Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey Patrons!

I have just released a video on Youtube which is a thorough analysis and my curated thoughts on the new Beatles song 'Now and Then.'

But as a treat, I thought I'd upload my initial reaction to the song exclusively for Discord Access Patrons and above! As I say in the Youtube video, I don't think I'd make it as a react channel because I kinda just sat there smiling the whole time (pretty boring response!), but maybe you'll find something to appreciate about it.I also figured, due to copyright issues, I'd let this video be my first video uploaded natively to Patreon!

Enjoy :)

E.

Comments

Jerod Ruschenberg

I noticed how you kinda popped up when the George Tribute Solo swell in. That slide guitar part is so unforgettable for me.

Jess the Stampede

Honestly I began tearing up listening to the song. There's something so bittersweet about the difference between Lennon and McCartney's vocals. You can hear the years in Paul's voice. He doesn't sound like he did when The Beatles were together, but that's okay. Meanwhile, Lennon's vocals are eternally youthful, but heartbreaking when you remember that he was robbed of the chance to grow old. I'm sure Yoko was likely part of the inspiration for the lyrics of the song, but what I would give to have been in the room with Lennon as he was writing Now and Then, just for the chance to ask, "Do you miss them? (George, Paul, and Ringo) Are they also on your mind as you sing the lyrics? Do you wish you could tell them you love them?"

Kahless

I think it’s an absolute clunker! The only slightly more listenable, but more sought after, ‘Carnival of Light’ woulda been a better choice. Especially since it’s now on Anthology 4.

Kahless

Oh dear! 😹

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

I felt the same back when I first listened, and I still tear up. I hadn't heard the demo before this, so my first reaction was full body chills hearing how clear Lennon's voice sound and the novelty of hearing him sing something *new* (to me) - that in and of itself felt like a gift. I loved the strange melody. But then when Paul's voice came in and it had clearly aged, and they synced up on the "love you...now and then I miss you"...I just felt so sad. Whatever can be said about if the song should have been released, or it was just a cash grab, or if this is really what John (or George) would have wanted or how it would have turned out if they had lived...in some ways I think it was Paul still working through his grief and getting a chance to write another song with his songwriting partner across time. I would like to think on some level John was intending it for him, but of course we don't know. It also came out right around All Soul's Day so I was already thinking about lost loved ones and hadn't been expecting such a bittersweet song. I think it might actually be my favorite of the 3 restored songs even if it can barely be considered a Beatles song.