Towards a Definition of Noir (Patreon)
Content
Been trying to figure out the essence of noir; it’s an elliptical task, maybe fruitless. It’s not the setting, it’s not the shadows, it’s not strictly a mode of production, a subject matter, or an auteurist intention. Perhaps it’s an impulse towards a tradition instead of a tradition itself, the idea of noir as an approach, a philosophic/sociological stance towards storytelling, not just a single type of story being told. The western is characterized by the sparseness in which it handles its environment, the melodrama is defined by the cadence of its characterization, and the action film is sold on the schematic structure of setpiece sequences, but noir is, perhaps tellingly, more elusive by nature. There are noirs without crime taking place, noirs without expressionist shadows, noirs without mysteries, noirs without death, noirs without detectives or femme fatales or rain-slick streets or fog or snub-nosed guns.

What, then, is the essential bedrock quality of noir, once stripped of all its particular cliches and stylistic signifiers? A comedy film has to be comedic, a war film has to feature mass conflict in some fashion, so what must take place in a noir that isn’t simply a prerequisite for a film to be classified as a crime film, or a gangster film, or a mystery? Michael Mann’s 1995 heist-opus Heat is obviously a crime film, but I wouldn’t call it a noir in the way that 1981’s Thief is a neo-noir. Heat is a massive ensemble cast spread across a long movie about a large city, an epic about two men’s personal and professional lives becoming entangled in their conflict with each other; Thief is a character study about a loner ex-con who wants to buy his way into bourgeois comforts by leveraging his talents for the wrong people. The budget and scope of the two is a clear difference, but I don’t think that’s as much to do with the noir-ness of either as it may seem, because Thief would still be a neo-noir if it was a much more lavishly produced film, because the story would remain the same. Does this point us towards the fact that noirs have to be atomistic character studies? I wouldn’t say that; there are plenty of noirs that shift perspectives between characters, or encourage us to have sympathies for more than just the protagonist. I think it has more to do with the arrangement of elements within a story: in Heat, every part of the story is explicated by another part, there’s a clear connection between how and why things occur because the narrative is wide enough to show us a complex causal relationship between all the characters. It makes sense why things occur, it’s a rationalist movie at its core. When the two main characters have their fatal confrontation at the end, there’s no misunderstanding as to why this had to happen, it’s a natural outcome of their choices and beliefs. But in Thief, there’s a sense in which the irrational is at the heart of the story, despite Mann’s personal proclivities. When Robert Prosky’s crime boss Leo screws over James Caan’s Frank by investing his score money into shopping malls instead of directly giving it to him after the job is completed, and also after Frank repeatedly established how he expects to work and expects to be treated, the spectre of absolutism enters into the picture. Leo proceeds to drop the facade of being a genial father figure to Frank and lectures him about how everything in Frank’s life belongs to Leo and that Leo will essentially work Frank to his death, and that Frank ultimately has no control or meaningful input into his job. While watching, we wonder if this was Leo’s plan all along, or if he only felt he had to become this looming tyrant over Frank because of Frank’s insubordination to the overall scheme. When the Vincent vs. Neil conflict plays out in Heat, we’re entirely aware of the two men’s personal standards and why they’re doing what they’re doing, but Leo remains an enigma in the context of Thief even after his death at the hands of Frank. Frank destroys his entire life in order to destroy Leo’s control over him, and we think that Frank understands this to be the requisite price for foolishly trusting Leo in the first place, but really we have no reason to think that Leo is such an asshole until he reveals himself to be, so that when it happens in the film, we feel like all of what had happened is a case of a life Frank coveted which was always too good to ever be true. It’s a bitterness to the story, not just a tragedy; the feeling that if someone like Frank begins to make real connections with other people, he will inevitably be faced with loss and regret the likes of which he cannot accommodate in his spartan ethical framework. It’s the enigma that’s dangerous, the inherent impossibility of being able to fully trust someone without knowing if you’ll be hurt by that trust or not, the leap of faith it takes to be more than an alienated loner which Frank is able to be but clearly isn’t happy with.

