Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The identification with the image has been a central problem for the cinema since its beginning -- as soon as we began to photograph our fellow human beings, much less film them, we became susceptible to imagining ourselves via the prism of their performances -- the movie star is a movie star because their characteristics are repeatable enough to be emulated, and as Andy Warhol memorably produced variants of Marylin Monroe and Elvis Presley, we are always finding ourselves swimming in a sea of icons which are reproduced and sold to a mass audience of impressionable onlookers -- as much as we may love the emotions and dialogue of conventional narrative cinema, we more often love the ineffable sensation that we are participating in the film itself as much as the creators are; this sensation is the arena of fantasy.

I've been considering the notion of the 'power fantasy' cinema in particular -- what does it mean to have a power fantasy? It's a character or set of characters feeling or acting in a way that someone might wish to act in their own lives, but for some reason cannot -- how many films are there about characters spontaneously quitting their shitty jobs, hooking up with someone who truly loves and understands them, getting revenge on all those who have wronged them (and then some)?

Capitalism sells these power fantasies to us with the implicit understanding that they are more or less impossible -- you'll never /actually/ find your perfect dream guy, but it's a nice comforting idea, an idea that keeps your heart beating as you work your menial day job, media nourishment for the soul. But what happens when the kids who watch nothing but action and horror films decide that's a model they want to emulate by shooting up their school?

There's not often a direct correlation with these sorts of things, but the general ambience is felt by everyone -- when we're pissed, we'd all like to have the ruthless stoic capability of John Wick, we like to see him act out extravagant violence, but if we saw any of that in real life, we'd be traumatized -- yet when that fiction/non-fiction border is broken, it's a mixture of terror and woe. We know people who take what they see in movies for fact, and often times they can be right -- movies show you how cars are driven, how guns are reloaded, how marriages fall apart, there is always this documentary feeling that thrills us, an educational aspect even with the dullest spectacles. We can say 'it's just a movie' all we want, but we then take it very seriously when it's convenient to us -- the arts have a fate of being extremely pertinent and casually disposable at the same time, aesthetics are a fragile-yet-powerful thing, a glass cannon aimed at our feelings and thoughts.

Films like Fight Club, The Matrix and Wanted fall so easily into the power fantasy mold -- the protagonists start out as white collar weaklings, then are able to actualize themselves via performing horrendous violence, the fantasy of every tie-wearing office clerk who secretly wants to be a Superman. Sure, you could say that Fight Club is a 'satire' of this attitude, that The Matrix contains gnostic and trans allegories, that Wanted... is stupid, so who'd take it seriously?

But from my experience, the average viewer takes it quite seriously, disregarding all possible nuances that they'd rather not register anyway -- a movie about kicking ass is a movie about kicking ass, and they hold that desire in the back of their minds, an 'only if' that usually is never actualized except in tragic circumstances -- everyone wants to be the epic individualistic hero, but most of us don't want to get punched in the face enough to harden us to the violence it takes to act with either reserved discipline or total impunity -- the forge of conflict breaks us, or it makes us into steel, but it's a process that the average moviegoer doesn't have to experience all that often, and perhaps that's why they segment it into being a thing 'only in the movies' -- the characters get to live full satisfying lives in a two-hour runtime, while us real people get to roll around in the discontented filth of reality.

What power fantasies indicate is this Platonic separation between the beautiful Form of something and the hideous manifestation of it -- real life gunfights aren't the balletic operas of John Woo's world, but we wish they were, we wish that we could find catharsis in something that's usually accepted as a terrible necessity. Through art, we try and find the ideal within the real -- the cinema is a literalization of what we so often wish our reality was like, even at its worst.

Think about a film like Schindler's List, or Letters From Iwo Jima -- far from glamorizing their brutality subject matters, these pictures are intense emotional ordeals for the viewer. Yet both films make sense of a senseless conflict, they bring humanity to a war which highlighted mankind's inhumanity to man -- the cinema, even when in a cynical mode, is trying to rationalize and reason through the chaos of its IRL counterpart, trying to make it fit into a story we can tell ourselves.

The cinematic power fantasy uses idealized versions of romance or violence to purify those contradictory topics into something legible for the human mind to experience -- even in the so-called 'end of grand narratives' heralded by postmodernism, we still require a logic to cohere our lives into images which we can accept and control under human will, even if that image doesn't include everything -- if you held all the contradictions and paradoxes in your mind at the same time, you'd go insane from the strain.

While we should always acknowledge the literalist limitations of power fantasies, we should also make room for what they symbolically represent -- the movie star, like a martyr, blesses and sins on our behalf, they embody symbols and archetypes so that we can then use those categories to structure our consciousness and our society. We must never totally give over to the imaginal world -- but we also cannot do without it. That conflict is what makes the cinema dangerously easy to disregard -- we never want to admit that we project ourselves onto the screen as much as the artists behind the films do.

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.