Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(This piece was originally a part of a longer article, but as it's more of a continuation of some thoughts I had after viewing The Song of Music, I thought I'd separate it out into its own thing. Enjoy!)


Recently I’ve been pondering the division between the great works of Art in the Cinema, and what are usually described as ‘The Best’ films according to the standard of Western popular culture. When the average non-cinephile watches an ‘older film’, they’re going to be watching The Wizard of Oz, Casablanca, Psycho, etc., and if they feel burdened to say that older films are generally more meritorious than newer films, they will say that these popular ones are ‘The Best Films Ever’.

But no cinephile I know, if making a top 10 of The Best, would put Psycho above Vertigo or Rear Window, or put Casablanca on there at all – maybe the Wizard of Oz, if they’re a sentimental type, but no one’s out here claiming that Victor Fleming is their favorite director (among the many hands that directed Oz). So why do these films persist in the popular consciousness and not particularly in the minds of many cinephiles, who make it their hobby/career to enjoy and evaluate films?

Because I believe there is a distinction between Beauty, and Decoration.

Let’s compare Casablanca, a paradoxically made masterpiece, with To Have And Have Not, a film later made in the quasi-mold of Casablana. The non-cinephile wisdom would be that Casablanca is the more iconic, more beloved, more recognized work than the later teaming of Hawks, Bogie, and Bacall – more iconic, to be sure. But what’s in that word, icon? Iconographic, the notion of a religious icon – is this a descriptor of quality? Is the icon of Christ’s cross inherently ‘better’ than the icon of the Hammer and Sickle? Doesn’t make much sense to think so…

Yet I believe one film exists as an Icon, and one exists as a work of Art – how? Apart from the plentiful history of adoration for Howard Hawks, the director of To Have And Have Not, we see in almost all of his work, but especially in To Have And Have Not, a distinct tone, a collection of phrases and gestures, a type of camerawork and lighting, all things that would repeat themselves across his career. THAHN has a masculine rigor to it, a film where the lead actress is the most ‘manly’ of all the characters, and is marked by a silent use of codes between characters, codes which signify respect and dignity between people – it has a world where individuals must navigate their environments through the sharing of cigarettes, the saying of the opposite of what one is feeling, the steely-yet-tender relations between two people with strong wills, Bogart and Bacall, who are able to fall in love precisely because the both of them are too weary and cynical to love anyone but another iconoclastic respecter of the silent code, a code which denotes wit more than honor, a code which allows alliances to form against systems of collective power, alliances which don’t compromise the integrity or specificity of the participants, a diverse gathering of outsiders.

It’s this diversity that Hawks trains his camera on – we are almost always looking at eye-level with the characters, they stand within a nebulous locale which serves as a noir-ish background for the events to come, but the performers always stand out from their surroundings, and react more to the actions of each other than they do with any external world. Hawks, a democratic-aristocrat, puts those who are of similar merit on the same plane of existence with each other – they sit at the same tables, share the same food and smokes, exchange visible glances, give each other nicknames, all within shots that emphasize more than one person in the space, often pairs.

In Raphael’s famous 1511 painting, ‘The School of Athens’, we see at the center a conversation between the two titans of Ancient Greek philosophy – Plato and Aristotle. Plato has his hand raised towards the sky, indicating his famous Theory of Forms, in which we and our material world are but emanations of a higher, more ideal reality; Aristotle has his palm held flat, perpendicular towards the ground, indicating his disagreement with his teacher, his own emphasis on the validity of matter, on observing the natural world and drawing conclusions from universally valid logical formula as opposed to Plato’s theoretical speculation on other worlds. 

THAHN is a work of the Aristotle of the cinema – there is no afterlife, no metaphysical world in Howard Hawks, no real idea of a God or absolute truth – there is only the contingent meeting of human beings on the same existential level, of struggling against systems and a reality which they themselves did not create – the only values are emotions expressed through physique, the material code which allows subtle communication in a crass world. THAHN ends with two lovers exiting the escalating conflict of World War 2, exiting politics, exiting danger, but above all, existing anyone but themselves – this and the endings of other Howard Hawks films tend towards future motion, if not inevitable oblivion. His characters are certainly faced with death, but they rush headlong into the danger, and Hawks ends THAHN not on moral or spiritual triumph, but the triumph of Bogart’s strength of physique and intellect – this is an animal world of men and women made equal by nature, not by civilization.

None of these strange qualities are found within Michael Curtiz’s Casablanca – which is not to say that Casablanca is without merit. It’s a charming film, loaded with amazing actors from top-to-bottom, produced at just the right time to capture the patriotic spirit of America joining the fight against the Axis Powers, and is appealing in all the ways that the expert Warner Bros. technicians could afford at the time – one leaves the film thinking that it is a story exceedingly well-told, with historically topical inflections, and with beloved stars who have become perennial American icons; in short, it’s stylish without being obtrusive to the viewer – Casablanca is perfect entertainment, the kind that Curtiz specialized in.

