AMERICAN SIEGE; or, Escape from New York (1981) (Patreon)
Content
John Carpenter creates a three-dimensional world out of a two-dimensional art form. He is a filmmaker of tonal spaces, not of people's lives. He is an immoralist, an iconoclast, an all-American dissident. Escape from New York (and its sequel) are perhaps the purest distillation of his central tenet: there's you, and then there's everything else.
The great Walter Hill once chimed that every film he made was a variation upon the western genre, and he would be equally correct in stating the same factoid about Carpenter. Carpenter’s world is the Technate Western, the Paranoid Western, the Eldritch Western, the Wuxia Western, the western where the borders are either iron-clad law or perilously porous to invasion, and it is this notion that separates him from a figure such as Walter Hill. In Hill’s films can be found a notion of catharsis, a breaking point, change is possible, discoveries are made. Carpenter has no such notion. Each of his films is a circular loop, a closed network of possibility and contingency. So many of his characters exist in an ambiguous flux: the uncertain humanity of the researchers in The Thing, the itinerant poverty of Roddy Piper in They Live, the worldly transience of Jack Burton in Big Trouble in Little China. There is no stability in Carpenter’s storytelling, despite his steady hand and quiet restraint behind the camera. Stability is the state, the state is the Man, the Man is not your man, and that’s not the way to be, which is by yourself.
To say that Carpenter is an immoralist is to say that he obviously draws from the grand tradition of Howard Hawks, that wily fox of Old Hollywood. Hawks, at his frequent best, did not give two shits about morality, about systems of justice or their societal derivations. His characters are, of course, professionals, and to say they have ethics is to say that they measure up to their own standards of being a professional at what they do, no matter what it is. His notable comedies ridicule the abstract, they befuddle the intellectualists, the over-determined upper-crusts of society that Hawks had little time for. His professionals don’t ‘think’ about things, they DO them, regardless of what that course of action may entail, damn all the consequences. And things work out for them, because they do their jobs that they’re best at, and that’s all that can be asked of anyone, for Hawks.
Carpenter isn’t so optimistic. Snake Plisskin earns himself two Purple Hearts for his heroism in Siberia and Leningrad, and not much else. As far as he’s concerned, those Purple Hearts were probably sold on a street corner for a pack of cigarettes. He doesn’t have a profession save for saving his own skin and coming out the other end of what Escape from New York puts him through. For Carpenter, his characters no longer exist in the somewhat playful, yet guaranteed mid-century middle class Americana of Howard Hawks. His characters are burnouts, refugees, the last cop on the payroll, the girl babysitting, the man who knows more than he should, the outlaws, the marginalia. Snake Plisskin’s definition of professionalism is having a bigger gun than the other guy, of making the best of a terrible situation. One eye’s gouged out and the other’s peering around that dark corner into the desolate future and it doesn’t like what it sees.
You’d have to lose an eye to make sense of anything in Escape from New York: Dead Cundey’s cinematography is pure darkness lit by gaslight and neon, it’s drenched in brutalist blocks of shadow bisected by the halo of lens flare and burn barrel. New York City is arranged in computer graphics before we understand at all what it is actually like, Carpenter compounds layer upon layer of geometry onto the streets and skyscrapers to create the surface tension of apocalypse, the clean right angles of a monitored display and the cavernous expanse of human debris on street corner. Escape from New York is high-concept, but low-life. The prison’s inhabitants are a Hawksian collective on steroids, their differences expressed in tribalistic clothing and quiet confidence. In many ways, it’s like the city never changed. The prisoners see vaudeville theater productions on Broadway, travel in tinseled cars and taxis, congregate in Central Park. It’s a real place with real people, only exaggerated, as all things can become. Carpenter goes from high to low, from helicopters, planes and Lady Liberty, to the still-erect World Trade Towers, to the city streets and byzantine sewers. Without ever actually shooting in the city proper, Carpenter creates New York solely with the power of anamorphic cinemascope. His ice-cold synths pulse throughout, the moody trepidation of an alienated world, a fascist super-state that communicates its statement for ‘peace’ on a flimsy cassette tape. Everything is broken and nothing is right and you just have to make do with a bad hand dealt.
If all of Carpenter’s films are variations of the western, they are also all variations on a very specific western: the exceedingly imitable and perfect Hawksian hang-out, Rio Bravo. Rio Bravo’s depiction of a town besieged by a criminal gang seeking to free one of their cohorts, and John Wayne’s sheriff and his deputies’ attempts to prevent that very siege, is more or less the Platonic Ideal for Carpenter’s filmography, the measure for everything he deftly accomplishes. Carpenter’s substantial innovation on this notion is to expand the notion of the ‘siege’, to extract it out of the realm of black hats and white hats and into the murky waters of post-Nixon America. He has several variations of this:
His straight-ahead ‘classical siege’ films would be ones in which there’s a malevolent outside force of a physical location trying to penetrate an inner sanctum of safety: Halloween, The Fog, Assault on Precinct 13. These are early in his career, formally beautiful, classy and sinister.
