Tale of Tales, and Thoughts Concerning Maury Island Mavens (Patreon)
Content
Yuri Norstein's Tale of Tales is the rare example in animation of what Deleuze referred to as the Time Image in his two books on cinema: images which carry a liberatory free-association in relation to each other, untethered by the bounds of classical realist continuity editing or narrative. It seems pat to regard the film in the way I usually approach most movies: there is nothing to 'read' here, no esoteric subtext that is more justifiable than another, and the cultural barrier between myself and Norstein surely accounts for some of my stupidity here: I recognize Napoleonic hats, soldiers, music, food, but the context by which these things are made clear is obfuscated not only by the structure, but by the way the animated figures are arranged against various panes of glass, looming in-and-out of focus, a children's sketchy storybook interrupted by real footage of cars and lights and newspapers, a multi-media blending which paradoxically makes the film feel even more nostalgic and dream-like, taking advantage of animation's inherent flatness to create a voyage into the depths of a fragmented experience: Tale of Tales feels primal, its chest full of rising air and moisture, personal heat savored against the cold stasis of history.
I was going to write about this in another post, but Tale of Tales made me further reflect on my own short films that I've made thus far, the obfuscation that the short film easily lends itself towards: not the platonic ideal of the 'feature length' picture, which articulates classic Aristotelian drama, but a direct cut into life, an easily accessible slice of the non-literal and ineffable -- I've written before about how it's easier to love short films because they do not ask that much of us, and with the animated medium especially, one grows to appreciate the precisely-wrought effects attained in an expensive and intensive form, the painstaking quality of cel or stop-motion animation giving us the same visual pleasure as a handmade clay pot or an origami animal.
With Maury Island Mavens, I had hoped to achieve an abstract feeling similar to Tale of Tales, using repetition and a symmetrical editing pattern to create a lure which made something legible out of these discordant thoughts and feelings I've been having over the past year: yearnings, encounters, obsessions, filtered through the figure of my friend Addison, who for all intents and purposes is my equivalent of the 'little grey wolf' in Tales of Tales, a Virgil spirit guide through the world of the imagination.
I felt I benefited greatly from Addie's presence. What I realized was lacking from XANATHAN was the idea of a central focus -- that film was a consistent set of ideas, something I wanted to channel from Fritz Lang, the idea that every image should be expressive of an idea in-itself. But Addie's role in Maury Island Mavens provided a clarity to me, a relief: the images didn't have to directly be ideas, they could suggest a pattern of thinking through this active individual, which is why the film has a more aggressive sense of montage: I felt that I didn't have to belabor the images, they could play out in a fragmentary manner which implicated a larger whole rather than being a museum-like tour of dead things that I had in XANATHAN -- rather than the gothic mode, I was able to now tap into a genuine expressionism, an illustrative quality that I found a great kinship with in Tale of Tales, where Norstein's mixture of simplified emotional caricature and grim darkness is characteristic of so many classics from Lang, Murnau, Browning, etc..
It's those elements that I feel are important now. One one side, allowing each shot to exist unto itself as an image, to contain a self-sustained logic, while also keeping an eye on the atmosphere, which is the sustained duration of the image-of-images, the total film. Each heightens and empowers the other: with strong individual images, you can then have a stronger total image, and I found this easier to do when using the audio track as a metronomic counter-point to the rhythm of the images. As I spoke about before, I wanted the audio image to be distinct from the filmic image, so I created both in complete separation from each other, yet united by the same themes and ideas I was feeling. When I finally synched each of them up with each other, the result was quite interesting to me: there was an inherent contradictory element, but there were also emergent synchronicities that I had not accounted for, resonances which had strengths that were the result of the incidental process of audio track colliding with visual track: this collision allowed for things which each part wouldn't have had, even if I had labored over trying to create them. In effect, letting go of control made the film feel more coherent than I had intended it to be: this is a paradox that I am in love with!
Tale of Tales gets at it from the other direction, I feel: Norstein's exacting animation style is the definition of control, nothing exists on the screen without the animator accounting for it. But Tale of Tales doesn't feel cold or sterile like a manufactured product: the result of all this control is something that is a figment, a hallucination, it extends into the unconscious. So whereas I set out to make something archetypal in Maury Island Mavens and ended up with several piercing details which prompted some viewers to read in these strong religious or political ideas that I had no idea about, Norstein starts with the specific technical mundanity of setting frames and drawings and footage into rotation, but his outcome exemplifies the same aesthetic ecstasy as the cave paintings in Chauvet, where figures flicker against the shadows of a dim recess in the earth, barely illuminated by the embers of dying lamps, or in this case, a fireplace which once held the place in the home we now have for televisions and smartphones, a source of light in our safe abodes -- in short, a naive art containing immense power, symbols disconnected from a system of symbolism.
I think there's something to this process of reversal, or enantiodromia: you begin in once place during the work, and in the process, an inversion occurs, and you're left with an art-object which is as mysterious to you, the creator, as it is to the viewer. This inherent index of mystery is a qualitative presence that cannot be reduced into this or that tradition or technique, although it is often the outcome of those things; enantiodromia ensures that change ineluctably occurs during the act, the exchange of energy between creator and creation, art and art-object. The art-object always exceeds our intentions or expectations -- it is always already coated in a sweet shroud which slyly bypasses the artist, the context, and the audience, ducking and weaving through all three, circling around to create a space where meaning and sensation are allowed to grow, a secretive garden that one stumbles in-and-out of, unsure of what delights were just sampled, half-guessing at the principles which make such a journey possible at all.
Files
Previews only