Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

If I had watched it a couple of years ago, I don’t think I could have finished Inside Llewyn Davis. Not because it’s bad, far from it; but because it’s too effective, too personal for what I was, what that would look like, seeing it projected out onto something external, that relatable rawness hurting my eyes as well as my heart. 

Depression is a self-fulfilling cycle of thought. It’s a subtle, gradual thing. You wake up feeling slightly off, and you pretend that’s normal. You wake up the next day and feel a little worse, and also pretend that’s normal. You keep doing this for weeks, months, years, and eventually, contrary to all common sense, you end up falling in love with feeling like shit, because your consciousness has adjusted itself to that new normal, it has a hard time remembering anything that isn’t feeling like shit, and in fact, thinks that feeling like shit is not only normal, but correct, and rational, and how the rest of the world actually is; projecting its own assumptions, what it’s gotten used to, as being baked into reality itself. At a certain point of living with that depression for years, it’s almost impossible to recall if you weren’t always depressed, because the depression drains away every little bit of joy that you’ve felt in your life and steals the energy that normally would be directed into positive emotions and instead channels them into magnifying every single tiny fragment of anxiety and frustration you experience, makes those fragments seem like eternal mountains that you, in your weakened, depressed state, can never dream of overcoming or even acknowledging. Depression feeds upon you like a vampire, and when you have nothing else left to give it, no more positive experiences or memories, it pushes you into a mental narrative of self-destruction being the only way out of this hell that you’ve been experiencing. It’s a parasite that makes the world look like shit so that it can then convince you that YOU are shit. You go from treating sadness and pain as usual elements in your life, to then normalizing thoughts of constant suicide, because the depression will not rest until it suffocates and exhausts the very atoms that compose your body and soul.

Llewyn Davis isn’t a movie about depression; it’s a movie about what the world looks like to someone who’s depressed. Colors don’t seem to have the same vibrancy as they should, everyone is conspiring to treat you like garbage, and nothing, ever, EVER seems to go right; even in the most basic situations, there is sabotage, denigration, and ridicule. Oscar Isaac’s Llewyn is battered around New York City and Chicago, barely able to avoid living on the street because, as a folk musician, he’s an object of curiosity and occasional  spurious amusing talent for those who grant him a bed to sleep in or an avenue to play his guitar. His meager pocket change is wasted constantly on avoidable things that continually pile up and prevent him from ever actually making any headway in his dream of being a modestly successful artist. Llewyn ends the film as he begins it: wounded, huddled outside in the cold, unable to escape his own personal hell of precarious existence in Greenwich Village, doomed by his own ego and agitation at life to repeat the same mistakes again and again because he’s unwilling to stop and admit that this just won’t work out for him.

The End;

Au Revoir.

As a general rule, I’m not very generous towards myopic films. I see them, mostly, as exercises in empty cynicism; why, I ask myself, would you go to the incredible lengths that a film production takes, cast, shoot, edit, etc., after all that effort taken, just for the sake of telling a story that denies any notion of hope or progress or even the most slight of satisfactions. At that, I even believe that there’s a difference between cynical cinema and myopic cinema: a filmmaker like Stanley Kubrick makes movies that are deeply cynical about human existence, constantly poking holes in our own self-image and cultural mythology, but what keeps him from being myopic, I think, is that Kubrick refuses to treat the subjects of his films in a dehumanized fashion. Figures like Barry Lyndon or Dr. Bill Harford may be, for better or worse, the rats within Kubrick’s intricately constructed visual mazes, but Kubrick does not treat them as illegitimate people, subjects unworthy of his gaze. Rather, he wraps us within the tangled nest of their subjectivity, allows us to empathize with them as viewers, rather than condescend to them. Barry Lyndon is a dumbass, yes, but he’s also hapless, a victim of historical and social processes that we are all victimized by. His story, the story Kubrick wants to communicate, is a universal one, a story based on empathy and humanity, if with a comic and sardonic twist.

But a myopic cinema, by definition, has contempt for its subject matter, designs the filmcraft around the perceived ineptitude and irrelevance of what it fixes its gaze upon; to a paradoxical degree, these types of films are very pointless in their articulation of pointlessness. Why put a narrative subject under the camera if you have nothing but contempt and scorn for it? If it was truly irrelevant, it wouldn’t be the focus of a film or any artistic piece to begin with; the sheer idea of singling it out makes it, despite the efforts and intentions of the filmmakers, into an object of interest, if not fascination. Myopic cinema forecloses itself in its own conceptual absurdity, going to such lengths to show why something doesn’t matter, but still, at the end of the day, SHOWING the damn thing, and thus making it a matter of contemplation regardless of authorial perspective.

With such a dark and circular story about a guy who seemingly will never remain un-fucked by the world he lives in, I asked myself if the Coen Brothers made Inside Llewyn Davis in the cynical mode, or the myopic. If the film never allows Llewyn to break out of the circumstances that he loops around within like a Mobius Strip, if it truly commits to the depression, the hopeless futility of any and all desires and actions on his part, than I immediately condemn it, disparage it, and have no desire on my part to take it as anything but a nihilistic exercise.

On the contrary, however, I don’t think that’s the case; Inside Llewyn Davis just barely skirts past the totalizing frame of depression, circles around it precariously like a high-wire circus act, all due, in my estimation, to one factor: the ending repeats the beginning of the film almost verbatim, save for Llewyn choosing to play a song that he last played with his former stage partner, Mikey, now lost to suicide. He plays the hell out of it, going from trying to avoid addressing Mikey’s existence throughout most of the film, to just winging it, ending his set by simply saying “That’s what I got.”

Because, regardless of what happens in the film, even if Llewyn is trapped in a perpetual cycle of disappointment that he struggles constantly against, he’s still got something, he’s still got his guitar, his songs, and the memories of Mikey. He might be put through the wringer tomorrow morning, the same old story that he’s used to, but he maintains his internal desire to try and try, try because the music that he and Mikey played was worth something, something personal, and if it doesn’t get him anywhere, doesn’t provide him any meaningful financial success, then the world’s all the poorer for it. Inside, he’s still who he is, he still values his own life. As someone who’s been on the same receiving end of that rough world, sometimes it’s what’s on the inside that you have to hold onto the most. If you don’t let the depression break that, then you can live through anything, even your own failure.

(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.