Rebel-Rouser (Patreon)
Content
I had an image in my mind of Nicholas Ray’s Rebel Without a Cause years before I ever saw it. In the pop culture lexicon, it’s synonymous with being one of the first Hollywood films to tackle youth culture in America from the perspective of teenagers themselves… but what that meant for me as a teenager was a kind of tough-talking, smart-alec rebellion that gave the finger to all the square adults of the world and embodied the cool nihilism of being young and directionless. In my head, James Dean was supposed to represent coolness, seeing that picture of him in the red leather jacket, his lips caught in the middle between a pout and a smolder, going around beating up those who deserved it without a care in the world; didn’t matter if it was the actor or his character, it was all the same to me. He lived fast, died young, and became a distant legend of an era I really had no relation to outside of 50s monster films. I had married the drag-strip racing greaser culture with a sort of pre-60s youth revolt against American institutions, that’s what this movie was to me.

And like so many incredibly famous movies, such as Casablanca, King Kong, etc., you have this personal image based on its iconography and reputation, and you feel like that image is identical with the film itself, and that you don’t really need to see the film itself, because you already know it, right?
Until you actually sit down and watch the damn thing, and realize that all of that is horseshit.
For one, it’s not really about ‘rebellion’ at all. Dean’s character, Jim Stark, is a very sensitive and reasonable person, and goes out of his way, even while drunk, to try and state his feelings as clearly as he can. When he gets taken to a police station, he doesn’t flail around in a fit of anger, and when he’s confronted with the violence of a teenage gang trying to egg him on, he tries repeatedly to back off and deescalate the situation. Jim isn’t a guy trying to pick any fights, and the only fights he gets into are ones with his incompetent parents when they refuse to treat him as a real person. That ‘rebellion’ against Mom and Pop is more than justified from the film’s perspective; they don’t really know their son at all. A tagline on one of the posters for Rebel Without a Cause has it totally backwards: “THE BAD BOY FROM A GOOD FAMILY”; I mean, are you kidding? His mother is an over-medicated tyrant and his father is a weak-willed sycophant, it’s a wonder that Jim became as decent as he is. It’s as if the movie’s reputation that I had learned was from the film’s marketing’s perspective, which is the perspective of his parents: James Dean is playing an ignominious son who is ‘without a cause’, but he actually has a ton of ‘cause’ in this movie for the situations he gets into, and he isn’t really responsible for that much harm.
Maybe that was the entire point, to set us up with a series of expectations going into the movie only to undermine them, but I really wasn’t prepared for how Rebel Without a Cause presents Jim with such magnanimity and understanding. It’s fascinating to see the concept of teenage identity emerge in the post-WW2 American consciousness; between this and Imitation of Life and The 400 Blows in the years soon after, we see young people in films not being treated like one-note characters who only exist to actualize the arcs of the older stars, and they aren’t cutesy comedians like Shirley Temple either. Adolescent struggles with trying to fit in and find your place in the world are now seen as worthy cinematic subjects, not the stuff of PSAs and cheap B-movie exploitation. To watch Rebel Without a Cause in 2022 entails a bit of irony, because this film about teenagers has the emotional maturity of any adult melodrama, whereas most films made by Hollywood today are written for a teenage mindset, even the films supposedly geared towards adults.
This is the first film I’ve seen by Nicholas Ray, who I’ve also only heard about second-hand from the adoring praise of the Cahiers du Cinema crowd and Martin Scorsese. Judging from this film alone, he’s easily an amazing stylist with Cinemascope, all his compositions are so dynamic and jarring that you can’t help but be involved with the story because of the sheer force with which it’s presented; lots of high-angle and low-angle shots, making this intimate story of a group of kids feel enormously important. The eye-popping color was something I also noticed, with Ray dressing his main characters in bright, primary colors while everything around them has a more naturalistic look to it. The contrast of locations and studio sets is also an important piece of this; the interiors are always claustrophobic, often featuring stairways that the characters are caught in, while the exteriors are shot in natural locales around Los Angeles, with the Griffith Observatory taking center-stage as the film’s miniature cosmological terminus. The the eternal ‘meaninglessness’ of a galactic perspective is contrasted with the over-determined drama of Jim and his classmates, and we have a doubling of setting and tone, where the feelings of teens take on an epic proportion in the tradition of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet.

That’s what I responded to most in Rebel: that feeling you get as a teenager that all of your life can and will change over the course of one night, that the world is nothing but untapped potential and that’s both scary and exhilarating. When Jim and his newly-found friends frolic in an abandoned mansion in the hills of L.A., I immediately recognized that set as being the same mansion from Billy Wilder’s Sunset Boulevard. This meta-textual bit is the whole film, to me: a bunch of lost kids, playing house in the hollow ruins of a once-important starlet, their gigantic emotions filling in the empty space of years gone by, the union of atomic age vigor and a suburban gothic decay.

I first heard of James Dean and this movie while excitedly reading the Marvel comic Runaways in the 2000s; it’s about a group of Los Angeles teenagers who discover that all their parents are ultra-nefarious super-villains, and decide to get the hell out of dodge and fight against them. There’s multiple references to Rebel Without a Cause in that first story arc, from the observatory to a crumbling mansion that the group of kids find shelter in, and it ends with a quote from this movie that will always stick with me, as the Runaways escape together into an uncertain future; they don’t know where they’re going, but they have each other. It’s a rebellion against the idea that the future is set for us, a reminder that the moment is all we’ll ever truly have:
“I never thought I’d live to see eighteen . . .
Isn’t that dumb? Every day, I look in the mirror and say ‘What? You’re still here? Man!’
Like, even today, I woke up this morning, you know? And the sun was shining and everything was nice, and I thought . . .
. . . This is going to be one terrific day, so you better live it up boy!
Because tomorrow, maybe you’ll be gone . . .”

Once upon a time, I never thought I'd live to see eighteen either. But I did, and I also got to see this movie a while after the darkest period of my life was over. James Dean didn't have that luxury... but in this movie, he'll always have his immortal moment.

(Requested by Freddy, a Patreon. Thanks Freddy!)