at my disposal for the entire length of my fandom. Hell, they were on iTunes before I even cared to be listening to them so I never even got the desperation to be tracking down digitised, remastered songs. So, for me, the intended impact of Anthology was never going to be felt and it was always going to be just ever so slightly a let down from the great, epic watch that fandom assured me it was. Dare I say, I found it to be a bit of a frustrating documentary in some respects for all the really interesting lore I was hoping to hear them get into that doesn't even get a look in (everything to do with their romantic lives, for example) . This is very much the "official" narrative of the Beatles and I respect how much episode nine is unashamed about that fact. Perhaps that official history aspect is going to be the most interesting thing to discuss over the next few years. The timing of this drop, intentional or otherwise, left it no option but to be overshadowed by the biopic project. Maybe that was the reason to do it now?

Brendan J. Smith

No mention of Carnival of Light’s absence?!?

Ben Dowson

That’s not what the box set says. It says Giles Martin mixed everything except Free as a Bird and Real Love.

Brendan J. Smith

It was the one track I was looking forward to the most! This was the best opportunity it ever had at being released!

Todd Costa Rica

Another fantastic video. Take 2 of I Saw Her Standing There and Money RM7 were released on the iTunes only Bootleg Recordings 1963 album and This Boy was on the Free as a Bird maxi-single. My favorites are Tell me why, I am the walrus and Baby you're a rich man. It could've been better if there were more unreleased stuff and less SDE material. The new documentary looks great and sounds fantastic overall. I would say that some of the add-in concert crowd noises sounds off pudding because I couldn't hear enough screaming girls half the time. But I felt we get to hear more of John speaking in some parts. I do miss Paul's B7 story, though.

Elliot Roberts

I think the time for its release will be once the Beatles have all passed or not at all.

Niko Lento

My first time as a Patron seeing my name in the list. Didn’t think I’d be feeling the high amount of Seratonin that I am! Thank you Elliot, please keep it up!

Christina Lohr

The last time I saw the Anthology before this was somewhere around 2003/4, when I was in my early teens, on grainy VHS recordings of the original U.S. tv broadcast (with “A-Beatle-C” idents and original commercials intact!). Despite the passage of time, I could tell quite a bit had been edited out—but you know what? I still very much enjoyed this new version of the Anthology, and I’m glad younger fans have an easy way to access it now. Getting to watch it with my dad, who’s responsible for introducing me to the Beatles in the first place, made it so incredibly special. An excellent and thorough analysis as usual, Elliott! And thank you for explaining exactly why the new mix of “Real Love” makes my ears uncomfortable. :p

Christina Lohr

It honestly wouldn’t surprise me if Carnival of Light is eventually leaked rather than receiving a proper release.

Morgan Michalko

I waited until this was up on youtube to watch it there in some small attempt to nudge its stupid algorithm in your favor, and I’m so grateful for such a thoughtful and loving breakdown of Anthology… and as I’ve seen a few others here say, thank you as a new patron (since Ringo), it is absolutely worth it :)

Jo

I love seeing the three-tles’ 90’s fits on the doc! Also LOVED THIS VIDEO ELLIOT!