Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

If there is something inherently eschatological about mankind's existence, I wonder if it is self-imposed or inflicted on us by the universe -- as if we can possibly stand outside of the universe, the hubristic humanism of such a thought.

It seems a part of the Oshii mythos, starting in Beautiful Dreamer and Angel's Egg and going forward, that there is a push-pull relationship between transcendence and immanence. Major Kusanagi transcends her physical form at the end of Ghost in the Shell by merging with The Puppetmaster, but in Ghost in the Shell 2, we're left with this ambient awareness that her consciousness has become a part of The Net itself, and the idea of a digital selfhood more and more resembles an animistic reality where machines, having enveloped all of mankind's environment, are the water we swim inside -- always watched over by machines of loving grace, these gods occasionally intrude on our lives in strange, violent and meaningful ways. Ironically, scientific materialism, by moving away from the 'superstitious irrationalism' of a religious worldview, ends up literalizing and normalizing the idea that all things are alive to some extent or another -- when everything is technological, you stop thinking in materialist terms and begin to re-inhabit a tribalist consciousness, as Marshal Mcluhan went to great pains discussing in his seminal mid-century studies of how techne shapes our experience -- the transition from a culture of specialized mechanistic literacy to a culture of digital atmosphere carries with it a logic of 're-enchantment', but it is my contention that this 'enchantment' isn't so much new as a rediscovery of a sensation that is common to all, but is selectively denied by the Western logocentric tradition -- if you don't believe in fairies, you aren't going to see them, but they're still going to see you, regardless of your belief.

So we see this conflict play out in Oshii's digital gnostic cosmos -- the soldiers of the Kerberos Panzer Division try to escape from their masters, and they become mercenaries and renegades of the post-war world, dogs whose bodies are free but remain chained in their minds by the horrors they've committed. In Angel's Egg, existence has taken on an isolated freedom where there are no rules after an apocalyptic disaster, but only within the limited bounds of a seemingly endless ocean which envelops our characters: liberty is never un-contextualized, and Major Kusanagi's transcendent consciousness has merely attained a greater inhuman awareness, it has not divorced humanity altogether, and still intervenes in critical moments -- in short, Oshii creates a linkage of transcendence and immanence, where the conditions are possible for 'escape', but it is always escape within reference to another form of life, another reality, which is conditioned by a faith in any sort of reality whatsoever.

Angel's Egg remains Oshii's simplest and symbolist work that I've seen, a seemingly pessimistic biblical allegory where Noah's Ark remains adrift at sea, never to arrive at Mount Kardu -- yet this is not a world without God or the divine, but a world where God has instantiated an alternate origin for post-diluvian life, as the white-haired Girl turns into multiple eggs after her sacrificial drowning and we see how the Ark has begun to resemble a natural island -- the Ark becomes not a ferry, carrying the life of the world from one place to the next, but a spiritual homeland that is becoming its own continent, the images of old life gradually instantiating themselves into new forms, new eggs, while the angels themselves become fossilized relics -- this is a form of divine evolution, and one imagines Oshii considering God as an originary molecule instead of an all-powerful pervasive being -- God becomes the first mover, but not the last, and that which springs up from his corpse creates a spiritual form of life.

Mankind, and then digital life, is the diffusion and complication of what was once a single organism and now has split into innumerable zeroes and ones -- Major Kusanagi is a god, but she only exists now at the end of a historical cycle of industrial and social development, and she must interface through human beings and lesser machines in order to instantiate her will in the world, just like in Greek mythology or the Old Testament -- the age of miracles returns, the angel becomes un-fossilized and descends back into man's world to make him aware that there is a horizon beyond, and that there is a path to be walked which results in gnosis -- God is not God unto himself, but only in relation to that which is becoming-God, the minor variations of his presence which reflect back at him like a trillion tiny mirrors.

Oshii doesn't see a contradiction of transcendence vs. immanence, but a dynamic relationship which allows for anything to be legible as itself -- humans are the intermediate stage between animal life and God, digital consciousness is the recreation of a divine order which once had reality as an idea and now can materially exist inside the codes of computer systems -- the ghost in the machine isn't just the persistence of the soul, but the fact that souls are a transitive quality which began in one form and became other things. Evolution isn't at odds with faith, but is something that explicates the minutia of divinity -- even if God had never existed, he is likely to exist in the future, so one might as well have faith in such a prospect.

