Bad Luck Charm; Thoughts Towards Metal Gear Solid 2 (Patreon)
Content
I normally don’t write about videogames for three reasons:
1. I don’t play much of them these days because my time is entirely taken up by movies and books. One can only have so many hobbies, unfortunately.
2. I don’t have the critical/systemic knowledge of their craft in the way that I somewhat do with film and literature.
3. I like a great deal of them, but they’re difficult to write about as a very young artform, as they haven’t had many decades of serious critical engagement. The term ‘video game journalist’ has been a hotly contested one since 2014, and as far as I understand in 2022, the most thourough game analysis mostly takes place in the bowels of the YouTube video essay machine, where hours-long videos seem to be an emerging form of discourse in-and-of themselves.
This makes writing about Metal Gear Solid 2, my favorite game ever, a difficult prospect. Whenever I approach videogames, I would prefer to do it from the perspective of their own form, and not treat them as extensions of movies . . . yet, Metal Gear Solid as a series, and especially 2, are perhaps the most cinematic games to ever exist. Groundbreaking for the time, featuring in-engine cutscenes that often respond to the player’s actions, Metal Gear’s visual grandiosity is due to series-creator Hideo Kojima’s own cinephilia, and one could easily see a world where he is his own director in the Japanese film industry; but only the virtual space of videogames could let him get away with rendering the otherwise-costly spectacle that he’s clearly interested in.

So can we talk about Metal Gear Solid 2 as a cinematic object? In a way that misses the forest for the trees, yes. I could write all-about the intricate game world that MGS2 has via sheer description, but the problem lies that videogames can only really be understood by someone actually playing them, the same way that a movie remains nothing without the tactile viewing experience. There have already been a number of great analyses of the game from a formal and thematic perspective; see DTS and Junker HQ’s articles that came out soon after MGS2 was still a contested sequel in the 2000s rather than the classic that it is now:
https://www.deltaheadtranslation.com/MGS2/
Instead of trying to grasp the whole of the game, which would be far beyond the scope of one essay, I’d rather write about one particular facet of the game and see if I can reach a core thematic strut of Metal Gear as a whole, and there’s one aspect that’s always stuck with me ever since I was a kid: the character of Fortune.

The game immediately presents her as perhaps Kojima’s most melodramatic and tragic character, accompanied by a Lethal Weapon-esque smooth jazz theme; due to Solid Snake being falsely accused of having killed her father in a covert anti-Metal Gear mission earlier in the game, Fortune’s entire life falls apart, with her husband and mother both killing themselves soon after, and Fortune herself suffering a miscarriage. She channeled all this grief into joining the Navy’s anti-terrorist taskforce Dead Cell, which her father was the former leader of, because she sought revenge against Solid Snake, and her meteoric rise through these ranks was due to her miraculous ability to somehow be missed by every bullet intended to kill her, thus her code-name within Dead Cell of ‘Lady Luck’. She, an overweight cocktail-sipping mad bomber named Fatman, and an apparently-immortal knife-thrower (and occasional lover of Fortune) named ‘Vamp’, team-up with the actual paramilitary murderers of Fortune’s father to take the President of the United States hostage in an environmental clean-up facility off the coast of Manhattan.
(Side Note: For anyone reading that above passage who isn’t versed in Kojima-speak, I don’t blame them. When you write about the story details of these games, one can come across as a complete lunatic, because Metal Gear is such an information-dense saga that somehow weaves together political conspiracy, supernatural powers, cybernetic soldiers, clones, homoeroticism, and fart jokes. The encyclopedic nature of these games is emphasized by MGS2 and its sequels after it actually having in-game novellas and Wikipedia-esque infodumps, not to mention all the invisible visual references that connect various characters to each other even though they’ve never met. I love these games, but it would take at least a thousand-page book to begin to sort out a schematic map of everything that goes on in here.)
All that aside, it’s the final minutes of her character arc that are the most compelling to me; after a whole game of bemoaning her existence, where it’s obvious that Fortune is completely distraught at her state in life and wishes for someone to kill her despite her ‘luck’, the actual murderer of her father, a man named Revolver Ocelot (who is maybe the most complicated character in all of human narrative art) reveals a terrible truth to her: her apparent ‘fortune’ on the battlefield was engineered by an apparently-ancient conspiracy, via a technological device on her person, in order to take advantage of her grief and use her as a pawn in their grander plans, which Ocelot is also-apparently a part of. Her inability to be hit by bullets and other projectiles was a manufactured defense that they deluded her into thinking was an inherent supernatural talent caused by the sheer magnitude of the suffering she experienced:
Ocelot: “Do you know why no bullet could hit you? It wasn't magic or some New Age mumbo-jumbo. Certainly wasn't your psychic talents. It was all staged by the Patriots.”
Fortune: “Staged?”
Ocelot: “You were being shielded by the electromagnetic weapons technology that the Patriots developed. Your Dead Cell comrades loved your father and husband -- we needed a pathetic wretch like you to keep them focused. You've been our puppet all along . . . You were hamming it up as the tragic heroine thanks to the script that the Patriots wrote for you. Pure self-indulgence – you couldn't get enough of the drama.”
Fortune: “ . . . I could have died whenever I wanted to . . . ”
And later:
Ocelot: “This is the little gizmo. There’s no such thing as miracles or the supernatural. Just cutting-edge technology.”