Could that be the essence of noir? Enigma? The distance between ourselves and our objects of knowledge and perception? When I was originally going through Howard Hawks’ filmography a couple years back, a film like The Big Sleep was somewhat an enigma to me in the context of his oeuvre, as it isn’t one of his adventure/western films featuring a group of individuals tasked with confronting an existential threat, and it isn’t one of his comedies which plays with gender roles and ridicules the white collar professionalism of scientists, specialists and academics; those two types of films can basically describe all of Hawks. But him making a straight-up detective story? It’s a strange work, and even Robin Wood’s book-length study on Hawks doesn’t seem to know what to do with it, so he relegates it to a failed experiment. Hawks doesn’t give a fuck about plots, not really, as he pays much more attention to the gestures and behavioral ticks of his characters, and The Big Sleep is infamous for being nigh-incomprehensible for trying to figure out what actually happens, why it happens, who it’s being done to, and how it’s all going to shake out. But all of that’s a question; perhaps that’s the key. Why, how, where, what, who, the asking’s the thing. A film like The Big Sleep doesn’t really provide clean answers for any of that; we could chalk that up to the heavy reshoots that the film underwent in 1945 in order to capitalize on the success of Bogart and Bacall’s burgeoning on-set relationship and eventual love, but even Raymond Chandler, the author of the book that the film is based on, couldn’t exactly recall who did what to whom and why all of this killing and intrigue, so clearly there’s an immanent confusion to the film’s text that was only then made more byzantine by those reshoots. The Big Sleep doesn’t stop to explain any of its events; we’re with Bogart as he’s trying to figure it all out, his teeth gritted as he bounces around Los Angeles and lectures all the suspicious characters on his theories of what’s really going on and the motivations therein. They remain theories, though, because the film stages so many of its important events out-of-sight; we’re wedded to Bogart’s psychological encounter with these events, rarely if ever leaving his side during the whole affair, so when he doesn’t see someone getting killed, doesn’t see the body being hidden, isn’t there for the car crashes and conversations behind closed doors, we’re left in the dark as much as he is! So much of The Big Sleep’s plot is kept away from our view, so when he offers these theories in a half-conspiratorial tone, we’re trying to pick up the pieces as well; it’s a true mystery, because there’s no authenticating apparatus in the film’s story designed to tell us what’s real or fake. In several crime stories or mysteries, there will be an Agatha Christie-esque authority figure who will state explicitly in the dialogue how everything went down and why it did, it’s the author literally exerting themselves into clearing up the cobwebs that they’ve laid down and showing you how the sausage is made, letting us in on the joke by making the implicit fragments into an explicit whole, reminiscent of how Shakespeare deploys the trickster-figure of Puck at the end of A Midsummer Night’s Dream who breaks the fourth wall and gives the audience permission to disavow the spurious contents of the play as a mere ‘dream’ if it suits their fancy. The removal of such a figure from The Big Sleep is like Leo’s betrayal in Thief, as it destroys this paternal authority in the context of the film and leaves us adrift as to the overarching purpose behind the storytelling mechanics we’ve thus far taken for granted.

Perhaps this vanishing author is a conceit that opens the gateway to noir. If Hawks, Chandler, and Puck are willing to deliberately orchestrate the events we see in a noir story, but then explicitly open up those events to our own interpretation in a display of playful renunciation, is the essence of noir to create a space of play? The rules and symbolic expression of a game are a pretense that is accepted by the players in order to allow the emergence of an alternate state of reality in which certain possibilities are allowed and others are not, but games typically have a win state which serves as a conclusion to the events they contain. If noir’s denial of such an absolutist conclusion is a central characteristic of its genre, then we leave behind the brackets of the game-space and enter into the field of pure play in which elements and rules change on the fly and the reality of the space is subject to arbitrary change at the drop of a hat. Noir is noted for being able to have both a documentary-style hard-nosed realist style, as well as evoking a hyper-exaggerated expressionist nightmare world, and it might seem difficult to reconcile the two presentations within the single space of ‘noir’, but they’re actually quite complementary. A director like Michael Mann makes very deterministic films that operate on a tight logic of a person’s behavior creating their fate, but when he’s operating in noir mode like in Thief, that strictness inverts into its opposite, where Frank more than abides by his own internal code to the extent that he destroys his own life as soon as he builds it. When we see him blow-up his car dealership, home, and bar, the film shifts from detailed verisimilitude to an ultra-stylish slow-motion inferno that basks in the cold catharsis of self-destruction. The noir world is characterized by this instability, the idea that the world is governed by a certain type of fate, but a fate that remains radically opaque to us precisely because it openly flaunts its status as a fictional construct. Frank builds his life from a cobbled-together postcard collage, a dream that he wants to inhabit but is unable to make the ethical compromises necessary to immerse himself fully into it. The Big Sleep contains loads of corpses and killers, but never together in the same space, and the only person we actually see violently murder someone is Humphrey Bogart’s Philip Marlowe, who is supposedly the ‘good guy’ of his story. There’s a disconnect between intention and manifestation, between feeling and relation, between mind and body, between dream and wakefulness, but noir traverses back-and-forth across this disconnect, leap-frogging from one to the other and laughing at our attempts to fully identify them in a causal relationship.

Noir is the enigma, it is the nightmare, it is the presence of absence, the awareness of a lack. It’s not just that the shadows stretch on for miles, it’s the smoke that breaks up the clearness of vision the almost-seeing of an imaginal object. Noir is perhaps one of the most cinematic genres precisely because it’s very concerned with what is shown and what is not shown, how film language can communicate truth and lies and confusion and ambiguity all with the same palette of light and darkness, the spectrum of existence itself being played with at 24 frames-per-second.