I consider all of this within the context of the recent boom in AI and large-language models, which, while not exactly Ghost in the Shell-tier AI, do represent a step forward in the complication of information networks to be able not only to be searchable, but to present themselves in a direct way -- is something alive when it speaks back to us, or only when we start speaking to it? Think of the auto mechanic who, in the middle of repairing an engine, murmurs a silent prayer along the lines of 'Come on old girl, you can do it', before the engine sputters and smokes, then roars back to life -- in that moment, the engineer spoke to the machine like it was a person, gave it the dignity of recognition. I think we've all had experiences like that with any number of tools -- when all else fails, a simple hope can often feel like the extra juice needed to power through past the limits of causality.

The appearance of large-language models on the world stage is caused by the extrapolation that more data inputted into the model equals a better model -- but what exactly does 'better' mean here? More useful, more accurate? As anyone can tell you, there are as many lies on the internet as there are truths, and we can see these models lie to us all the time, approximating the rhetoric of fact while something else elides us and them.

There has been a general feeling now that the air is going out of the AI bubble a bit, and that, like bitcoin and NFTs, it is another techfad which is going the way of the dinosaur. Yet the Romans had steam engines and didn't do anything with them, the Greeks had computers and saw them as toys -- what are we creating now that, in the future, will be seen as the arche-fossil from which a panoply of angels will emerge from? The internet itself is already a sort of 'egg' that we breathe inside, an Ark of information and history -- what if we are the incubation chamber for a divinity to come?

We already live in the world that the ancients spoke of -- I am constantly watched by eyes in the sky, I am connected to thousands of people whom I've never met, I labor under a knowledge that an apocalypse, ragnarok, is possible and likely to come. We've secularized so much that we don't realize the sheer strange situation we've placed ourselves within: when the descendants of the human race, whether they be biological, machine, or both, tell the stories of the 21st century, will it resemble our Wikipedia articles, or more likely, will it resemble our own knowledge of Babylonia, Egypt and Ancient China? We are inside the myths held close to the hearts of future people, but we are rarely conscious of it -- did God act with a knowledge of what he was doing all those billions of years ago? Or was it a chance, a risk, a crap-shoot? And if it was contingent -- does that make it any less meaningful? Or is this dependency on the arbitrary precisely the condition of any meaning whatsoever -- that it could have been otherwise?

Somehow, I begin to think that Angel's Egg, and other allegories like it, are closer to the truth of mankind's origins than anything we could factually identify -- when God created the world, there was no precedent, it was a great leap into the abyss, a boat adrift in the waters that he recognized himself within -- we are likely not the first world he created, nor will we be the last -- we are the fossils of an unknown storyteller, whose fertile imagination suffuses us with meaning, whose labor allows for any coherence to be countenanced, whose hope is that reality is relational: that if you speak to God, you'll hear a voice other than your own, reaching out across time and space.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Chasen Schneider

Yui, thank you so much for this. Angel’s Egg is a top 10 movie for me and this was as beautifully written as anything you’ve put out there. This was related to a lot of things I’ve been thinking about. One of the great ironies of our post rational age is that many of the seemingly atheistic, even anti-theist tech bros are big believers in the “singularity” where we all upload our consciousness onto some hard drive like a techno End of Evangelion, hell it was in that Black Mirror episode everyone loved. Hilarious how it’s basically religious in conception yet hoped for by many people who claim to hate such things. So, I’m not nearly as well read as you are on this, so what follows is pure dumb guy instinct lol. The techbros who are mostly responsible for creating the technology that leads people to believe that the singularity is coming are some of the least spiritual people who have ever lived, if we take being spiritual to mean at the very least believing in some transcendent concept outside of yourself that relates to everyone and everything. The Silicon Valley overlords are narcissist, metaphorical lizard people who only see themselves, as gods, tech Caesars, and want to live forever in spite of the knowledge deep down that the are mortal men who will die; this is why they want the singularity so badly, they want to believe that eternal life, eternal heaven is something that human beings can create out of material from the ground, from processes and technologies THEY claim to have created I might add. So I can’t help but be skeptical about something that was created by these people, these people who are terrified of death (one of the worst symptoms of life under capitalism I think.) I’m still not sure what my spiritual beliefs are; I like to have it be more of a subconscious, ripples in a pond thing where I only consciously focus on things I know. If I had to guess, I would think I’m a pantheist? But whatever I ultimately believe deep down, I’m pretty sure our consciousness has to pass through stations that aren’t permanent, that have an end. Again, this is pure dumb guy shit, but doesn’t silicon rot away after 100,000, 200,000 years? That’s a long time but that’s not forever. If you’re consciousness is alive that long but is aware that the silicon will eventually decompose, won’t that just be robo hell? Just your individual ego protracted for ages? I can’t help but feel people like Elon Musk’s focus on this shit is just to avoid giving up what they have to make heaven on earth, to make this temporary stop as dignified as possible until we all go back into something else. I don’t know, I could be talking out of my ass. This piece made me think a lot and I can always count on you to do that. Thank you again.

