Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

"What gives you the right, the right, to think you have control over your own life, who gives you the right? Not me, not anyone, not you, who are you to do that? Why would you do this, to me, to yourself? It’s simply horrible. You’re complicated, you’re naive, you’re horrid, and I love you. I hate that I love you but I don’t hate that I can’t stop loving you, because I know that I don’t have, what was that, yes, control, I don’t have control of my life, my love, of you. And I’m okay with that, but I’m not okay with this, what you’re doing, this, it’s not just hurting me, it’s hurting you. It’s hurting the you that I love and I don’t think that’s okay and maybe you should stop and I’ll make you stop if I have to and maybe that makes me wrong but at least I don’t have the right to do it, I’m not pretending to say that it’s okay, that I have any right to you or anything or anyone, I’m not presuming my own happiness is necessary, I’m not that far-gone. Not yet, not yet. And yet you can’t help it, can you? You can’t help hurting me, you’ll do it even when you don’t know you’re doing it. That’s the person I love; Madoka.

You’re too full of love to be able to appreciate it, to appreciate me, the one person, the particular, the conditioned, the me that’s right in front of you. I hate this. I hate that you think this is love, but I love that you’re, well, you’re generous. You’re godly, too much godliness. I didn’t fall in love with a Goddess, I didn’t love someone who was the eternal condition that allowed love to exist in the first place, I didn’t love, well, a principle, I loved a person. I loved you, the person called Madoka Kaname. The Goddess isn’t you, well, she is, but not the you-for-me, not of what I appreciate. The universal sacrifice you gave, your life in exchange for, god, everything, we didn’t deserve it. We don’t deserve you as a person or a Goddess, but I can only relate to the girl who made a choice on my, and everyone else’s, behalf. I can’t love the Goddess because she’s—you’re--everything that’s ever been and will be. And so much of that is what I can’t stand, what I’ve been through, time and time again. I hate that world, even if it’s ruled over by someone as perfect as you. I didn’t hate Kyubey for what he is, which is a miserable little utilitarian nightmare, no, he couldn’t help being awful, that’s just what he is. I hate what he did, what he pretended to be to us, how he treated you, how he forced you to become this, this… thing. A thing, not a person. It’s his fault that you made that choice; that’s what I wanted to stop. To relieve you of that burden, and, well, I just made it worse, more worse than I ever could have thought.

Even as a Goddess, he took advantage of you again, through me. He can’t help being what he is; I don’t expect anything better. But he used me to hurt you, and yet, and yet, he did a good thing. He gave me back the girl I loved, the real human person, not the ideal, not the image, not the presence, not the god-damned pre-tense of unconditional love. He didn’t know how much you and I loved each other, and now things are just as they should be. The problem was never Kyubey; it was simply that he was put in the wrong place. He manipulated this world like we were just an experiment, an exercise, buttons to be pushed and subjects to be controlled. He didn’t have a focus, he only thought about the entirety of existence. In that way, Madoka, he’s like you; always, at the end of the day, considering the big picture. The only difference is that he doesn’t have the heart to care about the little people in that picture, like me, like Madoka. You’re a better tyrant than he ever was, because you know what it’s like to be on the other end of things. Thomas Hobbes would be proud of the leviathan that you are, but I’m not.

So you want to be benevolent, and that should be enough for everyone else, but it isn’t enough for me. I don’t want to be loved by Madoka, the abstract; I want Madoka, the person, to be here, right here, right in front of me. That’s what I fought for, fought hundreds of times for, you don’t know what that’s like, even as a Goddess you don’t know because you don’t have boundaries, you don’t have limitations. Madoka the Goddess can afford to love everyone equally, to give grace back to all of us, us cursed magickal girls, to give us back a chance at something worth living for. But I’ve already lived my life, I’ve seen what it looks like, temporal distortion folding back, folding in, again and again and again. Even as a Goddess, you’re still that middle-school girl, that girl I had a crush on, that girl who impressed me so much. I’ve gone through so many timelines to save you that I don’t even know how old I am anymore; maybe 16, maybe 24, I don’t know, it blurs together in my head, and if I tried to parse it all out, I’m pretty sure I’d go insane, if I haven’t already, trapped in this immortal undead body for eternity, reliving the same moments, going through the motions, the emotions, feeling things to where I’ve gotten used to the despair, the hopelessness, more than anyone should. I’ve had so many experiences that no one else knows about but me, and maybe you. You do know about them, don’t you? You’re all-powerful, all-knowing, you can see into my heart, you know how dissatisfied I am, you know how much it hurts, and still you’re content to be this joke, this joke of godhood, this impersonal grace that I never asked for. I never asked for you to redeem me, I just wanted to save you. My wish, and, of course, you know this already, was to protect you—but a Goddess doesn’t need ‘protecting’, does she...?

That’s why I’m doing this. That’s why I’m keeping you, the real Madoka, the girl I loved, for myself. That’s why I’m taking you away from the rest of her, that Goddess. She can go govern the universe in eternal love and light and I won’t stop her. I just want my wish to be fulfilled, I want to protect you for as long as I can, protect that smile you have, the way you run your fingers through my hair, the way that your eyes glimmer when you see me, protect your shoe splashing into a puddle while you’re late on the way to school. I know the others will hate me for it, will say that I’ve tricked them, tricked you. And I have. And I don’t care. Something I’ve figured out, finally, after all this time, is that I’m okay with the suffering that comes with being a magickal girl. I actually like it, because it means that I’m still here with you, it means that, no matter how many times I go back to redo things in the past, that I won’t be alone, that I won’t be abandoned. With you, Madoka, I can be strong. I can be there for someone. And I know, ultimately, that you want to be here with me, in the flesh. I know that if it wasn’t for Kyubey’s actions, you’d never leave me alone to suffer. You’d never make that choice, not willingly.

This is why I had to trap you; because I know you better than you yourself do. I know what’s best, and what’s best is that you, even if only for a while, forget about having to shoulder the burdens of every magickal girl out there. They’ll be okay, you’ve done enough; the Goddess will take care of them now, and they can have her, as far as I’m concerned. But I get you, at least for a little bit. I get to see that smile and know it’s real and know it’s only for me and know that I was able to fulfill my wish. And I know you won’t let me do it; I know that the Goddess, the other you, will eventually come here and steal you from me. I know this.

But it won’t be without a fight. If I have to, I’ll destroy the rest of the world’s chance to be happy, if it means that you’ll still be here. Maybe that’s selfish; no, it absolutely is. But that’s love. I love you, Madoka, more than anything else, more than you’ll ever truly know. I will keep wishing for a world in which you can be happy; but if the world gets in the way of that, then so be it. Beyond hope, beyond despair, we’ll have love... even if I have to damn myself to do it. I’ll bear that weight for you, if you’ll let me. 

And you won’t."

(Requested by Selena, a Patron. Thanks Selena!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.