Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Every film which claims to be ‘based on a true story’ is full of shit, but even by that understanding, Chopper is a generous case to describe anything in it as ‘true’. From my own research and the film’s own attitude towards him, Mark Read was a naturally compulsive liar and probable psychopath, which makes the idea of a ‘true’ story about him absolutely laughable, especially when using source material that he himself wrote about his life and prison experiences.

Yet the director Andrew Dominik plays it safe by immanentizing that inconsistency and doubt into the story itself and leaning on Eric Bana’s tour de force performance – not that Chopper is badly directed, it’s quite handsome in that desaturated early 2000s way, but its source material is much more interesting than the filmmaking is able to handle here.

Much like Dominik’s later The Assassination of Jesse James by The Coward Robert Ford and Blonde, Chopper is about performance – those who perform and those who observe the performance, the meditative distance of subjectivity and subjectification. And similarly to those half-fiction/half-biopics, Dominik basically has no take on Mark Read in Chopper except for a simplistic ‘we enable psychopaths as a society’ implication that feels two doors down from Oliver Stone’s own batshit psychopath epic, Natural Born Killers.

Yet NBK thrives on its overclocked post-Scorsese neo-expressionist insanity, creating a hellish MTV texture that’s as manic as the characters it’s about, perhaps even more so. Dominik’s Chopper wants to embody the self-regard of Mark Read with a self-aware and half-ironic approach, reveling in the gratuity of its characters actions just as he himself reveled in them – perhaps more than Stone, then, Tarantino is the realer connection here, who pioneered an entire generation of cool post modern crime capers – is there not an immediate line of gratuity between the Reservoir Dogs ear cutting scene and the much bloodier one in Chopper?

The naive pulp sadism of Tarantino’s oeuvre feels like an silent yet ambient shadow in Chopper, which in my mind casts a limited degree of intelligence that Dominik seems to have accumulated in his reputation, mostly after Assassination of Jesse James and its faux-Malickian passages of narration and revisionist westerning. You get the basic pleasures of genre in Dominik’s films, as Chopper and Killing Them Softly have excellently crafted passages of underworld violence, not to mention Assassination, Chopper, and Blonde’s brutal anti-hagiographies which feed into the public’s appetite to see the disgusting extremities of celebrity lives while still being presented with the comfortable familiar figure of the celebrity themselves.

But ultimately, what separates these films from the rest of the Anglo-American realist-romance tradition of Hollywood? Blonde was supposedly ‘anti-Hollywood’, yet Dominik freely used the iconography and beauty of famous Monroe films that he explicitly stated having no love for – just like how Chopper mixes cool tough guy psychopathy with a preface that states that the entire movie isn’t a biography. Both Blonde and Chopper are projects which self-sabotage themselves before any footage is captured – there’s a protective distance of rueful irony which characterizes Dominik’s approach, a disavowal of the desire to make a statement on reality by filming his subjects, yet he is also drawn to material which postures alongside vapid scandal.

I did not have a bad time watching Chopper – I think that would be impossible to have, given Eric Bana’s charming and mesmerizing talent here. I find myself in the state of having seen (more or less accidentally) most of Andrew Dominik’s limited filmography (save the two Nick Cave films, as I don’t really care for documentary, and some errant episodes of Fincher’s Netflix show). Even in the spirit of generosity, I cannot say that I much understand the admiration and obsession with him, as it seems to have largely grown from an outsized legend and appreciation of his Jesse James film, which is likely his only satisfying work as a mutation and standardization of pop culture Malickisms. Dominik is fixated on self-aware celebrities who, in a Christ-like fashion, bear the pain and suffering of their fame. But he’s interested in the pain more than the fame, and that particular sadism towards his subject matter means that his films become recessive and self-contained enterprises without a firm commitment to morality, political sensibility, or even aesthetic drive. My big takeaway from Chopper is ‘Wow, what a guy who existed’, and my takeaway from Blonde was ‘Wow, what a lady who had a hard life’. The soft cynicism of these movies has no targets because they are unwilling to venture outside of the subjective bubbles of their main characters, or at least Dominik’s bubble of his perceiving of these characters.

A recent watch of John Hillcoat’s Ghosts of the Civil Dead, set during an identical period of Mark Read’s own Australian prison experiences detailed in Chopper, does this film no favors by comparison. Civil Dead is equally as grim and violent, but uses its docu-drama quality to make a firm statement about how the Australian prison system shapes and defines itself through the manipulation of prison life – meanwhile, Chopper’s prison life seems largely to be played as a series of gory jokes, because the film adopts his own egotistical perspective that all of this is very movie-like and deadpan and entertaining… whence then comes the safe prefix at the beginning?

"This film is a dramatization in which narrative liberties have been taken. It is not a biography."

Dominik’s filmography is boring precisely because of this sort of gesture – he plays with the idea of making an intensely subjective depiction of reality, but that subjectivity leads to an inherently naive view of the world. The prison system in Chopper is barely commented upon despite its massive role, it’s a cheap background dressing for the action taking place; Jesse James’ use of western tropes has a distanced risible contempt; Blonde’s depiction of 50s Hollywood as a rapist-misogynist nightmare is, while true, repetitive and risible, and that repetition has been in these films since the beginning with Chopper – he and someone he doesn’t like are having friendly shit-talk, back and forth, they let down their guard, then he hurts or kills them, this happens again and again, just like how Blonde has scene-after-scene of abuse and rape. What is the point of Dominik’s style if he just runs around his subjects in circles? His films are inherently centrifugal, and he depicts nothing in his depictions outside of what you want to personally direct his images towards this or that critique – which is boring to me. The images of Bresson or Ozu, while repetitive, always point to a spiritual outside which is breached at some point in the film, the light is let into the static structure to enliven it. There really isn’t that dimension in Chopper or any Dominik joint – his authorial voice, for me, is too meek, too crafty, too removed to be interesting – his sadism has no edge, regardless of whether it's true or fake.

(Requested by Patrick Newman, a Patron. Thanks Pat!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.