Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hard to believe that Spike Lee’s Bamboozled was released at the turn of the century, because it feels so intensely about the contemporary moment that we should consider why that may be: why do we, 22 years later after its release, still live in an ‘ironic’ culture where the creative process behind Bamboozled’s ‘Mantan: The New Millennium Minstrel Show’ could still somehow take place?

We don’t want to think that, of course. Coming out of the 2010s, we’d like to think that displays of ‘ironic’ racism have been exorcised from American mass media, that you Just Can’t Get Away With This Stuff Anymore™, because we have more diverse voices in writers rooms, more consultants on projects, more ‘accountability’ via social media scandals; that, in short, we’ve moved ‘beyond’ Spike Lee’s indictments about how supposedly ‘well-meaning’ and ‘self-aware’ people in the American entertainment industry could still perpetuate such a fucking abysmal attitude towards historical portrayals of black Americans. We’d like to think that.

And yet.

To look at Bamboozled and say “Oh, this would never happen!” or “This is fine satire, sure, but that was then, and this is now.” is to entirely miss the point, I feel. The revival minstrel show within the film isn’t a statement about how minstrel shows could verbatim be replicated today exactly as they were, because that’s to abstract it from a dialectical historical process that never says the same thing twice. But there are Echos; there is unrecognized damage, there is unaware and unseen stereotyping that, of course, still exists to this day.

The category of the minstrel show, as grotesque as it may be, was seen by its white audiences as ‘wholesome’ family entertainment, physical comedy and vulgar gags done by white actors who ‘ironically’ created their own exaggerated image of blackness, which was then seen for decades onward as a stereotype that actual black performers and figures were expected to replicate; the grotesque parody had become the ‘reality’ that white American mass media had accepted. The stammering, the imagery of watermelon and chicken and red lips, which was all deliberately designed by racists in a post-Civil War country to be an ‘ironic’-yet-denigrating portrayal of black people, then became ‘unironic’; this process still happens to this day with a whole spectrum of minorities and disadvantaged populaces. The tropes of the ‘Black Best Friend’, the ‘Gay Best Friend’, the ‘Spunky Asian Girl With Dyed Hair’, the ‘Lipstick Lesbian’, the ‘Neurotic Jewish Person’, the ‘Meek and Passive Trans Woman’; we can all recognize these cliché types of characters, and they didn’t just emerge out of a vacuum. They were constructed and built in an ‘ironic’ reflection of someone’s experience, then magnified to represent an entire subset of people over and over again, and even though we live in a time were these stereotypes are supposed to be challenged by ‘diverse creatives’, I still see them pop up time and time again.

Why?

For one, they’re crutches, crutches for writers and directors who desire a simple storytelling shorthand. Why create a complex and nuanced character if you can, in a simple act of racial, sexual and gender profiling, simply rely on the ol’ standbys? Because it’s what the audience supposedly understands. Because it’s supposedly something they won’t care about, something invisible:

‘Hey, we’re not saying that black men are BAD when we use the Black Best Friend stereotype, they’re being a positive force in the story! They’re supportive! They tell jokes! The audience likes them!’

And that’s such bullshit. The cartoonish buffoonery of characters in minstrel shows was meant to ‘entertain’, was meant to have a ‘positive’ effect on the viewers, just like any entertainment. They sought out their own negative version of black people, painted over their white faces to do it, and then taught people to understand that as how actual black Americans behaved, and that expectation replicated itself like a virus until you had actual black actors basically doing the blackface act because it was what was ‘expected’; the same phenomenon occurs with any of these, no matter how initially ‘harmless’ they may seem at first. In Bamboozled, we see black men who are forced to use their talents as street performers to then ‘ironically’ do a minstrel show, but this isn’t crazy, this isn’t unreality, this is what actually happened. They were expected to regurgitate the notions of their oppressors because it was the only way to get work and survive; Spike Lee is being an extreme realist here, the bombast is exactly as ridiculous as it should be seen in the contemporary moment.

The call for diverse casting, diverse voices in entertainment, these aren’t bad notions in themselves. But unless you have a creative like Spike Lee or Jordan Peele firmly in the driver’s seat, you aren’t likely to see something that much different from what happened with these minstrel shows. Perhaps not as harmful, but definitely still as pernicious. Film and television are all-to-eager to trade in character stereotypes in the same way they love logos, love brands and franchises and intellectual property. Because that’s really what the minstrel show was: a marketing of a false brand of blackness, reducing the complex world of lived experience to something made by the perspective of someone not of that experience at all, and likely hostile to the people with that experience. The Pepsi Logo is not the same as the Pepsi soda, the map is obviously not the territory.

But we keep falling for this trap that Bamboozled is at pains to bring to our attention. As long as American mass entertainment looks at black people as both a market force and a commodity to be traded, these stereotypes will never truly leave us. They’ll change forms, become less ‘negative’, but this attitude of irony nevertheless remains, the idea that you can divorce yourself from your actions and assumptions by ‘intentionally’ doing it. But there is no ‘transcending’ this; intention only matters to the extent that you’re willing to affirm an easy harm rather than confront a difficult truth. Because no one can get inside your head, and for the people on the outside, ‘ironic racism’ still looks a hell of a lot like actual racism, and in practice, it’s just as racist. Irony as a political gesture in-itself leads to passivity, complacency, and the acceptance to a litany of everyday horrors. If indulged to the absurd degree that American culture has, irony eats away your capacity to recognize right from wrong, destroys your sense of agency. It’s why Bamboozled is as grounded of a satire as you can possibly get, bordering on documentary. It isn’t that this ‘could happen today’; it does happen today. It does, constantly.

What the hell is wrong with us?



(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.