A Rejection Of My Former Thinking (Patreon)
Content
My thoughts drifted earlier this week to one of the earliest pieces that I published on here, one that detailed an auteurist preference for Howard Hawks' To Have And Have Not over Michael Curtiz's Casablanca, on the primary basis that one director 'had a personality', while the other did not.
What I write is a continuing process of learning that I know nothing.
I have recently been listening to an audiobook biography of Michael Curtiz along with reading a biography of Raoul Walsh, two directors who were well-noted for a seasoned career at Warner Brothers in the 1940s, just like Howard Hawks. All of them are clearly artists, despite my previous arbitration -- Curtiz has a streamlined acceleration of theatrical Expressionism, Hawks has a manneristic fusion of comedic adventures and adventurous comedies, and Walsh continues the nostalgic fugues of Griffith while anticipating action cinema's explosion in the 50s and 60s. All three Warners directors achieved a pitched balance by the studio's relentless churn and focus on gritty and grounded stories for the working audiences of wartime America -- to decide that one was an artist and one was not was a naive reflection on my part borne from the received wisdom of Andrew Sarris and other auteurist critics who were excellent in discussing overall narratives of cinema, but sometimes faltered when it came to articulating individual quirks or virtues of certain directors -- rewatching Curtiz's The Adventures of Robin Hood this month was confirmation to me that he is not just a hired-hand, he had a distinct vision of life, a high-contrast tempo that enlivened his subjects while throwing them into the realm of archetypes -- if I am able to see the connective tissue of his career, it seems to me now that Curtiz's perspective as a Hungarian immigrant allowed him to depict the larger-than-life follies and heroisms of Western culture from an off-center angle -- think about the final duel in The Adventures of Robin Hood, where we linger on the shadows of the duelists as much as we do the fighters themselves, or in his adaptation of Charge of the Light Brigade, where the spiritual truth of chivalric warfare is found at the expense of any and all historical facts. Curtiz is a director of myth more than Hawks ever was, as Hawks, the ever-sober Protestant, always sees the flaws in his own heroes, as much as he admires their spirit -- Hawks stands above and beyond his characters, but Curtiz follows them, cannot help but lionize some inherent light which peeks out from the corners of their souls -- Errol Flynn in real life was a bastard, but Curtiz and Walsh made him look like the gentleman's gentleman, a smiling Byron.
My own wrongness aside, I feel drawn inexorably towards a new current, a new way of engaging with cinema. Auteurism is wonderful, but it is like blinders on a horse -- you always find what you're looking for, so you have to take care to look for a lot of different things, not just the same few things over and over again. I'm starting to believe that directors can contain pluralities beyond their stereotyped images received in epigraphs and textbooks -- Godard is a director who never ceased to experiment and push himself into daring directions with every single project, and this doesn't make him a 'journeyman', he's a multi-faceted artist. Some of his occupations remain, some change, but he's still him -- we don't even have to look at an extreme example like Godard, though. Raoul Walsh seemed to have two different artists inside him: there's the Walsh who works in Academy ratio, the safeguards of 1.33:1, and delivers fast-paced tales in the Griffith school of shot/reverse shot coverage; then there is the Walsh of The Big Trail's widescreen and Cinemascope, the Walsh who plays every scene out in these proscenium long takes and two-shots, such as in the excellent The Revolt of Mamie Stover.
Which one is the 'real' Walsh? It's just like how there isn't a single Godard -- Walsh varied his approach depending on the technical situation he found himself within, he adopted the strengths and possibilities of different aspect ratios (just like Godard does in his 1960s material, flipping between black & white Academy ratio and color Cinemascope).
This search for the 'real' within a director only reveals our own preoccupations and preferences; when I wrote that piece about Hawks vs. Curtiz, I wanted to assert the monomaniacal masculine vigor of Hawksian formalism over the more fluid and malleable vision of Curtiz, and now I find myself more intrigued by the relaxed pictorial pleasures of Curtiz over the stuffy interior worlds favored by Hawks -- is this 'maturity'? Hardly; I'm on a journey, trying to harmonize my own way of seeing with various directors, and a director who has many different ways of seeing can strike me now as equally valid to a director who has one single way of seeing -- I felt this to an astonishing sense while watching the works of Straub/Huillet, I was crushed by their insistence, it was suffocating to watch, and I longed for dynamism. I wonder if I would react to Bresson today as I previously have -- he's still a genius of course, but he's a genius who never broke away from his own model, he embodied it, while you have directors like Godard or Walsh who weren't afraid to leave their previous selves behind when the time called for it.
Is cinema a dogmatic programme, or an adaptable methodology? Do we want our directors to always be doing the thing we think that they're good at, or are we willing to accept their desire to experiment and color outside their own lines? The rigid dogmatic cinema functions as a kind of marketing clique -- what you expect is what you get, you pay for a preconceived notion; the cinema of adaptation asks us to take critical and emotional risks on a project-by-project basis. Ultimately it's a question of the thick or the thin end of the wedge -- do we start from a single principle and then extrapolate outwards in an emenationist model, or do we condense a variety of contradictions into an epistemic and ontological pluralism of experience? Is a director a single artist, or does she contain several conflicting artistic impulses? Is this type of questioning a false dichotomy? I think so -- I'm trying to find the multiple inside the supposedly singular, and the singular within the multiple. We can't reduce one way or another -- we have to accept artistry as we find it, not as we want it to appear to our systemic contrivances.
Files
Previews only