Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

"Nobody has any reason I don't know about" bellows Cody Jarret, his brow furrowing into wrinkles, the slick gangster of the early 30s curdled into the neurotic post-war years. Walsh's characters always have their reasons, and seldom does he abandon this intensely subjective pursuit -- to each person is granted an inner life, and even if they embody a 'type' that is readily accessed via the imagination or the cinema, they remain singularities, never mythologies.

That anti-mythic zone is why White Heat is the type of film that John Ford would never make -- Walsh does not deal in broad caricatures, or even society-as-such, unlike Ford, who can easily be adored by the Marxist school of film criticism for his incisive portrayals of ideological imposition on communities. If we narrow things down, they could appear thusly:

Ford : Collectivism navigated by Individuals

(Ethan Edwards vs. his family/the Comaches)

Hawks : Collectivism negated/suspended by Individuals

(Bogart/Bacall vs. the Vichy fascists)

Vidor : Collectivism transcended by Individuals

(Howard Roark vs. the state/economy)

Walsh : Collectivism composed by Individuals

("Nobody has any reason...")

For these central American artists, though they share a similar commitment to holistic storytelling, we see magnitudes communicated via these differences. I personally believe that the most pertinent critique can only emerge from a place of admiration and respect, so when I say what I'm about to, it is from a place of love: Walsh is simply on another level in this juncture, and to understand his virtues is to reflect on the limitations of the other directors.

For example: Hawks made his own important gangster picture, Scarface, which has claim to the same level of influence as Walsh's The Roaring Twenties or White Heat. But Hawks, it has been noted by Tag Gallagher, never really directs a 'topic' -- his gangster milieu is easily exchanged for the world of aviators, detectives, cowboys, hunters, scientists, etc.. So when we look back on Scarface, what strikes us is its comedy, its blithe morality, its disinterest in the logistics of crime and overriding interest in gesturing towards criminality as an aesthetic -- the coin flipping, the machine gun montage, the 'X marks the death motif' and so on -- so Hawks suspends the notional reality of gangsterism and substitutes it with his own view of hubris in the face of death, which could be said to be the subject of all his films, especially his greatest works.

Walsh does the exact opposite: The Roaring Twenties and White Heat, although possessing portraits of hubris, are not hubristically constructed -- Walsh, unlike Hawks, grew up on the streets, and doesn't see things from a rarefied lens. White Heat's portrayal of criminal psychosis has a tangibility that Hawks would never approach -- Cody Jarrett's masculinity and sanity are constantly being compromised, yet this fact does not diminish him in the eyes of the audience -- instead, Walsh wants us to see Cody as a fully-realized human who nevertheless does inhuman things as an expression of his nature.

Indeed, Walsh's films of the late 1940s contain a neurosis that Hawks was fundamentally allergic to and that Ford only sometimes entertained in later works like The Searchers -- Walsh is more in-tune with the mood of the time, regardless of when or where he makes his pictures, and he is not shut-out from the broader world. We find a paradox with Walsh in that many of his films like The Strawberry Blonde or Gentleman Jim are about absolving nostalgia through introspection -- compare to Ford, who critiques nostalgia even as he relishes its dreams; Hawks, whose conservatism negates history-as-such and places his works outside of time and in the realm of speculative fugues; Vidor, who has an Emersonian embrace of the here-and-now and a flagrant disregard for historical precedent.

The attitudes of Ford and Hawks ultimately won-out and would influence films like Citizen Kane and Star Wars, where cinema seems to be chasing its own tail of images, where every image already has a haunted quality to it and that there is no present to document via fiction -- this isn't a condemnation of Ford and Hawks, but simply a remark on their vast pedigree -- we must remember that Hawks ghost-directed a science fiction film, a task which seems impossible for a director like Vidor or Walsh, for whom the future does not really exist.

