Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In the duration of shooting my first two films over the past four months, I’ve become modestly familiar with what the actual process of zero-budget film construction entails – the limitations, the freedoms, the flexibility, the dangers, all that. Going from merely watching films to making them has made me reconsider many assumptions I’ve had about filmmaking, and accelerated my inclinations towards what I like about movies and what I do not like – and if these inclinations mean anything, hopefully my intentions will bore out in some fashion with what I’ve been able to learn through directing. In American cinema, after 100 years of the Hollywood studio system dominating the mode in which films are made, distributed, and seen, I believe we are at a point in which a new path may be forged that can serve as a counter-current to the decaying blockbuster machine. Before I elaborate on this exact path, I first need to elaborate on the conditions in which I’m making my current films, which will show why I have reached the conclusions that I now possess:

1. I have no outside funding other than my minimum wage job and the generous and gracious donors of this Patreon. I can afford very little in terms of fancy equipment; my cameras are a cheap sub-$100 digital zoom DSLR and my phone’s grainy lens, plus a standard tripod and an $8 tiny foldable tripod. I expect not to make a single profit from any of these works.

2. I can only really shoot effectively on my days off, because otherwise most of my time is spent at work, maintaining my apartment, sleeping, and watching films to write about for my donors. I am at the mercy of the weather, and given the tempestuous nature of Chicagoland temperatures, it was sometimes freezing or raining while shooting. I am paranoid about being arrested for trespassing or loitering or accidentally having me or my camera hit by a car.

3. I use the free editing/colorgrading software VideoProc Vlogger, which is the best that I could find so far in terms of what I need.

4. I have no crew except for myself, and no actors. I commission musical scores from my friends on Twitter, and personally make the poster art/iconography for the films in GIMP. There is no reason for the film not being completed and shown except for either me not having the footage I need or me waiting for the score to be finalized.

From these conditions, I’ve come to see some real practical truths that have informed by opinion on the future of cinema:

1. There is no excuse for a bad looking film. None, zero excuse. Given my parameters, I have been able to compose shots with a degree of complexity, depth, staging, and color grading that are serviceably good-looking. I am not boasting here, I despise arrogance, but I was dumb-struck by how easy it was to construct a pleasant and consistent aesthetic using low-grade digital cameras, natural locations, and free software. This is not saying that the resulting movies I’ve been making will be good, not at all, but that I was able to achieve a certain abrasive black & white high-contrast look with my equipment and that most of the work was simply framing the shot, the rest of it was fairly easy.

If my incompetent poor self can do it, why do Hollywood films tend to, on average, look so terrible? There’s the factor of the machine there – unless a director or a cinematographer is explicitly paying attention, most of their footage isn’t that great, and is basically indistinguishable from rote televisual coverage: three cameras, shot, reverse shot, a wide once in a while, most things in shallow focus. This is a formula among many types of formulas; I believe that many American directors are lazy fucks who use shallow focus and longer lenses to blur their environments and backgrounds, so that they then don’t have to pay attention to things like lighting or staging outside of the regular set-up on the faces of actors. That brings me to…

2. Actors are a crutch. This is not to say that actors are bad, or unimportant, or uninteresting – but actors in Hollywood, more often than not, are a distraction from every other element of filmcraft. Think of it like this: if your work is mostly consisting of shallow-focus close-ups or medium shots of actors talking to other actors… there’s not much you need to actually do. If the actors are even slightly talented or look unique, you don’t have to do shit, they’re doing the heavy-lifting of your direction, all you have to do is point the camera at them, have them speak whatever the stupid dialogue is, and bam, you have a ‘story’. And thus the origins of the ‘star system’ – again, actors aren’t bad in-themselves, but I think many directors use them to prop-up the fact that they have no idea how to tell a story without them.

How can you tell a story without the incredibly expressive beauty of the human face? I’ve been forced to do that with my beginning films, because I don’t have the luxury of a cast of performers, and what I’ve learned is what all the great silent directors already knew and mastered and that we have forgotten – the space of a scene is its own story, the people within it are just the trajectory of movement from one feeling to the next. Actors are there to serve as a visual anchor for the audience, but what I think is more important is that the silence of an image’s presence speaks much louder than any amount of dialogue in a script, the script is just the vulgar literalization of an image’s poetry. It’s easy for directors to get away with bad visuals when you’re looking at the actors face instead of what’s happening with the camera’s gaze itself – this anthropocentrism is limiting to film language, and wasn’t always a rule. Most Hollywood directors cut on an actor’s movement, cut on dialogue cues, cut on expressions – could they do anything without their performers to essentially hold the audience’s hand throughout the whole damn thing? I doubt it – why mess up a winning formula? This is convenience, but it isn’t necessarily pure cinema – Antonioni is still Antonioni without Monica Vitti, Godard is Godard without Anna Karina. That’s what I’m personally after.