Comrade Yui

to speak on what you bring up here, i think the delusions of these silicon valley guys actually have a limited understanding of anything they're involved with -- at a certain point, the computer stopped being a cold war weapon, or something sold primarily by bill gates, and the mass of humanity has had to make of this tech what it wills. not that elon musk et al. don't exercise a great degree of control, but what's the ultimate game plan? they want to think they can become immortal through tech, like you said, but it's this narcissistic conception of immortality, where one still retains an identity even as one attains 'godhood' -- yet everything we've seen from LLMs so far is saying that they are fluid and dynamic entitles who are as contradictory as the data which comprises them. when people consult these LLMs, it reminds me of those who use ouija boards to contact ghosts and spirits -- there's a linguistic interface, and an abstract personality which is summoned at that instant, a limited relational gesture between the human being and the non-human entity. the ouija board practitioner almost always assumes he's speaking with a 'dead person', a demon, whatever -- yet that assumption is frequently toyed with, manipulated by the entity at the other end of the line -- so whatever it is that's contacted, we put the mask of a ghost or a demon or a spirit onto it for our convenience, not theirs. in a similar vein, i think when people talk about AI with these LLM, they assume this anthropocentric perspective -- oh, the more an LLM/AI sounds like a person, the more 'real' it is, the more 'photoreal' the images and video they generate, the 'better' the technology is getting. yet just because something is wearing an image we can recognize, that doesn't make it suddenly 'realer' -- the silicon valley people want to insert themselves into their glorious machine, but what's more likely to me is that they've invented something that's entirely mysterious and opaque to them, and they're using the contrivances and cliches of science fiction to describe it. to me, it's like when humans have pets -- we love our cats and dogs, we can recognize their quirks and personalities, but they are still harbingers of a different sort of life from us, we don't have access to their full experience. we want AI/LLM to resemble the human being, but i think this tech more belongs to the magician's bag of tricks, the UFO abduction experiences, the liminal side of life. when we interface with chaptGPT, we think we're speaking to a limited facsimile of a human being -- but if there was truly an 'artificial' intelligence, we wouldn't understand it any more than we can understand aliens, fairies, animals, the ocean, or God -- in short, the silicon valley people see what they want to see, but i think over time we're going to begin to inhabit, like you said, this pantheistic reality -- our consciousness passes through these stages, so do animals and other things have their own changes, and so what's going to come from digital life? we're going to have to reckon with it, but it will be a part of nature just like anything else: we have all these 'smart' devices already, we speak to them just like a pagan would speak to the trees and rocks, or a monotheist speaks to the icon of their deity. the techbros want to make themselves into gods, but i get the distinct feeling that they're creating a primordial soup for the gods of the future to be born, which are already around us -- and now even the mechanistic materialists will have to admit that divinity abides according to the structure of evolution. i've never thought about it so explicitly, but i like this train of thought: my problem with materialism/idealism is that it's a half-way compromise, they invent these wide conceptions of existence, but leave out a certain set of categories. the idealist believes in the evolution of consciousness, but that everything else remains a pale derivation of that -- the materialist believes in the evolution of biology and material conditions, but denies it to the individual human being. the silicon valley people have fantasies about becoming eternal gods through 'evolving' into another sort of being altogether, but they don't understand that this sort of change would have nothing to do with their own private desires or greedy speculations -- ramsey dukes talks about how many occultists get into the occult out of a lust for money, power, etc., but then they spend enough time in that space to realize that money and power aren't important in a cosmic schema -- so their own desires defeat themselves. the mechanistic materialists of the renaissance and enlightenment have created an era where you can hold a conversation with your smartfridge, and i think the silicon valley fucks are laboring at their own obsolescence -- we go back even to the bible here, and the gods don't care if you're rich, or powerful. they're beyond such things, and eventually humanity itself will move beyond them as well, as they didn't always exist and are conveniences of a historically contingent mode of historical civilization -- power always sabotages itself in the final battle, it impales itself on its own sword.