The reason why Hawks is a 'futurist' in this sense is that he does not seem to render any social relation in a self-consciously 'historical' way -- his characters never change, they simply acquiesce or die. It's the same reason why all John Carpenter films are the same regardless of genre or if they're set in the near future -- Vidor at the very least is aware of a tradition he rejects, Walsh considers the relevancy of tradition, Ford is sustained by tradition, but Hawks emerges as a full-blown modernist, even a post-modernist -- he directs as if he's not even impacted by tradition, and so he's able to construct timeless pictures -- think of how much of 2008's Iron Man is a direct copy of the Hawks screwball. You can only have a Fordian film by making it about the past -- like John Milius' Big Wednesday -- but the Hawksian element seems to exist in excess of the era in which he directed his oeuvre -- consider Land of the Pharaohs, where his most pressing question was "How does a pharaoh talk?" and not "How do we see Egypt?" Via language, Hawks obliterates the past, anything which lies before the industrial age vernacular.

Where does that leave us with Walsh? Unlike Vidor, there is no ubermenschian religious element in Walsh -- Walsh points to the transcendental sometimes, but more often, like in the endings of White Heat or The Revolt of Mamie Stover, his films serve as circular journeys which loop back upon their emotional premise in a poetic way.

This is why it is apt to compare Walsh with Shakespeare, why Ford/Vidor/Hawks cannot be Shakespearean -- The Tempest begins and ends with a 'drowning', but what begins as an external imposition by Prospero is latter reflected upon his inner soul, so there's a symmetry to the world even if the characters cannot see it in the moment.

Almost all of Walsh's films function via this 'return', a move from outside to inside or vice versa, and this is the genius of his 'map', which appears in White Heat, Objective: Burma! and many other films. There's a dual axis in Walsh -- the map narrative, which is horizontal movement, and the rise-and-fall narrative, which of course concerns the vertical motion. This is the fundamental difference between Walsh vs. Ford/Hawks -- Hawks only cares about the horizontal, the audience-eye-level of his characters, and Ford primarily cares about the vertical, the top-down hierarchy of the heavenly and earthly institutions. Walsh has both, and thus he has a much more well-rounded view of life -- Ford's images bring about ideas, Hawks' images generate discourse, Vidor's images manifest wonder, and Walsh's images create a way of life, a way that harmonizes the personal with the universal through struggle and the drawing-out of implications to their fullest extent.

For Walsh, this is the importance of 'reason' -- even if there is an appearance of irrationality, that un-reason works a certain way, there is a reason to madness. Cody Jarrett may be mad, but he's mad because his father was, he's mad because of his actions and the situation he's in, mad because the thin mountain air gives him seizures, there's a reflective mirror between himself and his environment, and so Walsh is always at pains to show us the 'reasons' at work not only in his cinema, but in our world as well. There is always a map, even if the edges remain currently unknown:

To some degree, Walsh and Vidor share this optimistic Emersonian ground -- Vidor is a firm believer in God, and so he sees mankind as moving towards Godhood via love, and Walsh, a classic raucous Catholic, knows that this movement doesn't always ascend, but that there is descent as well, and so the vertical has to be negotiated by the horizontal. To end on a more exacting juxtaposition:

Ford : Spiritual redeems the Material

Hawks : Material supplants the Spiritual

Vidor: Spiritual desires the Material

Walsh: Material reveals the Spiritual

So if Walsh strikes us as the most 'humane' of these directors, it is because he accepts mankind's capacity for goodness and evil, and he does so without abstraction -- for Walsh, reality is a surplus of many resplendent things which have their own purpose, their 'reasons' which contribute to a larger 'reason', a way of making the world reasonable and apparent in the Kantian sense; the way forward for Walsh is to see reason without the compulsion to insist that it must also be our 'own' reason -- to respect the subjective with an objective generosity.

“There is a time in every man's education when he arrives at the conviction that envy is ignorance; that imitation is suicide; that he must take himself for better, for worse, as his portion; that though the wide universe is full of good, no kernel of nourishing corn can come to him but through his toil bestowed on that plot of ground which is given to him to till. The power which resides in him is new in nature, and none but he knows what that is which he can do, nor does he know until he has tried.”

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.