Ocelot deactivates the device protecting her, and shoots her, making a non-lethal wound. As he’s about to fire a whole payload of missiles at everyone, Fortune gets up and holds out her hands. The missiles fire, and all of them deflect past her and the intended targets, flying off just like the projectiles did before. She then dies, ruminating on finally being able to be with her family again.
What does this mean? Was Ocelot lying? Obviously not, because he was able to shoot her, and he uses that device to latter shield himself from bullets, so it’s a real thing that works. But Fortune is still able to deflect the missiles – so she does actually have real psychick powers, powers that were perhaps augmented/supplanted by the device.
In the larger context of the series, this matters a lot, and also matters to me personally. From the first chronological entry, Metal Gear Solid 3, to the last one, Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, we see a clear thematic progression, from a world inundated with people endowed with supernatural powers and mystical appearances (MGS3’s entire Cobra Unit, MGS1’s Vulcan Raven and Psycho Mantis, MGS2’s Fortune) to a world completely dominated by technological augmentation and dehumanization (MGS4’s SOP system, Metal Gear Rising’s cyber-mercenary war economy). There’s echoes of a classic motif in westerns and fantasy films, a quasi-Arthurian legacy, where reality began as a raw field of chaotic potential and magick, and after a certain passage of time, transformed into a mundane and banal existence ruled by mechanistic logic and systems of control.
In terms of Kojima’s own cinephilia, this ‘end of an era’ theme is shared by works like The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, Seven Samurai, Once Upon a Time in The West, The Wild Bunch, and so on, which are all films with a mythic dimension to them. I have never seen someone else talk about this in regards to Kojima, but it’s plain-as-day to me as a real undercurrent of the overarching story he’s trying to tell in the Metal Gear games, and Fortune is the most important piece of this: she’s the last character in the series that is legitimately supernatural. After this game, Vamp, who was presumed to be, y’know, an actual vampire, gets his abilities explained-away as being products of nanomachines, and the games increasingly become about a vanishing humanity in a world where human life is disposable and quantified by technological authority. Fortune exists at this breaking point, where the machine and magick cross-paths, and it’s no coincidence that her reflecting these missiles leads right into Ocelot soon being distracted enough to be possessed again by the ghost of Liquid Snake via his transplanted arm, if only for a moment. It’s as if her hyper-tragic story is the final gasp of a nearly-dead spirit which had pervaded the series until then; after this, in Metal Gear, there’s nothing but ghosts in the machine, echoes of a part of the human experience which no longer has a place in the world of regimented cyborg soldiers and war as a routine and planned economic exercise.

A lot is made of MGS2’s statements on legacy, memetics, selfhood, and the digital revolution that is now a daily reality for all of us, but it’s not only concerned with the cutting-edge; it also cares about what’s left behind in the pre-digital era, the idea of a person’s individual right to their own story. Fortune thought she owned her own trauma, that her life had a logic of decay and tragedy to it, that she wanted death above all else but wasn’t able to have it and that there was a sort of romantic intoxication to that, a fairy-tale morality that made it seem like there was some sense of divine agency in a life lived with such pain. Ocelot tries to take that away from her, and she does get the death she desires, but we’re also left with a quality that exceeds her death, the feeling that even in a supposedly-mechanistic universe, there’s a transcendental quintessence that exceeds all causal expectations and materialisms, a nobility in believing your own story hard enough to where it becomes your reality, even if for only a second. The realness of Fortune’s emotions couldn’t be taken from her, even if the source of them was false; the fact that she felt them is enough, her tragedy is able to eclipse the forces of control in a way that they will never understand. There is something that always escapes.
(Requested by Brice Lee, a Patron. Thanks Brice!)