Carpenter’s ‘social siege’ films are ones in which the malevolent force has infiltrated the social body and rips it apart from within: The Thing, Christine, Prince of Darkness, They Live, Ghosts of Mars, Village of the Damned, The Ward. These tend to be his most political works, attempts to display big ideas within claustrophobic environments.
Finally, his ‘escapist siege’ films focus on the idea that daily existence itself is besieging the characters, and must somehow be dealt with and escaped: Escape from New York, Escape from L.A., In the Mouth of Madness, Big Trouble in Little China, Dark Star. In these we find Carpenter at his most existential, his most libertarian. Reality in these works becomes a deadly force, whether that is political reality or metaphysical reality, and the characters are no longer on the defense of a particular locale or group, but are attempting to grapple with the absurdity that their lives have become. The Escape duology stages multiple metropolitan areas as being the last remaining embodiment of The Wild West, their anarchic freedom paradoxically bound with inherent imprisonment. Plissken is equally tasked with escaping that prison structure, but also trying to escape the religiously-tinged neo-fascist America that lies outside of the prison walls. This double-pronged siege creates an inordinate sense that Snake, just like Long Island and Los Angeles, has become an island unto himself, an individual permanently adrift in a universe of cloying collectives.
It’s important that Snake isn’t respected within Escape from New York. He’s a noted figure, for sure, thought to have been killed in action by almost everyone he comes across (and interestingly, everyone who notes that observation later perishes in the film). But Snake isn’t a ‘cool guy’, he’s not a superhero. Snake isn’t invincible, he frequently gets beat-up, and has to walk with a limp through a sizable portion of the film. He’s trained, capable, a real professional at kicking ass and looking awesome, and yet his skin is frequently saved by his temporary allies who believe that he’s their ticket to their own profit. To escape these political sieges, Snake utilizes the desires of others against them as deftly as he uses his machine guns and state-provided gadgetry; and just as he loses those gadgets one-by-one, he inevitably loses his allies throughout the course of the film, often in senseless fashion. Carpenter is an immoralist; like Snake, he only cares about finishing the job and surviving, that is his extent of ethics. But does this make him a nihilist? Escape from New York’s ending, where he switches the President’s supposedly-important Peace Summit audio cassette for a comical rendition of ‘Bandstand Boogie’, suggests that the President’s apathy towards those have just been exploited and died for the sake of his survival is a blind symptom of a larger attitude of indifference. For Carpenter, a figure like Donald Pleasance’s President is not a professional, he’s not aware of who or what he is, he acts and reacts unconsciously, he gets threatened by The Duke of New York, whines and begs for his life, then later when he has the advantage, he cuts him down with a dead prison guard’s machine gun while laughing maniacally. This President isn’t even worthy of hatred or contempt, he’s a pathetic beast, he’s the American system’s pet that they keep on the throne, and this is even more explicitly stated in Escape from L.A. What the system really cares about is the tape; like Plissken suggests earlier in the film to Lee Van Cleef’s Bob Hauk, they can always get a new president. One would hope that Snake isn’t as easily replaced.
The individual's talent and potential is thus instrumentalized, used, then promptly disregarded at America’s nearest convenience. The idea of the Hawksian professional itself is under siege by the country that created it, it’s no longer a useful fiction. And just like how the independent yet still populist Howard Hawks film productions grew more rare as the 20th century wore on, the John Carpenters of the world faced extinction in the Hollywood system as the 21st century was born, the further marginalization of low and mid-budget filmmakers as their corporate masters dictated their expenditure of millions of dollars by committee, not by artistic vision. Carpenter, just like Snake, sees the writing on the wall. Better to survive another day, do what you can, and get the hell out. Of the films to truly give birth to the modern American action film in 1981 (them being Escape from New York, Mad Max 2, and Raiders of the Lost Ark), only Carpenter’s masterwork feels embodied in our current world, neither rooted fully in the recent past or the far-future. His dim nightmare of the future is one in which there’s no way for an individual to exist without being imprisoned or killed by larger forces; the Wild West is internalized into an inevitable fate that can only be stoically dealt with, not overcome. Nihilism, this is not, but pragmatism, the masculine negotiation between yourself and those assholes who put you in chains. If Carpenter is an illustrator of spaces both besieged and escaped, he’s an artist of impossible deadlock, of no right answers, of inherent paradox, of a ticking time-bomb in your neck.
What’s a professional to do when his profession is under attack?
Files
Previews only