Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The history of Hollywood is littered with Perfect Objects – films which are so popular, so redefining, so epochal, so gigantic, that they seem to transcend cinema as a medium and enter into the casual lexicon of everyday life – such films as The Wizard of Oz, Gone With The Wind, Casablanca, Singing in The Rain, Psycho, Star Wars, Jaws, Halloween, Titanic – and The Sound of Music. With these Perfect Objects, you most likely will have been exposed to references or parodies to them before you’ve ever actually seen the films themselves, which are afforded the lofty status of perennial classics and cultural benchmarks that even the most clueless of non-cineastes will be familiar with.

But where does that leave the cineaste? We can scoff and deny the merits of these sorts of films for one reason or another – Casablanca was a journeyman’s test-run for To Have And Have Not, Star Wars is a ritzed-up Columbia serial, and so on – but I think the relationship that cinema itself has to these Perfect Objects is more nuanced than unanimous praise or dismissal.

Consider The Sound of Music – produced at the perilous apex of the big-budget musical at the end of the studio system, filmed with impressive scope on the real glorious hills of Austria and the Swiss Alps, a light-hearted family picture which ends with the political gravitas of Nazism and WW2, winner of numerous Academy Awards, and a musical where almost every single song has become a pop culture staple. How can one have anything but respect and acclaim for such a movie? Yet upon further inspection, the seams begin to show – the Sixteen-Going-On-Seventeen dance in the rainy pagoda is a G-rated imitation of Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire’s lusty pagoda waltz in 1935’s Top Hat, and the picture-perfect family drama of early 20thcentury nostalgia-across-time is a less woozy version of Minnelli’s seminal Meet Me In St. Louis.

And that’s not even getting into the unavoidable comparisons to Mary Poppins, also staring the cold-yet-charming Julie Andrews. As a die-hard Disney cynic, even I find Poppins to be an irresistible production, its colorful bravura and bittersweet undertone are as stupendous as one can ask for, and The Sound of Music feels like a direct response to that work in several ways – instead of a stern-yet-wise nanny arriving to bring wonder to an Edwardian dysfunctional family as in Poppins, we have an energetic-yet-virtuous governess arriving to bring wonder to an Austrian dysfunctional family. Mary Poppins is more focused on the children’s perspective, while The Sound of Music uses the children as a way for Christopher Plummer’s tyrannical Georg von Trapp to lighten up and for the family to have the camaraderie and strength to face the oncoming fascist take-over of Austria.

Yet the essential similarities here belie how the differences make one film into a still lively and vivacious experience, while the other continues to exist in perpetuity as a monumental-yet-distant Perfect Object – Mary Poppins ends with a delicate touch of sadness, as her job to reform the family is complete and she has no longer any need to be there, so she drifts off with her trademark umbrella, supposedly to find another family to help in the same way. There’s a tender reflective moment on her part, a bitter realization that Poppins herself, while being able to help so many children and parents, doesn’t have a family of her own, lacks a stable center of her life, and is entirely a creature of mythical service towards whoever may be in need of her skills as a nanny. Throughout the film, she’s been the one exception to the otherwise domestic milieu – the children have complex feelings, the father struggles with his job at the bank, while Poppins almost comes across as a flat, archetypal character. But this ending forces us to reckon with Poppins’ own subjectivity – the idea that even a semi-supernatural woman of many miracles and beauties like herself has a sense of the melancholy of her own existence, the all-wise nanny brings a sorrow with her wisdom. She helps the children to actualize their father’s own life, and so the father then realizes what he’s been missing out on with his kids. It’s a film for children that asks them to recognize that everyone, no matter how strange or off-putting they may seem at first, has an internal sense of self that must be respected and ideally understood – Mary Poppins, in its own way, is a film about empathy.

The Sound of Music, inversely, is a film which pretends to be about something for the adults in the audience. The film was based upon the real memoirs of an Austrian family, but the Robert Wise musical relegates this to the last third of its three hours – one gets the feeling that the directors and producers, worried that all the saccharine singing and beauty might be ‘too much’ for American audiences, decided to inject the political weight of the Nazis in the last scenes of the film so that one walks away thinking ‘Wow, that really had something to say!’, when in actuality, the final 30 minutes or so feel artificially dour and toothless – the memoirs are one thing, but does the rest of this movie even belong in a world where Nazis took over the real Austria? Does the ‘My Favorite Things’ number mean that much more in retrospect when one understands where the plot is headed?

The critical issue I find with musicals of the 60s is that it’s not enough for them to be beautiful and well-directed – which The Sound of Music is – but that they also have to inject this idea that the musical, as a genre, can only be valid if it concerns itself with Big Ideas or Meaningful Topics. Take Busby Berkeley’s Gold Diggers of 1933 – a musical in which the Great Depression is incorporated into every single part of the production, from the drama to the songs to the camerawork to the staging. The film isn’t ‘about’ the Depression – it IS the Depression. There’s no extraneous effort made to inject a sense of importance to the proceedings – it just knows what it wants to do, then does it. When Gold Diggers opens with ‘We’re In the Money’, then cutting off the number because the characters cannot afford to stage it any longer, there is no separation between the style and subject of the film. Compare that to the Sound of Music, where none of the songs are about anything really except for one’s personal feelings, the joys of romance, and pretty flowers – there’s nothing inherently wrong about songs being about those things, but what does any of that have to do with the fascist invasion of Austria?

One could easily say, ‘Well Yui, the songs may be about positive feelings, but doesn’t that make the contrast with the Nazis that much more apparent? They invade this land of beauty and happy singing, they represent everything that is against the simplicity of the songs.’ I have no doubt that was some of the intent that Wise, Rogers and Hammerstein had, but the film then fails to make its events musical – the Nazi portion is non-musical drama. Wouldn’t it have been more daring for them to have a climax in which, under threat of seizure or death, the wholesome family starts singing some terrible fascist song about blood & soil, the dark inverse of the simple Austria beauty that has been championed so far, but either sings it with a note of irony that undercuts the Nazis intentions, or beings to improve another, subtly anti-fascist song which the audience begins to like more, and that populism saves them from the violence?

This question gets to the critical problem at the heart of The Sound of Music – it’s a G-rated film, and any substantial portrayal of fascism requires scenes which are not G-rated, scenes with communicate horror and dread. I’m not asking for The Sound of Music to be something it isn’t here, I love mostly what it is, but it simply does not have the thematic fortitude to handle the Nazis; it comes across as a film which postures at significance while never really signifying anything. Mary Poppins is able to have a quiet mature sadness to it without ever breaching the Disney visual identity, yet The Sound of Music’s own amazing songs and stunning landscapes are not able to fully tell the story it wishes to tell. So many Perfect Objects are made in this way – are The Wizard of Oz and Star Wars really ‘about’ anything except for themselves? The Perfect Objectivity of The Sound of Music masks its failure as a work of art – the iconography smothers emotion and stifles the imagination.



(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.