Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm thinking of ranking the "Fifth Beatles" for a little video and I wanted to check with you folks, who do you think is in contention for this ranking?Obviously there are the obvious key fifth Beatles (George Martin, Brian Epstein, Stuart Sutcliffe, Pete Best, Billy Preston etc.) but who are else would you say could be considered?And feel free to include any explanations!

Comments

flowers

allen klein >:)

flowers

(i promise that was a joke)

Beth Storey

Tony Bramwell, Mal Evans and Billy Preston would be my picks.

Christopher Newman

I think the thing about the fifth Beatle is that it actually is a composite; George Martin in the studio, Mal Evans as support, Brian Epstein from the management side, Billy Preston as the glue at the end - and yes, even Yoko and Linda. The Fifth Beatle is a gestalt of all of those people who played an integral part in the story.

Garrett Hicks

I think you got the primary ones in your preliminary list. You could also include Mal Evans, the Beatles' wives (Mo, Patti, Linda, Cynthia, and Yoko), Neil Aspinall, Geoff Emerick, Alan Parsons, and maybe Glyn Johns and Phil Spector. Tony Sheridan should definitely make the cut since he is the only non-Beatle aside from Billy Preston to appear by name on one of their recordings.

Fathom

I vote Mal for sure, but also Geoff Emerick, because he was so instrumental (ba dum tiss) in shaping that instantly recognisable Beatles sound

Eli Gallagher

Murray the K! Brilliantly parodied as 'Bill Murray the K' in 'The Rutles' 🤣

Gaby G

Undoubtedly little Heather McCartney, for all the productive contributions she made to the Get Back recording sessions 😁 In all seriousness, a couple other folks who haven’t been mentioned yet are Derek Taylor (who I know George Harrison mentioned as a fifth Beatle once), and Klaus Voormann.

Pat D

Everyone's answers are definetely better and more accurate, but there's two name that are important to mention if you twist the definition of Fifth Beatle. Jimmie Nicol played drums for 8 shows while Ringo was sick during the opening of the Beatles' 1964 world tour. While Pete Best and Stuart Sutcliffe played with the band in the early days and Billy Preston played in the later days, Nicol is the only man who isn't one of the four to know exactly what Beatlemania was like as a performer, and for me that's worth a mention. Andy White also has an interesting case because he's the drummer that George Martin brought in for the Love Me Do single that kick-started everything. Small contribution in the grand scheme of things, but given how rare it was for any body to play on Beatles tracks, it's worth a mention.

Matt Spafford

It’s 100% undoubtedly George Martin, but I’ve heard people argue that Clapton could be considered the fifth Beatle!

Edie Côté

My first thought is Mal, if just from his sheer delight at banging on the anvil on Maxwell's Silver Hammer

Bennett Billard

If nothing else, he's the father of the name.

Bennett Billard

Did the Beatles cartoon ever put them w/ a 5th person in one episode? If so, that would be a great gag for the video.

Emily Walton

I agree with a lot of the names listed here, and George Martin is at the top of my list for sure. Where would the lads be without him? My first thought when I saw this post was that sometimes places play a big part, almost like a character, in certain histories and legends. If I could vote for a non-human Fifth Beatle it would be Abbey Road Studios, the home of their experimentation and creativity. It looms large in their legend (just like Ringo’s drums lol).

John Vann

surely it’s the multitalented lookalike dude who took over from Macca after he died in the 60’s???

Mitch Weissman

In the US NY area it was DJ Murray the K. Look him up!

Chargelis

The fake Paul McCartney, Willie Campbell/Billy Shears.