Yet there’s a difference in Art between Beauty and Decoration – To Have And Have Not is a work of Beauty, and Casablanca is a work of Decoration. THAHN is Beautiful because, more than simply looking good or being an interesting story, it expresses a consistent and observable worldview – the Beauty is considered here, the camerawork and editing not only ‘function’, but they also philosophize. THAHN operates on its own wavelength, distinct from other films like Casablanca in that, despite the close similarities of a plot where a romance blooms on an outpost controlled by the Vichy Regime, THAHN could not feel more different in style and approach from its predecessor. Both were made by the same studio, featuring some of the same actors, yet THAHN mulls over questions that Casablanca quickly answers. Casablanca is pretty looking, but not in a particularly memorable way – the world it creates is one without a singular thought behind it, it is concocted piece-by-piece without much rhyme or reason as to why one shot looks like this or that other than that it’s glossy and occasionally striking. Meanwhile, THAHN’s eye-level approach to direction, the left-to-right orientation of the characters, the sharing of objects and nicknames and gestures between like-minded men and women, the individualist skepticism towards all authority – this is the unspoken sub-structure of the film, and Casablanca has none of that. Bogart in Casablanca is a thorny iconoclast because that’s the way his character is written, and no one else in the film shares his personality, and the film doesn’t either – while Bogart in To Have And Have Not is the microcosmic center of the movie, the work in miniature – he reflects everything that happens around him, and vice versa. Casablanca Decorates itself smartly with random appealing odds-and-ends, without any idea as to why these choices mean anything, but To Have And Have Not embodies its Beauty, lives as an organic work of Art that contains its own rhythm and pulse.

It’s not a difference in enjoyment – I love both films – but a difference in kind; To Have And Have Not is simply on another level than Casablanca is, from an aesthetic viewpoint. One is the happy accident of a mediocre craftsman, and the other is one of an artist’s many consistent masterworks. In Decorative works of Art, the artist’s vision passively withdraws behind the accumulation of various details, and those particular elements have to make up for the fact that there is no unifying force behind them – they might be strong and interesting, but they don’t strike one as pieces of a whole. In Beautiful works of Art, one is compelled aggressively to recognize what is happening before you – Beauty is that which, once noticed, cannot be unnoticed. The Beautiful is the incursion of the Particular expression as a Universal state of Being – the totality of Howard Hawks’ filmmaking can be summarized in the way that two of his characters casually share cigarettes with each other, that’s it, that’s the core of his notion of the universe. 

This is why Eric Rohmer deemed Hawks to be the “filmmaker of Being” – the smallest parts of his films are as integral as the larger parts – Hawks, like Aristotle, doesn’t seek transcendence from this world, but rather seeks to identify and explore the boundaries of it; whether ridiculous or glorious, he doesn’t accept the hierarchies of gender, race, class, or any type of contrasted relation – the relation between any two elements in Hawks is a relation of the equality of quality, of merit and stamina. He takes the world in its entirety and asks “How can the human being be what it must be in a reality which asks nothing of it?” This is why his characters are seemingly indifferent towards life and death – they accept any event on their own terms as a matter of pragmatic philosophy and self-regard, the physical intelligence of experience.

The Beauty found in Hawks isn’t necessarily absent in Curtiz – but any individual worldview that Curtiz has is muddled and mangled, at best, and it’s difficult to tell where Warner Bros. ends and Curtiz begins – there’s practically no distinction, when there absolutely should be. Casablanca asks nothing of the viewer, doesn’t challenge them, doesn’t impose any potentially foreign notions onto its audience – which is not the task of Beauty. The presence of Beauty in a work of Art is the area in which the work of Art ends and where you begin – this area is an Aesthetic Event, which is when a work of Art forces you to learn a new language. When you are watching a Howard Hawks film, you are no longer existing in your world, but you are entering the Beautiful space that Hawks creates within his Art – this Event is  you within that space, and trying to exist inside its parameters. If you are open to recognizing Beauty, the Hawks Event will change you, give you the tools to see what he’s doing, how he’s working his craft, and to what ends – careful attention will reward you with a new language of perception, a perception of film’s capabilities as a form and how one can utilize the tools of the medium towards expressing a distinct vision.

Casablanca is a Decorative Assemblage of such Events – this is the reason why it has attained such an intense status in popular culture, while the average person could not recognize To Have And Have Not as anything but a Casablanca rip-off. This Assemblage is the general average of a time and place, the zeitgeist of an era – Casablanca embodies the spirit of the classic Hollywood studio system, which made many such generic productions, as well as the spirit of Bogart and Bergman’s younger stardom, as well as the spirit of American films made during and dealing with World War 2. There are dozens, if not hundreds, of films which exemplify these specific qualities much better than Casablanca’s Assemblage does – but Casablanca did them all at the same time, and thus becomes an Iconic stand-in, a shorthand for many traditions and productions. Is Bogart’s performance in Casablanca his best? Better than Nicholas Ray’s In a Lonely Place, or John Huston’s The Treasure of the Sierra Madre? It’s inconceivable to say – yet Casablanca, because it lacks an authorial voice, comes to represent the totality of Bogart’s career; it’s a cipher which, because it is empty, is able to house so much within its walls.

Comments

No comments found for this post.