Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone!

I have just published my video on The Boys of Dungeon Lane exactly one month on from its release!This video is also part of a collab with another YouTuber and that means for this occasion, I wasn't able to post it to Patrons early (my apologies), but now you can access along with the rest of my viewers on YouTube all in one go!Hope that's okay with you all, and I hope you enjoy the video. It took a lot from me to get this done this month but I'm quite proud of it.

Hope you enjoy!

E.

Files

A closer listen to Paul McCartney's new album 'The Boys of Dungeon Lane'

Check out David Bennett's video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8hLxsauPL24 Paul McCartney's first album in over five years 'The Boys of Dungeon Lane' is also one of his most personal and retrospective, looking back on the days of his youth with John Lennon and George Harrison on songs like 'Days We Left Behind'. In this video, I explore the album in detail and analyse where Paul McCartney fits into the musical landscape of today as an eighty-four-year-old former Beatle. Chapters 0:00 - Intro 0:57 - Paul McCartney's last six years 3:09 - Making the album 5:09 - Promoting the album 6:45 - First listen 7:24 - Looking into the past... 9:16 - Days We Left Behind 16:39 - As You Lie There 20:32 - Lost Horizon 23:00 - Ripples in a Pond 24:28 - Mountain Top 26:25 - Never Know 28:59 - Home to Us 35:49 - Down South 38:42 - We Two 42:48 - Come Inside 44:11 - Life Can Be Hard 48:51 - First Star of the Night 49:35 - Salesman Saint 52:21 - Momma Gets By 55:12 - Concluding thoughts 59:48 - Is this the end? Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/elliotroberts Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotroberts Twitter: https://twitter.com/ElliotRoberts5 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliot.roberts Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/elliotroberts Sources Variety Article: https://variety.com/2026/music/news/paul-mccartney-listening-session-album-dungeon-lane-ringo-1236724612/ Billboard Article: https://www.billboard.com/lists/paul-mccartney-every-track-the-boys-of-dungeon-lane/ Guardian Article: https://www.theguardian.com/music/2026/may/05/paul-mccartney-the-boys-of-dungeon-lane-playback-preview-fans-abbey-road Apple Music Interview with Zane Lowe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-SY9ZKM5mw NME Interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=afHEY-7_-JA&t=3s Paul Mescal Interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxK5wkZ_scg&pp=ygUacGF1bCBtY2NhcnRuZXkgcGF1bCBtZXNjYWw%3D Chicken Shop Date: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0aq8OB-zwo&t=4s LA Listening Party (Home to Us): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayTRw-CNTs4&pp=ygUacGF1bCBtY2NhcnRuZXkgcGF1bCBtZXNjYWw%3D LA Listening Party (Days We Left Behind): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UYGbrfZWUM&pp=ygUecGF1bCBtY2NhcnRuZXkgbGlzdGVuaW5nIHBhcnR5 Ringo Starr Interview on Jimmy Kimmel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8d_nEJvbjx4&pp=ygUYcmluZ28gc3RhcnIgamltbXkga2ltbWVs

Comments

Gen's Portfolio

Love David Bennett! It’s cool to see you collab with him

Phil Pagett

David Bennett is a cool dude and certainly knows his onions. I generally only comprehend about a fifth of what he says but it’s all jolly interesting.

Peyton

I got the album the day it came out at my local record store hosting a listening party for it. It felt really cool as a 25 year old to be able to participate in a release of a former Beatle and a man who has had his music played by my family long before I was even thought of

Sarahhh

gah what a great album - serendipitously i had a listen to it today after a few weeks of non TBODL content. how lucky are we to have mccartney still making music! now not to expose my own fandom-like inclinations (ahem) but re: we two - interestingly the handwriting of the title on the track listing looks quite different from the rest, and is strikingly similar to the handwritten title for now and then (aka john’s handwriting hmmmm)

Alaina

OK I’m obviously not finished with this but OMG. This is so freaking good. Like you’ve outdone yourself here. I’ve been a huge fan of this album since it released and I feel like you’re verbalizing everything I’ve loved about it but couldn’t quite name. And you’ve left me with a newfound appreciation for the album too! (My mind is entirely changed about “Down South” now.) and also YESSS to your interpretation of “We Two.” I would love to see you go deeper into that haha. Thank you as always for the stellar work and I can’t wait to see whatever it is you’re putting out next year!! <3

Jorge Bernardo

Amazing commentary! 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽 Kinda wish you spoke 15% SLOWER, though. #feedback

itsbeanefun

I love this album, so different to what I expected but so full of rich storytelling. I always enjoy hearing your takes as well, you completely changed my opinion on down south! Really appreciate you taking your time to make an in-depth analysis rather than a quick review as soon as the album dropped. Additionally: Elliot Roberts mclennon video WHEN?

Rand

Thank you, Elliot! I've been tearing my hair out seeing people scoff at the simplicity of "Down South" when, as you mention, that's the entire point of the song! Just Paul and George trying to "work it all out". Both the guitars and their friendship. It's honestly one of my favourites off the album. Absolutely loved this video, btw. Learned a lot of new stuff. Think I'll be re-watching this a lot :) Looking forward to your future releases!

Neil Williamson

Great video Elliot! Appreciate the time and effort you put into your videos. You could have put out a much simpler, shorter reaction video closer to the release of Dungeon Lane. Instead we get an hour long deep dive, with so many interesting points and takeaways. Well worth the wait!! ✌️❤️

Trey Niño

Excellent analysis Elliot per usual. My favorite track on the album other than Days we left behind is actually the one you spent the least time on “Ripples in a pond”, which only goes to show how versatile Paul is! Your least favorite song on the album is somebody else’s favorite. And the fact Paul is making an album this good at 84 years old is mind blowing. He truly never disappoints ❤️

Margaret Synnott

Elliot I am so excited for your take on mclennon.

