Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone,

I managed to work in this Fifth Beatle video before the end of this month (Steve Jobs one is coming in September).

Thanks for all of you who contributed to this, I really appreciate it.

As usual, it'll be up on YouTube in a few days.

Hope you enjoy the early access!

E.

Files

Fifth Beatle Tier List

Who was the Fifth Beatle? In this tier list I cover George Martin, Brian Epstein, Billy Preston, Pete Best and many more to answer the age old question. Get Surfshark VPN at https://surfshark.deals/ELLIOT - enter promo code ELLIOT for 83% off and 4 extra months for free! Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/elliotroberts Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotroberts Twitter: https://twitter.com/ElliotRoberts5 Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/elliotroberts

Comments

Christopher Newman

Really loved the video Elliot (and thanks so much for the shout out). My only divergence from your list would be putting Epstein on the S level with George (and possibly moving Yoko up to A list). Really enjoyed this history of the Beatles from the perspective of those they interacted with.

Eli Gallagher

Jim Keltner fan club! Yes! Loved this one Elliot. A lot of people here I never would have considered, and some I'd never heard of! And loved the Apu reference 😂 Just a note: I noticed when you were talking about Chaz you said he played with them in 1969 where I think you meant '59. An honest slip, but thought I'd mention it 🤗

Mitch Weissman

Thanks for the recognition on Murray the K, Elliott. He actually was our "5th Beatle" during Beatlemania's early days. Telling us stories, looking out for us during rehearsals, the early shows and press stuff. Friends til the end, he had so many people answering his phone when he was ill at home. Tony Orlando, Dionne Warwick. Many more all took turns when Murray couldn't get the calls. I still miss him.

Gaby G

Loved this ranking! I agree that George M was very clearly the most 5th Beatle-y of all the contenders. He wasn’t only their producer, but also their teacher and sometimes basically their dad. Also, I was worried going into this that you were going to include some of the more unsavory Apple characters, like Magic Alex - very glad you did not 😂 Also also, #JusticeForApu!

Bennett Billard

The answer: The real Fifth Beatle was the friends we made along the way.

Kathryn Coffey

This is a great list. One thing I will say, I felt like Billy Preston was robbed of S-Tier. And maybe it’s just me, but S-Tier looked pretty lonely compared to the other tiers. Other than that, it’s pretty solid.

Elliot Roberts

I know what you mean, Kathryn! I struggled with this but ultimately I just wanted to make sure people knew who I thought was number 1. But I agree, Preston (and Epstein) are right there behind him.

Iñaki García

Fantastic video! I'd have both George Martin and Brian Epstein as S (I agree with Paul and I think both deserve it). And I’d rather have Richard Lester or the Maharishi in the lower categories than Chas Newby, Tommy Moore or Norman Chapman. But I basically agree with all the rest and I thought some of your choices were very clever.