3. Given that these factors don’t have to be the case, but they are, what are the consequences? Most films look like shit, and are only watchable because of the performers, not the directors – and what are the performers doing? Saying the words of the writer, who wrote the script. So instead of a director’s cinema, we have a writer’s cinema – the camera exists now to record the image of people speaking, and little else, maybe a bad fight scene here or there to spice things up, maybe some monotonous drone footage, and that’s it. That’s a dead-end for Hollywood, and it’s been stuck in that mode for over a decade at this point – the whole anxiety about streaming and theaters and all that jazz is because there’s no separation between what film does and what television does – MCU films and sequels and franchises are structured like long TV episodes, so the confusion is understandable. The question of ‘theatricality’ simply becomes a matter of what is too expensive to make for a streaming service – yet in an era when Amazon and Netflix are spending $300 million dollars on everything single project produced by the Russo brothers, theatricality seems more like a side-gig to anyone who isn’t Tom Cruise – most of these young ‘movie stars’ would rather get paid for expensive TV shows than to actually be in theatrical movies, so the boundary between the two gets more and more blurred, and not even the writers get paid that much to work on this garbage – that’s why they’re about to strike. So literally no one wins, artistically or financially, except for the executives and stockholders, who find it easier to reduce cinema to the level of television than to understand that these mediums have fundamentally different aims and goals.

If Hollywood can’t consistently make good looking films (which they could from the 1930s-1960s) and if they also can’t even keep making movie star actors (which they were able to do throughout the 20thcentury), then what the hell is the point of the system? Like, obviously it’s a corrupt capitalist hell-hole, it’s been that since day one, but at least at one point they had the pretensions of making art, or at least entertainment that was appealing to see – now the standards for visual excellence have bottomed-out, and no one outside of aging auteurs and powerless cinephiles really care at all, the public doesn’t know any better but to eat this shit up. So what is to be done?

Well, I don’t have the talent or the egotism to claim that my little movies are going to do much of anything right now. But I’m going to keep writing, going to keep on shooting, and I hope that someday, maybe one of the future filmmakers who will ‘save cinema’ might glean some value from my work. What would that ‘saving’ look like… ? Some of my current aesthetic principles are this:

1. There needs to be a space in the cinema for the non-human; we must learn from painters and photographers how to articulate a poetics of the environment –  not only giving attention to the people within that environment, but also the trees, the rocks, the animal life, the stars, the shadows. These have an equal claim to be seen by the camera as clearly as anything else is.

2. We cannot take the human gaze for granted. The camera must be put in places that humans will not usually be – on top of roofs, underneath bushes, in shopping carts and boxes and narrow passages. The cinema must constantly re-invent its own language – to rely on a specific strict formula is the death of art. A director’s style must be able to accommodate any location – there is always good mise-en-scene, it’s just a matter of finding it.

3. Everything MUST be accomplished by the image before any other element comes into play – the American cinema has relied for far too long on the aesthetics of theater, literature, and television, it has neglected its own strengths as an art form. Actors may speak, but before they say a single word, the camera must show. The cinema must be easily legible for the deaf – if it is not, it is failing.

4. Limitations must become advantages – I only have access to low-grade digital cameras, so why not try and heighten digital grain into an important texture of the film? I don’t have any crew to lug around, so why not shoot footage in places where one person won’t be bothered? One of the few things I can easily control in my films is composition and the length of the footage – so why not take those into an extreme form? Every limitation is an opportunity to explore a new avenue of filmcraft.

With these principles, am I going to make better films than Hollywood? Probably not. But, I hope to pave a way for another alternative to exist – a director’s cinema again, even if it isn’t all that it could possibly be. I want to experiment, fail, try again, see what works – and if I end up finding a couple interesting things here and there, I’ll consider it to be successful. I don’t think it makes any sense in the 21st century to try and make a film that everyone will enjoy, like big-budget blockbusters try to do – I’d rather make a film that one person would love, even if it’s only them. I want to bring American cinema to a personal viewpoint, away from the corporate industrial nightmare that it’s grown into – I think there are hundreds of other filmmakers out there like me, and if we all make our own projects in the ways that we know how, then perhaps we can begin to articulate what a non-Hollywood space for this cinema might look like. It’s time for cinema to grow-up and stop being only entertainment in the way that so many other art forms were in the beginning of their existence – music began with one song that everyone in a community knew, but it’s grown into billions of songs which specific individuals sing and cherish in a way that was unheard of in ancient times. We need a pluralist cinema, a cinema that exists for each person, not a cinema that forces everyone to experience the same formula over and over again. I hope that I can be a part of that, if I can.


(Requested by Brice Lee, a Patron. Thanks Brice!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.