Elliot Roberts

A lot of people watch YouTube videos at 1.5x or 2x speed so I’m just trying to find a balance haha

Jorge Bernardo

Regretfully, there’s no mechanism to slow down. It feels rushed. Especially for old guys like me. Let them apply the 1.5 or 2.0. I’m trying to process your brilliant writing! 🤷🏼‍♂️

Florence May Vintage

Loved your analysis, and so pleased you love the album 🫶🏼

Яна Уладыка

<i> JUSTICE FOR 'WE TWO'! Thank you very much, Elliot, for pointing all this out - I LITERALLY CRIED upon the first listening, SO OBVIOUS it seemed, MY JAW DROPPED - as from the very first song I tried to be very attentive to the lyrics (especially as a non-native speaker). Then I read the official explanations, listened to all interviews available in the search for a clue (as if my life depended on it... oh, what a sweet escapist curse to be a beatlemaniac) - and I thought, well, give the old man a break, maybe I'm biased: I had been intrigued by the 'secret code' hint ('Come inside' - is this it?) and read too much on, you know... the partnership topic - only to read too much into what was made for a laugh... Perhaps it's just my bended optics... But it's not just me - now it's also the sensible people like Elliot that point it out! And as for the public explanations this song might as well be 'not' about John as 'I know (I know)' with it's 'I've Got a Feeling' riff is 'not' about Paul! Anyway, what an exciting time for 'beatle people' to exist...</i>

Jordy

I loved you going off towards the end about the unstoppable force that is this man. Excellent as always!

Davis H

Wow Elliot, somehow you just keep getting better and better with every video you put out! I’m loving this album more and more every time I hear it, and yeah I 100% agree with your interpretation of We Two. I have no idea where it would slide into my McCartney album ranking, but seeing it placed so highly on yours makes me so happy. Never Know is one of those songs that makes me tear up every time I hear it, there’s so much Sgt Pepper/Magical Mystery Tour spirit in that song that just hits me right in the feels. Thanks as always for continuing to make me laugh, cry and marvel at the genius of Paul, I always eagerly await an upload from you! Can’t wait to see the Beatles related project you’re working on!

Matt Tregortha

Great video! I really enjoyed this album 👌

Margaret Synnott

I was so moved by your observation about the chords he used in Down South!

KathyT

Excellent video as always! I really love this album - it exceeded my expectations. I always love seeing the many film clips and photos that you add to your videos.

Davis H

You can slow it down by going to settings -> speed and then slowing it to whatever you need!

Erin Uy

god I would really love if Paul adds at least one of these songs into his tour (cuz I have no doubt in my brain he's gonna keep going). loved his setlist last year but so many of these songs would sound so amazing live. anyways amazing analysis! excited for your beatles project and your hypothetical johnpaul video

Alaina

Coming back here after somehow binging your entire Ringo video yesterday (which was absolutely phenomenal, like the work and research you put into it was insane, and you got me laughing so hard at points) and maybe I'm slow to realize this, buttttt is the video you're releasing next year a Beatles album ranking?? 👀

Caribythesea

We need that Mclennon video Elliot - it’s time for a new approach to their relationship. If we are all unanimous that We Two is about John, then we have Paul saying unequivocally ‘Over and over again, I’ll be in love with you’. Meanwhile Now & Then is widely presumed within Beatle world to be about Paul, and Sean revealed the sheet of paper showing that John’s demo lyrics included the line ‘I’m still in love with you’. So we have John AND Paul literally saying - in song - that they are in love with one another and no one talks about it. It’s time that the conversation was shifted from ‘they loved each other like brothers! They weren’t IN love with one another’, to ok, they wanted the world to know that they were IN love with one another… what now? How should we be interpreting their relationship if we actually *listen* to what they are saying in their songs?

Erin Wiggins

I think this is a wonderful review. I was hoping it wouldn’t be a rehash of the last 2 albums & boy was I happy with it! It came out on my birthday, so that made it super special. And way to bring in Les Miz!

Fran Mason

Very thoughtful and thorough as usual - thanks!

Craig Hilton

You put so much work into this, Elliot, and quality of the journalism shows.

Craig Hilton

I keep going back to listen to your post-Beatle solo album reviews, and I love them. The feelings I come away with: John - engagement Paul - respect George - happiness Ringo - surprise

Christopher Newman

Hi Elliot, I absolutely loved this video, you really capture some of the elements of Dungeon Lane that I had felt but couldn't articulate. A couple of thoughts to share. The opening track, "As you lie there," comes across as unusually dark and almost stalker-like - which I really dig. This is not a silly love song, it verges on obsession and I love it! Also, I didn't actually like "Home to Us" when I first heard it, but in the context of the album, it is utterly perfect. I equate it to when Ringo came on stage at the O2 with Paul. It might not have been the most polished thing ever, but that wasn't the point. After listening to this wonderful album I think I have the defensible argument that Paul McCartney is the greatest songwriter of the 20th Century, and Paul McCartney is the greatest songwriter of the 21st Century (just on his post Y2K output). Wonderful video, thank you for sharing (and without wishing to give you more work, this kind of deep album dive would work really well for all Macca's other solo stuff)., Sending love and good wishes x

BestDavidBowieSongOf1985?

PLEASE EXPLAIN HOW YOU JOKED ABOUT PAUL BEING A GEOGUESSER AND WITHIN A WEEK RINGO IS ONLINE GEOGUESSING

Debra Cope

I pushed send before I was ready because, hey, I’m a boomer! Anyway, I wanted to say that your video did a really beautiful job of driving home how you can follow your passions and still convert them into a career. I’m very happy for you.

R

seconding this! its gonna be a moment